Allan Pinkerton - The Knights of Capitalism - Extra History

📜 Allan Pinkerton - The Knights of Capitalism - The Pinkerton's National Detective Agency. A group synonymous with brutality, corruption, and private policing. But you may be surprised to learn about their founder, Allan Pinkerton, a man who was forced to flee his home country for supporting suffrage. So how did this progressive, working-class, activist become known for founding an agency famous for trading morals for money? It's a much stranger road than you may think.
* Watch Extra History ad-free & get 1-week early access on NEBULA go.nebula.tv/extrahistory
* Suggest & Vote on our next episodes, get exclusive content & 24-hour early access on PATREON bit.ly/EHPatreon
* Show off your fandom with MERCH from our store! extracredits.store/
* Interested in sponsoring an episode?* Email us: [e-mail]
TWITTER: bit.ly/ECTweet I FACEBOOK: bit.ly/ECFBPage
INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/ECisonInstagram I TIKTOK: bit.ly/ECtiktokz
BLUESKY: bit.ly/ECBlueSky I TWITCH: bit.ly/ECtwitch
GAMING: / @extracredits
Thanks for the high-quality conversations & for following our community guidelines here: bit.ly/ECFansRNice
Artist: Ali R Thome I Writer: Dr. Bob Whitaker I Showrunner & Narrator: Matthew Krol I Editor: Nick Rieth & Mac Owens I ♪ Music by Demetori: bit.ly/1EQA5N7 I ♪ "Extra History - Odds and Ends"
by Sean Kiner, Dean Kiner
#ExtraHistory #Pinkerton #History

[@Turnil321]

Remember when the Pinkerton did a raid on a collector of magic gathering cards last week because he got a card that was not a sale yet. Good to see American institutions doing so well.

[@Ryan2K900]

Just watched the historians video on it. I didn’t even know it happened 😮

[@Empressofnight]

Didn't even know they were still around until that

[@Wasserkaktus]

​@@Empressofnight They mainly do security consultancy work but yeah... Nice to see they remain in touch with their roots.

[@Wifgargfhaurh]

It wasn't a "raid", look into it.

[@Wasserkaktus]

@@Wifgargfhaurh It was still very embarrassing and a massive risk assessment failure on Pinkerton's part: They should have just politely asked to have it returned first.

[@ichangedmyaccountname2993]

“God dammed Pinkertons” -Everybody in Red Dead Redemption 2

[@Argacyan]

Also people irl like abolitionists and protestors for worker rights, anarchists, modernists, anti-imperialists, people who wanted more democracy in america, etc. There's a lot.

[@mattsmith3750]

Literally everyone who wanted to live in a better world hated the Pinkertons. They were just paid thugs for the rich and powerful.

[@alexalexandrov9684]

I’m biased but if you weren’t a pinkerton or a moderate to large business owner you would be better off if they all died

[@Abdirahman_Mohamed]

Dont Worry guys, Dutch got a plan

[@archosauropre-historico8708]

@@Abdirahman_Mohamed We just need money!

[@ratking9411]

I never would've guessed that the pinkertons would be returning later in the series, props to the writers of Earth for this crazy plot twist

[@Fly-the-Light]

Wotc?

[@Shyblook1234]

@@Fly-the-Light They’re still around and are mostly just mercenaries, recently they raided a guy’s house because he bought a pack of unreleased magic the gathering cards that had been shipped to the store he bought them from.

[@zephyrm.6564]

What's Doom Metal got to do with this?

[@mewmew8932]

@@Shyblook1234 ngl kinda fair

[@nanashi420]

​@mewmew8932 not fair at all. He couldn't have known, they easily could've sent a diplomatic representative rather than literal mercenaries.

[@aze94]

I am amazed by how many people seem to think that the Pinkertons were made up for RDR2

[@IsratJahan-th3fo]

I knew Pinkertons existed before RDR2 but i found how evil they were by googling them after playing RDR2

[@kingbred01]

Iam not from America so i wouldn't know

[@asovietdoggo2377]

I honestly didn’t know

[@King-xe3kt]

So what dude I learned about them in RDR2 so fucking what

[@heeheeheehaw6200]

@@King-xe3kt "Calm down"

[@Dr_Martex]

For those wondering, Yes, the Pinkertons still exist today and are still in the business of "risk management" and private security. They're owned by a Swedish company, but still operate under the Pinkertons name.

[@sombodythatyouusedtoknow9046]

rdr2 wiki says that the company that bought them is securitas AB

[@drewberrycrunch1417]

Weird how this is relevant again.

[@kaya-1094]

And aparently stealing Magic cards....

[@dongenove3048]

"You enjoy being a rich man's toy, do you?"

