Americans VS. Koreans - High Belt Notes Singers | REACTION

[@angelatolai4935]

Why would you assume the Korean singers are altered? yes reverb but everyone uses reverb, doesn’t mean its altering to hit notes 🙄

[@AnimeMovement]

Korean shows do edit a lot, to be fair.

[@iworshipgaysandsatan6822]

AsianMusicSubs as does every singer. It’s not exclusive to Korean shows, you just notice it more and so it seems like it’s more prevalent with them

[@AnimeMovement]

@@iworshipgaysandsatan6822 It's definitely more prevalent for Koreans in this video, which is why it got noticed.

[@AmiAki]

Because the Koreans definitely sounds less natural to the American singers. It’s fucking clear in this video. The Americans high notes sound more raw but let’s praise the korean singers with the modified mics. Make it make sense.

[@namis6925]

@@AmiAki okay but some of them actually got the notes?

[@a4235]

honestly it makes me sad how fast yalls expressions change from smiling to not whenever it changes from americans to Koreans,, is it that hard to believe that anyone who lives outside of america actually can sing and can have just as amazing voices or even better than some artists in America?

[@eiryves8554]

They're smiling out of recognition, as they're the only artists they ACTUALLY fully know. Please don't leave such presumptuous comments.

[@arydira7610]

Yeah they think only American artist can sing, hate this reaction

[@hannahuwu4499]

Alegriaa they literally said they don’t trust that the korean singers could sing so well, it wasn’t a presumptuous comment..

[@eiryves8554]

It's called inexperience. something you've never heard of before, it's easy to not believe, right?

[@hannahuwu4499]

Alegriaa there’s a difference between “wow that’s so good, I can’t believe it” and “i don’t trust the korean clips it’s lip sync or modified”

[@sayj1556]

You know Koreans train for years with professional coaches they can train for 2 or 6+ years you guys should have done you're research ....😒

[@mxrio-kun8107]

Wow, that´s why their vocals sounds robotic sometimes? No. Those tv shows in Korea had been dubbing k-pop singers performances for a long time.

[@notmyname3556]

@@mxrio-kun8107 it's not hard to find fancams of kpop these days. why don't you judge it from there?

[@mxrio-kun8107]

​@@notmyname3556 But darling i´m talking about some clips of the video. There are some that are dubbed/modiffied.

[@notmyname3556]

@@mxrio-kun8107 well, are those the only time they performed? The video used the audio edited ones, why not used the raw fancam to judge? Isn't that how analysing works? Not biased nor half-assed? The whole argument in the comment section talk about how Korean singers aren't even that good because they 'practiced' editing. So why not use and find the fancams like american singers' clips?

[@mxrio-kun8107]

@@notmyname3556 did i said that? No. I said that some korean clips on this video are edited. I know that some of the singers here can sing but we can´t deny that some clips are dubbed.

[@yerhighnessqueen5535]

You can already tell these two already started this video with prejudice.

[@dosunum6118]

Yes. And they still making the reaction to kpop videos as it popular now. Yet they still didnt believe what they watch.

[@양재혁-q2y]

Yer Moua Here here,,

[@guidaecho4861]

True

[@eduardgherasim2896]

They are Americans, they tend to come with prejudice.

[@iworshipgaysandsatan6822]

Yerhighness Queen yeah it’s obvious from how they react to Koreans that they have a bias towards Americans/Phillipinos

[@dilaylad1903]

Funny how you doubt the recording and quickly say that the only way those korean singers can do it is because they must've done something to the mic, and yet you never doubt the american artists's singing abilities... smh. Do you realize that people CAN sing in other countries? America isn't the center of the world...

[@malikaphal1769]

@@myopinion6748 that's just racist

[@jasperj483]

Euphoria how is that racist?😂

[@calebstephan2083]

@@jasperj483 his suggesting that no other race can sing except for Americans. That's kinda racist.

[@jasperj483]

Caleb Stephan i thought that he was replying to the first comment, but the second comment is racist.

[@kaaamipaws2289]

That's so true... I got a little pissed watching this

[@wredgefunky]

Most koreans singers are actually trained that's why they sound like that. their voices aren't strained (most of them) and are very resonant.

[@dodolgarpet]

Smh, people should do some research before about the difference between autotune and reverb. The Koreans DID NOT used autotune on live performance, but they did put reverbs on the microphone. Reverbs don't fix bad technique, it didn't make-up your incorrect pitch, it's not masking your strains whatsoever, unlike autotune. Reverbs are only used to make you sound somewhat "larger" and has that kind of a ringing slightly echo-y quality. If you understand vocal pedagogy, you'll see that singers with bad technique still didn't sound good even with reverbs.

[@jcxga]

LOL the funny thing is, when KZ used autotune in Singer 2018, they all lose their shit and posted "it's wasn't autotune, it was reverb" 😂😂😂 Can't even tell what's reverb and what's autotune LMAO!!

[@baddest12345]

But still it enhance their vocal thingy as you said. It is cleaner.

