Relationship Expert Reacts to JUSTIN + HAILEY BIEBER 3 | Addressing The Abuse

[@flower656]

Well Gigi and Bella have Lyme disease too and I don’t see them acting like him . 🙄

[@videolover988]

Gigi doesn’t have Lyme, anwar, Bella and Yolanda have Lyme I think his anxiety and low self esteem are the reason he is irritated all the time

[@WhiteNoiseOpEdCommentary]

There is no test for Lyme disease so they just need two symptoms & they say you have it so there’s also no real cute He might just be mean! 😂😂😂

[@WhiteNoiseOpEdCommentary]

I think she doesn’t give him enough time away from her We would all be tired of her & anybody else if we were with them all the time plus she really has had everything handed to her I think he respects Selena because she works hard & has worked for her fame Nobody handed it to her and Selena worked so they had time to miss each other

[@dylanwhite3383]

@@videolover988 yea i agree with you

[@cru1743]

@@videolover988 how would u know if he has low self aseem or anxiety? youre self diagnosing him when you dont even know him

[@victoriariddiough1963]

Imagine how happy hailey would be if she was in a relationship with someone who actually appreciates her

[@anaisdaniels1211]

She already is

[@ioanabbb5563]

why are ppl acting like she can't get out of the relationship, girlie has been obsessed w justin for years, she wants to be w him lol

[@taynarasantos1997]

@@anaisdaniels1211 NO , you’re really crazy about your favs

[@taynarasantos1997]

@@ioanabbb5563 yeah she’ll tolerating everything from Justin , she just wanna keep this marriage the rest of her life.

[@emilyblanzy7426]

It’s not always that simple especially if the person has a history with ANY kind of abuse (on the receiving end) ... there’s something called trauma bonding where victims of abuse bond with people who cause them trauma or disrespect and they do this because of their past relationships or childhood and how they were treated and if they went thr abuse affects their ability to be more okay with abuse then someone who hasn’t been thr it

[@taynarasantos1997]

Justin found a babysitter, i think this relationship is really weird

[@5954ldydi]

Unfortunately I have to agree.

[@ksachith4739]

That’s you; hailey and him don’t care

[@thesizz925]

"I think this relationship is wierd " Says a person who get to a conclusion by seeing cringy fake tik tok

[@cierraaaj]

Yes Selena didn’t want to deal with his shit but Hailey who always wanted him is willing to deal with it to make their marriage work

[@taynarasantos1997]

@@thesizz925 🙄

[@perfectlyimperfect4508]

He didn’t say anything to her… He did the “look” to her hand She knows the look. That’s why she pulled back and sat back right away. She is trying to not piss him off! This is so sad

[@habibihaya]

Time stamp?

[@shay5222]

thats not the full video they were watching a game and he told her something and she laughed right after but of course they dont show that

[@sofiarodrigues6675]

exactly, someone finally explained what happen!! In this type of relationship you learn to read the other person and he or she doesn't even have to say a word...

[@f.t.6764]

My sister is an exact same relationship, with a narcissistic abuser. He has done everything wrong to her yet she is still with him. He hurts her sadistically in every level yet she loses sleep about thr things SHE must change. The victim always succumbs to the abusers distorted and egopathic perspective on the world and relationships and lack of morality and they end up adapting to the abuse and to the abuser's tastes and distastes. As a family we've done everything to get my sister out of this relationship yet because she's a legal adult there's only so much we can do and because she is so much gaslighted by him she now has replaced even bad memories of the abuse with lies and calls us delusional and psycho when we try to remind her what he did (and still does) to her. And every time she does it and says we were and are good me and my parents are in shock. I'm heartbroken that a person can be so much in denial and so deep in it... Especially when it's your own TWIN sister... I don't know what to do. I'm jn therapy with two autoimmune diseases and because I'm loosing all my hair due to alopecia and all these things were triggered into existence cause of her, her abuse and how he had made der suicidal for a whole year and at the shame time she is physically lashing on to us whenever he torments her and kicks her out of his place as a form of sadism and punishment when she "misbehaves" and of course cause of her denial of it. I'm in therapy when SHE should be in therapy and when she should get out of this misery. But she thinks the worst that she deserves is the best. So disheartening and exhausting. Narcissists kill you slowly and they first make you crazy. And all your environment and people that love you are directly affected by it as well. It's like they're serial killers without lifting a finger. These are anthropomorphic monsters are a literal danger to humanity and are literal cancer. So raise your girls (and boys) to never tolerate abuse and to always have boundaries, standards, self love and self respect. And practice that every day as parents. EVERY DAY.

[@perfectlyimperfect4508]

@@f.t.6764 I’m so sorry you , your family , and your sister have gone through so much . You all are in my prayers 💕

[@SecretHollywood]

"Justin is not funny. His sense of humor is horrible" LOL so true. I could never be with someone like that but whatever. You have to think if this is how he treats her ON CAMERA it is probably worse off camera.

[@anaisdaniels1211]

Y’all are so dumb! He doesn’t treat her terribly at all. These videos are edited & out of context. You could never be w/ someone like him, GOOD FOR YOU. He wouldn’t choose you either. They’re perfect together & that’s all that matters

[@ina43431]

@@anaisdaniels1211 just because you’re okay with men treating you like trash and have probably grown up seeing and thinking this is normal doesn’t mean it is. he can’t treat his wife like that, and hailey is so invested in him that she doesn’t give a damn about what he does. selena said it herself he was emotionally abusive and that’s why he settled for girl who he knew is evidently more emotionally submissive, and would stand by him no matter what.

[@PrettyboiYT]

What makes you think a high tier guy like that would date you anyway LOL “the entitlement”. He’s 0.00001% of the planet

[@NhungHong-if2ij]

dude he seriously says that these videos r so out of context dont u hear?

[@PrettyboiYT]

@Louis Kingsta I don’t believe in the term “emotional abuse”. This is a very victim mentality to have. And as guys , we live in reality not a fairytale like girls

[@tesskaiser2190]

I feel like he definitely finds her physically attractive. I don't think he finds her intellectually attractive. He's always just a passive aggressive jerk to her.

[@biancadivinia4424]

cuz shes probably not very smart😅

[@reallygreat1505]

He can't find her intellectually attractive cause she keeps tolerating his BS

[@tesskaiser2190]

@@reallygreat1505 and shes deep like a puddle. Biggest worry is losing engagement ring or Bieber necklace.

[@reallygreat1505]

@@tesskaiser2190 I don't understand how she's okay being unhappy. Justin actually loves Selena cause she challenges him and he doesn't want to put in the work to change. he just cares for Hailey and that's it. That's why he's sexually attracted to her buh doesn't really respect her. If she wasn't so pretty.. he wouldn't have married her and I think that's sad. I've never seen him sexualizing Selena.. she won't let him do that to her.

[@tesskaiser2190]

@@reallygreat1505 Selena knows her worth. Hailey's mom showed her how to eat SH*T with a smile apparently. What an awesome lesson to teach her daughter. If you weren't so pretty I'd have gotten rid of you long ago. Noice

[@martacalabrese6736]

im genuinely so happy selena isn’t with him anymore

[@jollylola473]

I believe this marriage was a blessing in disguise for Selena tbh

[@ohitsmsollie.ollielee893]

Both are toxic for each other, no matter how much they love each other

[@Azarath_Metrion_Zinthos]

I'll be even more happy when selena isn't with anyone anymore 😂

[@pearlfischer4528]

@@Azarath_Metrion_Zinthos you love her that much awwwwe 🥰

[@ryrysam8464]

True

[@Potatocheesebread]

I don’t think fame stunted his emotional growth. It might be a contributing factor, but it isn’t the main reason. He had an unstable home with an absent father and a mother who was just 17 when she had him. He was broken before, but the signs shows when he’s older. Many child actors like Zendaya, Cole Sprouse, they got famous at a really young age but they had an amazing foundation which is their family besides them, and they’re literally the most charming human beings I know. So I don’t think fame is the main reason.