[@OrionsTale]

"I enjoy society, flaws and all. You people venerate savagery and you will DIE... savagely! All of you!" ~ Some Annoying Bald Man, 1899

[@mr.m6522]

@The plan man partially, yes.

[@loonyspoons5676]

Republicans certainly do 👞💋

[@MelonHead78]

@@loonyspoons5676 not sides kiss boots we just picked a different pair of boots to kiss

[@ashtonkatu7316]

@@OrionsTale “Oh, we’re all gonna die, agent.”

[@rvmaika5815]

Genuinely did not realize these guys were still around until the MTG incident

[@RedHoodedWraith_Boy]

With all the stuff about the Pinkertons and their anti-union activities and pretty much protecting the status quo, I was honestly surprised their founder was staunchly against slavery and played an active role in helping people get free from slavery

[@Nikko1Brown]

Goals change sometimes not for the better

[@carso1500]

Sometimes bad people can have good ideas and good people bad ones

[@falahati]

@@carso1500 so dumb. people are complicated, there is no bad or good people :|

[@sparkysmalarkey]

The status-quo they were building required slavery to be abolished. It was competition, plain and simple. I think it's called moral convenience. The same thing is happening with fossil fuels.

[@MarcelinhoTheRock]

One Thing is one thing and other thing is other thing, nobody is whole evil or whole good. Even criminals have positive things to say about them

[@zhaohuideng8836]

OK I know one of these Pinkerton men: Where is Booker DeWitt?

[@alexanderthegreat445]

Zhaohui Deng What about Milton?

[@rafisanders]

Gotteem

[@a.k.a_ems]

@@alexanderthegreat445 What about Edgar Ross?

[@alexanderthegreat445]

EMS Ross as well

[@juicehexed3498]

So hyped for the new Bioshock

[@user-xq5og9lt8p]

Why didn't you mention his death? He slipped and fell in the dirt biting his tongue in the process and in a few days died from the blood infection. I find this ironic how a man who had so many close encounters with danger could have died in such silly circumstances

[@Speederzzz]

Reminds me of Marie Curie'a husband. He also worked with radiation but died when he tripped and was hit by a coach.

[@jimtaylor294]

On of the GWR's most significant chief engineers died from being run over by his own creation, specifically a locomotive pulling the Fishguard express. (he'd been inspecting a track section and didn't hear the train in time)

[@monsieurouxx]

Karma eventually got that bitch.

[@d4n4nable]

@@monsieurouxx He was a hero.

[@lordofthechinesebiscuit8436]

Here Lies Alan Pinkerton He Bit His Tongue And Fell In Dirt.

[@patheticbadger3478]

Pinkertons in the 19th - 20th centuary: "The Knights of Capitalism" Pinkertons 2019: Suing a game company...

[@jacobthefiend]

Good to see not much has changed in 150 years, huh?

[@a.n.l.aantineoliberalismas4504]

Yha well due you for proteaing us accurately in red dead redemption 2

[@hansisbrucker813]

They still exist? 😳

[@tobybartels8426]

@@hansisbrucker813 : Not like they used to. They provide security guards and whatever ‘risk analysis’ means in this context. They were bought by a Swedish company in 2003, but they still operate under the name ‘Pinkerton's’.

[@generalgrievous2197]

There still protecting money though

[@SgtCandy]

"When education is not liberating, the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor." - Paulo Freire

[@mabimabi212]

Makes me think of a specific french 'pacifist' revolutionary that murdered thousands.

[@adamraserovaquera]

@snailwithinternetaccess chop chop chop chop

[@kkounal974]

You would think people understood the unity of means and ends. Then again he was pretty violent from the start so maybe he didn't.

[@holmesowen8558]

Pedagogy of the oppressed is one of my favorite books

[@Sewblon]

I haven't read pedagogy of the oppressed. But I suspect that The Ego and his Own would also be a useful way to view Mr. Pinkerton's life. He accepted that the only 2 possible ways of being are dominance and submission. So he choose to resist domination Except for when he got to do it himself.

[@bbehr-uv1ft]

Pinkerton being like Arthur Morgan being deputized while being wanted

[@samurguy9906]

Not actually that uncommon on the shifting American frontier. Turns out, the ability to use a gun and the judgement of when to take or not take a fight has some overlap between lawmen and outlaws.

[@Omnifarious0]

@@samurguy9906 - The same is true for the digital frontier. IMHO, the government shot itself in the foot early on coming down so heavily on hackers who were in it for the knowledge, fun, or glory.

[@bubblebreak4160]

Law men and criminals are the same

[@sleepypanda2696]

Yes, only one of them fights for themselves And the other occasionally fights for themselves

[@enigmabureau]

@ChipsBuzz or outlaws were as good as lawmen

[@thebutzel9752]

“DAMN PINKERTONS!” -Arthur Morgan, sometime in 1899.

