ALL THE MAKEUP I USED UP IN 2023 | Would I Repurchase?

Hi lovelies,
Today I'm sharing all of the makeup I fully used up this year! As well as sharing whether I repurchased and why!
**** Ad Info ****
This video is NOT sponsored. Links below to products used/worn in the video are affiliate so if you choose to use them to make a purchase, I will receive a small commission. I purchase all products myself unless they are clearly marked as GIFTED, in which case the brand has sent them to me with no obligation to post.
My Eyelash Growth Serum
rstyle.me/+eNYScwM9Re96_pv7DQ...
**** Products Mentioned ****
Mac Stack mascara
go.magik.ly/ml/1gkij/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1frx1/ (US)
Chanel Noir Allure mascara
rstyle.me/+epWXL_t_bjwwSEB-hW... (UK)
rstyle.me/+y9mMpbsRL2rbog-0pD... (US)
Benefit Roller Lash mascara
rstyle.me/+SlNucCGubNFPQ5YVee... (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1t00o/ (US)
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Mascara
bit.ly/3ExWUhu (UK)
bit.ly/3VktWrC (US)
Benefit Fanfest mascara
rstyle.me/+JwQiv_w-bWDH5Y7hjb... (UK)
rstyle.me/+iC7fHo6YmTDSFqQ6Yz... (US)
Benefit Brow Gel
rstyle.me/+3ssucbBtF6uPMgDAcy... (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/13770/ (US)
Huda Beauty Brow pencil
go.magik.ly/ml/15erc/ (UK)
shop-links.co/174297939536803... (US)
Charlotte Tilbury UV Flawless Poreless primer
rstyle.me/+z09gJdUUhSHE1pRIH6... (UK)
rstyle.me/+-KF5Y7sDQLY7uxSelM... (US)
Tom Ford Primer
rstyle.me/+P1syklAQe8Fw15s6aM... (UK)
rstyle.me/+GnShdI8Bgm4WnTKKKk... (US)
Tatcha Silk Canvas
go.magik.ly/ml/1k12e/ (UK)
rstyle.me/+nLtM4Zq8bsj7KySflC... (US)
Tatcha liquid silk canvas
rstyle.me/+82huTuo7d-FNwjeuEa... (US)
rstyle.me/+82huTuo7d-FNwjeuEa... (US)
Pat McGrath Undereye Powder
go.magik.ly/ml/xmzf/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/xmzs/ (US)
Tom Ford Shade & Illuminate Foundation
go.magik.ly/ml/x29g/ (UK)
rstyle.me/+7BThIsE16ZEPJJMJa4... (US)
Chanel No1 Foundation
go.magik.ly/ml/1egro/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1egrr/ (US)
**** Makeup Worn ****
Huda Beauty Brow pencil
go.magik.ly/ml/15erc/ (UK)
shop-links.co/174297939536803... (US)
Rare Beauty brow gel
rstyle.me/+DnEAaIsOstaBZQw_If... (UK)
rstyle.me/+En36fzPc9LfFs9MVA5... (US)
YSL 100 Stora Dolls palette
rstyle.me/+u0gUffjxm1HnLHvfST...
Benefit Fanfest mascara
rstyle.me/+JwQiv_w-bWDH5Y7hjb... (UK)
rstyle.me/+iC7fHo6YmTDSFqQ6Yz... (US)
Tom Ford Primer
rstyle.me/+P1syklAQe8Fw15s6aM... (UK)
rstyle.me/+GnShdI8Bgm4WnTKKKk... (US)
Chanel No1 Foundation
go.magik.ly/ml/1egro/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1egrr/ (US)
and
Hourglass Soft Glow Foundation
go.magik.ly/ml/1jzpc/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1k122/ (US)
Haus Labs concealer
rstyle.me/+q8ZQZ3hK54YWDS0dkJ... (UK)
rstyle.me/+N9MhSo0iW-INBeo3OJ... (US)
Pat McGrath Undereye Powder
go.magik.ly/ml/xmzf/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/xmzs/ (US)
Marc Jacobs bronzer
DISCONTINUED
Chanel symboles highlighter (Soft coral)
rstyle.me/+PMQMZOYP-vCn73WFt_...
Gucci Rosy Beige blush
go.magik.ly/ml/1lo5i/ (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml/1lo5g/ (US)
Bond no 9 ‘Gramercy Park’ lipstick
rstyle.me/+JIjoufAWmCbbsYPI-x...
**** What I'm Wearing ****
Top: rstyle.me/+zcgnQlrKFeLqIRGX5K...
Nails: OPI Bubble Bath
go.magik.ly/ml/15n9y/ (UK)
shop-links.co/174749169610543... (US)
My Brushes:
Rephr:
* www.rephr.com/?vr=oereeo
Sonia G:
* go.magik.ly/ml/xpg4/
BK Beauty
* go.shopmy.us/p-2866001
**** My Closest Foundation Shades ****
Winter shade | Summer shade
Chanel = BD41 | B50
Cle De Peau = 040 | 060
Dior Backstage = 2WO | 4WO
Estee Lauder = Tawny | Shell Beige
Haus Labs = 190 | 260
Hourglass = 8 | 10.5
Lisa Eldridge = 17 | 19
Nars Natural Radiant Longwear = Patagonia | Aruba
Pat McGrath = 14 | 18
Shiseido Synchro Skin = Bamboo | Citrine
Tom Ford = Shell Beige | Golden Almond
**** SKIN TYPE ETC. ****
I am 38 and my skin is pretty "normal" with no dryness or particular oily areas. I do have early signs of aging like fine lines/texture, as well as some sun damage and REDNESS!
I don't use fake tan, but I get very tan naturally in the summer as I have an olive undertone so my face is often a LOT lighter than my body, because I keep my face very well protected to keep my melasma under control and signs of aging at bay!
**** Contacts ****
Instagram: charlotte_holdcroft
Twitter: charholdcroft84
Business Enquiries: [e-mail]

