Arthur Morgan Making Me Cry AGAIN - Red Dead Redemption 2 - Part 31

[@kambo8930]

Hearing the most badass gunslinger say he's afraid, will always hit me in the feels

[@ejmtv3]

When he stared into the abyss while saying that line always gets me 😢

[@michelrogowski2950]

Landon Rickets said he was Afraid? 🤔

[@Caped__crusadervugilan]

He should be the day he shall be judged is not looking good you shall fear god because he can destroy Body and soul

[@nerdtom4513]

@@michelrogowski2950 Nope, Arthur GOATgan said so...

[@nonfungiblemushroom]

Truth. And the "But... I still don't believe in nothing" line is like foreplay ffs... goddammit now I'm crying again! Why do I keep doing this to myself?

[@cloutchaser8842]

That conversation with the Sister always get me 😢😢. “Life is full of pain but there’s also love and beauty” my favorite quote

[@miinijeu]

sister calderon is one of my favourite characters in this game and if only rockstar added mexico we might have been able to have more contents with sister calderon as john

[@noobishmacgaming]

It also really describes the game. The story is full of pain for the characters, but there is a lot of love in the decent ones and a metric ton of beauty in the world they inhabit.

[@montv291]

"I guess...I'm afraid." That moment is done better than 90% of films out there. It gets me every time.

[@neondarling379]

Watch more films

[@sillo__ett]

​@@neondarling379 no need, they're right

[@neondarling379]

@@sillo__ett definitely watch more films.

[@DarkPrinceEV]

The conversation with the sister scene is one of the top 3 part of this game, if not the best. It always hits hard.

[@FearlessGamer27]

You know a games story is great when you can make a S-tier cutscene just be two characters talking at a train station.

[@1polyron1]

@@FearlessGamer27 and to top it off it's a missable cutscene, many miss this gem

[@DarkAttackYT]

This is where Arthur Morgan became my favorite Rockstar character and no one could have done it any better than Roger Clark.

[@itskiki4979]

I would even say fav character of all time not just from R* games

[@nerdtom4513]

He is my favourite fictional character of all time ngl

[@1polyron1]

"Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act." are words to live by

[@BFG-hv2ml]

for real.

[@1polyron1]

@@BFG-hv2ml In my darkest moments I try to remember that: not everything is bad, lead with love

[@MrTSkV]

That conversation is Oscar worthy. Bravo Rockstar. It's very sincere and so profoundly sad

[@Lew99900]

“Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act” - my favourite line from Sister Calderon. Had me blubbering like a little boy after that conversation.

[@christopherchadwick2659]

You shouldn’t apologise for tearing up during emotional moments. We watch your reaction in the hopes this masterpiece affects you as much as it affected us. It helps us to relive the moment. The ‘I’m afraid’ scene gets me every time. You don’t need to hold back the tears.

[@rangerghost2474]

Hearing Arthur say “I’m afraid” was like a dagger to the heart the first time I experienced this game. I still cry every single time even though I’ve seen it countless times. Having him FINALLY admit that he’s scared of death. Of losing. I love this game. It’s truly amazing.

[@PerStenback]

That together with the look in his eyes makes it so real, that you can feel his fear through the screen.

[@fabiog9447]

It's so emotional to see someone as tough as Arthur opening up about his fears

[@Red_dead_Redemption_4_Life]

this scene always gets me like its the first time💔💔

[@belgarion4513]

That scene with the sister, is the final push for Arthur to become a good man in my opinion. Such a powerful scene, such an insightful character !

[@federicocarnebale]

Exactly

[@TheBlarggle]

I dunno, he seemed to be a good man, and depending on how you play he does good thing. She even says "Everytime I see you, you're helping people and smiling." She knew he was already good man, it was that moment he realized it too.

[@AnnedolfFrankler911]

Seeing Arthur's face when he says that he is afraid... it always gets to me...

[@SLITHERIS]

It’s so sad when you think about the fact that Arthur’s son and ex girlfriend died for few bucks which is similar to how Arthur contracted tuberculosis by beating a man for a few bucks who was already almost dead. Arthur’s redemption arc is in my opinion the best redemption arc in video game history.

[@altairtodescatto]

It trully is some red dead redemption!

[@MaYoRofSMACK]

Ah the Sister Calderon scene. I've seen it so many times now & it still always hits me like a freight train when Arthur utters those two little words. Great video as always, Cam!