[@baddest12345]

jcxga because you can clearly see and hear she is using that thing while in those korean clip you can't. Some people will assume that they are better because of that. They are faking their ringy or resonance and hiding some strain.

[@dodolgarpet]

@@baddest12345 Nope, I didn't say it was cleaner. I only said it was larger with echo-y quality. And also, I can still very much hear all the strains from some of those so no, reverbs don't hide strains from people with good ear.

[@jcxga]

@@baddest12345 LOL WHAT? 😂🤣The only thing autotune changes is *pitch,* as in *frequency in hertz.* Autotune can't hide strain or modify resonance. 😂🤣

[@JakeReeves001]

Americans use just as much reverb in their performances....

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith you’re so ignorant and obviously have not done proper research before making those stupid claims Sohyang, Son Seungyeon, Ailee, Lee Haeri, Lee Younghyun have plenty of amazing acapella moments with no mics look up Son Seungyeon singing let it go from frozen with no mic and here she does a vocal warm up with no mic and sounds just as powerful kzbin.info/www/bejne/nqalg4NomMuDeJo Sohyang also has demonstrated this in many interviews as well as the others do some research before making this outlandish claims

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith Ariana has a thin weak voice and she’s considered the best American vocalist right now Whitney Houston in her prime was amAzing but she was one of a kind.......

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith you’re so stupid and ignorant did you even bother to watch the videos??

[@jcxga]

@Jec Smith Untrained, questionable support, strain, technical mess. Can please untrained ears, never critics. Delusional, uninformed, bias subjective opinion doesn't mean shit! 🤣🤣🤣

[@jcxga]

@Jec Smith LOL! Fear? Try SHAMELESS LMAO! 🤣🤣🤣 ALICIA KEYS doesn't have good techniques either LOL. It's nothing but bad singers dueting bad singers LOL! Straining Fiesta! 🤣🤣 With Celine, the contrast is even more ridiculously easy to spot. LMAO!!!! But, I guess your poor ass ears can't differentiate proper technique of Celine vs that has been Charice or Jake or maybe Charice again in the future who knows LOL! Simple search of Patti Austin gave me ... The Voice of the Philippines. What's that logic of speaking roses about the people you work with again? 🤣 She ain't no legendary status either. She ain't the technical master level of Aretha or Patti or Streisand. THE TRUE LEGENDS! The STAR RATED vocalists.

[@Caramelletje]

The fact that they sound like that is because they're generally better singers than Americans. Almost every mic has reverb these days. Americans are all about that autotune though. These Korean singers are the best ones in Korea, that's why they are so amazing!

[@simon_a.j.7255]

Quit being a delusional "koreaboo" -- no one in Korea can match the vocal talent/power of Ariana, Christina, Mariah, etc. Not even the overrated Sohyang and ailee -- but even ailee is an American!!!

[@prodigous21]

That is such a stupid statement, were talking about actual singers in America not the ones who use autotune. Just because some do doesnt many everyone in America does.

[@jamiesilver7401]

There are very few good famous singers in America now, cause what the majority of people in America care about are trashy rap songs.

[@Nicole-db2ub]

Simon A.J. maybe you should educate yourself on what a koreaboo is first before spitting out that word

[@esther6664]

@@simon_a.j.7255 Sorry but So hyang by herself just end them all XD

[@christiananaya7299]

y'all are haters. you guys hear something good and say that it's modified. wth

[@Zachzn4lf]

I mean the mics I'm those shows are modified but not with autotune. Lets to lie to ourselves

[@imjustsuperiorrr]

there are always effects and some post production on those singing show mics tho.

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

Actually, Sohyang sounds worse in these tv shows compare to listening her live which is incredible. I've listened to her singing "You Raise. Me Up" in IMS2 performance and believed that she isn't a human. However, yes, these korean shows do add some reverbs but not too much modification which this also applies to American as well. This technology was been around for decades and there are American clips that do add reverbs and modification as well. I believe a singer you mentioned would be Son Seung Young, but this may be my guess.

[@brenomagalhaes7891]

There's actually a big difference between korean singers and korean idols. In fact, when we talk about idols performances, groups, solos... Those who don't just sing, but dance and etc, they really tend to use auto-tune, or pre-recorded audios, because it's actually difficult to sing, dance, jump, look to the camera... That's why even koreans says that idols and korean singers are actually different. When it comes to competitions like Immortal Songs, King of Masked Singer... They don't use these kind of things, it's really live. You can search every korean singer that appeared in this video (Park Ki Young, Ali, Ailee, Sohyang...) and see that they sing exactly the same way in others shows.

[@한지훈-h4b]

I agree... i mean even Bada's voice has always been like that ^_^

[@ultrakill40]

You can see bada the most stable idol singer i have meet she sing will wild dancing in immortal song 2 and perfect voice...

[@thaisyamamoto6032]

Not only on shows, but also in lives or their YT channel. Solar and Eunji, for example, they didn't use autotune when cover some songs on their channels.

[@melaniaarce8226]

Yes.. and also they were many idols who participated on Immortal Song or Masked Singer they sing completely live.

