Are Shias Muslim & Haram Asked| Shamsi VS Two Shia | Speakers Corner

Answering Questions from Shia Regarding Haram
#speakerscorner in Hyde Park
Invite you to participate in making more dawah videos
Donation link:
paypal.me/dawah2soul
***Disclaimer: The views and opinions of partakers in these debates and videos in no way represent the views of Dawah2Soul but are a representation of what takes place at speakers Corner.

[@AHAdams]

Ma shaa Allah, I am so proud of Shamsi for educating the gentlemen.

[@LifeRelevant]

I am sorry but I find Shia and Christianity have very similarities. Ya Allah forgive me if I said wrong/bad.

[@saadhasan2300]

100%

[@yusufalmaweri]

😂😂😂😂😂 that's haqq

[@tawfikmohammed6051]

Me too I think the same thing

[@Monotheist-dr5id]

You Said correct

[@rcmysm9123]

Sunnis follow deviation from false leaders like Abu Bakr and Umar similar to Christians following Paul who deviated from the teachings of Jesus pbuh. So Sunni is the Paulinian version of Islam whereas real Islam is Quran and Ahlul Bayt! Alhamdulillah!

[@Sk80sLondon]

good brudda with the hoodie, seems sincere and listens to the proofs.may Allah guide us

[@LiveLoveMazy]

the hayawaan with the tattoo got humbled hahahahaha

[@WaqarKhan-ee5bt]

Hayawaan😂😂

[@ihab505]

If only Shias knew the "Fatiha" well enough to get to the comprehension of the verse "Ayak na'bod wa Ayak nast'een" they would know by default that this verse of the "Opening" Sura dismantles Shiasim as a whole from "ethna 'ashar" to "Imamism" and all Shias concepts/sects. La hawl wala Qwata ela b'Allah

[@rcmysm9123]

If only the salafi knew the "Fatiha" well enough to get the comprehension of the meaning of Siraatal-lazeena an'amta 'alaihim ghayril-maghdoobi 'alaihim wa lad-daaalleen The path of those You have blessed, Not of those who have earned Your anger, nor those who have gone astray.

[@mountainleopard5370]

@@rcmysm9123the verse you mentioned is a general verse talking about righteous people who Allah is pleased with, it does not refer to the ahle bayt specifically although we believe the are also included in this verse, so what point are you trying to make with this verse?

[@TheHonestOne1]

@@rcmysm9123ya Ali cannot madad

[@rcmysm9123]

@@TheHonestOne1 Saying you haven't a clue who Imam Ali ibn Abu Talib (as) is. Alhamdullilah! Ya Fatima!

[@TheHonestOne1]

@@rcmysm9123 yea ok son, it’s actually laughable 🤣 You do shirk

[@asimshafique7733]

I think the main problem is with the extreme twelvershia, I these guys are not showing hate

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

ya Ali CANNOT madad

[@tzarak6257]

Bro be saying that for 3yrs or more than I’ve seen 😂

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

@@tzarak6257 and u here reading all comments for more than 3 years

[@tzarak6257]

@@zahirkhan-yq3gr Hahaha yeah brother, I’m also using your till then XD

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

​@@tzarak6257 Never seen your comment of That

[@rcmysm9123]

The liar still won't type the names of the 5 purified by Allah swt under Al-kisa as he promised. Satan won't allow him and his hatred for Ahlul Bayt is clear.

[@superrobloxgod3778]

For all sunni brothers bukahri is ur book so love how you all ways use this as refrence

[@saudienglish5146]

Old is Gold

[@antonioatedzi6290]

Shamsi May god continue blessing you I love you mean

[@helpoj]

May Allah guide the lad with the hoodie

[@twatik]

U created ur account 17 years ago?

[@noyonbhai1440]

Its shirk to say " Madad ya Ali".

