Alan Wake Critique - Beyond Inspiration

[@jjef8706]

The single scariest moment for me in Alan Wake is during a pretty calm exploration section. Its been a while, but if i recall right after you leave barry in the cabin on the Elderwood trail, theres these cabins you can explore in or around. And while youre inside one of the cabins, a Taken walks by one of the windows outside. There no big noise or fight, and absolutely no follow up to it, but that single interaction set me up for fearing the setting for the rest of the game.

[@IAmTheFourteenth]

"Barry, my beloved" - Bricky, 2024

[@matthewmcshane399]

Excited for your inevitable video on alan wake 2. The game was amazing.

[@casual1118]

I'm personally waiting for the lore dump episode on that one!

[@atanamorell2]

​@casual1118 💯 Haven't been able to play Alan Wake 2 and I've avoided all spoilers and Let’s Play video so I can fully enjoy the Lore Dump on it. The Remedy-verse Dumps are my favorite ☺️

[@garc115]

@@casual1118 I don't like the format they follow there at all, I think the best videos come out of a structured script, in a podcast you say a lot of things, but rarely get anywhere. Just my humble opinion, I don't want to offend anyone 🙂

[@WeMissDimebag]

I have no idea how they plan to do that lol, I think there’s still massive pieces of that narrative that we don’t understand. We sort of understand the journey Alan goes on but everything else there seems to be room for interpretation/speculation as to what’s happening.

[@DiegoSouto-fy9su]

That game was DEI, politically fueled dogcrap.

[@picahudsoniaunflocked5426]

"The lake noms Alice." Brilliant.

[@Warriorette12]

Happy to see that reference to Lore Dump

[@SuperClarisso]

Something that I found interesting is that if the first game was about writer's block, the second game seems to be about depression, trust and impostor syndrome. And both are about Alan not being able to run. I'm not even halfway through the video, but I'm loving the aditions. Great work, as always.

[@SidPhoenix2211]

Now that I've seen ALL of Twin Peaks... I can finally watch this whole video. This remaster came out just in time!! Looking forward to that Alan Wake II video!

[@SidPhoenix2211]

That opening story... Your dad is hardcore lmao. Such a cool thing for him to do

[@DJTS1991Yes]

I know it’s a redo, but it’s still a phenomenal video. I work in Digital Marketing, and I’m a bit of a cynic when it comes to advertising, but Alan Wake was one of the rare few gems I purchased outright back in the day by looking at the cover art alone. Didn’t even look at the description on the back. And I was so taken back by the beauty of the game, I hunted down Twin Peaks and had my mind blown. And I was so taken aback by the beauty of the show, I hunted down episodes of The Twilight Zone. It’s just all so good. There’s something to be said about this game though all by itself… without the wider extended universe. This in all its simplicity is a beautiful story and a phenomenal piece of art.

[@AlienDemonKing]

Man gave me a heart attack. Though we got Alan Wake 2. I am desperately waiting for it's Lore Dump and analysis

[@brain_drops]

U been around a couple years Monty, so im sure people have said it before. But I absolutely love the costumed controller changing with the game being covered. SNES Wake and the ones for the BG3 video were peak

[@samgonzalez8662]

This was well-timed. I recently finished Alan Wake II, and your Remedy content was what revived my love for their games. I’ve been looking forward to this rerelease since it was announced, and now I have the updated thoughts to mull over while I look forward to the Alan Wake II Critique

[@pimscrypt]

Damn, I made a deliberate effort not to watch too many other Alan Wake videos while working on my own, and I just now realized that you also had the idea of actually looking up where that King quote came from, three years before I did. I thought I was so clever haha! Anyway, I'm 18 minutes in and I'm really liking the video! I'm glad you shared that anecdote about that time you spent Halloween with your dad, it was very sweet. Also glad to see that I agree with a lot of your opinions on the game so far!