[@pipinm2214]

I was thinking about Zendaya and the Sprouse twins, I think the environment you have as child contributes to how you turn out as an adult, at least to an extent. Zendaya seems to have a protective family around her and I think it kept her grounded. I don't know much about Justin but I think having fame at such a young age and coming from an unstable family makes it worse.

[@anabelleh2069]

I think people who always try to defend him always blame it on being a celebrity at a young age he isn’t a little kid anymore he’s a grown ass man who acts like a selfish child he’s disgusting and abusive and it’s not what people write about him it’s what he himself has shown to be

[@janeryan2709]

You know? You...know?

[@f.t.6764]

I've known people that come from very abusive and toxic familial environments and they were aware of their faults in their character and how they were a result of that environment and took accountability and are now amazing people and emotionally mature and empathetic individuals with good intentions and not sadistic tendancies, misogynistic views and toxic and abusive behaviour. Bieber is an adult and he knows right from wrong. He just doesn't care that he does wrong and is a piece of shxt cause he has a sense or untouchability and immunity. The environment is a big factor but it's still an excuse. Cause at the end of the day if your nature is to be a good person and if you WANT to be one, you WILL be. That loser is unapologetically toxic. Cause he wants to and cause it's in his nature. Plain and simple. He was emotionally abusive to Selena too and when she exposed the truth all his obsessed fans attacked her.

[@r.k.6483]

…dude. He literally said that no one would ever say “no” to him since he first got famous. Imagine going through 10+ years of your life getting anything you wanted. It definitely affects your mental growth. People grow through difficult experiences and money solves a lot of worldly problems.

[@ina43431]

selena said he was emotionally abusive, she’s more mature than him in age as well, and there’s a massive age gap between her and hailey. guess he picked the girl who he knew would stand by him and settle for his BS no matter what. smart move on his part.

[@auroperrone]

"Massive age gap" lol you don't really know what a massive age gap is

[@whatisilyionlyknowipurpleyou]

What the hell? This made no sense on any level. First you say Selena claimed he was abusive emotionally towards her and the end you mention that Justin chose to stick by Haliey because she would be the only one who could tolerate the abuse???

[@taynarasantos1997]

@@whatisilyionlyknowipurpleyou Selena was abused by Justin but they had a lot of fights because Selena is millionaire and famous like him and never would be submissive like Hailey , but of course in a lot of moments she also was a little submissive but Hailey is more and more submissive of course and always she fakes a perfect marriage . Sorry about my english, I’m learning

[@thatrandomirishpotato4779]

@@taynarasantos1997 your English is very good 👍

[@kiks2793]

selena dated justin at 18 when he was 16, and justin and hailey are 2 years apart so uh??

[@Joemaniac]

I hate imagining how much Justin must have hurt Selena. 2 yrs later cringing at my own comment.

[@mxlahpta]

Yea same :/

[@fabulicioustee9244]

And he loved her and poor Hailey must be having it bad since he doesn’t even love her

[@cristinaatenco6443]

and many other women

[@Azarath_Metrion_Zinthos]

@@cristinaatenco6443 oh boohoo cry me a river with the petty woman issues

[@heydeeeguia8421]

He is competing with Selena that's why it's not mutual. He's not focusing with the relationship.

[@TheMothernerd]

They don't need marriage counselling, JUSTIN needs therapy to work on himself.

[@Heatherzrule]

I think Hailey knows she was a rebound or at the very least a relationship of convenience for him.. she clearly worships him, and he loves that, but doesn't see her as an equal and gets easily irritated by her affection and neediness. There's no challenge for him, he gets to act however he wants and she just tolerates it, I don't think he has a lot of respect for her. To me it seems that the biggest difference in his relationship with Selena was that he chased her and she had the upper hand in their relationship a lot. I think having that much power over Hailey and not being challenged is boring for him.

[@samiid6391]

I think you’re right. Justin loves the chase

[@Vanillaaxo]

So true being too needy is boring and exhausting

[@jojijosette5946]

Good analysis. He abused Selena too, but she did not put up with it, that's why they kept breaking up.

[@lisaphillips9991]

Every man loves the chase, they are the male...Selena wasn't putting up with it. While Hailey is his door mat, she just accept whatever he does and says..

[@aya-_-3045]

definetly agree with you. he chased selena and she challenged him and didnt put up with his shit. hailey kinda lets him do whatever and he seems bored and doesnt seem to respect her tbh. i dont think he respected either of them

[@twisted__stars_]

"Justin Bieber is not funny. Nobody had ever just cracked up at what he's said" had me infact cracked TF up 😂

[@ellabgoldsmith]

No fr🤣🤣

[@nik.kinetikentertainment2298]

I had never thought of this before but it’s true 😆

[@CradleRobbingRuthy]

I looked around the internet for anything funny from Justin, nope, just Justin la douche

[@jacobbake1094]

I think he’s funny he’s not a comedian tho

[@Sasha75995]

Right 😭😭😭😭😂😂😂😂

[@alisak58]

The comments that his management & mother made about Hailey being 'good for him' & ' just what he needs' but no one said they were happy for her or implied that he was good for her. It just seemed they all knew he needed a new minder/ mother and that they felt she was up to the task...smh

[@virginiasugliano8611]

that series is so fucked up, they didn't even realize what they were putting into it, each and every interview has something low key or high key off

[@cookielyon3937]

dude!!! yessss!!!!! now that you have brought it to my attention that is true!!!

[@AlejandraGarcia-st8wi]

Ella tiene muy baja autoestima.ademas de que no hace nada ni brilla por si misma. Parece su sombra

[@darkeststar3640]

I've never heard Justin's mom say helly is good for Justin. She's always said Selena was good for Justin and she loved Justin and Selena together.

[@eleonoraaaaaa]

in my opinion this relationship has always been really toxic. as i’ve been in one myself, if i put myself in hailey’s shoes i would feel trapped and guilty if i wanted to break up with him. he’s always showing gratitude on interviews, all the love songs about her.. i feel like “oh he’s writing all these songs about me, he just gets mad sometimes but he loves me i promise!!” i get triggered every time i see them together. she’s not truly happy and you can see that from how she talks or looks at him. i’ve always loved justin’s music but i will always stand for Hailey.

[@juanitaflorescabrera537]

Yep he's hella toxic I Know I been in one myself

[@cristinaatenco6443]

he is a weirdo n narcisist

[@eleonoraaaaaa]

@@speed2834 he does with most of them though

[@taniaglezr84]

Yep, I had a similar relationship and always blamed myself when he were at defensive mood. Hailey needs someone as charming as her.

[@eleonoraaaaaa]

@@taniaglezr84 absolutely!!

[@benny9913]

This was Hailey’s number one goal in life since she was young. She worked for years and waited around for him while he was with every other girl. She will stand by Justin regardless how he treats her. She also knows how to turn on the charm in front of cameras. I’ve seen them ride in the car together not saying a word, and as soon as they are in public she smiles non stop and is constantly hugging and loving on Justin. Her mom has given her advice on how to date men like this. I don’t think either one will change much… they both know what they got into with this marriage and we should wish them the best. Celebrity relationships are a whole different animal… a lot of perks, and a whole mess of cons. You can’t diagnose it like you would a normal couple’s relationship. Unless you’re in that world, you’ll never truly understand.

[@Foxy11123]

I agree with u… the same as politician … they always have two face … cause that what they selling , their image to public …

[@Shannon606]

I agree this relationship is fan girl and troubled pop star! My aunt is great friends with her mom. She is actually a very humble sweet woman . Def. not because of her mom. Haileys parents let my family have a repass for my uncle at their home. This is all Hailey in my opinion. Fan girl who fell in love with a pop star but got Justin the troubled person!

[@tatik-22]

True.

[@victoriahaines8211]

Yep

[@samridhi4719]

So true!!!

