If I Could Only Keep 10 Indie Eyeshadow Palettes 2024

[@tiffanykennedybeauty]

Girl, you keep tooting that horn! You worked extremely hard on your palette with Adept and created something stunning to be proud of ❤

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Aw thank you 💙

[@christyhudson2760]

The first 2 you mentioned are easily the 2 I've been drooling over most all year. SO. PERFECT.

[@kittycloud6693]

I just got the cold moon palette and it's breathtaking. I'd definitely keep the rose quartz palette from Huda, I've panned a few shades. I'm excited to pair it with cold moon.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

That sounds like a pretty pair!

[@dianapolishchuk8248]

yes to a full comparison betwenn your palette with Adept and the Cold Moon by Ensley Reign. Since you described them as being sisters, maybe you could also do a look (or multiple) using the two palettes together

[@angelacochran7249]

Yes to using your pallet with enchanted autumn.

[@GaleSapphyra]

Yes!! I definitely second this 🙏🏻😃

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I will try to do that sooner rather than later then 💙

[@sashaminium]

I have 8 out of your top 10 palettes, and I agree that they’re great! If you do a palette mashup with your palette and Amanda’s palette, you guys should make it a collab video! I’d love to see what looks you both come up with.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I would love to do that with her but I know it’s a very busy season. We’ll see ☺️💙

[@Audiomajik]

This is a great concept that really challenges you to make hard choices. For us, it tells us what creators really like, what color stories you vibe with and why, and what you prioritize when you make these choices. That inspires processing usage vs. wants-of-the-moment. Sometimes a palette will inspire one good look one time, but it might not really be a keeper. All of the palettes you chose kinda scream AMY and maybe it will help others make choices that fit them as well.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I completely agree ☺️

[@zerbirae4224]

Yes to a besties-collab-palette mashup! The warm bronzy shimmer from Enchanted Autumn looks like a perfect match to your hair color!

[@MichyScents]

I purchased your palette a while ago and it’s such a pretty palette. I love that the shimmers are thin and don’t accentuate texture!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you I’m so happy they work well for you ☺️

[@sassyfairie0]

I’m so so so glad you enjoy our palette that much omg it’s an honor to be an included

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

You did amazing!! ✨✨

[@carlamiller2330]

I was finally able to purchase your palette today. We have the same preferences. Can’t wait to get her.😊💞

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Oh my gosh I’m so excited for you!! Thank you!! 💙✨

[@GaleSapphyra]

My goodness! Nearly every palette you mentioned I have on my wishlist. I guess we have similar tastes. Speaking of similar I literally just got done doing a beautiful look with the Enchanted Autumn palette. Mine just got delivered yesterday along with the Wizard palette lol. Those are the two I chose to get during the sales along with 6 of their holochrome singles. Thanks for this great video! Love your choices 💙💜🩷

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

That’s too funny! Definitely the same taste! ☺️

[@lgies66]

The best part of your videos is that you can’t keep your hands out of the shadows!! I do the same damn thing every time I pick a palette up.

[@MsAlyssaJM]

It's ok for shimmer swatches...I think most indie lovers are sparkly fans!

[@denisevictordavis674]

Yes definitely. 😍😍

[@pinkTonya24]

I ordered the Realm of Fairies palette, and O can't wait to have it in my hands! I think so many of your choices make perfect sense ! I would have a fee of the same palettes i think!

[@dawnbonome9056]

Cold Moon and your palette together. Do you pair them together at all? Do a comparison too. Do the Amanda and your palette together too. This was a fun one.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I do pair them together! I will try and do a video soon 💙

[@palettesandpans]

The first few that come to mind for me are your palette with Adept, Blends from Blend Bunny, So Jaded from Colourpop, and (surprisingly) Moonlit Seduction from Pat McGrath (I'd literally keep it for two shades! 😅). Also ND Retro & My Dream, the first Ethereal Eyes, Smokey Glam, Hela, Off Melrose, & Club Nebula as a bonus #11. It's so hard to pick just 10!!!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Club Nebula will always be that girl!! I don’t mention her as much since she’s long gone but soooo good!!

[@dottyquack]

Yes, use your palette with enchanted autumn!

[@jillyp9181]

I’d definitely keep BB Sickly Sweet too. I use it all the time for inner corner highlights!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

It’s so good for that!!

[@kate98765]

I would keep BBB Basic Witch, Kaleidos Flower Punk and not sure what else!

[@joannahutz1258]

Yes to a video looking at your palette and ER’s Cold Moon in depth!

