JBL Charge 5 vs Motion Boom vs Sony XB43 - a step to far? 🤪

[@idontknowhowigothere33]

Can’t believe I’ve actually found a trustworthy, engaging, likeable and genuinely informative channel on KZbin in 2021. Thank you!

[@alanrossreviews]

Which one? 😳 🤔

[@saketchaturvedi1073]

@@alanrossreviews lmfaooo

[@alanrossreviews]

0:00 intro 1:39 Specs 7:27 40% volume test 9:27 40% summary 12:02 70% sound test 14:13 70% summary 16:21 80% sound clip 18:33 80% frequency analysis 20:18 80% summary 22:51 maximum volume test

[@alanrossreviews]

tracks: 7:27 Floppy Circus - Wayback ft. Jeff Kaale 12:02 Nexone - Memories 16:21 RVPTR x GODMODE x YUNAY - Assassinate 22:51 Alban Chela & Braveboy - HAJDE

[@user-pq3v2yw3v]

A year later, listening on my Charge 5.. Only $170 CAD. Or about 120 Pounds. Great deal, and a significant improvement over my Charge 3. Fills a room with great sound!

[@mangaas]

Came here from searching the Soundcore Motion Boom reviews -just before an Amazon purchase.... and I watched this entire video. I'm now buying the Soundcore, and just subbed to you too. Good, thorough stuff!

[@alanrossreviews]

you cant go wrong with the boom for the money 👍

[@derekwright5722]

Picked up a Motion Boom (to replace my Charge 3 that no longer holds a charge) mostly due to watching your reviews. I'm impressed by the sound, especially for the price. Appreciate the hard work!

[@alanrossreviews]

No worries 😜

[@julian-fricker]

Just wanted to say thanks. Had decided to buy the Charge 5 but after watching your video I'm a very happy Motion Boom owner, loving the bass.

[@alanrossreviews]

good choice!

[@waynedexter]

Meticulousness is your niche in this budget Bluetooth speaker comparison game. Your hard work is greatly appreciated. I’m surprised I haven’t copped the motion boom yet. I guess it’s partially due to me being completely satisfied with the motion plus, still...

[@alanrossreviews]

i simply dont listen the m+ any more, i cant be without the bass of the boom 😁

[@carbonation28]

I wish the motion boom had like a fabric or removable handle so it would be more compact. Without the handle, its size would be much more comparable to other smaller speakers

[@alanrossreviews]

There is no perfect speaker sadly 👀

[@BenjiMiranda]

Man you read my mind, I was watching your videos this morning and comparing this speakers with your previous videos, you’re awesome!

[@alanrossreviews]

thanks for watching 😁😁

[@gcleveland]

Thanks for the review. My Motion Boom arrived today. I am returning the Charge 5. It is as you say (of course), the JBL is amazing till about 40% volume or so, then it becomes bass-less and the highs are way too sharp for me. Really hurts my ears at louder volume levels.

[@alanrossreviews]

Motion boom bass will not let you down 😝

[@gcleveland]

@@alanrossreviews Appreciate you taking the time to reply. I really love the sound from the Boom, now that I have gotten the chance to try it with your EQ settings. I am finding that for me, personally, it does not quite go loud enough. What would you try next in my shoes? Love the sound but want a bit more volume. The charge 5 is not full enough at high volume though. I have the W-King X10 coming (ordered before the Anker). Thanks! I should add I also have the Ion Sport XL and it does get very loud, crazy good for the price but it's too big to lug around all the time.

[@alanrossreviews]

well the x10 will go louder for sure. or you could get a second boom. not sure what sort of levels you are looking for but clearly bigger speakers will be required. i guess you will be looking at the partybox type speakers.

[@gcleveland]

@@alanrossreviews Thank you! This is exactly what I wanted to know. I will try the x10 and if it's not enough, I may have to go the Boombox 2 etc route. Appreciate you!

[@danielmcclory8675]

Listening to this on my Motion Boom just to say thank you Alan Ross!!! Thinking of getting a second just to hear them paired

[@alanrossreviews]

get a 2nd, thank me later 👍

[@ThibautMahringer]

Hell yeah ! I was waiting for that video !

[@alanrossreviews]

Hell yeah, i was waiting for your comment 🤗 🤗 🤗

[@ThibautMahringer]

@@alanrossreviews I always comment, you should take it for granted at this point 😂😂

[@alanrossreviews]

yup i do! 😋😋

[@ThibautMahringer]

@@alanrossreviews I have seen several videos about a new Tribit speaker, the Stormbox Pro. I would love if you could check it out !

[@petervdveenmuis]

Got the Motion Boom! Thnx for your advise. It's a gem.

[@alanrossreviews]

now you have to save for a second one 😊

[@shoerice5083]

Not great

[@Proches91]

@@shoerice5083 big ratio🤠

[@arrakis8320]

Wow man! magnificent analisis. I love soundcore motion boom. Thanks and suscribed 👍😊.

