AHS:DELICATE Book vs Show Ep 1-3

[@WhytheBookWins]

People have commented letting me know the show is broken up into two parts! So there are more episodes left than I realized! I will still release a video after part one ends. Part two comes out next year, so maybe I'll just release one video all about part two.

[@EMMYMXNC]

I bet part 2 will be the vignettes

[@WhytheBookWins]

@@EMMYMXNC oh that would be cool!

[@DanteSapiain-xr2gc]

I thought the second part would be a completly different story

[@tinapuddin9923]

​@@DanteSapiain-xr2gcit better not be if they don't finish this storyline I will be done with the entire franchise. It's the writers strike for the sudden stop after 5 flipping episodes

[@DanteSapiain-xr2gc]

@@tinapuddin9923 dont lie to yourself, it doesnt matter how bad a season might be youll still watch the next one, we always do

[@brooklynbarbieedoll]

I’m SO glad I found your channel. I’ve been waiting for someone to make a video about this - especially since it’s the first time AHS is adapting a book as part of their franchise.

[@WhytheBookWins]

I'm glad you found the channel too 😁

[@TV-yb2bn]

I’m an actor and let me tell you, Kim is delivering freshman level of acting. But good for her, she’s remembering her lines and hitting her marks

[@Adn2nAwan]

lollll

[@courtneylester9592]

You’re an actor but you’re spending your time criticizing on a KZbin channel? Sketch Totally believe your an actor 😂😂

[@Adn2nAwan]

Its believable tbh, not every actor is automatically famous and devoid of spare time... the AHS season is literally about actors lol@@courtneylester9592

[@JillianVSJill]

@@courtneylester9592aww yes cuz every actor/actress on set 24/7 and have no life outside of acting

[@K.Adamsan]

Kim did not deserve the role... she is not an actress and there are people out there who take acting very seriously who would have done a better job.

[@Em-os9yj]

The show just seems like bad rosemarys baby if she cuts her hair im dead😅

[@themissitalk5208]

fun details, in episode 1 Siobhan top is similar to a spider legs, in episode 2 she's wearing a spider ring and in episode 3 her skirt look like a spider web

[@13pac55]

😮🤯

[@DCJackson7]

understandabl;y, there are quite a few moments where you refer to the show as the movie. Love your review!

[@WhytheBookWins]

Thank you! 😁

[@Thatboymojojo]

This channel is going to blow up. We live in a world of shortcuts, and I can totally see a bunch of people watching these videos so that they can feel superior in conversation about the source material. You’re the next cliffnotes 😂

[@WhytheBookWins]

lol thanks!

[@zeej80]

Absolutely! I love how she brings this story to life-I was instantly hooked!

[@WhytheBookWins]

@@zeej80 thank you so much!

[@nikkimurphy1737]

Then you have people like me who watch these videos...watch the show and will still read the book lol

[@Avasfridays]

That’s why I’m here. I feel seen.

[@drinks_menu]

I’m so glad someone posted this because I was so curious

[@Adn2nAwan]

Very good summary of the contrasts between the two! I will be watching part 2 of this too Thanks

[@Stef-Bef]

Interesting. I definitely think you should do a video for episode 4&5 and then when part 2 comes out next year finish the series! These videos are definitely making the show a more enjoyable watch for me since it’s a little slow moving and that long break had me even less interested in keeping up, but knowing where it could go has my interest piqued.

[@WhytheBookWins]

Yeah I'll definitely be talking about 4&5. And as of right now I'm also planning on covering part 2 when it comes out 😁

[@NikkiBWithTheAdHd]

Same!

[@NikkiBWithTheAdHd]

I am obsessed with your channel! I love the book vs movie videos/ television vs book. I love hearing your thoughts. You have a way of explaining and expressing your thoughts and feelings that keeps me interested. So glad I found your channel. I would love to read more but sadly I am always working 😅 so this channel has been lovely. Sending you lots of love and positive vibes. You’re definitely going to blow up! 🤗

[@WhytheBookWins]

Thank you so much!! I'm so glad you like my channel and your kind words mean a lot 😁

[@robertwood1701]

American Horror Story season 12 :Delicate will have 9 episodes with Part 1 being episodes 1--5 from Sep 20th--Oct 18th 2023 and Part 2 being episodes 6--9 from April 3rd--April 24th 2024.