[@bennice6811]

*all the time in 1899

[@Deivid-bn6yw]

“Hey umm you heard anything about Pinkerton round these parts?”- Arthur every time he enters a new town

[@Joedoeem]

@@Deivid-bn6yw when u have a bounty in the area thatll happen

[@thebigdrew12]

Pinkertons' intelligence in the Civil War, while technically accurate, did often end up misleading McClellan. Pinkerton usually reported the number of units opposing McClellan, and McClellan used that information to estimate the size of the Confederate Army. Unbeknownst to either man, the Confederate units were often much smaller on the individual level, leading to Union confusion.

[@Tyracus]

Odd that this pops up in my feed after the Wizards magic story breaks. Didn’t know Pinkertons were still a thing after their history in the 1800s

[@someone_one_one]

Right?

[@nananakeson]

Tbh there wasn't a better time for this to pop up.

[@felisd]

I only knew about them (before the MTG thing) thanks to reading Sherlock Holmes.

[@nathanyakich3152]

I'm a Pittsburgher, and we learned about the Homestead Strikes in school: Frick, Carnegie, and the Pinkerton Agency. Nothing about the man himself though. This was fascinating. Thanks!

[@zane9464]

Nathan Yakich Carnegie can go frick himself.

[@Sleight-lq8qd]

It’s weird how different I laced in the same country get different educations. I had three us history classes that never spoke a word about the Pinkertons. All the way from the revolution to WW1.

[@thundergozon6439]

@@zane9464 The Pinkertons can go frick themselves too

[@roguishpaladin]

@@Sleight-lq8qd Did they cover Carnegie and similar monopolists of the period, though? The Pinkertons were the hand, not the brain, so it's less important to know about them than about the overall themes of the period. Yes, it's interesting, but it's a piece in a large puzzle that I could see a teacher leaving off for sake of time.

[@Sleight-lq8qd]

roguishpaladin “covered” is a generous term “touched on” more like. We talked about Carnegie and it was in a favorable light. Outlining his rags-to-riches thing, and John D. Rockafeller. Who we definitely did cover. We had a whole unit on trusts and monopoly’s and he was the name that kept cropping up. Also it is worth noting that for a class covering everything from the end of the civil war to the beginning of WW1 we spent 4 of 14 weeks on Custer getting his ass handed to him at Little Bighorn

[@splayairplane3418]

Damn you Leviticus Cornwall!!

[@ziggitee3500]

If only Dutch didn’t rob that damn train!

[@nobodyimportant130]

Damn you Walpole

[@thomashambly3718]

I read this like Timmy's dad going "damn you dinkleburg"

[@DokturProfesur]

"Who tha hell is Leviticus Cornwall?"

[@splayairplane3418]

@@thomashambly3718 *Shaking fist angrily in no particular direction*

[@eizenbrook6777]

Well Wizards of the Cost literally just sent them after a KZbinr that wizards accidentally sent a unreleased Box of Magic the Gathering to

[@haydenhayden]

Allan Pinkerton is a great example of “You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”

[@NuncNuncNuncNunc]

Pinkerton may have had some not too proud moments in his life, but he had been dead several years by the time of the strike in the video.

[@tomwhitworth1560]

He was a hypocrite

[@siyacer]

they were mever the hero

[@cb41503]

The Pinkertons are still around today to my surprise

[@kurskfirebrand4494]

yeah apparently they tried to sue Rockstar for their portrayal in Red Dead Redemption 2

[@sabotabby3372]

and disgust

[@Liberty_Bull]

They have linked together with Securitas security

[@js500y9]

I almost went to work for them once guarding a power plant in Illinois.

[@fenrirumbra3772]

They still do anti union activities.

[@brownmims2311]

I remember when calling someone a Pinkerton was a grave insult.

[@NotHPotter]

It still should be. Let's bring it back!

[@thundergozon6439]

it should be, honestly

[@d4n4nable]

Goes to show how much incessant socialists subverted morals. They were true heroes.

[@adamplentl5588]

@@d4n4nable yeah they were heroes for wealthy industrialist pigs I guess.

[@d4n4nable]

@@adamplentl5588 LOL. Thanks to those "industrialit pigs" you have a (too) comfortable life today. Be grateful do them, you worm.

[@Supadubya]

Pinkerton's also killed strikers in the Bread and Roses strike in Lawrence, Massachusetts. Tossed a grenade into a crowd of striking teenage mill girls at one point if I recall correctly...

[@uhtredragnarson9128]

Exactly why they are deserving bad guys

[@tonysladky8925]

Oh, don't mind me. Just a Magic: The Gathering fan rewatching this episode in late April, 2023 for NOOOOOOO REASON whatsoever...

