Nissan Navara vs Isuzu D-MAX vs Ford Ranger vs Toyota Hilux - Pickup Truck Comparo

Pickup trucks are being launched left and right. Manufacturers are bringing in their best and brightest models for 2021. With all the options out there, we've decided to make a new comparo, this time with the likes of the Toyota Hilux, Nissan Navara, Ford Ranger, and Isuzu D-MAX. All of these models are new for 2021, and they're all hot off the presses in terms of features, looks, and performance. Join Caco as he lets you know which one is the best option currently.
Visit our website at www.autodeal.com.ph​​​
Also check our video page here: bit.ly/2Oe8qT4​​​
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:29 Brief History of the Competitors
1:36 Scoring/Categories
2:11 Power & Fuel Efficiency
3:45 Tech, Safety, & Interior
6:02 Ride Comfort
7:56 Payload & Capacity
9:24 Price
11:10 Best Overall Looks
11:41 Outro
Facebook: / autodealph​​​
Twitter: / autodealph​​​
Instagram: / autodealph​​​
LinkedIn: / auto​​​. .
Don't forget to subscribe for more AutoDeal videos.
Music
Retro & Synthwave (Music For Videos) Odyssey by John Tasoulas
Carbon Citizens - Mobara (Copyright Free Music)
Cinematic Epic Trailer Music by Infraction [No Copyright Music] Atlas

[@jancasanova5863]

6:37 when Caco is having a second look on that WRX ❤️

[@diethersantos6404]

Hahahaha!!! I noticed that part he was like: "Oh it's the WRX"

[@utkarshschauhan1713]

Me everytime i see a beauty on the road. 😂

[@axltroyortega4467]

Haha

[@ejbals9951]

It was a brilliant Comparo, you let us decide the voting for the subjective looks 👏👏👏

[@adamsabri5363]

the way you compare it is almost the same when i tried to find a truck in 2018 and had the same verdict. me and my bro bought the navaras and going great so far without problems. they are underdogs that don't get much in attention or reputation compared to the others but they are strong, comfy, reliable and economical daily trucks.

[@nahumcheer6685]

No regrets on our navarra. It's been super awesome so far. My only comment about it is that it takes time to get used to driving it because it's too big..

[@jojomarcelo781]

The high hood maybe

[@realtalker101]

musta navara mo boss?

[@jakevancleave7]

​​@@realtalker101 yeah, same question... after 2 years

[@ladyannepagaduan]

I would also go with Navara. Having a pick-up truck probably driving it for many years of your life-you got to have the comfort it provides.

[@brianbarcoma7938]

Great review as always Caco! Very thorough and informative!

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

after watching this I went straight ahead and bought the Navara 2021. I love it! Rides like an SUV, and looks like an american pick-up truck! And I love the around view camera (360). Definitely a life changer. haha

[@LunaThalia1319]

I just bought ford ranger raptor which was not in the choices haha

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

@@LunaThalia1319 ibang price range na kasi yan kaya di sinama

[@sallydelacruz884]

Congrats sir.. Enjoy & stay safe 😊 Navara & Terra owner here 😊

[@chucky882]

Nice Engr! Enjoy your new ride, I learned remapping the new Navarra will increase its power by another 50 hp. Maybe you want to check it out...

[@perezroderic]

@@LunaThalia1319 congrats

[@sayconamiel]

I couldn't agree more with this review... so on point... kudos to Caco and co.

[@theartninja14]

the graphics are impeccable!!! kudos to the gfx team!!!!

[@tongferlion]

the new 2021 navaras are basically an improved versions of the D23s debuting from 2015. my family have 2 of them since 2017 and have no problems with them so far. reliable, comfy, practical and cash saving workhorses. glad they are part of our family.