[@ana.jensie]

I literally hate when people tell me no relationships are perfect & everyone fights like why? If you can improve other aspects of your life and grow why not do the same in relationships

[@AnthonyRecenello]

yuppers puppers

[@gloriaw1379]

Right! I've been married for 21 years and my hubs and I don't fight.

[@listentome271]

Tbh I don’t think any relationship is perfect but I think every relationship could and should always be improving

[@avoelle2605]

I'm inrelationship for a year I can tell you that we never fight something really serious. Me and my boyfriend got into a fight when im so bored I just want to annoy him but he literally dont care if I shout or I over acting. he's like "oyeah baby is bored again" and Im so happy to have a person that matured enough to be focus on the things that will make our emotional mentally and physically health healthy. so yeah there's no perfect relationship yes but you make a relationship felt home.

[@cupcake123462]

You can but people are different and have different personalities that not everything your partner likes youll like, in the end no matter what you can end up fighting no marriage can be truly perfect where you truly don’t fight about anything if that was the case then you’re lying to yourself. In the end what matters is how you approach conflict and how you handle conflict with your partner. There’s going to be fights it just all matters how two people can handle that conflict and how things are said. Because even when there’s fighting you can still say things with love,respect and wisdom. Which honestly the Bieber’s are only a few years into their marriage they still have so much to learn about themselves and part of making a marriage or any relationship work is learning to be mature and grow up from both sides.

[@atika540]

It's a shaky relationship, a rushed marriage. Justin marries a fan and assumes that she will stay wise since she idolizes him. Hailey wanting to be in the limelight so even with therapy things won't work. We talk more about sex than love in their story. Now, the fact that he can't stand her constantly touching him is a feeling we all have. Sometimes we need to find ourselves in our bubble and not feel suffocated. Hailey needs to have her own moments of freedom in order to have the pleasure of being together, but she's so afraid to leave him alone that it will lead to a breakup in the long run.

[@cristinaatenco6443]

uffff terrible

[@Jess0423]

One thing I will say from just what I see, is Hailey is too touchy and I'd get irritated and need some space also. To each their own. I am very affectionate but she's too much it seems.

[@sakurakty7121]

Divorce*

[@HAHA-kk2xy]

I think she is a sweetheart idk what y'all are smoking.

[@samiid6391]

@@Jess0423 I have to say I agree. I think Justin is a super douche about it, but she does kind of seem smothering to him sometimes. No excuse for him to be mean tho

[@imaneel784]

He is emotionally abusing her cause he knows that she loves him and she always loved him so he is sure that she will NEVER leave him all he has to do is tell her sorry and she will forgive him on EVERYTHING and she is okay with that cause she wants that attention and he knows that as well that’s why they post a lot in their social media letters of love and how she saved his life , they will have children but he will divorce her

[@AsapChalan]

Didn’t he do that with Selena too. There’s a reason why Selena’s mom disowned her after taking Justin back.

[@ElizRued]

@@AsapChalan yea just see justin after Selena and selena. he IS the pattern. Abuse is the action:( its codependency and abuse. Been there and done that. Hopefully they look for therapy and act on it. It will help if its consistent whatever action they have to take

[@sylviaj3010]

I don’t think they will have kids

[@Carolina-rd3gh]

Right on the money!

[@intotheunknown2363]

Exactly, reason why hailey isnt having kids with him. He will be done with her. He loves kids n ofcourse wants to have his own. He has always said he wants have a family young and no one in sane mind would have kids with him n become a single mother knowingly just for money. Also she needs some more years before she will get to a state where people know her without the bieber surname

[@Lamby495]

It’s actually not about being famous.. it’s that fact that becoming famous can be Traumatic, and Trauma can stunt emotional growth

[@frummel403]

Yeah.. well I might be a simple person, but I think Justin would be the same piece of shit if he didn't get famous, he'd just be the office bully fucking over his colleagues for a shitty promotion. It's scary when people like that get famous and rich.

[@BrandonG444]

Yeah getting paid millions on millions of dollars a year, getting any girl you want, traveling anywhere in the world you want too is so traumatic lol

[@tasneem6114]

@@frummel403 he would just be like his dad

[@frummel403]

@@tasneem6114 You know what they say: learnt in the cradle is carried to the grave

[@tasneem6114]

@@frummel403 yep sadly. his dad was in and out of jail, physically assaulted people, did a bunch of drugs and went to parties. there was a time where justin did the same things

[@shannonbowling7215]

Just a note: I am a chronic Lyme sufferer and when it is bad you can not stand to have people touch you.

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Wow very interesting thanks Shannon.

[@thegardener3650]

And why is that? Is it because it physically hurts or is it something else?

[@ina43431]

@@thegardener3650 it ruins your immune system leaving you to feel like shit 24/7.

[@Babylexxx]

how come if you don’t mind me asking?

[@thumperasasha2201]

@@Babylexxx because nobody wants to feel smothered or over touched when you're hurting and feeling like complete crap. You just wanna be left alone sometimes honestly

[@frutigermetroboomin]

That "I WASN'T TRYING!" was literally terrifying. I can't even laugh at it.

[@sophiagabrielleachacoso6663]

all I know is Shawn Mendes would NEVERRR

[@PinksMidori]

You're 100% right about that ! He treats Camila like a queen . He carries her purse and bags, always holds her hand, speaks so loving about her, is a total gentleman , the list goes on and on. Also he was famous very young , but hes mature . Shawn is a role model for how to treat women , guys need to take notes from him.

[@sararockybrown3242]

@@PinksMidori yeah that’s why he yelled at her over yogurt 😂

[@l.adodg3r70]

He would yell at me

[@ktsb1563]

i think rob lowe had a point about immaturity. like becoming that famous that young is likely very traumatic (also the music industry is probably one of the most predatory legal industries but thats speculative to assume jb went through abuse from being in the industry) and trauma left untreated can make aspects of your emotional maturity pause/halt.

[@kkuczak0001]

Watch his music video yummy & him cry for Billie Ellish (hoping that what happened to him won't happen to her). Then see what you think.

[@ktsb1563]

@@kkuczak0001 i do think he was likely abused but w/o him telling his story its completely speculative.

[@antisocialapple7795]

I mean. Kinda depends if you can handle the transition I guess. And unfortunately doesn't look like certain people could.

[@Cammay15]

Lol my fiance accidentally slammed a car door on my foot because he thought I was going to get out on the other side, but he apologized and made sure I was okay. Idk if Justin just didn't notice but that looked bad.

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Nah because that’s a busy city street.

[@anaisdaniels1211]

He thought she was going the other way as well

[@paiger1084]

No way he was pissed about something look how he acted after she got out ... I don't know about any of theses ppl .

[@anaisdaniels1211]

@@paiger1084 they were smiling right after this at lunch

[@taylor7077]

@@anaisdaniels1211 he told you that?

[@JR-md9rz]

Haley running and falling, while he's on a skate board, we'll he knew she couldn't keep up!!! How about waiting for your wife, and covering her, make sure she's safe and ok, period. Be a man, be a husband. I think he humiliates her to keep her in line. And to keep her from challenging him again, in any way. Even if its her simply giving an opinion etc, if he's not interested, your gonna pay....

[@thesizz925]

That video was 6 year old when they were not married idiot

[@JR-md9rz]

@@thesizz925 I think your directing your anger in the wrong direction. I did post that pic. But take that one out ok, know it all (super fan) lol. There's plenty more to look at, js. Irregardless Hailey deserves more respect, period. You got issues, take it up w/ Anthony, Scott Travis lmfao 😆

[@thesizz925]

@@JR-md9rz doesnt change the fact that you are wrong they were not married at that time just freinds

[@isabellarose6514]

They weren't even dating back then. They were just two friends hooking up.

[@ina43431]

she’s definitely walking on egg shells

[@chocokat97]

Justin seems to have a lot of anger pent up inside. He might be the kind of person who would never be violent, but emotional abuse can wear a person down, even someone who is strong. It is also okay to not want someone to touch you sometimes, it can be when you’re overstimulated. I know people can be helped but if he can’t be helped, I hope it doesn’t wear down Hailey over time.

