Massive uproar rocks Lok Sabha over ‘One Nation One Election’ bill

[@LifeBeyondTrends]

All I can hear “we are opposing” but not “why”.

[@Huthuka.kibami3445]

We already know what will be the result and how the single party i.e modi is manipulation the constitution for his own party and personal benefit

[@n3umonium]

​@@Huthuka.kibami3445😂 nice joke

[@thenotorious-2]

​@@Huthuka.kibami3445 not we bro only some liberals .. opposition has no agenda they only oppose everything which govt does ..

[@thenotorious-2]

​@@Huthuka.kibami3445nd just go through 42nd ca u will get to know what manipulating of constitution looks like

[@shadowtheproplayer9437]

@@thenotorious-2 he has islamic mindset

[@User-w2t4e]

Less. Expenditure 2 more voter turnout out 3 less corruption by parties for election 4 more smooth Governance Can implement more govt projects without ban Becos of election code and conduct

[@ChandanKumar-qs6ep]

5. Foreign investment will come if they know this govt will be for 5 years so stable investment will come. 6. Indian foreign policies will be stable.

[@Davosky1234]

You are only talking about it positive outcome. It might also have negative outcome. 1 ) less accountability of the govt towards citizen. 2) Results of local and state assembly elections might be influenced by the central agenda not on the ground level agenda of the constituency. 3) less responsible govt. As they only visit their constituencies when they have elections. But if they don't have to face election then it's fine if they ignore people's basic concern. 3) may be delays in govt projects and schemes. 4) most important no reduction in petrol and diesel prices as only during election times this govt reduces fuel prices. But we have to see how it turns out for us.

[@ChandanKumar-qs6ep]

@@Davosky1234 You have written one disadvantage corrent that is no 2 only. Otherwise other points are useless because every government still comes for 5 years period and even today many times government are not accountable towards citizen but still the elections are held in 5 years. You are leaders will forget and not come to their area after this bill, still today they are not coming so what they will not come after the bill so there is no difference which is making any sense... This bill is useful and give full support because at the time of elections many people get disturbance, businesses get disrupted during elections, 144 section bla bla bla comes many times which disturb more, create more loss of money, humans because of political parties, many drama happens. At least these things happen at once in 5 years that will be useful for country.

[@midorimashintaro2092]

😂

[@Davosky1234]

@@ChandanKumar-qs6ep that's your opinion. Iam not saying this bill is wrong. Iam just saying time will tell whether this bill was for our good or theirs. And I always doubt politicians intentions no matter who it is. They will do anything to be in power. We have also seen many examples where govt agreed to public demand just because there was election comming. I have no problem with this bill if it's constitutional and is implemented properly for peoples benefit, it shouldn't be for the benifit of political parties. And I think all my points are valid and not useless for me.

[@GagandeepBhattacharya22]

1:34: TMC guy wants to use tax payers money as his election fund & calls it a reform!

[@suvamdutta676]

He is a drunker

[@bhaskardeysarkar6849]

They are chore

[@imranvlogs1701]

@@bhaskardeysarkar6849 bjp badha chor

[@ramniwas_dkd07]

​@@imranvlogs1701peaceful community Wale roo rhe h😂😂

[@MayankChaudhary-fy5gq]

​@imrmulla sabse bada choranvlogs1701

[@Jatav-n7k]

Full support to one nation one election

[@shaanjain7100]

Just analyze how Ruling party was behaving and how opposition was behaving.

