Alif الف - Is Sufism a parallel religion? (2/4)

الف - کیا تصوف ایک متوازی دین هے؟ ۴/۲

[@daimalishar6926]

حضرت احمد جاوید کو سننے کے بعد کوئی اور دل کو چھو تا ہی نہیں ❤

[@MrEngineer377]

ماشااللہ آپ غامدی صاحب سے علمی اتفاق کریں یا نہ کریں لیکن محبت خلوص علم اور اخلاق کے ساتھ اختلاف رائے رکھنا کوئی غامدی صاحب سے سیکھے۔نہ کسی کو کافر کہا نہ کسی کو حرامی کہا نہ کسی کو وہابی کہا نہ خنزیر کہا ۔اس لیے وہ ِدلوں کے فاتح ہیں۔

[@shakeelferozshakeelferoz6263]

گھی آپ اُن کے کولی عقل پے نیگاہ ڈالئیں خود کو ہی عقلِ قول سمجھتے ہیں۔ موصف

[@High_101]

آپ نے سچ کہا

[@Thothali]

People will hold their own opinions, and it will not be possible to convince them otherwise. However, the first and foremost lesson to be learnt from this discussion is the etiquette of Islamic discourse. Ghamdi sahib is a gift from Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala to our times.

[@hasancoool]

subhanAllah.. Peaceful Islamic debate ! I love the soft style of speaking of Ghamdi Sahab though I disagree with him badly on several issues.

[@High_101]

True brother

[@tanveerahmed-jo1xd]

very nice debate. ghamdi ,jawed sab and other scholars gave their opinions I salute. Tasawwaf is nothing but the highest approach of WISDOM.Its not a parallel DEEN.

[@Ex_Brelvi_Attari_Now_Muslim]

Sir ye result h taswuf ka kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXupi5h6hsifn7c kzbin.info/www/bejne/sGXWkHqtib6rjJI kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXmlgmCpfc2gg9k

[@mohdumar7455]

Ghamdi sahab great scholar

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Ustad e Muhtram: Ghamidi Sb ❤️

[@ThePakiparis]

what a respect full environment of debate MASHALLAH

[@manidar1977]

i love barrey Javed sb. (ahmad Javed). he is like the sweet grandpaa. It takes me some time to understand what he is saying because he is so learned he can not come below a certain level but i still love listening to him. As for this issue, i think Ghamidi just nailed it. it is very difficult to differ from his point in this regard. specially after the arguments he has given from all those books.

[@SankiKingOfficial]

Ghamidi Sahab kamal kar diya!!! Ma'sha'allah!!

[@sufisoul6293]

Gamidi sb is Great schlor

[@booksbrains1249]

Dr israr Kaash hota is bahas mai

[@JudgeD007]

3 men said "I will offer the prayer throughout the night forever." The other said, "I will fast throughout the year and will not break my fast." The third said, "I will keep away from the women and will not marry forever." Allah's Apostle said to them "By Allah, I am more submissive to Allah and more afraid of Him than you; yet I fast and break my fast, I do sleep and I also marry women.So he who does not follow my tradition in religion, is not from me " (sahih Bukhari Book62, Hadith 1)

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

Great brother

[@abrarhussain413]

غامدی سے کم از کم کوئی جیتنے کا سوچ نہیں سکتا اور اس کی وجی دلائل ہیں اور وہ بھی بہت کھری کھری باتیں

[@furqankhanrind-azizmianqaw746]

Ummat e muslima par 3 Tabqo ka Bahut barra ehsaan hai jismai Pehle 1: Muhaddiseen jinhony Puri dunya mai jakar ahadees ikhatti kee or unko kitabo ki shakkal mai darj kya Jissay aaj bhi dunya Faaidaa uthaa rahi hai 2nd : fuqha jinho islam ky pecheeda masaail Ko Logo ky saamny pesh kya Or wazeh tor par Unko samjha Dya 3: sufiaa e karam jinhony muhaddiseen or fuqha ki kahi gai bato par amal kya . Agar kui deen ky seedhy raaste par koi chaly hain to woh sufia hai deen dar haqiqat islam kee rooh . Ye Adam A.s ky daur say hi hai Magar Lafz taswwuf ya sufismm deen e islam ky pehle qarn mai Aya faqat lafz. Aap Sufia ki kitabo ka mutalia karain unhony jo shan e nabbuwat wa tauheed bayaan kee Ussya patha chalta hai ky kittny woh deen daar hai. Lafz e tassawuf ky lughi maani hai apny aapko khtam karden Allah ky marzi ky agay. Ab kuch log aima karaam En par kufr ka fatwa lagaty hain daleel yeh dete hain ky sufia ki kitbao mai jo lhika hai woh Islam ky mukhalif hai magar ap essy andaza lagaye ky Hadees mai bad mai any waly logon nay Changings kardee hai to tassawuf ki kitabo mai kyu nahi hosakti? Ap agar tassawuf kay bar e mai jaan na chachfy hain to Barre baare aimma karaam ki ktaben parhen 4o imamo ky aqaaid parhen woh tasssawuf waly nahi thay lekin unka nazriya tassawuf ky bare mai barra dilschap hai.

[@daimalishar6926]

Blessings from Khairpur Sindh ❤

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

May Allah bless Ghamidi sahb. Ameen

[@shahidmasroor8670]

Khurshid nadeem is also follower of ghamdi. He should invite the mushaikhs of such caliber who have the knowledge and practical peer. But these liberalized the deen .

[@Rah_e_Ishq_e_Khuda]

Iss discussion main Syed Sarfraz Ali Shah sahib ki bohat kami mehsoos hui...