[@alvinalson6966]

7:10 that lady is park ki young, Sohyang Best Friend is I am not wrong. Anyway all those Korean clips inside is from Immortal song, Korean TOP music competition, which no lip sync, no autotune, or any alternation allowed. 500 audience will be the judges, and Shane filan (west life) and Michael Bolton was invited at there when Sohyang sang "you raise me up" and "lean on me".

[@wen.d4157]

I'm so done with this video smh. Y'all should do some research. There's many countries and places that can sing way better than america. America just has the topically basic voice not gonna lie. Don't be so closed minded and maybe react to some kpop groups or solos.

[@고양이-c6j]

@Estela Lopez Yes

[@j2kay93]

and not all american singers are bad* lets not drop down as low as these two please.

[@valscottage]

@Estela Lopez not every American is Michael Jackson

[@AnimeMovement]

Lol American singers are largely the standard. Deal with it.

[@joshuachristiankatuuk7829]

philippines and indonesian say hello 👋

[@Shelby-tt4tv]

Y'all should stop reacting to high notes since all you'll do is say that it's lipsynced,modified and etc. Just like dimash's sinful passion last time.

[@MA-ko6bf]

Hehe, I remember that video. I mean, just because Dimash can hold his breath for quite a long time doesn't mean he's lip-syncing. Literally lost an ounce of respect for them that day.

[@reysal3347]

Thanks to this comment I discovered a great singer with an *AMAZING* voice😍 I mean I read your comment and checked him on KZbin and ... WOW! His voice... So thank you😊

[@Zachzn4lf]

@@MA-ko6bf they didn't say it was lip synced... They said it was modifying. Whether thats reverb or autotune.

[@MA-ko6bf]

@@Zachzn4lf If I'm recalling correctly i'm pretty sure they said he was lip-syncing in sinful passion.

[@Zachzn4lf]

@@MA-ko6bf if that's correct then yeah they are just wrong

[@nevermindiana]

not at how your most "reasonable" excuse to discredit koreans -or basically anyone who's not american- it's because of "modified vocals" when it's america that breathes for autotune and lip syncing lmfao, but go off i guess💀💀💀

[@sass_king5576]

KookMin No Na Wa u mad lol kpop singers all the sound the same lmao

[@appu5593]

You read my mind. I got so triggered watching this. Learn to listen to music without prejudice. Sheesh

[@hannastar]

Sass_King5 WHAT KPOP SINGERS ALL SOUND THE SAME, YOU SERIOUSLY NEED TO GET YOUR EARS CHECKED. WHAT KIND OF BULLSHIT ARE YOU SAYING!

[@milgramer]

tea, if american artists are so talented like people say i'd like to hear them not lip sing for once lmao

[@cloudykookie8660]

wow this is exactly what I was about to comment

[@gadmantandian6942]

Most of the perf from korean are from immortal song. A singing competition, but between well known singer there. There, autotune is like a cat deep in the sea breathing, no where to be found. Only reverb / whateva you call it. The perf sometimes got edited a little before broadcasted, but it's all live with no tuning whatsoeva.

[@gadmantandian6942]

@James Bond maybe, just maybe. 😂

[@MonkeyKong38]

Thanks for saying it, at least I don't have to post it my self. Like their reaction for all korean singers is "We can't trust this, it's so modified" but for the American Singers it's not modified at all, ahahah the bullshit is real. "those asian shows tend to modify" ahahah holy crap.

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

gadman tandian Recent American clips are also modified not just Koreans. Remember! These technology was ADDAPTED from US. At least Immortal songs are live but one of this clip from America was studio.

[@drewcurtis738]

Koreans singers are too nasal. They lack music artistry, plus they are a product of hd audio enhanced

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

Drew Curtis still much professional than karaoke Fillipino 😁

[@user-t3bg9c]

HAHAHAHAHA modified? lipsync? your saying is so funny as a Korean living in Korea lol You SHOULD just say "I am so surprised and shocked" and not doubt their ability until you know exactly. I think all of the Korean and American singers on this vid are best.

[@mohamadhusaini1974]

I love koreans more, especially SOHYANG

[@JakeReeves001]

Koreans are the best belters in the world!! How could you not know there’s at least 10 women that can be considered world class and Korea is about 100 times smaller than America. Notice how the American clips go back 50 years while Koreans are all recent....they’re culture and formal vocal training show how amazing they are

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith the USA has trash vocalists and I know this because I live here they all use auto tune and sound terrible live even the better singers.... and filipino’s strain and make my ears hurt.......

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith you’re so ignorant it’s almost laughable

[@jcxga]

@Jec Smith Audio engineers aren't gods. They can't make bad singers good. They can't hide shitty techniques either. The FX is like "put make up" but not "plastic surgery". Even in that analogy, plastic surgery is not "facial bone reconstruction. That's what's needed to turn an ugly person to become beautiful, not simple touchups of the usual plastic procedures or surgeries. A complete overhaul of the entire face from within. There are lots of audio engineers working on pinoy artists and shows. Ask them what audio engineers can and CAN'T do from pinoy audio engineers, or any audio engineer around the globe.

