Makeup YOU Said You'll NEVER Buy Again..

[@javibb5964]

tylan is the employee of the month

[@smithpaulina8]

Nope! I call a do over! 😂 Allie, I want to see you use products that are bad quality, not just because someone doesn’t like the scent. Let’s get crazy with it!

[@annabusch3382]

YES!!!!!!

[@ev_green_]

Haha yess! Are we sure she never did this?

[@ericahipolito8144]

Yes!

[@geniej2378]

Right?! I want to see the duds that are on the market!

[@unfilthy]

You know what's way worse than having a product not work for you at all? Having the product you love the most discontinued! Anything I absolutely fall in love with and rely on as an infallible holy grail item gets discontinued. I swear it's borderline traumatizing.

[@deeice5398]

Same here!!! This happens to me all the time especially with foundations. It takes a while to find a good foundation where you like the shade/finish/wearability, etc ... Then the company discontinues it or replaces it with an inferior product. This happened with BB Moisture Rich foundation which I LOVED! Then EL discontinued the Perfectionist foundation. I was devastated. Thanks to Allie I'm now using the Nars Light Reflecting foundation which has worked great with my dry skin.

[@1981jsk]

SAAAAME! I literally must love things that everyone else hates because this always happens to me too 🤣

[@mollyjust9745]

Too Faced Natural Nudes lipstick! Heartbreaking!

[@patty4393]

I also hate it when products get reformulated. It’s usually called “new and improved” but almost never is.

[@laikanbarth]

Yes!!!! I hate that!!

[@montananerd8244]

For those who think that the days of $1 elf makeup must have been amazing: it was so bad that I declared "never again" to the *entire brand* from 2010 - 2020. It was a nice surprise that it improved and lemme tell ya, the current low price stuff is a much better deal.

[@ei42877]

Lol sooooo true! 💯

[@Mpiewizard]

True. Elf was kinda sketch back in the day.

[@jgray690]

haha. this is so true. But now ELF is one of my favorite drug store brands. They really upped their game over the years.

[@orewahouston2143]

Yes!!! Used an elf product back in the day that was so awful that I couldn’t believe the hype haha

[@pinkbubblesnake]

Makeup revolution used to be like this too for a bit. Single shadows at £1 or palettes at £4

[@ilsecontreras7467]

6-9 shades in an eyeshadow palette is perfect for me! I am agreeing with most of these products!

[@kelseykmua]

Oh I'll also never buy the IT!Cosmetics CC+ foundation...it NEVER dries down. Even with the lightest layer of product and a lot of powder, I STILL feel goopy all over the face!😮

[@stilwellpianostudio7813]

I have a theory: many of us can only afford a minimal makeup collection, which means that we only have ONE concealer, ONE primer, foundation or whatever on hand. Many of these products look great if you just wear them once or twice in a long while, but with repeated use they wreck our skin and give us breakouts, etc. Influencers often don't experience that because they cycle through so much product.

[@majesticbeast4830]

I agree for the most part, but I would say that's why we have to be careful with our trust in online personalities. Some influencers strictly do longer term reviews. Some do a mix. If we are going to base our purchases on someone else's opinion, we gotta decide if that person has similar makeup preferences, skin type, etc.

[@mk52211]

thats why I never watch the videos with titles like what I bought from Sephora , or this month fav . we need more longer use reviews

[@clairecooks5257]

Hmm for me I feel it straight away after the first try - like burning on my skin

[@jacidel]

Yeah like the elf halo glo filter stuff made me break out so bad after a few weeks and i didnt even get that good of a result from it. I was just wearing it bc everyone else was😂

[@rosettaroper3317]

5 pallets.