[@twatik]

I love how everytime the "why tattoo haram?😮" brother tries to be confident (which just looks so cringe wallahi), and when shamsi dismantles his claim he starts looking around at every atom except shamsi😂

[@user-se4jw4sn6o]

❤❤❤

[@abdulelah9726]

من المهاجرين والانصار ! يعني منهم أي من أمثالهم . . ❤

[@burhanuddinsandhu75]

i am from Algeria. we dont go down. we only go up 🤣

[@user-gb7uo6cc7k]

This guy loves the sound of his own voice I swear! As soon as an interesting point gets made and starts to heat up, he has to interrupt and speak over them and start preaching to the crowd slowly and cunningly diverting away from the point and then has the audacity to say others divert. Pot calling the kettle black!!!

[@Altima2024]

mASHALLAH

[@mohammadjangda2253]

One biggest issue in islamic world is that the non arabs learn to read the Quran in arabic which is a must reciting the words of Allah getting blessed with the Creators mercy but they do not read the translation of what they recite thus no understanding period. Allah states to think and ponder upon what is read recited from Quran bit not reading the translation many muslims do not even know that Allah is asking to think and ponder upon what they recite from Quran. This lack of knowledge filling up the ignorance gap if acquired is as simple as going a step further and also reading teanslation after the arabic recitation of Quran. Quran is in arabic. Pure preserved words of Allah and thus fornit to be Quran must be recited in Arabic only but then mandatory should be the translation too for non arabs to be able to ful fill what is commanded within it ie the thinking and the pondering aspect. Reason due to ignorance many ppl if it be shias and some sects of sunnis gonpray to Prophets pbut all and saints and members of Prophets pbuh family. Reading 67:21 translation Or who is it that will provide for you if He withholds His provision? In fact, they persist in arrogance and aversion ˹to the truth˺. 67:28 Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “Consider this: whether Allah causes me and those with me to die or shows us mercy, who will save the disbelievers from a painful punishment?” Both above verses translation from tje Clear Quran are of Surah Mulk. Now after reading the translation and understanding it, thinking and pondering how can one call upon saints and Prophets pbut all for help and other things if they r not present in this world. As we ask others to make dua for me was what ppl asked the Prophet pbuh when was present here on earth. Simple! Period!

[@YA-hm5zy]

No it's what they have been taught. Plenty non Arab Muslims understand.

[@muniralam1501]

Anyone believe Kitab al-Kafi by Yaqub kulayni is a kafir......or Not Muslim or in Islam.

[@or1equalsto1]

"he does shirk and say astagfirullah to me" 🤣😂🤣😂😨😨😨😂🤣

[@twatik]

Its crazy

[@nasirali9609]

Sunni islam is the real & right islam.

[@Ochocunco]

Did shamsi say he has 2 wife’s?

[@Foralluhaterz]

Yes, MashaAllah good for him

[@user-zj5kj4tc8e]

These youngsters need schooling

[@IamJeweler]

Gold tooth is Haram brother Shamsi.

[@ar.dz09]

its for medical/dental purposes so its permissible because its not used as jewellery

[@thepr1ntgnome430]

🤡🤡​@@ar.dz09

[@Warlock786]

Shamsi needs to stop snorting charlie before he debates.

[@osamamanan2723]

Shia laymen are muslims if there is a room for taweel which protects you from takfeer.

[@superrobloxgod3778]

U lost my friend

[@siimoveli]

the other guy is so slow :D or he just cant accept facts because he likes to follow his desires

[@Humble.Servant]

_Of the 72 sects in islam, which only sect will enter jannah according to the god of Islam?_

[@alqudzz-9864]

The one who follows Quran and sunnah Not all Shias,sufis will go hell, just the ones who curse sahaba (Mohammed’s companion and his wife aesha, who Allah praised in quran and even some of them like uthman helped compile the Quran) And the people who commit major shirk by saying maddad y’a ali or calling for ahlul bayt or the dead to help them will go help as this isn’t in quran or sunnah And Allah said he’s all hearing, and hears the Duas of his servants, so why does he need another person to hear us? This is like Christianity

[@Humble.Servant]

@@alqudzz-9864 so the god of islam *praises the prophet and his wife.* The same is recorded in your scriptures. Good! *Which came first? The scripture or the final prophet?* The God of the Bible praises no man. John 12:43 For they loved the glory that comes from man more than the glory that comes from God. Hebrews 13:15 Through him then let us continually offer up a SACRIFICE OF PRAISE TO GOD, _In your case it's the reverse._ Grow up soon bro!