[@alanrossreviews]

welcome aboard... 👌

[@ypoora1]

After doubting between these options a lot i ended up getting the Charge 5 anyway. The Boom sounds so, so great (and i might still buy one down the line!) but it's too big for me to be taking it everywhere. For it's size, i am massively impressed with my Charge 5. Probably helps that i sold my Charge 4 for a great price so the upgrade was cheap ;)

[@alanrossreviews]

Enjoy!

[@Autunite]

If you want something more portable with better clarity and deeper bass than the Charge 5, you could get the Soundcore Motion+. It's just amazing for its size.

[@Nosuchthingasnormalhere]

@@Autunite I wouldn't say deeper bass at all.

[@Ikhlashasib10]

@@Autunite that speaker is no way better than the charge 5

[@davidbezzant9820]

@@Autunite bro deep bass on the motion plus? You must mean the motion boom. And it's not even more portable either lol my charge 5 is 970 grams and my motion plus is 1060 grams haha

[@_-Z-]

Awesome comparison, Alan! 👍 The value of the motion boom is undeniable. The fact that it can be adjusted to personal taste within the Soundcore app automatically gives it an edge but that low end bass really sets it apart from other speakers in it's size and weight class. On another note, how do you think the maxsound plus would compare to the charge 5 for low level listening? This video prompted me to think about it since clarity at lower volumes seem to be strengths for both of them.

[@alanrossreviews]

hum, not sure, i would expect the c5 to sound more dynamic and the maxsound a bit thinner more neutral and honest. good question, would have to have a listen 😁

[@0525ohhwell]

Was just hoping there was a solid comparison between the Charge 5 and the Anker Boom. Damn it was good to see you pop up in the search results! I am really interested in the Charge 5 for taking on vacations where I have to fly.

[@alanrossreviews]

Charge5 is decent but motion boom can go places the charge 5 can only dream of

[@0525ohhwell]

@@alanrossreviews Yeah, I was coming at it from a size and weight perspective but man, that Motion Boom is only $80 USD right now on amazon with a coupon code. Might be worth packing a few less swim trunks...

[@alanrossreviews]

jeez, how big are your trunks? 😂😂😂😂

[@0525ohhwell]

@@alanrossreviews lol. I just picked a single item at random! Probably not over a Kilo worth of fabric.

[@0525ohhwell]

@@alanrossreviews I did end up getting a motion boom and it's smaller in person than I expected. Perfect! They really did an amazing job with this thing. Max volume is a little rough but I can't imagine anyone will care in a scenario where it is at 100%.

[@FuKungPandaa]

Got the Motion Boom (instead of the JBL which I initially intended to buy). Man the Motion Boom has some awesome base! Gonna get a second one now :-D

[@Yt_ShadowBannedme]

Definitely get a 2nd one. Paired together it’s hard to beat.

[@rodanakgul8984]

Please compere the Motion boom to the Onyx Studio 7/6

[@alanrossreviews]

i have already done that 😱

[@andreaszimmer6447]

Just got the second Motion Boom! Definitely worth it!!! Thank you for convincing me to get the Motion Boom!!! It plays in a completely different league than my old JBL Charge 3. Man my room is vibrating!!! I think my neighbours won't be happy with me any more!

[@alanrossreviews]

Two booms are still nearly half the price of the xtreme, crazy!!

[@KingdomWithin7]

Had the Charge 3, Charge 4, and now the Charge 5! And let me tell you the sound of the Charge 5 is on another level! JBL did it right this time for the Charge Line.

[@alanrossreviews]

hum.....better than charge 4 does make it JBL getting it right.

[@HansPeter-pe6cw]

Hello Alan is the boom better or Charge 5 ?????

[@user-ik8wd9vm7r]

How can you do karaoke on the charge 5 if it doesn't have an aux input port? . I'm trying to find out because this speaker has everything I'm looking for except this little detail.

[@jeffmccrady9456]

as usall alan great review!! plain and simple! the person at anker who designed the boom? was a millionare over night! BOOM!!!!

[@alanrossreviews]

they shook up the market thats for sure 🧐

[@abdullahamr8779]

You are the king👑 of comparisons👍🏻

[@alanrossreviews]

i will have to start wearing a crown? 😁😁😁

[@Glossopwildcamp]

Very informative comparison Alan, thanks a lot. I opted for the Motion Boom after seeing your vids and am so impressed I bought another one! To my ears the Motion Boom, with custom EQ, has a glossy sheen at the high end compared to the other speakers you have tested it against, which I love. As you say the deep bass is amazing, I never thought that it could be produced with only 60mm drivers, I'm guessing that with them being titanium they are able to have greater excursion, compared to paper or plastic, without potentially damaging them.

[@alanrossreviews]

But i think any theoretical advantage of titanium would be for the high end?

[@DreSttarr-yi7lz]

Top review mate👍👌 What a let down by Sony. The Srs Xb3 was a little montser.

[@alanrossreviews]

the older sonys were definitely better

[@V.M.P.J.]

That Soundcore Motion Boom it’s something out of this world for the price, I hope I can be able to get one these to hear in person. Great review Alan 👍🏽

[@alanrossreviews]

whats stopping you?

[@curtcodein6486]

its 70 euros now on amazon in Europe i want to buy but i am not shure

[@V.M.P.J.]