[@TheGuGuSssS]

Ok but can we please talk about how perfectly that shade of green suits you?

[@tatiana_sh8089]

Can we "rummage" into your make up drawers please 😊? haven't seen them for ages

[@infamousamazonian]

Just when I think my day isn't going to turn around, there's Charlotte's radiantly lovely face to put a smile on mine. ❤

[@awalker127]

I actually used up an entire Hourglass powder 😮 I was so proud of myself. 😅

[@sep.s]

Morgan Turner mentioned the Tom Ford products are getting new/updated packaging, which is why some products are out of stock at the moment while they do the switch,

[@Elsawilliamson2007]

Impressive! ❤ I use 1 foundation and concealer at a time so I finished 4 foundations and 2 concealers. Plus a bunch of mascaras, brow pencils, setting spray, powders and lip balms.

[@sep.s]

New subscriber here :) For me it has been the Rose Inc concealer and foundation that I will repurchase, as they are such a good shade match for me and trying to find something pale/desaturated enough for me is a real struggle. Skincare-wise for me it's the Lisa Eldridge cleanser as it has been helping my skin and I don't need as much skincare when I use it. Really interesting to hear about what has been used up.

[@Notperfecttonya]

Ohhh I’ve been wondering about the Rose Inc concealer (and now foundation!) for the same reasons! I saw it on another channel on someone who is similar. I struggle so hard! Do you have any advice about either product? ❤

[@megdvs21]

Such a good list, well done 😀, ok here we go the short list of all the products I have used up this year and would i or did i repurchase it : Tatcha silk canvas primer liquid - yes always Tatcha silk canvas primer balm - yes always Charlotte Tilbury exaggereyes duo liner in black and champagne - yes always Charlotte Tilbury brow cheat pencil refills in taupe and natural brown - yes always Makeup by Mario prep and set compact - yes always Mini Hourglass veil translucent setting powder - yes bught the full size Mini Benefit fan fest - yes bought the full size

[@kimberlykay2131]