[@siddeshwarprasad]

Ruling side - maturity Opposition side - hooliganism

[@jeenasongs]

One nation One election Required for India. Who will bare a common man expenditure for various elections. Now time come to empower Indian President power

[@Bharatiyaonly]

Excellent move ' One nation one election '

[@_SoapMacTavish_]

Care to explain how and why?? Aandbhakt

[@ThakurDevanshSingh-q8n]

​@@_SoapMacTavish_ Less expenditure, More voters turnout, Less chances of corruption

[@user-ESTERIFIY]

Chal bhai fir bata ki sal har saal kitne election hote hai aur kaun kaun se hote hai .😂😂 itna bata diya na toh bhi dhruv rathee ki mehnat safal samjho😂​@@_SoapMacTavish_

[@Musicmaestrosubra]

​@@_SoapMacTavish_ druv ka chamcha😂😂😂

[@shloakrajtiwari1022]

Chamche 😂😂😂​@@_SoapMacTavish_

[@POCHINKISUMESH]

Shame Congress We need One India One Election

[@ShivarajaSjr-b8y]

🇮🇳One Nation🇮🇳One election🇮🇳. 🙏 save money develop country🙏

[@amaanhyder9935]

😂

[@AshokKumar-jt3su]

This bill is strengthening the democracy

[@Justinfo101]

Why this small parties are afraid of ONOE. These people doesn't understand or least bothered about the nation growth... continuous election means people of India will get fed-up. This move is great for nation growth ...

[@GYANENDRAKUMARSATAPATHY-e5m]

They fear that it will nationalize the election. Before emergency era there was only congress ruling. They are fearing that it might be repeated again

[@DiYNO.]

Work Of Opposition --- Only Opposing No Explanation I made a mistake this time voting for Congress I thought our country need some check nd balance but They aren't even considering the Good things of the bill they're just making nuisance now

[@heartofbuddha63]

This Bill will actually empower "Smaller Political Parties" regionally to become Nation-wide Political Parties !!! This will actually strengthen Democracy and encourage MORE Parties like BJP, Congress to become National Parties and will remove MONOPOLY of just 1 - 2 Big Nationwide Political Parties.

[@enthuneverdies]

People like you easily belive to check and balance things..... thanks for voting congress.... We came to know that even all the tides are against Modiji he can still win 240 seats😊 People like us do voting only with one motive NATION first.😊

[@Lucifer-jr5ye]

​Nation first or hindu or upper caste first bro?... because we all know both govts are corrupted and only see their own benifits instead of peopl.e​@@enthuneverdies

[@bharatcurrent]

Perfect bill for those who are working..opposition are talking about samvidhan whata pitty

[@arpity....4901]

Who in favour of the bill say ... I ....

[@siasia_2000]

😂😂😂 love this comment😂😂

[@Sushil_Kumar_1529]

17:18 When will it turn from On Behalf of my Party to On Behalf of the interest of this Nation.

[@shahs5270]

Don’t roar at parliament . One nation one election

[@icyy9864]

This bill must pass

[@pravinpremilladaya5485]

Kalyan Bannerjee clown of TMC and INDI Block . He opposes but gives no alternative. Just an empty vessel making noise .

[@Ronifromearth]

Same here iam from Kolkata We call him "matal bara"

[@maruthinara6604]

Why Opposition Parties making big voice don't respect the BJP voice in parliament ❓

[@siasia_2000]

They oppose our nation

[@deepakverma-ls5gw]

I couldn't vote in the last election because I had an exam "One nation one election 👍 great move

[@icyy9864]

Opposition is thinking of there party more than there nation

[@therealbirdmachine]

Owaisi is saying that this is likd presidential style of election but..... what is wrong in presidential election? Does presidentaial style is not democracy!? 🤔

[@kniharika6634]

Public required one nation one election🎉🎉, jai bharath

[@SunandaKeshnoor]

One nation one election is something all indians should support ❤

[@rimbis62]

All support to this step taken by Govt. It is a much required legislation .

[@manoranjsahoo9197]

One nation One election ko Full support hay

[@Breathehills]

Good questions raised by the opposition 1. How will the states tenure match with the unions tenure of 5 years when a state legislative assembly dissolves or the Lok Sabha itself dissolves? 2. Will there be another national level election if one state assemble dissolves ? 3. Are the people of India so politically aware that they can differentiate between voting in the union and state assembly elections ? 4. What about the regional issues won't they be suppressed by the National issues ? 5. People in India vote in the name of the leader majority will vote in the name of Modi. I have seen booth capturing and the police does nothing won't this just be a BJP rule over India ?