@@alanrossreviews There’s no shipping to my country at the moment. I’ve only managed to get the Motion Plus which I’m in love with.

[@witchkinggilles]

@@curtcodein6486 Definitely get it, It's a steal at that price

[@Jul0570]

Thanks again alan, great vid!👍🏼😜

[@alanrossreviews]

You're welcome as always 👍😝

[@kenmusicman7061]

I own 2 xb43''s one black n one tan and want to buy 1 in blue when on sale.I do own a lot of others but something I love is pairing up the 2 sonys at full volume and enjoying the light show.They sound great side by side in the vertical position.I love the video👍

[@alanrossreviews]

👌👌

[@leandrosilva6414]

First to comment eheh! I have been waiting for this!! Great comparition! Thanks Alan!

[@alanrossreviews]

you are current first commenter champion, well done 😁😁😁

[@ComedyAustria]

I wanna buy one for my room, not that big, mostly would listen to it on like 50 %. Which one should i go for? I mostly listen to hiphop Would love a respond!

[@alanrossreviews]

charge 5

[@ComedyAustria]

@@alanrossreviews thanks for the quiz respond! I ordered the motion boom yesterday, mainly because its 70 bucks cheaper than the c5. Hope i‘m happy with my choice when it a arrives!

[@NetRolller3D]

About the XB43 sounding muffled: reduce the "mids" slider in the EQ, and it's gonna improve. There is possibly a bug in the EQ w.r.t. that slider (on FW 38.00 at least), since setting it high, to me at least, results in a sound that seems deficient in mid-tones.

[@alanrossreviews]

your right, and not just with the xb43, the sony eq does weird things at different volumes, hard to get it right.

[@NetRolller3D]

@@alanrossreviews I bet they didn't quite update the EQ code to account for the crossover. The "mids" slider is probably routing midtones to the tweeters, hurting clarity - meanwhile, midtones to the woofers are uncontrolled, or controlled by the bass slider.

[@NetRolller3D]

Took apart mine today; turns out, the situation is far worse than I thought. There's no crossover, the tweeters are pretty much just for show. I tested the speaker with the tweeters disconnected - virtually no change in sound. Then I disconnected the woofers, and only plugged in the tweeters - barely anything audible (a very quiet and bassless version of the original track, and not at all like what a proper low-pass filter would do). Finally, I took out the main PCB, and traced the connection to the drivers. The tweeters are directly connected to the woofers on the negative side, and through a 1.8μF capacitor on the positive side. That's 8.84 ohms of reactance even at 10kHz, and over 25 ohms at 3.5kHz, essentially connected parallel to a 4 ohm -woofer- full-range driver, in essence. This also means, since the woofers are fed by a YDA174 amp, with a maximum sustained output of 30W, and burst output of 40W, that the XB43 can only be called no more than a 30W speaker in good conscience. Sony did not fail to disappoint with this one. EDIT: I may just be an idiot. I completely missed 2x100μH of inductance in line with each woofer. So it is a proper passive crossover (as much as a passive crossover can be called "proper"), but still only a 30W speaker.

[@alanrossreviews]

@@NetRolller3D thanks for the info. so the takeway is? what frequencies are the tweeters actually playing? when you say it is a proper crossover the woofers are still full range right outside of bass? so it cannot be said to be a proper crossover i would have thought if the woofer and tweeter are still covering the same range at the high end. the tweeter your saying only has a filter fed from the woofer?

[@NetRolller3D]

@@alanrossreviews The capacitor & inductor values seem correct for a 3.5kHz passive crossover assuming a 4ohm woofer and 32ohm tweeter, but there's definitely still quite a bit of sound coming from the woofers even at 4kHz. Maybe the speaker impedances aren't actually 4/32.

[@konradmajewski7032]

Hey, I just ordered charge 5 but after seeing reviews I think of returning it. I will mostly use it for my PC so the volume will be probably around 30-40%. What do you recommend guys ? I thought that clarity and good bass for low volumes will convince me but now I dont know :(

[@alanrossreviews]

Charge 5 is ok, what's putting you off?

[@konradmajewski7032]

@@alanrossreviews Mostly the bass. I haven't heard neither of these speakers in real so I can't really tell but I am seeing really different opinions regarding the sound quality on lower volumes. (30-50%).

[@udim7284]

Thanks for another great review,Alan. What would you say is the best stereo setting for a small room? which speakers in case portability is rarely needed? Thanks.

[@alanrossreviews]

minirigs in 2.2, but for what budget?

[@udim7284]

@@alanrossreviews anything under 150 euro...

[@alanrossreviews]

So hard to say because of variables in taste, room acoustics etc. Even how loud does it need to get?

[@udim7284]

@@alanrossreviews medium loud, there are houses behind my house so I don't want to go jbl extreme/motion boom loud. Strong but smooth bass, stereo surround feeling, its for my bedroom which is small - medium size, playing mostly epic music (two steps from hell and alike)

[@supremevisor]

Thanks for the review. Received my MB and absolutely happy))) plays down to 45hz though, not 40.

[@alanrossreviews]

how are you measuring that?

[@supremevisor]

@@alanrossreviews frequency generator software

[@bradgutches6266]

Would a combination of the motion boom and the motion plus be the perfect sound to get and play together?