[@kaylacorinne37]

i’ve come to realize if someone is willing to show that kind of anger and emotional abuse it is very likely it will escalate to physical abuse at some point

[@nadamahmoud6915]

He found a babysitter or a mother and she has been so obsessed w him ever since she was a kid she is a fan she will do anything to please him and satisfy even if it will humiliate her dignity. It’s sad that women do this to themselves for men who ain’t worthy anyway the kind of relationships don’t last I promise I have been there before

[@tarotdreamseverythinginbet350]

Well said!!!

[@soulrelaxation5977]

Were you as patient as she is?

[@nadamahmoud6915]

@@soulrelaxation5977 yes cuz i loved him back then but by time this love died slowly

[@soulrelaxation5977]

@@nadamahmoud6915 love who? Your man or Justin? If is Justin he doesn't even care. So stop. His wife is good with what she is doing so let's just encourage her struggle cos she is not complaining. After all all men love humble women. They are big babies.

[@nadamahmoud6915]

@@soulrelaxation5977 lmfao i am talking about my ex why would i love justin i just related to haily and i had the same toxic relationship like ha that's all

[@ina43431]

she was so young and naive and settled for him because he’s justin bieber. she won the social climber medal, this is her dream

[@menottu]

Her childhood fantasy too, w/ all his $$$$ as the perk of a lifetime. The reason her father & mother groomed her to get in his inner circle, stalk @ any cost, go to the same church in order to seduce him. She grew up in Rockland county, ny. NOT LA where the jenners r from. So somewhere along the way, before she got married @ 21, for years, she was able to get to where he was at. What was she 12 yrs. old, when her dad introduced them. Sick. But that’s hollyweird for u. Check the timeline. She married @ 21/22, claims they “knew each other” for 10 years. How was she “ allowed/ able “ to go all around the country, following Justin, his friends, church in Miami, w/ out her parents involved???

[@f.t.6764]

@Annointed peal. That's where you're wrong. Read the comment above you. Hailey is enamoured and obsessed with her disinterested abusive and narcissistic husband who she was fangirling over during her teen years. But that was ingrained by her parents. She grew up with abusive misogynistic pos in her family, the Baldwins, with a parent who didn't care about having an empowered daughter, but cared about remaining in the Hollywood cycle and relevancy and maintaining the wealth. Cause he is the lesser known Baldwin or the two brothers, her father. And even the known one, with his wife's scandal, is now ridiculed and a bit out of relevancy. And look who is the wealthiest and most relevant of them all: HAILEY. But she is in denial about all of the superficiality of it. She is miserable and has been conditioned by the men in her own family to tolerate and normalise abuse from narcissists. It's not a choice when it's all you've known your whole life and when you think that the worst is the best thst you deserve. That girl has no self esteem. She was literally caught many times stalking fan accounts of selena gomez and Instagram accounts of selena and Bieber shipers. Meanwhile it's been almost 10 years from that situation and Selena stood her ground, exposed bieber for the abuser that he was to her too and is now happy and away from him. So Hailey doesn't know any better, so it's not a choice really. And for all these reasons, I, pity her VERY MUCH. That woman deserves better. She can make money as herself and be equally relevant. She's beautiful, talented in interviewing, from what her KZbin channel shows and she already has wealth. All she needs to do is believe in herself and not be dependent on men, even more so TOXIC and abusive excuses of men. It's so sad. I hope she wakes up and breaks free and finds her boundaries and happiness. Cause at the moment she's the opposite of happy, she's living a miserable life and delusions of happiness and all of it tied up in a golden bow. The thing is that you can wrap up shζt and make it look like it's a present but at the end of the day it's still a turd in a bow. Unfortunately, she's deep in it, I doubt she'll ever leave him, on the other hand he'll break up with her the moment he finds another one to manipulate, torment and play god with and treat them life their benefactor. Sad, sad, sad.

[@Jay23487]

Look she exactly knew that marrying justin is the "craziest " thing she is ever gonna do she is not naive but she went with it with wathever she was thinking which I don't know but she knew from the beginning, being with him for lifetime is gonna be "crazy"

[@nicolejackson7134]

I agree. I think she loves the fact that she is now a list celebrity then she loves him.

[@helloworld2784]

Funny that every person bringing her down on this thread are all women. Woooh let's go victim blame another woman because she married a toxic man! Haha good on her! 🙄

[@e-feitonachina2921]

hailey is very patience. either she will be tolerating this for her whole life or at some point she will really get tired of it and find someone else

[@taynarasantos1997]

Of course she’ll be tolerating all bad situations

[@nataliam.8322]

@@user-Imani yeah it came out in the news that her dad cheated on her mom with a massage therapist but they're still together

[@ina43431]

she’s been social climbing her whole life so marrying justin bieber is THE ultimate jack pot. she’s staying until he decides to leave.

[@water3345]

@@ina43431 and without him signing a prenup lmao, she struck gold

[@juanitaflorescabrera537]

@@water3345 for real though 🤑

[@cgygflkj]

After the Gabby Petito case we should never EVER assume anything is "obvious" in a relationship

[@Kanakdev99]

I have been in a relationship like this . The problem is that when u are in there u cant really see it because u keep weighing the good things with the bad things . You choose the happy times over the fucked up times. You just dont see how fucked up the things are. You choose to ignore it and tell yourself if only i can make this work. But now years later after getting out of that place. When i finally saw how much i was in denial and was trying so hard i worked on healing and also i worked on myself too. I know breakups can be hard and make you feel bitter towards relationship but there is so much out there . I became more kind and understanding and understood where to put my energy and where to say no. So if anyone is going through this. If u are here and u realise what is going on then congrats u completed the first step of realising it. The hard part is to move out of it and and get help. Currently i am in a much healthier relationship where i get unconditional love and support. He is my childhood bestfriend and he showed me how much a relationship brings to the table. And we never had a big fight but we do work and talk if anything bothers us . Communication is the key.

[@isabellarose6514]

I have a question. I hope I'm not being impolite but the person you were with before did they know that they were a problem and actively work on themself?

[@Kanakdev99]

@@isabellarose6514 No thats not impolite at all. Well things did not ended well between us. He did asked me to stay friends with him after an year of breaking up with him . But he started being inappropriate and soon I realised why did he wanted to be friends after the breakup. I tried to talk some sense but it didnt work. At last i just had to leave because being in touch with him was making my emotional state worse so i just blocked him and moved on.

[@nykhiarines]

So happy for u girl!

[@Elizabeth84517]

I’ve been there too.

[@Kanakdev99]

@@nykhiarines this means so much to me that u took the pain to read my big ass comment and being such an angel 😭. Thank u ❤️

[@MissLeonable]

I always used to think it’s normal to fight in a relationship. Now I‘m in a truly loving one and we never fight. I really want him to be happy, because he‘s the most wonderful person.

[@run2.thefather]

I would love to see you react to Selena and Justin and their whole years of dating/interacting. Not because I want them together or wish they were. Not even to compare him with Hailey vs Selena. Just because I’ve always wanted a professionals opinion on them. A lot feel he toxic and a lot feel he really loved her but idk

[@luluwilliams8434]

No, no, no. I won’t accept a guy to treat me like this. I have been married for 20 years and marriage is not perfect but I don’t approve an abusive relationship.

[@thegardener3650]

Also, Hailey has said for a while now that they have been going to couples therapy for at least a coupe of years now.

[@AnthonyRecenello]

That’s great.

[@cassandrawaldenmaier8142]

Also Anthony when you were talking about your girlfriend you can see how much you’re grateful for the relationship and in love I can’t help but aww at it

[@claudiao7743]

Right? It’s so wholesome and mature how he talks about his relationship.

