As the Donetsk Flows Armageddon, Resolution, or Irrelevance | Raisina Dialogue 2023

Raisina Dialogue 2023 | The war in Ukraine has transfixed the world. Countries have taken or are being urged to take sides, even when they have no direct stakes. And yet, no clear end can be seen or even imagined to the conflict. Even as Ukraine determines its nationhood and future, the prospects for Russia grow uncertain in the eyes of the world.
What are the consequences for Eurasia and the wider global system of an unremitting land war in Europe? Has the world responded adequately? What does Russia’s conduct of the war imply for its future as a great power and its relationship with other stakeholders?
Manish Tewari
Member of Parliament, India
Jane Holl Lute
Former Deputy Secretary, US Department of Homeland Security, USA
Vlada Galan
International Political Strategist, Actum, USA
Feodor Voitolovsky
Director, Primakov Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy Of Sciences, Russia
Eeva Eek-Pajuste
Director, Lennart Meri Conference, ICDS, Estonia
Moderator:
Ajay Bisaria
Former High Commissioner of India to Canada
About Raisina Dialogue:
The Raisina Dialogue is India’s premier conference on geopolitics and geoeconomics committed to addressing the most challenging issues facing the global community. Every year, leaders in politics, business, media, and civil society converge in New Delhi to discuss the state of the world and explore opportunities for cooperation on a wide range of contemporary matters. The Dialogue is structured as a multi-stakeholder, cross-sectoral discussion, involving heads of state, cabinet ministers, and local government officials, who are joined by thought leaders from the private sector, media, and academia.
The conference is hosted by the Observer Research Foundation in partnership with the Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. This effort is supported by a number of institutions, organisations and individuals, who are committed to the mission of the conference.
#RaisinaDialogue2023 #russiaukrainewarupdates #ukrainerussiaconflict
Raisina Dialogue 2023 Full Playlist Link: • Raisina Dialogue 2023 ...
Subscribe, follow and engage with us:
ORF KZbin: / orfdelhi
ORF Facebook: / orfonline​
ORF Twitter: / orfonline
ORF Instagram: / orfonline
Raisina Dialogue Twitter: / raisinadialogue
Raisina Dialogue Instagram: / raisinaofficial
Raisina Dialogue Facebook: / raisinadialogue

[@mr.d2124]

I dont see an INDIAN perspective in this discussion , Mr. Manish Tiwari is here but we all know about his history he is just another Brown Britisher and also we know that ORF is funded mainly by Western block so i didn't expect them to uphold the idea of #OpportunityForALL kind of thing

[@just_an_observer-k3r]

Maybe what Russia is doing is wrong, but we should also see that while Pakistan was doing the same thing to India these hypocrites (West) was silent.

[@divyasatheesh2529]

What is the reason for Russia to start this war ??? Why the NATO has to expand to east Europe near Russia?? Why Russia was denied to join NATO before?

[@LearnWithVikram7]

Are these experts? Disappointed they could not showcase Indian wisdom and talent. I am a layman and I can talk better about peace comes. That would come when military outcome will be clear and then instead of reaching inevitable just finalize that outcome peacefully. Russian dude was honest

[@SS-nu5xe]

Eeva Eek states Nato is more united and stronger then ever now. Yet a Nato country bombed another Nato countries pipeline, ending it's cheap energy supply that it's industrial base is so dependent on. This has nothing to do with being united

[@abdulwadoodabdallah1139]

😃

[@mairca80pais96]

The Russian guy calla a spade a spade

[@staceycolangelo8940]

12:00 I want to hear the rest of what Feodor was going to say before he was cut off. The guy was going off!

[@iheanyiekeke4941]

@united states being an honest broker 🤣🤣🤣

[@mini_agarwal]

Interesting discussion, imparts the rigid stance that each section of panel holds for. It seems more like a blame game, even for seeking peace.

[@knowwhouare]

Russia can just go home and war will be over. Ukraine has no where to go… Becoming slaves to ruzzians is not an option.

[@stephenyang2844]

I applaud this panel's rational approach, with representation from all sides. It stopped short in examining US's role in instigating a democratically elected government in the first place in 2014.

[@tada2508]

Why was Manish doing the barter for the west?

