Are Jews indigenous to Israel?

Are Jews indigenous to Israel?
The Salon discusses this question!
Jews are indigenous to Israel, the birthplace of their identity, language, religion, and culture. Zion is an age-old name for Jerusalem and the land of Israel. That is why Zionism is the name of the liberation movement of the Jewish people who sought to restore their freedom and independence in their ancestral homeland.
Jews are the indigenous population in the sense that they are the ethnic group w/ the oldest and longest continuous presence in the region. Some Jews might have bee absent fro certain periods of time but ther was never a period when the South Levant was devoid of any Jews.Jews are a subset of the ancient Israelites. Israelites are descendants of a subset of ancient Canaanites. Ancient Canaanites are the descendants of ancient Levantines,, who are in turn largely descendants of the ancient Natufians - the Proto-Semitic population that inhabited the region since at least 12, 500 BCE. There's plenty of historical, linguistic, archeological, religious, and even genetics to connect Modern Jews to ancient Israelites. So indeed, palestinaian Arabs as we see today actually got their identity from Arafat in the 1960'ies.
Carla Van Walsum KZbin Channel:
/ @carlavanwalsum8
/ @creatingloveproject
_______________________________________
Follow me here:
Instagram: / creatingloveproject
Website: carlavanwalsum...
Facebook: / carlavanwalsumbiz
__________________________________
Take the Quiz to Know What Type of Lover You Are!
www.carlavanwa...
Get your free gift: 3 Easy Tips to Be Heard Effectively
www.carlavanwa...
Get your copy here: Feelings and Needs
www.carlavanwa...
The 10 Commandments for Lasting Love
www.amazon.com...
Book a Free Call here:
calendly.com/c...
#carlavanwalsum #goldasgirls #israel #jews #podcast #youtube #viral #antisemitism #antizionism #carlavanwalsum #gaza

[@jfalk35]

Jews are originally from Judea, hence the name of our people. Although Jews have lived in Israel throughout the centuries, we are back again after 2000 years. 7 million Jews in Israel today. The largest Jewish community in the world.

[@Bluebelle51]

Obviously you've never been to Miami

[@jfalk35]

@@Bluebelle51 I have. But not nearly the population Israel has.

[@eudyptes5046]

The largest fascist community in the world.

[@fitzburg63]

@@jfalk35Israel is our homeland. We can share it with peaceful folks, but not with murderers, thieves and rapists. They have no place in Israel.

[@semsemeini7905]

As prophesied over 2,000 years ago.

[@MsMeWatchYou]

Thanks for making this very interesting historical and factual content. I learnt a lot. It makes sense to me now - especially understanding the biblical timeline and the archaeological evidence.

[@eudyptes5046]

Lol

[@paulhandley3246]

Long live Israel! It belongs to the Jews, it always has and it always will. 🇮🇱

[@kotorita1]

Crazy people you are. Crazy and criminals

[@Eli-j6r6j]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Eli-j6r6j]

"Most Zionists don't beleive in god but they do believe the he promised them palestine (the promised land)" ~Llan Pappe

[@johnwebber750]

@@Eli-j6r6j That Israelis are proud of their queers community means they are not the Judaism religious kind. Anybody holding real Abrahamaic faiths (Judaism/Christianity/Islam) find it very difficult to accept homosexuality. Hence the Jews in Israel now is of the secular, atheistic kind. That's definitely not who God gave the land to... ISRAEL IS A SECULAR, COLONIALIST SETTLER COUNTRY, NOT A TORAH LOVING JUDAISM COUNTRY THAT THE COUNTRY WAS MEANT FOR.

[@CarlaVanWalsum8]

We don’t dismiss any suffering. We just share facts.

[@Bluebelle51]

White supremacy movements always end in genocide facts

[@Rootportz]

Karen, I only watched the first 10 minutes and found many miss-information.

[@CreatingLoveProject]

Ah in that case you really need to deepen yourself in history books. Our information is fact checked. Facts that many people don’t want to know.

[@Bluebelle51]

@@CreatingLoveProject I have all sorts of original source materials what would you like to know?