[@twinklearlington]

She reminds me so much of how I was in my last relationship. He was an abusive narcissist and things started getting bad when he slapped my ass in public. It degenerated from there but I kept hoping I could explain to him how his behavior was hurting me. After two years, he cheated on me, and then I experienced some of the worst pain I've ever experienced. I loved the "nice side" of him and it was pure hell accepting that person had never been real. I allowed myself to be fooled and abused and dragged into a dynamic I should never have been in at my age. But I had just come out of a horrific divorce where my family and my ex ganged up on me and then shunned me (they still are) and I was in such a sad and desperate place when I met him that I just clung to him despite the red flags. Many things happened where I could have been badly hurt or killed. I think Justin is an abusive narcissist too. I really feel for Hailey. It's so hard to leave sometimes.

[@ashleykelly9458]

I was engaged at 20 and was set to marry at 21, I ended that relationship and I am so glad that I didn't go through with it.

[@trinityputnam3666]

Omg same!

[@filipa8626]

I really like your analysis of them you were respectful about it and give the benefit of doubt in your analysis and took in consideration we don't really know them or are with them 24/7 i agree I feel like Hailey is like a babysitter to him and Justin team really made that point in those series which is really sad for Hailey she's so young feels like she could be taking on a lot and trying to help Justin fix his problems while maybe discarding herself but hey I don't really know them so this is just my assumptions

[@taynarasantos1997]

I agree

[@paiger1084]

I also agree 💯. I also agree that Hailey would never leave his side cuz I believe if she ever did he's going to run back to you know who ? The past of theses 2 so young will kill this relationship and Hailey mental state also in the long run I believe . I really hope not .

[@Foxy11123]

But wait we dont know hailey true inside … is she that good ??? Or she made that good to look good in public… we never know , young age doesnt mean u innocent even a kids can kill someone if they train to br that way… and with hailey background i dont think their family grow her to be that innocent kid …for me i think she is clever girl how can u turn a man to leave her previous 10th year relationship with just 2 month convince him to married her 😂😂😂 come on , i think she now what she doing, she know what she gonna going through , she just already prepared for it Hollywood live … also good friend with kardshian family no one innocent can go hand by hand with this family 😂😂😂😂🤣

[@jacksonrichard3754]

Anthony you speak so highly of hailey but I'm warning you she tried to sue a plastic surgeon who gave his opinion and said she had work done. I would be cautious around her. She reads everything about her and her relationship bc she is insecure. Therefore, she definitely knows who you are. I remember you said she gave you a dirty look in public

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Not a dirty look. Just was staring. It wasn’t rude. I’m a hot guy 🤣

[@mamimimusubi3116]

Ya I did my digging cuz I was really intrigued she and Justin remind me of an ex narcissist and his new primary supply. I know she used to stalk Justin while him and Selena were together she’s very sneaky and manipulative in my opinion cuz she hides behind an innocent persona but there are receipts for her stalking on Justin fan accounts

[@mamimimusubi3116]

I think they are both highly narcissistic Justin obviously more overt and hailey is more covert of course she seems like a victim but I don’t think she is

[@estiben9203]

@@mamimimusubi3116 tell me about your digging I need more

[@anaisdaniels1211]

@@mamimimusubi3116 you guys so WEIRD 😂😂 this fan fiction land you weirdos have created is beyond laughable at this point. She KNEW Justin since was 15. She was a FAN & the fact that y’all on the internet “digging” into people’s lives calling someone else a stalker? Do you have no self awareness to see how your weird ass is the STALKER!?? Unlike you, she was a fan that became a close friend of his after she started to hang out w/ the Jenners & his inner circle. She didn’t have to stalk anyone. Get a life you miserable bats

[@5954ldydi]

Having them on your channel would blow up KZbin and it would be great to watch especially since they have spoken about their relationship and the work they put into it. Let's not underestimate the power of networking and hope they will appear on your channel in the near future! :)

[@AC-jp1lm]

As someone who has been in very abusive relationships i really hope hailey is okay. Very concerned for her.

[@katjohnston9836]

I was a fan of Justin VERY early on in his career, (Debut - Believe era) and as much as I loved him as a kid, looking back, I don't remember him ever being like this (publicly)until the DUI incident, and it seems like everything went downhill from there. I do remember that he has talked about a wife/kids since he was very young. From a psychological perspective, it seems like he is also trying to create a stable family (which he didn't get to experience), but doesn't have the tools to create one ATM. Hopefully with therapy and time, he'll be able to have a family. As for him and Hailey, it does seem like she has taken on a caretaker role in their marriage. I think the part of the videos of them that gets me the most is her face before he looks back at her, it's completely solemn/sober until he does, then it's a huge smile that seems to dissipate quickly. I think people are hyper-focused on their relationship because of 1) how public Justin's mistakes have been 2) his relationship with Selena. I think if him and Selena had never been that "it" couple, the speculation would be 75% less. I was a preteen when him and Selena first got together, and man did I LOVE them back then, and I looked at them as relationship role models since my parents had never been good role models to look to in terms of what is right/wrong in romantic relationships (which was terrible, and my first relationship felt like almost an exact parallel to them). Selena was not perfect, as she has explained briefly her part in the relationship, and from an outsider's perspective, it seems like relationship throughout the years was creating an environment of reactive abuse for her. We'll never know exactly what happened, but I do think Selena's music and words have spoken volumes about his character. This is just my perspective though!

[@losttoni7528]

I think the notion that in a relationship you should be focused on making the other person happy before you should come with great BIG WARNING! I know this probably works for people who grew up surrounded by fairly normal and healthy relationships that would work really well, but as someone who grew up in a codependent relationship with their parents and also witnessing their codependent relationship it‘s really important that you always cover your basic needs and communicate those to your partner. I have had relationships with people that were really great and wanted to give me the same love and affection i gave them, but i would never show them when i struggled or needed them because in my head my worth was defined by how much i could give them and how i could fix their problems for them so they could be happier. So in principle being focused on your partner‘s happiness is a great mindset, but you should also make sure to allow them to do the same.

[@AnthonyRecenello]

I agree. I hope it’s assumed that all my advice is targeted to typical people and not with people who are already working with psychologists on a certain condition. But in the end, it’s important no matter what to be vigilant in who you are dating and making sure they have your own interests in mind.

[@thegardener3650]

You mentioned that Justin's childhood neighbor made a Tik Tok about him. Did you end up finding it?

[@petralazic5923]

Tbh they are a great match because both of them stopped with their evolving and maturing at least it seems like that. Both of them seem overprotective and low key possessive but she is on much lower key. But why it works for them is because she doesn't stand up for herself in public unlike Selena. Justin was the same in both relationships but Hailey is just overlooking the problems while Selena spoke her truth.

[@thegoodinlife8729]

As someone who got married at 21, I can tell you I’m so glad our marriage was not put under a microscope those first 3 or so years. You really are so young still, and we got through it and I would say our relationship is a dream now compared but I do empathize because man getting married young can be tough. And we are now going on 9 years and so they can do it if they put in the work individually and together

[@shannonbowling7215]

Love this

[@shannonbowling7215]

I married at 21 also. We have been married 43 years. So glad we were not celebrities with paparazzi following. The first years were so rough.

[@kingayy9267]

@Shannon Bowling 43 years, wow! That's so sweet to see. Glad you (and the other commenter) were able to work out your early issues and hopefully are happy together all this time.

[@lesviesblanchescomptent]

Racemixer 🤢

[@travis6694]

This is how my boss is at Starbucks. It’s like 70% joking and 30% kidding. Everyone knows he’s actually being mean with his sarcasm because we all feel the same way about it.

[@hannahpatience]

Thank you for sharing that it’s possible to have a healthy relationship where fighting is a very rare occasion. It’s a much-needed reminder. Have you made a video about how to get to a place yourself where you are ready for that type of relationship and then how to identify the right partner?

[@empea3837]

Anthony, your commentaries are always honest, respectful, insightful. You’re a great relationship coach. (P.S. I hope you coach them in private ☺️.)

