NMIXX Tiny Desk Korea - Vocal Highlights!

[@Joonpathy]

It's over for us once Nmixx starts writing and producing their own songs (because I heard that some members do write lyrics).

[@아-e7k9g]

Jyp회사의 책임자가 앞으로 jyp 아이돌은 전부 자체 제작곡으로 활동 시킬 예정이라고 발표했음....엔믹스도 작곡,작사를 배우는 중이라고 생각됨

[@bierangtamen]

​@@아-e7k9g진짜요? 기대되네요

[@bierangtamen]

The Korean commenter below just said that JYP made an announcement that artists under their label will be involved in the production and songwriting process :))

[@Joonpathy]

@@bierangtamen Oh that's nice to hear

[@vixxexo6855]

Self producing does not mean good.

[@dski2e]

Bro kyujin has shown the most growth in last 2 and a half years in terms of vocal ability.She has easily become my 3rd favourite vocalist of this incredible group.

[@Kaybye555]

Sameeeee, love her voice. It's so pretty

[@halian9256]

It is simply stunningly breathtaking that she is only 18. Such an incredible talent. I love her spontaneous, youthful energy in everything she does. That mischievous sparkle in her eyes - she is indeed so pretty - is just icing on the cake!

[@vixxexo6855]

Kyujin has improved her vocals a lot.

[@Z7Z77Z]

규진이는 올라운더 인듯..

[@northrnstar]

love how driven kyujin is to improve. she was already a great dancer and a decent singer during debut, but she clearly has been putting the work to polish her technique in both areas. and she just recently turned 18. girlie is on her way to become a beast.

[@kschshchshl]

her improvement can even be seen from o.o (released feb 22) to kiss (released july 31) and it was like a decent jump too... she's so fascinating i love watching her improve! so much talent in one girl

[@Joonpathy]

I am so invested in Nmixx since their debut and they're finally getting the praise they deserve.

[@mrrenewable]

Yeah, same. Though there were some rough moments, like the recent one when they were being targeted by netizens for doing their job of singing live exceptionally well. I mean I was just so frustrated that I was just at loss of words. But I am always here for them . 🐬

[@kaiquew7312]

​@@mrrenewable wdym? Was nmixx being roasted because of their good live singing? Omg...

[@mrrenewable]

@@kaiquew7312 yeah kind of , it was when they were going from one university to another for performance ( before their recent comeback:- SEE THAT ) . During one of their many performances jype decided to cut off the bactracks completely as a suprise for whatever reason. So as we know Nmixx, they handled the situation very well showcasing their vocals prowess but when it was revealed that it was basically a publicity stunt and they probably already knew about it....yeah that was when netizens started to complaint about how nmixx is now overdoing with their vocals and trying to show some shade at other groups and what not.., it really became messy. Though it cooled down after sometime.

[@mrrenewable]

@@kaiquew7312 yeah kind of , it was when they were going from one university to another for performance ( before their recent comeback:- SEE THAT ) . During one of their many performances jype decided to cut off the bactracks completely as a suprise for whatever reason. So as we know Nmixx, they handled the situation very well showcasing their vocals prowess but when it was revealed that it was basically a publicity stunt and they probably already knew about it....yeah that was when netizens started to complaint about how nmixx is now overdoing with their vocals and trying to show some shade at other groups and what not.., it really became messy. Though it cooled down after sometime.

[@mrrenewable]

@@kaiquew7312 yeah kind of , it was when they were going from one university to another for performance ( before their recent comeback:- SEE THAT ) . During one of their many performances jype decided to cut off the bactracks completely as a suprise for whatever reason. So as we know Nmixx, they handled the situation very well showcasing their vocals prowess but when it was revealed that it was basically a publicity stunt and they probably already knew about it....yeah that was when netizens started to complaint about how nmixx is now overdoing with their vocals and trying to show some shade at other groups and what not.., it really became messy. Though it cooled down after sometime.but let's not dig too much into such bitter memories of past . But then I guess it was my fault to bring it up..

[@mattw6627]

This is what i expect to hear when i want to hear Live Performances. Imperfections, changes, harmonies, instrumentals... they just seemed so real they almost made the performance sound easy to do! It was all so...natural! In the end, i think Tiny Desk is one of the best (if not the best) format when real live performances are involved. And NMIXX.. found the best format, so they can shine even more! Ty for your analysis!!!😊

[@WinChi_315]

I've lost count of how many times I've watched their Tiny Desk performance 😅

[@riyanagda]

Same!😭✨🐳

[@TholoanaN]

What I like about this particular comeback is how out of their way NMIXX and their team have gone to make them sing live. Like they’ve been going on “kstar next door”, “maybe singing” and even their KBS K-pop performance like come on. 🔥🔥🔥 I also noticed that they didn’t even go on itslive this comeback.

