Are “CHEAP” Boots Better? Timberland, Carhartt, Caterpillar, Keen, Wolverine, Irish Setter, Skechers

[@ProjectFarm]

Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! Skechers: no longer available with steel toe Keen: amzn.to/3dHPLNv Carhartt: amzn.to/3hfeATf OUXX: amzn.to/40QleVb Timberland: amzn.to/36bxuEa Irish Setter: amzn.to/3wkj5A6 Caterpillar: amzn.to/367Eoua Condor: amzn.to/3hA2TFp Wolverine: amzn.to/3hh9SEC Dickies: amzn.to/3ykZilz

[@corvette4923]

Wife: "I love you!" Todd: "We're gonna test that."

[@strokermaverick]

😄

[@Dark00Wolf79]

LOL! Dude, you made me spill my drink. Hilarious!

[@SE45CX]

He'll make that a fair test anyway so the lady should not be offended or anything.

[@blazeandcyrus]

Ouch lol

[@dteh4501]

She passed the test, great family 👍

[@ROKASniper89]

When you realize this man just spent around a thousand dollars on shoes to bring us an honest review. He's not sponsored by any of these brands.

[@brqxton8974]

He would have tax exemption not to mention will make probably $10000 on this video from ad revenue

[@alecjones4135]

@@brqxton8974 10k from ad rev? They fucking wish

[@brqxton8974]

@@alecjones4135 more than doable for his channel

[@AntonGully]

@@brqxton8974 Nobody is getting $10k from a YT vid with under a million views. Maybe argue about what you're arguing about. Being right about it is still bad.

[@normanbuchanan9710]

@@brqxton8974 and he would earn and deserve every penny of it too, far as I'm concerned he's better than the BBB because we actually see him doing the testing.

[@RedHaloManiac95]

Love how much success this man has seen. There’s literally no other content out there like this. And whenever I need a new tool I know exactly where to look

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@adambrown4911]

couldn't agree more. I always reference Project Farm before buying anything to see if he has done a video on the product.

[@sciji3118]

@@ProjectFarm There's many more boots I know we'd all love to see, vet's like me would love to see some issued and non issued work type Danners. Love your content no matter what it's about!

[@b_f_d_d]

Gotta see round 2 for boots testing

[@tommyjamesandtheshondells4095]

I've been wearing keen boots for years. I'm on my feet 60+ hours a week. And a pair usually lasts about a year. And they feel comfortable straight out of the box. They may cost more, but I'm willing to pay more for comfort and safety. The last pair I bought was actually made here in the USA.

[@jesseback3536]

Yes they are comfortable right out of the box, and stay comfortable longer than most brands.

[@Gibsonfan1989]

Agreed. I love every keen I've bought

[@eyellgeteven9928]

I have a pair of Keens, and they're the most comfortable boots I've ever had, not to mention, as a plumber, my boots are always getting wet on a daily basis, and they are the only boots I've ever owned that have never once allowed water inside the boot. I've been wearing them for about two years, and just guessing, I'd say they should hold up another year or more. Once these wear out, I'll buy another pair, and they should last until I retire.

[@Fortuna_716]

Yessir, I love Keen boots. I wore a pair doing demolition for 3 years and I could've kept going. The toe box is wide and very protected, I was stomping through demo rubble and never once hurt my feet. I tried a pair of timberland pros and I absolutely hated them, way to narrow at the toes and very uncomfortable compared to keens

[@ebf1003]

My favorite hiking boot by far

[@DanE-ew1yt]

I'm shocked at how thorough your tests are. After working in a foundry for the past decade, it's not surprising to have the bottoms of your boots melt. I can't believe you tested that. Well done, sir!

[@CavemanZerron]

As a welder i step on hot slag all day, indeed a great test

[@Pandemanium_TV]

I had a cheaper pair melt just from walking around a campfire that was burning a bit hotter than it should've. Completely warped the sole.

[@journeyman553]

I wish he had tested US Army combat boots. I started wearing them for work in construction and found they lasted far better than anything else i tried. Properly fitted they are comfortable the day you put them on. Just keep them out of wet concrete, that will eventually destroy any non-rubber boot . They can be purchased at some Army surplus stores, if you live near an Army base you should have no trouble finding them.

[@greatdaneacdc]

@@journeyman553 I bought brand new issued Army boots at Surplus Store and they were Amazing for what I put them through ! I also had a pair of Desert combat boots too ! 👍

[@journeyman553]

@@greatdaneacdc I really don't understand why anyone would buy anything else for a work boot.

[@David-xu6xw]

There is a reason I keep seeing people mentioned "I want to see Project Farm test this." You have singlehandedly become the consumer reports all DIYers wanted. Great job as always.

[@MrNaliux]

I think CR sold themselves to companies paying them for better product placement of their brands. They have a few different results on some products presented here, but I have not seen any proof of their claims like we have here on PF.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@jesseparkhurst3037]

I feel like PF does his best to have fair, unbiased testing and gives us accurate results. There has been more than once I have re-watched a video before making a product purchase

[@craignmz5264]

Wow, the rr track portion is impressive.

[@AlanDike]

I regret that I can only vote this up once

[@tyrereviews]

Still one of my favourite KZbinrs, even when reviewing boots. What an amazing test, respect sir!

[@djexclusivee]

So true! The effort in is so respectable. Helping out the blue collar man with facts! To be better we need to get better

[@journeyman553]

I worked construction for 45 years. BY FAR the best pair of boots i have ever worn were bought from an army surplus store. Combat boots properly sized are comfortable the day you put them on til 10 or 20 years later when they wear out. Just keep them out of wet cement and they will last LONGER THAN ANY OTHER BOOT ON THE MARKET. They are a little pricy but well worth the money.

[@thisguy4614]

Especially when he tests boots! 👍

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@HariSeldon913]

@@ProjectFarm I suppose it would have been difficult since it's now summer, but traction on ice would have been a good test.

[@danielrollins4315]

I'm surprised that Skechers did such a good job they probably raised their price after seeing this. I really appreciate being able to see your channel on KZbin.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@GonnaRunAmuck]

The leather does not hold up on the Skechers

[@elmirmisir-zada8470]

I paid $110 for mine last July and it's already wearing out lol

[@heffeysadoggful]

​@elmirmisir-zada8470 that's almost a year thats really impressive.

[@Adoogin]

good gear costs money. I've worked construction/carpentry in Keens... 1st pair lasted a good amount of time, 2nd and 3rd pair barely a year: holes in uppers, threads giving out and the soles lugs delaminating. Never again. I had to switch to an old pair of redwing work boots from the late 80's. Guess what. They're great. Finally resoled them at Redwing for $175. Worth it.

[@dmcd7448]

The tests themselves are amazing. The real mind boggling part is how he finds a way to quantify the variables and make everything a fair comparison

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@milojadez]

@@ProjectFarm You should invest in a hydraulic press!!

[@bganey]

Project Farm: "I'd like to return these boots." Store: "Reason for return?" Project Farm: "They did not meet my expectations."

[@STB-jh7od]

:()

[@VintageCars999]

🤣😂

[@jasonc3522]

He uses a different email and PO box for every order.