[@evilproductionstudios9659]

This is extra history’s new series, extra police

[@evilproductionstudios9659]

Mac McJof that’s better

[@DallinBackstrom]

@Frank the Bunny extra criminology! come on, they're academics, we've got to give them some credit

[@alejandrokaplan7243]

evil leafy Production studios extra labor

[@evilproductionstudios9659]

Alejandro Kaplan 🤣

[@alejandrokaplan7243]

evil leafy Production studios it would be cool

[@realrock333]

As someone from Illinois, please remember that the S is silent

[@TheTestyDuck]

Illi noice

[@kathic6402]

It was so subtle the first time I thought I imagined it

[@mustafabeer1791]

A omeone from Illinoi, pleae remember that the S i ilent. Better?

[@williamwulff289]

Not even in French do we pronounce the "s". Your Illinoy is for us "Illy-nwa"

[@SamWeltzin]

I have a similar pet peeve from having lived in Nevada. People pronounce it NeVAHdah, when everyone who lives there pronounces it NeVAduh (short A sound, like apple). So I feel your pain.

[@KyaniMosaic_Crone]

Anyone else here to show this educational video to kids/teens because Hasbro just sent the Pinkertons to terrorize a KZbinr who legally purchased the Magic the Gathering cards that Hasbro accidentally shipped out 2 weeks early. Yup. That's where we are in America 2023.

[@purromemes7395]

That’s normal. They’ve always done that lmao. Your just waking up now. I’ve been talking about this since the 1990s

[@qawamity]

The only "terror" involved was if there was recognition of the Pinkerton name. If a couple guys knock on your door saying they are private detectives there to retrieve property. there isn't much there that is "terrifying".

[@purromemes7395]

@@qawamity they didn’t knock on his door they broke it down and ransacked his house

[@purromemes7395]

@@qawamity and threatened his wife and kids

[@qawamity]

@@purromemes7395 That's not what he said, last I heard. Has he changed his story?

[@squidythe3rd927]

You forgot the greatest Pinkerton story of all: When heroic agents hunted down the infamous Tacitus Kilgore and his far scarier brother: *R I P V A N W I N K L E*

[@wagwarn3957]

Squidy The 3rd you all know what he’s talking about

[@afriendlyrebel5709]

lol

[@ApeNaticZoo]

And arthur calahan

[@enriquepowers]

I think Jim Milton was far scarier

[@tuweegaming7593]

@Arthur Marston And also Archibald Smith

[@the_last_raposa3810]

I was expecting Emma goldman to come up here, given her attempts to assassinate the steel company owners, you should do a video or a series on goldman

[@evanweiss71]

Hell yeah

[@NotHPotter]

Yes please!

[@BaronElBardo]

If I were a patreon of EC, I will prupose one series about Emma Goldman. Se had a very interesting life and still being an inspiration for modern anarchist.

[@TheShadowwalker007]

Never hear... sounds interesting!

[@ziggitee3500]

I was expecting Rip Van Winkle to show up

[@sitcom4008]

Milton: Mr. Dutch Van Der Linde, Mr. Morgan... and you are...? John: R I P V A N W I N K L E

[@notoriousnostalgia9642]

Dutch: And to what do we owe the pleasure, Agent Moron?

[@thefakebarrybonz4492]

how do you know my mothers maiden name?

[@kursk_kuku141]

“And it’s always a goddamn train!” -Arthur Morgan, 1899

[@CitanulsPumpkin]

How big was the view spike for this video in the weeks after Wizards of the Coast sent the Pinkertons to that guy's house to retrieve those Pre-Pre-Pre- prerelease magic cards?

[@tjoconnell2524]

Ok, this mans life is full of ironic situations. He has a criminal record in Scotland, but becomes a sheriffs deputy. Founder of the Pinkerton detective agency, but is instead used to break up union strikes, not what he exactly wanted.

[@kchishol1970]

Considering the rationalizations he engaged in about the last activity, it became exactly what he wanted.

[@thundergozon6439]

Except he defended it with stupid non arguments while still alive and in charge of the agency

[@MStonewallC]

I didn't expect to hear that Pinkerton himself fought for working class rights in his early life. Now I know what Chartism is too, interesting stuff.

[@maximsavage]

Didn't you watch the video? That was exactly as he wanted. He was just a hypocrite who reneged on his ideals once he got money.

[@palladin9479]

Pinkerton didn't do anything with unions. the guest author was extremely deceptive in how they portrayed the order of events with an almost lawyer like approach with a disclaimer. All the anti-union stuff happened after Pinkerton's death and the private security company being passed to his children. Pinkerton himself didn't sell out his values.