[@vishalkumarpandey4433]

one nation one election. Yes

[@amareshbhangari1767]

Mr Gaurav where do you get money for elections.Whose money you MPs want to spend.It's tax payers money.All MPs should forego their salaries and pensions for elections.

[@GNB-0707]

Indian people save 5 lack + crore rupees ! If one nation one election may implement 🎉🎉🎉

[@sunnygupta1320]

The bill will anyhow pass

[@kuldipsingh5821]

Opposion parties doing bakwas in lok sabha.

[@SuryaMantha]

Opposition.. Remember one thing.. You're there for just 5years...thats it...i am paying taxes for 20years...you must answer for every rupee I paid as a tax? Who are you to waste my hard earned money

[@krishnanarayan2409]

If Dr. BR Ambedkar alive he also very happy with this decision because they know reforms which make our country powerful and stable is necessary. Congress and leftist thinkers always oppose these reforms because they don't want to see India as a super power.

[@pranaya2800]

I feel one nation 2 elections is better. General election should be held once and all the state elections should be held once with 2.5 years gap.

[@shahs5270]

Indian public need this . Politicians want to election to happen to loot money from common man . Every election politicians want to collect money during from Common man and this is the time all party members and leaders make money by manipulating accounts and expenses and collect Money from entrepreneurs

[@NmD-no3vo]

The day will come when Dotted Alliance will opposed bills That says Human need Oxygen to breathe. I really want to see Bjp bringing up such bills 😂

[@YOYo-09]

Now I understand, why opposition was happy when they got little bit more seat. They thought that, they will bark in higher voice with huge crowd and disturb the parliament sessions.

[@RameshCK-b5v]

The way the opposition parties opposing the bill, it seems they have the fear that they will never come to power in the centre.

[@arjunpradhan2079]

I support ONOE

[@riteshjat108]

One Nation One Election 🙏🏻

[@manoranjanrout9111]

We all support this great bill for the development of our country 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤

[@AkiStylE_funny]

I Stand with One Nation One Election

[@somenathpyne9659]

We supporter " one nation one selection"

[@davidrajan2795]

The proposal for One Nation, One Election-a system where elections for the Lok Sabha (national parliament) and all state assemblies are held simultaneously-has generated both support and opposition in India. Here are the primary reasons for opposition: 1. Federal Structure and State Autonomy • State-specific issues: Critics argue that combining state and national elections undermines the federal structure. Each state has its own unique political, social, and economic issues, which could be overshadowed by national narratives. • Autonomy of states: It may limit the flexibility of states to dissolve assemblies and call for fresh elections based on their unique situations. 2. Dominance of National Parties • Advantage to national parties: Simultaneous elections may give a disproportionate advantage to larger, well-organized national parties like the BJP and Congress, sidelining regional parties that rely on state-specific agendas. • Diminished focus on local issues: Regional issues may get lost in the larger narrative of national elections, reducing the voice of smaller parties and communities. 3. Practical Challenges • Logistics: Conducting elections for the Lok Sabha and all state assemblies at the same time would require massive resources, infrastructure, and security arrangements. The Election Commission of India (ECI) faces logistical constraints in organizing such a large-scale event. • Constitutional hurdles: Simultaneous elections would require significant constitutional amendments, including changes to Articles 83, 85, 172, 174, and 356. These amendments need broad political consensus, which is difficult to achieve. 4. Impact on Governance • Accountability gap: Frequent elections ensure constant accountability of governments to the public. With simultaneous elections, voters lose the chance to express dissatisfaction in state-level elections during the tenure of the central government. • Risk of policy paralysis: Critics argue that if a central or state government collapses mid-term, re-aligning the electoral cycle for fresh elections may lead to delays and governance issues. 5. Disruption of Democracy • Presidential-style campaigns: Simultaneous elections could shift focus from candidates and issues to a centralized leader, turning elections into presidential-style contests. • Voter confusion: Holding multiple elections at once could overwhelm voters, reducing their ability to make informed decisions. 6. Historical Context • India initially had simultaneous elections from 1952 to 1967. However, disruptions caused by mid-term assembly dissolutions and political instability ended this system. Opponents argue that returning to this model ignores the complex, evolving nature of India’s political landscape. 7. Criticism of Centralization • Many opponents view the proposal as an attempt to centralize power and diminish the political diversity of states, which could harm India’s pluralistic democracy. Conclusion While proponents argue that simultaneous elections reduce costs, time, and governance disruptions caused by frequent elections, opponents emphasize its risks to federalism, representation of local issues, and democratic accountability. The opposition primarily stems from concerns about practical feasibility, constitutional changes, and the potential erosion of India’s federal structure.