[@AbbyMerida]

I feel so bad for Haley.. on top of the pressure in her career i can’t imagine how stressful being married to him would be

[@Jadoreeee]

Im honestly shocked they've been together this long i thought once hailey grew up and matured she would realize there problems but i guess i was wrong🤷🏽‍♀️

[@ina43431]

she’s still sooo young. reminds me of how someone said leonardo dicaprio leaves women when they turn 25 cause at 25 that’s when you find your voice lmao

[@Foxy11123]

😂😂😂 she not that in matured … she not 23 or 24 pheasant or country girl … she grown up in Hollywood live no innocent or in-matured , she also friend with kardshian the drama family in the world that know what public wanted to watch for money and fame …she work as model that we all know how world their work … if she that in-matured she cant catch a big fish 😂😂😂 she know how emotional abuse justin are, she already prepare … come on this how to be famous and rich by doing drama sensation in the easy way … she learn from kardshian 🙄😂😂😂

[@Mari-sm9zp]

Very good points being made. I think it would be nice to do a video on selena. She got so much shit for not being the woman to "fix" him. That Hailey was the one who didn't give up on him. Even in that seasons videos everyone says "she's good for him" like a mother ?? That needs to be discussed even about Hailey how she's seen as the "good wifey" for "fixing" her husband. 2 roles of a woman the media the fans have put on these two ladies and left the man Justin in the victim role.

[@tasneem6114]

there's no way you believe the media was ever on justin's side. justin, hailey or selena were never innocent and the only person who claimed they were was selena

[@nataliamunoz9407]

NO ONE IS INOCENT HERE, Selena wasn't an angel but the media didn't bother to make that shît viral bc she's not Justin, if you really look, she was sooo toxic too (ex: she once SLAPED Justin on the face in public but that never went viral) AND THE MEDIA WAS NEVER ON JUSTIN'S SIDE, HE'S ALWAYS BEEN THE BAD GUY AND SELENA THE LITTLE ANGEL. THE MEDIA DISTROYED JUSTIN BUT THAT DOESN'T GO VIRAL

[@Mari-sm9zp]

Natalia Muñoz the fact that you're using those examples proves how you can't comprehend my point.and yes she did get the most shit media wise the only reason the couple has is because of petty fans. It's all a cycle of the industry and my point again it'd you can't understand- is that everyone is putting women's roles in relationships on blast yet no one is taking his role in all this. Idolizing celebrity relationships bad or good is disgusting and allows young fans like you who comment to develop your own view thinking this is "goals".

[@Mari-sm9zp]

grr grr your clearly a child fan and don't see the message here. But you're proving my point. The media does favor the man because look how you're shitting on selena your made to believe to pit two women against each other who are victims of this Guy - and you're being told what you should perceive as "love".

[@MiMi-rc1bv]

Your execuses for Justin‘s behaviour like this and that is „just“ a joke is not ok in my opinion. He is passive aggressive towards her, like the Karate gesture. My boyfriend would never behave this way cause he respects me.

[@jenniferl8967]

All these comments trying to analyze what’s wrong with Justin but I’m like….. girl Hailey…. Why you putting up with this 😭 You’re such a good partner and he’s so abusive 😭

[@sararockybrown3242]

It’s so sad how he abuses her in public as well

[@adrianamejia318]

hates hailey 🤢🤮

[@aqilahchase-hill]

That hockey game was a clear indication because I have been with someone like this before. You feel like your walking on egg shells. She was rubbing his shoulders and he looked at her hand and look annoyed and irritated and she felt that energy and she backed off. I was like omg hailey I felt so bad watching that clip.

[@lyaadonara1386]

You are so right. I was in toxic relationship for 3 years when I was younger & I can feel Haley. I remember being uncomfortable around my tummy & just by seing her leaning back I kinda get that feeling again. Ugh...

[@srslyfinnick]

the ig live video where he said the “don’t touch me” thing is actually super out of context! not a fan of justin by any means but to his credit, he was talking about the times when he DOES need space, and he’ll say things like that just straight up so she knows. that’s why he clarified and said “not right now, just in general”

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Yeah it seemed to be out of context.

[@kita3256]

Christian or not, Justin is just off. Something is very terrible off about him. And if people can’t see it, then 🤷🏻‍♀️ 🤯 Narcissistic traits all over him. And possibly Hailey is an enabler.

[@amymybelieber]

Seems to me like justin wants hailey to leave him alone and leave him forever vibe or i hate you i want you gone forever vibe Divorce is coming very soon this summer mark my words

[@bonak2531]

i think justin actually hates hailey in a way he wanted to waste her time with him, hurt her emotionally since she forces herself so much with him

[@tabithagrimes405]

He only loves Hailey as a friend not a wife.

[@jessepaul5643]

true

[@giyapuspus8449]

😥

[@annaec1822]

Woow that’s not how you treat a friend either

[@tabithagrimes405]

@@annaec1822 I agree with you .its really ashame

[@frnzilla]

Anthony as much as I love your channel, I think you’re being naive. I think that Justin Bieber is a narcissist, and it’s not one of those things that you can really *see* unless you’ve experienced it. I think it takes a certain type of sensitivity to detect. The exact sensitivity that one who faces this sort of thing would have. The abuse is so nuanced that you almost don’t know it’s there(even for the person being abused). It leaves you feeling confused, and second guessing yourself. On top of that, you end up being gaslit by yourself, the abuser, *and* the world, who, like you, chalk things up to “a terrible sense of humor” or “being charged or hyped up after a performance.” You keep saying you’re working hard to remain unbiased but it’s more like you’re working hard to remain BLIND. Narcissists are indeed children(emotionally speaking) but that man is an *adult*. And if you need to know more Dr. Ramani has a wide array of resources on her youtube channel on the subject. Her body of work on narcissists may be able to help you to detect it better. I’d hate for you to actually get that interview with the Bieber’s and not know what to look for.

[@frnzilla]

I don’t know what it is about Justin Bieber, whether you have a soft spot for him or something, but you’re absolving him from all accountability. I think you’re an *excellent* social cue reader, but I think this may be uncharted territory for you. I hope you find Dr. Ramani helpful.

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Hi Finesse! Did Dr. Ramani make a video diagnosing Justin with narcissism? Thanks!

[@immadebe6043]

@@AnthonyRecenello 🤣🤣🤣

[@frnzilla]

@@AnthonyRecenello Smh. Good luck w/ your interview. 🙏🏾

[@janeryan2709]

@@frnzilla Why "Smh" LOL

[@slim_stinaxoxo8226]

The feeling of being touched when I’m stressed or having anxiety or to my thoughts & my fiancé touches me, it’s irritating & only makes it worse. & I tell him that. It’s hard bc he does get upset & take offense. But once that time has passed, it’s MY responsibility to make sure he knows it wasn’t about him & for him to know I love him & nothing personal.

[@e-feitonachina2921]

I think u give good advice for all ages and cultures. thanks for sharing

[@AnthonyRecenello]

🙏🏻

[@Olivetree80]

It's so refreshing to actually hear someone refer to the cognitive functions.

[@irishelinac]

Oh my, you just explained narcissism to a tee. They do get stuck at a really young age, not all for being worldly famous but for being overvalued and praised by their surrounding, which might impact in the same way the brain. Hence the emotional evolution just stops there, at their perceived peak point in external validation. And the pattern is hard to change, positive inforcement and enablers doing their parts.

[@carmennlii]

I was thinking the exact same thing while watching this! I’ve watched so many videos on narcissistic personality disorders (and had many experiences with them) and he shows all the same red flags.

[@antonioaguirre9295]

I fee like it's the opposite, because my sister is the same way. She just doesn't like being touched period. She also can't take little teasing when she is on her bad days. Growing up he has always had hate directed towards him, I mean he has changed alot about himself in terms of looks and I get the feeling like he's always trying to prove his "machoness".