[@Emansky84]

aaaaah been waiting for this comparo! awesome as always

[@davesoninigo872]

Thanks Caco.. i bought 2022 Navara coz of this reviews.. d ako ngkamali .. so happy 🤗🤗

[@oversteer_9339]

Its more common to see isuzu and toyota to be workhorses and so people dont usually sell them after a few years. Im not saying the other 2 arent workhorses. Im just saying the isuzu and toyota are the go to ones. The ranger and navara are more of a lifestyle choice. If you want a pick up as a daily driver, Nissan is the best drivers pick up. The driving position and power delivery is more desirable than the rest. Ford has everything electronically assisted. So its for drivers who want an effortless drive. Toyota and isuzu are no brainers for hardwork and lifestyle. If you are a diehard carguy, i recommend the nissan. As for reliability, they are all very reliable. But, there have been a few reports of ford transmissions going wrong. But only very few. As for the rest, they all do well. It also comes down to who uses these things. Are they careful? Do they maintain the thing? If you don't know how to take of a car, any of these brands that you buy will always have problems

[@DL.j]

Agree, i have both dmax and hilux as it is needed for my work and have to say you can never go wrong with this two.

[@oversteer_9339]

@@DL.j Thats good to know po!

[@sherwintoncomique4384]

I had a ford ranger xlt 2013,A/T, casa maintained since day one, 115,000 km mileage. Rarely having a heavy load. My transmission problems suddenly just occurred rendering it non-driveable, casa recommended a repair worth 70k pesos. Sold it right away for 470k , then used the amount for a brand new Dmax.

[@oversteer_9339]

Damn. Its good to know that it lasted that long though.

[@jasona9354]

@@sherwintoncomique4384 Reminds me of my 2013 Escape in 2019. Also transmission issue and since it was already phased out, it took me 3 months to find the parts for 50k+. Sold it after fixing and got a Navara EL as my daily drive. Now I sold my EL to my brother and got the Navara Pro 4x last month because I want a 4x4 vehicle.

[@likerussel]

I considered DMax as my next pick-up but after comparing all the specs plus this video, I changed my mind. The Navara's ride and looks made my choice. 👍

[@nurseelmarninja8197]

Got mine and it was a great choice!

[@akopocmichael]

got the nissan too :)

[@vanhelsing3225]

this is bias comparison...

[@gutadin5]

@@vanhelsing3225 why?

[@hunterdouglas6210]

the spare parts though is way more expensive in Phil.. 😂

[@ichewwie]

i like this format of comparing... do more of these... please

[@dwengkikay]

Thank you for the knowledgeable informations, sir! Big help. Good job and more power!

[@Tatay-Mong-Kalbo]

Nice review, as always. It was as objective as it could get. I don't rely on badges, I base my purchase on many factors and then decide according to what I need the most out of my car. I am a Navara owner, my second choice would have been the Isuzu D-MAX. To each his own, my main reason why I bought a Navara is the ride comfort whilst still being able to carry load if need be.

[@gerryrementilla5178]

im a dmax user (2nd gen)... and i agree with u....this time i pick Navarra... Nissan did a great job!

[@paulnav]

Great comparo. Thanks!!

[@FerryMalsadaFMAZINGTV]

ibang level na ng Comparo to sir Caco!! mas preferred po namin ganto pagdating sa scoring pati sure malakas boses mo pag nasa desk mo langs. hehe! A huge fan here. Godbless to this channel

[@haroldfpv3667]

Awesome comparison video. Nailed it!

[@TheSkooterbords]

Love the behind the desk format of the comparo. We gotta do what we gotta do.

[@SuperMario-iy8cx]

6:38 I saw it too Caco😂

[@elbertjanrecto5658]

Kuddos sa video editor! Ganda pati color combinations! 🎉

[@jmdomingo2114]

Caco you are the man! Thank you for immediately doing the comparo!

[@Rusty_Raine]

I really like your review. You conducted it in a very impartial manner. Most videos that I have seen input a lot of confirmation bias. Personally I feel that in the US there is a lot of confirmation bias when it comes to Ford. I have seen many years that Ford has been given the title as #1 truck when it really shouldn't have been.

[@gutadin5]

How about the Dmax 4x2 LS and Navara VE 4x2?

[@a.c.cabatan8728]

This is what we've been waiting for! Ute for days!!! Greetings from down under Mate! 🇦🇺🇵🇭 Love your work Guys!

[@mr.boondox9970]

Thank you guys. Well reviewed.

[@gatotsubandrio87]

I believe your comparison is fair. At least for neutrals. Neutral could means relatively debatable anyway. Love it.

[@UrsaWarrior95]

Dmax all the way! This generation has partnered with Mazda for their BT50. Shared tech and Mazda like quality just stomps the rest of the competition.

