Buy this, NOT THAT: Cream Eyeshadows!

[@AmandaZ]

Hey Everyone!! I see a lot of comments asking about specific cream eyeshadows, so i decided to put together an entire playlist of my cream eyeshadow videos!! Here it is: kzbin.info/aero/PLvnjY_enbbxgm9kHpemsE--k06LwbTgS9 Still want to see a review/round up I don't have? Reply to this!!

[@hannahkenny502]

Round of applause for Amanda, who took one for the team by applying 20+ cream eyeshadows in one sitting, just so we don't waste our money on poor products.

[@xxInfiniteGasp]

Loved the "stole my heart vs. stole my money" --I audibly giggled.

[@corinovelli604]

Same!!!!!

[@reesereaves9257]

I’m still giggling 😆

[@proud2bnumber1]

Yess!!!

[@fatbottombiker3038]

So many of us can relate to that statement!

[@kroy2121]

Ba dum tiss 😂

[@nailinthefashion]

for those looking for more definition or with deeper skin tones than Amanda's wanting a natural matte cream eyeshadow, i propose looking at concealer ranges. i use pat mcgrath's in d23 or something like that, a deep reddish brown. it wears way better on my hooded lids than a matte with or without primer. rimmel & ulta's shade ranges are abysmal, but there are work arounds!

[@Updog89]

Smart tip! Thanks for sharing!

[@saracontesavieasmr]

You're THE queen of cream shadow, I wiil only listen to you when it comes to these kind of products ! I really want to try Oister Pearl from CT and the Dazzle Stick !

[@AmandaZ]

Thank you so much!! If you do, let me know what you think :)

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

Dazzle stick is amazing

[@carolineletellierdest-just8623]

@@AmandaZ Will you be trying the L.A. girl Dream glitter liquid shadows and the Lisa Eldridge liquid shadows? Thanks!😃❤️

[@rims.1196]

@@AmandaZ I bought a LOT of cream shadows because of your videos 😂😍 but I wish there were more affordable ones (less than $10) and available in Europe 😅 I know it's a lot to ask P. S. I Tried recently the Barry M euphoric ones and not bad at all in comparison with CT. And a LOT more affordable. The CT are the tops so far for me but too expensive to be able to get all the colours I wish for 🤣😅

[@evettetetu7900]

Could you do a video on the NYX Jumbo Stix?

[@janmarchand7294]

A thumbs up and real appreciation for you actually trying out the products and not just swatching them. I like to see the application and how they look on an actual face so thank you for that!

[@ANURIMA_BARDHAN]

Amanda you saying you have two drawers full of cream shadows just made my heart skip a beat... I can only imagine the heaven.. I am patiently waiting for the day you could do a full cream shadow collection!! 😍

[@tiradomaribel9436]

I started using the Ulta's matte cream eyeshadows thanks to you and I'm in love. I have the same shades best of the best. They are perfect on my dry mature hooded eyes. I learned how to wear a little ✨ on them strategically placed 💖. Thank you very much Amanda 💕.

[@lilg3514]

A) I love your intro music. B) I love when you do the closeups. You always look like you could be a model with your gamine look and beautiful skin. You have such delicate features and every time I watch your videos I think about how unique you are and sort of ethereal. :) Thanks for all the cream product videos. I’m just getting into them and have bought many of your suggestions. Just picked up the Ulta ones you always talk about as there was some sale plus $5 off so they ended up being three for $13! . Amazing!

[@lilg3514]

P.S. I think at this point I’ve decluttered ALL of my glitter liquid eyeshadows with doe foot applicators. It could be user error 🙈🤣 but I’m talking the glitter ones…they are either too lip gloss like or dry if pigmented, in my experience).

[@lilg3514]

One last thing…that Italian ice + Game Over made me think: “Yep! Game over!” At first was unassuming…then caught my reflection in another room mirror and was able to see how it shifts and how wet it looks. So very beautiful. Thanks!

[@Gorditavont33se]

I just ordered Milky Way during the Sephora sale and am SO glad I did! That formula is absolutely bulletproof. It lasted flawlessly all day-including through a 4 mile run in the Seattle rain. Can’t WAIT to collect more shades. Anyone reading this with oily eyelids…RUN, don’t walk!

[@twentyone177]

What brand is Milky Way from!? 🤗

[@Gorditavont33se]

@@twentyone177 it’s from Danessa Myricks.

