‘All of this unintelligent gymnastics about $35-55 trillion GDP by 2047 is sheer nonsense’

[@sps6]

How can india be a 10 trillion economy without any major economic reforms....where is economic reforms promised? They didnt even sell the loss making PSUs

[@counterpoint9260]

absolutely

[@vijayv2k]

Sounds like a grumpy professor's rant. Thanks to digital media they get exposed by none other than themselves.

[@kumailalimasjide7895]

The rusty truth about fake positive growth is eating you like termite within .

[@rajasekhar7951]

Have you seen the GDP numbers today! We frogs in a well should wake up!

[@Nintendo_fanboy87]

Yes! That professor should really cut NaMo some slack. Itss not like NaMo invented lying in politics. In a democracy especially in India politicians fibbing, promising rainbows, and leading people down imaginary golden paths is practically a national sport. It’s all part of the game, and NaMo’s just playing by the rules. Game is game......might is right.

[@ayushgangwar8]

Lol stupid bhakts believing in their own lies!

[@jackbal7623]

Unfortunately the Professor is correct. As of the latest reports, India's GDP growth for the second quarter of the fiscal year 2024-25 slowed to 5.4%. This is a significant drop from the previous quarters1. The slowdown is primarily due to poor performance in the manufacturing and mining sectors, as well as weak consumption.

[@suppiahmurugesan8343]

Carry on ranting Babu....we don't need enemies like you.

[@shubhamkumarjha4469]

We don't need gobar bhakt like you

[@counterpoint9260]

bhaktidiot spotted

[@MAHIPALBHATI-h6o]

This man had reputation of being one of most corrupt civil servant in his home cadre Rajasthan. And now since he was booted out by Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman ,hes been on a jihaad to malign the present government economic policies. Corrupt IAS. Ask anyone from Rajasthan

[@shubhamkumarjha4469]

If he was so corrupt in his home cadre then why did modi brought him in centre and made finance secretary and if he was so corrupt then why was there no enquiry against him

[@MAHIPALBHATI-h6o]

@shubhamkumarjha4469 are you serious in your logic...do you really believe that corrupt are brought to book?!!

[@shubhamkumarjha4469]

@@MAHIPALBHATI-h6o if not then that's another jumla of modi that he had taken action against every corrupt people in government which he has spoken of many times

[@pzende]

@@shubhamkumarjha4469Bro why are you arguing with bhakts ?? 😂😂😂

[@ramko1980]

@MAHIPALBHATI no wonder this guy going against current govt, like Subrahmanya swami.

[@thyagarajanriyer3284]

Through media, the Indian middle class is being cultivated to just Chest thump all the time. Being from the field of finance and economics I am able to clearly see that this Government has completely failed to manage such a high potential talented economy like India. All Unicorn startups are in deep shit...inflation is way above income growth for 90% of the population, India's debt is 4X of what was borrowed for 60 years. Yet massive unemployment, low wages, shrinking lower middle class consumption which is 70% of the country and therefore Private Capital investment is not taking off even after 10 years of corporate tax cuts, PLI stimuli etc. Complete Failure despite the high calibre and potential of Indians

[@mumbaiindia1512]

Another Congress era babu who is probably bitter that he didnt get a post retirement post.

[@DhawalDubey-br5hn]

हर हर मोदी जी जिंदाबाद

[@shankerram6076]

How much they might try, people vote only for BJP. Politics is not only about economics. That is why we cannot allow bureaucrats to rule the country.