[@WhytheBookWins]

I'm excited for the last episodes! I'll make another video about them after they have come out

[@andrealee8561]

Im not a fan of Kim but she reminds me of her mother Kris n i think this role was made for her

[@WhytheBookWins]

Yeah so true!

[@kelvinfields7804]

The Gotham awards are a real award ceremony. They are predominantly for independent films along with the Film Independent’s Spirit Awards. Smaller non televised ceremonies for independent films to gain traction as we go into the bigger televised ceremonies like Golden Globes, Critics Choice, SAG, BAFTA, and Oscar.

[@WickedMo13]

Kim kardashian isn't the reason it's mid. It's been mid for a while but I keep watching

[@travglav1]

Siobhan is not infertile. She has children of her own in the book.

[@matmoorgring]

Kim is good Everyone expected her to be the weak side of the season, but no, she coped with her task

[@Cyan_Orange]

never knew it was a book too

[@lilmelvin11]

Almost forgot...gotta pick a movie tomorrow from my local public library called "Mary Shelley"; with the actress Elle Fanning playing the author who wrote "Frankenstein" when she was 21....Hope it's a good movie! Should be interesting!

[@WhytheBookWins]

Oh cool! I'm going to look that up!

[@lindseystein9676]

The movie is good, but depressing. I didn’t know much about her life besides who her mother was, so I didn’t realize what she had all gone through before watching the movie.

[@me6796]

Great breakdown

[@blueviolets52]

Great analysis! Is it true that this book/show is inspired by Rosemary's Baby? I haven't seen AHS, but I'm interested in reading the book now.

[@WhytheBookWins]

The show is based on Delicate Condition, not Rosemary's Baby. Both books deal with strange pregnancies, but the story itself is very different.

[@Emma88178]

@@WhytheBookWinsI think OP means that the book Delicate Condition was based on Rosemary’s Baby.

[@leomuresan599]

The series is divided into two parts, part 1: 6 episodes, part 2: the last 4 episodes.

[@WhytheBookWins]

Thank you for letting me know! I hadn't realized how the show was set up lol.

[@l0us3rr]

Where did you see this?

[@leomuresan599]

@WhytheBookWins it was made like that because of the writers' strike, half of the season premiers this year, while the other half premiers sometime next year. In the meantime American Horror Stories will debut with 4 episode in that time window.

[@13pac55]

actually this season is only 9 episodes like 1984 was. and part one is 5 episodes not 6. part two will be the final four episodes.

[@eumilacerda]

Actually Gotham Award exists 😅. I found out looking for it. its a award for Indies movies

[@WhytheBookWins]

Yeah I realized that after the fact lol. I should have fact checked that before uploading the video!

[@lilmelvin11]

You make this so very very interesting....Ironically, you mentioning the character Siobhan so much reverberated my memory because if my wife and I had been lucky enough to have a daughter I wanted to name her Siobhan....I had read the name in the Inspector Rebus books by Ian Rankin in the 1990s. Siobhan was his detective partner, a very strong and forthright woman character and I wanted to name our hopeful daughter after her, if we were so lucky to be blessed with a daughter, but I didn't know the pronounciation of the name until I watched the BBC of both Inspector Rebus Mysteries, one series with John Hannah, the other series with Ken Stott..."Shiv-on" is so cool! .Alas, it wasn't meant to be, but "Siobhan" will always be an especial name to me. Just a stupid footnote. Love the Irish names. ...my maternal grandfather was named Elvis. Ain't that a hoot!😎 ...Thank you for your posts and heads-up. I'll get it from my local library, or "sail the seas", if I must...You are much appreciated for the turn-ons.