[@SoumyaAdhikari-k4g]

I mean how ridiculous is that we have bunch of fools opposing one nation one election, i mean how can you criticise that

[@siasia_2000]

14:26 well said 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@amareshbhangari1767]

Speaker Sir please bring a law to forego the salaries and pension of MPs for elections.Then let Them do any no of elections.

[@Khairul_Islam0909.]

ruling party talking about expenditure if they need to conduct simultaneous election then need more equipment like EVM, logistics etc agar election ko expenditure bolte ho toh aur kiya bolu . election democracy ka ek part hai election

[@kalyanb854]

I support One Nation One Election Bill👍

[@Jamesbond-f2n]

From 1952 to 1967 , one nation and one election was being already happened

[@VJ_Nic]

Full support to ONOE ❤ It will curb election expenses both black and white

[@Paparox.12]

Shame on congress WE WANT ONE ELECTION ONE NATION

[@143varunsherke2]

They aren't even willing to listen to what the bill has. Just opposing everything just for the sake of opposition.

[@nrusimha11]

"All I can hear “we are opposing” but not “why”."

[@sangram39]

We support this gentleman

[@vikasSharma-ox7on]

Tmc kalyan banarjee is like nedumpara of sc

[@Boostiger-ez8qk]

Every time get in line in the summer just to vote in every two years.. Every school and college stops because of Election. Every govt office says work will continue after the election from 2 months prior to election... I Support One Nation one election.. 🙏🙏

[@thenotorious-2]

When opposition mp speaks other listens , when mp of current govt speak opposition keeps shouting.. so immature behaviour just like their aka pappu

[@simhadrigarlapatidayanidhi2702]

Excellent bill we save lot of money and development grouth doubles if non corruption leaders are there 🎉🎉

[@praveenkumarkavadi6574]

One who don't participate in voting should be exempted from all basic facilities !

[@m.kumarpillai2285]

We indian need one election.let them cry

[@siasia_2000]

2:33 this is kalyan bannerjee . Koi do aana to de do use😂😂

[@praveenkumarkavadi6574]

ONOE is must in India

[@Incredible_World_2023]

If you scientifically analyse election budget it is not that much

[@_SoapMacTavish_]

Aaandbhakts will not understand. They consider mogli as their god and want his wishes to be granted. India is doomed

[@Educational-window]

No that is not the reason but the development that comes to stop during that election in respective area impact more

[@_SoapMacTavish_]

@ so the development occurs only during elections?? What were they doing the rest of the time

[@SumitSinha_ArtFreak]

@@_SoapMacTavish_it stops because of elections

[@CprtFM]

*IT'S JUST "1.35 TRILLION INR OR 16.3 BILLION DOLLARS ! + COST OF DISRUPTIONS IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF INDIA ROUND THE YEAR".*

[@heisenbergyo5578]

Real peace has been atoned by the guy sitting behind the mp lol

[@atulsahu8784]

bloody banana republic

[@santhoshrajadurairaj5042]

Full support to One nation, One election 👏👏👏

[@dibyochowdhury4514]

We Indians are in the favour of "One Nation, One Election"

[@madana1507]

One nation one election🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@sagar-ip7gg]