[@richardp1037]

No need to return them they’re tax deductible as a business expense

[@fleurdewin7958]

Project Farm : " I suddenly realized that I'm not a caterpillar thus do have so many legs that need so many shoes "

[@OyeBelafonte]

I’ve had to wear steel toes everyday for the last 15 years and when it comes to work boots you get what you pay for which this video proves. This was one of the most detail testing/review videos I’ve seen on KZbin.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@republicoftexas4651]

I drive a flatbed rig. I bought a $71 pair of Herman, Survivors from Walmart coming up on 4 years ago. For what I do, this is the absolute best bang/buck pair of boots I've ever bought in my 49 years. The waterproofing and slip resistance are golden. All comes down to your specific needs.

[@firebymisfire1022]

Factory 12hrs 7days for 7years. You definitely get what you pay for. I spent 35 on my first pair. Lasted 2 months. Spent 80 lasted 4 years.

[@wzpu3283]

Walked on wings of upside-down airplanes for 99 billion years and Binford Boots have been on my three feet the whole time.

[@brahtrumpwonbigly7309]

@@wzpu3283 Sounds like a rough gig.

[@joelw2023]

Been through Skechers, Wolverines, a half dozen more Skechers, Red Wings, Georgia Boots, and probably going back to Skechers next time. Glad to see your tests reflect what I've learned over the years. Great vid, thanks for putting it together.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@TheMightyDR84]

My favorites are thorogoods, great workboot. Ive tried all of thee above in comment above. Thorogoods

[@hughmassey6712]

The slow-motion carrot scene was more suspenseful than a scary movie.

[@wim0104]

the carrot test was *inspired*

[@thereissomecoolstuff]

Should have used Vienna sausages for more effect.

[@ProjectFarm]

lol Thanks for watching!

[@yurdp]

😂🤣😂

[@jamesplotkin4674]

@@thereissomecoolstuff Or that annoying neighbor kid who always fly's his drone over your daughter while she sunbathes ;-)

[@Hfoutdoorsyt]

Man! There’s nothing you can’t test!

[@MrMillander]

I’d really enjoy seeing him test different alcoholic beverages.

[@michaelpolaski4186]

How about testing different brands of condoms

[@ChrisNole_]

P

[@Mr.Pidgeon]

Agreed

[@coreymerrill3257]

Firearms related stuff apparently can't be tested lol.

[@alfredsmith1182]

This guy seems so nice. He’s just a regular guy doing stuff on the internet, but makes it so interesting to watch. Keep it up PF, love the content :)

[@pamike4873]

One of the coolest things about this guy? I subbed when he had only a few thousand, but he hasn't changed a bit. He did just as good a job then as he does now. This is the best "real-world" testing on youtube. Sure it's not scientific, as I was told once by someone, but who cares if the humidity level is 1% higher or the temp is 5° hotter throughout the testing. I'd rather see this than testing in some lab.

[@alfredsmith1182]

@@pamike4873 man that’s so wholesome. this guy 100% deserves more subs, definitely one of the better youtubers out there

[@lansonfloyd4687]

@@pamike4873 I'd contend it is scientific, in that he's changing only one variable at a time (the product), per test. I learned a lot about masking tape and paint from PF!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@etienneleclerc3492]

I think you missed the most important test - the wear test. Hard to test though. Failure point on my boots have varied. A quick test might be bending the toe over and over, but a long term data tracking endeavor is needed on many fronts to get a good idea.

[@26longlongtime]

Yeah, pretty much impossible to ensure a perfectly even test. I would give them to the same oil field worker for x amount of time each, maybe 60 days. Far from perfect but easy enough to do

[@gabrielstarlight9003]

I can attest to the poor durability of the Indestructible Shoe. 1 week for bits to start falling off and lost the sole off one in a month. They are useless garbage.

[@kategrimshaw1546]

Yeah, I worked in the restaurant industry for years, and having tried many brands of non-slip shoes, Sketchers fall apart QUICKLY. So, maybe saving money up front, but in the long term....

[@dankyle6924]

Comfort also can change with wear, in my experience Sketchers comfort goes away and Caterpillar stays comfortable until worn out. In my job I was on my feet all day at a grocery store, about 4 hours on tile and 4 hours on cement in the backrooms, and Caterpillar has very good durability for me.

[@jamesallan1883]

Very subjective and factors for a good quality study and tough to control esp over long-term. For most safety and or warmth take priority over how long boots last.

[@carstrucksntrattors3070]

Me talking to a sketchers store worker: Yes could I buy some light up sketchers boots

[@Oddman1980]

I'm 40 years old and I have never had light up shoes... but I've always wanted some.

[@MrTaxiRob]

@@Oddman1980 I'm 49 and I got Heelys bruh

[@dav1d629]

@@MrTaxiRob lol

[@scriptonite2182]

''Merica may just be a little too diverse, here in 2021.😱

[@Clay3613]

That would actually help in dark areas.

[@ronanderson982]

Ive been a coal miner for nearly 20 yrs. I’ve tried Carhartt, RedWing, Danner, Wolverine, and Timberline. While none of them lasted more than 6 months underground Timberland Pro by far are the most Comfortable.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@beaucephus526]

Try keens. Timberland pros are great but keens are more comfortable and outlast them by far.

[@waltercurl2398]

you must have went cheap with the Danners because my 400.00 quarry boots have lasted 4 yrs on construction sites ,and are so comfortable I wear them walking my dog (1400 miles in last 20 months) and they still have original laces .Danner by far the best.

[@isaacwakefield5915]

Yeah Red Wings definitely don't make sense in a scenario like that. They take 6 months to a year to break in at least before they're comfortable. Once they're broken in they are very comfortable though.

[@zacharypeery4082]

@@waltercurl2398 I've had the bull run moc toe and cristy by Danner, very comfortable boot but the only downside is the soles wear out very quickly

[@10tacleMatt]

Something to keep in mind with boot cost is not only the performance of safety features, but the longevity of the boot through constant wear. This is especially important for anyone doing ironworking or concrete/asphalt. Those kinds of conditions will eat through leather and glue in a matter of weeks to months.

[@TheKnobCalledTone.]

True. But would a pair of Keens last 5 times longer than a pair of Sketchers?

[@donpayton737]

One pair of thorogoods will last about as long as 4 pairs doing iron work. I can get a year and a half to two years of a good american-made pair of thorogoods. None of these boots will last 6 months. I've tried many of these.

[@kayoh3423]

iron workers boots generally have a softer crepe style sole to grip steel and rebar you are climbing on, and concrete, asphalt or hot tar roofing no boots last through that, most companies in those industries (in my local) have boot allowances or discounts at a local retailer for employees

[@garyvee6023]

Ha, I just wrote about that before scrolling through the comments..., I was a concreter.

[@tp8835]

Concrete and mortar just destroy boots in about six months no matter what I have bought.

[@tdogtexan3445]

I went with Redwing 2 years ago and am still happy with my purchase. There were expensive but absolutely worth every penny.

[@ProjectFarm]

Great brand! Thank you

[@kayamorris3144]

Just bought a pair today actually lol

[@mortrek]

Unfortunately they do not make boots in my size. I'm 12 EE or EEEE but I just about tried on every boot and shoe in the RW store that was near my size and none fit right. Only a few brands make shoes in my size, and Skechers is one of them.

[@barrythomas529]

I had a pair of redwing boots stayed water proof for 4 years wore them 6 days a week construction and farming. Lasted for almost 5 years.

[@wahooiron]

@@barrythomas529 Same here. I tell people I wear mine 24 hours a day.