[@alqudzz-9864]

@@Humble.Servant nope we praise Mohammed as the best being then the prophets, then his companions we don’t go to the level saying Jesus is god like ur book does

[@alqudzz-9864]

@@Humble.Servant u say Jesus is god when he is tired, when in the bible it says god can’t be tired, u say Jesus is god when in the bible Jesus was hungry and not all knowledgeable When god is meant to be all knowledgeable Jesus said “only the father knows the hour” if he was god wouldn’t he know that?

[@alqudzz-9864]

@@Humble.Servant god praises them because their good people and helped Mohammed and said “he’s pleased with them” and that their destined for heaven for their deeds what’s wrong with god praising his servants for the good they did.

[@patlimkh]

So which sect will go to heaven Suni or Shia?

[@rosdykalat2620]

Doesn't matter what sect you are in...the Muslim that will go to Heaven is the one who follows Allah's Quran and the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad (saw)

[@patlimkh]

@@rosdykalat2620 but it’s obvious all sects are following the Quran differently. That might be a problem right?

[@rosdykalat2620]

@patlimkh just like any other sects in any other religions. Christians do the same for the bible ..just ask the protestants, Catholics, orthodoxy

[@rosdykalat2620]

@patlimkh difference with Christianity os that Catholics have certain number of books, Catholics have their number of books etc... In Islam, Shia and Sunni all follow tye same Quaran

[@patlimkh]

@@rosdykalat2620 I’m talking about Islam

[@user-gb7uo6cc7k]

Truth is it’s hated when we say Ya Ali because it burns you to the core how firm we r on our conviction to imam Ali as and his position and relationship (by family and as a companion) to the Holy Prophet saw as well as being his best chosen and successor so yous try and twist it to look like shirk! YA ALI🙌🏽 Ya Allah Ya Muhammad Ya Ali!🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽

[@Warlock786]

well said Brother...Shia Islam is the only Islam.

[@abbasawan1829]

holy prophet Muhammad pbuh so many times told the Muslims to only follow quran and his holy ahlebait

[@djelalhassan7631]

That is a lie, Honorable Messager Muhammed/Praising one told the Muslims/Peacemakers to only believe in and follow the Quran/Reading alone as he was believing and following the Quran/Reading alone and only.

[@SalehAbdurRaheem]

Prove it.

[@djelalhassan7631]

@@SalehAbdurRaheem I hear that the fire of Jahannam is very very HOT, enjoy the heat

[@twatik]

OPEN QURAN 9:100 RIGHT NOW AND COME BACK😂

[@khalidedros743]

Whenever Shia debate, when it's their time to be silent and listen to our sunni brothers to learn the Deen, notice how they look all around them instead of listening to the answers. They all insincere. Ontop of that, no understanding on how to interpret quraan, yet wants to argue their beliefs with someone that has studied that. My experience with Shia, none of them read quraan properly.

[@saadhasan2300]

There are no Shia hafidh

[@wonderwalls3565]

Ammar bin Yasir was killed by Mawiya's Army. Allah's messenger's hadeeth mentioned that the party who kills Amar bin Yasir will be calling him to hell fire and he will be calling them to Jannah Mawiya was the leader of the bagi jamat and according to the hadeeth of the prophet PBUH should have been killed. Ghadiya, the guy who was one of the 10 sahabas who took the oath under the tree, he killed Mawiya and he kept crying rest of his life after realising that he killed Ammar bin Yasir and he remembered the hadeeth of the prophet PBUH about his demise. The Sunnis need to come out of their ignorance and start acepting that Mawiya was the bagi and should have been killed.