[@ChristinePacinda]

I can totally understand how your young, beautiful skin would make it so much easier for many products to work for you. I promise you that as you age, you'll discover the need to change out the types and brands of products that you can use. When I hit 50, many of the makeup products I was always thrilled with suddenly looked horrible on me, and it was just a reformulation issue with one or two items. I initially invested in new tools and learning new application techniques, but to no avail. I had to completely change up my foundation, concealer, blush and mascara. Only my lip products remained consistent (though I love makeup so I've expanded my lip product selection exponentially just for the fun of it). It was initially downright distressing to realize I'd have to change out all of my products, but then it just served to fuel my makeup addiction and became really fun. When I was younger I would NEVER wear cream blush and was terrified of red lipstick. Now I use both and get tons of compliments, because my face is now oily/normal combo and can accept cream blush, and red lipstick now looks kinda classy instead of scary. The ONE item I absolutely cannot use Grande Lash Serum. I woke up in the morning looking like someone had beaten me in the face while I slept... purple red swollen eyes, undereye bags that were headed for me chin... It was horrifying! I actually refused to go to work that day because I was afraid someone would think my husband had abused me. Never again!!!! And please tell your husband that this was a brilliant idea!

[@Elizabeth-dq6hg]

I think you are just so good at applying makeup that I can’t get mine to look that good!! Tylan is so supportive it’s sweet!! Love ya!

[@VC-by5rs]

Honestly the Tarte shape tape. It’s SO FULL COVERAGE which is nice, but I found it thick and hard to blend, and it honestly looked so heavy.

[@hannahr9712]

I’m someone who likes to have a small makeup bag for daily use. Holy grails only. That being said, single eyeshadows are my favorite and I always use my bronzer for the crease. I have neutral, fair skin and hazel eyes. I find it extremely hard to find eyeshadows that flatter both my eye color and skin tone, and also won’t crease on my hooded eyes. When I find that unicorn eyeshadow, that’s the only one I ever want to wear! Right now that unicorn is the Revlon ColorStay Crème eyeshadow pot in the shade Creme Brulee. So affordable and beautiful. 😍

[@carmendemiguel7056]

Everybody and their mother absolutely loooooved the L’Oréal Infallible fresh wear foundation but no matter how I applied, how well prepared my skin is (as with any other foundation) and how little or more I applied, it always looks so so cakey and dry on my very dry skin 😢 and I wanted to like it so much seeing how it seemed to work for everybody but nope, horrible!

[@k.popper2620]

Me too...

[@montananerd8244]

I've never found a foundation, at any price point, that I like. I gave up on complexion products until I got a really good tinted moisturizer in boxycharm. Then I realized that I absolutely despise the look and feel of any visible foundation on my skin, so ofc I hate every one I try!

[@neverinurdreams]

I have oily AF skin and it looks a little cakey on me too. It clogs my pores too so I don't reach for it on daily basis. There's something about L'oreal products in general where they never seem to be good in the long run for me.

[@laurielyons2284]

Same for me plus the turn orange on me.

[@onewhisper22005]

Same!!! It looks SO SO SO dry on me! Like immediately, as applying it. Crap dried down so fast, like before I could even blend it out nicely. I HATED it! I also HATE the L’Oréal infallible concealer everyone else seems to love!

[@robinhoward4204]

Many years ago Revlon made compacts with interchangeable eyeshadow pans. I'd love to find the same thing but affordable. I basically don't need more than four to six colours and find at 68 I can't wear glittery shades, although I love the look. One of the best palettes I've ever used was Flower Beauty Nude Remix. Subtle and buildable colours and I used most of them. I didn't find the magic cream that special, although it felt nice on my skin and I don't mind the smell. Love the Elf Camo concealer.

[@pamjones6909]

6 shades in a palette is my ideal. Love benefit brow pencil thanks to your recommendation as the only range with the right shade (but agree it’s pricey). Loved this idea for a video! ❤

[@Potterhead.]