[@3dtesseract853]

I cannot express how much I appreciate this channel’s complete adhesion to science and consistency in testing, along with having absolutely zero hint at any sort of bias to any brand.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@infernoleviathan8868]

Saw this video 6 months ago and i chose the cheap option with the sketchers. I work on the tow industry and the sketchers died after 6 months. They gain humidity and mold. Leather cover stared to ripped off after the first 3 weeks. But they were very comfortable at walking. Now I'm going to try the keen brand and I let you know how they perform.

[@blanksymortimer4088]

that's great to know was thinking about the sketchers myself but I'm not buying new shoes every 3 weeks thanks

[@SweetT00f]

My biggest complaint with Skechers boots is the leather tearing on the shoe. Not even 2 weeks later it's ripping.

[@davebanach9891]

Make sure you pick the options you need because quality brand offer many different boots, this guy did some of the weirdest tests that don’t really relate to the real world. I personally wouldn’t buy anything other than Irish setter and maybe keen. There are tons of other brands that make great boots and the majority of these boots just won’t be able to hold up to daily wear. I personally have a $250 pair of Irish setters I bought 5 years ago. I wear them in the summer for work with the city and work on remodeling/demolition with houses. I’ve never had an issue with them.

[@stephenreiter6585]

I bought them about 6 months ago myself, and have noticed the same problems. The interior of the shoe is disintegrating, the heels have completely deformed, and the seam between the sole and the top of the boot has ripped on both, letting water soak in

[@NipplesOfDestiny]

buy jim greens Razorbacks - best boot Ive ever owned - General labour/renovations

[@WarpedYT]

I got and ad for indestructible shoes watching this video lol... also I have seen so many people wear Crocs on everything from construction sites to the more popular setting, restaurant kitchens! That was a great pick and not very far fetched !! These are very clever and amazing tests! I check your channel every time I'm going to buy anything.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for sharing.

[@LukaArtelj]

@@ProjectFarm Can you test "Unior" hand tools against its competitors one day? They say Unior has the best tools in Europe, which I think it is true

[@tatewallen3035]

I do the same

[@eneshadzidedic4368]

I had a trucker fellow, man that guy wore Crocs ALL the time. One time guy got out of the truck in Crocs in -7°C with 5cm snow and walked around like its completly normal

[@taipan8021]

Until something Heavy falls on their foot

[@rlow3516]

Your reviews are very thorough and informative. There’s no unnecessary dialogue. Thank you for providing a wealth of useful information.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@user-ur7wd2zp2v]

When you wear boots all day, every day, cost isn't near as important as quality, protection and comfort. They're a tool and having a cheap wrench slip is no different from being sore from cheap boots. But more expensive isn't always better. Also from experience as a field service equipment mechanic, high ankle protection is important for working in rough terrain.

[@G53X0Y0Z0]

I put work boot to the test and won't consider boots that cost under $200 a poor buy. Also, they have to be made in the USA. Brands like Whites and Grizzly are among the best.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@dennisgonzalez4562]

I personally love thorogood American heritage 8” best boots hands down but being a ironworker I’m bias

[@sbenn6917]

@@dennisgonzalez4562 They do make a great boot with almost no break in time, but I've noticed with mine that when working in winter conditions these boots get very cold. Not sure if they make an insulated boot.

[@coffeeblood]

I've worn Keens for work boots everyday for the past decade. Hands down the most comfortable and durable brand I've ever worn, and worth every penny.

[@robbfisher2876]

I've been wearing steel toe work boots for going on 27 years, even still have some of my USMC issue boots (anybody remember the good times when you could have your boots retreaded ;)) In the last two years I switched to steel toe work shoes (getting old sucks, your feet getting old sucks more). One factor that is really difficult to test is durability and plain old comfort. My Keens, while comfortable, just didn't last that long... I was fairly disappointed as I'm nowhere near as rough on shoes these days. I bought a relatively cheap pair of Skechers, not knowing they actually made something other than teeny bopper shoes, and I must say they have really impressed me, they've outlasted the Keens, and are still comfortable even after 11 hour days.

[@teekay_1]

I gave you a thumbs up for your comments on your feet getting old. Yeah, it's kind of tough. And it happens even if you stay in shape.

[@WaitWhat-jy9ck]

I've experienced the same results with Keens and Skechers. The Keens looked great, but didn't last long and the Skechers are still going strong.

[@ahmadghosheh3104]

I agree on the comfort, being older, 64, with foot and ankle injury from my younger days triggered some arthritis and it seems steel toe shoes just terrible for that.

[@r0nd0n39]

You don't have a cobbler near you? I live in a somewhat big city, but was surprised to find that there were 8 of them within 30 mins of where I live.

[@aelfswith]

Good to know, Have worn Red Wings for 20 plus years, tried some Timberland Pro and found too uncomfortable for me. May try some Skechers. since RW stopped making the design I preferred.

[@Dea7hWarran7]

Indestructible Shoe’s new facebook ad: “We’re better than crocs?”

[@289pinto]

Seem about the same lol. Look the same too

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@Paul__FC]

Awesome comment! +1 sir!

[@sally6457]

Lmfao!

[@carlypete3830]

Lol

[@wjk94061]

When I go back to watch a video before you put a summary table at the end, I really appreciate the table. The summary table is a great add. If KZbin let’s you update a video, adding summary tables would be a great add.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@samuelcabrera6942]

my wife: what are you doing? Me: watching the farm god, My wife: and what is he doing? Me: showing us the right path.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@jonadam5392]

This is the way!

[@anotherrandomtexan25]

@@jonadam5392 dis is da wai!

[@MrHarbinged]

@@ProjectFarm I'm still waiting for a degreaser or carpet cleaner test..

[@benlikebike]

@@MrHarbinged im sure he's figuring a solid method out.

[@johnsommer2445]

Great video! Having worked in heavy industrial plants and fab shops, it was quite enlightening to see what boots held up. For me, if I'm on my feet all day around hot, sharp heavy stuff, I wouldn't hesitate to drop $500 on boots, if the boot offers good protection, was comfortable, and didn't leave me sore at the end of the day. Your reviews provide a valuable service to us. Thank you!

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.

[@paladin44]

once you buy $500 hand made boots there is no looking back IMHO. i bought another pair when they were on sale XD

[@Mattspips]

Wish you would have done a pair of Red Wings in there!

[@hunterbarksdale9778]

That was literally the brand I was most curious about. Love my Redwings but I wanted to see them compared.

[@DarkLinkAD]

I have a pair, paid like 300$ and the things broke leather from kicking a tire. Absolute waste of money

[@38unknownhinson]

Or danner, chippewa, and rockies

[@Mattspips]

@@DarkLinkAD Which pair did you get? Made in USA or elsewhere?

[@indyguy04]

That was my first thought when looking at the title of the video. Red wings are like the snap-on of work boots.

[@DanB95]

I'm a welder at a shipyard and despite the very high price and slightly painful break-in, Keen has been the most durable boots I've had so far. 6 months in and they're still in good shape, whereas Caterpillar/Dickies only lasted me about 4 months each. As always, absolutely fantastic job!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@freetolook3727]

"Some random manufacturer claim" Project Farm: "We're going to test that!"

[@firebirdude2]

Random comment gets a lot of likes. Random KZbinr: "I'm going to copy that!"

[@DGTelevsionNetwork]

The ____ is made in China!!!

[@GodWeenSatan]

"Manufacturers that tested poorly" hope nobody sees this!

[@stlkngyomom]

Background noise you hear is "Indestructible"Shoes going out of business...

