Atheism and Agnosticism Q & A - Hassanain Rajabali

[@MrHndsome]

elhamdulilah Hassanain Rajabali is a very knowledgeable man and he is using it to benefit us all.

[@AhmadAli-gy5wk]

Mashaallah Sir may Allah Almighty bless you with His special peace and blessings...اللهم عجل لولیک الفرج ع

[@jacquelinechahine5645]

Great lecture. And and top it all off, the advice he gave at the end was priceless. We should try to eat as much as possible organically grown fruits and vegetables and only Halal meats.

[@mrsghada123456]

Hussainain you are a hero, may Allah bless you and preserve you. Keep speaking out the truth you have really inspired me

[@pinkrain2]

Knowledge does not imply interference. This man speaks the truth. Wonderfully enlightening lecture.

[@GullJaan52]

Amazing lecture presenting very eloquently with priceless advices, honestly! People are in need of such knowledge and advices now a days..

[@akbarsyed3932]

Subhanallah what a personality...Allah bless him.

[@shi3i4lyf44]

As amazing as usual

[@TheMohammadr]

Masha Allah

[@xoxrandomgirlxoxlol]

some of the factual things he's mentioned were slightly wrong, e.g in regards to the discovery of the black hole ¬ however, I loved the ideas he's introduced. Lovely lecture. Keep at it brother!

[@Mikros0ft]

Very interesting. Thank you!

[@Karradaguy1]

At the 46:30 mark he challenges us to find an instance where a prophet commits a mistake against a person. Moses kills a person and asks for forgiveness in verses 15 and 16 of Surat al-Qasas.

[@Karradaguy1]

The Tabraiz You've just confirmed my point but seem unable to realise it.

[@2009mikeyo]

+Karradaguy He said where a prophet asks forgiveness from ANOTHER HUMAN BEING, That's his words at 46:45-50 Go hear it again. Quran 28 15-16 moses is asking god to forgive me not a human, And it say he unintentionally killed a person.

[@SIWJEE]

Thanks for uploading!!!

[@Karradaguy1]

Around the 11 minute mark, Rajabali appears to confuse black holes with dark matter. He claims to have studied these topics but cannot differentiate between what a black hole is and what dark matter is. He then speaks of "String theories" in the plural. The analogy in my opinion is quite poor. He attempts to conflate separate issues here. He speaks about electrons not being visible, that's true. But you can measure electrons, we know how small they are, we know how many there are in a given atom, we know their charge etc... This is observation from a scientific perspective, you cannot see the electron but you know it's there because you can measure it. This cannot be conflated with Jinns for example. They are a supernatural entity. If you want to say they're the same thing as electrons, then we cannot measure Jinns or make any useful predictions on their whereabouts or behaviour, and that is something that can be done with an electron.

[@mosemobuckland4287]

Well, the same goes for dark matter. Other than our knowledge of dark matter that it caused (and is still causing) our universe to expand, we know nothing about dark matter's essence.

[@Karradaguy1]

Moslemo Buckland Which is why it still isn't definitive. We can measure its effects however. Can you measure the effects of Jinn?

[@mosemobuckland4287]

Check out quranandquantumphysics.com And click on the topic ' Jinns '.

[@Karradaguy1]

Moslemo Buckland What a mess! They're trying to claim jinns have no mass. Jinns will need neurons to think and therefore mass. This is a website for complete idiots who just want to pretend jinns can be explained scientifically.

[@mosemobuckland4287]

Humans need neurons to think what makes you think Jinns also need these? Dark Matter (and a possible Dark World) could be totally different than 'normal' matter and 'normal world' if indeed there is such thing as a Dark World.

[@titamonk9770]

Hasanian Rajabali, Hamza Yusuf, Hamza Tsortzis, Nouman Ali Khan, mufty Menk are the best....

[@pure475]

amazing

[@yahyaal-andalusi6371]

Mash'Allah. Allah is above all!

[@m.faizansyed5609]

I agree to what Brother Hassanain is saying however I find a slight downfall within his rationalist arguments. Hassanain Rajabali tries to prove God using scientific data, probability, and causality. Now this is great but it's still problematic because it is still confined to the physical world and observations. I believe the perfect way to prove and experience the existence of God is through Metaphysical Truth. Metaphysical Truth refers to Reality, Truth, Being, and Consciousness. Each being synonymous of each other. The atheist are limited within physical limitations and the only way to break their limitation is to expose them to Metaphysical Truth. Imagine an atheist trying to argue against Reality! Only Metaphysics can lead us to Truth.

[@aaeeliiaa1917]

M. Faizan Syed whilst I do agree with you, it is bear impossible to talk to atheist about metaphyss and attempt proving God that way since they are sceptical about all that. What the speaker does is approach them from fields they have no doubt about, atheists who have an open heart to the truth will be led to it by the signs in the physical then can take on the beautiful path you mentioned

[@Moowy]

I believe the answer to that is that every single thing in it's nature worships God, therefore when he turns those people into those animals then they return to their nature because they no longer have the ability to disbelieve in God and would likely ask for God's forgiveness

[@nidarcoder8484]

my man has read too much pop-science.

[@MultiGreat1]

48:00 The oldest fossil of a human dates back 400,000 thousand years where as the oldest ape/primate fossil dates back to as much as 23 million years so this man was wrong from what I gather unless I have misunderstood him.

[@memeandrew3152]

Can i please, please, please ask someone to email me brother hassanian email i looked for it everywhere how ever could not find it, so please with all my respect to everyone if anyone has his email send it to me. mashallah god be with him in every step of the way.

[@xJaysrox]

Perfection does not imply divinity! Okay!

[@wedzistar1]

Who made God ?

[@matthewtawfiq1417]

He has always been there nobody brought him to life

[@wedzistar1]

Anime Boy And where is your proof ? is it something you believe because some book claims so? What are the signs that you look for to see if you are wrong?What evidence can you present to us ? Tell where he lives ?

[@EliSaeed2]

+wedzistar1 every created thing need a creator God is not a creature to be created

[@wedzistar1]

Muhannad Al Nadaf And how do you know this? Did you get this directly from god or you redefined god to protect him from scrutiny?How would you know if god is not created too? The books that you trust were written by men who are just like you. If you do not know they didn't either.They simply guessed and came up with clever ways to define their god. I could say the real god is Santa Claus and say Santa created the universe and I believe it by faith. I would say to you prove me wrong that Santa did not create the universe. Every culture has invented a story to try and explain where we came from. Check out Zimbabwe's own story about Mwetsi. www.bigmyth.com has a catalog of creation stories from all over the world. All of them are products of men's imagination.

[@a_gen]

It is Santa, you're right. I will not argue that at all. We call Santa, Allah or God, Dios, or yes old st nick. What ever helps you sleep. As long as we are not all here by accident, I can believe that at least because there's logic behind it.