Can you do a video about your hair routine? It loooks amazing!!! 🫶🏼

[@paolaandreu4191]

I love also 10-12 pan eyeshadow palettes, but a good basic palette such as Colourpop Stone cold fox is a great add to my collection. Love you Allie. From Mexico, Paola

[@neesa5613]

9 pan palates are my fav! Enough to get a couple types of looks but not so much it’s bulky or overwhelming!

[@Punksimmons]

I used to be into the midsize, eyeshadow palettes, but now I am definitely a quad and single shadow girl.

[@heysaras]

Bobbi Brown liquid foundations. I wear the lightest shades and they oxidize to orange like crazy on my skin. No more!

[@patriciakeegan4228]

Eye shadow palettes…4 to 5 shades…a base, a transition, a shimmer, a deeper corner and a dark lash liner. Eye liner pencils irritates my eyes but dark shadows applied with a very narrow angled brush…perfect!

[@mrsamcnizzle]

I think 9 to 18 pan palettes are where it's at, 15 pans is probably my sweet spot. Something with enough options to create several uniquely different looks, but not so many choices that i have to really think hard about what shades to pair together. I really prefer indie palettes over main stream now, their formulas are just superior generallly speaking (obviously there could still be indie duds though) ❤

[@georgettecooper711]

I like nars light reflecting, don’t like any of their other foundations but it does crease a lot for me too I just put eye primer on my smile lines

[@CathyVaughn-ph3lr]

I wear very minimal eye shadow, usually bronzer in the crease and maybe a color on the lid. I have a few small pallets but very rarely use more than 1 color.

[@user54782]

Oh my gosh, is your hair that wavy naturally or is it curled/from a braid? It looks so smooth, hair routine video please. 😍

[@kenziehiatt4318]

My go to is the Jeffrey star mini breaker pallet, born to run and sweet talk. Those all work together great to make casual to intense looks. Love em

[@mk42997]

I love minimal eyeshadow, so I gravitate towards single eyeshadow pots or crayons. When it comes to palettes I love the size of Ilia , Lisa Eldridge, or the UD mini palettes. My makeup "fun" comes more from colorful blushes and eyeliners, with a great mascara

[@amandavandewalle3514]

I loved Coty Airspun but could not get past the sweet tart scent. I never got used to it throughout the day so was constantly smelling it.

[@KarrasSim]

Just saw your subscriber count and realize that I’ve been with you for quite a few years now! Since somewhere in the mid 200K! Can’t wait until you hit 1 million!

[@LuvsCats297]

I love the benefit eyebrow product

[@dnbsvitkona3802]

I haven’t watched your videos since I am a little busy. I missed them so much! Love your videos❤❤

[@nikkiburns6291]

I absolutely DESPISE the One Size setting spray! Hear me out....I love how it truly holds my look all day, BUT...the smell is atrocious! And I can't stand the aerosol can! If it was an unscented misting spray, it'd be perfect.

[@susanjacobsen4567]

This video made me laugh so hard! Everyone has their own opinion but you handle it so graciously. Great Job!

[@luciabeernink5322]

My perfect pallets are the ABH ones. Not too big, perfect size!

[@annrider7096]

Hi Allie, re eyeshadow pallets, I prefer fewer options like 6-9 pans.

[@frazzledhaloz3184]

ALWAYS prefer smaller palettes!

[@XverreauX]

Small palettes are best for me. I love the size of the naked palettes from Urban Decay, and the new format from ABH are great for traveling ❤

[@Mari-nw1zx]

For eyeshadow palettes I like a 9 pan. It’s somewhat compact, but a few different options.