[@tacticalcenter8658]

Check out Rose Anvil on KZbin. You won't be disappointed with there boot reviews.

[@AlAmantea]

For the next round, how about comparing high end boots? Carolina, Keen, Doc Martin, Ariat, Red Wing, etc. I'd definitely be interested in seeing that comparison test!

[@tacticalcenter8658]

Watch Rose Anvil and you can see right now. He's done videos on most of those brands and more.

[@Soxruleyanksdrool]

Don't forget to include Chippewas. They are my favorite high end boots for comfort and durability.

[@johntruxal432]

@@boskobear Agree the Keen Detroit lasts good about 9 months for me.👍

[@pleappleappleap]

Kamik. Made in Canada.

[@Si74l0rd]

Doc Marten boots are priced for style, not quality. Especially in recent years the quality has taken a dive, but I wore them throughout my teens, going back a few decades and they were never tough boots. Comfortable for sure, and lightweight, so great if you're on your feet all day. But the uppers are thin, I've punched holes through the back of the heelcap just walking in the woods before now, and that's the thickest leather on the boot by far. The soles aren't terribly durable and a nail goes clean through them with very little pressure. Definitely fashion footwear rather than working footwear, especially the more recently made models. The Goodyear welt is about the only quality part of them now. I've never had a sole come away from the boot, in all fairness lol.

[@doublepower206]

Totally addicted to this guy's tests. In a head-to-head test of product testers, Project Farm comes out on top! 💪

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@KM-ew5rl]

...or should we say, "toe-to-toe" test in this case?

[@joeyricefried9621]

No need to scroll through written reviews anymore. Just come here and see the results

[@paulholtzclaw8476]

Yup! Me too!!

[@gora876]

The amount of hard work to create these comparisons videos is bar none. Thank You for your dedication.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome!

[@robertdascoli949]

Imagine making a work boot that had less traction than a $20 pair of crock knockoffs.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@Dan12077]

Lmaooo! 🤦🏻‍♂️ Talk about embarrassing lol

[@gg-gn3re]

@@Joe-nq6hy Bottoms are rubber / silicone so they probably are. Timberland had good traction but the bottoms fall apart pretty easily.

[@slidetek]

Glad to know that my choice in Keen products is backed up on the review - I like them because they're comfy. Dying to see the Amazon review: _"Very disappointed in the quality of these Timberland boots. Walking out to my driveway in Phoenix, the soles began melting. I turned around to go back inside, stepping on a board, and a nail went right into my foot. As I tried hopping on one foot back to my front door, the toe fell right off the boot! I stumbled, trying to grab something to keep my balance. Unfortunately, it was an electric fence. I was electrocuted, and fell backwards onto the remaining toe portion of the boot, crushing it flat. Am returning. Cannot recommend"_

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@travisjazzbo3490]

I knew a lot of folks were going to complain about boots that 'weren't tested' on this one... Way, way, way too many boots out there to test!!! Can't possibly satisfy everyone on this one!! Keep up the great work!

[@tubastuff]

How about good old made in the USA Red Wing? A bit surprised that they weren't in the mix.

[@travisjazzbo3490]

@@tubastuff that is definitely a GOOD ONE!

[@nickajk1]

@@tubastuff probably too expensive last time I went to Red Wing I had to second mortgage my house

[@tubastuff]

@@nickajk1 Agreed--they're not cheap, probably because they're a franchise operation. Good boot if you get the ones that are made entirely in the USA. I chickened out with the last pair of boots that I bought--RW was too rich for me, so I settled for Bieker--now sadly gone. As they were closing out, however, I purchased three pairs of boots from them, so I'm set for life, unless I live to be 175.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@anthonyiannone7618]

this guy is simply the best!! i love all the homemade test rigs!!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@BrentConway]

As someone that wears work boots 6 days a week, 10 hours a day, I've found that the cost is not the defining factor for work boots. Its the day to day comfort. As such, I've been wearing Keen brand boots for years. Good to see that they protect well as well.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing!

[@Dan-bl9ly]

i have the same kind of experience though i like a lighter boot because i run alot while working so ive been rocking a hytest boot but after about a year the $120 boot is falling apart and i need new boots

[@killernat]

@@Dan-bl9ly go for keens i get 2-3years out of them vs 6mo-1yr with other brands

[@robbiemckane9474]

@@ProjectFarm can you please do oil stain remover at some point! So many don’t seem to work or live up to their claims.

[@mikeflippin5568]

@@robbiemckane9474 that's a super idea. Todd would smash that test.

[@BigDposey]

Would have loved to have seen some Red Wing King Toe work boots in that test.

[@wertot2752]

Throw in a pair of thorogood steel toe as well.

[@jeremymann8930]

along with Carolina and Georgia boot

[@ducewags]

Devin Posey or even some Doc Martin's.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the video idea.

[@RedPillAlways]

That's what I was thinking Red Wings and Caterpillar Excavators witch is what I wear

[@jasonwalter2924]

Great video! I have spent 28 years standing on concrete as a metal fabricator and sheet metal mechanic, and after going through so many cheap boots I started buying Red Wings; they are pricey, but they last MUCH longer than cheap boots and they are the most comfortable boots I've ever worked in. Thank you for another great comparison.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome!

[@metamorphicorder]

Yeah. The company i work for used to use redwing and woodward for shoes. And your first pair was from redwing. My experience with redwing is that they are not the most comfortable shoe ive ever worn. They are pretty comfortable though. And heres the thing, they stay that way all day and for a long time im really hard on shoes because im heavy and cant find cheap shoes (less than 100) that will last a year. My red wings have held up. They arent pristine to be sure but they are still intact with no seams ripped or soles hanging off and im pretty sure redwing will actually repair their shoes though i dont know for sure. They are a different type of shoe. They arent super padded. The best i can compare them to is strapping a thinly padded piece of floor to your foot and walking on it all day. I have a newer pair of wolverines that i got from the woodward truck this year. It has the boa lace system which i like, and they are comfortable, but harder to get on. Most days im still rocking rhe red wings. I hear they are a good company to work for too.

[@dasteufelhund]

Your channel beats out every movie there is on Netflix. Keep up the great work!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@rasco81]

Oh thank goodness. I was worried we wouldn’t get a 4th of July video

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much! My goal is to always come through for everyone.

[@bobmorris6708]

I love project farm. Been watching for years now and really appreciate the honest and unbiased opinions as well as the creativity he uses in the tests. You can tell he is a true salt of the earth man and I consider him a kindred spirit. Keep up the great work and thanks for being here.

[@ProjectFarm]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@paulhays2171]

I used to wear the caterpillars & they would wear out in 6 months, then I switched to Red Wings which last about 3 years or more. The replaceable insoles maintain the comfort level even longer. So in the big picture The more expensive boots are cheaper.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@SS-cc3km]

I think that without testing the durability of the outsole of the boots that this test is not complete. Skechers shoes have by far the weakest outsoles of any shoes, sneakers, or boots that I've ever purchased. You'll be lucky if you get 3 months of us before the outsole cracks in half of wears off in some other way. The recommendation for Skecher work boots is not doing anyone want favors in the long run.

[@redrock425]

Not work boots but I have some Hanwag walking boots. Just having them resoled after 10 years. Expensive but very comfortable and long lasting. Expensive and high quality can be cheaper in the long run.