[@Yoarashi]

47:00 the actual in-game explanation given for why the birds are specifically ravens is because the Dark Presence stole Odin's ravens, Huginn and Muninn. Sam Lake didn't really start drawing on Finnish mythology for inspiration until Control, unless you count lil Easter eggs like Nik'sih-Pir'kah, the Dweller in Flesh :)

[@TheOnlyTaps]

Fantastic watch! Was surprised when I saw the title initially coz I was like wait "did he mean to say Alan Wake 2?" coz I remembered catching up to the original Alan Wake video recently after watching your video on Control.

[@viroszelmire1391]

Oh yeah it’s always a great day when Monty uploads a 2 hour critique I love watching these while playing long jrpgs

[@TalesZuliani]

I'm watching it while grinding invasion on MK1

[@RelaxingApple]

Lost my mind and was half convinced I went back in time until I saw the description and read that this was a remastered video. I'm still gonna watch this because these are the best but like. Still gave me a heart attack

[@onebaddayaway]

Great video. I'm the other way around. I've been a Twin Peaks fan since it came out (I was in high school at the time) and have only discovered Alan Wake (and, to an extent, Remedy games, although I loved Max Payne back in the day) in recent months. I love it, and (being a Stephen King/David Lynch inspired game dealing with conflicting realities and Jungian philosophy, and featuring Nick Cave on the soundtrack) my son commented "this game was made for you". I was thinking about doing my first attempt at a video essay on it, but then KZbin's algorithm did its job for once and I saw your video, which said everything I wanted to say and more, so no need. Thank you for this analysis. Have subscribed.

[@MontyZander]

If it means anything I’d watch any Alan Wake video essay so don’t let this stop you! Appreciate the words

[@totallyarealdoctor6498]

Your dad taking you to hint werewolves is amazing

[@manganimesYT]

the og vid was good enough, one of my favorite vids on you tube... so getting this... a welcome surprise. its just such a great video, and your father knocked that spoook out of the park!

[@shoobey]

i spent the last month playing all the alan wake games just to watch these videos and now im sitting down with a video game experience that absolutely floored me. thank you Monty! (not done the final cut of 2 yet so maybe your alan wake 2 video will have to wait a little longer)

[@GubtodiReviews]

Correcting Walter from 'drunk' to 'slightly inebriated' is the Scottish peak of this video.

[@rngwrldngnr]

Alternate epigram for opening Alan Wake: "Believe it or not, Eraserhead is my most spiritual film." "W... Wha-- Elaborate on that." "No."

[@kinglyer5640]

Your amazing Monty. Can't wait to watch this when I get off work today

[@melissaosburn6661]

Love this. Your original video introduced me to Alan Wake. I look forward to the Alan Wake II critique and the LoreDump episode!

[@hawkins347]

LoreDump for AW2 is gonna be such a mess, I can't wait 😂

[@Loot_NukemXD]

Character development is when monty complains about Suicide Squad instead of Avengers

[@MightyShakaZulu]

I was about to freak out and loose my shit then I saw the intro. Still, new Monty video, so I'm going to watch REGARDLESS. I can't wait for your Alan Wake 2 Critique. I've honestly never loved a game as much as I do that, not since Mass Effect 2.

[@SidPhoenix2211]

10:10 Having played Max Payne 1 not too long ago... Alan Wake's dream tutorial is kinda reminiscent of that game's tutorial level with its intense hand holding and old-timey feel

[@cannonfodder4376]

Been listening to this every so often at work and again today when I had to go into the sanding booth. Just put on my ear buds and listened to this. Simply superb. As someone who fell in love first with Control and then with Alan Wake, I am glad to be old enough to appreciate these works of art now. So much depth, care and creativity in these games and I am glad you have equally as much love and passion to put out this great video essay. I am in agreement with your thoughts and opinions with regards to these two Alan Wake games. Put to words what I think but can scarcely articulate. Once I complete my replay of Control and do Alan Wake 2 Final Draft I plan on watching those videos and I have no doubt I will enjoy them. Superb work.

[@tylernelson9039]

Loved the new video! You’ve been improving so much, keep up the great work. Can’t wait for the greatness of the Alan Wake 2 critique!

[@osap4]

The whole Allen wake/Mr. Scratch stotyline was lifted straight out of Stephen King's excellent "The Dark Half"

[@rruhland]

I need to read that again. I also need to read Bag of Bones again, as it feels like an obvious inspiration. Writer with writer’s block stays at a lake house on the shore of a lake that appears to have some sort of mystical power.