[@shubhamkumarjha4469]

He had taken voluntary retirement if was so keen of getting job he wouldn't have resigned before his term

[@vikrambhandolkar]

I think this video has triggered a large number of bhakts. You can't escape the facts. For those internet friendly middle-class that saw their income zoom like rocket in last 3 years, they done realise that it was because of the global liquidity rainfall. Now with Trump cost of capital will go up, fortune will soon turn. Expect more Hindu-Muslim, freebies by this government. Middle-class doesn't realise that they are paying the highest %tax in last 20 years

[@pzende]

The Print is like bhakts paradise 😂😂😂 when ex CEA said about 55 trillion I knew he was smoking something smuggled by Adani 😂😂

[@soudaminipanda]

Absolutely correct assessment of the situation. The government despite its best efforts has been unable to get rid of the bureaucratic high handedness. Sunrise sectors such as green energy and container shipping are victims to a distorted market mechanism fully controlled by oligarchs (Adani). While the Modi government is definitely less corrupt than the past UPA, it just doesn't have the perspicacity to look beyond highway construction and dole outs; whether food or cash. It can effect change in the Indian bureacracy in 1 hour by charging these corrupt bureaucrats with high treason and throwing these invidious pigs into prisons for cheating India for the last 75+ years. Why can it not pass one law that provides a single window mechanism for individual sunrise sectors? I don't understand why no one in India can see that most of the future employment for Indian youth would be created in the following sectors: 1. High Quality Living - The country needs to embrace sustainable living solutions. Villages and Cities need to be completely transformed from the ground up. This means unprecedented scale of construction of new homes (using modern materials and not concrete jungles), utility, water, sanitation, community facilities, energy and green transportation. These will create tens of millions of jobs in (a) creation and (b) future maintenance. 2. Food, Waste, Air and Water - Urgent interventions are necessary to reform the food sector. Uncontrolled use of chemicals has transformed food into poison. The government is doing absolutely nothing in this regard. Focusing on safely growing food at food parks spread across the length and breadth of the country will again unleash tens of millions of jobs. Similarly, large scale waste management stations and water treatment coupled with recyclable water management systems can generate even more jobs at every nook and cranny of the country. 3. Service Delivery - We need an Ola or Swiggy for every conceivable service in the country. The government can fund creation of service center per 10k of population. These service centers will act both as logistics hubs and rent space to local entrepreneurs to unleash a wide swathe of services that the population needs. Now, you will ask where will the money come from? 1. Massive privatization - This is a no brainer. Just need the right intent. Start with PSU banks and SAIL. 2. Issue "Build India bonds" - Let the people of the country invest in their own future. Vast capital reserves of the Indian middle class can be intelligently employed. All that is needed is to remove the market bottlenecks and provide tax incentives. Give people a sense of pride that they are doing something for the country.

[@Sigzohdlhdlhdoydoyxlhdphdpydpu]

Nice

[@girirajsinghkushwaha2530]

Very well articulated. One fails to understand why all these things are not taken up? Only Hindu-Muslim chanting is going on.

[@raghunandan9290]

So You are expert ? And your Suggestions give us 10 pc GDP growth

[@Chigrikmarak3016]

Would be cool if your concept of build India bonds is applied to municipalities,we need to pour money in fixing our urban infrastructure.

[@sps6]

​@@girirajsinghkushwaha2530because their pea sized brains know that when they cannot perform make common citizens go at each other's throats...

[@gautamsen4195]

Please take into account that ONGC was forced to buy the government share in HPCL. This was in Modi 1.0 . ONGC had to shell out 35 k crores

[@PradeepNarayanan-b3y]

There is a lot of criticisms you could make of the Modi’s govt in not opening up with reforms but this author is being disingenuous in not attributing the impact of COVID 19. In fact unlike Western countries, India did not loosen the purse and indulge in massive splurging (quantitative easing).

[@xxyz2023]

US's GDP is $29.35 trillion yearly. India's GDP is around $3.4 or $3.7 trillion. The Consumer Price Index for October 2024 was 6.21% & for urban CPI is 6.68%. The Consumer Food Price Index for same period was 10.87%.