[@melvinperez4786]

D’max Lover here! ❤️ Someday! 🙌🏻

[@janreu22]

I have doubts with the navara but unexpectedly made the number 1 spot. Thank you for this “COMPARO”

[@markangelo01]

I like the new comparo feature with visuals and other visual collaterals

[@miguelangelojf]

I wonder how the subjective looks rating would change if it was the Ford Ranger Raptor variant used instead? It won’t win the value category but men I’m sure it would definitely be a real toss up for top prize.

[@unknownd7409]

They're all good in their own way. The D-Max for its newfound interior refinement, tech, and reliability, the Ranger for its most powerful engine and car-like handling and interior, the Navara for its ride quality and comfort, and the Hilux for its effortless performance, off-road ability, and reliability. Choose what you need/want, but you can't get it all. Personally, I'd go for the D-Max closely followed by the Wildtrak.

[@yengsabio5315]

We just got the Hilux about a month back; mostly for use in the farm, and some long-distance hauling. So far, it's doing well.

[@petergriffin4588]

maganda din bagong mazda bt-50. exactly the same sa isuzu d-max underneath, pero may free 5 year maintenance plan. depende nalang din kung maayos pricing & specification ni mazda ph

[@roamaroundgisg7362]

Agree hehehe

[@bogartjudakan6547]

isuzu for engine, my 4ja1 and 4bd1 are 20 yrs and still running hahaha

[@aviationaerospacechannel5987]

Is Ford reliable nowadays ? Because in the past, Ford wasn't reliable at all. Always full of problems. So I'm wondering if they improved nowadays ?

[@kyellandreilabay8396]

Nice review sir caco!

[@weldottv6973]

What a world class comparison...👍

[@bellacreed]

hope you could include soon 1) maintenance cost 2) common replaceable parts costs & availability

[@serdayapan3562]

Navara for the win!♥

[@gutadin5]

why Navara? can you tell us

[@serdayapan3562]

@@gutadin5 watch the video and see for youself. you'll know why.

[@Kyxmyx]

@@serdayapan3562 liit ng likod jusq

[@jakerio8]

Good thing Autodeal didn't wait for the incoming all new Ranger for this comparo to keep it interesting at least. 😁

[@cjbongalon2064]

we just bought a caliber x yesterday, were happy that we pick the right one :)

[@sayconamiel]

Have tried all these pickup trucks and yes, the Nissan Navarra has been a prime contender for durability and all-out performance. Still, it's really up to the consumers on what they prefer and what they need...

[@marinonginhinyero1590]

Durable ah? Tignan natin after 10 years

[@gole2188]

@@marinonginhinyero1590 kwento mo sa 20yr old Nissan Frontier namin na buhay parin

[@suzukimotv1340]

@@marinonginhinyero1590 2015 debut ng navara d23. kulang kapa sa research 8 yrs na sya marine engineer kapa man din HAHAHA

[@ApArt1003]

@@marinonginhinyero1590 Yung nissan pickup 90s model na gamit ng munisipyo namin sa contruction buhay parin kinain na ng kalawang ang body, wala ng windshield at ibang parts parang galing sa gyera or zombie apocalypse mo tignan pero tumatakbo parin hakot ng mga workers, materials at towing concrete mixer. Dpwh din sa province namin may mga same same unit sila na tumatakbo parin. Unreliable nga gaya ng sabi mo.

[@lovellagabisan]

@marinong inhinyero after 8 yrs? baka gusto mo sendan kita ng video o photos ng nissan frontier naming model 1999? hahahaha

[@annihi_lator9457]

Best video, superb presentation, what i like about Autodeal is their reviews are high class not like other car reviews that is uploaded to be monetized. Always a good a job.

[@Eggsplorer0421]

Well done Caco, I was also looking forward with the comparo including Strada Athlete.

[@crizvlogztv]

been waiting for this men oryt

[@jarrodtabuada7203]

BEST CAR YTUBER EVER! HONEST REVIEW AND FLAWLESS VIDEO!

[@kevinelove4711]

At the end of the day, it comes to affordability as the main deciding factor. Total income per year as to cost of vehicle+maintenance cost ratio. Good luck buyers🤞

[@marlonramosexpeditions]

Looking to purchase a pick-up truck in the PI...this vid was MUCH help! Thanks!