[@MrFishman55]

A rags to riches story with a protagonist who also happened to help McClellan, save Lincoln, and basically interacted with almost every prominent figure of the 1860's? I smell a self-insert, they're getting lazy with story arcs these days.

[@logankrohn1472]

Samuel You are right, this story is exactly like you described and full of cliches

[@thundergozon6439]

Who would write a self-insert as betraying his own former brothers and morals for cash?

[@henryhaile1653]

@@thundergozon6439 HE DIDN'T. His sons were the ones who ran the anti union activities. Pinkerton died in 1884 if I'm correct.

[@thundergozon6439]

@@henryhaile1653 I'll politely refer you to 7:20 Just the next half minute should be enough of a reply.

[@henryhaile1653]

@@thundergozon6439 so he had a change of heart regarding anarchism and socialism, and he tested railroad workers to make sure they didn't take bribes? Someone doesn't have to believe in one set of ideas their whole life, and making sure workers aren't corrupt seems to be good in general, just making sure trustworthy people are working on the trains.

[@autoklashkinov]

It should also have been stated that The Pinkerton Detective Agency is still around today and also responsible for some of the most horrific Anti-Labor violence in American history

[@troybaxter]

Oh, we are definitely aware of their existence now. Looking at you Hasbro.

[@justsomeguy3686]

And noooooow they have allegedly raided some youtuber who seems like his only offense was to be being sent the wrong cards and inadvertently leaking them. Going to be interesting to see how this plays out and expands their history

[@spencerthomas913]

Found my way here after hearing about that whole situation lol.

[@Cuinn]

IIRC, they didn't actually raid his home. They knocked on his door and demanded the return of the cards. Still somewhat bullying in appearance, but there was no raid involved.

[@falcor200]

​@@Cuinn you come to my house with a gang of armed men demanding something that's mine legally that's a raid period

[@Quinini76]

Suddenly this is APPARENTLY very relevant TODAY too

[@morganahart2575]

It's always fascinating to hear an aspect of such a widely discussed historical organization that I've never seen discussed before, thanks for all the work you guys do

[@LordOfSilense]

There is a clear and direct reason why American education and social commentary don't touch on America's anti-Union groups. $$$ is at play.

[@davidhansen5067]

Three guesses as to why a MtG player got this video in his recommendations at the end of April, 2023.

[@skillganon606]

Me too lol

[@MedioTaffy]

Hey that's me!

[@Sketchman911]

"You people venerate savagery, and you will die! Savagely!" -Andrew Milton, 1899

[@jurtra9090]

Oh we're all gonna die, agent

[@Sketchman911]

@@jurtra9090 "Some sooner than others!"

[@hendadon718]

"enjoy your fishing, kid"

[@juliocaesar2268]

@@hendadon718 while you still can

[@thomasmanley9118]

And now theyre back in the news in 2023 thanks to Fucking Wizards

[@chaoscontrollerdx9303]

The journey through the Red Dead Redemption games introduced me to the Pinkertons and their role in history as I had never heard anything of them in real life. It's sad to see how a humble and well intended ideal can become something that went against it's own values. Really makes you rethink a lot about those games and who you were facing.

[@jacestar3007]

They at it again, Agnes

[@torcaace]

this just happened to appear in my yt recommended page. Considering recent events, i don't think it's randomized

[@mauktheogre4477]

Do the Battle of Mount Blair. Fits perfectly with this episodes theme.

[@travishabursky4362]

My Great-Granddad was apart of the Battle of Blair Mountain. We need to talk about that battle a lot more than we do.

[@LegendStormcrow]

@@travishabursky4362 sounds about right to me.

[@judebreheny3925]

They choose video topics using patreon. Sorry, man.

[@mauktheogre4477]

@@judebreheny3925 damn. Well, there's always hope they'll listen

[@judebreheny3925]

@@mauktheogre4477 Not really. You have to pay to be a patreon and part of the way they encourage people to support them on P. is by only offering votes to patrons. There's really no chance unless someone decides it would make a good video.

[@annew6501]

I just very recently found out Allen Pinkerton is my great great great grandfather... Oh man. I am adopted so it's certainly been a whirlwind of information. Thanks for sharing.

[@thezombiekat7506]

Oof

[@Remix2366]

You need to mentally separate memes and genes

[@LaborwaveLenin]

Damn that’s sad

[@openthinker6562]

@@LaborwaveLeninwhy? He’s a descendant of an abolitionist, an Underground Railroad worker, a defender of immigrants and a man who saved Abraham Lincoln. That is worthy of being proud of while also denouncing the organization that he created and emerged after him

[@yahboisquishy5561]

Well this video is now relevant thanks to Wizards of the Coast.