[@drewcurtis738]

are u serious? A lot of Korean singers lack vocal artistry and they are too nasal most especially So Hyang! Koreans are great in Kpop but they cannot produce a great singers/divas

[@drewcurtis738]

I am not a Filipino, let's stop denying because everybody knows from all over the world, Filipinos are beast in singing and have the best singers in asia and one of the beast in the world, they produced a lot of good singers and belters too while Korea are only known for their kpop but sadly cannot produce great singers and belters, at least they excel in kpop thing wc is also commendable

[@bonskyu6616]

Wait wait wait waittttt..... So what if the koreans have some kind of reverbs? Atleast they don't use autotune for every concert they have like US

[@simon_a.j.7255]

US singers rarely ever use autotune anymore -- this is not the 1990s Britney spears era ....while kpop have used it alot in recent years

[@pennybleta2300]

@@simon_a.j.7255 I don't care about other Koreans my faves don't they are live all the time Here this is for you m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5vIqqqhjJqYl68

[@nguyenthanhha860]

yes. All the general Performance of Koreans artist is use Playback. Don't belive ? It's up to you.

[@nguyenthanhha860]

It's live but it's not singing.

[@pennybleta2300]

@@nguyenthanhha860 Watch the video I posted it answers your bullcrap but if you want more Suga can give it to you here m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnO1pIyIdrSAY8k

[@jennyarriola4107]

To those who said that Koreans lip-sync and use auto-tune all the time, maybe you ought to watch their performances on YHY's Sketchbook where lip-synching is not allowed. And there's plenty of concert videos on KZbin where anybody with a working set of ears can tell whether it's live or not.

[@신인혜-c1f]

Almost korean singer's song in that video is from one of the survival programs '불후의 명곡'. In the program all singer sing real

[@gersonryansumampong3125]

Asians really have the tendency to sing higher because the placement they speak in their native language are higher than the usual placement for most people. The language has certain tones and phonetics that vary belting styles. Anyways, singing higher doesn't mean singing good. It's always a matter of preference.

[@honeybee_241]

Gerson Ryan Sumampong I’m a bit curious, there are tons of countries and tons of languages in Asia, and they all have higher placement?

[@gersonryansumampong3125]

Honey Bee Not all. Some countries in Asia have lower placement like Mongolia and India. Neutral placements are those coming from Southeast Asia. And higher placement are usually from the East Asians. P.S. This does not discredit their singing ability and the potential to sing "outside" of their speaking placement. Yet this only shows how placement varies through the language spoken.

[@honeybee_241]

Gerson Ryan Sumampong I understand you have no intention of discrediting their singing abilities 😁, I was just intrigued with the speacking placement of asian countries. Thanks for the reply

[@withshoonah]

"I didn't even know that koreans belted" lol K. So much ignorance and salt y'all need to brush off ya shoulders. There's a difference between a singer and an artist. Respecting your opinions. Just get your facts straight next time. 😉

[@Xiatic-nim]

You guys are so damn consistent on claiming that everything is modified (like duh, nothing is perfect). Don't listen to anything other than English again. *Do us all that favor* You already messed up when you questioned Dimash.

[@nikalsson]

One of the best korean singers in the video is Son Seung Yeon. She is quite young but already very famous. Her singing is influenced by SoHyang. You could find some similarities in the way she sings. However SoHyang style in more unique - epic, divine and her songs are not commercial. You are correct. Belting in Korea was /is/ dominated by SoHyang but now there are more new singers such as Son Seung Yeon. The impressive Korean female singer is Park Kiyoung. She is very talented and she is in fact a very good friend of SoHyang. She can sing not only pop but opera as well. Most probably the best Korean female singers vocally are exactly SoHyang, Son Seung Yeon, Park Kiyoung and Ailee.

[@carlosroberto3168]

I LOVE YOUR COMENT, THANK YOU !!!!

[@m.ashraf3341]

well its ur opinion but i prefer son seung yeon more than sohyang...so...............................

[@riosaveroo]

What about davichi's lee haeri?

[@drewcurtis738]

so hyang is so nasal. She also lacks vocal artistry!

[@nikalsson]

if you have already watched all vocal analysis by vocal coaches and vocal teachers on youtube you should know that Sohyang is one of the best vocalists in the world. These people are much more knowledgeable than you and their opinion is worth million times more than just an useless hater on youtube. Even in Music Game News' reaction videos you can see their opinion about Sohyang. You are just nobody, a useless hater who can't change anyting and nobody give a shit about your opinion.

[@julesphi777]

For your information, 5:49 was not a performance. It was an improv. The MC asked so she just stood up and sang. That’s why she belted a bit too long at the end there. Y’all just made yourself look like dumb dumbs with the comment of how Korean sounds edited right at that minute lol

[@rosylinpar5171]

Koreans are just great singers!! Just because they can sing so well doesn’t mean their voices are modified!! They trained for it for many many years. Don’t assume and judge with prejudice.