[@parvadhami980]

3.73 Trillion

[@xxyz2023]

@parvadhami980 wrote 3.7 trillion

[@parvadhami980]

@@xxyz2023 3.4 OR 3.7 trillion

[@xxyz2023]

@@parvadhami980 OK understood

[@Rudi_Mentary723]

@@xxyz2023 Should I post the conversation you deleted about Indian inflation manufacturing and GDP where you thought the previous government did better but you were proven wrong ? So you went on and deleted the whole comment thread ?

[@rpmittal50]

Subhash Chandra's Views are down to earth and show a deep understanding of economic situation and honest evaluation of the steps taken by the govt. Finance Minister should ask him to provide his assessments, once in a while. It will be good for them in decision making process and good for the country.

[@FlyingHridayBoy]

With about three decades in govt circles, he and babus like him could not figure out how to build toilets for the Indian populace. He acts as if COVID never happened.

[@nagraj2k1]

A large part of the fiscal consolidation in Modi 1.0 was due to oil falling from 100 to 25$ and settling at 50-60$ by 2017

[@rajbasu8649]

Haha after the "sheer Nonsense" statement, Sharad decided not to shake the tree too hard 😂😂

[@vaidheeswaranravi]

Grapes are sour. He was shunted from the ministry of economic affairs to the ministry of power. So he took vrs. He does not like Modi government

[@xxyz2023]

@@vaidheeswaranravi China's GDP is around $18 to $12 trillion

[@kumailalimasjide7895]

Nobody likes Modi govt

[@SumitKumar-yw3pb]

​@@xxyz2023ok, is that a some kind of secret? we all know china was $4 trillion economy in 2009 and is almost 15 years ahed of India in GDP terms.

[@rajasekhar7951]

With the GDP growth of 5.6 percent no one will like modi govt!

[@SumitKumar-yw3pb]

@@rajasekhar7951 lol, it's a Q2 data, yes it is low but everyone was expecting it as consumer consumption was low in Q2 but the trends are already changing, check the data of october month, see the export data, it's 17.25% jump in month to month which was

[@jackbal7623]

India needs a better education system funded by the government to become even a middle income country.

[@rajeshsookram3038]

I think it would be 5 trillion in 2030. What a tragedy for India with it's chiwala prime minister and illiterate finance minister.

[@saptarshiadhikary3736]

one minute, saffron party said that they are intended to make India a first world country by 2047. that's it.

[@jackbal7623]

As of the latest reports, India's GDP growth for the second quarter of the fiscal year 2024-25 slowed to 5.4%. This is a significant drop from the previous quarters1. The slowdown is primarily due to poor performance in the manufacturing and mining sectors, as well as weak consumption

[@pzende]

IT cell aa Gaya comment section main 😂😂😂😂😂

[@vaitheeswaran.s.easwar5382]

sidelined by Modi regime and ranting on all topics under the sun......

[@xxyz2023]

China's GDP is around $18 to $12 trillion

[@manishanand420]

Thanks for Print which brings a well researched and data driven conversation and talk, it’s shame that TV and print media completely ignored

[@ajaykulk]

Talking about fiscal deficit without mentioning the extraordinary impact of Pandemic itself shows it is a totally biased discourse. And what elsevwill you expect from The Print?

[@niteshsharma8493]

Everyone what about says for the professor but it seems like we just going to reach current level of china's gdp with inflation. It is really pathetic performance.

[@akarshitbali1914]

I too understand!!

[@janakcontractor4466]

He is totally biased. Should atleast tell what was good about the fiscal management in spite of Covid

[@shantanusapru]

Well said!!

[@ATK2724]

My one Question : what have done except warming chairs and making paper plans in AC rooms. All babus become wise once they retire.