[@PlatinumCyGirl]

Thanks for sharing ❤ I have oily lids too

[@XxMetalMoMxX]

I absolutely love how you went into the inner corner of your eye! Looks phenomenal and awake.

[@saranpratt]

Thanks so much for your dedication to the application footage! Even for unpleasant products. It's so useful to see.

[@Updog89]

I appreciate that you offer so much information about the products and your reasoning for (dis)liking them. The hallmark of a truly great reviewer is someone who makes it easier for people with different tastes or needs than yours to decide if the product is worth trying.

[@kellkell-er6bv]

Totally appreciate this video. I can not stand having to fight with a shadow for mediocre results. Thanks for sharing and showing the examples.

[@traceymcgarry9466]

I would love to see your Colourpop supershock or pressed eyeshadow collection and swatches if possible ? Thank you

[@Junaida-j8p]

Hey girl, Amanda. If you get a chance please review the new cream shadows from Lisa Eldridge.

[@dtsotm]

i was so ready to buy the jones road liquid eyeshadow, soo glad i watched this video!

[@tori.shalee]

Thank you for talking about these brands! I've been wondering about the 3INA, Eyeko, and Jones Road but now I know they're not what I'm looking for 🙏🏼

[@nancyelfar7401]

I’m glad you mentioned some recommendations for dry eyelids!

[@chickflickangel]

Hey Amanda, fun little fact I learned in a Wayne Goss video (his CT setting spray review video), he mentions that Charlotte Tilbury was behind the Tom Ford products! Which may explain CT Oyster Pearl and TF Platinum's similarity!

[@sandyvandy6483]

Interesting! I love TF creams and hate CT. They perform so differently on my eyes.

[@janerochfort2134]

👌 wow....bravo lady....I have only just found you....you certainly know your cream eyeshadows....now I have been using cream eyeshadows since I discovered TRINNY LONDON.....absolutely amazing...I am sure you can get it in the US....all her make up is fabulous...the one product I couldn't live without is her BFF face cream ( I suppose you would call it a tint ) it has a sunscreen also....you must look her up great videos on utube....I haven't tried her glitzy eyeshadows as I don't go out in the evenings...the other reason I'm a big fan is I am in my sixties...I wished all women over say 50 would try cream eyeshadows much more flatteringas one ages....I do hope you read this and try my recommendation....Trinny London...she is also a fashion guru and mad as a box of frogs....🤣🤣🤣...my very best wishes and a happy Christmas from Jane Rochfort...North Wales...UK...x

[@SerenityChaos1975]

The Morphe 2 Jelly Eye Shimmer pots are good, they are a gel formula and set for a long lasting finish, they are more of a topper but perform well and can be built up although I have only used them as a thin layer.

[@billiecomeaux]

I have recently had to switch over to (almost) all cream makeup products, and I love the RMS Eyelights and the Phytosurgence cream eyeshadows! I also enjoy E.L.F.'s liquid metallic eyeshadows, and the no budge eyesticks and cream shadows, and the Moira cream shadows all make excellent eye bases for my mature, dry, sensitive skin.

[@penny-joshelton6554]

I can’t believe you posted this! I was just watching your 6 month old video cream shadow video yesterday!

[@lilyrudy5679]

The bad ones were.....omf - I really appreciate that you put those on. It definitely drives home your point

[@Khaleesi_Of_Kittens]

Also, the Super Shock shadows in the shades Ladybird and Sailor are stunning, as well. Especially for the "wet" look on the lids.

[@ZZgem]

I’m curious about auric and Victoria Beckham in this comparison round up. I have oily sensitive lids which makes eyeshadow and liner very difficult so I immensely appreciate the detailed comparisons!!

[@lindseyandsarah]

Auric is hands down the best I’ve used…I’m not great with cream shadow (the CT doesn’t work great for me) and Auric is freaking foolproof. I can’t screw it up!

[@kohk79]

Skip the CT, they crease like there’s no tomorrow!

[@stellafe866]

The key is a good primer! I use the Urban Decay original primer and set it with powder or a lighter eyeshadow. Afterwards you can use all of the cream shadows you want to use without creasing. You have to start with a little bit of product and build it up than. I personally have very oily eyelids and cannot even wear normal eyeshadow without primer. I use this combination of primer, light shadow and one of my favorite formulas is the Charlotte Tilbury. Ladies we cannot compare our eyes to those who’s eyes aren’t oily. If you want those things to work you have to help your eyelids a little bit. Work with your oily eyelids not against them :-)

[@ZZgem]

@@stellafe866 thanks. I always forget to prime! Or get lazy 😊. Ud primer burns my eyes. I have some from Erin’s faces that I’ll pull back out and test.

