An Updated Look at My Most Valuable Disney Pins

Back in August of 2020 I made a video looking at the most valuable Disney pins in my collection, and I said it'd be fun to come back in a year and see what values are like then! It's been a little bit longer than that, but we're finally here to take an updated look at the most valuable and expensive Disney pins in my collection. Pin values are generally determined by eBay sold listings, but sometime you have to use active listings when there haven't been any sold recently. Despite the complete total lack on updates related to the Princess and the Frog re-theming of Splash mountain, Splash Mountain pins still hold incredibly high values!
Original Most Valuable Disney Pins Video | • My Most VALUABLE Disne...
(You can tell how incredibly sick I was when filming this video, I'm so happy I've gotten back to being fully healthy!)
Find me online!
Instagram | / magically.emily
TikTok | / azurite.emily
Twitter | / azurite_emily
🍭Check out my handmade sweet treat-inspired mouse ears!🍭
Etsy | confectionearshop.etsy.com
IG | / confectionearshop

[@MagicallyEmily]

*Let me know what your most valuable pin is and how much you’d be willing to spend on a pin!*

[@carlinc2362]

The "wanna pin trade" pin is so cute! I love how your videos always show me pins a casual collector like me has never seen before!

[@TheFlirtMeister]

My thinking for the Disneyland Paris Mickey pin being so popular/expensive is that it appeals to the American market more than the Disneyland Paris market, but it's harder for Americans to purchase thus raising the price

[@Kris10Banci]

Wow did not know zootopia pins could get so expensive! I have a couple emperors new groove pins that I’ll definitely treasure more now. Thanks for the informative video!

[@MagicalDayWithBae]

Loved this video! ❤

[@Alecswelms]

The most I spent was for my Elsa profile. The best deal or wealth gain was the D23 Elsa postage stamp that I got for retail and it goes for $400+.

[@BasementMermaid]

I’m glad I took your advice with the monthly pin series! I got the Fantasyland poster pin for $30, it has definitely appreciated greatly!

[@susanmcallister4912]

You will never sell it though

[@ginaperez1804]

Thanks for the update I had to go to your old video your talked about eBay sold listings

[@mindyschocolate]

The most I paid was $75, but that was a huge, palm sized pin I got at Epcot. I have like over 400 pins dating back to 2000.

[@kristenswanson5872]

I'd love to own the Briar Rose Hero Profile pin but I think I'll have to sell a kidney because they're going for $1,400 lol the most valuable pin of mine I can name off the top of my head is my Prince Philip Heroes Series LE 500 pin, I only paid about $30 for mine but now they're selling for over $150 on Ebay. Thanks for another great video, Emily! :)

[@aliciabruce9881]

My most valuable pin is probably my wdi penny profile from the rescuers! Nearly all of my artland pins have tripled in value too!

[@TropicalThunder21]

Where did you get that tapestry WDW 50th thing that’s behind you! It’s amazing!

[@v_zach]

The most I've spent on a pin is $60. One of them is selling for around $70. It's the Neo Nouveau Jasmine.

[@girlinthe3102]

The most I've spent is $55 each on the WDI Dinah cat nap and the Si Am paint drip. They've gone up significantly but you know, it's all a crap shoot lol

[@bobibear85]

My most expensive pin is the Ariel profile pin from WDI. The most I’ve ever spent for a pin is $500 and that was for the Vanellope profile pin from WDI 🍭 🧜‍♀️

[@tandopack2714]

Hi! Your pins are really cute. I’m just looking into pin trading. I have a few pins from years ago, but I never traded any. As far as value, how much is lost in value when the cardboard is missing?

[@cyannemelody]

It’s crazy how expensive those monthly DLR poster pins have become! I was able to purchase the 1st castle one from the park as I live close by but haven’t been able to get any of the other ones as they sell out in a couple hours. Are you still trying to collect them, even at these prices?

[@MagicallyEmily]

Yes, I’m collecting the rest of the set, it’s only the first pin that’s at this really high price!

[@UnCreativeBeliever]

I've spent about $100 on Disney Cast-exclusive pins, which was probably the wrong thing to do because it just proves the people they can markup the prices and get buyers. I want to stick to lower than $60 now, depending on how rare the pin is and how much I love it. I will pay more for Meet The Robinsons and Tangled pins.

[@ae8710]

I just bought the sugar skull inspired mickey pin for less than 10 on ebay, i thought it was beautiful, now im scared to wear it ha

[@lesliecink5016]

I going to be selling my collection. What is the best way or place to do that?

[@dannystargazer]

omg where did u get ur mickey ears

[@kaitlynjolly9565]

where did you get your Tshirt it is so cute 🥰

[@MagicallyEmily]

It’s from Etsy!

[@joshuatoro8977]

most expensive pin I've ever spent money on outside of buying from the park is about 30 bucks The most expensive pin I've ever bought in the park or a Disney store was 25 bucks I can't imagine spending much more than that

[@TheSmellymuffin11]

I recently paid a ridiculous amount of money for a pin and I’m kinda upset at myself for it lmaoo

[@tschotty5034]

2:45 it didnt sell for 185, the best offer was accepted, meaning it was less

[@MagicallyEmily]

That's correct, there's a number sold as Best Offers, but eBay has stopped sites like WatchCount from being able to show what it actually sold for, so you just have to go off what the list price states.