Within Temptation What Have You Done live at Pinkpop 2007

[@crossfire527]

I live in the US, and just now heard these guys, and I have to say that Within Temptation is probably the best band I have heard in a LONG time! They will not leave my CD player in my car. I would love to see them live!

[@UdoShan]

I bought this CD the moment after I heard the first two tracks. I'm a fan for LIFE!

[@Warlogue]

I just love her voice...

[@MoonOfSorrow]

Ive been waiting for someone like you, but now you are slipping away... ohhh I love the lyrics

[@yu5bloom]

wonderful.. i just love this song

[@N3Ti]

its not an insult , both bands are great i would never insult amy ... she is one of my favorite female singers =]

[@Duck0426]

i love this band

[@amanduhedmo]

my opinion is that i love them both.

[@michellec061192]

evanescence started 1995 within temptation started 1996 lacuna coil started 1994 nightwish started 1996

[@sorshaporsha]

Brilliant Song my fav

[@EternalLies]

That was truly amazing. They are mindblowingly awesome live. I just can't understand why people keep comparing Within Temptation to Evanescence and Sharon to Amy? Within Temptation and Sharon blows Evanescence and Amy out of the water. Evanescence are utterly pathetic live. Long live Within Temptation. \m/

[@xwithintemptationx]

i saw an interview with WT and sharon said "of course you always have something in common with other bands, but you must always do your own thing. something which makes you unique. if you look in the same genre like lacuna coil, Nightwish, Evanescence, the four of us are so different."

[@liveforlife2494]

Yeah. She was awesome at the Tokyo concert though, just amazing.

[@HHHvsHBK]

that is music , Yeah baby !

[@daSONNE1]

AWESOME! =D GREAT song! =]

[@dani_linna]

What you have done to us - is GREAT to us

[@calebepar26]

amazing

[@tunojarro]

ustedes son geniales congratulations

[@apitmickey]

this one is longer than the original... and i like it

[@pantertjee]

holland!!:D going to WT 24-11-07 in Eindhoven :D see you there sharon ur the best

[@freakofevolution]

sucks that Keith Caputo isn't actually there, but she sounds great. Reminds me of Amy Lee.

[@vampiress222]

I love this band. They rock live. But I have to dissagree with the ones who say it is hard to find artists who sound good live. Most of the people I listen to are wonderful live. A very few aren't good live.

[@dukiofree]

they sang this in my club......... totaly AAAAAAAAAaaa

[@Apokalypes]

Holy shit that is amazing live :O

[@bodgely]

they were great at twickenham, they were a really good support act for maiden

[@IsabelOEM]

LUCKY!!!

[@lillyhoefer]

ich schon!! war schonmal live dabei - in SAN FRANCISCO

[@GroundTravel]

She sounds fairly good in this video. A little flat on a few notes, which in the studio they fix because she can probably sing it again or fix it digitally. Still love the music, though.

[@ichigosan777]

she's dutch.n amazing voice!

[@laminack]

i wonder how many languages she has to know to tour in as many countries as she does awesome band

[@liveforlife2494]

Guys, if you're going to thumb her down, BleedingAmy LIKES Evanescence (look at her profile) and she's just giving her opinion that sometimes Amy Lee isn't that great live. So stop doing it.

[@MeenaOh29]

The guy's voice is recorded because he isn't part of the original band so of course they have to put his part in and then dim him out so Sharon can be heard live

[@crazybizarrka]

just amazeing,cool,sexy,hot,gr8,beautiful,the best...

[@liveforlife2494]

WHAT IS THE DEAL?? STOP COMPARING EVANESCENCE AND WITHIN TEMPTATION! I am so sick and tired of it. They are both great live and recorded, they both create awesome albums and they have amazing voices. So just stop arguing!

[@ElinevanderLaan]

With the dauwpop festival I was in a wheelchair. But: Keith Caputo was there too with WHYD! How lucky xD ghehehe.

[@DTL0201]

How come the live version is different to the actual version?

[@DraculasNephew]

This is like my theme song.

[@mhelvaROCKZ]

have you check their other live performances?? you should try to check it before making some silly comments..

[@afanofmeanythings]

I am a bigger Evanescence fan then WT. But youve gotta understand, WT was FIRST. WT had released two studio albums, and two EPs before Evanescence even came about. But I do prefer Evanescence. I'm not dissing eather of the bands, there both AMAZING

[@michellec061192]

evanescence first started in 1995 and WT started in 1996.

[@Songofwyrd]

Except for the fact that Within Temptation's first album saw commercial release 3 years before Evanescence's.

[@MyLoveAnime]

ik wou dat ik er bij was :P

[@StraightJacket65]

i would compare within temptation with lacuna coil there both amazing

[@Rock-Metal91]

They are nothing alike

[@f426b]

It is her corset, and Emilie Autumn does not wear real corsets when she performs. It's easy to tell by watching her move, she has far too much mobility. She has a false corset with plastic bones and seams sewn along the bones to make it appear more realistic. However, it's not a real corset. There's no way to "lace a corset right" to make it easier to sing. Only another wearer can understand that.