[@GoldasGirls]

@@Rootportz Your answer showsn us how necessary our channel is - ppl like you just believe lies without fact checking. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@mitchellbelzer1359]

The land of Israel was given to the Jewish people by G-d as specifically stated in the Torah.

[@Bluebelle51]

Nobody believes in your sky daddy

[@mitchellbelzer1359]

Torah is the will and wisdom of the Creator and the blueprint for all of creation.

[@Bluebelle51]

@@mitchellbelzer1359 No one cares about your sky daddy Now shoo, there are grown ups talking

[@mitchellbelzer1359]

Latest Harris-Harvard poll shows that 82% of Americans support Israel over Hamas !

[@GoldasGirls]

@@Bluebelle51 It's not sky - its a history book. Go one time to Israel and you'd see archeological evidence all over. That's not at all the same for Arabs. but then, what do you care about the truth, right?

[@debwhite9432]

this should be removed from youtube. it is very insulting to me as I see the innocent kids that have been slaughtered. . at 14:30 omg already. I am 70 and yes I protested viet nam. your dismissive attitude just shows your ignorance.

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

Good record for the Hague though, and an interesting case study in the mental gymnastics played to justify supporting genocide.

[@debwhite9432]

@@bryonbiondolillo6545 we will term them Jezebels from now on. The zionist Karen!

[@GoldasGirls]

@@bryonbiondolillo6545 You clearly didn't watch, and just post.

[@GoldasGirls]

What are you talking about? It's very insulting to us, comments that clearly don't make sense because the writes didn't even watch. Ma'am. Open a history book instead of your mouth.

[@GoldasGirls]

@@bryonbiondolillo6545 The Haque loves us.

[@inkipinki8468]

Talking complete nonsense! You guys are living in a different world!

[@GoldasGirls]

Talking only truth. Facts are hard to believe right?

[@GoldasGirls]

Yes, not in your antisemitic world -at least. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@inkipinki8468]

@@GoldasGirls I see anything that you don’t agree with is antisemitic!

[@inkipinki8468]

@@GoldasGirls that is what you were brainwashed to believe!

[@inkipinki8468]

@@GoldasGirls

[@bentethompson7572]

Jews religion is much older than Muslims religion,, so sad that religion is not learned in school nowadays, this would not have happened if history lessons were in school, you can change history doesn't matter how much you try

[@pennydixon1565]

Yes

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

28:18 aah, yes, human shields, human shields..........not another penny to Israel

[@GoldasGirls]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fnPPYqdrra5rga8si=akc7uuafCyEkvZTo Not another penny to Israel

[@StopSettlerViolense]

KZbin bows to Israel.

[@magmil]

Of course, the Palestinian ones. They are indigenous to Palestine!

[@CarlaVanWalsum8]

No they are not. Most Arabs came the last 150 years. Rather watch the video -

[@yansideabacoa6257]

@@CarlaVanWalsum8Palestinian Arab Jews had always been in the land

[@NJIT22]

Arabs came as invaders from Arabia,

[@Bluebelle51]

@@CarlaVanWalsum8 You do know that there were Jewish Palestinians who were driven out of their homes and massacred by the white European Zionists, right? Palestinian Jews, Christians and even some Hindus were all part of the Nakba It has nothing to do with Arabs, it has to do with white Europeans colonizing a territory

[@magmil]

@@CarlaVanWalsum8I think that you mean well. Your facts are different than any that I've heard. Can you back it up?

[@TzefanyahBenAvrohom]

You're intentionally conflating Hebrew and Israelite artifacts as "Jewish." You're ignoring the indigenous people who converted to Islam. The Ashkenazi connection to the land is only spiritual.

[@semsemeini7905]

Historical revisionism the sport of antisemites. The Roman historian Flavius Josephus clearly documented the exile of Jews from Judea by the Romans in 70 AD and how they resettled throughout the Roman Empire. The RFoman Forum in Rome shows the destruction and looting of our Temple. The arrival of Jews with the Romans in France, Germany and Spain is clearly documented. There are also remains of Jewish catacombs in Rome from 2,000 years ago and Jewish presence in these coun tries from 2,000 years ago. 55% of Israeli Jews are refugees from Arab countries; Egypt, Iraq, Libya, Yemen, Syria, Sudan etc. We Iraqi Jews are descended from the the Jews taken by force by the King Nebukenezar in 586 BC from Judea.

