Anakin vs. Obi-Wan, Duel On Mustafar - John Williams (UPDATED)

[@NormalChannel95]

I love how the piano tiles show the color the lightsabers and Anakin's is basically red at that point

[@limitsofthepiano]

nice, someone noticed the lightsaber colors

[@SemISkUIZTheRaccoonSpider1st]

That is because he is already Darth Vader.

[@The_K-Dude]

I never realized just how much of a role music plays in movies. Great job to both you and John Williams.

[@aimnobody1]

when yoda landed in the speeder, was that a minecraft villager hit noise lmaooooo????

[@limitsofthepiano]

yep you caught me if you listen to the original it kinda actually sounds like it

[@micoangelobarrios9668]

😮

[@chelseafromberg2079]

SUS

[@SMc-uh5fi]

This is the best piano tutorial of this theme that I have seen and I just love the accompanying visuals. The movie and the music, thank you so much.

[@XxJayDogxX7933]

Great editing, this is a really nice piece. John Williams did so well with Star Wars.

[@Cybermash16]

Fun fact, you can only play this ONCE on a piano as it will literally catch fire from playing this legendary song

[@chelseafromberg2079]

LOL

[@dyroth]

Dude this is so crazy, and super interesting to see the music cues and tension builders john williams uses in the movies, many thanks for this!

[@staculette1919]

Wonderful work. As a fan of this movie and this movie's soundtrack I applaud you

[@JeffreyBarkdull]

This video deserves more likes and views

[@DeadEyes63]

I have never seen anything like this before. very well done

[@milad.nikzad]

I agree, the immolation scene is an underrated part of the soundtrack. What a haunting ending

[@howtoappearincompletely9739]

I totally agree. IIRC, on the CD soundtrack, the music then fades into the song played at Padmé's funeral. Really wonderful.

[@silverhand9965]

The Final Fantasy final boss music of Star Wars Motifs all over the place

[@aaronisveryawesome]

woah underrated video... awww man now i gotta rewatch it to see what you put in the subtitles ;)

[@youraltsarecool1528]

This is pretty good! I was surprised to see it only had 2.5k views

[@collinsfamily6819]

Amazing. Just, amazing.

[@Useryoutube02847]

Just watching this makes it feel like watching a 20s silent film. 🎥🎹🎶

[@8bitpokie826]

“I will learn how to play this on keyboard.” “You will try”

[@Sithlord04]

My cochlea is hard and it’s not even noon. FUCKING AMAZING JOB!

[@limitsofthepiano]

legendary comment right here

[@Sithlord04]

@@limitsofthepiano Legendary Pianist here 🫡

[@limitsofthepiano]

@@Sithlord04lmao I wish I could play what I write

[@Robby_wolfe]

Amazing music

[@Ericlewis-kk1wx]

Fun fact the reason obi wan and anakins mouth open with no sound right after Anakin gets chopped in half is because he originally was going to plead for help from obi wan, and obi wan would deny him, but George muted it

[@springgamerreiniciado8551]

8:48 What- a villager sound? XD

[@howtoappearincompletely9739]

This should have more views that 18K.

[@antonioarredondo9680]

the subtitles actually broke me

[@AeroBennett855]

This reminds me of my dad yelling at me angrily

[@BenjerDaMan]

Nah for me when my mom used to say: I’m calling your dad I could barely hear the darth Vader theme playing in the background.

[@chelseafromberg2079]

COOOOOOOOOOOOL

[@mackoronni5393]

Amazing! Duel of the fates next..?

[@limitsofthepiano]

Good idea, I might do that someday

[@mackoronni5393]

@@limitsofthepiano I look forward to it.

[@ForsakenSandpaper]

Sounds like a comedic battle where something silly happen.

[@Rpetros_editss]

Bro COOKED

[@COMMANDER_ANDREW-CT-5372]

I can't this to save my life😂😂😂

[@TnlGC]

3:47 Of course you wouldn't be able to hear those sounds, you're like 100 meters away from them

[@Ericlewis-kk1wx]

I think bail organa had a villager in his speeder

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

I noticed in the description you said make it playable, could you make one that is accurate like this, but not being playable, if that makes sense, like a piano remake

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

For example I've noticed that in the boys continue there seems to be notes missing

[@limitsofthepiano]

@@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficialI’ve tried to get a balance between playable and accurate, because I feel like there’s no point in being exactly accurate without any care for playability. At that point I might as well just copy in every note from the orchestra. Where do you think there are missing notes in the Boys Continue that I should add?

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

@@limitsofthepiano idk I just feel like the part where they cash and the lava goes up could be a bit stronger, it's missing some of the notes that add that idk what to call it, but that feel to it yk what i mean

[@limitsofthepiano]

@@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial ah I see what you mean, I might revise that part for the official versions in my google drive later but I won't release another video for these small changes

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

@@limitsofthepiano alr, I'll check those later

[@System.Error.]

now that musescore got updates u can use musescore 4…

[@limitsofthepiano]

I have tried musescore 4, and my main problem with it is that the offset note velocities work differently, meaning it’s harder to do the same kind of dynamics microadjustments I do in all my arrangements for realistic playback. I also prefer not to use their automatic realistic playback feature, because I prefer to be able to adjust things exactly the way I want them to be. Thanks for the suggestion though; musescore 4 is great otherwise, just not for my specific purposes.

[@JeffreyBarkdull]

You’ve got to tell us how you made this video?

[@limitsofthepiano]

Check out the description for a huge list of videos I referenced like scores and whatnot to make this-besides that, it was just about two hundred hours of figuring out which soundtracks went into the full fight scene (originally I was only gonna do Battle of the Heroes), tweaking things in MuseScore to sound good and be theoretically playable, syncing the music to the movie, and editing the video.

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

@@limitsofthepiano could you make one that is not just piano? like remake the orchestra, I'd like to hear how that would sound, also this looks good btw

[@limitsofthepiano]

@@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial thanks! unfortunately I don’t think I’ll make one for orchestra since I have 0 experience at all and I personally find that reducing a score down to piano is much more interesting and creative than recreating the orchestra. Plus I don’t usually get access to full orchestral scores so it might be a lot harder to figure out what all the instruments are playing.

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

@@limitsofthepiano fair enough

[@ZakkarytheAnimatorOldOfficial]

@@limitsofthepiano as a remixer/recreator myself, I do 100% understand where you're coming from

[@Viktor47917]

Love the soundtrack itself. And did you put a villager from Minecraft getting hurt in the Yoda part going to exile? Lol

[@limitsofthepiano]

lmao yep, it sounded kinda like that in the movie so I was like “why not”