[@L0velyCharMing]

you're right, but the video is smashing =) Put it's live weird cause he's singing on tape =( a bit weird

[@pqdmoovies]

F**k sind die live gut! Echt ey so gut hätte cih etzt nich gedach!

[@Sarastrah]

Would you mind if I hurt you..? Would you mind if I killed you..? Nope, not at all;-D Love this song!

[@tiffany02020]

why does the guy shes doing this duet with (supposed to be) never with her? this is the 2nd vid of this song live ive watched and in both hes "singing" with her on..... a screen.... whats up with that? i LOVE WT, but isn't he kinda blowing her off?? jeez...

[@N3Ti]

lol , go listen to eavenescence live xD and compare them with within temptation =]

[@commirevo89]

I wanna see her and Amy Lee from Evanescence collaborate on something.

[@Negnuks]

ye true :P

[@crimsonphoenix35]

They're not shit! >.< lol I think they're both fantastic. But, after watching this and Evanescence's "Weight of the World," Amy Lee's opera solo was a tad stronger. Putting aside that minor difference, both performances were great!

[@BrokenWing233]

is that Dutch or German that she speaks before the song though?

[@loseurillusion15]

this is what i think evanescence should do with bring me to life, cos their new guitarist cant sing lol great song, only got into them last weekend lol! sharon is a goddess, even more so than amy lee

[@mitsuki091]

Desafina demasiado; si que es dificil cantar tan agudo en directo, pero si sabe que luego va a desafinar..que transporte las melodias un tono mas bajo, porque sino sale desastroso. De todas fromas buenas cantante y GENIALES canciones. (evanescence tiene mucha mas afinacion en directo que within) CONGRATULATIONS two bands

[@GroundTravel]

Actually, I can...lol. You don't go flat because you are tired. When your voice starts to get worn out it gets softer, or more harsh sounding like you need to drink a gallon of water. It's ok though. I understand that most singers these days can't really sing that great without studio help. No offense meant to you, Lozza.

[@pantertjee]

because english sounds better than her own language (to sing than..:)) Im fromt he same country:D my teacher knows the guitar dude:)

[@wickedcat29]

What is with Pinkpop? Everytime I hear a band or singers there, they don't seem to be as great as they usually are. They sound off or breathey, or not as strong as they normally are. Maybe Pinkpop as bad audio or something?

[@starsaunt]

were is the guy? this song is so recorded -.-

[@kalika2011]

If the corset is laced right she should be able to sing fine. Also, Amy is terrible with performances because you can hardly understand her. I think that during this part she's just a bit tired. Unless this is one of her first songs..... But I don't believe it's because of her corset. Look up live performances of Emilie Autumn and you can see she doesn't have any problems with singing while having her corset laced tightly.

[@LawyerOSRS]

All hail rubber boots!

[@steven6488]

hahha gewd song

[@vladimirstar]

It seems they haven't had Keith for many of their gigs...shame reallY...

[@liveforlife2494]

Yeah. I just about had it too, it's just so annoying! If you know who Enya is (She sung "Orinoco Flow/Sail Away"), everybody has to compare Enya and Celtic Woman. The deal?

[@angelofdarkness49]

Stop going on about amy lee.. does this look like an evanescence video? Stop comparing bands please, and just enjoy the music.

[@Abekatteprut]

aww she sings false quite a bit :(

[@f426b]

Simple. She's singing while laced in. She should know better than to perform in a corset. I'm a wearer too as well as a singer, it causes problems and doesn't allow for proper breathing while singing. She should know to wear a fake corset or not to lace so tightly.

[@xwithintemptationx]

oh fuck here we go again? why can't you people make peace and appreciate music? WT and EV are completely different bands. i personally like WT better but Ev is awesome too, but you can't say EV is the original band cause WT came about three years before? I think. and if you have nothing nice to say don't say it all, you can be civilized.

[@metalhearrt]

in fact ... the 2 voices of Amy and Sharon are too dif. and they are overtalented in their style, but the two bands are completly dif. the music of WT is more easy to play in every instrument than plan one of evanescence(is not a large diference of dificult but Terry Balsamo and Amy makes the music a little more hard) one of the bands are too commercial and the other more underground the 2 are exelent, is only a trouble of likes and dislikes

[@kerenn]

shes really great in live. but she dont know how to move..

[@keeponplaying]

God..there sure are alot of petty people in the world. Evanescence and Within Temptation are both fantastic..why does it always have to be a hateful 5 yr old "This is better" Battle. And for the record, WT new album sounds alot more like Evanescence than their previous work. "Amy lee is untalented"! Hahahhaahha!! Do YOU even believe that?!

[@GroundTravel]

Lol. Try to follow your own advice.

[@keeponplaying]

I will also add that Evanescence are pretty terrible live, Amy lee always seems to be to gruff, like she's trying to put on a man's voice to sing, and it completley ruins it, Sharon is waaay better live. That I will say.