[@kyuken893]

KZbin recommeding this to me shortly after WotC's use of them is... interesting to say nothing else.

[@D2RCR]

This just became relevant again.

[@Paveway-chan]

Shoutout to everyone back here after the Pinkertons were hired to steal back Magic: The gathering cards from a KZbinr who accidentally got merch before it was supposed to be released

[@kudorgyozo]

Wow what a coincidence that I get this in my recommended list to me right now

[@ApotreNoir]

They've been in the news recently. Wizards of the coast sent some to a streamer's house after mistakingly sending him the wrong Magic card to tease. Zero chill

[@darthnihilus1608]

Well, thank WotC for bringing your video back into relevancy

[@goosey1513]

nowadays they use the Pinkertons to raid youtubers for magic the gathering cards

[@alexr6705]

Note: the Pinkertons, albeit diminished, still exist today, still attempting to bust organized labor for the highest bidder, and other disgusting companies like them rose up in order to break the common man, and they’re still quite prominent, if much more subtle and silent.

[@mapleflag6518]

And now stealing cards

[@2hot34]

And were bought by a big Swedish company in 1999

[@Jack_Zandara]

Hey it's those guys Hasbro hired to harass someone for mistakenly sending him the wrong pack of cards two weeks before release date

[@DivineShieldmaiden]

Imagine having these mercenaries sent to your home for piece of cardboard...

[@tathemrelag3123]

I'm still hoping you make an episode about Georgiy Khrustalyov-Nosar. The father of Russian socialism and one of the leading figures of the 1905 Russian Revolution, who was later driven from the RSDLP and killed on the orders of one of his own proteges, Leon Trotsky. He really deserves to be more well-known.

[@user-fl8lq7xq3c]

Extra class consciousness

[@DallinBackstrom]

@@user-fl8lq7xq3c underrated comment

[@TransientWitch]

And then Trotsky was later driven out of his homeland by Stalin. I'd still say his ideas were better than Stalin's, but clearly he wasn't all that much better. Can't we have just one historical figure that's just half-way decent with no contradictory actions? Please?

[@sandrosixarulidze398]

Where I can find information on his deeds and biography? there's even no wiki page for him. And that is weird, if he truly was such an important figure in Russian revolution.

[@tathemrelag3123]

@@sandrosixarulidze398 Sadly, there isn't a lot of readily-available information on him. Probably in large part thanks to Trotsky. There are a few mentions of him on the Wikipedia pages for the 1905 Russian Revolution and Leon Trotsky: "A strike by railway workers on 21 October [O.S. 8 October] 1905 quickly developed into a general strike in Saint Petersburg and Moscow. This prompted the setting up of the short-lived Saint Petersburg Soviet of Workers' Delegates, an admixture of Bolsheviks and Mensheviks headed by Khrustalev-Nossar." "By the time of Trotsky's arrival, the Saint Petersburg Soviet was already functioning headed by Khrustalyev-Nosar (Georgy Nosar, alias Pyotr Khrustalyov). Khrustalyev-Nosar had been a compromise figure when elected as the head of the Saint Petersburg Soviet. Khrustalev-Nosar was a lawyer that stood above the political factions contained in the Soviet. However, since his election, he proved to be very popular with the workers in spite of the Bolsheviks' original opposition to him. Khrustalev-Nosar became famous in his position as spokesman for the Saint Petersburg Soviet. Indeed, to the outside world, Khrustalev-Nosar was the embodiment of the Saint Petersburg Soviet. Trotsky joined the Soviet under the name "Yanovsky" (after the village he was born in, Yanovka) and was elected vice-chairman. He did much of the actual work at the Soviet and, after Khrustalev-Nosar's arrest on 26 November 1905, was elected its chairman." The citations provided for those sections are: Voline (2004). Unknown Revolution, Chapter 2: The Birth of the "Soviets" Isaac Deutscher, The Prophet Armed: Trotsky, 1879-1921, p. 131 Leon Trotsky, 1905, pg. 218 Additionally, there is a Russian Wikipedia page for him, if you can either read Russian or deal with the extremely broken Google translation of the page. Unfortunately, I can't link you directly to it because of the Russian characters in the url, but it's the second link in the "Usage on ru.wikipedia.org" section on this page: commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Georgiy_Nosar.jpg#filelinks Hope that helps you get started!

[@scorchclasstitan6727]

“Agent Milton Agent Ross *Pinkerton detective agency heard you robbed a train up near granite pass* ?

[@scorchclasstitan6727]

David Castillo *sorry can’t do that friend*

[@kirknay]

Magic the gathering does a thing KZbin recommendations: I'm about to ruin this guy's entire legacy.

[@JohnnyElRed]

"Poderoso caballero es Don Dinero."