[@DoraTheExplora50]

I like the look you created 🎉❤

[@sitikhadijahhalim1505]

Hi Allie, I've been your suscriber since I'm in college (2018-1019), I've bought the NARS light reflecting foundation because of your recommendation 😊😊 My honest review are that because I live in tropical area that is hot throughout the year, this foundation tend to melt on me if I'm outside (plus I have oily skin), initially I actually wants to invest in high-end foundation and before this I had this small sample of the Nars sheer foundation, and I love it ❤ so I thought it will kinda have the same vibe with the light reflecting one, but not really😅. But I still wear this, it's a lovely product, have a lightweight feels and mosturizing, but I will only wear this to the places that is not hot. It's look and wear amazing on those times ❤ So you don't really have to feel bad, just like you said everyone's type of skin is different, our enviromment is different 😁😁

[@paigejohnson9201]

the hydrating camo concealer isn’t bad but it emphasized my lines compared to other concealers

[@kerryberes6886]

I love the elf putty primer

[@ngsinman613]

It would be fun if you try Asian’s favourite/least favourite make up products since the weather/humidity are very different between Asia and US

[@veram.6549]

I laughed really hard at 'soo thick and clumpy, never again! Well, let's apply it' moment 😂😂😂 Great video!

[@melissakoontz7764]

I like 9 to 15 shades in a pallet. I mostly use the Natasha Denona or Sigma palettes. For me I would never again but the Best Skin foundation or concealer for some reason they turned funky on my skin.

[@rachelr589]

I bought the NARS light reflecting foundation as well and hated it. But I have dry skin. Not oily. It made me look 10 years older even after prepping my skin. Creased so bad that I returned it. Too expensive to be that bad. Obviously also hated the Laura Mercier powder.

[@kellycastillo241]

That Nars foundation is the best foundation I’ve ever tried

[@geniej2378]

My favourite palette size is 12-15 shades in 3 rows. Smaller than that I can usually find enough shades I don’t love to avoid buying the palette, anything bigger I know I won’t enjoy holding while I do my eyeshadow. I also love a palette with a big mirror

[@LacyyGerelli]

Tbh the new benefit volumizing brow pencil has been my new go to. Ton of product and my brows look great!

[@jessabeauty917]

I got this and loved it. Then went to replace and the tip was always breaking and the product was dry and crumbled. I tried several too!

[@mona1190]

Could you do a video in which you try the lowest rated make up?

[@lesliesaperstone172]

I bought LYS liquid foundation on the advice of one of Wayne Goss’s videos. It didn’t work for me at all. Every time I applied it, it would pill up no matter what moisturizer or primer I used. Ended up getting rid of it.

[@cindygirard5170]

You look so pretty!!

[@itsmeayanna]

The overall eyeshadow palette needs to easily fit in a makeup bag. But 10-12 is a good number but if there are more eyeshadows they better be able to do liner, brows, brighten my under eye, and etc.

[@EmGGunns]

12 eyeshadows in a palette is perfect for me

[@angelinag9675]

I used to buy morphe 35 pan palettes but I finally realized that was unrealistic and I tend to go for colourpops 9 pan palettes specifically now

[@Alice-fr1ef]

I like the NARS Foundation and love ELF products. I like the Colourpop palettes and have most of the large ones and lots of the smaller ones too. I love the Patick Ta palettesn most. I think your makeup look really pretty Allie. I enjoyed this video and we love you too Allie.❤💗🌺🌹💐🌸🥀💐

[@bradenroberts1633]

I like an 18 pan palette the best!!!

[@missmeliarenee]

the nars foundations lightest shade was like four shades too dark for me 💀😭

[@janeashton2027]

Hi Allie, l love all the Laura Mercer products, they work really good on me, but l also use all the Dior, their bronzer is the perfect shade for me, because I was buying a lot of other bronzer but they wouldn't work to good, the Morphe palettes l love those ones, and also the huda beauty palettes too, hugsssss ❤❤❤

[@karlakramer6490]

Bah! The mac fix plus setting spray original is my every day setting spray. Love it. Charlotte tillbury is my absolute fave but not as economical. It burns, lets put it on (and other funny mentions in this video).😂

[@olgaderun6196]

Quad is perfect Amount for me. I like that I use every single shade. Charlotte tilbury exaggerize palette is perfection