[@auroperrone]

I just think that justin has a terrible sense of humor and he may be a narcisist. I don't believe that he said those things with bad intentions, he just thinks that he is funny. While in the first video, he may have thought that Hailey was getting out of the car by the other side so he just closed the door but what let me really shocked was that he didn't even looked at her to see if she was ok. Like... was he aware of what he did or didn't he even noticed? But I agree with the rest of the video, especially with the karate move. He was joking, they had big smiles on their faces as they were walking hands in hands. Why people want to address him as an abuser even when he doesn't do anything wrong?

[@f.t.6764]

"May be"? He is definitely a narcissist and has a god complex. And he knows Hailey would always tolerate his narcissistic and emotionally abusive a$$. I hope Hailey wakes up and dumps him. For her own good. Cause as much as you try to humanise narcs and try to correct their idiosyncracy with therapy, it will never freaking happen. Even the best psychologists admit it. They will never be in a level of a level headed person with empathy towards others, without their ego in the center, without sadistic and sociopathic tendancies. You cannot humanise narcissistic abusers it's a literal disservice to the victims and it's not even a possibility. Cause it's not a psychological disorder just because it can be subtitled in psychological terms and just because it can be analysed in the field of psychology and psychiatry. It's got to do with a very aware idiosyncracy. And that's why most narcs refuse to go to therapy and many times when theur victim suggests to do so. Cause it's against a narcs agenda and cause peoffessionals can see right through them. So a narc is never going to change.

[@tasneem6114]

i think he's just one of those people with that kind of humor tbh. but people need to be aware that a lot of these videos are indeed taken out of context. they were talking and laughing right after he "maliciously" slammed the door on her. there's paparazzi footage

[@Sofianova17]

You know being a narcissist is an awful evil thing to be this guy making this video and all these comments are so enabling. I really hope none of you ever end up in a relationship with a narcissist

[@tasneem6114]

@@Sofianova17 you wouldn’t know if he’s a narcissist unless you knew him personally, no matter what videos you’ve seen. just bc someone is not good with intimate and deep romantic relationships doesn’t mean they’re a narcissist

[@Sofianova17]

@@tasneem6114 that’s true there’s lots of people that are just not good at relationships but their not abusive like he is. It’s obvious he is a narcissist I don’t know what more evidence his mindless followers need or the people that excuse his behaviour just cause he’s a man. Selena Gomez was with him 8 years and said he abused her what other evidence do you need at this point?

[@redjuice02]

As someone who grew up with trauma that causes rollercoasters of instability, I learned in trauma counselling classes that having this happen at an early age can set your brain up to expect uncertainty. It gears up for a constant fight-or-flight response and this carries on into adulthood. For me, if things were stable, I feel uneasy, like something isn't right. I feel like Justin's early fame could have caused this and that he may be CAUSING fights in order to create the instability he expects.

[@Terressa_]

I believe all she ever wanted was to become his wife. She would have done everything to get him. I think she was blindly in love and hoped it would be better in the future. That's probably the reason why she agreed to marry him after few weeks of dating. They both must have known it will look odd to get married that quickly. He had never looked really in love with her before they got engaged and married. She was one of the many girls he dated. Not a special girlfriend. She became important to him when he decided he needed to be married and he knew she wouldn't reject him. I think it was way how to improve his image. He got married, he settled down... Instead of this he should have worked on himself, on his mental health, not just jump into a relationship which is supposed to be forever. His own problems will haunt him till the day they catch him. Maybe one day she will realize she is better without him.

[@randybobandy4000]

Him screaming at skeeball...dude that's so embarrassing 😂

[@ChristinaMoralesMindfuqed]

Its true. Me n my boyfriend dont fight. We bicker but we always come to a compromise or an understanding. We respect each other equally and dont like yelling at one another. Not even when we're upset. Self control is a big part too.

[@nataliiayermolaieva3700]

What's the difference between getting into a fight and bickering, tho.. :) there's a fine line really

[@jessicafermanelli28]

When he screamed in the basket game... omg, he sounds like my 7 years old little brother when we are playing Uno 🤣

[@jujubee6030]

I really appreciate how you are unbiased with these type of videos and don't just jump on the bandwagon of hating on them. You see it from all different types of perspectives which is good. People act like they know so much about these celeb relationships just from a 20 second video.

[@noellenebriscoe9986]

Exactly, there are 365 days in a year in total we see not even a full day of their life and all of sudden ppl think they know them and can criticize their relationship. Majority o these ppl have never married and don't know what it's like to even be in a relationship w someone w so much baggage..... his baggage won't just go away. It seems ppl expect him to put his life on hold and to not be w the woman he loves because he has trauma no ..... I'm pretty sure they've both said they go to therapy. I'm sure he's been through things he hasn't even talked abt openly and that's ok.... Ppl need to realize we don't know celebrities, what goes on off camera and ppl need to stop assuming they know what goes on in ppl's life and assuming the worst..... I can guarantee a lot of the ppl who hate their relationship aren't perfect themselves and have done wrong in the friendships and relationships they've been in. Can u imagine how it would feel to have random ppl oh the internet tell u u abuse your wife who u love dearly.... marriage doesn't seem to mean anything to ppl anymore, it's like we all feel this uncontrollable need to input our opinions everywhere especially when absolutely no one asked for it.

[@shellyb2042]

Hailey was also obsessed with Selena and Justin’s relationship and was in their friend circle so she 💯 knew what she was getting into with the emotional abuse! She is the type to think she can save him or fix him when in reality she’s only losing herself and her 20s which should be the funnest time of her life! Instead she’s in marriage therapy with a brat for a husband lmao I guess it’s kinda karma tho for how she weaseled her way into his life and for what she did to Selena bc we all know that girl is so pure and truly loved jb! I also think jb is to scared to live like he did Selena bc he was so broken when she finally realized how toxic he really is!!

[@rebeccabahamonde9944]

True 💯

[@maegantrice936]

Thank you for repeating how possible it is to be in relationships without fighting. I was just reflecting with my sister on my first significant relationship in my early twenties and late teens and how it was very much emotionally abusive and caused a lot of mental damage to me especially when I had to convince myself that I was not trying hard enough and I was the problem. My references at the time, had me believing that that level of drama in a relationship was indicative of how much we cared for each other. It wasn’t

[@filipa8626]

Oh this is a interesting video I wasn't expecting nice suprise their relationship is interesting cause they seem great in some moments and then others that are really worrying

[@zebrinapendula922]

Hailey, tripping, falling never took her eyes off Justin, was sad to watch. It could be explained by saying Justin, was not aware Hailey, had tripped. Glad to know the face hit was in play between the 2. They have been married for 3 yrs, I think Justin, being as rich as he is, Hailey, must have everything she wants or needs. She's in for the long haul, I hope she starts to demand respect from her Husband Justin. Twice she has (1) Her high score at the arcade. (2) His comment, "If you weren't so hot.......

[@isabellarose6514]

They were just friends, hooking up back then. Not dating.

[@zebrinapendula922]

@@isabellarose6514 More reason to treat her well. Sometimes people will treat their friends better than they treat their spouses, significant other. I am referring to the look on her face, straight, focused on his direction, even when she tripped never took her eyes off him.

[@Bloomingjas]

You’re definitely a Scorpio with some Gemini vibes. Definitely a strong Scorpio

[@crpbxg3127]

he seems very immature still and has a lot of work to do

[@tam_pow2092]

As someone who was in a relationship a person who acted just like Justin when I was young these videos broke my heart. He would smother me with love and affection so that when he made his hateful remarks towards me I wouldn't notice as long as he played it off. I was just like Hailey. I was so in love with him and tried to see the best in people that I looked past it. Even when the "jokes" got worse and more frequent. The remarks soon turned into accusations of cheating, and then sexual abuse started. He would gradually make me feel like shit if I turned him down. Eventually, he didn't even care about trying to coerce me. He just took. Because of the years of jabs at my self confidence and worth I told myself no one else would put up with me bc that's exactly what he had told me so much. That I was the problem. That somehow it was all my fault. People can try to say that Justin's actions towards Hailey aren't that bad, but as someone who has lived through it I can tell them that's a lie. She seems like such a sweet and genuinely good person. I hope that she gets away from him and he gets the help he needs before moving onto a new woman.