[@lightlysalted7790]

Rimane sontato pfuggure solo nero

[@TransSappho]

0:48 it’s honestly really refreshing to hear someone talk about the railroad strike of 1877 cause it was both one of the most widespread strikes of its time and the opposition to it killed and injured so many. And it’s just not talked about enough

[@Austin.Kilgore]

Wizards of the Coast are fcked up for this lol

[@martinpat94]

Funny that this may be relevant now and days. Perhaps a revisit on the Pinkertons is in order?

[@janoriegam2107]

I did a presentation on then and I’ve wanted to see more people cover them ever since! Great job guys!

[@amiscellaneoushuman3516]

Learnt to pronounce "Glasgow" I see.

[@wanderingrandomer]

Almost. It's still sounds more Glass-go than Glaz-go

[@amiscellaneoushuman3516]

@@wanderingrandomer he is an American so we should give him some leeway. Besides, at least it's not glass-cow

[@luciddreaming4478]

*learn No t in learn.

[@frankdantuono2594]

But not "Illinois", the "s" is silent. He made that mistake at least 3 times.

[@FistoftheSnackBar]

@@frankdantuono2594 Dude, that was so painful. I often wonder if people outside of Illinois just don't know that.

[@LemonMoon]

Hmm, how convenient this appears in my subscriptions after recent events

[@Logan-tz1ry]

...Well fucking played, KZbin. Well fucking played

[@rashkavar]

Interesting. A pity this seems to be just a one-off, I'd be up for a whole series of Pinkertons' history. There's a lot to unpack in there.

[@alancranford3398]

Thank you for this informative presentation. I wish that public school history classes were as factual. One of the security guard companies I worked for was Pinkerton (and Pinkerton provided the guard force for Disneyland during the Fifties). Part of orientation was being taught Pinkerton history, but they left out the part about Allen Pinkerton's criminal activities. One part that really hit the target was that local "law enforcement" during the 19th Century had severe issues with corruption. Two other issues raised in this presentation were limited jurisdiction and general incompetence. Law enforcement didn't have to be competent at the time. One reason for the 1893 Anti-Pinkerton Act was that the Pinkertons were investigating corrupt law enforcement organizations run by Democratic Party political machines--and this was stopping the South from rising again. Now we have multiple alphabet organizations doing the same jobs that the Pinkertons did for the federal government.

[@drewberrycrunch1417]

I can not believe that in 2023 I'm watching this video because WotC just sent the literal Pinkertons to intimate and harass a client/youtuber.

[@Rez-bg7go]

Apparently they also seize magic the gathering cards

[@clamum]

Just FYI guys, the 's' is silent in "Illinois."

[@Apesrock12]

I was going to comment the same thing! Had to do a double listen!

[@lobster5364]

No, its spelled illinoi-s-e

[@sethleoric2598]

I'll Noise?

[@MarlsbysDragons]

Yes thank you that was bugging me so much

[@Genericnameperson]

It's illy-noice. Anything else is just propaganda

[@JacKm0z]

I'm here because Hasbro just used Pinkerton's to raid a guy's house for magic the gathering cards

[@stefanneculae9502]

Same bruh

[@kriosuranous3440]

Just wanted to mention, the “S” in Illinois is silent.

[@kevinsullivan3448]

There is no oy in Illinois either.

[@kriosuranous3440]

Kevin Sullivan ??? How do you pronounce it?

[@sld1776]

What? ??? I have always called them the Illiniissss.

[@RenMagnum4057]

"A hundred thousand dollars, can I turn myself in? " Arthur Morgan

[@indiepants-6861]

“We want vanderlind” Milton

[@Rajsilver]

@Arthur Marston is your name seriously Arthur Marston

[@Ofxzh]

Schools should use these types of videos, it’s factual, and suited for modern audiences who would like a reason to study history. Because instead on a focus on a person, area, or time, it focuses on reasons, backstories, and other things. Not to mention the animations are professional and not just built to be educational, but for people to be interested in it without being up in your face.

[@enchantedfoxysword25]

can we use them to get trading cards back

[@agentxx3022]

...and they are still going strong, even in 2023. Little paper cards are serious business.

[@huxleyleodwalding5751]

The story of Allan Pinkerton working for the working class in the beginning and ultimately leaving for the cushy life of a bourgeois boss of a prime union-busting agency reveals only one important truth. The liberation of the working class is a job for the worker alone.

[@ossifiedprophet7495]

F in chat for Hosea and Leny 😔

[@CarrionCrow993]

In the UK we don't learn about the Pinkertons in school, but I've seen so many references of them in film and the like I wondered what on earth it was all about. Thanks for making it clear and fun, Extra History! :D

[@kidayuki9884]

I cringed every time he pronounced the 's' in Illinois.