[@Bluebelle51]

Defund Israel!

[@GoldasGirls]

For the haters who want to understand something: kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

26:40....only okay in Likud party charters ;) not another penny to Israel

[@Eli-j6r6j]

"Most Zionists don't beleive in god but they do believe the he promised them palestine (the promised land)" ~Llan Pappe

[@semsemeini7905]

Ilan Pape is not a good example.

[@Eli-j6r6j]

@@semsemeini7905 "If you repeat a lie as often enough you become a isreal"

[@Eli-j6r6j]

@@semsemeini7905 "Isreal is nothing but an illegal terrorist nazi colonail state used as a proxy by US/UK. the halocaust destroyed the jews but the jews joined zionism to destroy western imperialism" ~ A.N

[@GoldasGirls]

@@Eli-j6r6j Cheap comment. Gp somewhere else. Liar.

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

Ciao ladies, see you at the Hague........and not another penny to Israel

[@GoldasGirls]

Ciao. Another person that doesn't care about the truth.

[@GoldasGirls]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

With 18th century logic and based on a promise from gawd......who has a mysterious habit of favoring whatever group happens to be writing him into existence

[@Rozenblad]

This lecture is better than in class at the university.All those who try to take over the land from the Decedents of Jakob left and destroyed what they could,but thank GOD Almighty, there were places they couldn't demolished. GOD has blessed Israel wherever they lived .My great grand parents always were telling them, the Jews are GOD Ambassadors wherever they live.As a child, I couldn't understand GOD HIS divine plans for Abraham descendants.I have a plant they call Wandering Jew,when my great grandpa told me ,were ever you see the plant,Jewish people had lived there.We in the family are glad as Christians that our greatgrand pa told us were our family can from.In college my professor was Jewish and he was the one told me I should talk with great grandpa about his forefathers. He was always praying with a long white cloth over his head,we thought because of the hot sun,but he was Protestant Christian.GOD has called Israel back home were their ancient Ancestors has lived.When my mother set feet on the ground in Israel on the airport she kneel down lift up her hand ,and felt as one of the angels that watched over Israel stood there because many of her church members kneel down.I have soil from Israel when I pray ,I ask GOD to bless me and serve HIM.This video make me so strong and encouraging me to pray more for Israel. Since the war I pray longer for the Jewish people.I am black and blessed You must forgive me I was praying more for Christians to stay strong in their faith in GOD,now I bee longer in my prayer corner for Israel and the Jewish people to be stronger in their faith in GOD.Thank you mothers of Israel.I can say queens and princess of Israel. GOD bless and keep you under HIS wings.

[@mitchellbelzer1359]

Torah is the will and wisdom of the Creator and the blueprint for all of creation.

[@eudyptes5046]

Torah is just another collection of stupid jewish fairytales.

[@fitzburg63]

Nope, it is not, because simply there is no creator other than nature itself.

[@eudyptes5046]

Where can I see this creator guy?

[@fitzburg63]

@@eudyptes5046 might be on some drawings

[@mitchellbelzer1359]

G-d is close to All who call upon him in TRUTH !

[@KidIndia]

Palestinians are indigenous to that land. This is a channel that supports the last phase of European colonization

[@GoldasGirls]

Jews are indigenous to that land - for 3000 years. You seemingly follow the mis- information that circulates. Indigenous people can never be colonizers. Most Palestinians came to that region during the last 150 years. It's worth deepening yourself in the history if you want to have an opinion.

[@KidIndia]

@@GoldasGirls With your logic - then the people before the Jews should be rightful owners of that land. Just like how the Native Americans should be the rightful owners of America. If the Native Americans came back with genocidal weapons - pretty sure you wouldn’t be defending them because people have acclimated and adjusted to that land for centuries.