[@dhadumia]

Just like Manish Tiwari here. Congress can't be trusted with the nation! 😅

[@bijoydas449]

The US representative had lectured a lot about humanity and global order etc. Good. But what is their explanation about the Iraq war, Afgan war, Vietnam war and .. the list goes on. They should rather be silent if they have the minimum sense of shame. And about NATO .. what is their explanation about failed Minsk agreement?? The NATO representative was silent on it. In international politics, trust once lost can never be regained.

[@ansa336]

I could not agree with you more, here comment that Democrats and Republicans are united against China gives the game away. She should have been asked, why is the United States preparing to go to war with China.

[@MsThePrettiest]

Wow US lady managed not to answer the question. So many empty words. Others were way more straightforward.

[@naynay1139]

Her job to keep war going. The Ukraine lady with flag jacket spoke most sense. She had American accent. Looks like she had clear path

[@SS-nu5xe]

Interesting point Vlada states about what the US doesn't want. "the last thing the US wants is to see China be an international peace broker and rising to another level on the world stage"...... she admits the US doesn't want this, yet she thinks the US is a good peace broker. This is illogical.

[@goldenaye3]

Is Ukraine a puppet of America, this conflict is not what America wants, it's not Americans who are dying

[@botshelomoatshe3153]

I heard that and felt like okay, so usa's position as number 1 is more important than Ukranian lives

[@mairca80pais96]

Why get Manish Tiwari a congress mp. You should have brought a bjp mp

[@parthar101]

This way CONgress cannot say that they are not being allowed to speak

[@divyasatheesh2529]

Congress ideology is getting exposed more and more… so it’s not Rahul Gandhi alone, it is the whole congress party that has lost its relevance in India today

[@mairca80pais96]

This Portuguese guy is fed up after Minsk. Is the nut a bit dense. It was the west that had no intention to implement it. This entire discussion is a Russia bashing Fiesta.

[@deepanshusaxena7836]

Just like zylenski, Valda seems to be an actress.

[@amateurgamer2079]

Manish is infected with Rahul's intellect!

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Manish is in Tihar jail.

[@amateurgamer2079]

Did u mean massage parlour?

[@anthrax0pranav]

Jane Hall! Kudos to you for representing basic humanity

[@ihs51]

For Ukraine 🇺🇦 an honest broker can be USA 🇺🇸 😂 Germany 🇩🇪 😂 Britain 🇬🇧 😂😂😂 she is shell shocked 😳

[@SodiumSyndicate]

What is Manish Tiwari doing here?, he is not from the ruling party - he is useless to the event, maybe that is why he is here.

[@acerrome9672]

This discussion is more a Blame Game. It's surprising this is West gimmick to blame Russia Once again.

[@mridulaghosh]

Despite the stellar composition of the panel, it is utterly shameful not to have Ukrainians from Ukraine represent themselves. We talk about Ukraine without Ukraine: this is the core problem. The US representative said this, but it would have been better to mention that in this panel there is no Ukraine. Only the Estonian representative could say something sensible. The Baltic states, Ukraine and the Eastern Europeans know Russia best.

[@Shady689]

Great! Atleast India is having such discussions. Thanks ORF

[@saffron1977]

Manish bimari does not represent indian view point

[@ritvikdiv]

He doesn’t represent Indian views.

[@ullassharma86]

ORF is growing very well. I am very happy to witness this.

[@vishalkumar-nt9wd]

What is this? Rusiya baising drama with indian left

[@akshaysharma9727]

No its not russia bashing at all. And Manish tewari is a centrist. Vishal we need to realise that ,just because Europe is dishonest and hypocrite on China and Pakistan,,, does not mean we have to be like them.

[@vinayakshinde3950]

I'm BJP supporter I think it's better BJP leaders not enculded & I don't think anyone from BJP want to be here.

[@wonderworld7721]

@@akshaysharma9727 : "does not mean we have to be like them."... we r not gandhi bhakt !!... do not force Ur ideology/stupidity in India !!... change Ur attitude yourself or society will force U to do that !!!...

[@wonderworld7721]

@@vinayakshinde3950 : useless, unworthy, time wasting !!!...

[@mumitsami8442]

Their hypocrisy and this type of leadership took them here!

[@judelanoue9334]

Eastern Ukraine does not want to be a part of Ukraine therefore they should not be forced to be a part of it.

