Aruran talked about Kira 【Holostars】【Eng Sub】

[@another-kun]

I wish we lived in the timeline with Kira/Kaoru/Suzaku 3D, original songs, nuis, etc… 🥺 But considering how tough Holostars has had it in the past I think it’s kind of a blessing we haven’t had any more graduations than that, I don’t wanna think about a timeline where holostars is only 8 people 😭

[@politiyuuto11]

"In another life" "In another timeline" "In another universe" "Only IF" This starting quotes is what I always think about in this situations

[@potechiz]

Even Miyabi considered to graduate in the past, but THANK GOD Izuru is there to stop him 😭🙏🏻

[@watataenjoyer]

Hope they are doing alright

[@aeris_aeris]

@@potechiz do you have the link where he said that

[@potechiz]

@@aeris_aeris sorry, I don't exactly remember which stream he said it... but I'll put the link here if I find any clip about it

[@mcosmos-h2w]

i mean just my 2cents but sometimes you gotta read between the lines and glean that arusan would rather not talk extensively about the graduated members and the details surrounding their exit, likely out of respect to said people. the current members have different levels of comfort with talking about this matter after all (i mean a few months back iirc temma did mention kira once and said kira is doing fine now so theres no need to worry). there are things that viewers ought not to be privy with and that’s ok

[@aoitsukishiro9926]

Astel and Aruran talking about Kira. Kinda unexpected since it's been 2 years since he graduate but I'm happy he's having a good life now based from what Aru san said

[@saifors]

Huh, I'd have expected things to have at least been explained to his genmates.

[@SoraRaida]

I mean, not everything has to be told to each other and that's fine. AruPapa probably don't wanna pry into other's private business anyway

[@Sieghiro]

Maybe Kira asked them not to? Just a wild guess. It has been some time, so maybe there was another management at the time. Once again, I'm just talking out of my ass, it just feels weird since Holostars members seem really close to each other.

[@peanutsbutter3295]

Once Astel and Izuru said on their apex stream, that Holostars members dont stepping on other member business, both of them agree that the good and bad things about Holostars. Seems like the members who know the reason about Kira graduation are Astel & Izuru since the three were so close.

[@samikrungoken]

Kira voice is still my favourite in holostars

[@mufty_11]

Before I saw this clip, yesterday I saw a clip of Astel playing Apex saying that he misses Kira a lot.

[@vgc_ivan8391]

the sudden talk about kira is a blessed after how long it's been, astel still misses him

[@salplayer9198]

I guess it because of his voice, doing that voice would put a huge strain on his throat, and doing it every time as Kira would be really tiring and harmful to his health

[@CaptainFracture]

Yup was going to say this. His voice wasnt natural albeit he does an insanely amazing job and maintaining it for how high pitched he gets. But yeah doing that voice all the time is TERRIBLE for your throat and vocal chords, it’s a shame really.

[@TheRealVordox]

If i recall correctly from the Cover announcement... It was related to his health (Not sure which, mental or physical) but due to one of them, he had to graduate and return home (His family I presume?) to recover. It was so long ago, if someone could find the announcement and do a proper TL you may have the most official source. Izuru and Astel did talk about him after his graduation and that Chibistars would never disappear and they would keep in touch still.

[@KalleBerendijk]

@@TheRealVordox The official announcement mentioned both physical and mental health. Though it also specifically mentioned his weak constitution so it's most likely his physical health was the main factor.

[@abbypal7283]

We REALLY want to see Kira's 3D as well😭it's sad to know they can't communicate anymore😢 or prob just coz he is not that close to Kira.

[@-Raylight]

Awww Kira, miss him :( I thought it's because of his health? Or it was Kaoru who graduated because of his health I wonder if they still hang out sometimes

[@Ivan_RA]

Kira was due to his health, Kaoru due to some drama

[@cicron10]

@@Ivan_RA Kaoru didn't graduate because of drama. Please don't spread false info around when you have no idea of what you're talking about.