[@nieczerwony]

@@SS-cc3km I have Sketchers for the gym for over 5 years and nothing wrong with the outsole at all.

[@SS-cc3km]

@@nieczerwony I've had many pair of working boots and sneakers outsoles either split it wear out in less than 3 months. I stopped buying them because it was like throwing money in the trash. They are a garbage product from my own personal experience. You may have had a different experience than me. That's why I was saying that without testing the outsoles in this video, he shouldn't be recommend any of the boots. Skechers is a garbage brand from my experience. My brother also had the same experience as me and he stopped buying that brand as well.

[@josephr2766]

I wear keen boots. Found them years ago and fell in love with the asymmetrical toe box. If you have wide feet and big toes with huge calluses from years of wearing regular steel toe boots try keen they are twice as comfortable as the redwing or danner boots I used to wear.

[@Derek8487]

I second this, keen boots are great for wide feet.

[@williamstevens4172]

I kept tearing my Keens up after 6 months (went through 5 pairs), finally switched to a Danner track welt and am still wearing them a year later! The toe box is huge and super roomy, but the sole is a bit firmer so takes some getting used to

[@arcticfox5118]

I used to love keens. But then they got rid of my size and yet again left me with either sub par options or custom orders

[@joshshelton7580]

Agree 100%

[@TheMCD1989]

I'll have to keep Keen in mind, I just made the switch to Danner from always having cheap boots and love them so far.

[@pedext]

I bought the Keens for work after watching this and 6 months later I am still very impressed as they just stick to any roof I've been on. They are very comfortable and have held up well with only cosmetic wear. The water proofing is great and they are even my go-to boots for the snow!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@SnapshotRC]

I love my keens. Cough up the extra cash for your feet, knees and back.

[@ehrlich_]

Been hip to keens for a minute! They are great!

[@Purozamachihue]

I wonder if this are good for lawn care cince I’m walking constantly

[@SnapshotRC]

@@Purozamachihue keen are great boots, they have light weight non-leather versions and non steel toe aswell.

[@mr.createandfix5504]

I wish there wouldve been a durability test from repeated flexing simulating walking. Most of my boots come apart at the seams or the soles fall off. In conjunction with that test, a water proof test. Maybe submerge the boots in water after 5000 bends, 10000 bends, 20000 bends, etc. Great job as usual

[@TheIdeasGuy]

This is what I was thinking. Most of my boots physically fall apart after 6-8 months. Occasionally I’ve tried brands that fell apart after just a couple of months so these days I generally spend the extra on more expensive boots and consistently get at least 6 months. Our brands here in Australia are different to American brands so I’m basically watching this video for curiosity reasons lol

[@jonathang6920]

I think you’d have to do a few more bends than that. I can easily walk 10000 steps in a single day, so just 6 months’ worth would be over a million bends.

[@sleepyta]

Redback seem to be very durable. And they're made in Australia. Only boot I'll wear

[@korndawggy1801]

I like the comfort of Skechers shoes and boots but, I've found that the seams wear out sooner than others in my experiences.

[@mr.createandfix5504]

@@jonathang6920 yes exactly. Some of those boots look so cheap that the seam would come loose in 5000 steps 😁

[@believe722]

WORK GLOVES!! I would love to see a video on actual heavy duty work gloves, durability, waterproof, insulated, size consistency, etc... I believe this to be a very true, accurate, and honest review of these brands and items, you know all of your episodes. Thank you!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you for the video idea! I tested gloves a while back but can test them again

[@believe722]

@@ProjectFarm The ones I would like to see if possible are actual work gloves, insulated, waterproof, especially their durability and holding up.

[@Devou1s]

The Sketchers seems like a good allround package, specially for 50 $.

[@that1guy82]

Seems like for me they last about 6 months b4 theres wear on the bottoms of my skechers, but for the price and comfort its worth it. Just gotta buy more every 6-9 months.

[@Leafmate79]

Not so good if you have flat feet the seams blow out in a month for me

[@crazyrobots6565]

Unfortunately I hear the tread doesn't last long. Not to mention they're just kind of ugly.

[@tubastuff]

@@Leafmate79 That's because the really cheap brands use a cloth "sock" and simply glue the shoe together, even though it may appear to be stitched. Thus far (about a year out), I've had pretty good luck with my Merrell Vibram-soled trail shoes. But yeah, Carhartt ain't what it used to be--and neither is Pendleton. Both brands moved production offshore with the predictable decline in quality. Used to be that the standard wintertime hiking gear included a Pendelton wool shirt--made from US wool in the US. Now, Pendleton is just a name... Could be that both marketing outfits figured that the memory of quality would fade and the public would be content with something that approached trash. Daddy left me with this sage advice that hasn't steered me wrong in the decades since he's been gone: "Never buy cheap shoes--they're not worth the pain".

[@jasonpatterson8091]

I don't buy the $50 Walmart ones; I get the boots off their website (more like $100). They are much more durable and look nicer as well - mine last 1.5 - 2 years before needing replaced. Something like this: www.skechers.com/men/shoes/work-argum-st-wp/200034.html

[@jasonblahafitness6349]

I love when the cheap equipment performs well, but I also love when the expensive stuff proves why it costs so much more.

[@PanchoPistolas45]

No way your the real Jason

[@urgamecshk]

@@PanchoPistolas45 just click his profile... Fake

[@adrianoperez2257]

as a field marine engineer, is really nice to come here and see that my preferred boots brand is actually the best performing by the best youtube tester... Keen boots are ridiculous expensive but if you want one that you can seriously rely on... pay for it and you won't regret! =)

[@kcin2der18]

I had keens and paid 225 for them, they lasted about 8 months before the bottom sole split in half towards the front of the boots, ive consistently gotten 18 months out of my timberland pro helix HD’s(180$), had 3 pairs of timberlands so far and decided to try the keens, big mistake, took a month before they even broke in, timberland are the most comfortable boot I’ve ever worn from day one. ✌️ I do seamless gutters so a lot of ladder climbing

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@adrianoperez2257]

@@kcin2der18 well... that's interesting... for me is exactly the opposite... my last two pairs of timberland (which i used to love) torn apart really fast... then I tried one caterpillar, which is decent but can't handle the severe condition of my work environment... then 4 months ago I decided to go for Keen again (I tried keen few years ago) and I'm loving it, ultra comfortable, nice temperature feeling (even during japan summer) and handles awesomely well on the heavy duty job of mine... perhaps you got a bad batch... or i'm lucky and got a good one...

[@adrianoperez2257]

@@ProjectFarm always nice to compliment such a good job as you always do sir! best youtube channel ever

[@916commons]

Thank you for you precision and “to the point “ reviews. I just subscribed a week ago and have used your reviews on ceramic auto coating and headlight restoration to purchase products. I use ConsumerReports, and equate your testing as good or probably better than theirs. Thanks!

[@ProjectFarm]

My pleasure!

[@weldingrockandroll2197]

I've burned through a shit ton of boots as a welder, the keens in this video have lasted months and they're the most comfortable boot I've ever worn. Highly recommend.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@BlackMan614]

Yeah... somebody hipped me to Keens. Terrific brand.

[@danielmcgrath9548]

KEEN is the best ever. Based on a comfortable hiking boot. I wear them all day trudging up and down construction sites and slopes. Great comfort, great stability. Well worth the money.

[@yevrahhipstar3902]

For most of my 36 years as a welder I've worn calf-length slip-ons like the Keens. Trousers over-boot to stop crap going inside, and no laces to catch dross and burn lace, boot and foot..