[@lorijones9579]

You've persuaded me with cream eyeshadows. I love how easy they are, how they set up and last forever, and how easily one and done they are. I'm glad I don't have that many shadow palettes, because I'm not reaching for them.

[@tinapolanco134]

Thanks Amanda for the swatches and closeups. So helpful! ❤️

[@Daisy_dayzie]

I would love for you to try and see how you like the Smashbox always on cream eye shadows

[@hannahjane8275]

the charlotte tilbury eyes to mesmerize… are probably one of my top three products, ever. they’re just a beautiful formula, comfortable and easy, i love that they’re a sheen, satin to metallic cream in a pot. i’m not a fan of liquid shadows, even more so i dislike cream/liquid shadows that are in a tube or have a doe foot application. i’d love to see more potted formulas. i strongly desire to try out the auric shadows, and have my eye on the phytosurgence ones as well. i’d own all the charlotte tilbury’s ones if i could and it wasn’t a waste. the ones i have are oyster pearl, copper sunrise, and walk of no shame. really want amber gold, and for rose sunset to return. purchased the pillow talk one for my mother for christmas as she only wears pink eyeshadow and on a daily basis, i hope she enjoys it as much as i do,

[@Oi_li]

Luv the green background😍💚

[@nonone347]

I love “ that’s not that” could you do one about blush please?

[@gypsysnickerdoodle4354]

I LOVE the Armani Eyes to Mesmerize formula: STUNNING & smooooooth

[@PlatinumCyGirl]

Thanks so much ❤I love those recs for sure. I have oily lids and love that wet look too. Good to know which ones look great 😃

[@TheClairelikescats]

Another more affordable gem I recently discovered is the Sephora brand Colorful Shadow & Liner stick. I have the shade brown copper and it makes my green/hazel eyes pop 😍

[@atadlish]

Totally agree with those who appreciate GREATLY that you swatched these on your eyes (oy, that must've required big hydration afterwards), so we can see exactly the pros and cons you mention. Lovely channel Amanda, new subscriber!🤩🙏🌺❤

[@sevenoctobers7471]

This is valuable content -- always interesting to know which formulas don't work for you because hey, it's highly possible that it wont work for me. And you know the shit out of cream shadow formulas so I really trust your opinion 👌

[@nancycohen3968]

I LOVE DYNESSA MYRICK SHADOWS

[@KeepBeautyReal1]

I was applying a dazzle stick as I started watching this video! Thanks for giving us a list of what to pass on. ❤️

[@makeupminx6103]

When all of the eyeshadows, even the bad ones, look amazing in Amanda 😭

[@ColorfulGlueStick]

Maybelline used to have a line of their Color Tattoo pot eyeshadows called "Leathers" and Creamy Beige was my favorite. I still try to hunt it down on ebay or Mercari lol I also really like the finger foil eyeshadows from Tarte - those are so underrated and they have amazing color payoff.

[@patriciamays8873]

Amazon has the Maybelline cream to powder shadows. Color selection varies. Prices unbelievably low. Like much less than a Walmart. I have worn only cream to powder shadows most my life. I love those Maybelline pots!

[@karlakramer6490]

Thank you!! Love the why you like it versus expectations, vs who it might work for, etc. And thank you for speaking to the longevity too!

[@anniepursel3716]

Omg I'm new to your channel and I love it!!! No one talks about cream eyeshadow and it makes me so happy

[@elisasanchezcorrea9739]

Are you planning on trying the new liquid eyeshadows from Lisa Eldridge? I'm really looking forward to your review of those!

[@heathermargison-hillyer6531]

Love your recommendations! Thank you! Also I love your voice. It’s quite soothing. 😀

[@digestiblelantern]

I wonder if the holika holika shadow is meant to be applied in a more "korean makeup" type way where it's not used all over the lid and more as a glitter topped pressed into the center and/or below the eyes, because korean shadows with chunkier glitters are usually used that way !

[@WriterSnider]

I love your videos! I’d love to see one on your favorite brushes and favorite bases for cream eyeshadows. Thanks!