[@rodrigoenriquez7259]

Zane: Mr. Scratch does not matter... *Scratch does not matter in the great scheme of things* Monty: Why does Scratch dooes nothing in the cannon? Loved the video!

[@ThousandairesClub]

*I'll always be a fan of how Control inadvertently revived the AW franchise. that's what happens when you fuk around and make a Great Game* 👍

[@Ancor_Vantian]

So, people in Scotland just _Carry_ torches around like it's no big deal? I mean, I was born in the equivalent of bumf*ck nowhere in Latin America in the early 90s but even in my village we had flashlights 😅 Edit: While we are at it, [to my shame] Alan Wake was the sole reason why I bought an Xbox 360 back in the day.. I... _obtained_ the game after Jailbreaking my console. (Legally, most videogames were banned in my country, so we either had to resort to pirated games, or buying the oficial titles at an incredibly high rate). It became one of my favorite games ever. I was super happy to be able to play Alan Wake 2 on my PS5 last month. Loved it even more so. The long waiting was worth it Edit2: 19:47 I remember that small revelation stuck with me. "He still wore the ring. He'd been waiting for her to tell him to take it off..." 💔

[@sweypheonix]

European countries call flashlights torches just a heads up

[@jonasrichter2306]

Love your Alan Wake critique. The new as well as the old. I always feel inspired by it, so I always come back when I feel the need to get my creativity back. I don't know how often I watched this or fell asleep to your voice. So this critique inspired by this game, inspired by this TV show, now inspires my... What a strange world.

[@sanyokS1]

You clearly have been working on this for a while, but im still choosing to believe that my alan wake 2 comment on the suicide squad video is why you're doing this

[@varunmittal1860]

Your original video is what got me to play the Alan Wake series. The butterfly effect to find your channel is crazy too but I’m so glad I saw the original and got to play such beautiful games

[@DelinoK]

Thank you my champion of light, this shall help me face the herald of darkness ( my sleep )

[@onceortwiceooh]

Ahh I just watched your original one a short while ago, really enjoyed it and will surely enjoy this one. Can’t wait for the video for Alan Wake 2

[@timeneses]

Im exited for this remastering, can’t wait for the next video!😊

[@TATERplaysGAMES]

2:10:23 i like to think scratch isnt really burning away, this is just the dark place playing Alan's game, letting him get juuuuust to the finish line, the escape, before pulling the rug out and laughing. Its the dark presence humoring Alan's attempts and playing with its food, so to speak, seeming fully confident that Alan is incapable of being a good enough writer to outfox it, humoring his little attempt to drive him so insane that he becomes so desperate he writes a true horror story the dark presence can use to expand its domain in reality. In other words, it thinks alan is a hack it can take advantage of, and american nightmare is the dark presence giving alan enough control to think he has any at all, just to keep him trying and writing until he slips up and writes something the dark presence can use for its own means.

[@TheNomnomnommer]

>this is a reupload with the editing, script and audio reworked so it's a completely new video, a remaster in the same way that final fantasy 7 intergrade is a remaster

[@RaptieFeathers]

More like the Dead Space remake-it's very much the original in nearly every way, but remade from scratch.

[@cxlesstial2]

beautiful video, I love and appreciate the respect and care you have for the game and how much depth goes into your videos

[@RaptieFeathers]

Comparing the reading in this video to in the original really helps highlight the subtle differences that elevate a vocal performance. I've gone back and forth several times listening to the intro, and holy moly.

[@candybeans]

These videos are amazing for watching while working. Thank you for your hard work, as always!

[@sebastianholtsvendsen2597]

Seriously whenever I hear the 1... 2... 3... I just crave to re-watch all your critiques again again

[@ItsJuls1]

Today I have added "chaos goblin" and "thunder fuck", to my vocabulary.

[@ryanakahoward5246]

this was a great video, worth the rewatch. I love the story of your father in the beginning.

[@CallMeKes]

2003...he's 9 years old. I graduated high school in 04. I'm old...

