An attempt at a coherent song: Honkai: Star Rail - Before The Next Song Begins web event

I had a lot more fun than I expected messing around with the music, so I tried my best to come up with a somewhat coherent song, despite all the limitations of the event.
This is the second song: If I Can Stop One Heart From Breaking
Edit: I added the songs to a playlist on soundcloud in case you wanted to listen to them there: / honkai-star-rail-befor...

[@Vroeyn]

Thank you to everyone for your kind words and comments. To be honest I wasn't really expecting my 2 videos to go anywhere, they were mostly just for me so I could save what I came up with in the event since I spent a lot of time on it and had a lot of fun with it. I was expecting at most for the videos to get at most maybe 1k views between the 2 videos. I did not expect to get anywhere near this amount of attention. Originally I wanted to at least try to respond to every comment that I got since I wasn't expecting there to be that many, but with there being way more than I anticipated and with me being busy with Uni work I wasn't able to do that. I've been reading through the comments though but sorry if I never ended up responding. I've this mentioned in other replies but I don't actually have any proper experience with making or performing music, hence the title being "An attempt at a coherent song". I don't have a lot of confidence but if you guys would like to see me try my hand at making music of some kind then let me know and maybe I can give it a go. Anyways thank you to everyone for sharing your thoughts on the video/music, I'm happy to see that at least some small part of KZbin was able to enjoy what I managed to come up with. Lets all continue to enjoy Honkai: Star Rail Together! Also Hoyoverse please add some kind of permanent music event it doesn't have to be the same as this but anything would be cool. Edit: I added the songs to a playlist on soundcloud in case you wanted to listen to them there: soundcloud.com/vroeyn/sets/honkai-star-rail-before-the-next-song-begins-vroeyn-remix

[@Mirosuke.]

This event still far better than Genshin's in-game music events lol

[@SubCryo]

Appreciate you making this videos man! Event is already down from hoyo website. Glad to hear this attempts in youtube.

[@AnissaDaaBomb]

The single Clockie moments were perfect

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks, I had to re-record a couple of times because I got the timing wrong

[@Xuan-r1h]

he can do more better when the single moment occur

[@lisssafilipe]

"An attempt" they said, while bringing out a banger

[@Vroeyn]

An attempt was made

[@AndreaFrancoise]

@@Vroeyn Your "attempt" boosted my productivity at work

[@karu3724]

@@Vroeyn and it was a succesful one

[@CarlosCampos-ig8bg]

@@Vroeyn I feel LoTM vibes

[@AngelBolt]

And then there's me: get the 7 loudest tracks playing at once.

[@thesleepyreader]

Lol same

[@hanbaebummie3215]

Same xd

[@maddiekaty1189]

SO TTRUE

[@Hanachi707]

Sunday looks so cute

[@nguyendanhbang11a26]

dead af

[@Hanachi707]

@@nguyendanhbang11a26 uhh no he’s not? Did you forget that robin saved him? He went missing after they woke up and there are theories about him joining the stellaron hunters.

[@nguyendanhbang11a26]

@@Hanachi707:o damn

[@kaiserdlt5576]

@@Hanachi707 i hope he'd be playable

[@rcl4737]

@@Hanachi707It doesn’t really make sense, your theory that is

[@itslikeameatyexplosion]

wish this event stayed longer. not for me specifically but for talented people like you

[@Vroeyn]

I would argue that I’m not that good but thank you, and yeah it would be great is this was made into some sort of permanent thing

[@pumkinpatchwork]

I wish events didn’t end and just kind of passively stayed there (with no rewards though) forever afterwards. I don’t see why not either, like they made the whole event and everything just don’t lock it?

[@viieswkit]

@@pumkinpatchwork website costs?

[@hanabiyoshi6940]

I agree. I played it for a bit until I realize that I can make music too. Tried it with Sunday starting point and and with birds and Clockie, until I lost interest. A banger event sure.