[@JegsTV]

Great video!!!

[@bignay113]

Thank you for helping me decide on what to buy. Now I know I'm sure I hope I'll get a good deal.

[@monas]

Which one are you buying?

[@gutadin5]

which pick up?

[@iluvanielle]

You also need to take into account parts availability and reliability as well as after-sales support. Time will tell for the first two and swertehan sa dealer sa number 3. Sayang absent yung ibang brands. Request po, comparo between all top spec models na automatic, then another one for highest spec manual models din. Thanks!

[@jessiedelantar4710]

Toys for the big boys Ang hirap mamili . Thanks autodeal Stay safe stay cool caco.

[@thegrimreaper6926]

Ano po na pili niyo?

[@emj1311]

It's here. Can you do also a SUV and van comparo😁

[@BOBOKA55]

I thought Navara would fail my expectations with this review against other Ute's but I was wrong.. You can never go wrong with Navara.. Since we usually carry light to heavy type of payloads, we preferred to choose Navara, to meet our expectation into a pick up truck that can carry light to heavy loads that we wanted to without compromising its riding comfortability which Navara never failed us to do so. "May karga man o wala, hindi matagtag" Smooth manakbo..360• Cam is also a plus.

[@cyborg5407]

Does Ford ranger last more than 10 yrs? Is it impossible to find parts after 5yrs? Planning to get a pickup which can be maintained for at least 10 yrs

[@bogartjudakan6547]

i would go for isuzu due to engine durability, and price of parts, navarra would only last for 5 years and the difficulty in conversion of parts incase of no production

[@kylepagador2786]

@@bogartjudakan6547 we have a 2015 np500 navara, properly maintained, used for farm hauling and business purposes. no problem in parts availability and to our surprise, it is much more expensive than parts for our 2016 montero

[@ervasvap6265]

@@cyborg5407 it can last for 10 years if you maintained it properly ford ranger is reliable but not reliable than those 3 trucks, ford ranger can be better for offroading and hauling

[@aviationaerospacechannel5987]

​@@ervasvap6265 Ford is more famous for reliability problems.

[@lebronisthegoat3064]

Probably would be the most viewed episode sir caco! Navara all the way!🤟🏼

[@ernestosalunatd4th298]

Ayos! thank you thank you

[@CapitanFALCON809]

This is actually a great comparison

[@kiyazaki4975]

They forgot to mention the additional safeguard tax in the price category. The Navara includes the tax in its SRP, while the others don’t. That’s PHP 123,200 to their respective prices.

[@general8vergel]

Oo nga mas nakatipid pa ako sa navara

[@aviationaerospacechannel5987]

The Navarra is still the best value pick-up. Simply here they took the Pro4X, which is only a Navarra VL 4x4 AT, with a different body kit. It costs only 1,701,000 pesos, so this is still the cheapest.

[@martsmarts]

Majority of Filipino consumers are stereotypes.. so they'll still choose the Toyota Hilux regardless of the scores.

[@pouriajaderi3858]

Couldn’t agree more, I think the fact that it’s one of the cheapest (starting at P843,000) has a big play in it. Hate to admit it but most of us pinoys are cheap. Sure the D-Max is close as well BUT “isuzu yan eh” that’s what I hear mostly.

[@roamaroundgisg7362]

Agree hahaha

[@jessaalquizar8392]

still hilux dominate the roads,on and off...number one in sales

[@martsmarts]

@@jessaalquizar8392 that's quite an old tale. But the Hilux is indeed a good utiltarian truck. But other brands and models have been outperforming the Hilux and even beat it on sales numbers. Because if it's capability and durability there are so many models and brands that beat it now. If you read enough auto articles, the Hilux is a great truck, but not the greatest. Ford Ranger Raptor sucks by the way. Lol

[@jldp24]

South africa and australia ..same

[@50n6keyxz4]

Thank you so much sir for a very good comparison of pick up trucks.