[@guardacivil6237]

Go worshipping Ali 😂

[@agostocobain2729]

Shamsi, your'e saying Iraq was in better shape before Iran stepped in? when America ravaged the place? Isis came to Iraq before we stepped in, and we supported Iraq with money, and artillery, and Iraq has always been a majority Shia country even during the Iran-Iraq war. Iraq was a majority Shia country before Iran even was. Also, we Persians have a lot of scholars that you guys look up to like, Al Bukhari, Imam Muslim, Al Juwayni, Al Tabari, Abu Hanifa, Al Ghazali, Khwarizmi, Imam Razi, and so many more scholars, and Persian Sahaba like, Salman Al Farsi, Fayruz Al Daylami, Salim Mawla, Abu Hudhayfah, Munabbih Ibn Kamil. Stop saying we destroyed Iraq, Iraq was in bad shape before us. What do you think man, Iraq is 70% shia country, with way more devoted Shia than Iran bro. What do you think, we made Iraq Shia? stop your anti-Iran campaign. I've noticed you don't like us, and If you don't like us, then you don't like our scholars, and sahaba as well!

[@SalehAbdurRaheem]

Iran was majority sunni country until a tyrant Sufi turned shia forced everyone to accept Shi'ism at the threat of death. Mat Allah make Iran Muslim upon the Sunnah of the prophet(saws) again.

[@lhommemystere3938]

@@SalehAbdurRaheem Baraka Allahoufik, shia has been invented by a jew and was firstly spread by the fatimiyoun... they are moushrikoun kafir. It has been reported by the consensus of the scholars he dare quote and they were all muslim upon the sounnah, that anyone saying : - Aisha mother of the believers, may Allah be pleased with her, has committed zina is a kafir bilah and if dies on that belief, he will join fir"awn and the moushrik of qurash - Ali or any human being is better than the prophet muhammad peace be upon him or any other prophet is a kefir by ijma3 al 3oulamaa - Asking and call upon 'ali or any other human being besides Allah is a moushrik kafir. -Cursing the best believers of the community after the prophets and messengers that is to say abou bakr, , "omar, 3othman and 'ali and any other sahabas, will be cursed and if he denies that they are moubashouroun bi al janna kefir bi lah. The shi3a are kafir bilah and some other moushrik in addition, you are our enemies and we will never respect you, you are worse than atheists to the extent that you spread ambiguities. A word to the wise and the sincere ones.

[@saadhasan2300]

Shia death squads came long before ISIS

[@baghdade]

I don't think shansi is a qualified person to talk about religion. He is Hakim wershiper submits to the missgided ruller

[@mariokart6118]

Smug Shia kid laughing

[@twatik]

😂

[@jenitagomes2401]

Question is did God told the hour no....so Even Jesus cannot tell.... because Jesus is word of God......

[@alqudzz-9864]

Huh?

[@jenitagomes2401]

​@@alqudzz-9864 ??

[@Amben991]

Wrong video, this person also commented on the video with brother Siraaj, still their English didn't improve 🤣🤣

[@alqudzz-9864]

@@jenitagomes2401 english pls

[@alqudzz-9864]

God knows when the hour is Jesus doesn’t he even said in the bible “only the father knows the hour” so if he was god why wouldn’t he know?