[@Yusuf76029]

deen or bina classic tasawwuf ko jane ya practice kiye aap kisi ke argument ko sahi or ghlt nahi kh skte . tasawwuf islah e nafs par mabni hai , islah e nafs kiye baghair iss debate ke conclusion tak nahi pohncha jaskta .

[@Learningnfun643]

Sufism ki support mai koe valid arguments nahi hein. Sufism k supporters q logon ko quran or sunnat sy door ker k sufia ki examples dyty hein???

[@warioreaction]

''Uploader'' can yu translate this talk in english?..don't understand it..

[@ubaydmir9233]

warioreaction...dont u understand urdu? where r u from?

[@faisalmasoodsunny]

Thought of a Pakistani My mother tongue is Punjabi. My national language is Urdu. I am doing business in broken English moreover, Allah has made my religion in Arabic the language more then 99.99% Pakistani even don't speak, read, write, and completely don't understand. Faisal Masood.

[@thirdmasteraamirkhan5410]

Tasavvuf word bana hai tasavvur se agar islam me tasavvuf naa ho to(jo k har mazhab me hai or budh mazhab to hai hi kora tasavvuf) koi bhi kah sakta hai k Aap Allah ko jaantay hain jo daava e itaat kartay hain Aap jaantay hain k aapkay ander rooh hai Aap jaantay hain k mout k baad aap bacheingay Aap jaantay hain k paida honay se pehle aap thay(aalam e arwah) Aap jaantay hain k qaainaat Allah hi ne banaye hai or Allah hi ki milkiat hai Aap jaantay hain aapka jism Allah ki amaanat hai Aap jaantay hain k Allah ka aapkay ooper haq hai kisy musalmaan se baat karnay k liye to Alhumdulillah quran o hadees hi qaafi lekin is duniya me sirf muslim hi nhi hai or bhi log hain jin tak quran ka paigham ponhchana musalmaan ki zimmedary hai. isliye Tasavvuf ki field me boht kaam karna baaqi hai lekin badkismati se muslim ummah isy maslah par uljhi hai k tasavvuf koi cheez hai yaa nhi

[@ikrar_393]

Tasawwuf mens in English?

[@mustafaal-husayni6864]

It is an Arabic Term for Sufism

[@muhammadhaseeb6038]

Mysticism

[@foodbareillywala720]

Imeginitoin,

[@arsalannn1292]

Ghamidi is great scholar, indeed.

[@jax9574]

Sufism is a tricky subject, to each their own, but I personally won't indulge in things that are not needed imo. You can achieve the emotional and intuitive connect in your Namaaz when performed properly and through the life of the Prophet SAW and his sacrifices for Islam. That's more than enough for me personally. I don't need to renounce the world for it that's not the purpose this life though temporary is important and you should have your share of it also.

[@rajazulqarnain9487]

Chotay zehan walo ko tassawuf ki kya samjh aae gi, yehi farq hai khawas aur aam logu main.

[@muhammadsuleman3958]

Haan hindu or musalman me farq hi taswwuf h.. Musalman Quran or Sunnah prhta h Hindu tasawwuf prhta h

[@rajazulqarnain9487]

@@muhammadsuleman3958 kon sa hindu tasawuf parhta ha

[@muhammadsuleman3958]

@@rajazulqarnain9487 Jo Musalman Islam nhi prhta wo phr taswwuf prhta h jo inspired hai mysticism se...Oye Khuda k Bandy Islam Hukumat krne aya tha dunia me tmne isko mimbar tk rkh dia h.. Allah Ka zikr ktna krna kese krna hai Sb mere Nabi ne sikha dia Deen Quran or Hadees me hai jaker prhlo history kia tha Islam ki..Tm log Haq Haq krke mazaro me mushkil kusha dhundo

[@rajazulqarnain9487]

@@muhammadsuleman3958 bhai tassawuf ki jitni b buzurg guzray hain sb hi aalim thy..

[@zohaibkhan-zx9lb]

Jo mein ne samjha hai k Sufism ko hawas e khamsa se nhi samjha jasakta. Is k liye extra sensory perception ki zaroorat hoti hai.

[@zulfeebaig]

sufism..............Ghamdi sahib keh rahain ke glass adha (half) pane se bhara howa hai jabke javeed sahub keh rahee hain ke glass adha (half) pane se khalee hai...dono apne gajha thak hain. sufiism ka talak dil aur ruh se hai aur mazhab ka talak aqal o danish se....

[@abdulkhadermohammad3981]

zulfeebaig hor tadda talak punjab de naal hai 😉

[@xtremeownage2]

Why did Sajid ur Rahman sahib get only 2 minutes but Ghamidi got 15 minutes? Not fair. This is a biased and anti-Islamic program.

[@dawood2u]

Quran, Sahi Hadith, Life of the Prophet and life of his companions. To hell with the rest of the world!

[@MrDon313]

Ghamidi is true

[@ahlkhalid]

tasawaf nay islam ki jaroon ko kohla kar dia. islam main is kay kohi daleel aur saboot nahi hain.

[@rabbaniqadri]

IT IS NOT PARALLEL RELIGION BUT IT IS DEEN ISLAM IT IS ONLY ISLAM NOTHING ELSE...

[@Ex_Brelvi_Attari_Now_Muslim]

Taswuf ka result ye hota h kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXupi5h6hsifn7c kzbin.info/www/bejne/sGXWkHqtib6rjJI kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXmlgmCpfc2gg9k

[@rabbaniqadri]

But why is he changing his mind now

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

lol, read Buddhism and Hinduism, tasawuff is only reformed form of Buddhism/Hinduism