[@IvyJames-ru4vj]

That’s not why they said the American one sounds more clear

[@baalu7073]

7:14 this is Park KiYoung. And she is sooooo underrated

[@ashgillani5215]

O god thank you

[@Ari-kt2tu]

I am disappointed to see how their expressions change when they see someone of their own nationality sing. I mean, when they listened to an incredibly good voice from Korea it was like ... "oh * pretend interest * this is good ...? ..." instead you could tell kilometers your expression of "pride" when you heard a English voice and RECOGNIZED saying "ah yes, this is talent, it is the best !!" .... Please do not react to more Korean talents, no, in fact, do not react to anything outside your nationality. Because I think that not only with Korea would it be like that, with any other culture. It is sad to see people who react to great talents just because it is fashionable and not even give it a little appreciation, this should have more dislikes for their individualism.

[@jomnuel]

If Korean singer sing you guys said it modified lypsinc and etc Maybe you just stop reacting to high note and compared each other

[@MaitreRed]

So you guys don't say anything about So Hyang's Bb5 but all the other Korean singers such as Son Seung Yeon belting those F#5 or Bada belting those G#5 have their vocals modified ? The sound quality is exactly the same in all the clips. Just accept that Korean Singers can truly sing and have an overall better technique than American singers.

[@hakanai23]

It is modified... By extreme training & talent, sister!

[@loonytoonyful]

The fact that they were under the impression that Korean/Asian singers "discovered belting" is very telling of a lack of worldly comprehension.

[@blinkz191]

Just so people know Korean idols have to sing 100% percent live at comeback stage bc Korean are very strict on their musician and comeback stage like music programs must actually do singing live .they have healthy vocals so they do sometimes lip sync bc you don't always want to sing live bc that can damage your voice look at what happened to Mariah Carey voice were she stucks now at high noise to me bc something happened to vocal cord like her whistle register . And American also use a lot auto tune and also does Lip sync during stages even your favorites American artist can Lip sync as well and I know I have heard Justin Bieber use auto tune doing performance on video release on KZbin . Plus BTS always sings 100 % live and Korean boy group. Also Exo has song called lotto it very heavy use of auto tune but when watch them perform it live it sounds way better then the recorded song and sing it live. So what I'm saying not every artists use auto tone or modifications on mic that's just my opinion don't hate me for it.

[@ultrakill40]

Lol bts sing live lol..

[@justanotherhuman4068]

@@ultrakill40 Whats your problem? They sing 100% live! Whats so funny about that?

[@oscarhumphreys9029]

HeyHey nah... they’d probs say it’s all lip synced so there’s no point x

[@pennybleta2300]

@@ultrakill40 Yeah they do this video is dedicated to you enjoy m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5vIqqqhjJqYl68

[@antonino2229]

5:57 HAHAHAHAH OMG THAT’S HILARIOUS: that singer is BADA, the leader of the first girl kpop group and she’s one of the greatest vocalists in korea ever, that program was filmed in 2016, in that episode they asked her to sing a little part of the main song of her brand new musical so she did it, the original key of the song is lower but she raised it up and improvised, all this was did in a few seconds, how could they be able to set up autotune and that kind of stuff in a minute? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAJ (btw u are so good at ignoring comments, good job love u)

[@미혜-w3i]

Yes we have an obsession with perfection. As in, perfect TALENT. that's why our singers and girl/boygroup members often train 12+ hours a day.

[@dinairentta7756]

미혜 I’m proud to be Asian and I love kpop ☺️☺️☺️☺️

[@James-ve7ip]

Y'all smell that prejudice?

[@Boa.sira.]

I'm not from korea but as far as i followed them and knew their culture for years.... The solo artists which are not well known outside of korea are really good... And their voices are real because in a live performance they really sing well apart from the high quality of the voice. Koreans are perfectionist in terms of practice , they practice years and years before going pro. their voices are not altered..... Hope you'll discover them soon 👍

[@JakeReeves001]

Son Seungyeon is in the intro and the F#5 and I can confirm that she is just as amazing without reverb and she never uses auto tune ever

[@JakeReeves001]

Jec Smith you’re so stupid.... I’m an American but I recognize talent when I see it why don’t you do some research before spewing bullshit...... Son Seungyeon and all of these women have plenty of amazing acapella moments you mad????

[@jcxga]

@Jec Smith HAHAHA! Pinoy use all kind of shit in their performances too. If you think what you're hearing haven't been altered or enhanced in any way, then you are a delusional fool. But, we already know that.🤣🤣🤣

[@jcxga]

@Jec Smith Reverb, check. Echo, check, Autotune, check. All other effects in the audio engineer table, check. Only fucking idiots think pinoys don't use all those shits available to them. This is the modern era! Even third world countries recording artists use all kind of shits provided in the studio, and even LIVE! Anybody who thinks there are no audio engineers in Philippines are just fucking morons beyond delusional ROFL!!!! 🤣🤣🤣

[@jcxga]

LOL! Fear? Try SHAMELESS LMAO! 🤣🤣🤣 ALICIA KEYS doesn't have good techniques either LOL. It's nothing but bad singers dueting bad singers LOL! Straining Fiesta! 🤣🤣 With Celine, the contrast is even more ridiculously easy to spot. LMAO!!!! But, I guess your poor ass ears can't differentiate proper technique of Celine vs that has been Charice or Jake or maybe Charice again in the future who knows LOL! Simple search of Patti Austin gave me ... The Voice of the Philippines. What's that logic of speaking roses about the people you work with again? 🤣 She ain't no legendary status either. She ain't the technical master level of Aretha or Patti or Streisand. THE TRUE LEGENDS! The STAR RATED vocalists.