[@albita7574]

Thank you Amanda for all your videos about Cream Shadow they are my favorite.

[@greenlean8890]

I so appreciate your recommendations, I've tried and loved many of them! I really wish I could get the Ulta Matte Cream Eyeshadows that you often rave about (the colours are gorgeous), but unfortunately Ulta doesn't ship to Canada 😭

[@BeeGeeTee]

This was sooo great! Thank you for the indepth reviews

[@RosaBlancaFdez]

3ina recently released a line of eyedhadow sticks! Swatches them and they seem promising

[@alicegoldenvalley]

I love these videos!! I wish we had colorpop and ulta in Europe!

[@aura3337]

Sydney Grace also makes some amazing cream shadows!

[@JaimieAppleton]

Have you tried the Shiseido single shadows? I think you may like them. Super intersting texture.

[@braevelystudy8481]

Amanda, you should get the Sephora single eyeshadow in the metal effect formula for the sale (it’s 30% of Sephora collection). They’re all beautiful but i think you’ll specifically enjoy Shock choc and Fantasia

[@penelopefongers2384]

Totally helpful. Thanks for showing us how they look on dry eyelids.

[@evelynesparza9477]

I just bought CT star gold and TF platinum. I want them all😩 I own the CT oyster pearl and it’s stunning. Sometimes it’s better to buy quality eyeshadow that you can wear non stop. Honestly Tom ford and Charlotte tilbury never disappoint when it comes to eyeshadow. I know it’s expensive but for me I will continue to buy their eyeshadow because they look beautiful on the lid

[@leanneharrison5750]

I have watched a ton of your cream eye shadow videos and I never get sick of them ❤

[@paulamorris7466]

The CT shade in oyster pearl is so beautiful!!

[@erinnswan7063]

Have you seen Lisa Eldridge Lurex shadows. I hope you can do a review. These look wet and glorious. You must watch her video.

[@Dawn_______]

I bought the Ulta beauty matte cream eye shadow on your previous recommendation. I absolutely love it. Thank you. Thank you. It exceeded my expectations.

[@BleuMeow]

I recently found your channel and really enjoyed watching all your videos w/cream shadows. I grabbed Laura Mercier and Bobbi Brown mini cream sticks during the Sephora sale and I absolutely LOVE them. I also got few Sephora liquid shadows and they're pretty good. Thank you so much for the videos and introducing me to the world of cream shadows!

[@AS-qk5ii]

Those are my two faves too!

[@AbrilRamirez]

Amanda! You are my go to girl for everything cream! Thank you for your in depth reviews! All your recommendations are 10/10! 😊

[@natalies7813]

Amanda, you NEED NEED NEED to try the decorte eyeshadows!

[@chickflickangel]

Woop loving all these uploads!! 💖

[@vanigatla2045]

Thanks amenda for swatches and close-up eyeshadows...i like single eyeshadows cery much ...after watching ur video got TF eyeshadow and mac eyeshadow...❤❤

[@chebeatus]

Hi Amanda! Are you going to try the new Lisa Eldridge liquid lurex shadows? I’m curious how they perform, and I love your reviews

[@kzl217]

You must try the Vesca cream eyeshadows. They’re divine as well!

[@notjustirene4302]

I have super oily eyelids and I use the 3ina cream pots as primers because they just don’t budge! I don’t like them very much on their own either but it makes any shadow on top bullet proof.

[@AmandaZ]

yes!! I imagine this would work well for that

[@beckyshaknovich7554]

Love you, Amanda! 💕

[@celestialbr0nze]

hmm I just ordered the glossier skywash in pool and I’m having second thoughts now…hopefully I’ll like it

[@AmandaZ]

I hope you do too!!

[@BrookeInProgress]

It looks like some shades of the Brilliant Eyes definitely work better than others! I own Amber Sparkle, Bronze Light & Diamond Drop and they're all gorgeous and pretty easy to work with. Royal Onyx looks like a tricky shade, though!

[@rebeccahegewald9170]

You NEED to get the Wander beauty double date cream shadow and glitter topper in smitten and swoon. The cream is absolutely perfect!! And the topper makes it that much better. I highly recommend it to you I think you’ll love it!! Blame me if you don’t! Haha

[@yanalysenko139]

Thank you for the foort filming demos! Very helpful and I like listening to you a lot as well as hearing your recommendations. Could you please do a video on favorite stick foundations?

