Athhoi VS Omkara|কোনটা better Adaptation?

Made by Aritra Banerjee
Instagram:-thepunk26
#Athhoi #omkara #vishalbharadwaj #othello #williamshakespeare #anirban_bhattacharya #athoi #svf #sohinisarkar

[@sayansaha340]

Etar kono comparison hoye na. omkara is a masterpiece movie

[@tiyasbhattacharjee10]

😂😂Baler Masterpiece, Boring piece of Shit.

[@SPARSHAGIRI]

Bekar cinema

[@rnbasak1]

ভিশাল ভরদ্বাজ এর এডাপটেশনগুলো অনেক কমার্শিয়াল ওয়েতে করা। মকবুল, ওমকারা, হায়দার তিনটাই এমনভাবে স্টোরি সাজানো যেটা সহজেই আকর্ষণ করতে পারে। বাংলাতে এডাপ্ট করতে গেলেই সেগুলোকে আতেল মার্কা লাগে। আমি সহজ সরল সিনেমা দেখতে ভালোবাসি। আমার ব্যাক্তিগতভাবে "মন্দার" ও আঁতেল মার্কা লাগছিল। অনেক ব্রেক নিয়ে নিয়ে দেখেছি। অথৈ দেখারও ইন্টারেস্ট নেই তেমন। ইন্টালেকচুয়ালিটি দেখাতে স্ক্রিনপ্লে এমনভাবে সাজায় যে আমার বা সাধারণ অনেকের কাছেই আকর্ষণ হারায়। শেক্সপিয়ার এর গল্প বাংলার ব্যাকড্রপে সিম্পল ওয়েতে কঠিন বিষয়গুলো তুলে ধরলে মানুষ দেখার ইন্টারেস্ট পাবে

[@swapniladak2912]

Maqbool,Omkara,Haider jokhon prothom dekhechilam amar ektu slow legechilo kintu scene by scene ki hocchilo ami puro bujhte parchilam ar tachara kichu kichu charecter er style, natural swag oigulo dekhte moja lage ar tachara bhalo gaan,solid bgm to achei

[@rifatmeem5040]

Right, bangali ra etai bujhte chai na, ei art art kore atlami shuru kore diyeche, Vishal bhardwaj er movie dramatic holeo kokhono boring lage na......

[@subhankardas3064]

Ami ekta katha bolte chai, hoyto oneker kharap lagbe, oneke maante chaiben na, seta tader byektigoto byapar kintu amar mone hoy it's high time ebar amader shob Shakespearean adaptation ke Vishal Bharadwaj ere Shakespeare Trilogy taar sathe compare kora bondho kora proyojon. Vishal Bharadwaj byektigoto bhabe amar favourite Filmmaker kintu sobi je onar moto korei Shakespeare ke adapt korbe, sobi ke socio-political adaptation i korte hobe taar kono mane nei. Keu chaile Psychoanalytic adaptation kortei pare. Ami Omakara ebing Athhoi dutoi dekhar sutre bolte pari Athhoi Othello r onek beshi literal adaptation than Omkara aar ekhane human mind ere opor beshi focus kora hoyechhe than the village and the social life. Vinshura ta ekhane just ekta metaphor. Ei byapar gulo amader bojha uchit. Better adaptation bole kichhu ei khetre hoyna, sobi nijer moto kore adapt kore. Akira Kurosawa r adaptation of Macbeth aar Roman Polanski r adaptation of Macbeth ke ki amra ei bhabe dekhbo je konta better adaptation naki duto ke separately analyse korbo?

[@apurbokarmokar7752]

Ektu age darshan ke Niye Tmr kora video ta Dekhlam... Ekhn tmr ei video ta Dekhtesi.. tmr ei analysis video gulo Sottie Khub enjoy Kori.. ei Jonnoi tmr channel ta versatile Lage . Darun enjoy Kori.. onk Kisu Jante Pari bujte Pari.. Keep going like this Dada.. Love From Bangladesh 💓

[@nilayendrachakraborty4098]

Its a very good classical analysis, I saw Mandar, Omkara, Makbul, those r very good adaptation, unfortunately I couldn't see Athhoi but whatever explanations u have given, I feel those r very logical.

[@ayansen2452]

Adaptation hisebe omkara ekta milestone. Kintu ami othhoi hall e bose jothesto enjoy korechi! Amar oshadharon legeche. Ami dutoi grohon korechi.

[@rnilu86]

Denzel Washington obhinoy kora "The Tragedy of Macbeth" apnar kemon legeche? Cinemata kintu puro Natok er moto kora hoyeche. maane cinema style e kora hoyni.

[@subhradipmondal4630]

R duto jinis othoi te besi convincing legeche - 1. Omkara the indu tyagi omkarar bon chilo tahole nishchoi familyr precious jewellery ta chinto..seta churi korlo..trpr omkara r dolly er problem suru hole tader satheo kotha bollo onek but akbaro oi jewellery tar karone problem hote pare seta doubt holo na..even indu kno churi korlo setao clear chilo na..coz character ta khub e positive character chilo, sevabe churir motive dekhaini. Hote pare casualties er jonno jetar kalka dharona ache mela te nijer cheleke fele asa diye but well established noi sekhane othoi te mili character tar gogor proti weakness,bideshe jaoyar swapno, simplicity egulo diye churi ta justified hoi. 2. Gogo jevabe othoi k affair er proof gulo dei seta simplify holeo more convincing legeche. Omkara te process ta complex and coincidental onek khetrei jmn kesu er pocket theke mobile pore jaoya decoration er somoi, ‘Namak' song cholar somoi omkara billor komore goyna ta dekhte na paoya etc.