[@jang2386]

I didnt know there was a web event😭😭😭

[@Kuyuki]

As someone who also stayed there having fun with it i really loved this. I wish they had put Robin singing for us to use as well but well, overall a really nice event.

[@Vroeyn]

Yeah I guess the point was to make a DIY song, and having Robin’s voice there would make it more just a remix instead of your own thing

[@khwanboochasenruk6283]

Not me doing rock if I can stop one heart from breaking

[@calliesnotcreative]

I wish there was an official rock cover because it sounds so good 😭😭

[@_planetMagi]

NO CAUSE WHY DID I DO THE SAME 😭💀

[@JuliaNina]

Acheron 🥺

[@rebbieornot]

the way this web event as endgame content or a permanent website would actually go SO hard... hoyo, i beg of you...

[@TheMattVis]

LOL I even love the Mixing drink event, some HSR event really is fun even if it's a simple events

[@rebbieornot]

@@TheMattVis exactly! i totally agree!

[@privacypolicy123]

they can't do that, this is an incredibox rip off which already exisys

[@rebbieornot]

@@privacypolicy123 that is fair, it probably wouldn't fly at all, just wishful thinking on my part lol

[@bignonoIamAgirl]

I love that it ended with Sunday standing alone in the center…

[@Vinxy-o1z]

Not everyone becoming musical geniuses with this cause this is literally so fun and so good

[@Volair]

Ending this with a Sunday Solo is my go to as well.

[@Ravenna.E.Blackbird]

The well-timed solo snippets were super cool ♫ ♪

[@ionmeth2031]

epic, you did what i could't after trying for hours, in the end i gave up and came to find on youtube.

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks, it took me a while as well, I think between both songs I spent about 5 hours to come up with the songs, it took me a while to get a song I liked

[@PersesEmi]

I tried to make a synth pop like this too, gave up cause I wasnt musically inclined enough xD nice rendition by the way. Its funny how there are times where the instruments would desync. Its so bad.

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks, I have no experience making music but I decided to give it a go and this was what I managed to make. As for the desyncing I noticed that if you pause the page it would cause some them to desync and you had to reset all the instruments to get it working again, which was kind of a pain to deal with.

[@SlayrinaF]

This is brilliant! This is one of those minigames that would be amazing to have in-game permanently, i can imagine so many creations and ways the content could be expanded.

[@Vroeyn]

Something like this or something similar to the Windsong Lyre from Genshin would be cool

[@H4DESROSE]

THE SOLO PARTS GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS ESPECIALLY SUNDAY AT THE END TYSM ILY

[@pancakeser]

THIS IS SOOO COOOOL

[@Clockwork_Mk3]

подтверждаю

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks!

[@codetibers]

This guy for sure played around with incredibox

[@Vroeyn]

I actually don’t know what incredibox is but now I guess I have to check it out

[@sushishishu]

@@Vroeynit’s the original music game this event was probably based on lmao

[@bobuxman1434]

​@@VroeynBasically the same as this, but the characters do beatbox to make music

[@BlackTigr]

​​@@sushishishu oh? And here I thought it was just a nicer-looking My Singing Monsters copy.

[@TheLawlessRogue]

@@BlackTigrhaha I thought the same! My Singing Monsters was my jam

[@endoleon2765]

it's really good, but man I could listen to Sunday piano for hours xD

[@Vroeyn]

Yeah I liked the piano because it reminded me of the actual song the most

[@ThatOneGuyYaKnow]

It almost perfectly loops as well which makes it even better

[@wonyxung]

THE SOLOS ARE SO WELL DONE WOWWW

[@sutine-yueling]

I love how Sunday standing in begining, giving main rhythm to the song, and then returns in the end, when main rhythm sounds again❤

[@Nobody-dd3hr]