[@ryanfarthing8434]

Keen holds up on an asphalt mat as well. Those sketchers would melt in a week

[@firstlast446]

Surprised to see a brand like sketchers preform so well, I'd have never thought of them for work boots.

[@codysoest8646]

These are the most straight forward honest review videos anyone could ever ask for. Thank you good sir!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@drewe2331]

One factor that's important and hard to test is real life wear. I had a pair of Worx that felt great, fit well, light, good support, all that... but only lasted about 6 months before really falling apart.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@nickwickersham1703]

“Unfortunately the carrot experienced multiple fractures” hahaha I was dying with that one

[@BernardBethea6339]

better than loosing a toe lol

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching! Glad you enjoyed!

[@xSeRosiSx]

That test with the carrot was reminisce when the Mythbusters tested if steel toe boots could cut your toes off.

[@krisfarlee]

I love that Keen is finally getting the recognition it deserves through your videos. I'd love to see Keen against other well regarded and similarly priced boots such as Danners and Thorogoods. Awesome video! Thanks for testing!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@MrNastytrucker44]

I'd love to see some boots made in america, honestly is anything made here anymore? Pathetic

[@JrGoonior]

I had never heard of the Keen brand until I bought a pair of composite toe shoes on Amazon last week. One of the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn. Working as a mechanic for a John Deere dealer and on my feet most of the day, comfort and the composite toe were the biggest deals for me.

[@guillermotejeda692]

How long do they last you on average? What do you use them for?

[@krisfarlee]

@@guillermotejeda692 3 years on one pair with quite a bit of usage and 2 years on another pair with a bit less usage. I use one with a leather upper and carbon fiber toe for motorcycle riding and the other with an aluminum toe for work where I'll be stepping on hazardous & biological material and walking a lot. They both definitely have wear and look beat, but functionality remains unchanged. Still completely waterproof, protective, & comfortable.

[@gmguy156]

This guy is as real as it gets! Your efforts of real world situation testing is much appreciated!

[@SedatedByLife]

Well that makes me glad I bought the same set of Sketchers earlier this year they do just fine for working in a mechanics shop on oily floors and do pretty well with water ingress. I was surprised as to the puncture resistance and toe compression tests. Definitely worth the affordable price

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@nagydeak]

dry traction 4:52 wet traction 6:08 sole puncture 7:24 top puncture 8:32 electric 10:24 steel toe 16:32 comfort 18:35

[@twhort6569]

I wish everyone was that polite n helpful.... thanks dude 👍🤗

[@harryriveraconcha8908]

Thabk you, for the e-organic arrangement ?! Prejudments outthe braindoor 19:16;19:17;19:....

[@twilightsparkle75]

10:45 Melt Test

[@lordmadmunki1918]

Being in the military for 14 years, I’ve learned to wear quality shoes, and I love KEEN! Glad to see how well they did!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@mikeregan3174]

I'm not military, but if my house was on fire, I would grab my Keen boots on the way out.

[@b.c.2281]

I work in mining and my locker has three pairs of boots below it at work. Two are Keens, that's how much I trust them. They've got nice wide toe boxes and the composite toe caps are awesome. My last pair of Gore Tex lined Red Wings lasted about 6 months.

[@billbauer9795]

But these shoes are so heavy! Wouldn't it be tiring to drag that on your feet all day long?

[@rico76]

Keen, the USA made one's, are my everyday work boots. Comfortable as hell, durable, and already have 2yrs into them, only changing the insole every 4-6mo. I expect another year out of them, but I am very harsh and sometimes abusive to them, so the average user could easily get 10+ years if properly taken care of and routine insole changes. Cheap boots are uncomfortable and most won't even make it 6months with full time labor use. You spend less long term by spending more upfront in the case of boots. Redwings are also solid and comfortable.

[@KrepsyK]

I love how thorough you have always been and your content is evergreen. Please never take down any video unless it doesn't stand up to your standards or needs an update. Thanks for always being straight to the point, informative, and also entertaining.

[@WHSHAFT]

I would like to see some American made ones in there. Thorogood, Redwing, Justin's, Carolina's, etc... there are US made and China made of those boot brands that might be a good video

[@jaredleber2347]

and maybe add danner on there. most people on my jobsites wear danner, thorogood or justin's boots. would be nice to see those tested

[@jrambo2424]

I bought a pair of Carolina's last year because they partnered with Diresta. I was under the impression that they were American made. The pair I got definitely says "Made in Vietnam". They are just okay compared to the Redwings that they replaced.

[@TherapyGel]

I agree. I've had great experience with Thorogood (both USA and China made) and was surprised they weren't included.

[@Jester-Riddle]

I'd like to have seen De Walt Boots included as they are popular in the UK ...

[@denniskennedyjr.9128]

Been wearing Carolinas for 8 years now, Walmart brand lasts about 2 -3 weeks, the Carolinas have consistently lasted a year although the quality went down a little when went to overseas manufacturers

[@GrowlieDave]

Best line of the episode "Resistant to 475 Degrees, We're going to test that!" Thanks for this video, i spend 12 hours a day, 6 days a week in a pair of boots and walk about 24 miles a day, so my boots go from new to ruined in about 6 months.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.

[@GrowlieDave]

@@ProjectFarm No thank you, and ive shared more than once to friends with similar booty issues.

[@davidnewkirk2438]

Going through so many pairs of boots.. what’s held up the best for you/?

[@angelesparza2587]

i know youre probably sarcastic but you are walking a mile an hour my guy!!

[@pdufusc]

I have a pair of pull-on Dr Marten. Worn usually 6 days a week, sometimes 5, for the past seven years. Just under 2 years was on a flightline, acft/mech, the rest working at my barn, bush-hogging and working on cars... You have to have something to do when your retire! 75 next April... LORD has been good to me. Have a talk with HIM, HE's always there waiting to talk!

[@WojciechKalka]

And people in Thailand do construction in flip flops hehe really enjoying your videos all the best from Thailand

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Glad you enjoyed!

[@TheConjurersTower]

I've seen some mechanic's in India working on cars barefoot, carrying and swinging huge chunky steel parts around. Scary but what can they do?

[@jar407]

wonder how often they lose toes and or feet. doubt if theres any workmans comp either

[@MrSGL21]

the flip flop the national shoe for what every county in SE asia, and my state of Florida.

[@TheMrBrendo]

I owned those Sketchers when I was a rigger and i can attest that they were comfortable, they protected my toes from being run over by a 3000 lb dolly and they were very water proof, great value and a great video to prove it! Great video thanks!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for sharing.

[@chriscornett7299]

The Mrs would like to see Camping Coolers tested.

[@Nico777s]

Seconded

[@Ahto42]

yup

[@SerpentDrago]

3rd ed

[@broando336]

Second that one. *Esky for us Aussies....

[@sheetstr88]

Nice idea. Would like to see the Otterbox Venture cooler if you end up doing a video on premium camping coolers

[@Pastroodle]

If you're ever looking to create a spin off series...testing small kitchen appliances like blenders, air fryers, waffle makers, etc. would be amazing!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the suggestion.

[@mikeflippin5568]

This guy could test toilet paper and we'd learn which one is best.

[@drippingwax]

@@mikeflippin5568 I keep seeing ads for paper plates that are supposed to be able to hold 5 pounds of food with one hand. Which paper plate is the best?! :D (this should be cheaper than the boot test! :D)

[@masamune..]