I started an empties bag back in June. I really like the idea of having an empties bin. It is very telling as to what products are actually getting used. I used up a Chanel foundation, a Tom Ford concealer, a Guerlain primer, a Chanel lip gloss, a Tom Ford lip balm, 2 cleansers, several perfumes, and a lot of skincare. I used up the Gucci mascara and I might replace it. Most of my makeup is all new since June so it will take awhile to use up. I have the Chanel Allure Noir Mascara as well. It won't be a repurchase for me. I enjoyed rummaging through your bin! 🙂

[@Notperfecttonya]

I have used up NOTHING in 2023! 😂😮 I am determined to use up at least 1 foundation this next year (2024). And 1 mascara!!!! I’m very close to using up a Dior lip oil and sugar scrub. I recently bought the Gucci micro brow liner and I love it. So I’m going to try and use that one and my Victoria Beckham one to figure out which is the holy grail. 🧐 Loved this video!! ❤❤

[@lisapierce525]

I think it says a lot when you’ve used up a product considering the number of different brands and shades you try out. Well done! Happy New Year Charlotte!

[@carriebrooks2664]

I too did an empties bin in 2023. Powder, mascaras, brow and lip pencils were the most used products. Eyeshadow and blush pallettes ...will follow me to the grave but I Love them!!

[@valgarrett63]

I would have cut the end off the tube of CT primer to really get every last drop out! - and got a skinny brush into that Chanel foundation bottle :)

[@anitanowogorska3853]

18 make up products finished in 2023 here, I'd only repurchase ABH brow definer, Bobbi Brown Golden Pink eyeshadow and Bobbi Brown Smokey mascara. The rest was nice to use but not exceptional. I'm impressed that you've managed to finish the products even though you have so many to test! I absolutely love this kind of content as this shows real opinion on the product, much better that the influencers that show 30 shades of lipstick but you never know if they will really use it after the video.. And yes, the green sweater suits you really well!

[@SueGreene-st7qc]

You must try the Estee Lauder sumptuous extreme mascara if you haven’t already done so. I have 65 year old lashes that are rather straight and when I use that mascara my lashes look close to what yours do on a normal day lol and that’s saying something.

[@aoifeg1466]

Would love to see beauty empties including skincare/ body care/ hair care aswell as makeup x

[@sunshinestate4001]

Now this was fun and interesting.Happy new year my dear🎉 Havent used up anything this year cause I didnt use no make up last year,cause of my health issues I couldnt really go nowhere.But this year....ask me next year around this time and I will let you know.I will return to make up finaly again😊

[@Notperfecttonya]

Same, girl, same. We’re going to be able to use our amazing makeup this year! Sending you prayers, well wishes, positive vibes!! 🙏🏻❤️

[@sunshinestate4001]

@@Notperfecttonya thax hun ans same to you :)

[@carriebrooks2664]

Hope you have alot of empties this year! Feel better❤

[@sunshinestate4001]

@@carriebrooks2664 Ty dear :)

[@claudilovesbeauty9573]

I used up a bare minerals face palette from some christmasses ago and was .really sad. They brought out a new one this christmas, but the packagaging is so bulky. I use only the chanel healthy glow foundation in B20 and B30, but they last forever. Only 2023 I began to appreciate Charlotte Tilbury`s products and used used up at least one lip liner in pillow talk. Happy make-up year everybody!!!

[@ordysparrow7574]

I’m so impressed you finish makeup completely. I’ve only used up mascaras, lotions, face wash, body wash, shampoo and conditioner, and serums. I am more loyal to skincare brands and share the love with my makeup decisions based on my mood and what I’m wearing.

[@jenniferdonohoe4392]

I used up my favourite foundation Beautiful Skin by Charlotte Tilbury. I'm so happy that they were bogof on her site recently and have stocked up x

[@keldarawlings332]

I used up an hourglass tubing mascara and Bobbi brown skin long wear liquid foundation. I just love this foundation, looks natural and lasts all day, and the colour match is great for me.

[@TinaZ9]

The TF primer and the Traceless foundation (most shades) are sold out everywhere in the U.S. I hope they aren’t discontinuing!