[@jcxga]

LMAO Grammy isn't a standard of vocal prowess FOOL! Britney Spears, Bruno Mars, Milli Vanilli were given grammy too LOLOLOL!!!! 🤣😂😂 There are TONS more crappy and even shittier "artists" too many to list here ROFL!

[@bluejazz9736]

The woman in black and white is barbara streisand guys

[@waynersmith9646]

blue jazz Barbra*

[@bluejazz9736]

Wayner Smith im sorry my friend my bad i stood corrected ladies and gentlemen it’s Barbra

[@bluejazz9736]

Wayner Smith sorry for not being perfect 😔

[@himikr1895]

I can see both countries have equally amazing singers. However a striking difference I noticed between the belts was that Americans prefer the usage of visibly dynamic and highly varying multi-compressions, while Koreans tend to hold on a single note with gradation during the entire stretch or more quick and less varying multi-compressions if they ever do so. Varying Multi-compressions are technically difficult to do when compared to holding on single kind of note. Yet this does not prove one's better than the other because ultimately one should be able to enjoy the music. It's only a matter of difference in technique. Indeed Loved both American and Korean singers.

[@kiokothecuddlyquailspud1389]

I can tell you for a fact Bada has one of the clearest voices I've ever heard! It's a consistent quality you'll hear in korean and japanese singers. They train so incredibly hard and for so long compared to american singers.

[@wilzenryanbolak2521]

When Korean singers sing so fucking well "nah, you can't trust this performance". But when Americans just fucking appear, they smile and then says "who else? "

[@sweetpunze25]

WTF?! All of those Korean live performances was LIVE 110%! Koreans are can built! Its their voice! You need to react to more korean Immortal Song performances! Its all about live performances 100%.

[@dellunzaga3067]

That Mariah doing many and jumping notes are so technically hard than hitting a single high note. Oh ghod!!!

[@princeclarke2010]

Ikr lol

[@GarageStudio7]

Exactly! ✨

[@yerimwon1995]

I don't think you know what you're talking about. "Jumping notes" isn't a technical term so I really don't think you would know if it's harder. I believe you mean phrasing, I guess? The difficult varies.

[@prodigous21]

@@yerimwon1995 you dont need to kbow the technical term to know that its harder.

[@yerimwon1995]

@@prodigous21 A person who doesn't even know what it's called won't know either way. It's a 50/50 shot.

[@bored4110]

Those Microphones aren’t modified they are genuine, natural singers.

[@dellunzaga3067]

Many Mariah Carey fans want you to react to If It's Over live in Grammys but i think you already did with the climax part.

[@nguyenthanhha860]

No, Because There's another Climax.

[@ilyemzz]

Three minutes in and im already done. Do yall think anyone outside of America cannot hit super high notes? All ive seen was yall smiling when americans appeared and then they faded when koreans appeared. Yall can take your hate and negative thoughts some where else. 🙃

[@Otokima12]

Sohyang one of the best singers ever !! 😉

[@drewcurtis738]

in nasality so hyang is the best!

[@jcxga]

Nasality isn't the same as nasal resonance or twang. Rather than explaining with words, faster to just witness Professor Sohyang's own demonstration: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZC5e4ucdsSNa5I

[@nguyenthanhha860]

@@jcxga she can't do Upper Belts without Nasality

[@Lenkunuwu]

@@nguyenthanhha860 its. not. nasality. its. called. twang.

[@nguyenthanhha860]

@@Lenkunuwu It's not the same?

[@TenYasha897]

I can tell 100% you did not do your research

[@treatpeoplewithkindness_1251]

Wow it amazes me how you guys are so easy to judge Koreans singing ability even though they train their vocals for years and then they debut unlike American artists who use autotune most of the time I am American but I love and prefer Koreans vocals voices more over Americans

[@canpfire]

When she asks,"My God who are these performers!?" It was the Unsong Hero herself, Park KiYoung who had just performed "Yeonan Pier." KiYoung is simply the best!

[@sssourwav]

Most of these Korean Singers were on either YHY SketchBook or Immortal Songs which are singing competitions where people go to prove their singing ability. They ARE NOT KPOP IDOLS and no the shows do not accept the use of auto-tune or any sort of mic modification as that results in immediate disqualification.

[@pranay.7649]

man the one u said "u can't trust these recordings " go check that video out then you'll realize you were wrong .