[@ttiian]

My palettes if I only could keep 10: Blendbunny All Done Up and Surge, Lunar Beauty Moonshroom, Oden’s Eye Merry Christmas, Trick or Treat and Jewel & Gem, Ensley Reign Lands of Enchantment, Micka Beautyshop Serpent, Adept Element 115 and Fantasy Cosmetica Harvest of Souls. This was so difficult!

[@matilda_bruchenbach]

All of your picks are amazing! Stunning palettes😍

[@MellaYellow]

I agree with almost all but I would Unity it's my cool tone fall palette 🍂🍁🍂

[@noheliavila8940]

Loved this!! I really want your collab, cold moon, and Samarian sunset. I just know these would be top used palettes in my collection!! I’m a green/warm tone/spicy neutral girl at heart but lately I’ve been digging cool tones! Hope you have a great night/day whenever/if you read my comment🤗🫶🏽

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

It’s funny I used to be a spicy neutral girl all the way and hated grey shadows but now cool tones are my favorite. The phases are fun. And thank you!!

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Such beautiful choices. Thank you ❤

[@cassieobryant9032]

I just received your palette from Adept yesterday. I’m in love!!❤❤❤

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Omg! Thank you!! Enjoy 💙💙

[@chiyoh]

If I had to limit myself to just ten palettes the first would be my five Blend Bunny palettes so Blends, Surge, Primal, All Done Up, and Sickly Sweet. Shroud x Batty Bean It’s Freakin’ Bats. Definitely Club Nebula. Fantasy Cosmetica Druid and Harvest of Souls. For the last one I guess the September Rose Slush palette, even though it’s super old (the brand isn’t even around anymore) and it’s definitely past its expiration date but the matte yellow is still the best one in my collection lol

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Oooh I love your vibes!! And yesss oh my gosh that yellow was amazing!!!

[@kayla4702]

Yes to a comparison video of your adept palette and ER Cold Moon palette

[@careyloveslipstick525]

You are helping me narrow down my wishlist. 😁 I’d love to see looks with your palette and Amanda’s 😍

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Okay thank you for the feedback!!

[@blendofdays]

Love your choices! I love that you swatched mostly shimmers, the heart wants what the heart wants 😂

[@AnnieWiz1978]

LOL OMG did heather austin mythology explode in there!! So far we gave some similar palettes nice that samarian sunset is about 4th in my whole collection I just bought the new magnetic basic witch today!! Realm of Fairies is sold out already I'm sure they will restock selling out that quick so did recently deinfluenced

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Haha yess I should probably clean it up but I kind of love the look of a messy loved palette

[@AnnieWiz1978]

@AmyLovesMakeup no I get it, it's Heather's I have her palette too!! It's such a gem I love what you said about the first 2 you swatches how soft but gorgeous they are I love grayish special shade honestly the whole palette is good it doesn't even matter how it's laid out ive played with it super cohesive!! 🙏✨️❄️

[@carolynhutchin8984]

I don't think I could only keep 10 indie palettes because I have at least 6 Natasha Denona palettes and 3 Pat McGrath palettes alone that would never go anywhere lol. But on top of those I'd choose Glaminatrix Nearly Natural and Rich Romantic, Unearthly Cosmetics Spring Magic, Odens Eye Christmas Eve and Solmane II Moon Wish, Huda Rose Quartz, Ensley Reign Cold Moon, and even though I haven't even touched it yet, it's on its way and I absolutely can't wait for the Ensley Reign Light in your Eyes palette. I absolutely know it's going to become an immediate favourite. ❤️😂

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Glaminatrix nearly natural almost made the cut!! It was so close but I kept going back and forth 😅 Love your list!

[@BelleStreetBoyz]

This was fun! I'm so curious what singles you would keep if you had to choose ten? I tried to mentally pick 10 from my collection and it was absolutely impossible! lol 🙈

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I did do that video forever ago!! I have no idea what I would pick now!!

[@cjaneg97]

I want the Ultra Violet palette so bad!!! I Feel Beautiful Canada got another shipment as it is going on sale tomorrow but it will likely be $100 Cad + shipping. I wanted to get it on black friday but BBB shipping price to Canada was $41. It's probably one I'll never get to have 😭😭

[@gatesofeden]

Lands of Enchantment I think would be in my top 10 😊 great picks! 💯

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

That’s such a good one too!!

[@sara.sara.]