[@sabsa70]

I used up 2 CT push up lashes mascaras (black), 2 Sweed lash lift mascaras in brown and 1 MAC stack, also CT pillow talk lipliner and a Lisa Eldridge lipgloss in muse. Always interesting to look in other bin bags 😉. Love Sabine 😘

[@r17l]

You're looking so pretty!!

[@zipperdidoodah5411]

In 2023 I used up a Lisa Eldridge Velvet lipstick in the colour Beauty and of course I bought another one!😬 She is magnificent! And so is Lisa :D For foundation though I'm exactly the same - I have several partly used bottles, but not because I bought a winter and summer shade, because I'm not very good at selecting my shade. I'm getting there but over the pandemic I ran out of makeup and had to guess my shade as I was trying different brands. So I've a few bottles of mistakes and they are still in good condition, so I'm trying to use those up now before I buy any more :)

[@evakalan4504]

Happy new year 🎉. I always love your makeup reviews, but your stories are the best.

[@kemberlymclain5800]

You cracked me up with the Chanel Foundation "I'm not trying to lick it clean or anything"....but are you??? Goals this year is to empty all those products that are close to being done. Why I savor some of my favorite products---I just don't know. I paid good money on them and need to use and enjoy them. My Hourglass Ambient Soft Glow Foundation has less than an inch left--it's like I'm hoarding it. Happy New Year. Charlotte!!!!

[@michellegerrell2375]

Got my backup TF primer from John Lewis-am on the the last dregs of my current one! Was in complete panic mode as it was out of stock everywhere then on Saturday I had a notification from John Lewis and it was like straight to checkout-phew!!!!! Xxxx

[@mariam.a.]

I finished quite a few things but most happy about two foundations that I had been working on for a while, the PML one and the pre-reformulation Dior Backstage. Currently no plans to repurchase because there are others I need to finish first.

[@pixieburton3131]

As usual, I am late to the party!!!! In 2023 I have completely used up at least 2, maybe 3 Lancome Monsieur Big mascaras. At least 2, maybe 3 Hourglass Unlocked mascaras. At least 3 Estee Lauder DW foundation in 2N1, Desert Beige. Believe it or not I have panned two shades in my ND I Need a Nudes palette. I can’t get enough. I can’t wait to get the new ND mini My Dream palette, as well as the new blush/highlight palette. I have been through at least 3 or 4 of my favorite brow pencil in granite by Anastasia of Beverly Hills. I have almost obliterated my MAC lip pencil in stone as well as my ND I Need a Nude lipstick in Beatrice. My favorite lip pairing. Skincare. I have been through 3 Clinique Smart Clinical Serum. Also, I have been through 3 Lancome HCF Renergie Vitamin C Serum. The skincare names aren’t exact but close enough that most will recognize them. I have used both for years and they keep me sooooooo happy with my skin. Okay, LOL, I call uncle I can’t think on it anymore!!! Happy New Year to all of Charlotte’s subscribers. Happy 2024 makeup and skincare shopping 🛍️ Loved this video!!!!!

[@laurieann2714]

I was actually adding up the COST of all those products. Lol THAT was impressive! I love your videos and your sense of humor. I am someone who uses a mix of drug store and higher end makeup but I am not at Tom Ford prices yet. I am waiting for a product that really wows me (and does my laundry and feeds my dogs, etc.) HAPPY NEW YEAR!

[@cristinamerlini]

Happy New Year Charlotte ❤ Let’s see what’s in your bin :)

[@melindagenitempo2359]

I used up Anastasia foundation. Its actually lovely but I still have 5 or 6 I am working thru. Also a CT pressed powder and a Tower 28 skin tint. And mascara, Mac, Lancome and 1 Tower 28 Already repurchased T 28 in summer tan shade, and my HG mascaras are the Tower 28 and YSL lash clash. Very disappointed in my 2 Dior show mascara new formulations.