@@mikeflippin5568 I second that request!

[@TheDarkSkorpion]

@@mikeflippin5568 I actually like the toilet paper idea. "At only .227 ounces, my finger easily penetrated the wet toilet tissue. With this little resistance, you'll have to be careful not to penetrate anything else..."

[@niko1even]

“the carrot experienced multiple fractures” I don’t know why but this is really funny to me.

[@Tuuktalus]

Its in carrotical condition.

[@niko1even]

@@Tuuktalus vegetative state

[@Tuuktalus]

@@niko1even Still edible.

[@LaloSalamancaGaming69]

LMAO

[@dricardkr]

Made it to 69 so u could enjoy more

[@isustudent514]

I've tried several brands-- Avenger, Wolverine, Georgia Boot, and Danner. The Avenger was pretty weak, $90 and lasted about a year before the grip and waterproofing went away. The Georgia Boot was somewhat pricey at $180 and was a nice boot, but ended up being awful for my line of work. The Wolverine was only $50 so I expected it to be trash but it was actually incredibly comfortable; I ruined that pair pretty fast though since I was working around concrete at the time. My current pair are the Danners and they are really nice, but expensive at $200. I was planning to keep buying Danners but I may look into Timberlines since they seem to have positive reviews. I like that this guy does the review but comfort is a huge, huge thing when it comes to boot quality, imo, and that's not really tackled here.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@DadCanFixAnything]

A good point, but as he said in the video, comfort is subjective. He did present a comfort graph at the end, but I agree that just giving a subjective score isn’t the same as documented testing. So how exactly does one document and test comfort?

[@sebasstein7014]

@@DadCanFixAnything You can`t because everyone has differently shaped feet.

[@conyo985]

Project farm one of the best channels in KZbin! Sometimes it's refreshing to see a youtuber not doing any sponsored content and not having ads in their video. When I was 20 years old, I bought a working boot because it looked good. Some working boots can be fashionable.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for sharing.

[@Leron...]

It's great to learn my inexplicable brand loyalty for Skechers shoes is apparently backed by excellent performance and not just a random gut feeling

[@Josh-eu9wz]

I’ve always had a problem with sketchers wearing out to fast but they’re extremely comfortable. Do you have any problems with them lasting? Because of that issue I’ve switched to timberland but they usually last around 2 years!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@TechGorilla1987]

I, too, have this feeling. I'm on my 4th set of a particular style. They sell them in extra wide which makes Sketchers the company to beat.

[@travisjazzbo3490]

Skechers does have impressive footwear, particularly for the price. If they last 1/2 as long, for the price and even the design, sure are hard to beat!

[@glenr7393]

@EZ Z not according to these tests!

[@blazinggazelle6957]

I've love my Keens! Been wearing a pair of hiking boots for five years and no wear on these boots and they are 100% comfortable. Best hiking boots I have ever owned. When these are worn out I'll get Keens again!

[@dmilk47]

Amen I've had mine 7 years now and going strong

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@tacticalcenter8658]

Check out Rose Anvil's channel. He dissects many brands and models of boots to see which ones will last and why they do. You have plenty of options as good or better than Keen's. I have a pair of Keen's and they are overall decent for the money. But not so much the made in China ones IMHO.

[@stephenstrang590]

The drop test on the Irish setters was shocking, and considering the look I would get those probably.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@mat22279]

M 19:15

[@Its_just_Dave.]

I knew there was a reason I loved my Keens. The only brand I used that were comfortable and didn’t mind wearing fit 12-16 hours.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@KirbyJ89]

I burn through a pair of Keen San Jose’s every six months and will not change just because their so damn comfortable. Plus love the rigger soles without a heel for climbing scaffold all day. The squared off inside edge bites good on rosettes.

[@SUBARCTICPSYCHO]

I am not impressed by their hiking boots. They fall apart after moderate use.

[@daftnord4957]

@@SUBARCTICPSYCHO i had a pair of keens last a year. i use them for moderate farm work/project uses and hiking/motorcycling. lasted just over a year before the inner fabric liner delaminated, so my heel would lift inside the boot pulling the liner up, and inside out when removing my foot. Also wore through the fabric in multiple spots. other than that they held up. because of that i'm looking for old school heritage style boots with no textiles to wear out or delaminate, leather and rubber only

[@robertm.6285]

@@ProjectFarm I wonder how a pair of Thorogood boots would hold up in the tests. The model I have is the 1957 series crazyhorse 8” tall boots.

[@samhanna9409]

Excellent editing! Very informative, no bs, straight to the point. Very solid content. We need more people like you making videos!! Awesome job!

[@chrisbotham5331]

I love how you just get straight into it no messing about and no background music👍

[@k4piii]

And still ~20 min, this guy is amazing!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@bjmurrey]

my guy, your comparison videos are magic. Love them. Very very useful for me - I am an off-gridder, mountain climber, distance hiker, and I remodel homes when I need gas money or plane tickets. So I constantly use these as resources :)

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for sharing.

[@brucewarren5248]

1. I continue to marvel at your ingenuity in setting up tests. 2. Has there ever been one product that you've tested that is just way better than all others?

[@MrApontjos]

I'm surprised that Sketchers even made boots, nevermind boots that can hold their own

[@FlourescentPotato]

They made the best value ones of all in fact

[@johnd4348]

There mote like running shoes with a composit toe. I wear them at work. They hold up very well. and comfortable. Mine last over a year depending on how wet they get everyday. I walk about 8 to 10 miles each day at work on hard surfaces. Industial HVAC.

[@diegorod117]

I do hvacR and I just went through my sketchers boots after almost 2 years and I live in the desert

[@james_chatman]

@@johnd4348 Good to know. Thanks!

[@kenmore01]

I have had a pair of sketchers for about seven months now, and they are holding up very well. They are composite toe but the places I visit say they're okay. I like the composite because I don't have to remove them at the airport security, though they probably aren't as strong as steel. I was always worried if steel got crushed, it may trap my toes in the shoe, but it looks like they bounce back which is nice. In my industry, though, they are only needed by me to walk through work areas until I get to a lab where there aren't many drop hazards of heavy items, so they seem a good compromise. I too have had pretty expensive work boots which fall apart after six months and that sucks since I don't work with harsh materials / environments. The boots I had prior to the sketchers made my feet hurt and I ended up having to go to a podiatrist and get an injection in my foot. Size matters a lot!

[@DvS2171]

I know it’s subjective, but a lot of the tradesmen I work with, including myself, go for thorogood boots. I would have liked to see those, red wings, Carolinas and maybe an Ariat.

[@amalau2472]

Sounds like we might have a part two one day! I agree, would love to see these brands as well.

[@brianpond945]

In the new construction trades in Northern California the boots I see most often are Danner, Redwing, Thorogood, Ariat, and (sometimes) Keen. Typically anyone wearing a lower end boot is either a manager type who only puts on boots when they want to walk the site, or an apprentice.

[@iratevagabond204]

I like Haix and Carolina (Matterhorn/Corcoran/etc.).

[@curtisjohnson944]

The reason is Thorogood is one of the few affordable boots that you can still buy unlined. Gore Tex in the heat is a killer.

[@jasonc3522]

That's almost a grand for 4 pairs of boots, throw in a pair of Danners, Nick's, and White's, and your upwards of 2 grand.