[@kimhyosik]

5:58 이거 심지어 ㅋㅋ 갑자기 나와서 즉흥적으로 노래부른거고 반주도 옆에서 피아노반주자가 맞춘거임 그리고 원래노래 키보다 높게부른거ㅋㅋ 제발~쫌~

[@caratstaytiny0097]

Some of these comments and the reaction to this video itself disappoint me. Korean singers work their asses of through years of training to have amazing vocals and yet they're being accused of auto tune or lip syncing. These singers are well known for their vocals and these shows are just like other American survival shows, talent shows or things like that. The vocals are all live. Plus, why accuse them of auto tune when we all know how many American singers use it. In no way am I saying these singer in the video are, they have amazing vocals themselves but don't go around saying these Korean singers do or that they don't try.

[@james-so8rz]

If Sohyang was used for all of the Korean examples E5 and up, Korean's would win lol

[@AnimeMovement]

Wrong.

[@shiningstar939]

Among the many singers in this video .... The only thing I can remember is the powerful high treble of Sohyang.

[@AnimeMovement]

Sad because there are better voices in this video.

[@theabusivechanteuse]

6.05 there wasn't any pitch correction or Smth like that . She so young as u can see. And her tone should be so rich and light. That G#5 was unsupported . She can't control that note. That's why it sounds so. Her larynx was so high. Just a bit and she will just scream that part. But she is truly insane. She has a great potential.

[@youssraelhourch2973]

Just so you can know there is no lipsyncing in kpop because the idols are chosen by their talent and they train a lot so you can't find a untalented idol

[@renzotorres475]

There was video where someone hit a c#5(i think) and the video said “it’s sounds like a c#6. The guy then said “ there is no way it could sound like two notes, it’s either a c#5 or c#6” and thats when I knew he didn’t know what he was talking about.

[@joyce1343]

Umm tad bit biased.. these are actually renowned singers in Korea so they can sing extremely well. Additionally they only really use reverb in their live performances so its not modified or autotuned. I believe others have explained what that is so please don't keep jumping to conclusions. In Korea using autotuned for professional singers is frowned upon immensely and if they were found to have use modification or a utotune in a live show their careers would be over.

[@nadiagarcia5439]

The first Korean woman is Son Seung Yeon. You guys seemed impressed every time she came up so you should react to her. She's one of the best in Korea.

[@mic-shellcrackson3800]

5:55 Bada who is in the first kpop girl group has that natural voice

[@hinatasharem3259]

Okay, yeah, there is a pretty high standard over in Korea. But by saying that you don't 'trust' them is really offensive. They are just as talented as American singers, yet you didn't say anything about the possibility of the Americans modifying THEIR voices. They work hard, and yet you guys think that it's not their voice.

[@artistaroundtheblock2047]

No guys relax I think I know why they act like this about Koreans.ITS BECAUSE THEY JUST SOUNF TOO PERFECT 👌🏽 OH WELL 😋

[@devonmuna4897]

i hate how u guys just keep saying they edited the recordings like,,, is it hard to believe that these are their ACTUAL voices and theyre just that talented

[@JJ-eu3oi]

손승연 오토튠 아닌데.. 원래 토닝 그런건데 ㅠㅠ 영어를 못하니 답답하다

[@한지훈-h4b]

괜찮아 ㅋㅋㅋ 알잖아... 한국 가수들이 오토튠을 사용하지 않은다.

[@dailylifeofanything399]

Song seung yun and all of those korean singers on that show do not use autotune. Its agianst strict restriction of the program itself and only rely on reverb if anything. Its so frustrating i cant speak a lick of english. 영어로 써드렷슴다

[@AnimeMovement]

@@dailylifeofanything399 The shows are still pitch corrected and brushed up before going on air, but sometimes it doesn't make a big difference.

[@Cora_Laine]

You guys really need to apologize for being so rude to the Koreans. Just because their not Americans doesn’t mean they aren’t good and need modifiers to sing.

[@sjwe751]

it seems a little unfair to compare and say that the Korean recordings are not reliable when you could say the same for the American recordings. Yes, there could be some tweakings, but it applies to both instead of just emphasising on how the Korean recording' s are modified cause they aim for perfection.

[@soph1097]

In my opinion, kpop vocalists are some of the best, mainly because of the fact that they can't debut unless they've had sufficient training, especially SM groups. They have some of the best vocals because of the vocal coaches and the amount of years these guys train for to get their voices so clear. I gave up on this video half way through, just because y'all were saying the only way the kpop singers were good is because of 'modification on the mic', like no these people have beautiful voices and they've had so much training it really shows. The techniques and the notes are so clear in kpop singers because they've been taught for so many years, because they have to be before they can even think about debuting. Ugh I wish people wouldn't be so ignorant and appreciate these artists for the blessings they are

[@하-t6n]

우리나라 사람들 왤케 노래 잘함?