[@markevayne]

So scatch alan and Zane are all different parts of his personality that's what I took from it

[@BlueWaffle3]

Great video, are u gonna cover aw2 on loredump?

[@MontyZander]

I am! Working on the AW2 critique first but will definitely do AW2 and the expansions on Lore Dump. Timeline was originally October and might still be but things are in flux so TBC

[@atanamorell2]

​@@MontyZander The Remedy-verse Lore Dumps have been my favorites. Excited for more! 🎉

[@That_Ifrit_Guy]

I love how, even though Alan is a dick, he did not hesitate to dive into the lake to try and rescue Alice when he thought she'd fallen in. Also with America Nightmare, I see it as Wake destroying Mr Scratch's body as it where, he destroyed his ability to be physical in the real world but not the whole thing, which is why he can still taunt Alice, but only through the shadows, pictures and what have you.

[@jasonck9635]

I restarted this game ! I played a few hours of it before , but didn’t really take in everything the way I really wanted ! So I started over and I’m really taking my time to absorb everything , the story , the views , and even the manuscript pages that I want to try and collect ! This game is truly something special . Now that I’m looking at it with a in depth viewing . I’m really enjoying it so much more , this time around !

[@sayborgoussawa4424]

Amazing video, I love it. So excited for Alan Wake 2 video.

[@Teckman8]

Now this is a welcome surprise, even if it may be a remaster. Love your stuff!

[@levstepanov2892]

Scratch is Zane in AW2, I dont know how you could miss that.

[@MontyZander]

I didn’t - that’s just one of dozens of theories about Zane - none of which are proven at this stage!

[@KittyKatty999]

Watching this video back to back with the original analysis is great, in a trippy way. Certain lines, like "If a genie offered me 3 gaming wishes" are subtly different compared to the original. Almost like a Mandela Effect, which is fitting. :O

[@RaptieFeathers]

I keep pausing and comparing them, and it's fun hearing how much goes into making a reading sound natural. You can hear in Monty's voice that there's actual acting going on during the reading, too!

[@bluecat3338]

1:27:16 ironic that the location is so grounded in realism when DISconnecting the location from reality is such a staple of Control and (to a certain extent) Alan Wake 2

[@Plasticroll]

Amazing video❤ Your first Alan Wake video got me started watching twin peaks and playing a lot of Remedy games. Can't wait for the AW2 video🎉

[@quentinb4321]

WHERE DID IT GO

[@warelf97]

Okay it's not just me questioning if they imagined an Alan Wake 2 video

[@MontyZander]

Major error with the ending so had to re-export a new one - bear with it should be up and fixed in a couple hours all going well!

[@quentinb4321]

@@MontyZander thank you 🙏🏾

[@martian712]

I'm watching this even though I JUST rewatched all of the Remedy videos last week and the Lore Dumps the week before that (As well as blitzing through all of Control + DLCs the morning of the eclipse) Interesting thought - how much of the Alan Wake 2 script do you have? Is a lot of the skeleton there, just waiting for the DLC and any further impressions or details that emerge? Edit: The Lore Dump clip of "The Lake has eaten Alice" was a perfect inclusion

[@MontyZander]

Bones are outlined - I’ve been working on it in the background for a few months, got a couple of cool things I’m doing in it so needed to reach out people about collaborations early doors! It’s a while away but it’s taking up my main focus starting May

[@Frankenwookie]

It’s 2024… Sam Lake is dead to me. Is now my quote for the day.

[@sebay4654]