[@wignorf21]

Great stuff! I’m a heavy duty mechanic for a living and have tried several different boots over the years. Timberlands are by far the most comfortable boots I’ve ever worn and have been great for longevity. No other boot compares for me.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing!

[@bradsanders407]

I'm in masonry restoration, and I have to agree. No boot compares to Timberlands. Something that may be hints of bias is he uses some boots top of the line version where as the Timberlands are their middle-of-the-road series. Also, on the rail drop test, if you look closely, some of the steel toes are getting hit more square than others. All the highest ranked ones were getting all of the widest part of the rail directly across the toe where the more poorly ranked ones were getting hit at more of an angle and farther out making the overall leverage worse and impact surface smaller which is going to cause more damage. I'm also not a big fan of not being able to see the entire setup of things like the traction test. Moving the fulcrum just a fraction of an inch can make a big difference. Whether these things were intentional or just overlooked or deemed too hard to get perfect makes me question the entire test.

[@peanutbutterandjammy]

I'd really like to see this experiment Revisited with red wing, Georgia, Ariat, Brahma and the more traditional model of wolverine. These are the more popular brands here in Texas.

[@bsquadrider]

Throw danner and Justin in there too

[@858momoney1]

@@bsquadrider yup! Danners and chippewa are super durable

[@peanutbutterandjammy]

@@bsquadrider damn I forgot about Justin!

[@AdRock]

The Irish setter is a Red Wing boot. So he did that already.

[@garrettchurch604]

Thorogood union made in America baby USA USA USA

[@nunya___]

Wife: "Honey you need new boots." Husband: 💡 "Let's test that!"

[@mouaxiong8618]

Only the man decides when to get new manly boots.. so who or what are we testing exactly?

[@thedevilinthecircuit1414]

Guido!

[@CrippledEagle]

I used to have an “argument” with my Brother about boots. He would buy cheap boots and go through a minimum of two pairs a year. I buy Danners and usually get 5-6 years out of each pair. Yes I paid around $300 per pair but he was paying $40 a pair. $80 a year. 5years at $80 equals $400. He seemed to always have foot pain with those cheap boots while my Danners were comfortable from the beginning. I was on concrete 8 hours a day. Retired now and I have Danners that I bought 10 years ago as the agency I was part of bought us boots every year. I wear my Danner Fort Lewis boots for dress and my regular Danners for every day wear. I refuse to wear cheap boots.

[@promo130]

work boots are done after 1 year. no matter the price

[@V77710]

Though useless advice for construction sites, when it comes to "long standing" jobs, decent running shoes can also put up a good year or two with confort

[@CrippledEagle]

I have to disagree about work boots being used up after a year. I still wear a pair of my Danners that I wore in my work that I bought in 2016. I worked in diesel and road oils during the summer and cutting brush and other jobs during the times we couldn’t work on the roads. I spent the last 10 years of my career as a oil distributor operator and was continually exposed to chemicals that deteriorated lesser boots.

[@shabadoo24]

Does work boots in the states have a steel plate in the soles.. Here in Canada, most have steel toe and plate. They are tagged with a green triangle. Steel toe only are blue triangle..

[@promo130]

@@V77710 😂 sure, they will give alot of support after 1 year 😂

[@Derakkon2]

I absolutely love my Keens. They are very comfortable and have lasted much longer than my Dickies and Sketchers ever did. My Sketchers were more comfortable than my Dickies but they start falling apart a lot sooner. The Keens may be much more expensive, but I would have gone through several pairs of the Sketchers and a handful of the Dickies in the time that I have owned them. I think it's well worth it to spend the extra money if you can. Thank you again for the awesome videos!

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.

[@BonnieMCarter]

Ariat, wolverine, redwing and Tony llama are the most common brands I've seen in my workplaces (mostly because that's what the mobile safety shoe mobiles have on hand). I'd love to see those compared! And also how well the heel stays attached and water resistance.

[@jonathankuhn483]

Thorogoods too!

[@lamb88ert]

100%

[@rdizzel1]

Irish Setter is a redwing brand sold at redwing stores. I believe the difference is that they are meant more for outdoor wear like when hunting, so i would second a comparison involving main redwing branded boots.

[@RadDadisRad]

@@rdizzel1 Irish setter makes the original ironworker boot.

[@jeffries196]

Carolina and Georgia boots as well

[@swebigmac100]

For sale: boots. Toe sections might be missing. Willing to negotiate.

[@cocodojo]

Might find small bits of carrots inside, "slightly" used, otherwise "just like new"

[@Varangian_af_Scaniae]

Need to put the up as summer work boots.

[@swebigmac100]

@@cocodojo ”actually never worn”

[@swebigmac100]

@@frenchonion4595 that my wife approves

[@garydouglass3597]

For sale: CoolToe (tm) Summertime , warm climate boot. ( CoolToe socks available when I find my scissors.)

[@JunohProductions]

I'm honestly surprised that a $51 pair of boots managed to hold up in almost every category. The Sketchers seem to do everything I need a pair of boots to do so I might end up getting them in the future.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@thomassimons8570]

Don't do it. I have them and they are stuff as heck and uncomfortable.

[@philindeblanc]

@@timchamberlin9280 Sketchers for a few years did suck, but I think they have improved. I am shocked how they performed, so looks like they have actually done somethings to improve.

[@jasonwood7340]

I have a pair of sketchers slip on leather steel toes, they have held up really well for 2 years at a machine shop.

[@nabormartinez3266]

I bought some Sketchers about a year ago and I have to admit they are Very Comfortable. Unfortunately my job doesn't put them through rigorous testing so I can't speak to that, but they are still going strong from normal wear and tear.

[@fredinit]

Todd, Love the test - if you do a 'round two' on the boots - please add Red Wing in the mix... and a chainsaw/axe head trying to split the toe open. Think y'a missed with the axe and you now have a cloven foot. Please keep up the great work!

[@ordinaryjoe2247]

I'll second the Red Wing request. Always heard glowing praise about them over the years. My first pair didn't last more than a year before coming apart. For various reasons I currently have a second pair that's been holding up much better.

[@xalvist]

Loved it! Really eager to see some testing with "outdoor" boots like Lowa, Ascot etc. Another thing every man will be happy to see - knives! The one for a real job like Hultaforce, Mora, you name it - the cheap ones ofc, not those 200+$. Have a great everything!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for the video idea.

[@stephenparinisi7040]

Don't forget tac-force

[@deViant14]

Right I like Lowa and wouldn't even consider buying these brands. Timberland had their day but they like others here are pretty low end. My last Timbs definitely separated early.

[@JS-wc4xs]

@@deViant14 mine too. A 2 hour ride with the floor heat at max killed my Timberlands. (The vehicle was overheating)

[@JS-wc4xs]

I'd love to see cutco, shun, and henkels knives.

[@thatilluminati_3421]

I think testing wrench brands would be a huge hit and I'd love to see that video. Personally I'm especially interested in the ace house brand

[@eluminaryxarrais7735]

I've been using Keens for years primarily because they were the most comfortable work boots

[@ProjectFarm]

Great feedback on the Keens. Thank you

[@lindsaywilliambrown808]

Thank you so much. This is such a labor of love! So grateful for the immense time and due diligence you did on this, especially when most buyers of these are on a very limited budget. It's amazing to see that there's really no "best buy", with all the variation in performance in each element across brands. Thank you!

[@ProjectFarm]

You are so welcome!