[@georgettecooper711]

I didn’t like the Magic cream. It’s very silky but made me breakdown and burned my skin and I’m not that sensitive to fragrance. I own Dior complexion products so I feel like that says alot

[@Zil_Senczy]

Yeah, totally got the Nars light reflecting foundations from Allies recommendations, so as much as I love her, it's awful. It breaks up quickly and emphasizes my texture. It basically ends up just highlighting and emphasizing any imperfections

[@ashvinirawal5359]

Okay, I really appreciate that Tylan does things for you. Bcz my husband is my another baby, before we have kids. 😂 He wants me to do each & every stuff for him, and he just wanna sit like a baby. 😵‍💫🧚

[@katfanker]

Such a beautiful look Kelly! 👏🇭🇲

[@alishaculver4779]

I bought the Bare Minerals Complexion Rescue tinted moisturizer and it breaks on my skin so bad! I cannot get it to work for me!

[@heatheroney3760]

Maybelline Superstay. Heard so many people rave about it, but just looked awful on my skin. Tried different primers and junk, but nothing worked. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@YayaBolender]

I received lately a sample of the Kosas revealer concealer, I was so happy to receive it, but it is a catastrophe under my eyes, for sure, it reveals lines that I didn’t know I had 🫤. And I ordered the Kosas mini cloud baked setting powder, nice on the sides of my face, but certainly not under my eyes and on my T-zone. I felt really left out and suddenly very old, probably these products are great for young people. I am lucky enough not to be very wrinkled in spite of my mature age, but these products made my skin look very old. I have a very dry skin and I need a lot of moisture and a lot of lightness, so not for me.

[@joycekerensky6880]

I love Tarte Shape Tape Concealer❤❤

[@CH84015]

I think it'd be cool to save Ty be your sub host one day ... he could - or not - use you as a model, but HE'D be responsible for content on air. 😊😊😊😊😊

[@rickiebee6011]

I feel like everyone but me LOVED the elf bite sized eyeshadow palettes, but they were hard to work with and didn't last.

[@joycekerensky6880]

Every product that you used looks terrific ❤

[@alexandrascully4033]

The sky high mascara is so odd to me because I loved it in 2021/ 2022 and stopped using while pregnant and BF. Repurchased and used several times in combo situation that usually worked. Tried it by itself and it made my eyes itch so badly. I wonder if they switched the formula. But I was super sad.

[@ellejirapat]

benefit precisely my brows is of the same price as the goof proof one. But the goof proof has 3X more product if you compared by grams. I’d say goof proof worths it more

[@katiecieri8520]

Your hair looks beautiful in this video! You should wear it curly more often :).

[@parisqqq78]

A duo or a quad works best for me

[@emison6554]

i like a four shade eyeshadow palette that tells me exactly where to put each shade xD nine shades max

[@1981jsk]

I love videos like these! Great idea, Tylan! ☺

[@allisonpowers6804]

Mine would be the L’Oréal infallible fresh wear foundation, I absolutely hate it on my skin. Tried different shades, techniques, primers etc. and always looks terrible.

[@BullDurham12321]

I go through phases with this one. I feel like when I restart using it, I like it for a minute. Then it looks awful again lol. No more spending money on it. I wanted to love it, though.

[@k.popper2620]

Me too!!!

[@trishamarie]

I hate the price of Benefit’s brow pencil, but I suck it up because they have the only good shade for me. One pencil lasts me two weeks 😢

[@mauranoonan8951]

Very pretty!

[@PatriciaMonahan]

The size has kept me from buying Colourpop's Stone Cold Fox palette, although I love the colors. That's Taupe is a perfect size. High end, I prefer the size of the full-size Huda Beauty palettes (Rose Quartz, Mercury Retrograde) and the smaller ones for travel (Nude Obsessions, Matte Obsessions).