Yes, your adept palette is one of my favorite too!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you ☺️☺️

[@Lindsaymarie927]

That Ultra Violet palette😍😍

[@johannaecheverrylopez2386]

4:18 Could you pls swatch that metallic blue in Realm of fairies v the metallic blue in Angie's Galactic Visitor palette?

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I’ll try to remember but I don’t have Galactic Visitor yet. I can’t wait!!

[@christahodges]

I'm late but I'm here! Thank goodness you post on IG, or I wouldn't have known. No notification.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Oh no!! That’s frustrating!

[@Emily-qh9tj]

Bella Beaute Bar is solidly on my radar. Both of those palettes are sooo pretty.

[@Emily-qh9tj]

And I would love to go on Fantasy Cosmetica and literally just purchase every palette they have. They’re all so pretty and unique. I love the curation of their color stories.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

They truly have some of the best color stories!

[@amelimelia]

Great selection ! As for me I can't really choose only 10 top palettes in my collection, dilemma dilemma ...

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I feel you!!

[@marlenegomes4008]

There is so much that i want but fantasy cosmetica rogue bbb recently deinfluenced nd yucca er harvest moon and er cold moon. Also bbb basic witch.

[@sheilamoriarty3169]

You are so fun to watch, Amy.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

You’re sweet ❤️

[@ferdottir]

I want your palette so bad, it's so stunning, but unfortunately they don't ship to Spain!😢

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I believe Monolith ships to Spain and my palette is available on there! ☺️

[@Gulupi23]

I can't believe you did not choose either juicy olive or tropical vibes for your green story 😮.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I’m not the biggest fan of give me glow but yes tropical vibes is such a good one!!

[@RAINtears91]

10 palettes is so hard 😅 some natasha denona, nearly neutral would be in there for me for sure, also odens eye

[@sarahelkot5950]

What if ensley reign and these brands come to ulta ..what a dream❤❤

[@paigehurley9354]

If I had to keep only 10 ten it would be tough, but my glaminatrix palettes are the biggest no brainers!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Nearly natural almost made it in! It was so close!!

[@OnceOnly24]

I mean mattes ground the look but shimmers are what the look shines! Swatch away!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

🙌🏻🙌🏻🤣

[@kayla4702]

Soo I only have 6 palettes, with 5 of them being indie brands. So I suppose my 5 to keep would be: Blend Bunny Blends Blend Bunny Sickly Sweet Glamlite Rick and Morty Glamlite Garfield Ensley Reign Groovy Garden They pair well with the Devinah singles I own, too. My grudgy greens come from their mattes. Lol.

[@sylrodrigues36]

❤❤

[@helsconceit]

If I were to buy anything from ND it’d be Yucca but it missed the mark slightly for me. Way too matte-heavy

[@JorgeGarcia-qq2nr]

Hi im new here hope that you don't mind that I'm a guy im a crossdresser guy and i love makeup i love your video

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

All makeup lovers are welcome here ☺️

[@JorgeGarcia-qq2nr]

@AmyLovesMakeup thanks 🙏

[@YouTubeVideoSEOExpertbd]

Hello dear, I noticed that you don't reply to my comments when I comment. I really like watching the videos on your KZbin channel.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

This is the second time you’ve commented this even though I commented back. Weird strategy??

[@YouTubeVideoSEOExpertbd]

@@AmyLovesMakeup You Making amazing video content. I just watched the video and your video quality is appreciable. I am very impressed with your content. I was analyzing your channel and noticed that your videos are struggling with video views and ranking. May I share some tips on how to improve your KZbin channel? can achieve the your goals.

[@michellecaudill7936]

Please pronounce it correctly Yuck ah cactus not yucca

[@andmoreagain7]

Great choices! I only have Yucca because it's readily available in my country. Other brands are so hard to get to my country (shipping is too expensive and then duties and taxes...). And I live in freaking Europe, just not the EU so it's so complicated and I keep missing out on some great stuff, but I live vicariously through you and some other creators! 🤍🩷💛

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I’m sorry that sounds so frustrating

[@andmoreagain7]

@@AmyLovesMakeup annoying as hell!

[@denisevictordavis674]

I have 3 of the 10 you mentioned and yes your pallette is one of those and so is the cold moon pallette. I love those with my whole heart.I also have the sickly sweet pallette. The newest pallette s in my collection are from Jolie beauty the spellbound and the til death pallette Im really enjoying them.Since ive starting buying Indie makeup 5 years ago ( because of your channel ) thats all ibuy really.Ty for making such great videos n making that cool tone beauty that im constantly reaching for.🩷

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Aw thank you that means so much 🥹