[@Ivan_RA]

@@cicron10 1. Yes, I'm sorry I didnt mean to, I actually hate misinformation 2. I was there when that happened and Narukami in that time was a strong voice about vtubers, specially about Mel case, but now we know he wasn't a good person, so his infor about Kaoru was probably fake 3. Don't be condescending

[@cicron10]

@@Ivan_RA Wrong, Narukami wasn't trusted at all back in 2020. People already knew him as a drama youtuber who got his sources from the boards back then. If you know who he is, then there really isn't ANY reason for you to repeat what he's saying unless you like drama yourself.

[@SakurakoMikage]

i really miss the three of them kaoru suzuka and kira, at least i know what kaoru and suzuka are on other channels but to kira.... i don't know at all i just tried to research here and there but to be honest kira it's like being swallowed up by the earth

[@deecanno]

can you share on what channels kao and suzu are?

[@Lemonalisushi]

Can you tell me their other channel? 😢

[@SakurakoMikage]

I don't know if giving this information will cause problems or not, but it's been quite a while so it seems okay.... for suzuka you can search by keyword.... sentan among us , and for kaoru I forgot because of the channel it's written in Japanese. they are the same grub if you watch some videos of sentan you might be able to hear the voices of temma and shien there.

[@saifors]

Ah- ah achooUCX9hZ8xWYlhllPCJZki1nGQ Huh, that was a weird sneeze, maybe I should put on a beanie to keep me warm.

[@lancelot7380]

@@SakurakoMikage no the one that the channel written in Japanese is kira while for kaoru it's muutu gaming

[@andii4423]

pat pat Kira

[@ye3623]

Patto patto

[@Nikou_Editzz]

in someones past life and kiras past life im glad they still collab (wont say who) but when i watch them i think i wonder if this is what it wouldve been like if kira stayed

[@wiwuwiwuw]

Why do Holostars fans always hide new accounts from members who have graduated?

[@Nikou_Editzz]

@@wiwuwiwuw are u new? in jp vtubing usually PL is a Taboo, at this point its only a western thing somehow its fine now but it's supposed to be not disclosed all u gotta do is search it up urself rather than me saying it here with a bunch of people reading.. In most reddits and socials its also not allowed to be mentioned like. NOT just holostars. with that first statement i already know ur not a real fan

[@wiwuwiwuw]

@@Nikou_Editzz i see😌yes im new with jp vtubers, I have only been watching English VTubers all this time because of the language barrier

[@Nikou_Editzz]

@@wiwuwiwuw oh wait you are new? sorry lmao i thought u were doing a bait comment 😭😭 but no its mostly all vtubers especially on JP side

[@FreyjaWion]

after hearing Kira getting new outfit....his graduation news shocked me back then.

[@cicron10]

Thanks for the clip!

[@fauxvier8519]

Thats quite peculiar of him. Also leaves the impression that he is used to events like that 🤔

[@jinruich]

aruran is the oldest member in Holopro it makes sense that he is more mature at things like these and experienced more than most members

[@ZuFriX]

I really miss him ( ⚈̥̥̥̥̥́⌢⚈̥̥̥̥̥̀)♥️♥️

[@dylives7667]

How tf no one knows? It's been 3 God damn years of that already!

[@SakurakoMikage]

It's quite strange for me that aru San doesn't know where he is now... maybe they don't know each other well enough, but on the other hand, Rikka is very familiar with kira, I forgot which video. but rikka had said Kira is in pretty good condition now,

[@poli4734]

can someone tell me where is kira now like if he has afterlife

[@sekaishinryakusenda3753]

He has, he plays with suzaku and kaoru's afterlife too

[@poli4734]

is he still active? mind telling me the name

[@mlight03]

Sorry i can't tell much but Kira is friend with Roberu in real life, they sometimes play game together in group

[@hairanndo2002]

野郎は野郎に興味ないもんで