[@S0LAVELLANHELL]

tbh i was constantly on the verge of tears at the later half of the game, and then moments like this happened and it was over for me lmfao

[@Merczid]

What an open-minded, genuine, and delightful person you seem to be! Your videos are a silver lining in this rough patch in life I'm going through. Thank you, truly.

[@frama7844]

1:40:00 don´t appologize! That scene made me weep like a baby. Greetings from a grown 45 year old man. I love your videos

[@mummycool1]

I've done 7 playthroughs of this game & lost count of how many times I've watched others enjoy the game. It never gets old, it's a masterpiece.

[@bamacopeland4372]

@@mummycool1 same

[@onemoreturn]

"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." That's a beautiful line.

[@dukiroki6891]

The whole conversation is so touching but the line that always gets me so emotional is (obviously with the "i'm afraid") sister's "But then i meet someone like you... and everything makes sense."

[@TheSatyrIcon]

Cam, I have been watching your RDR2 playthru from the beginning, hoping you'd to get to the Arthur/Sister cutscene and you made it... Wonderful. It's easily My fave cutscene ever and you continually provide great playthrus on your channel. THANKS!

[@xdDominik99]

Played this game multiple times and have seen this scene even more often. But Arthurs "I'm afraid" gets me every time.

[@JohnMarston1876]

Please never apologize for crying, I promise anytime you cry it’s usually a really special moment. The nun interaction is like one of my top 5 favorite interactions.

[@AnnaDiLiberto]

Seeing the thumbnail I better get some tissues too. That part always gets me to tear up.

[@Cambonano]

Tissues will be needed! 😭

[@jacksonhodge4638]

20:07 the first time I had this encounter I was lucky enough to come in through the back and the Grizzly was walking out. Happened to have a powerful rifle, still scared the shit outta me. Glad you’re playing this again!

[@lynette50]

The low honour talk, not with Sister Calderón, but someone you'd least expect, is also hard hitting in the feels. It's extremely hard when you are playing a low honour ending, not to switch to high honour after the conversation. Both versions hit hard. Trust me 😢

[@421sup]

who is it? Never heard of this before

[@pickledidiot4569]

@@421supreverend swanson

[@Bos6682]

You only get that convo if you do not do the nun missions.

[@SLITHERIS]

If you’re sad that the game is almost over then don’t worry, if I had to guess you still technically have about 12-15 hours left maybe even more because you love to take your time and do as many side activities as possible. I have been absolutely loving the way that you play this game, the way that you take the time to smell the roses reminds me of the way that I played this game for the first time.

[@joeydrummer7929]

That conversation with the sister makes me tear up everytime. Only game I’ve ever teared up playing .

[@MrDarkcook]

We all waited for the Sister's scene reaction :) One of the most tearjerking moments of the game !!

[@ajbratley9082]

i no joke bawled my eyes out for a good 30 minutes after the conversation with the sister. i went into this game knowing arthur's fate, but i wasn't expecting to love his character as much as i do. his face when saying he's afraid killed me, he looked so sad and worried. i cried a lot during all of chapter 6. every time his sickness was brought up, every time i got him to help people, conversations with mrs. downes, all of it ruined me. a big reason this hurt so much for me is that the first family member of mine that passed away was my grandfather. i was in highschool and he was the youngest and most healthy, active grandparent of mine. he ended up getting cancer that spread and progressed very rapidly. in 6 months he went from being diagnosed, everyone being told it was going to go away, then to him quickly getting worse and passing. since then i've had this huge fear and hole in my heart thinking about what was going on in his head during his final weeks. i can't imagine what it's like knowing that the odds aren't in your favor. being sick like that has been something i worry about ever since, even though i'm perfectly healthy. this experience of mine really made this part of the game hit close to home for me. i adore this game with all of my heart, and it has taught me a lot of things i think i've needed to hear.

[@cliffharjo712]

The train scene when Arthur says he's afraid never fails to bring a tear to my eyes. My younger brother is terminally ill and it breaks my heart to think what one goes through when you find out that your health is slowly failing and every day the pain and anxiety and uncertainty grows stronger. I just wish I could take his place and it was me that was sick instead of him, his suffering is unbearable and I'm not even the one sick.