I know yall cooked real hard with this event

[@SuigetsuIsArt]

sounds genuinely really cool

[@Naxnest]

incredibox moment

[@DaNoobrobloxNoobIsBest]

nice I personally just put the horse, sunday and the barrel thing I just thought these 3 together were nice and didn't add other stuff cause it kinda ruined the calm ambience for me

[@Vroeyn]

I actually started with the off with just Sunday, the horse and the guitar bird as well because I wanted something that was similar to the actual If I Can Stop One Heart From Breaking song, but more than half the instruments were too high energy so I had to sacrifice the nice relaxing tone in order to get more variety in the song

[@eis6570]

​@@Vroeyn Well it turns out turning into a semi-trance remix did the job for it. Seriously, your improvisation sounded well as a trance remix

[@sei9176]

It's so good~ I was aiming for almost the same thing but w/o hanu and the drums. I just couldn't get the timing right... glad you were able to do it XDDD

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks! I had to retake a few times because the timing, it was frustrating to have it sound off by just a little bit and have to re-record but I got there in the end

[@sei9176]

Damn being a perfectionist is hard (and yes that applies to me too) but it is satisfying in the end ❤

[@_ANGELDIE_]

Guy.... Respect to you I've never seen cooler performances in my life, and even added effects, you're the best ❤❤❤❤

[@Absolute__Zero]

Xipe casted her gaze on the Trailblazer, but you now have her full attention with such a great show of Harmony!

[@Vroeyn]

Nah man I’m just an ordinary pathstrider

[@bennettmatthews8445]

i clicked on this video expecting a silly little song and stumbled across a masterpiece. beautiful work

[@chosoistryinghisbest]

man i've been listening to this non stop since yesterday, man i wish i didn't miss this web event it looks so fun 😭😭

[@sashako421]

good song!

[@Vroeyn]

Thanks!

[@theampeel]

Nailed it. Bro cooked good for us

[@serinahighcomasi2248]

It’s like a synthwave version of If I Can Stop One Heart from Breaking. Pretty neat.

[@jdod666]

When the clock boy do solo is so amazing!

[@corvus6971]

Both of the origami birds are so good in this one, the animations are great too

[@beezy.gaming]

They should’ve made this a permanent event, sad that I missed a gem like this

[@dontusethesamenicknameonthenet]

i put the instruments i liked, it turned out nice but idk im not a musician

[@Vroeyn]

That’s pretty much what I did, just messed around with the instruments for a few hours to get something I liked

[@YudasBlackheartCh4th]

If you familiar with Aimer RE:IAM, you can clearly hear the same feeling at 00:13

[@Vroeyn]

I actually love that song, it’s hard to top the Aimer and Hiroyuki Sawano combo

[@Nemchick]

Not bad, not bad. Octopus and that tasmanian devil agent guy give the best sounds.

[@oceanwhisperer]

Hopefully in the future hoyo is going to make more web events like this just so I can wait to see more of your works!

[@icewinSicily]

sunday was there for emotional support

[@AstrayCuriosity]

I kid you not I just downloaded the video and transisted it into mp4 to listen

[@Asaku17]

Damn this is dope, especially that guitar part!

[@mmelo7832]

The hanu solo is godlike

[@ricebutcake5754]

i wish this could be turned into a whole song

[@notclock]

Incredibox walked so this even could run

[@daisana]

I didn't knew Toca Band got an update

[@user-id3qj8ks6g]

YO I THOUGHT THE SAME THING 😭

[@Certifiedfrogluvr]

This was the most fun event Hoyo has ever put out and you can’t tell me otherwise

[@Trakedoo]

that solo moments are some nasty work🔥

[@lazagna6969]

this ain't an attempt, thats a success

[@mao-mayo]

This is amazing the Clockie solos were a great touch!!

[@galan2541]

Bro just made a banger

[@user-os1id7vt8b]

最後にサンデー1人になるのが好きだ🥲

[@flebbewebbe88]

Bro wtf this goes SO hard!