[@WhytheBookWins]

Yeah it's a cool name!

[@Mrcjcbs]

In the show emma/Anna notices ivy in the back of the photo darkened by the lighting or simply her mind playing a trick on her before when she looked at it u must’ve missed it it was a fun little nod to the similar situation w the photo in the book

[@mmmm-co4dc]

Gotham awards are very real thing. It’s for independent films and they take place in NYC. They are indictors for the Oscars

[@elenacalvillo11]

Siobhan had a daughter and I think they do discuss her troubles achieving getting pregnant

[@yanghonghui]

I hope you review the Changeling!

[@rondazug9967]

I love this Channel so glad I found it.!!! But I’m a little confused when u said sioban didn’t try having a baby with IVF then u said she had a miscarriage thru ivf? But anyhow I’m so happy you’ve made these videos. I’m loving this season so far and I’ve been looking for a SPOILER video exactly like this one, recapping episodes vs the book. And yes I want all the spoilers bc although I know the show may not follow the exact twists, turns, ending I can NOT wait until an unknown date in 2024 i need an idea of what’s going to happen NOW!😂 you’re amazing and your channel is going to blow up no doubt 🎉❤

[@WhytheBookWins]

So glad to like the video! And I know! I wish there wasn't such a long break in the middle of the show 😖 It might have been confusing how I worded it, but in the show Siobhan had a miscarriage while doing IVf whereas the book Siobhan didn't do IVF so that was exclusive to the show.

Yea i won't be watching anything with kim in it but i will definitely watch this

[@crimsonxdd]

for now there are 2 episodes left, then there will be a hiatus and the other 5 episodes will be the same story. Knowing the series I think they will do something more original and there will be some plot twist, because otherwise I don't know how they could finish the story following the book to the letter. btw, nice video

[@WhytheBookWins]

Oh, wait so there are seven episodes left still?? I thought it was just the five lol. It'll be interesting to see where they take it! I guess I will see how it like part one and see from there if I want to watch part two next year. And thanks!

[@crimsonxdd]

yep! these 5 chapters are only what they were able to record before the writers and actors strike started(?) then the other chapters I think they will be next year. @@WhytheBookWins

[@13pac55]

That would be 11 episodes. Ha I wish! This season of AHS is only 9 episodes like 1984 was. part one is only 5 episodes, so this Wednesday is the mid season finale. Part two is 4 episodes and returns next year.

[@corrinestrick1011]

I didn't want to watch the show but I did want to know about the differences so thank you so much

[@WhytheBookWins]

You're welcome! 😁

[@justanormalwoman5230]

Watching the show and now your video as a 7-months-pregnant woman. Such a surreal experience, it is my first pregnancy and it gives me a different view on several things. I am glad I have found your channel, now I think I will read the book also 😊

[@WhytheBookWins]

I would love to hear your thoughts on the book, especially since you are pregnant! I'm sure it is a different experience than it is for someone like me who has never had a child.

[@haileymorris174]

I watched handmaid's tale while I was pregnant so I know that feeling! Sorta

[@reneelyons6836]

So nice, how you gave no spoilers. In the show Dexter's character is boring. Was it that way in the book? Just wondering.

[@WhytheBookWins]

I think I found him a bit more intriguing in the book, but overall I think book and movie Dex are pretty comparable so far.

[@reneelyons6836]

Oh, very interesting. Thank you. Your video is great.

[@andrealee8561]

Jus wait for episode 5

[@TeamMaddisonYT]

Ooh have you done The Handmaid's Tale yet?

[@WhytheBookWins]

I haven't been I want to! I would most likely compare the book with the 1990 movie though not the TV show. Shows are just so time consuming! But who knows, if I love the book enough I'm sure I would be curious to see what the show is like.

[@ilenegallo6406]

The saddest adaptation for me is what they did to the Virgin River Series😭😭😭

[@bellz9113]

The gotham awards are a real thing. I think it's like an indie movie festival that is specific to New york. I don't know a lot about them so I hope someone else can provide a better answer.