[@wegbc3906]

Next video should be makeup you can't live without. Like the movie "Sapceballs" says... take only what you need to survive!! And Princess Vespa brings her industrial strength hair dryer 😂🤣

[@janeashton2027]

Hi Allie, l love all the Benefit products, l love hourglass products, hugsssss ❤❤

[@Michelle-il2cf]

It's funny, I love the Revlon lipsticks, and don't notice a smell, but the tower28 gloss smell, gag!!! It's so funny how something triggers people so differently!

[@annetteskolnik9858]

Hi Allie! Great video! Have a wonderful day.

[@Fealcristina]

Allie we need a hair tutorial please 😍❤️

[@karenallen3486]

Yea Ty! Allie you can't make everyone happy! Some people just don't want to spend the money either. I have used some of the products and I have never had a problem with them. I think some just like to gripe.

[@nadhirah3243]

Fenty skin tint for me. So patchy no matter what i do. Only continue to use it since I already paid for it

[@virtuallyerin]

Agree about the Benefit eyebrow products! I LOVE Gimme Brow, but there's nothing in it! Lash Paradise Mascara has fibers in it that get it my eyes! UGH. L'oreal Lipstick- Archaic scent and smell-gross-needs a massive remodel but I love the shade Fairest Nude.

[@amylofton4589]

I like ,3-5 color palettes, where I know what can go where & they all go together, but I'm a toddler mom not looking to impress anyone

[@CariSouza]

This video was kinda funny to me because these are one of my favorite makeup products 😂❤

[@vickyemmans2083]

The Too faced Better than Sex mascara. Im someone who cannot afford expensive products, but now and then I purchase something that I think worth spending on. This mascara smudged on me eveytime i used it! ! And i was sad..because i have some from the drugstore that last all day !! As for palettes I would say around 10 eyeshadows its perfect.

[@kelseykmua]

The e.l.f. Hydrating camo concealer is the bane of my existence 😂 I have oily skin so it just melts off of me. But the OG formula is my FAVORITE concealer in the whole world!❤ Also I double down on the maybelline sky-high mascara in it being the worst ever 😂 but mostly because of the flexible wand. It gives no grip to the lashes and then I have to apply 5 clumpy coats in order for it to show up! But I LOVE the L'Oreal Lash Paradise!!❤❤

[@parisinthe30sx]

Magic cream broke me out bad. Fragrance in makeup/skincare whyyyyy! It does nothing good for your skin, usually the reverse

[@korikuulei]

I REALLY don't like the elf concler, I've tried it a couple of times, but always creases on me, and doesn't feel that great.

[@sandijsmith8295]

What a fun video! I could have written this list of products myself, I agree with almost all that were chosen. “oh, that sounds awful, let’s apply it” was hilarious!

[@fionadarragh1004]

Hi Allie ❤, Your make-up looks good in this video 🥰.

[@GlowITG]

Product I’d never buy again: The Glowish by Huda Beauty skin tint. This product is so shiny and metallic it’s more like the Elf Halo Glow or Charlotte Tilbury Flawless Filter. I wanted a skin tint, not a glowy primer or highlighter. Maybe they could market it differently.

[@PatriciaMonahan]

If I don't like something on me that I loved the look of on someone else, it's usually because the shade in person is way too WARM for me compared to the YT, Insta look, and isn't flattering. I'm always on the lookout for truly cool lip colors, eye shadows, and blushes.

[@jennifermolina4396]

Start off with the most controversial eyeshadows…. I don’t think there is anything special about Pat McGrath eyeshadows. I owned a pallet and think it’s way over priced and I had a lot of fallout when I used them. I think the perfect eyeshadow amount is 6-9 shadows. That’s why I love the Colourpop 9 pans. I can’t do the Elf Halo Glow Liquid Filter. It makes me super shiny and I just can’t do it. But I understand that it works for so many people. Just different preferences. And that’s the beauty of life, people don’t have to agree on anything! That’s what makes us individuals.