[@MideanStone]

Easily the best written game of all time. No other game comes close. This is the only game that repeatedly brought me, a 44 year old man, to tears. Bravo Rockstar.

[@lucaspintooc]

I cried too, this scene always gets me. The two best missions in the game back to back, this episode was full of emotion.

[@ratm1966]

Gotta say that his talk with the Sister always hits you in the feels. I watched this episode of your play-through earlier today at work. Needless to say, I was happy that I sit in the back of the office behind three computer monitors.

[@michaelallen2957]

I’ve been waiting so long to watch you see that scene with the sister and Arthur. I’ve played through it myself and watched many people react and it gets me every time. I think it always reminds me no matter how strong or tough you think you are, we are all still human and even the toughest people can still be afraid. Seeing Arthur say that may be one of my favorite parts of any show or game ever. They did such an amazing job with this game.

[@madTbonez]

The encounter with the sister gave me an unexpected chin wobble on my last play through too.

[@danseeloff867]

There's still so much to do in this game, even after you finnish it there are the rock carvings, dinosaur bones & a ton of unique things to find.

[@KV-Kensei]

That “I’m afraid” hits us all in the same way

[@augart89]

That "I`m afraid" line still makes me cry to this very day... I mean, he had such a rough upbringing, and to listen to a such hardened man to say something like that... To expose himself like that. I don´t know. Sister Calderón is such an underrated character. 20:13: poor Cambo lol 1:33:12: damn!

[@mikepetterson357]

Fine Art of Conversation DOESN'T get any better. It gets us ALL everytime. The trees tie in qith the Drwamcatchers. Even if You look them up, it doesn't create a fun side mission. Again, WONDERFUL PLAYTHROUGH

[@gmoneyak]

I know everybody likes to talk about the sister scene, and it's obviously very deep and emotional. But I still like to think that the Bridge To Nowhere mission and conversation with John is one of my favorites as well. A real turning the corner for Arthur and planting the seed for John. Great video

[@snookyookum]

The sister is one of my favorite people in this game. There are three scenes she has with Arthur (I think) and in every one she is nothing but uplifting and life confirming. The honesty and the way Arthur opened his soul to her brought me to tears. A separate fun side note: the 100 dollars Arthur got back from the wage thief in today's dollars, 1,900, about 1800 euros. I love your gaming videos and I'm sure that movies, music and anything else you decide to try out will go well for you. I wish you the best. PS; I adore Sadie in everything she does and in the way she picked herself up from the depths and made a life for herself. I think there's a good example there for all of us. ❤

[@Auramus]

that "I'm afraid" from Arthur hit me like a truck too.

[@GuNStaRia]

01:37:05 one of the strongest scene ever

[@Winter_ECU]

Arthur and Niko are the best characters Rockstar has ever made... the way he says I'm afraid.. cried the first time I played this part...

[@John-996]

Its great you found the rail way quest so many ways to go about that quest make sure to go back for the second part. I missed this quest on my first playthrough. Many people who play this game miss the quest.Since you did this in chapter 6 Arthurs dialogue changes since you have high honour if you do the quest in Chapter 2 its differnt. you can also tie the guy up and bring him to the foreman. You also did not have do this stealthy you could have ran up to him and forced him to tell you were the money is. You can also keep the money for yourself the game will not tell you that though.

[@EdenRiot2]

Cries at one of the most gut wrenching and (somehow) simultaneously heartwarming moments of the game, "I'm sorry." Don't be sorry, this is what we're all here for.

[@mrbaddog4749]

Hi Cam, Happy for another episode. You can spend some of your money getting more weapons ( and upgrades ) and more clothing and accessories, The best places are St. Denis gunsmith and tailor. Yes, at 36:25 you did see a weapon location on your mini map. You just had to go a little more north, you kept going south. Lol. You can also sell/donate wolf hearts, you can't craft/eat them. I can't remember if those weird trees have something to do with the Reed Cottage Treasure ( Reed's cottage, North of Annesburg, E of the N ). I know there is something to them. There is another stranger encounter, if your interested. It's south of Butcher's Creek, under the first train track bridge that crosses Kamassa River. Many people don't realize those nasty O'Driscol's had Sadie locked in a cellar for three days, You can imagine what they did to her for their enjoyment.