[@winstonbachan9661]

In Wars Fathers Bury Their Son and in peace sons bury their father 👈 Choose One 👈

[@mumitsami8442]

They were independent! But Couldn't because of world leaders like you!!

[@Manoj-bi3rd]

Manish tewari point of view seems good and to the point hitting, he is not taking any side view rather he is speaking to his thaught and mind. That's fantastic

[@mumitsami8442]

They provoked and not telling about the peace!

[@showkatkhan8209]

Unfortunately, this conflict will lead to nuclear Armageddon.

[@VeeraRaghavan]

Why are those not involved in the war funding & arming to teeth, Ukraine.. when NATO could've done the deed at a lower cost..

[@mumitsami8442]

You answered india's position last day sir!

[@mumitsami8442]

Translate this video for honourable putin sir!

[@mumitsami8442]

We don’t know them can they introduce themselves briefly?

[@saffron1977]

Victory to Russia , hell with Europe for breaking Minsk agreement, specially Angela Markel and Francois Hollande

[@hashimoto942]

Thanks 🙏 to Dr. Fedro. Russia is Russia 🇷🇺 will never gave up until achieving all its goals. Western collective think that Ukraine is a battleground for the western proxy. But they will never win 👍🏻🇷🇺

[@ihs51]

Estonia 🇪🇪 better be friendly with Russia 🇷🇺 after Ukraine 🇺🇦 thrown under the bus 🚌 by your Americans government

[@edwardmagoffin5095]

Estonia can tell Russia to go to hell.

[@dharmikrakshak8340]

This war among WASPI Christianism catholic Christianism and orthodox Christianism.let them send each other to heaven as they believe they are born sinner..sanatani should stay out of that.

[@ritvikdiv]

Manish Tewari: Military industrial complex is not responsible or leading! How interesting view point! Totally wrong.

[@PankajSachdeva]

Reasons for war: 0. Russia looking after Russians 1. Human Folly 2. Great Expectations 3. Profits from war 4. EU looking back in time but not forward 5. China luck playing out

[@mumitsami8442]

What did you get? Question is simple

[@mumitsami8442]

They used them they couldn’t realize yet that's why I said savage people

[@vikrantrathaur_]

For some reason the first speaker's accent and the way she spoke was very displeasing to the ears..

[@abhisheksharma_humblenrespect]

This Yuga

[@dhadumia]

Manish! 🤦

[@parthppopat]

Yeh Jane ke liye koi Tarzan ban ke nai ayga. Dollar sambhal nahi raha baday aye gyaan pelne. 😂

[@mumitsami8442]

They can't even take control in ukraine together!! 🤣🤣

[@jorgefructuosomartinez5391]

Russia will never loose,

[@nihaox]

there is no point of discussion for this if their is no indian narrative,the person so called representing india has no popular opinion neither policies who actually represents indian narrative

[@mumitsami8442]

Without keeping good relation with power like russia you hear country like so called "" who provoke nato and others to use against Russia 🤣🤣🤣

[@mairca80pais96]

Why was there no Chinese representative

[@vinayakshinde3950]

China didn't visit

[@arlrmr7607]

They should start with a minute of silence to honor the civilian casualty. And, the Russians should begin with a 2 minute explanation of their justification for the murders of Ukrainian civilians.

[@yashkumar3196]

Then wee would some words from usa also about afganistan Syria Vietnam

[@saptarsimondal7653]

This manish tiwari is a complete sham, correctly resembles the state of Congress Party 😂😅🤣

[@mumitsami8442]

What can you get from this then? You're representing which country? If not mistake it is Ukraine I heard

[@mumitsami8442]

Your this bodylanguage, you want to see their body language?

[@mumitsami8442]

India will attack you or russia what are you saying?

[@mumitsami8442]

You’re representative of US or Ukraine?? What did US and NATO did for you?? They only used you fool

[@mumitsami8442]

In footage we see russia in Ukraine! We saw US and NATO power what they are capable of!

[@mumitsami8442]

It is your perspective not for peace 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 my dear ukrainian representative 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@rhaegar2138]

Manish Tewari is brilliant. Great rare Indian politician.

[@siddheshdeshpande7183]

Yes, he is one of the few leaders in Congress I have respect for.