[@ortegachristianmark1255]

Subscriber since 90k❤️

[@CM-ys3ei]

i bought a 2019 navara as my daily driver since philippine roads are not car friendly. even the expressways tend to be on the rough side. also during the time it was the least expensive amongst the available brands in the market. i was and still am very satisfied with my decision. even my cousins who also had pickups from other manufacturers were envious of its comfortable and relaxing ride.

[@sunburn6135]

How bout it's reliability sir?

[@riderman600]

Nxt time try these 4 on OFF-ROAD! Let's see who goes on top!

[@number25jason]

Ranger no doubt!

[@MarkArthur]

I'm sure talo pa din Toyota haha

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

ranger or navara yan but obviously not hilux hahaha

[@fulgham2734]

nice... more comparo in the future

[@harviedelrosario9375]

Thanks autodeal😊

[@mikzfronda]

How about making a part 2 comparo after 2 or 3 years. Hahaha! Ask mechanics, not the casa mechanics but the old timer mechanics from talyers on what they think about these cars. Which of these trucks have the overall durability, parts availability, maintenance costs etc. Just my opinion. Very nice comparo though, i've been waiting for this for a very long time. Nice one sir caco...

[@heyjun1283]

Not to belittle the abilities and skills of talyer mechanics, but I think they wouldn't be able to apprehend those aspects you were asking with high accuracy. Sure, they have learned through experience and could even know what's the problem of a certain automobile without having to thoroughly check the source. The thing is, these pick-up trucks pertain little to none differences between how they're built. To be straight, there's really nothing to compare between these pick-up trucks apart from their interior and features for the price u pay (which were already justified in the video*) and the only most relevant thing that really sets them apart is how the ecu is programmed to efficiently manage the overall performance of the vehicle. And these computer boxes that controls the cars today run way different from how it was back in the day. And I am leaning towards being sue to assert that the talyer mechanics would have a hard time dealing with these computer boxes, let alone to evaluate which one is better. Hence, why I am able to imply that even your idea was somewhat good, it would really be more of an entertainment video rather than a comparo. You might not agree with what I have spitted but this is as far as my knowledge goes when it comes to automobiles.

[@thatdude6271]

Making excuses such as this ain't gonna make the Hilux rank any higher in this comparo. If you're focusing on reliability, you're better off with a kalesa.

[@neilfrancosubang2991]

Underated car review channel, should've millions subs fr.

[@yejin101]

Please do a comparison between compact/midsize sedans!

[@mendozamarcvincec840]

My wish granted thanks autodeal next suv naman

[@dalealo3164]

After service spare parts price should be also in the category

[@dalegrana7517]

This is where dmax might give an edge

[@gerikmd]

Great review Caco and team!! I still went with the Hilux, reliability and resale value has no comparison.

[@gutadin5]

My cousin has 2009 Hilux manual trans with over 200,000 kms on the odometer.

[@adm1nistration]

yes, it's literally a work truck

[@rogeliogamboa7644]

this is an awesome review - I don't drive a pickup, just me & the mises - I'm a car guy, drive a MT sedan - but this comparo is interesting, as you see so many pickups on the road, you wonder what they are like in the real world

[@Vam0sProductions]

We should also consider the customer support, parts availability and the re-sale value when comparing. But nonetheless, great comparrison.

[@Steegampoota]

I have a Navara, and happy with it. But if I would pick a pickup today, I'd go for the Dmax.

[@franzcalipusan3367]

Pwede po ba malaman reason sir?

[@Steegampoota]

I feel na masyadong tinipid ni nissan yung navara, in terms of features. Outdated na din yung engine nya, maingay masyado and di kasing tipid ng ibang pickups. But, again, I am happy with the navara, maganda ang ride nya, and easy to maintain so far.

[@franzcalipusan3367]

@@Steegampoota maraming salamat sir..

[@arnelcaluya7403]

Thanks Caco, this really solved my dilemma between these beasts. Now I know which one to get. Now where do I get the money to buy one…? 🤔

[@romanbersamira4533]

my same problem🤣

[@braveheart1416]

there are many banks along the way, but choose the one less guarded or protected...

[@sepic13]

Every ute is good as longs as you looking after the car. Of course everyone has a preference! My self I love my V6 amrock but that's me.

[@johnkinsjayjaum5227]

It would be nice that the next video would be comparing Nissan Navara which is based on this video the TOP, vs. Ford Ranger Raptor? Would love to see this comparison.