[@ZoeAlleyne]

I'm Australian and yet, same.

[@nolanleblanc]

Yes, great video, but Illinoisy

[@nolanleblanc]

I'm actually surprised his cat didn't correct him

[@callumjohnston858]

The wizards summoned me for a rewatch.

[@charlie11ng42]

Possibly the most significant impact Pinkerton had was often more than doubling the size of the confederate army in his estimates greatly contributing to General Mcellen's catastrophic caution and potentially greatly lengthening the Civil War.

[@achintyanaithani889]

Which, ironically, ensured that the Union shall stay in long enough to whip up abolition and the total crushing of the South.

[@josephattwell1006]

I am sad there wasn't a Bioshock Infinite reference.

[@Sketchman911]

I'm sad there wasn't a Red Dead reference

[@Kadaspala]

I'm sad there wasn't a Deadwood clip of Al Swearengen saying "Fucking Pinkertons"

[@insertnamehere6067]

Kadaspala I'm sad there wasn't a weezer reference

[@c182SkylaneRG]

Thank you for doing this one. I was trying to explain the Pinkertons on another historical video (I believe it was The History Guy's videos on Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid), and was starting to second-guess whether they were actually as violent as I thought I remembered learning in school. Turns out, I was remembering correctly. :)

[@basementdwellercosplay]

I'm using this for one of my sources in my history paper in the pinkerton's before and during the civil war, really good video!

[@senorPachuChay]

Kate Warne, the first female detective hired by Pinkerton, is the one largely credited with rescuing Lincoln! It was her in that train with him to Washington! It is even believed that Pinkerton got their slogan "We never sleep" having been inspired by Kate Warne's vigilant watch over the President throughout the journey.

[@damianarvizu1095]

I watched when it was new… and KZbin recommended it today. Hmmm, perhaps WotC has whacked the proverbial hornets’ nest again. 😉

[@BuildinWings]

Pinkerton isn't a paradox. He was selfish. He supported worker's rights when it benefited him, then he made money opposing them. There's no logical contradiction if you understand he only ever cared about himself and literally nobody else. His depiction here should have had horns.

[@connormcgehee9349]

Now they protect the makers of both dungeons and dragons

[@gilliganallmighty3]

Watching this after the Pinkertons were used by Hasbro to illegally break and enter into people's house. They shiuld be disbanded.

[@stormhawkdude]

KZbin algorithm working perfectly with the timing on this. Why the hell are they still around!?

[@tdtdbanana]

This may have gone unnoticed by most but I have to say I love the Blazing Saddles reference in this episode!

[@illegalprime3626]

You should do a series on the history of airline travel. It would be interesting to see your take on advancements like the Douglas DC-3 and the de Havilland Comet.

[@SaiyanHeretic]

So like many "great men" of history, he was also conveniently hypocritical.

[@reedhoward27]

Hypocrisy is a requirement to be a class traitor.

[@Soundwave3591]

Do you know how many people branded as "colleagues" or "Comrades" hated each other's guts? look at all the "Communist" powers: the USSR and the PRC hated each other (they fought more than one border skirmish), and most of the South American and Southeast Asian "communists" simply used the USSR and China as resource mills. Ideology is distressingly fluid in the face of practicality. The US happily looked the other way at the Fascist regimes they put in power so long as they were ardently anti-communist. Hitler readily armed Muslims, Slavs, Poles and Ukrainians if they were willing to fight the allies for him. The Communist regime in Afghanistan was as farcically inept for the USSR as South Vietnam's government was for the USA.

[@henryhaile1653]

How was he hypocritical? His organization later betrayed his values, but the testing of workers isn't unethical, taking bribes is a crime and the testing of workers was a nessecary evil. While he may have opposed anarchists and socialists, he was overall a good man.

[@NoFlu]

Well I think when making the video they forgot that he didn't strike because of work conditions or whatever but because he wanted to vote. Since people in the US could vote, he might have seen them as beeing too needy and whatnot. Now if this is true IDK but that's what I got from the video, if he was a socialist before, might have been good to mention that in the vid....

[@evilbound]

@TrapLordHodor Yes

[@lilzowsk8960]

am i the only one annoyed with how he says “illinois”

[@themonkeymoo]

Nope

[@rowdiken4837]

Im enraged as a local

[@TheFuri0uswc]

Very very annoyed

[@Cemi_Mhikku]

To be fair, we're from a region of pants on head on fire pronunciations. Like 'Jolly-ette'.... But I won't say I'm not disappointed, they usually do a lot better.

[@robertwalpole360]

First Glass-cow and now Illi-noise?

[@XxSubaDudexX]

I was just in homestead today! I was hanging out with my friends and always like to pass by the old smoke stacks from carnegie's steel mill