[@alanrossreviews]

not really, the boom just needs the wide angle tweeters of the plus.

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

One question, have you tested the new NT and TT models (CHARGE 5H AND CHARGE 5J)? Which one did you find the best in terms of sound quality?

[@alanrossreviews]

no i only have the tl version.

[@ana99tav]

The charge 5 looks so pretty, i really wanna get it, but the motion boom sounds soooo good 😅 well my budget is 100 euros so.. What should I doooo Alan?

[@alanrossreviews]

well charge 5 smaller and more knockable while motion boom has great deep bass for size and price that you wont get from the charge 5.

[@ana99tav]

@@alanrossreviews Alan Im so sad, the motion boom was at 71 yesterday but now its 100 euros

[@alanrossreviews]

its always coming back on sale price, just wait it out.

[@udim7284]

Would you say the motion boom will be a considerable upgrade coming from Charge 3?

[@alanrossreviews]

Holy shit yeah 👍👍👍

[@udim7284]

@@alanrossreviews cool. I'll order one in a few days, will be on sale where I live on 5.5

[@rubif5797]

How does rock and metal sound on the speakers? Would there be maybe a different result?

[@alanrossreviews]

big difference! only the motion boom will dig out that kick drum!

[@gkiss2030]

@@alanrossreviews So it's very low on the Charge 5? I mostly listen to these genres and was pretty satisfied with Charge 4, but now contemplating moving up to C5.

[@rubif5797]

@@gkiss2030 charge 5 is supposed to have better sound than charge 4. So if you liked the 4 it will be fine. But they are not compatible.

[@gkiss2030]

@@rubif5797 I know...and because of this, I am thinking about getting another Flip 4 with my Charge 4 (my previous Flip 4 just died recently, charging port problem...but they sounded fabulously together), instead of getting the Charge 5.

[@rubif5797]

@@gkiss2030 charge 4 is on sale as well because it is old gen. Actually a good time to get an additional speaker for a lower price from the last gen......

[@MrPiootr81]

Hi ! I have FLip 6 GG and its great ... i bought another flip 6 - CS version - its horrible ... I want to but Charge 5 (maybe 2 for stereo) . Sir, tell me which version is the best , please.

[@alanrossreviews]

I only have one charge 5 so i really don't know

[@MrPiootr81]

@@alanrossreviews ok Thank you

[@marcusstavenger6968]

Hey Alan, how does the motion boom compare the Sony xb40. Does the motion boom have significantly deeper bass and how much louder does it go?

[@alanrossreviews]

i havent compared them directly but yes the boom goes places im pretty sure the xb40 never went. the boom is bigger of course.

[@roybodin7301]

Hey Alan, do you think you could review the UE Hyperboom? I know people haven't been a big fan of UE in the past but we were all pleasantly surprised by the Wonderboom.

[@alanrossreviews]

well compare it with what? we already know its an upper bass box, not sure whats left to discover?

[@roybodin7301]

@@alanrossreviews The JBL boombox 2 and HK Studio 6 or 7.

[@xiuzzit4893]

Ignore the price and focus on sound quality, Which one would you choose between Motion boom and Xb43? I usually listen to Pop, EDM and some chill-out music. Need your help!

[@alanrossreviews]

motion boom 👍 pair for same money as xb43 depending on deals and country.

[@Dani-C71]

If you listen around 40-60% volume which speaker in sound do you like most... charge 5 vs xtreme 3?

[@alanrossreviews]

i have yet to compare them but i will say the charge 5 has been one my fav listens for low volume.

[@Dani-C71]

@@alanrossreviews Thanks Alan! Maybe now it is time to compare after charge 5 got updated and played in.. or is it speaker or ears that got played/tuned in 😆

[@alanrossreviews]

Who can say for sure, measurements suggest its improved. Im working through the charge 5 requests, vs xtreme 3 to come.

[@mbu5371]

Very nice job 💥 THANKS 🎶

[@alanrossreviews]

Thank you too!

[@andreaszimmer6447]

Thanks for your awesome reviews!!! Like your channel! I was about to buy 2 x JBL Charge 5 to have some nice stereo sound. After watching your reviews I decided to go with 1 x Motion Boom instead!!

[@alanrossreviews]

and of course you can get two motion booms for one charge 5 and still get really great stereo.

[@jcdupuy4809]

With custom eq on the motion boom, can it be as good as the jbl charge 5 ?

[@alanrossreviews]

For sure, but the c5 is very clear at low volume so this is the only area i would say the c5 can have the edge on the boom, its a lot smaller of course.

[@alentiangco4327]

What if the motion boom and the ibl charge 5 has the same price what eill you choose between the two?

[@alanrossreviews]

boom|||!

[@alentiangco4327]

@@alanrossreviews thank you so much!

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

Sorry, I'm using a translator. I am from Argentina. Here there is almost no information about Jbl. Only 2 versions are sold here, both manufactured in March 2021 from what I saw on the box. The NT version (CHARGE 5H) AND THE TT VERSION (CHARGE 5J). If you're so nice, would you tell me which one I should choose and why? Thanks!