[@aintnootherfan]

It seems like the company knows well that the members shine when singing live and they’re looking for good opportunities to proudly show that off - as long as it’s safe and reasonable; I’m all for it!!

[@izzme5204]

And their Milan show was just golden. One of the best nmixx performances in my opinion

[@mAsHuMaRoPanda]

Coming from a musician and vocalist, in all honesty. This is the best live raw performance I have ever heard and seen. I have never considered NMIXX as simply idols. To me, they are true artists! The level of vocal skills each member has is almost unheard of, put them together and you get a vocal powerhouse that can quite literally do anything. Not to mention the girls just keep on improving at a very fast pace within a very short time, which goes to prove just how much time the girls put in the vocal room. But to me, I think Kyujin is the most improved since the beginning of this year, even more this past SEE THAT era. Her vocals have become much more stable, her tone more refined, she is slowly but surely getting rid of the nasality, and her breath control has improved greatly. Even her pitch and note accuracy has gotten better, you can tell she's been putting in the work in the vocal room. But what I truly love about this performance, is how much confidence the girls have. With that being said, the girls are able to truly enjoy themselves. This is what singing is all about! NMIXX doesn't sing because it's their job, but they sing because they love it, they enjoy it. I must also mention! That modulation on Lily and Haewon's two part harmony and run on LMLT really caught me off guard 😂. I have been so used to the motif of the original track that I was actually expecting the descending run like they usually do 🤣. But then I realized "yup they're NMIXX", I mean it descended just from a much higher jump off point 😅. Like many here, I have watched that part more than I would like to admit. As a matter of fact, I would like to admit that I have watched the performance more than 20 times 😁. But I have listened to it maybe about....... Well I lost count at 50. Anyway, this performance will go down in the history books 📚 (pun intended).

[@busybody5381]

I really need that blues jazz version of LMLT in spotify, I gasp. I am so excited for their future endeavour after seeing this performance. Sure, it's a small space, still, when you are used to use in-ear, sometimes you couldnt just grasp the rhythm, flow, even pitch correctly to the smallest details in a fast performance at that. I couldnt imagine how hard they had to work for making this performance amidst their busy schedules. Also, all in one take. Just how much they could have grown when they reach their 7 years, I hope many more people will appreciate their massive talents.

[@jacade5898]

The only disappointing tjing to come out of their tiny desk performance is that none of them are on Spotify lol

[@u1o1]

I'm so lucky i was born in this dimension where nmixx exist

[@moodindemand]

Cause youre gonna be reincarnated. Reincarnated as a Villainess to Conquer the World to Become The Best Opera Singer. HAHAHAHAH

[@mattlau95]

1:29 Sullyoon reacts to her minimal pitch imperfection, you can tell she’s like “alright i gotta get this”, I love it. I have listened to this performance so much since it came out, Runs for Roses is my favorite!

[@aintnootherfan]

Exactly, you can tell by the look on her face!😁

[@chewyy3121]

Kyujin, the jack of all trades

[@adjkshdj-mc7tw]

Nmixx never fail to serve vocals💅💅 Now seriously, its amazing how they always have a new thing to show us. for example haewon's growl or their harmonies. they are just amazing🤧

[@OleDirtyBastard68]

Lily and Bae harmonizing was a real ear-opener for sure

[@amethyst034]

Kyujin proving she is the most all rounded 4th gen kpop idol. Her continued improvement is not only guaranteed due to her young age but also her commitment & will to improve.

[@mfuerza5356]

I'm not sure if it was intentional, but I love how you can still hear them harmonizing during the 'Run' chant in Run for Roses.

[@martacastillo6272]

I just love how the LMLT arrangement is the first one in the medley, that way I can slap anyone in the face with the link to introduce them to NMIXX HEHE

[@runtomixx]

Kyujin's tone is very versatile and her voice/vocal/tone texture(?) is satisfying to listen to. Also she can bring out the emotion of the song easily. I really love her tone

[@maddiej2165]

Nmixx has been serving good vocals since like pre-debut but the fact that members have the desire to keep learning and improving themselves set them apart from other groups. Like some of the members re-took vocal lessons before recording the new album to ensure they would sound good

[@stevensong8618]

😂 me too! This group is special to me. Plus if i simp for any kpop idol , it will be Oh Haewon , the girl is so all around freaking talented it is insane. This group is truly top tier. Every member is so amazing.