[@WhytheBookWins]

Wow I should have Googled it before I made the video lol, Gotham just made me think of Batman so I assumed it was made up. But it started in 1991 and Wikipedia says The Gotham Awards are American film awards, presented annually to the makers of independent films at a ceremony in New York City.

[@charlesjunior5087]

This is based off a book??

[@justokayemilay6029]

Subscribe! This was my first time watching you!

[@WhytheBookWins]

Thank you so much! 🤗

[@pigdog8228]

Is this how they got around having actual writers or why is this book even exist

[@WhytheBookWins]

No because a writer still needed to adapt the book.

[@pigdog8228]

@@WhytheBookWins didn't they commission her to write the book

[@OktoberJournal]

I know nothing about the book, but find the show super boring (it also doesn't help I don't like 99% of the actors of this season). I'm most like DNF-ing this season, like most of the later season of AHS :x But this video is definitely interesting!

[@WhytheBookWins]

I'll be watching the rest, so if you DNF but are curious to hear how it plays out, you can watch my videos instead lol. I have never watched any AHS before, and maybe it helps that I have nothing to compare this season with. Because it seems most AHS fans don't like this one, but I've been enjoying it for the most part.

[@OktoberJournal]

@@WhytheBookWins Thanks so much, I will definitely come back to your videos to see how it will be!

[@PrettyGothBoi6085]

I think Gotham awards actually do exist. Interesting name though.

[@WhytheBookWins]

They do exist lol 🤦‍♀️ I mention that i was wrong about that in my video on episodes 4 and 5

[@andrealee8561]

The crib in the basement For someone who doesn't want kids why the crib Who would hold on to there baby crib

[@WhytheBookWins]

Yeah I don't get when people hold on to baby stuff forever... especially since like you said, her character in the show doesn't want kids!

[@VictoriaTraducciones]

I thought that was her crib, as in the crib her mother used for her when she was a baby, it's right besides the boxes with all the photos from her childhood, so I thought that was from her childhood aswell

[@kp7032]

😂 I kept my daughter’s cot bed, Moses basket, high chair, pram, and a few boxes of toys and books. 28 years later, my grandson uses the cot bed and was in the Moses basket during the day when he was first born (new mattress and bedding for both). It has meant that they’ve been able to save money to put towards the equipment that they wanted. The pram we gave away as it had too much of a 90s feel, but the toys and books have been put to good use both at him home, and at mine when I look after him on a weekly basis.

[@Smaugsss]

Gotham Awards are a real thing, lol

[@sportluver98]

Kim is such a bad actor i wish she had more trainingn

[@ChillHills]

I said this a lot in the first trailer. Kim has a very LA accent and she doesn’t try to mask it at all. She’s basically playing herself reciting lines.

[@evegusman7626]

AHS give me Rosemary's Baby vibs. And I hate that movie. Boring as hell

[@13pac55]

Lmao I watched that movie last night for the first time ever to see any comparisons to AHS. And I agree it's very boring. The main connection I found tho was Dr. Hill😮

[@larissaarazi7775]

Kim is doing amazing the haters will hate but she's just as good as Emma Roberts a power house actor she's iconic also let's remember Emma Roberts is the best biggest twist in the scream franchise so for Kim to be amazing with Emma even the way Kim emots is amazing let's be honest facts 💕👑💕

[@Rachel4momo]

I know ur not doing it on purpose but it’s kinda annoying when u keep saying movie instead of show

[@WhytheBookWins]

I try to avoid saying movie in my videos for part 2!

[@brandyloutherback9288]

Pregnancy-themed horror? Been done to death, Pun not intended!

[@heavenlyarianator6335]

This is IVF themed horror though

[@Gee-xb7rt]

This is kind of its redeeming value though, is it redundant? It uses your knowledge of film to throw you off course. The only thing people have guessed if they don't switch it up is Dex is out getting some.

[@indydude3367]

Didn't hear a word she said.

[@MadiDollie]

Clean your ears out