[@abouttime5377]

"Harmony"

[@tsadriu7861]

Actually sounds very cool! The solo parts of Clockie OOF!

[@sarantuya2098]

Holy shit Bro cooked with this

[@lemon_cream184]

my singing gambling addicts

[@fritz4262]

This is IncrediCony

[@coralpersimmon]

I really love the way you arrange your music！ I wish this beautiful song could be played on the train

[@xDJxChowwy]

lmao dude!!! i used the same lineup and slowly introduced them as well. Legit almost the same minus the sick Clockie isolation.

[@charms7232]

They need to make this event permanent cause its amazing what y'all are cooking

[@spottfi2407]

LET HIM FORKIN COOK 🗣️🗣️

[@danilaq1]

I love this event so much

[@user-dm8zp9ru8h]

This is really good! Amazing how some people can drop a banger like this, and then there is me, who just mutes the whole thing, press some randon buttons and play it for 15s just to get the reward. 🙄

[@lizn160]

i enjoyed this event so much. the music is awesome especially this one

[@marsh7824]

this deserves a nice, cozy spot in my playlist

[@SundayLover2.0]

Sunday looks so majestic, as always

[@eligoruwu5423]

Ive heard other's rendition of this song, some are mellow some are sad, yours are like perfect combination this rhythm can ask for! The solo moments going hard!! 🩷✨

[@maffeistaruu]

absolute banger in 1.5

[@amerx2x]

This should be a permanent event

[@isegeese]

sunday is so cutie

[@nothark]

This is really good. I actually put it on my playlist lol

[@Destinywalker3088]

Thats fire,

[@crowtit3794]

First thing im doing is begging them in the next survey to add this as a feature for the parlor car. They could add more tracks like Wilffire, Samudrartha, and a few more of their hit tracks and allow players to make their own makeshift track for the phonograph! Along with a feature that allows you to share a track on your trailblaze profile 🙀🥺🥺

[@TIME-fe6ne]

This is actually so friggin AWESOME!!

[@mavtato6898]

this is so awesome

[@thea2865]

"an attempt" bro i have goosebumps

[@pst4428]

Bro absolutely cooked 🔥🔥🗣

[@Carnaj90]

This goes SO HARD!!! I want this as an in game BGM!!!

[@AmikaYTAnimator]

Dude you cooked

[@tylosenpai6920]

Sunday looks so happy there...like...actually happy

[@pipedream2556]

Wait this is a web event?? How have i not heard of this yet...

[@manokechi]

It's the diy song one. Robin invites u to make music with her on the in-game email! The one where it's just credits, u probably only claimed the credits and didn't read, but yeah it's there and it's really fun

[@tomirismadiyarova1943]

OMG YOU COOKED SO HARD🔥🔥🔥

[@Julian-Lehmann]

You've made a good vibe, great job

[@_ao]

this is genuinely so cool

[@rasteros]

Coherent? This sounds exactly like 86 anime ED song ‘avid’ in electronic rendition, you my guy KILLED IT

[@adorkablerandomness7210]

This was a really fun event I hope they bring it back

[@hayang4]

I LOVE THIS WEB EVENT

[@aresondesu1564]

So amazing!! I love all of this!

[@dairee_soulstrong]

I miss this event so much 😭😭😭

[@nghiemle9504]

I had made mine, I thought that it was a good one until I saw yours. OMG, It's sooo good

[@yongyilim1655]

I really loved this event too, great work!

[@Top_Nep]

i really wished this event was permanent, i would pay a good $5-10 for just this as a game

[@sev3208]

This is actually a banger omg

[@lunaredevinare7913]

Hey man if it wasn't for you I wouldn't have discovered this web event, saw your videos tonight and it inspired me to make one song and then i ended up making four more lol

[@t11fa25]

THIS IS SO GOOODDD???

[@fishbol478]

Man i really hope they make this a permanent in game event. It’s so fun tinkering with it 😂