[@alanrossreviews]

who is the biggest brand of speakers in argentina?

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

@@alanrossreviews I don't know, but there is an e-commerce platform (similar to ebay) and there the only 2 versions of jbl charge 5 are sold, the tt and the nt. That is why I ask for your advice, to be able to decide. I'll wait for your answer, thank you so much!

[@alanrossreviews]

i have not got those versions to test, sorry.

[@WikiReever]

Helo sir, I own JBL charge 2+ should I upgrade to soundcore motion boom ?

[@alanrossreviews]

if you like deep bass then yes. if you prefer clarity get the motion plus instead.

[@toaoGEO]

Hi, I bought the Motion Boom. But, it's really quiet. :O I'm testing it against a JBL Charge Essentials 2 and I would say it's significantly quieter.Not even the bass does't hold up. I've tried it on both an iPhone and a Samsung with Soundcore app. I've updated the firmware to 0.43 and still the same. Am I missing something?

[@alanrossreviews]

yes, you have a dud or havent got the volume in sync.

[@frankferman8994]

Hello Alan have you ever had a chance to test the Sony XB-501G ? That speaker is pretty unique its a single mid/bass driver and 2 tweeters set up this speaker is truly impressive on the low end it would be an awesome battle against something like JBL extreme 3 Anker Motion boom even the Onyx Studio 6 yes its really that good cheers.

[@alanrossreviews]

quite muddy im told?

[@frankferman8994]

@@alanrossreviews Actually if you use the sony app and play with embedded eq you can make it really "sparkle" I own lots of nice speakers and believe me if you get your hands on one you will more than likely really enjoy it. I listen to lots of music with acoustic guitars and they sound so natural but it will handle anything like hip hop or dance or rock its just a really good all around speaker. Oh and its also google capable so you can have 1 or 2 or 100 playing at the same time its truly something nice.

[@MaximoAtonducan]

​@@frankferman8994 no no no

[@joser3613]

The Titanium Speaker Drivers in the Motion Boom make it sound like a speaker bigger its size.

[@HugoRHut]

Alan Ross would you recommend the Charge 5 or motion boom if im going to use it 85% of the time indoors in small rooms

[@alanrossreviews]

boom............

[@ulliu.3200]

Is the motion boom actually waterproof? My first unit had water inside of it after I tested it under some water out of the shower (just some sprinkle from the top) and with my replacement now I don't actually want to try it anymore 😂

[@alanrossreviews]

same for me. it filled right up with water but did play after drying out.

[@ulliu.3200]

@@alanrossreviews Ok seems pretty weird to me. When I shook the motion boom I heard the water splashing inside of it and after I set it on my shelf for a night there was a puddle. Anyways it's a great sounding speaker and I don't regret buying it. Thanks for your valuable comparisons :)

[@ubonsampson4123]

Soundcore motion boom is expensive here in Nigeria, just bought mine $136. thanks for the video.

[@alanrossreviews]

well still a decent speaker.

[@Владислав-с8ы5ч]

what microphone do you record on?

[@mihutCIUC]

Hello what do you recommend JBL charge 5 or Sony SRS 43?

[@alanrossreviews]

over the long term maybe the xb43 but its way heavier.

[@mayanroses1]

Can you pair a Motion Boom and a Motion + ?

[@alanrossreviews]

nope!

[@mayanroses1]

@@alanrossreviews guess I'll have to pair 2 motion + then

[@alanrossreviews]

Yup 🤗

[@abrado1]

I bought an Anker Boom thank to your videos. Alan you re the best, keep up the good work ;)

[@alanrossreviews]

i am trying 😁

[@andrewbarnett2761]

Jbl to me just sounds so much clearer. While sony sounds to warm. Sound core shines at 80 percent.

[@chrisvondoom3679]

A Sony that sounds warm? Nah man never 😂 You got it backwards. Sony actually has a cold crisp bright sound with emphasis on the highs.. JBL actually sounds warm with deeper mids and lows. Which sounds better? It’s actually a matter of taste. I love JBL’s sound signature. I think there highs are loud enough to not sound over bearing and the lows and mids hit hard enough to not drown out their not so bright highs.

[@TheChiraagG]

The JBL is actually quite nice, but for the price the Boom is the one. Often times I'd be listening blind on these tests and some parts of songs the Boom was better, some the JBL, but when the JBL shined it shined nicely. I just have personally a limited use case for speakers but want something that outshines my old Motion Qs, and the Motion Booms do it well. Great bang for buck. I prefer the Motion Boom more than the Soundcore party speakers for overall sound.

[@MangaAnimeStyle]

I found the soundcore have more sounds! One of the sounds is losing from another two speakers. That one ts tc ts tc ts xD

[@jamieeisenhower1560]

I like lassability and quality and quality sound over lights.

[@alanrossreviews]

but having lights doesnt mean you cant have quality

[@jamieeisenhower1560]

@@alanrossreviews In some cases yes but I like old school and I like quality Everything today is getting too fake.