[@lhommemystere3938]

Baraka Allahoufik, shia has been invented by a jew and was firstly spread by the fatimiyoun... they are moushrikoun kafir. It has been reported by the consensus of the scholars he dare quote and they were all muslim upon the sounnah, that anyone saying : - Aisha mother of the believers, may Allah be pleased with her, has committed zina is a kafir bilah and if dies on that belief, he will join fir"awn and the moushrik of qurash - Ali or any human being is better than the prophet muhammad peace be upon him or any other prophet is a kefir by ijma3 al 3oulamaa - Asking and call upon 'ali or any other human being besides Allah is a moushrik kafir. -Cursing the best believers of the community after the prophets and messengers that is to say abou bakr, , "omar, 3othman and 'ali and any other sahabas, will be cursed and if he denies that they are moubashouroun bi al janna kefir bi lah. The shi3a are kafir bilah and some other moushrik in addition, you are our enemies in Allah and we will never respect you, you are worse than atheists to the extent that you spread ambiguities. Your belief is based upon nothing but lies and rejection of the sounnah and the Quran that you don't even know. A word to the wise and the sincere ones.

[@wonderwalls3565]

"Cursing the best believers of the community after the prophets and messengers that is to say abou bakr, , "omar, 3othman and 'ali and any other sahabas, will be cursed and if he denies that they are moubashouroun bi al janna kefir bi lah." Provide source. First 3 I agree.

[@masumanoorbhai7958]

Dudes , there is not a single Shia mosque in Palestine , yet who supports them the most , Shias , Oman Ali states support the oppressed first and that's the Shia doctrine , Sunni states are hardly there .

[@27Seymur]

The same people who killed Uthman after they joined to the army of Ali and then they betrayed him and killed him so are still believe that Ali was in haqq then he did not punished them the killers of Uthman?

[@TheMan-xp4cb]

Shia are not muslim

[@masumanoorbhai7958]

This Shanghai just knows how to bark and throw Arabic around to sound very knowledgeable but will not debate a true Shia scholar on a moderated regulated formulated forum , says , nononono, and runs away

[@Foralluhaterz]

Your nakshawani went running

[@selemanmartin]

Always truth is painful, sorry.

[@Omar_0987]

Shamsi you don’t know how to debate. All you do is shout. Very very lost and continue being lost.

[@ar.dz09]

go debate him then. you seem to have more knnowledge

[@Omar_0987]

@@ar.dz09 Debate him? Haha. You don’t debate someone who has very small knowledge. To debate someone you need to be qualified. Nobody likes to debate someone who is lost and screams while talking. Also, what they doing is not debating. It’s very embarrassing way of doing dawa.

[@masumanoorbhai7958]

I see a lot of carp by non shoals on these threads , they don't have the faintest idea of Shia doctrine and regurgitate filth fed by apologists like Shmshi

[@irfankurrimbux5445]