If I were to identify a muse it would be my Trauma and Emotions as it's the heart and soul of my writing. My main problem (outside of struggling with punctuation) isnt Writers block it's that I struggle to believe in my own Ability especially since my story concepts are regularly grand in scale and I don't feel confident enough to be Happy with any Description I could write of a scene, Weather effects, or Characters appearance. Combined with the scopes of my stories the one Im currently focusing on I feel would be best as a game/multiple games. Project Blackrose is the working codename and their are 4 protagonists whom all have their own moralities, Motives and Actions that all Domino effect each other like akane attacking a bank(to break through its foundations into a Sealed Chest containing information she's After) Early on causes An Entire District of the City to Be Sealed off By Police limiting movement and/or Providing a difficult challenge for Iris(Vigilante and PI (their double life is literally either being a private investigator doing cases they're hired for or a Vigilante who's Target isn't Crime Like a Batman Type But Instead Abusers (her personal history has a lot of abuse causing her to have a Saviour Complex that she Must Sacrifice her self to safe as many People as Possible from Having to go through what she went through) and Lucius (full Time Private Investigator/Spy For Hire who's Opening scene has him Finishing the uploading of data from a police database that is normally an Air Gap system so he had to manually break in order to get the data he was Hired to Obtain Relating to a ten year long Cold Case and Information not revealed to the public), whilst crimson a Special investigator for the Police Is called out of Classes (he solved Multiple cold Cases And Even an Unsolved Case from over a hundred years ago without access to crime scenes or Police Records whilst studying criminology and as such has been Given Special permission to act as a police detective including basic firearm and Standard Combat Training along with permission to be an active detective whilst still studying as an On Call only Detective (since begining this agreement every case he's touched has been solved within a few hours to a Month at the Longest) with an exception organised for this with the school to be considered as off Campus study, Specifically he's called in to try and Help As Another person to the and Apprehend and if needed shoot to kill the Masked person who's used unknown Incindiary weapons to enter and if Neither Try to Use his Intelligence To Develop a Psychological profile on the suspect and their methods.) and that dynamic demonstration is just one chapter from the first Major Arc(games/Books per perspective character) of 3 Planned

[@Red_Clegane]

I just watched the original video and I clicked on this the second I saw it! Love these videos so much 🙌🏻

[@mrfreddorenton]

So THAT'S what all the dancing was about. Thanks for analysing Twin Peaks in accompaniment

[@TalesZuliani]

"SAM LAKE YOU HACK!" Bricky, somewhere in the internet

[@liquidrufus]

"Don't mind him.." Oh Bright Prescence Zane. Alan is going to ignore this advice in the future repeatedly. Edit:Uh wait what if defeating Scratch with a projector in AN turned him into Thomas Zane the filmmaker...

[@suburbansamurai3560]

I'm pretty sure the remaster of this essay exists solely to add one more dig at Suicide Squad Kill the Justice League.

[@ProfComic]

Great video. I'm really thrilled for your Alan Wake 2 video.

[@Gooblong]

Waited to watch this until I had played through alan wake myself, and I have to say I really loved the episodic chapters. I treated the game like a tv show, after (almost) every episode I would take a 1-2 day break to breathe everything in. And when I jumped back in, it was phenomenal seeing how the buildup I allowed myself to feel payed off.

[@picahudsoniaunflocked5426]

I remember the opening anecdote & I still love it. You should consider releasing it as a Short for Halloween.

[@Rust1809]

Alan Wake: American Nightmare was one of the first games I played. The franchise, as a whole, has a special place in my heart. I was so stoked for the release of part 2, even though my pc has trouble running games that are a decade old. One day, when I complete my schooling and make my own money, I hope to get a decent pc and play it to my hearts content!

[@Vebsters]

Goddamn, for a second there I thought this was for the second one. Keep waiting I guess

[@naoto-chan9807]

I can't wait for alan wake 2 dlcs to be released so we can have Monty's video on it

[@Lubble-]

Aw thought this was Alan Wake 2 for a second :(

[@rangerghost2474]

What’s funny is I listened to the original last week. Welp here we go again. 🤙🎉

[@ekkkkkknoes]

"Remedy is so good when it leans into the cheese" Honestly couldn't agree more. Watching writers have fun is the best.

[@JToffton]

I can’t wait for your video on Alan wake 2. That was a fun game!

[@lkotro21]

#JessieFadenCanRun =D What I liked about Barbara vanishing is that you can find a black blot where she stood. (Is it not there in a remaster?) Can you please make a short where you go "Alan can't run"?