[@ramenkar7505]

Hey can you pls help me select between charge 5 and sony xb43 I am really struggling to make a decision a reply will be highly appreciated thank you

[@eddievelazquez6097]

Charge 5 if you want fidelity, xb43 if you want louder sounds I’ll stick to the charge 5, sounds more crispy to me

[@dagg497]

Tested the JBL extreme 3, Charge 5 and XB 43 at Mediamarkt. I must say the difference of the smaller and larger JBL wasn't that big. The JBL has alot of bass but lacking in mids and has a high pitch treble that left my ears tired from It. The Sony has a much more musical If not more relaxing tone response IRL. What was surpising was the sound spread oattern! The JBL had 40degree sound cone before it dropped of by 50%, whereas the Sony had a 90degree sound cone. So the Sony is better for entertaining a few friends on a blanket in a park I would say. The JBLs bass is a bit much in the park aswell 😅

[@alanrossreviews]

id rather loisten to the motion boom (not plus) than xb43 and x3. the charge 5 as portable travel speaker i really like.

[@dagg497]

@@alanrossreviews I'll see If I can find It somewhere.. I tried a haul of BT speakers last summer and wasn't pleased with amyone from Oluv's Gadgets top 5 here on KZbin.. I actually tried Charge 4 and Anker Motion+ and had to send both back. The Anker hurt my ears so bad with the ear piercing Treble.. I like the Onyx 5 though but the speaker format is so inpractical. Maybe i can saw off the handle on the motion boom and add a leather strap instead hahahah 😅

[@alanrossreviews]

the handle holds the speaker together so not possible 😭

[@aktunav]

Great comparison, thank you... I like charge 5 more cause of size-performance criteria... Usually C5 performs quite nice and balanced. Only issue is the price of C5

[@alanrossreviews]

And very narrow sound but you notice it less at lower volumes where for me its strong point is, the sheer clarity without pushing volumes. 👍

[@aktunav]

@@alanrossreviews Now i am so happy that i couldn't buy Motion Boom :D I prefer C5 instead of Boom...Thank you for your comparison...

[@cosminpopescu6748]

First impression with my Jbl charge 5, a fairly clear and neutral sound without impressing in any way. Then I set an external equalizer (10 bands), turned on dolby atmos and started listening the "Two steps from hell live at Wacken Festival" concert. It was wow, the sound quality is impressive for a mono speaker under 1 kg. The speaker suddenly became much more dynamic. Jbl products always sound better on live music than on studio albums. To get a quality sound, the speaker must be set according to the type of music you listen to. Jbl eq in the app is quite rudimentary.

[@alanrossreviews]

This is fine if you just listen to one genre. Often though i find it doesn't work out if you listen to multi genres. But if you are just adapting it to your own ears and room thats different, then it works all round.

[@cosminpopescu6748]

@@alanrossreviews Yes, I adapt the eq for each musical genre. I usually listen to rock and metal. I don't think the perfect speaker exists just to plug and play. It's like a concert without FOH Engineer sounds flat without life.

[@theboston3386]

Finally got my Boom. Compared to my JBL charge 4, Minirig 2.1, JBL partybox 100, Sony XB43, JBL xtreme 2 and a few others. Im utterly impressed with the motion boom: that deep bass is something else. For long term listen, I'll grab the Minirig but for some fun listen, the boom but partybox for outdoors or party setting.

[@alanrossreviews]

custom eq?

[@theboston3386]

@@alanrossreviews Yes, with yours buddy.

[@xiuzzit4893]

Ignore the price, Which one would you choose between Motion boom and Xb43?

[@theboston3386]

@@xiuzzit4893 Motion boom, there's something magical about that deep base. However, it's not as loud outdoors as the xb

[@baohungnguyen8069]

about XB43 and Motion boom, Can you tell me which one sounds better? I usually listen to pop and some EDM. I'm going crazy with these two lol.

[@tripuluhjuniantoro6551]

Motion boom or sony xb43 for outdoor activity alan?

[@alanrossreviews]

neither are great outdoors, check the mifa wildbox, more of an outdoor tuning

[@tripuluhjuniantoro6551]

@@alanrossreviews thank you alan

[@firestormstarzy3067]

What speaker would you go for the jbl charge 5 or Sony xb43?

[@alanrossreviews]

well the sony is veryy heavy for its size, i would rather live with the xb43 but i would take the motion boom over the xb43 and keep the charge 5 for low volume or travel

[@brandonbrodbeck6688]

I get for the waterproof part and the sound clarity. I have a kid I like to go to the beach and pool so... are the others waterproof? And their marketing. They do have ones with LEDs but I don't know if those are water proof and it's a bit more too

[@alanrossreviews]

they are all waterproof, only xb43 has lights.

[@shaolindreams]

65 quid for the Motion Boom atm. Seems a solid deal. Ironically i can hear the Boom's Bass is the best overall.. on some big Sony Xtra Bass headphones ho ho ho

[@alanrossreviews]

ho ho ho 🤣

[@RC-df9lz]

Ouch I want to buy it but it’s £90 at the mo... shall I be a stinge and wait for it to be reduced again 😩

[@shaolindreams]

@@RC-df9lz Yeah i saw it went up soon after.. I'd hold out for a deal still.