[@jasmin_sohal]

hey Charlotte you mentioned products you've discarded half used (I'm assuming cos of quality). Any chance of a declutter/recap of what was so bad you just got rid of it?

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

That’s a really good idea!!

[@deborahcates]

I used up a Pat McGrath foundation, plus lots of various mascaras and lip balms. 💋

[@kirstenolson776]

I used up the Glossier primer. Since Glossier isn't carried in Sweden (where I live), I had to wait until I visited the US for Xmas to repurchase.

[@rubypriceallen9584]

You are amazing!! I never miss your videos!! Can you do a video “ my makeup on non filming days” ?

[@bymillie]

Need to try the Fanfest mascara after hearing you rave about it!! Sounds amazinggg 🤩

[@HairFanatics]

Finished/Repurchased; *Pat McGrath Concealer and Black Coffee Gel Pencil... *Charlotte Tilbury's Foundation, Fnishing Powder, and Lip Liner. *Huda's Easy Bake Powder *Gucci Brow Pencil.

[@sharonalexa]

I just ordered Chanel No 1 foundation. The only makeup I order are ones you recommend. You inspire me & Ty ♥️

[@carmensplacebeauty]

Happy New Year! It was fun rummaging through your bin. I used up my Suqqu (The Cream) Foundation and my Chanel Les Beiges Water-Fresh Complexion Touch. I haven't repurchased either yet because I'm working my way through a Guerlain Parure Gold and an Hourglass Ambient foundation. Per your recommendation, I'd like to try the Prada Foundation next.

[@bevyoung2009]

I have Ombre Brows. I love them. I also love your laminated Brows.

[@africke744]

Thank you, Charlotte. Almost all my current make up was bought in 2023 and I've only finished a Lash Idôle (disappointing) and a YSL Lash Clash (which I LOVED! I know you didn't like it.) Best wishes, Anne

[@HannaTK]

I'm rubbish and using up my make-up - maybe because I have too much of it 😂But I'm super proud to report I did pan my TF bronzer (finally!!!) and Chantecaille blurring powder. Thinking of buying back-ups as we speak!

[@joanaguedes1155]

Happy new year Charlotte! I used up the NARS light reflecting foundation, Armani luminous skin foundation, rose inc cream blush and joker high coverage concealer. Will definitely repurchase both foundations. Really like Rose Inc blush, but there are a lot more to try until I think about purchasing again.

[@tamizilla]

I have almost used up 3 maybe 4 of my foundations should be used within the next few weeks and my replacements are ready, used up CT flawless filter and corrector from bobbie brown.

[@redouteshabby2024]

I used up my Dior eyebrow pencil and my Chanel No 1 foundation. They are staples so I definitely repurchased! Also my Covey Vit C Serum if we are counting skin care!

[@stinefriis76]

I just used up the Lumene cc-cream and the Urban Decay setting spray. Have backups on both

[@jennifermajor5013]

💖 you! Was wondering if you had a layering body lotion or gel for Angels Share. Would love to see a vid or suggestions on how to layer our more expensive fragrances to last even longer. 😘

[@patriciaschmidt4786]

I'm starting an empties bin, so I can really see what I use up. I've just been tossing in the trash. So far, I've used one smaller size Ilia mascara, which I liked but probably won't replace. I have several other mascaras.

[@ingevanhulst1528]

I finnished my Nars tinted moisturizer ( and I replaced it by the Hourglass skin tint, love that new one but it is more sheer and more expensive)

[@SueGreene-st7qc]

Hi Charlotte, I hardly ever use anything up which is very irritating because when I like something a lot I try to use it sparingly and save it and then I never get through it and move on to try some thing else. The only thing I go through on a regular basis or eyebrow pencils And eyeliner’s

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Thanks Charlotte love the jumper on you love the shade I love green but so many people don’t like it for some superstitious belief see you soon ❤

[@cristinalungu5157]

I finished a make up for ever liner, Bobbi Brown vitamin enriched face base, foundation finished: Mac face and body and a Armani luminous silk, until March i'm sure i'll finish the Lisa Eldrige foundation and Pat McGrath ( 5ml or less on each), also Huda beauty baby bake powder and the cream bronzer... mascara, too disappointed to remember them 🤔🤭 I have a new Bobbi Brown primer and won't repurchase other products 'cause i'm curious about other brands 🫣 ( instead of Mac i'll try Dior face and body... i've got the Lisa Eldridge liner...which i adore and so on)😁

[@pixieburton3131]

Oh goodness, you reminded me!!! I have gone through a BB Face Base Primer and Moisturizer!!! It’s my favorite for sure!!!!