[@Slm99]

I miss jazz in kpop. This was such a reminder of a great moment in the industry.

[@wannabe7598]

IMO, Nmixx is most talented group so far in kpop industry

[@dantarctica9430]

They remind me of Mamamoo.

[@gragalakaisel1477]

@@dantarctica9430 it's kind of a 50/50 similarities. Mamamoo is a group of singers that was made as an idol group. NMIXX is an idol group that happens to have singers as members lol.

[@emmityemmity6159]

@@gragalakaisel1477that actually makes a lot of sense omg

[@greeng6914]

Agreed, they are the top in singing and their average dance skills is above average as a group. Rapping wise i think they have sooo much to show and are still holding back, because their technique is really good and they can definitely take on more difficult raps. Their current raps are so melodic and jiwoo especially is incredible rapper, one of the best female rappers of 4th gen.

[@Legacy_2109]

As the whole package, they are just nº1, but when it comes to singing you just cannot claim that they are better than monsters like Big Mama. Another thing is rap is so overrated by the K-pop kids nowadays, rapping is mostly a skill rather than a talent, they can all clearly rap since they have the attitude, diction and rhythmic skills, another thing is that they are willing to take the time to practice it knowing that their fans want more vocals and dance.

[@DioBrandoDaGOAT]

Love the Kyujin appreciation 🫡

[@jacklastimosa2802]

Tbh... These ladies literally have fun in making there tiny desk mini concert.. nswer need more ballads from nmixx... Their voices literally shines in ballads..

[@Joonpathy]

The way this is one of the most watched tiny desk performance (considering it was only posted a few days ago) shows how this is one of their best vocal performances.

[@jjuaassol]

I love this review as much as NMIXX's TDK performance 😜 NMIXX is the spear head of K pop as Tiny Desk is the spear head of any live performance program. Go higher my stan, NMIXX!!!

[@mamamoofrvr]

12:28 i completely agree, she sounds so much more relaxed at that part compared to the recording video! i love that NMIXX have improved so much!!

[@bierangtamen]

I think your channel introduced soooo many people to Nmixx thank you so much Our fandom was so small but it's only been growing recently and I could not be happier

[@AnimeIntroStyles4]

When Lily spent so long as a trainee, I was genuinely worried that JYP wouldn’t place her in a group that was worthy of her talent. When NMIXX debuted, I initially thought JYP had failed. However, over time I’ve seen SQU4D gradually learn how to manage a K-pop group effectively. As for the NMIXX members, JYP didn’t fail Lily. He surrounded her with some of the most talented idols in K-pop. Now, she’s part of one of the most talented K-pop groups in history.

[@sowhat1674]

I honestly believe that nmixx was built around lily.

[@xryvxctyrsyndry]

​@@sowhat1674Nahhh i disagree

[@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy]

​@@xryvxctyrsyndry it was sort off. More as if the group was made for lily

[@Legacy_2109]

Lily isn't this unheard-of talent that K-pop has never seen, she's been receiving vocal training almost since birth with a relentless work ethic and practice time. SQU4D's only purpose was to make a vocal group after JYP had Mamamoo in his show, he felt real singers were about to go extinct (everyone lip-synced, and live singing was becoming a myth) and wanted to turn things around. It was around that time when he said that famous "people who sing well will never fail" quote like it happened with Mamamoo, "ugly" girls who were beyond popular and respected against all odds and beauty standards. So It was never centered about Lily or any other member. NMIXX is an outstanding group in everything be it singing, dancing, visual, charisma, humor, you name it. Only XG are better dancers than NMIXX (but who is?) and they aren't even K-POP, the Jiwoo, Haewon, Kyujin, Jini combo was just crazy. The hard part about being an idol is NOT just being able to sing well, take note of at all the checkmarks I mentioned above, it's not that hard to find a better vocalist than Mamamoo or NMIXX combined. Still, it's way harder to find a passionate singer, dancer, visual, charismatic, balanced, funny and interesting idol at the level of the NMIXX members.

[@jorge33484]

NMIXX will join Billboard Latin Music Week 2024. They were invited for October 16th, it will be in Miami, Florida ♥

[@camrionr]

DAMN I WAS IN MIAMI ON OCT 16th THAT PISSES ME OFF

[@mtlfpv]

This was exactly the sort of performance i've been dreaming of for ages.