[@atanasdionisiev3031]

@@RC-df9lz it is on discount now. 69£ ;) I just ordered one for myself

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

I don't know, but there is an e-commerce platform (similar to ebay) and there the only 2 versions of jbl charge 5 are sold, the tt and the nt. That is why I ask for your advice, to be able to decide. I'll wait for your answer, thank you so much!

[@xAbnorse]

You are literally under every charge 5 video asking for these two models.

[@Tony_ChidiEbere]

It really doesn't matter anymore...trust me, its not the same story with the flip 5s. I've tested all versions! The tl & tt are the same speakers, same goes for the nd & nt. But they all sound basically the same on their latest firmware.

[@kevinfotsch6421]

How does the motion boom go against the select pro

[@alanrossreviews]

the select pro is inferior.

[@luisignaciogarciaguarda6626]

2 flip 5 or 1 charge 5? 😱😱.. Nice videos as always !

[@alanrossreviews]

For the future 🔮

[@gkiss2030]

@@alanrossreviews So, which one? :) I am considering getting another Flip 4 with my Charge 4 (my previous Flip 4 died), they sound so good together (Charge gives the meat and Flip the extra mids/highs).

[@Electrifize]

I know I'm late, but although you get Stereo with 2 Flip 5's, they dont have tweeters - so the high's would sound easily better on the Charge 5. The bass would probably be identical but a slight edge to the dual Flip 5's

[@godspeedsr1471]

Is there any noticeable difference when you hear or feel the overall bass frequency range from a pure subwoofer ( with additional drivers handling other frequencies ) and compare it to motion boom's bass character considering the subwoofer will not play lower than the boom ... I mean any difference in bass character comparing subwoofer (open port design) and passive radiators...?

[@alanrossreviews]

not sure what you mean by the subwoofer wont play any lower. the bass in the boom does roll off and doesn't play down to 20hz flat like a decent sub would/could. yeah a sub would sound different, the bass of the boom for me isnt of great quality its more about he quantity, its not very tight or defined by great for size and price. this passive vs rad will be a matter of opinion i would say. i have always thought of ports and passive rads and the same thing, using the air pressure, both having advantages and disadvantages over each other. at least with a passive rad you dont get that port noise.

[@godspeedsr1471]

@@alanrossreviews ohh huh I was not talking about 20 hz sub something like goes down to 30 hz ... more similar to minirig subwoofer that has port open... but boom goes deeper... but thanks for your opinions that helps a lot... i don't have any experience just started experiencing... yeah the bass quality is not as good as jbl but motion boom is fking impressive... it just looks bigger than it should be with the handle that's something i don't like...

[@alanrossreviews]

Yeah the boom goes deeper than the minirig sub but the minirig sub is more punchy, tight and detailed. But its also tuned to match the mk3. If it just had gain and low pass control 🤣🤣

[@godspeedsr1471]

@@alanrossreviews so overall the open ports vs passive rads depending on their advantages and disadvantages, you think it's kind of same though they sound different...?

[@philjoysavio6805]

getting 2 booms & playing in stereo👌🏻

[@alanrossreviews]

Heaven 😝

[@mattheturk8158]

So my charge 3 doesn’t charge anymore literally so I was like ok charge 5 is on the way I’m gonna get it when it’s released then I started watching your videos and actually now I’m in between jbl extreme 2 and motion boom. Where I am extreme 2 is on sale so I can buy it for the price of charge 5 but do you think boom is gonna be the better option regardless. Mostly listening to rock/electronic genres which one would be your choice in this case?

[@alanrossreviews]

will depend on taste, x2 upper bass heavy but motion boom deep bass heavy. i find boom more for long term serious listen but x2 for maybe outside and more fun party listen.

[@mattheturk8158]

@@alanrossreviews thanks for your answer. Motion boom it is then for me thanks a lot.

[@Lionspel]

the motion boom covered the highs well especially those at 8:58 compared to the jbl and sony

[@darrenwipf9868]

Is the xb43 worth it for 100 and how is the loudness indoors

[@alanrossreviews]

not for me given its weight and what the motion boom can do for half the money

[@darrenwipf9868]

@@alanrossreviews well I can't really find any speaker of that size and quality with lights and the live mode which I really like

[@alanrossreviews]

@@darrenwipf9868 the world has moved on since the xb43, its a very safe sound and you will enjoy it but you can do better these days. the stormbox blast for example so much better.

[@cubancigarman2687]

I have a pair of Sony xb40’s. Many people have commented that the older Xb40 has a better sound signature over the xb43. The only drawback back with my Sony xb40 is that the barrel charger requires an ac plug. I had wished that Sony would have used usb instead. I have a Sony Bluetooth speaker(2013) with the first liquid radiator and the signature is quite awesome. I believe it is 40watts plugged in. Seems like Sony lately has been just pushing out non offensive products. Pricy middle of the road products. I recently bought a JBL bb3 and a flip5 mainly for the deepest bass. We’ll see how long these JBL’s will last.

[@alanrossreviews]

its been downhill since the xb40 and xb30

[@cubancigarman2687]

@@alanrossreviews yes sir I agree. I must say the bb3 and flip combo really bumps when pushed. I’m a truck driver and the company has no radios installed in delivery trucks so I have to haul my own sound system in daily. Good day and god bless.