[@amaloel95]

"I'm afraid" damn that still got me

[@tonydeluna8095]

One of the best games I’ve played from Rockstar Games. And including the old school , Max Payne

[@the_omg3242]

I love the reaction that people have to the bear in the cabin. She even heard it but didn't connect what the sound might be. lol.

[@cUb3P1xL]

19:20 yeees you found THE cabin 😂

[@Mxsfit11Six]

"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act"

[@nervosuss]

I just knew a vid was gonna drop tonight, thank you Cam, always with the perfect timing 🤠🏇

[@dylanholman3]

1:51:30 the way you just calmly put down those guys with perfect headshots and turn away saying “bastards”, I feel like you and Arthur are the same person now 😂

[@SofaKingWashed]

I might be in the minority, but I'd be there for any "Legend of the East"-type streams where you do all (or some) of the challenges, hunt or whatever random exploratory stuff you wanna do.

[@Atarigen1]

Speaking of that view at the beginning I have never seen the game just show someone a rock carving like that

[@findlestick]

You can also do missions in the day if you like.

[@avader5]

@1:59:45 it always gives me chills to see Arthur’s spirit animal guide.

[@Schoggele]

The idea about streaming you explained at the end sounds good. I would really appreciate it to see all those things. And exactly as you pointed out nothing speaks against streaming those things on KZbin.

[@sanitallica]

The railroad camp where you found one of the foreman stealing money has 2 more 'missions' but they are small. If you help them, they might be able to finish the construction of the railroad. You could if you want to go back there and help them

[@belgarion4513]

No horse was harmed in that safe robbery ! So Proud !

[@secretweapon7764]

If you haven't been inside the abandoned mine before you might have missed the butcher's creek quests (I don't remember). That starts with one of those missions you need to be near to see. A guy along the river south of Butchers Creek by a large bridge.

[@helentunnicliffe7684]

I don’t remember her interacting with anyone from that stranger mission. Keep searching near where the trees are and butcher Creek for the NPC.

[@rip.van.winkle47]

1:40:00 if you have low honor you will not get that cutscene with sister calderon

[@ejmtv3]

Oh I missed watching you play Rdr2. AND FINALLY WE REACHED THIS SCENE! 1:36:26 😢 Sending virtuals hugs to you, Cam!

[@illstreamthat]

20:14 My favorite thing to watch people do for the first time. When I go by this place in a new playthrough, I throw dynamite in the window before entering.

[@Jack_2004]

I had TB in September it's awful i was coughing up blood & some rancid stuff I'm still coughing now from scarring on my lungs but the doctor said it could take months for it to heal I'm on steroids atm to help relive it but i can't even begin to imagine what it was like having TB in those days

[@wherestheaudio1]

We all been there, I’ve played this game 3x so I’ve been there for 3x😢

[@CapturedByKen]

The “I’m Afraid” heard around the world

[@princesilver1387]

1:39:50 you thought that encounter was unexpected? how many outlaws do you know get the chance to speak with a sister of faith before they pass away? not many.

[@Y0Da77]

Nothing wrong with crying when you get emotional while playing RDR2. I bet everyone who's played the game had the same feeling/reaction 😥😢😭 to it. 🤠

[@alexfarman4580]

The weird shaped tree i think is a reference to native americans bending trees in this way when they are growing to mark trails.

[@hakanmansson9951]

It’s the heartbreaking last part of the game😢but it still has some tension, turns and action left to give you. And I would love some extra content to see when you hunt or fish those trophies or finish side quests left behind cause we cannot be so many episodes from endgame now. You still have a night encounter in the swamp I think you haven’t encountered yet or the vampire in st Denis, but those is to search and like i said evening or night encounters.

[@Red-hw5ue]

This part had her going through it, red dead depression 2, we’ve been there cam it’s ok.

[@rabooey]

The bent trees are called Indian marker trees or trail trees. Native Americans cultivated sapling trees as a way of marking important locations like good hunting or gathering areas. There are many that still exist.

[@belgarion4513]

The poisoned mine is linked to quests given by people from near the people living near you camp, the village in the woods.

[@artmarquez4714]

Another great playthrough from the wonderful Cam! I believe that the trail trees are a nod to the Native American people who lived in the Appalachian Mountain range (Roanoke) area of the U.S. They had techniques for growing trees with those 90 degree bends in them to point people in the direction of life saving things, such as settlements and water.