[@giocoby]

Overall Navara wins. Period. Just accept the result. Wag na iyakin. Kesyo walang resale value, kesyo mahal ang parts and service, kesyo sa aircon lang malakas. Mag upload ka ng sarili mong Video Comparo para panalo yang brand na gusto mo. 😀 by the way. Love the graphics. More power.

[@gutadin5]

can you tell us some reasons

[@giocoby]

Did you watch the whole video? That's the reason for you.

[@johnnybimmer2661]

When you take a car reviewer for a "car expert" 🤦🏻‍♂️. Ask any veteran mechanic, the real car experts, they fixed them all and know it all, the story is much different. Yung brand known for making "disposable" cars in the 90s and early 2000 😂.

[@AR-px1ty]

Why did you not include water wading capacity? Thats very important.

[@ricacollado2184]

can't wait for the SUV comparo! :D

[@frankolaws8870]

very good comparison video i do think Nissan is working overtime to keep up with the competition am waiting to see the vans lol

[@cantiladrianeb.6241]

Nobody Reviews like Caco🤝

[@neifengg]

For handling & comfort , i think navara is the best.. however all factors counted, I finally bought D-max

[@Kyxmyx]

Ranger is the best handling pick up..

[@pinayinfrance2642]

​@@KyxmyxNot the most reliable sadly, people don't really like spending long time in reoair shops.

[@bebing1000]

I bought the Navara after watching this comparo, 👍

[@adrianp7255]

what to choose ? getting my first pick up navara vl AT 4x2 vs toyota conquest 4x2 AT.

[@d-rivechristian9317]

I heard fuego in the earlier part of the vid. Then I went out to see our family's 1994 fuego. 240k mileage

[@007pikes]

Yeah i noticed it too..

[@jayrstaana5131]

Eagle or pathfinder

[@Yejiiishi]

bakit walang Strada Athlete?

[@zypsy24]

phew! Them graphics are super saucy!

[@Rainrainrain17]

Im so excited because im gonna get the Nissan navara CalibreX Red this weekend!

[@gosoarchitects9464]

How about 1 category more: Warranty & Aftersales services, maintenance/parts etc? which is is the best and cheapest?

[@zoiloperlas91]

toyota

[@johannpaolocarino4905]

Ford after sales is the wwworst.

[@ErnestMarvinEsteban]

nissan's after sales based on my experience is one of the best. 5 years of warranty and they always offer me free checkup whenever I want which is a very nice gesture from them. I really don't know about the parts though since I haven't got a single problem yet with my unit ever since I purchased it.

[@cyborg5407]

@@ErnestMarvinEsteban free checkup kasi kakahuyin nila sasakyan mo

[@thegrimreaper6926]

Isuzu and Toyota based on my experience.

[@tuyokmanok2314]

And dont forget nissan has the coolest aircondition system. Additional point to comfortability

[@daxdyn12]

very nice review

[@inobaytv5270]

Any recommendations in any of these trucks would be good for a heavy payload capacity performance?

[@denverpranganrivera]

DMAX all the way!❤️👌🏽

[@haringusbaw6132]

So, which one breaks easily and a lot more expensive to maintain and repair?

[@kb7013]

Nissan suspension sucks.First thing to go on any Nissan vehicle.

[@thegrimreaper6926]

I heard a lot from friends that Ford is the one that easily breaks, and has the most expensive parts and are hard to find in markets.

[@lennon6277]

galing talaga ng autodeal.

[@boypay8293]

We have both of the older Ford and Nissan model Ford built tough as they say but not to tough as our Nissan Navara up to now with 200kms stills feels brand new unlike the Ranger 100+ kms, the damage is just a hose of the turbo, they want to replace all turbo. Navara the best plus the AC near the cup holders it beats the cooler box of my LC VX 2014

[@kaika201]

Yeeeesss... Navara! ❤️

[@tobythegreat8760]

Bat walang strada?

[@awtzzzzzzz2151]

I have no problems about the rank. But at the end of the day it all depends on the persons preference whether its reliability, brand, aesthetic, or feature. Subjective vs objective buying.

[@joes5509]

Can we include in the category the PMS cost and consumable Parts Prices?