[@ZootAY45]

Ata akta web hoya uchit,but cinema ta jata dakhiya cha sata valo,Jodi sob kota aspects thik hoto toba masterpiece hoto.

[@nilabjabhattacharjee1816]

দারুণ analysis ❤❤❤❤

[@manishasarkar5008]

Ai video ta dekhe ami omkara abar dekhlam (choto belay dekhechilm vule gechi 😅)... akhonkar onk cinema theke onk onk better hoiche.. KZbin e free te available ache

[@sayandutta5368]

Amar mone hoy othellor shomoy jei major criticism ta chhilo, ar hoyto Shakespeare o shetikei mathay rekhe likhechhilen- ei class difference er upto bhitti kore jealousy, etai mul kaaron hishebe niyechhey. societyr preconceived notion thake, west er manush are intelligent, civilized, east er lokera barbaric, black magic jaane, uncivilized, ei stereotyped, racial difference taa kei as it is niye build korechhey; kichhu alter korchhena, korte chaichhena. Tai 'atthoi'-te chhotobelay dekhachhey atthoi asha theke gogor ekta hingsha, as if ekta gota powerful community ekta powerless communityr upgradation taa ke chhoto chokhe dekhchhey, sheta mene nite parchhena. Shekhan theke shey taader existence nullify korte uthe pore legechhey. Shamogrik text tar mul stombhotai holo ei stereotype er upor. Ekhane neither the author, nor people associated with adaptations are inclined towards making any changes for the betterment, that is, audience jeta aashole chay, dusher domon, bhalor ogrogoti.

[@shresthadas4723]

Amar stylized way ta bhalo legeche sotti bolte camera, lighting usage gulo bhalo legeche kintu Athoi r Diyar bhalobasar proti kono emotional depth toiri e holo na sesh porjonto, Diyar kosto ta feel korte parini sesh porjonto Gogo kharap joghonno sick janar poreo kothao jeno bhalo lagchilo j o jitey jacche.. That's the problem when you present your antagonist as protagonist.. Tar upor Anirban er character ta ar obhinoy sobaike overshadowed kore diyeche jeta as a fangirl dekhte bhalo laglo botey kintu golpo onujai justified na..

[@arnabbanerjee4900]

অথৈ অনবদ্য লেগেছে। অনির্বাণের অভিনয় আন্তর্জাতিক মানের

[@aniket3811]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@suvranildas2677]

Atthoi amr bhalo legeche,but omkara no doubt best. Ar omkara commercial film hyeo unsuccessfull in box office,pore cult status peyeche. Ar haa,atthoi ektu commercial kora jete parto.

[@sharmileebasu4307]

Anirban Bhattacharjee is far better director than Arno

[@mahimabag4654]

Anirban er supermacy dakhare giye onake enlarged korte giye, baki prem, onno character sob blurred hoye geche ojantei

[@pankajmandal_2648]

Always waiting for your analytical videos . Fan of your work 😊

[@debdeephalder9757]

Anyday omkara

[@arnabdey7832]

Amaro khub ekta valo laglo na 😢 kichui believe korte parlam na

[@BruceWayne-hb7sc]

Athhoi Amar Kintu Bhalo Legeche Tbh

[@dipannitabhattacharya262]

Amar o…mukul er bepr ta weird legechilo Rest movie was extremely interesting

[@nijhumzannat5525]

কীভাবে সম্ভব ২টাকে এক কাতারে ফেলে তুলনা করা? এতবড় ভিডিও করে ভরদ্বাজের সাথে তুলনা? কোন দৃষ্টিকোণ থেকে? কপি ডায়লগ আছে তাই?

[@sagar29609]

Bharadwaj er moto real filmmaker ar Anirban-Arna r moto bhekdhari jaali amateur antel der kono comparison somvob ki?

[@debrajbanerjee7581]

Maharaja review please🙏🏻

[@aniruddhachowdhury9478]

Darun kotha outright korben na galagali korben na khisti korben na

[@mohojitchakraborty1323]

Athhoi bhinno bhabe toiri kora... Omkara onno bhabe .. versus kothatai ashena ..

[@SusovanP]

চাঁদ ও পাদ এর তুলনা নিয়ে একটি আধ ঘন্টা ধরে রচনা লিখ।

[@Thekudghat]

Acha apnader moto reviewer ra ato easily flaws identify korte pare kintu arno-anirban ar moto por khawa actor,director..ai bhul kore kore falle...sotti obak lage😂

[@arpanacharya4495]

Eta kono kotha holo? Tahole to kono vlo director konodin kono kharap cinema banabei na tahole... Coppola Spielberg o kharap movie korechhe...

[@krishnendughosh619]

Jokhon Ranna ta complete hoye tokhon kheye bola jaye taste kmon . Kintu je ranna korche tar mathaye hazaar ekta chinta thake ; Noon kom holo na toh, jhal beshi hoye gelo na toh, etc etc. Tai duto khub ee different ekta jinish

[@farhanisrak2229]

নিজের পাঁদে কেউ গন্ধ পাই না, বাকিরা পাই। আশা করি বুঝবেন এবার