[@rabooey]

Oh whoah I totally forgot about the Central Union Railroad Camp, Random Encounter(RE) string not being discovered yet. Nice. @Cambonano There are three such Random Encounter strings in the game and you've already finished the first two; the Castor's Ridge RE string(the father and two sons building a house near Valentine), and the Appleseed Timber Company RE string(the lumber camp that you could sell supplies to). Each RE string has multiple stages and the window of time for completing every stage of all three RE's is relatively short once you discover the first stage. I don't recall if you discovered every stage of those two RE strings, but you can try to fully complete this railroad camp one if you choose to try. I do not know the exact cut-off points for any of the RE strings, just know that the clock is now ticking for this one. If you'd like to someday watch a video of all three, complete Random Encounter strings I can give you its video title if you like.(I would not recommend watching it until you're done with your current playthrough of course)

[@helentunnicliffe7684]

I think that there are two more stranger missions that you can complete in this chapter. The first one is near the trail trees, where you will find a man near a bridge, not far from Butcher Creek. The second is in Lagras (if you have met the night folk) at night time.

[@veikov7766]

No horsies were harmed in the progress of this process. 🐴 I would love to watch your stream.

[@rabooey]

Don't forget, you can wear two Talisman's at a time. You might like some of the perks they give. They are kept in your Wardrobe and must be equipped. All of your Trinkets have passive effects that are always working for you though, because they're all kept in your Satchel.

[@lobid9585]

The cave you could nit get into is part of a stranger quest you will get….

[@1polyron1]

It's strange. Being an outlaw you'd think Arthur didn't fear death given his life could be compromised at any time. So it begs the question why is he afraid? Is it the cold reality that death is coming soon or is he contemplating his life and is filled with regret. Fear of unfulfillment? This game has so many emotional layers and life lessons. I never liked Westerns or cowboy anything. Bought Rdr2 out of the blue back in the day because it looked the best on the console and for the open world aspect. Boy was I surprised to find such a rich story and a character I will never forget

[@Adler.AntiCtzn]

phrases in the desk drawers are cheat codes that can be activated in the menu with the loss of achievements. 24:45 )) 1:09:53 this mine is available during the task received in Butchers Creek, if before that you met a strange exhausted man not far from there, who calls Butcher Creek and you can take him there and after a while there will be a continuation task. And the "guiding trees" also point to the Annensberg mine, which has a clue. If you just ride near from Annesberg to the hills, you will find a lonely house (green door) and a treasure map in it.

[@taikalai]

About the trail trees mine entrance, you should check out the railway bridge over the river west of Van Horn for a new side mission!

[@NyMyers64]

When you were riding up to that cabin I was thinking - is that the one with the bear in it and...yes it was 😄. The conversation with sister is one of my favorite scenes in the game. Enjoyed your latest episode as always.

[@SallyCat84]

I don’t know where it was but I did a lot of exploring when I played and went to the top of a really high mountain and found a Monk sitting at the edge of the top and he was just in a meditating position. I saw a video where someone pushed him off the cliff and the monk was screaming on the way down. Why do people do that?!

[@fashionfullife]

If you wait long enough around the gold hunters, they usually find gold that you can then rob from them

[@MrPerry61]

the bent trees are part of a side mission. Did you find an old man screaming in pain and talking about "the darkness" it's linked to that.

[@BTipp24]

If you have a legendary pelt or legendary carcass on your horse, its good to just go to the trapper right away to sell them. If you die, you will lose the carcass. You won't lose the pelt, though. The pelt will get transferred to the trapper, but you won't be able to make money from it. Dont forget to visit the Fence too. He can make you trinkets from the parts, giving Arthur some perks. I would love to see you play the og Red Dead Redemption in the future.

[@Kurkess]

That comment: "I'm afraid" just broke med when I played the game.

[@secretweapon7764]

Continuing to play through the night hours makes it difficult to see sometimes. It's ok to let Arthur sleep now and then.

[@einer0157]

Well done for picking up the Litchfield repeater, best repeater in the game

[@michelrogowski2950]

BAKED BEAAAAAANS !!! 🙀🙀

[@kratosexxen_0024]

Your playing style is amazing

[@godofwar2790]

Nothing brightens my day more than a NEW Cam video!! You da best 👍

[@simonrockstream]

Re-equip Arthurs holster and belt. It's glitched

[@Mazecraft]

An exporation/hunting stream would be cool! I'd watch it!