[@bitbr7]

What made this performance so special for me was just how obvious it was that the girls were having such a great time. I’m so glad they had a chance to show off their skills that they have worked so hard for!!

[@BloodAndTsundere]

I just want to say thanks since it was your channel that originally turned me on to NMIXX some months ago. I wasn’t really familiar with them but noticed that you kept bringing them up as an example of a good vocal group so I felt compelled to check them out. I’m so glad I did

[@spotteddogmemphis]

This is why I stan NMIXX, vocals.

[@bcray2548]

Was waiting for the video😂😂😂😌 Honestly the administration and respect I have for NMIXX is insane. These girls are talent personified

[@gilbertombp]

Roller Coaster and Party O'Clock would sound really well with the band setup they used.

[@arrrrrkkk]

NMIXX slay 👑

[@chvv7776]

NMIXX is a group with best vocals in the whole industry. I have never seen idols as talented as them in live singing, literally there is not even a single member that is behind everyone. Each of them *can* sing and they do it so well. And they sing live so often, it's honestly incredible

[@Nunyabby]

Yes, Kyujin has always had a strong head voice.

[@Jules-dt5wb]

I'm so happy we got this analysis. The girls killed it! Can't wait to see them grow and evolve in the future.

[@Bringiton-d7j]

Thanks for the evaluation. Nmixx is the Best. ❤

[@user-uu5dd5jj2k]

Yes. Kyujin has been an ACE since predebut

[@Books-gb5]

I don't want those other fandoms to say that their fave group will be the best vocalist, will Infact I want proofs I don't want it's live, or performance something like that cuz I know some of that is EDITED obviously and I'm done with those shitty, I want them to prove it on tiny desk Korea, if they really are that good and if they pass those requirements on tiny desk. I'm afraid they can't, considering the requirements are already at the next level, not to hate those other groups but nmixx talent is not just an average it's more than that, the amount of energy they have in performing they really are enjoying, they're too talented. The nmixx tiny desk Korea performance is such a big flex.

[@nl7230]

Yes, in fact, the number of people who don't understand how much nmixx is higher than the average K-pop group is simply astonishing. Do you remember the story about the naked king? The naked king is the K-pop industry, and the people who admire the king's "outfit" are K-pop fans, and nmixx is a boy who shouts "WAKE UP, THE KING IS NAKED!"

[@samuell_blink]

NMIXX keeps improving and IMPRESSING!! 😳💙

[@Kep1lieo_]

4:32 they need to give her more vocal parts, I love her voice and she doesn’t get much vocal parts

[@halian9256]

I've been admiring them from the sidelines for a long time, but with this comeback and yes, the Tiny Desk performance, they've shot right up to the tops of my favourite kpop groups. NMIXX is simply superb!

[@blaykehawk_]

not to mention (idk if you do bc I'm only on the DASH section) but they did that entire performance WITHOUT IN EARS. that's soooooo impressive 😭😭😭

[@Dani-wh2ul]

Early!! I'm so excited for another NMIXX video!!!

[@SoraiaLMotta]

I must say that you have influenced me to pay attention for this group, and I ve become a fan of them as well.

[@大宅海斗-g4m]

Nmixx is the best! Hope they'll be more popular worldwide

[@amadadam6620]

everytime you do Nmixx's content Nmixx will release another singing content too I mean it's so funny in a good way😭

[@aintnootherfan]

It’s killing me😂😂

[@christianlamar_]

Dare I say, NMIXX may have saved K-Pop for me. Remember when Girls Generation did jazz versions of Gee and even did Suju’s Sorry Sorry? This tiny desk performance reminded me of that.

[@akovalskiy]

NMIXX best of the best ❤NMIXX magic ✨

[@aloarina]

then i heard lmlk i frizzed i swear, that jassy delivery and harmonies are sooo good, i can’t stop watching it

[@troua2001]

agree love me like this was the best

[@jarinChong]

with 'tiny desk' & N-MIXX, somehow make feel like OST. as 'run for roses' like a song they sing before the war and follow with 'see that?' as epic war fight scene in an epic movie see in IMAX digital, and i love it so much. (also put the 'soul' of 'see that?' song by that little instrument performance as 'twinkle little little star'. ~ so~~~~ good~~~~~~) (also like teen movie before & during concert showcase, but need much much more bigger scene to contain this energy. :D) anyway, have a good day. :)

[@sayurioffenborn4960]

Thank you!!! Can you check some more tiny desk performence?