[@nausikaaleukolenos]

Amanda, have you tried the Kiko cream eyeshadows (the ones that come in a pot, not the sticks)?

[@kellywatts6227]

Thank you Amanda so so helpful, love your channel and cream products ❤ watching from Australia and I appreciate all your efforts so much Happy Holidays😘🥳

[@IonaReads]

I would be interested in seeing a review from you on the new Lisa Eldridge liquid eyeshadows and finding out how their formula compares to others in your collection

[@AmandaZ]

coming soon ;)

[@maryclebeau]

Awesome video!😊

[@jonah9516]

Thoughts on eyeshadow gels or jelly pots and the likes ? Also, would love a k beauty version of this😘😍

[@sasseeSAMurai]

i clicked on this video bc the dark background is gorgeous.

[@JBSouls]

Aw, the last ones from Ultra look amazing - I’m a little sad that I don’t have access to them (I’m not from the US).

[@Oranaiche1]

I was literally just watching one of your older videos and thinking about how I miss your old “I’m tolerable” tagline as I saw this video pop up. 😂 Had to pause to watch this one because of course I need more cream shadows (as I sit here unboxing my most recent Sephora haul 🙄).

[@jessicalawrence3074]

Please do a full Jones Road Beauty review!

[@nataliemammitzsch4369]

What would you suggest for more mature, sunken in, very dry eyes? I have the Charlotte tilbury oyster perl but it make my eyes look even more sunken :( I have deep set blue/ grey eyes, with blond hair and light skin 🙏

[@yinok7misu]

Hi Amanda. Have you tried Ilia eye tints? Thanks. Great video 🤗

[@tinkerbell8661]

What are you wearing on your eyes in this video? It looks so nice!!

[@belindah6554]

Wearing the KVD Flashstorm today based on your recommendation! Love the Rimmel too, spiced petal shade is also a fave of mine. Going to check out the Danessa Myricks also as I'm looking for more matte shades & can't access the Ulta ones in AUS ❤ Would love to see a K/J beauty version options, appears to be their forte.

[@pchen88]

Wish I got a hold of the KVD dazzle stick when they were available at Ulta. There's only 2 shades available now when they used to carry most of the shades.

[@Ghost-iv9os]

Amanda, what’s the music in your intro? I love it so much!

[@AmandaZ]

les Joies Ephemeres :)

[@dianevitale1214]

me too. Feel it is the perfect intro for Amanda,

[@Khaleesi_Of_Kittens]

Hey Amanda, great video! Have you tried any other shades of the Loreal Brilliant Eyes liquid shadows? I'm 46 and I absolutely have textured lids...There are some beautiful shades that work great for me. I think you chose a dud shade. Amethyst Quartz, Diamond Drop and Amber Sparkle are lovely. I love to mix Diamond Drop and Amber Sparkle on the back of my hand and then apply the mixture! (Got that idea from Shelbey Wilson) Makes a gorgeous sparkley lid.

[@janeyhughes4148]

Can you create some videos dedicated to eyeshadow application technique and creating the shape you have with your eye makeup??? 🙏🏻

[@arascab2505]

I love the forever eye shadow GOSH COPHENAGE, very recommend!

[@angelinatan7790]

Would you consider trying Korean liquid glitter shadows? They’re quite popular so I’d imagine the formula is a bit better, colourgram makes some well loved ones :)

[@AmandaZ]

this has been on my mind!!

[@kelxox55]

Dying to try the violette_fr cream eyeshadows.

[@melissatdo]

Where did you get your green sweater? It's so lovely 😍💕

[@Brabelbla]

Any recommendations on brushes to use with cream eyeshadows? I really want to get a CT eyes to mesmerize but I'm not sure if i want to dip my finger into the pot everytime!

[@Djk8263]

Absolutely love colourpop super shock shadows. Muse is divine! Love Revlon colorstay shadow pots too…emerald is a great alternative to the emerald you tried. And to be honest, I bought some of Amazon to try. Luxana, 6 for $14.99. Pair with a base of ultas cream shadow (per your recommendation), they ended up working really well. Not so much without that base though. The colors I’m currently into are 004 melted-caramel and 003 flowing-chocolate. Great for someone looking for new colors and on a budget!

[@Djk8263]

*Luxaza

[@ParisSunset]

Hail Storm by KVD is also gorgeous.