[@GoldasGirls]

@@KidIndia Your logic shows that you don’t know the history of that land. Jews have always lived their but expelled by Romans, Ottomans, etc. They came and left. The entire area is loaded with Jewish archeology. Most of what are called Palestinians since the 60’ies came in the 19th century. There was NO Srab state ever. The Arabs were not expelled by the Jews - even when Israel was established - most of the Palestinians left because the 5 neighboring countries told them to leave so they could kill and throw tje Jews in the sea- which didn’t happen miraculously. It is NOT about the land. It is that they dont want Jews next door. Most Muslims are raised to hate Jews - wherever they live. Please deepen yourself in the details before you want to respond. It seems you even didnt watch the video. And yes - several Native Americans and 1st People Canadians came last month to Israel supporting them and acknowledging them as the oldest Natives belonging. Do you know how incredibly small Israel is and how incredible much land in the hand of Arabs?

[@KidIndia]

@@GoldasGirls expelled by the Ottomans? Are you serious?

[@GoldasGirls]

@@KidIndia Yes I am. You do your homework. Let alone the app 850.000 Jews that were expelled from all Jewish countries around 1948. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWbIdp-gqLiEnMUsi=s77KIR3Agy4UoXjZ

[@judylan9207]

Toda Raba

[@yansideabacoa6257]

4 white women

[@GoldasGirls]

Very intelligent observation

[@yansideabacoa6257]

@@GoldasGirls Speaking on indigeneity to the Middle East. Please spare us the propaganda attempt. We know you’re all European colonists.

[@GoldasGirls]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@catsandcrows8880]

Why is that a problem? Are you a racist?

[@semsemeini7905]

Just as white as Lebanese and Syrian women.

[@selamatmunap9062]

The Palestinians are descended from the peasant Samaritans who converted to Christianity and Islam.And thus are descendants of the Children of Israel just like the Jews from Judea.The Palestinians are natives of historic Palestine.

[@semsemeini7905]

Historical revisionism.

[@GoldasGirls]

They are not. MOST of them came during the British mandate. They grew exponentionally.

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

I knew I wasn't getting through this without hearing it😂 but 😢....................not another penny to Israel

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

31:43

[@bentethompson7572]

And not one red cent to Hamas people in Gaza

[@bryonbiondolillo6545]

@@bentethompson7572 What's your excuse for the west bank? What's your excuse for East Jerusalem? What's your excuse for the settlements? Not another penny to Israel

[@javajava8856]

Which ones? The Ethiopian ones who look like sub-Saharan Africans? The Yemeni ones who look like yemenis? The Iraqi ones who look like a Iraqis? The Polish ones who look like poles? The Lithuanian ones who look like lithuanians? Last I checked, the 613 commandments don't change your DNA.

[@GoldasGirls]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHbcpWRsgZlroa8si=Fy1HKVSpKCDXS5zW

[@semsemeini7905]

We Iraqi Jews are known as Babylonian Jews because we are descended from the Jews taken by force in 586 BC to Babylon. Any Iraqi historian will confirm this. We ignore the historical revisionism from the antisemites and we really don't care what they think. We know our history. We don't need to be lectured by our enemies about our history.

[@sallev1136]

To palestinian from the river to the sea Israel is the only thing you'll ever see

[@eudyptes5046]

Israel just dug its own grave.

[@samehabuerreish8785]

The question is absurd Not all jews are descendants of Israel or Canaan ! Some Jews are , others are not ( Ashkenazis ) The same question can be applied to Muslims and Christians- are Muslims indigenous to Iran or Persia ?? If you are Persian , yes . If you are Arab Muslim or Malaysian Muslim , then obviously not. A Catholic Mexican is not indigenous to Rome Italy . Next year in Jerusalem is a prayer . It is a different Jerusalem . Why ? Because the Palestinians Jews in Jerusalem said the same prayer while they are in Jerusalem !!! The American blonde in the left lower corner is the poster child of semitism …. Notice how quickly they pivot to Islam and Muslims ….. The Jews they are talking about are the ancestors of the modern day Palestinians ( Christian and Muslim alike )

[@GoldasGirls]

Nope. Not much from Christians in the soil. Not 3000 years. But then, Christians can live freely in Israel, not in Gaza, or most other Muslim countries for that matter.

[@geralddavidson55]

DNA studies show that Palestinians are closely related to Askenanzi. Yes truth is stranger than fiction.

[@eudyptes5046]

@@GoldasGirlsThere was a small community of about 1000 Christians in Gaza, until the I"D"F killed many of them and destroyed their churches.

[@magmil]

Well said!