[@nadiadncr]

I'm here for all the Mascaras from my favorite Mascara guru. One I discovered last year by an accident it was gifted to me by a friend was the Essence purple princess mascara. I've never was one for drugstore but it is very good. I love the gve mascara and the new benefit one as well. ♥ Great video Charlotte love watching you

[@kiran-bilal]

100% with you on the Chanel noir allure mascara….it is an amazing product but dries up so fast….its definitely because of the packaging even though the packaging is so pretty🤷🏻‍♀️

[@annhall2331]

My empties are all skin care and 1 or 2 charlotte tilbury mascaras and I have/will re buy them xxx

[@lindak2807]

Most of the products I used up were mascaras, so I'm going to pick my most repurchased to mention here: Charlotte Tilbury Legendary lashes vol. 2 mascara.

[@reneegrace7965]

Oh forgot to add! I go thru tubs of loose powder! I know it's not your thing, yet I HAVE to put it on my foundation, all over! Can't stand to touch my face and have the foundation tacky... am missing though my Laura Mercier Tone-Up. That too seems to be MIA..... :)

[@bevyoung2009]

Hello beautiful Charlotte 😍

[@tamipie]

Nyx Marshmallow Primer, and Mad Hippie cleanser. I get bored with things and just give them away all the time. 😊

[@tamipie]

Oooo, and the red Ordinary bha mask, and their Copper peptide serum...

[@jjjjk1241]

What about the Huda one coat wow mascara? Would you repurchase it? I’m trying to decide whether to try it. My very favorite mascara is Nabla Vicious. (Probably partially due to the fierce kitty cat packaging.) Used one up, tried a couple of different brands, was not impressed, went back to Vicious and actually bought a backup at the same time I re-purchased. ❤😊

[@Randilynn66]

I think it's contact lens solution that goes in your dry mascara.

[@Mommaslew]

Here is a crazy question……If TF Primer is your fav, why do you also purchase both CT primers? Totally just curious!😊😊😊❤

[@tarski7420]

Fun video, thank you! I used up a Gucci lipstick and repurchased already - it’s the Glow & Care Shine lipstick in the shade Sally Soft Honey. It’s incredibly hydrating for the lips, and a pretty everyday shade - goes with almost any lip liner too because it’s not too pigmented, but can be built up. Just love it

[@shelleymalone4427]

Sadly, I need the Tom Ford stick foundation in my life, and it is being discontinued. Trying to find back up of my shades appears to be a “no go”. Sigh …

[@barbowens8626]

Hi Charlotte! The Tom Ford website says the primer is no longer available.😱 There is no waitlist, rather they suggest you shop their other primers. I'm sick.😩

[@rubypriceallen9584]

They are also no longer making their traceless matte foundations. Something is up with TF

[@carmensplacebeauty]

They are reformulating the Traceless Matte (I grabbed a bottle at Nordstrom for half-price).@@rubypriceallen9584

[@reneegrace7965]

I went thru a Tom Ford primer seemingly in months now it's just GONE!! Can't find it in stock anywhere

[@aprilrich807]

😊

[@jennawoodard8386]

💕💄

[@cynderella2867]

Tom Ford foundation and the stick are out of almost all of the shades at the Canadian Sephora and the primer is out of stock. Somethings up!?

[@rubypriceallen9584]

I came to say the same thing!!

[@pixieburton3131]

I can only say that the Tom Ford foundation is half price at Sephora. Maybe a new formula is on the way?

[@marionallen2222]

🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