[@exph0lieproph3t]

i love this groups sm omg

[@poltergeistducs2948]

Well nmixx is a great group they had more to offer

[@artistman5533]

Everyone learns and grows.

[@SmilingCheckers-yk8qx]

NMIXX TOP

[@amjadbalobid8041]

NMIXX IS THE BEST

[@amandag1337]

Their Tiny Desk performance was so enjoyable to watch and listen to! Also, those notes you were hitting at the end of the video?! 🤌🤌

[@yunko7076]

Thanks for the analysis! I thoroughly enjoyed the video!

[@mygamora4897]

Bae and Lily harmonizing at the end of LMLT is pure bliss ❤❤ it's heavenly.

[@mistermystery2143]

NMIXX THE STANDARD

[@SsnGA15_amnd]

Ate

[@knives26]

Nmixx is the best

[@jkl10.0]

The best

[@poltergeistducs2948]

I would love for them to cover rv bad boy. It fits them perfectly

[@Neptune153]

13:37 "There is a bit more pushing, fatigue, and tension" To my untrained ear the following clip just sounds fucking amazing LMAO

[@emcuscoo]

NMIXX! ❤

[@cesaralejandropintoleal8129]

Lately, i've been disconneted to k-pop because i've already stablished what groups i do and don't like, after what it felt as a novelty. But watching this video inspired me to look out for more. Can someone recommend a good ep or album from Nmixx?

[@Mmaufid]

expergo, fe3o4: break, fe304: stick out All 3 of their EPs are really good😊

[@aintnootherfan]

Fe3O4 Break is for sure their magnum opus so far!

[@blas_de_lezo7375]

@@aintnootherfanagree in terms of overall good songs.

[@sgvnssa7369]

NMIXX: Lily: ^B Haewon: B Sullyoon: C (She’s now a strong C, girly be supporting a lot of notes for the last two years of her debut) Bae: ^D (Her whistle ascended me to heaven, hopefully, she’ll be showing more whistle notes in their next songs) Jiwoo: D+ (As the main rapper of the group, she can be a main vocalist to other groups out there) Kyujin: C- (She’s a menace…)

[@brodude825]

woah lily is not on the best condition in that performance? i couldn't tell the difference shows how great of a singer she is

[@rabit1377]

I would say multiple of the members weren't in their best conditions, they barely slept before filming it, and they have been getting cold one after the one for a while 😭

[@hanxiw]

​​@@rabit1377 yes! in this comeback with "see that", they had so much content, members were very busy even at the stage of creating the album, and also after they had a lot of shows and etc, and besides, the girls are also preparing for concerts. But even so, they really sound great! It's not for nothing that they are the most talented group in recent years.

[@anisafza9493]

lmao not me liking all the comments praising kyujin

[@AMfireworksz]

❤

[@Yurito12]

Lily should take a break, her belts been sounding pushed for sure. They have her belting live almost every other day 😭

[@kimkardashi-un2.051]

Yeah it's time for them to let Haewon take the lead, it's good for Lily to rest for a while

[@cattosakamotto]

​@@kimkardashi-un2.051its also not gonna begood for haewon since she's booked for different variety shows. She will use her voice not only through singing but also speaking just like how she was overworked for nonstop shooting for jtbc, workdol & mbc shows & isac mc. The best way is for div4 to tone down any belting or highnote.

[@Aaron-wm4fy]

She had a cold, so her voice is not fully recoverd yet

[@ales608]

​@@Aaron-wm4fy but this wasn't recorded before that ?

[@moodindemand]

I guess thats the reason why they did not let Lily have high notes on See That?. Also, when Sullyoon did high notes on Dice, after that SQU4D limited her lines and pushed Haewon on high notes. I believe that SQU4D knows and monitors their vocal. Its just Lily is way skillful that she can do it but maybe next comeback it will be the same structure to limit Lily straining her chords. What I observed recently is that Bae and Kyujin have been doing more lines and especially Kyujin that with more training she can belt. She might be pushed next comeback to take high notes.

[@toriwenzel2758]

the EXO female ver of new gen

[@armandomarquardt]

" I have played the humming part an unhealthy amount of times " Haha... mee too!

[@armandomarquardt]

9:38

[@Neon00000]

The king delivered! Great vid mam

[@SwagyNysc]

Thx

[@Mbcreplysection]

Good

[@SueweetieAJYPN]

Thank you for your review and critique!