[@ianagrace9212]

this remaster was so fun! i loved the original so i had to watch this whole thing too

[@talicarson3970]

(Spoilers for Alan Wake 2) I think that theory you had about tom zane being mr scratch is actually the other way around. Mr Scratch was temporarily defeated in American Nightmare but not destroyed, and he then took on the role of Tom Zane and tried to create art to escape. I think it's notable that A: Tom's voice actor changed, B: Tom changed from a poet to a filmmaker who made a movie about a poet, C: Alan, the Andersons, Jesse, and Cynthia all still remember him as a poet, and D: Tom looks exactly like Alan, much like Mr Scratch does. What I think happened is that Thomas Seine the filmmaker is Mr Scratch, and either he made art or influenced Alan to make art during their bender that erased Tom the Poet and left Tom the filmmaker in his place. I feel like we'll learn more about this in Control 2 since "Tom" and Darling are together now.

[@jiopa]

Personally, i think thom seine is an alternate version of alab stuck in the dark place.

[@meimei8718]

How have I not liked and commented on this?!? I’ve watched this at least three times.

[@hylianxbox6586]

Monty remastered a video about Alan wake Does this mean alan wake 2 video soon??

[@mr_queue]

Third baby! I'll always watch an Alan Wake video! Does this mean you are prepping for an Alan Wake 2 critique?

[@h.salihoden]

A damn fine video as always, I really hope to hear you talking about Silent Hill 2 someday.

[@mikefisher4051]

On the matter of Remedy scouting locations for their games, I am convinced of an idea that as Finnish devs, they visited my town of Houghton (no, not houghton lake) Michigan which has one of the highest Finnish heritage populations in the US to either visit relatives or something and saw the lift bridge and that's why the bridge in quantum break is a perfect replica of it. Surreal to see it get destroyed like that.

[@DJArkum69]

I'm loving the rework of your original video. (R.I.P. Sam Lake. LOL) Seems like a great way to fill the time between your full critiques. I would love to see/hear your take on Arkane's 'Prey'. If you already have that video, I'm unable to find it. Be well, congrats on the marriage, and good luck going to Neal's wedding. 😂

[@Zebula77]

Yes, please, please do Silent Hill one day. I'd love that. :D

[@Jillbles]

Looking forward to the Alan Wake 2 video; take your time. Thanks for what you do! ❤

[@batteredthem]

I loved this video the first time, can't wait to love this one too!

[@edwardsjcblues]

Unsure if this has ever been mentioned, but I was playing with my girlfriend today and she noticed that the tv switches set up on the TV playing the first episode of Night Springs are actually configured to read as sheet music, and it plays the Night Springs theme if you read it.

[@atanamorell2]

Best Monday morning surprise! Thanks 😊

[@rogueraccoon1840]

Well Monty there's also another story of Alan which happens in the game Dead by daylight which Remedy confirmed that the crossover of Alan wake and DBD is canon and it was one of Alan's escape attempts to write himself a way out of the darkness but instead he ended up writing himself into the Entities realm instead and into another nightmare

[@palput6884]

I'd really like to watch this Critique to be up to date to your newest AW2 Critique. I've watched original Twin Peaks run and Fire Walk with Me and now I'm waiting for my Twin Peaks (2017) boxset to arrive. Will it be ok to watch this film for me, or should I wait and watch it after TP: The Return series?

[@MontyZander]

There’s throwaway references to Twin Peaks: The Return in here but I don’t explicitly spoil anything after the Season 2 Finale

[@palput6884]

@@MontyZander Thanks for an answer, in this case I'll sit back and enjoy it now

[@pdpMASTERP]

Would be cool to include Alan Wake 2

[@jasonck9635]

That’s a good father to make it such an exciting Halloween !

[@Aarkwrite]

Love to see it

[@styeiwehdeisfdo]

Do Quantum Break, please. It's underrated. Of course, I love American Nightmare though. It's a B Movie.

[@nickblack2006]

Hey he did it about a year ago if you go to his channel page then scroll down to about a year then you will see a thumbnail with Jack Joyce face.

[@LovesDanceCentral2]

Every year without Barry is another year of bitter coffee without a donut.

[@mrkillerar1]

Lets gooooo!!

[@willisrose9756]

I wouldn’t have understood the AW series if not for Gaming University and your videos!