One nation one election is good Idea 🇮🇳

[@shanb2631]

An opinion for clarity …. But the power goes to one person right .?? That will make opposition tougher

[@sunnygupta1320]

Fight should be over facts

[@SsdMaster-c6p]

We are with ONOE 🎉❤

[@Dolutraveller93]

Shrikant shinde 🔥🔥

[@srinivasanrajagopalan3140]

Support one election and one nation ❤

[@sagnikpatra9391]

Kalyan Banerjee 🤦‍♂

[@vidyanair77]

- How about making changes in model code of conduct to ensure development isnt obstructed. - How about reducing the tenure from 5 to 4 years for state and central elections? This will ensure that political crisis in a particular state will not make people suffer for far too long - What happens when government loses the trust vote after a year or mid term? - Why give an option to the corrupt politicians to come back every 5 years?

[@JagbirRanwa]

Kalyan Banerjee next election harenge

[@pradippatel8466]

The uneducated will never understand One Nation One Election.😂😂😂

[@somduttiwari1713]

Muje lgta hai nda pass nahi kr paygi dono sansad me

[@NirkashBali]

Dimag hota to 2019 me late tab dono me pass hota ab kaha se hoga

[@ShubhrajyotiMallick]

​@@NirkashBali don't underestimate the power of a common man. Bill to jarur pass hoga.

[@BhaumikPatel-o]

Us time pasmad pasmada kiya.khus karne mai rah gaye.leki game hoga bjp majority mai a jayeagi dek Lena​@@NirkashBali

[@aayushkumargupta2195]

​@@BhaumikPatel-opta nai modi ka pasmanda bukhar utra ki nai or sbka sath sbka vikas wala bukhar v.. 😂

[@AjayKumar-yv3yg]

Pass ho jaiyaga agar government chahe toh

[@SubhamDas-y5s]

JAI HIND JAI BHARAT JAI MODI JI ❤️🇮🇳❤️.

[@siasia_2000]

9:12 kalyan bannerjee barking ??

[@soumyomondal]

One nation one election is necessary for our country

[@swapnilraja1409]

😂😂😂 Pahele bolo ELECTIC Machine se vote karwa DIYA 😂😂😂sansad ke andar 😂😂😂EVM ko kya nakaro ge😂❤❤❤

[@Jaxteller-c5j]

Seats won- zero Wild opinions - millions😂 chaddi alliance

[@vivekmuradayil5594]

Hamara tax paisa kalayan baki logo ka paisa nahi

[@Newbie-su2lb]

These MPs are not representing us! 😮

[@georgefernandes848]

Why Opposition can't stay quite and listen?

[@davidf2623]

Majority of Indians support this bill..

[@VJ_Nic]

Desh k dalle bhaunk rahe h 😂 Dr. Ambedkar has made the provision of ONOE but later due to congress misuse of article 356 to dismiss elected state govt… these blunders occurred 🤦‍♂️

[@kniharika6634]

One nation one election,save money 💰 & save bharat Jai shree ram Jai Modiji.🎉🎉🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🕉️🕉️

[@Rajnikant-eu4ej]

Kya zhant ukhad lega

[@shankarkendre1579]

Its not new in india all ready intial years of independence all elections are done simultaneously how its inconstituational??

[@bhakarsabgaisadiqali9814]

🦂B🦂 j 🦂p🦂

[@palungshakkum2640]

Before bringing up ONOE ..implement the CAA first ..my feet

[@Ranjankumar-kx3nb]

Full support to ONOE

[@Gamingblastllegend]

संविधान निर्माता ने जब 3इलेक्शन साथ में कराए तब तो कोई प्रोबलेम नहीं था,,इनको आज क्यों प्रोबलेम है?

[@florineroche4702]

Stop politicians contesting from two constituencies Orr from resigning to contest assembly or MP seat ad per their whims. Also stop those in jail fm.contrstint. they can't serve people from.jail

[@Jamesbond-f2n]

Full support!

[@ravindravarna8783]

I support - One Nation One Election