[@mangadolo]

Is there any other portable Bluetooth speaker that has frequency low of 20Hz besides Sony XB43?

[@alanrossreviews]

Xb43 does not play down to 20hz. If its not within 3db of the rest of the frequency range then its not actually playing music to 20hz

[@mangadolo]

@@alanrossreviews I see. Hmmm... so I produce music on Serato Studio software. I tend to create bass heave dance music/HipHop. I already have monitors... but I like to test my beats on a portable Bluetoothspeakers to simulate average listeners. Which portable Bluetooth speaker would you recommend that has the lowest, useable frequency range?

[@aidenmiddleton]

@@mangadolo Soundcore Motion Boom, even with the default Soundcore Signature mode, it has the impressessive deep bass, with decent mids and highs.

[@mangadolo]

@@aidenmiddleton much appreciated! Cheers!

[@brandigamelo8958]

2 flip 5 or 1 motion boom? My girlfriend have 1 flip 5, and i thing in buy another flip 5, 6 or charge 5 for connect the two speakers for surround sound.. only for that if not i choose the anker 100% Thank you for the rewievs and sorry for my english😊

[@alanrossreviews]

motion boom for me

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

the best sound quality, tl/tt or nd/nt?

[@alanrossreviews]

is your keyboard stuck?

[@antonellalujanelmo6890]

@@alanrossreviews Sorry, I'm using a translator. I am from Argentina. Here there is almost no information about Jbl. Only 2 versions are sold here, both manufactured in March 2021 from what I saw on the box. The NT version (CHARGE 5H) AND THE TT VERSION (CHARGE 5J). If you're so nice, would you tell me which one I should choose and why? Thanks!

[@dimaskresna2079]

Deep bass on motion boom is a beast 😍

[@alanrossreviews]

yup 😜

[@udim7284]

1 motion boom vs 2 charge 3 - who wins in sound quality?

[@alanrossreviews]

charge 3 simply cant match the bass of the boom whether one or two of them.

[@Kyriakos1206]

Is the boom still good at max volume ??

[@alanrossreviews]

it loses bass so its still good but much thinner than at 80%.

[@Kyriakos1206]

@@alanrossreviews but im gonna go for the motion+ because of its size

[@kuwwo]

Great comparison video. I don't know much about speakers but I'm really learning alot from watching your videos. I really love the xb 43 because i like punchy bass but not deep bass, idk if I'm getting this right or not but i don't like the kind of bass in subwoofers, so the xb 43 lacking deep bass is actually perfect for me. Wish it'd go louder for the size tho.

[@alanrossreviews]

yup you described it well, sub bass being a different type to punchy upper bass. and xb43 lacks sub type bass.

[@Darrell-o7j]

I own a JBL charge 5 TT model does anybody know anything about these models❤

[@Guts7417]

What would you recommend? Charge 5, motion boom, XB43 or Extreme 4? Forget about the budget Please give me you ans with list to 1-4

[@alanrossreviews]

go play 3

[@mubarakhsquare]

I may Like to see comprising thus and transmart t6 max also, if you have it

[@capitanlevi203]

Sony xb 43 (LDAC, Tweeters, ESTEREO, input 3.5)>> all jbl flip & chargue (sbs mono)

[@alanrossreviews]

Stormbox blast

[@BertoJim]

Hey man please review head to head the Soundcore Motion Boom and the Alec Lansing Mix 2.0. The Altec has a huge light show.

[@Kaabosurron]

Ordered a motion boom should come in today

[@alanrossreviews]

enjoy! 😊

[@pawew6312]

Which have more powerfull bass?

[@lukkov89]

Słychać wyraźnie i nawet on sam mówi który ;)

[@pawew6312]

@@lukkov89 spoko własnie juz ogladałem

[@aztech6436]

love anker motion boom so much

[@alanrossreviews]

a gift from heaven 🤡

[@solomonododoru2061]

I still prefer my charge 5 when it comes to Bluetooth portable speakers of it categories if a mono speaker (charge 5) could compete with its big brother xtreme3, motion boom which are stereo speakers and other high end brand (B&O and Bose) and it has a resale value in my country Nigeria then that little thing is small but mighty. I will get one more jbl charge 5 for stereo and if I need a really bass portable speaker then I would rather go for the big boy boom box3. I know that motion boom is cheap compared to the jbl c5 but the rule thumb is “YOU GET WHAT YOU PAID FOR”

[@alanrossreviews]

not with the modern soundcore you dont. im even told the newer motion booms have different chips and less bass now.

[@halfcrazyluv1]

I hope you can recommend a portable bluetooth karaoke speaker in the future, since you love singing like I do. 😊

[@alanrossreviews]

But you are the karaoke 🎤 king 👑 😝 maybe the soundcore mega version with mic input if you can source one?

[@halfcrazyluv1]

@@alanrossreviews Was looking at the JBL partybox on the go but it has a poor battery life.

[@alanrossreviews]

one thing we know for sure, there is no perfect speaker! it has to be portable?

[@michaelcorcoran8768]

I never noticed the clock on your wall!

[@alanrossreviews]

it just needs to work 🤣