[@letym2271]

You're right. That's called intermittent reinforcement, the love and affection and then withdraw of it. It's so messed up and a mindfuck, gives you cognitive dissonance ("I'm sure he didn't mean it... I mean he's shown he loves me right?" like thoughts). I went through something similar too and it's taken me 2 years to break off the dissonance, thankfully I can say I achieved it. Sometimes it creeps back in but I can shut it down and not doubt myself again. The passive agressive jokes, the unfunny ones that left you confused, right? I hated those. I see the same with this couple. The 70% truth 30% joke comment validated my experience so so much. 🥺 I completely understand what you went through, to him I was the problem, too (for putting up boundaries 🙄). Thankfully someone healthy came into my life after all that traumatic experience. Sending much light your way 🤗

[@TiaVaghela]

I’m actually obsessed with your videos 🤣 “that’s my thumbnail face right there” 😂😂😭 you need to start a podcast!!!

[@todayandtomorrow123]

this is very educational, thanks for the content. I learned a lot about relationship dynamics.

[@erinb4596]

Speaking about his manager, you should make a video about his relationship that just got super bad (separating and working on their relationship to filed for divorce in less than two weeks) that he disabled all his social media. Scooter Braun- there are tons of tweets and videos talking about this right now

[@cmielak]

She will grow out of him sooner or later. It's inevitable. Justin reminds me of these sh**ty boyfriends from highschool or college that you have for no one knows what reason. Maybe just to appreciate your real deep relationships that you have later, who knows

[@hanrowe2367]

Justin peaked a long time ago. He fell out now

[@PinksMidori]

I dont think its a reach viewing these clips and assuming they are not healthy. I personally dont find the clips playful, or non-issues, considering his past. He has a history of being a emotionally abusive partner. He himself has admitted it . Selena said she was emotionally abused by him and made to feel less than often. So I can only imagine what its like now when he has his off days. I hope he gets the help he needs to address the issues and possible trauma that caused him to have toxic traits. And ill leave this here... -Selena Gomez says she experienced emotional abuse in her past relationship with fellow musician Justin Bieber. "I've found the strength in it. It's dangerous to stay in a victim mentality," Gomez said of her on-again/off-again relationship with Bieber, in an interview with NPR on Sunday. "And I'm not being disrespectful. I do feel I was a victim to certain abuse." When asked whether this abuse could be categorized as "emotional abuse," Gomez answered in the affirmative. - Bieber revealed in an Instagram post in September that he "started doing heavy drugs at 19 and abused all my relationships" as he grappled with rising fame.- I feel there's its not a reach to assume the worst because of his history.

[@LysLovesAlpacas]

my heart truly hurts for hailey. she deserves better, not only is she in a toxic relationship but she also has to deal with the abuse and assumptions from his fans who support his past relationship, even though he was also INCREDIBLY toxic and abusive to selena as well and she’s still dealing and healing with everything he caused to her. i hope hailey gets out.

[@ruthmorales7839]

Omg! Hailey has been stalking and copying Selena for years. It’s not Selena’s fault that her marriage to Justin is toxic.

[@victoriaf.8420]

On being an introvert and communicating to your partner: I used to tell my husband that I needed alone time, but that made him feel bad and like it was personal. Now, I say things like, "I need time to recharge," or "I need me time, and that me time is about me being alone with myself, not me getting away from you." I also get really overstimulated sometimes because of my ADHD and because I've learned to recognize it now, I can verbalize it and he knows it has nothing to do with him. Getting to know yourself is so important for your relationships.

[@kiddalove0446]

I love Justin. But I think no one deserves to be unhappy. I think Justin is sad, I wish he have a wonderful life. I think he is good and happy with Selena And I think he stopped talking with his family. He keeping distanc from everyone. I think some things is not right! I wish him happy ending... ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏

[@khemetsmom713]

This video just made me remember when my ex slammed my foot in the car door. Emotional abuse involves passive aggressive physical abuse disguised as a joke or an accident.

[@dayaneribeiro7761]

i love how you came trying to be neutral and just analyze, i would just recommend looking for a bigger context when looking at videos people use to portray celebrities as bad people. Most of these videos were proven to be taken out of context and were not what it seems in this few seconds. I think looking for the context of videos before analyzing and posting would help your analysis and would also make people see that sometimes trolls on internet will take things out of context and make compilations to make celebrities look bad. I love your analysis tho, sending love ❤️

[@dayaneribeiro7761]

would love to send you the proofs that some of the videos you used were not complete/ out of context for further analysis if you’re interested ❤️

[@helmutrosendal]

belieber much?

[@marissadrew8233]

Hailey is so patience woman , very lucky to have her by Justin! It is difficult to find that patience behaviour in a women as of now.. this lady is real a woman the best to be for life!

[@WithAngelWings]

Your laugh made me laugh extra hard at everything 💀 especially the “I WASN’t even TRYYYING 😡” arcade basketball rage fest Justin had. Dude idk why I love how much you cuss cause I feel like so many youtube channels are so squeaky clean and afraid of demonetization that they bleep everything out. And it’s just so unnatural but I feel like i’m just laughing with a friend watching this. Appreciate you

[@AnthonyRecenello]

Awww Sarah. Yeah I just can’t help it honeslty. I dint feel myself otherwise maybe?

[@leshsstrickland]

SELENA KNOWS HER WORTH...AND THATS WHY SHE'S NOT WITH JUSTIN...SHE WAS RAISED VERY VERY WELL..GREAT JOB MOM..SMILE..JERSEYGIRL❤

[@linnjohnsen4073]

Your gf is lucky! It’s so sweet of you the way you do. It’s so important to treat people the way you want to be treated, respect and love each other❤️ I’m happy for you. May I Ask how you become the profession you have? I’d love to become one! I can eadily analyze people and understand peoples reactions/feeling etc. keep up the great work!! Btw, Poor Hailey…, it breaks my heart to see how he treats her🥺 She deserves sooooo much better!! Poor girl…

[@shawnaelong]

I do feel that Justin is like you said the type of person that just needs space Sometimes or half of the time. Hailey does seem very affectionate and Justin definitely can be. But I can only imagine all the people that constantly want to touch him all the time, and then when he’s at home in his comfort space he wants to be loving to his wife, but yes, at times he needs his space and not trying to be touched constantly. I can completely understand.

[@ibeabea4073]

Let‘s get them onto this channel

[@nayonikadhagat]

Kindly read through:- Firstly, I love how this video tries to cover all sides of their relationship-good and bad sides of Justin and Hailey’s relationship. I appreciate Anthony’s hard work and dedication for creating such quality content! I genuine acknowledge and admire how neutral he is to everything and doesn’t base anything on assumptions. He views them as two people in a relationship, that’s it. Coming to my point, I personally feel a little differently about one part which was mentioned in this video. I may be wrong when I say this but at 16:48 (the part where Justin is “rolling” his eyes), I personally feel that he just silent burped (it could have been a hiccup too) mid-sentence, at that very moment and just shifted his eyes from one place to another. I personally feel like it wasn’t an “eye roll”, but it just rather seems like a normal human reaction; imagine talking to someone and you are about to burp but you’re talking so you try to burp as silently as possible and sub-consciously shift your eyes, from one place to another. I’m sure most of you have done this sub-consciously, if not consciously. I do reiterate that this is just my personal observation, and I hope no one feels offended by the same! Feel free to share your views as to what you think about the same, I would love to hear you share your thoughts too, reader! Thanks for reading, I appreciate it! Stay hydrated and have a marvellous day ahead! You matter! ^_^

[@PaulaAmmons]

Selena dodged that bullet...bravo!!