[@kayliawilson8842]

Ohk but the lil riff at the end. Pop off King 😭😭 nmixx 8th member is that you???? I would say 7th but I don’t want Jinni/Jini fans to eat me up even though she’s not in the group anymore.

[@HoudaDahane]

Jini's fan will not attack you because nswrs aren't that toxic we are peaceful 😊

[@xryvxctyrsyndry]

​@@HoudaDahaneNahhh jinni fans are toxic since she left the group blaming other member😒.Jini stan are always say "Nmixx is Flop without Her" and they hating on other members for weird reason.

[@HoudaDahane]

@xryvxctyrsyndry really I didn't heard about that since jini left nmixx I didn't follow her so that's why I thought like that before 🫤

[@vargant100]

It's someone who dislikes NMIXX pretending to be a Jini fans.

[@ledao-oo7jy]

Can you talk about kpop idols on the first take? I feel like it's also a nice live show with minimal editting and one take only:))

[@jieurs]

THIS MAKES ME CRAVE TINY DESK PERFORMANCES FOR OTHER GROUPS AS WELL!!

[@AMfireworksz]

🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊

[@Kamiisama69]

Queens

[@fromEPtoFW]

Favorite group! It’s been so fun getting into them this past year. Their live vocals are always such a pleasure to the ears ❤

[@n.137]

The other great shows to watch live performance are Jukjae's Late Night Studio and Hyunsik's Late Night Studio. Even the live band impromptu play the instruments.The shows are from Naver Now.

[@jorge33484]

I'm not impress, i'm proud ♥ nmixx is different

[@skillbopster]

Lily had only just recovered from losing her voice from a bad cold here.

[@xryvxctyrsyndry]

But this is before that happen

[@Mozhi.Line.84]

Definitaly Nmix is his favorite group😂

[@xryvxctyrsyndry]

if yes, why? is that a problem?

[@Mozhi.Line.84]

@@xryvxctyrsyndry No problem but imo There are better cases to make this much content about however Nmix is really good in recent kpop

[@Mozhi.Line.84]

@@xryvxctyrsyndry No nothing😂 I prefer to say nothing actually

[@Mozhi.Line.84]

@@xryvxctyrsyndry No nothing They are good

[@jimmycroni]

I don’t know if they’re his favorite group but this a vocal channel and Nmixx is definitely one of his favorites to showcase vocal talent

[@madalenklare6025]

As soon as I saw the Tiny Desk I knew you would have a field day with analysis!!! Truly what an explosion of musicality, it was such a treat to watch. Amazing video as always!

[@Abhi-moh]

Hey since I saw RV here I want you to check out their cosmic live stage on mnet's mcountdown with blue outfits ....it was really good live stage and I feel like after so much time I have seen a SM group live stage like that ...PS: Live stage with dancing at a music show

[@MeronOppa]

NMIXX’s Tiny Desk is AMAZIN! Period. It’s pure bliss, pure joy; their vocals, their performances, their presence, the music band, the arrangements, everything! And if you still doubt about their vocals, after watching this video, go watch their Tiny Desk if you haven’t and, then go to watch their Run For Roses Dance Practice video, OMG!

[@MeronOppa]

Great video BTW! 👌🏻

[@1swerdna]

Thanks for another great video! I love seeing these groups that raise the bar for vocal performances. I think Nmixx, Aespa, and Blackswan have the best vocals of the newer generation. Are you going to do an analysis of Blackswan's vocals? They've done Arirang radio with no backtrack and then there was their It's Live! performance. Even certain stages you can hear them singing over the backtracking. I'm especially interested in your take on Nvee's performance and what has changed over time. It seems she really struggled with her diaphragm at first (as a fellow asthmatic, that's what it sounded like to me), but I'm this last comeback her breathing sounds more stable. As a professional, you can probably hear what's going on better, so I'd love to see a breakdown.

[@blaykehawk_]

I watched ur other video HOURS before the tiny desk vid dropped lol and I was like omg he would love this. I hope he does a video on it

[@aeong_bread]

8:28 they made it look easy oop- lsrfm shade???

[@trustme7068]

항상 느끼지만 nmixx는 앨범을 들을때보다 라이브영상이 훨씬 맛있음 왜 그럴까?

[@mayiluvu3]

Because it’s more real I guess. An artist will always sound better if they sing their songs live, they interpret it how they want to. Also the band was so impressive and added flavour to their songs.