[@sanjeevkaushal5969]

I hate this typical govt Babu of olden times

[@shubhamkumarjha4469]

I hate all the gobar bhakt

[@banditonehundred]

Very insightful

[@Bhimarmy2347]

IT cell in comment box😂

[@sachindhawan]

Print keep begging for paid subscription because their neutral journalism, and then they bring such garbage pappu

[@surendrabarsode8959]

Indian economy is doing well in terms of many basic parameters even though it may be missing many targets and specific benchmarks. Let us focus on basic tasks like deregulation and quick decision making, encouragement for manufacturing, opening of economy in a phased manner etc. Everyone knows that no economy can grow at rates higher than maximum 7% on a sustained basis. So as long as we are around that target, we should be fine. Subash is a tricky person to understand. He keeps smiling all the times and he keeps vacillating between for and against the Govt. But he did his bit when he took on those 2 johnnies in RBI during his time as Finance Secretary!!!

[@rajasekhar7951]

Have you seen the GDP numbers!

[@surendrabarsode8959]

@@rajasekhar7951 As long as there is growth, we are fine.

[@rajasekhar7951]

@@surendrabarsode8959 with 7 plus percentage growth last year our unemployment was so bad you think we are fine!

[@rajasekhar7951]

@@surendrabarsode8959 do you even have any idea how much taxes you pay!

[@rajasekhar7951]

@@surendrabarsode8959 how will you encourage manufacturing when people are not spending!

[@indian5227]

Sour grape. Shunted out. How come we grow unless u have a huge target.

[@prashantshukla9586]

I is blaming others what did he do when he was secretary

[@rajs3181]

For sure well informesd people know its herculean task to acheive the foals set by Modi. The key is to see if actions are taken towards that goal rather than just dreaming and sitting ideal. Which ia why he is still able to get urban votes especially in a financial savy metro like Mumbai. People handling.with Money in my oppinion are.usually shrewd and will vote form party which they fwel will be good to protect and grow their money

[@Zambia974]

mmh

[@utpalmishra3789]

Another agent 😂😂

[@xxyz2023]

5.4 percent growth in q2

[@utpalmishra3789]

@xxyz2023 still fastest growing economy........

[@xWarLegendx]

@@utpalmishra37891.4 billion people, 3.7 trillion GDP when China is 15-18 trillion with same population. Infrastructure, roads, bridges, airports terminals, highways and railways and trains collapsing left right and Centre, recent corruption charge against Adani

[@xxyz2023]

@@utpalmishra3789 India's GDP is around $3.4 or $3.7 trillion.

[@xxyz2023]

@@utpalmishra3789 US & China GDP is huge compared to ours

[@vijaykrishnann6483]

Grapes are sour.grumpy oldman.his ilk the ias officer who are morally responsible for all what went wrong with India.

[@abhiyanc]

CHIPS = Creating Helpful Incentive to Producing Semiconductors!! Kind of this U.S. Act is very soon coming soon in India too?

[@pragathikumar9503]

Like Subramanyam Swami, a bright guy to whom the Modi government doesn't entrust key responsibilities and they keep finding fault with Modi government financial planning. Somehow these detractors are proven wrong. Again and again. 😂

[@xxyz2023]

5.4 percent growth in q2

[@TheKumbakonam]

Mody is waste fellow economy slowing ...neibouring bangladesh burning Hindus harmed jayshankar akagayshankar big mouth knows to lecture western nation...now he has to go his daddy pootin for help 😅...zelensky is not a clown as told by foolish indians mody is biggest clown

[@Junu-l6v]

Feel sorry for this pandits ….they think this is still 1990 …whatever they vomit (they can’t digest the success of this government) we will believe them .

[@ravinasta4256]

This man was one of yhe most corrupt officers This is well known in the bereauctatic world

[@ArvindLeoPereira]

Intellectuals

[@_rohit97]

Subash is a sonia bootlicker!

[@Trust-z9v]

These channels not learnt any lesson I think, I will cancel his subscription

[@anujgarg2605]

Shane on this guy

[@naysayer7540]

looks like he was kicked out by government and he is venting his frustration ever since. Is he the last word on economics that what he says is Satya Vachan? Print as usual looks out for such guys who will help extend the leftist narrative and ecosystem

[@prashantshukla9586]

I is blaming others what did he do when he was secretary