Oh champion, oh hero, I watched your debate with brother A'ala al Mahdawi, it was very interesting ! You started stammering, finally lost your tongue and fled like ..... If you don't understand the Quran, why pretend to perform da'wa ? You want to know where, in the Quran is mentioned to follow Ehle Bait عليهم الصلاة و السلام, stay tuned : قُل لَّا أَسْأَلُكُمْ عَلَيْهِ أَجْرًا إِلَّا الْمَوَدَّةَ فِي الْقُرْبَىٰ ۗ do you think you follow this order of Allah ? إِنَّمَا وَلِيُّكُمُ اللَّهُ وَرَسُولُهُ وَالَّذِينَ آمَنُوا الَّذِينَ يُقِيمُونَ الصَّلَاةَ وَيُؤْتُونَ الزَّكَاةَ وَهُمْ رَاكِعُونَ who is your third wali here? ( إِنَّ الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا وَعَمِلُوا الصَّالِحَاتِ أُولَئِكَ هُمْ خَيْرُ الْبَرِيَّةِ ) يقول تعالى ذكره: إن الذين آمنوا بالله ورسوله محمد, وعبدوا الله مخلصين له الدين حنفاء, وأقاموا الصلاة, وآتوا الزكاة, وأطاعوا الله فيما أمر ونهى ( أُولَئِكَ هُمْ خَيْرُ الْبَرِيَّةِ ) يقول: من فعل ذلك من الناس فهم خير البرية. وقد: حدثنا ابن حميد, قال: ثنا عيسى بن فرقد, عن أبي الجارود, عن محمد بن عليّ( أُولَئِكَ هُمْ خَيْرُ الْبَرِيَّةِ ) فقال النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: " أنْتَ يا عَلي وَشِيعَتُكَ". تفسير طبري So, what's the use of these futile discussions ? You pretend to follow Quran & Sunnat, here you are : حديث عُمرَ بن الخطَّاب رضي الله عنه: ((تركتُ فيكم أمرين لن تضلُّوا بعدهما: كتابَ الله جلَّ وعزَّ، وسُنَّةَ نبيِّه صلَّى الله عليه وسلَّمَ)) [إسناده ضعيف] أخرجه بَحْشَل في ((تاريخ واسط)) (ص50)، وفي سنده مجهول FAKE hadith, chain of transmission unknown ! And now the cherry on the cake : مسند أحمد | مسند الأنصار حديث زيد بن ثابت، عن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم (حديث رقم: 21578 ) 21578- عن زيد بن ثابت، قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: "إني تارك فيكم خليفتين: كتاب الله، حبل ممدود ما بين السماء والأرض، أو ما بين السماء إلى الأرض، وعترتي أهل بيتي، وإنهما لن يتفرقا حتى يردا علي الحوض LOOK WHOM IBN HANBAL HAS RECOMMENDED YOU TO FOLLOW !!!!!

[@guardacivil6237]

Sry i forgot to being your dog food out.

[@theamirbarismillworks2253]

Shamsi, prove your Sunni calipate from Quran and sunnah.

[@lhommemystere3938]

it's proven since a very long time, just because you are an ignorant does not mean it's not true. if you don't believe in this, you are not a muslim. If you think ,'ali mayh Allah be pleased with him is better than the prophet, you are a kafir bi lah et if you ask him besides Allah, you are mushrik kafir.

[@rcmysm9123]

@@lhommemystere3938 Prove it from the Quran is the challenge, why are you avoiding it?

[@lhommemystere3938]

@@rcmysm9123 Because you won't accept it anyway, not from Quran only but from sunnah as well for those who want to accept truth.

[@rcmysm9123]

@@lhommemystere3938 Shamsi keeps becoming a Quranist when talking about Shi'ism, so that's the challenge back to you guys. It's actually just exposing the disingenuous tactics of Shamsi. Thanks for being honest and admitting it.

[@lhommemystere3938]

@@rcmysm9123 There is no challenge here, you are ignorant and you can't even align 2 words in Arabic without making a mistake let alone reciting and memorizing the Quran. You are a shaitan and shi3a as a whole are kefir bi lah, pagan disbelievers, useless to waste time on you, you follow your desires. No need to debate with someone like you who rejects the holy Quran and the Sounnah that Allah soubhanahu wa ta'ala has both preserved. Keep crying in a corner, in silence, ya sheitan. wAllahi we will fight you even worse than we fight regular disbelievers. A word to the wise.

[@kaashee]

Wallaahi these sons of mutah should learn respectful communication from ibn halal. We should not engage with fools

[@narco-zone7404]

Wallahi Aysha is a who're and your son of a who're. You should learn from Aysha lanatullah

[@theamirbarismillworks2253]

Shamsi, debate with Yasser al Habib. He will thrash you!

[@admiralesevic6305]

Who is yasser or shsmsi …. Is Allah and his masenger and Quran biger then this who you mentioned use logic if you believe in Allah ?

[@otoos1284]

Shias can have tattoo, anal is not haram... read in their scripts anal doesnt even invalidate fasting like wtf I mean who are these people

[@rcmysm9123]

Shias follow real Islam, you follow usurpers.

[@Warlock786]

like you know better ?

[@Anal-Kapoor-uf7nn]

Mature men vs school bullies.