[@밥줘-g9u]

비교는 안좋지만 여기서는 한국인이 좀 압도적인거 같아요

[@emmaline4342]

The amount of years put into training and especially vocal training means they don't. use. autotune. They have reverbs (but not all) but not autotuners

[@keyannahenry8334]

If Asians they can sing they CAN HELLA SING you should look at all the live performances they voices soooo flawless and they don't use autotune

[@Cyblps]

I hope this video never gets erased. Just to prove how ignorant these people are

[@divineubalde1913]

Ailee Mamamoo Solar Park Ki Young Kim Ah Jung There are also many great vocalist in Korea..you should also check out Taeyeon, Yuju, Hyorin

[@siboykafka2752]

Aw So Hyang and Park Ki young are my favorite 😍😊 Edit: Koreans do not shout, they're belting! They used to belt upper register unlike Americans who can only belt mostly on lower and middle register. That's why it sounds screaming for you. Plus they don't strain.

[@Xdianaandini]

Guys u should react that Mariah performance. Grammmy 1992 "If it's over"

[@manfredgoh3127]

why do y’all keep criticising these singers for modifying their voices when their actually not. those singers have trained their whole life to get this clear sound

[@paigetimmons6264]

The ignorance in this video is so so gross. I can’t believe you would accuse the Koreans of using auto tune just because they had better voices than the Americans. Just because they are better and train harder than the Americans doesn’t mean they use auto tune smh

[@arupkumargogoi1370]

I don't care what other people say but I feel more comfortable and satisfied when I listen to Korean singers high notes then the Americans you have to admit that there are better singers in outside of the America and in this video Korean wins

[@josiahwendell]

The girl singing the C#5 before Christina is Solar from Mamamoo. The girl singing the D5 is Ailee. The lady singing in the beginning I think is Park Jung Hyun but there is another female artist who sounds similar to her who was also displayed in the video is really good also but I forgot her name sadly. Bada is the lady that sang G#5 great vocalist also. I hope my little explanation helps you guys discover new artist.

[@yuliantochandra4003]

Park junghyun was not in the video... thewoman in the beginning was Son Seungyeon

[@josiahwendell]

Yulianto Chandra , thanks for the correction I wasn’t sure who it was at first now I know.

[@JakeReeves001]

The First Lady was Son Seungyeon.....who can sing all the ladies you named under the table

[@sheoulgra]

The different between koreans and american singers are that korean train much longer and know how to use their voices...

[@laniluvsu1904]

korean idols train for 6+ years while american artist get big if their voice is heard. their voices aren’t tweaked, you would know that if you are educated. they are really being biased. don’t react and post if you are just gonna be like “oh they tweaked their voices” cuz you will get hate from kpop fandoms 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@瑞-c8p]

영상시작하자마자 "I didn't even know that Koreans belted" ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ어이가없네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋSeriously?

[@mohamadhusaini1974]

Please react to Sohyang vs Americans -belting battle

[@mckealalfred9229]

When Americans do the same High ass notes as the koreans they believe but when the Korean singers do they don't think it's real?

[@김태훈-i6k]

차이점: 미국은 대부분 옛날 가수 한국은 현역

[@ruatdikafanai4685]

I wish that Korean and American Singers had a live battle... Then you will see whose the best... Korean singers are amazing

[@niceandbryan]

Love koreans people!

[@markdeguzman6556]

I love our Morissette but I have respect for Ms, Soh Hyang. She has some serious high notes. I hope they can collaborate just like with Charice.

[@dulchea3382]

Koreans did not and do not use autotunes in their live performances. Smh. So like, "modified" my ass.

[@blackfriday2242]

most koreans where trained before their debuted and work hard. so don't always say that they use auto-tune

[@hoyun-c3v]

미국은 다 옛날.한국은 현재!

[@rikardoleitte406]

Most part of the korean singers in the video is from "Immortal Song 2" it's a competition program and they all have to sing live.

[@GarageStudio7]

*Park, Sohyang & Mariah* had them *SHOOKETHED!* You're spot on about exceptional vocalists not being as Mainstream in America anymore. You're also right about the altered (reverb) vocals from the Korean singers.

[@mjsc4jk]

Most of the korean clips are from Immortal songs...its a singing competition. I don't think they use autotune tho since I've seen some singers and groups that strains some of their belts there...and other idols that go off tune because of their dancing while singing. But...for sure any info/comment from its viewers here wouldn't matter anyway...so what's the point?

[@jessimin160]

"Modified, lipsync" Is TALENT only 😉

[@silverstarkitty2000]

The past US divas were total powerhouse queens, they knew how to sing with everything they had, they had real passionate charisma & they took you to another world every time by their vocal colours. Even now I can play an old album from one of them and their notes would still give me chills. (Same with a lot of the past male singers. They had that spark ) Unfortunately though imo MOST (not all) of the popular singers in the US now I feel are a major downgrade. I don't dislike US singers (sincerely some stuff is nice) but overall I think a lot of Americans need to wake up (& admit) to the fact that over time the singers quality in their music industry has diluted down to mostly being kinda basic. If you look around at the vocals & skills of many singers from different countries of the world you might understand what I mean. Once you see & hear the variety it's addictive & music becomes an exciting journey of discovery. :)