不满被呃灌錄《赤子》 葉德嫻：我嬲羅大佑！

不满被呃灌錄《赤子》 葉德嫻：我嬲羅大佑！
雷霆881《1圈圈 星光背後》
視電台 crtv.881903.com/
日期 ：2016年8月13日
主持 ：梁泰來
嘉賓 ：葉德嫻
節目中，葉德嫻坦言87年推出完《邊緣回望》專輯後，一度對香港的音樂製作失望而拒絕再錄歌，及至91年，台灣音樂教父羅大佑「音樂工廠」的《皇后大道中》收錄了《赤子》一曲。Deanie姐直指灌錄《赤子》是一次很不愉快的經驗，她說：「之前羅大佑說想跟我切磋，那晚忽然羅生(羅大佑)助手的電話叫我到金冠錄音室，我已很奇怪為何要到錄音室，由晚上九點錄到凌晨四點，當我對歌詞有些意見，林夕更特別走來研究再錄至早上六點。我是不太滿意效果，離開時羅生說要收錄專輯中，我說沒所謂，但要等從美國回來再錄。」怎料留美期間，葉德嫻收到羅大佑助手通知，《赤子》要推出巿面，羅大佑助手的語氣，更令她為之氣結，「當時我收到電話那版本已出街了，為何可以這樣？他助手更說：『你不會有錢告我們！因為你窮。』我是真的嬲羅大佑，不是我有沒有版稅分的問題，而是嬲這樣的產品也可以推出，是水準的問題！」
更多內容：
bit.ly/2aRCDpc
相關影片：
剖白拒拍劇因由 葉德嫻：王晶應該唔會再搵我合作！
bit.ly/2aIO6Zs
否認行得太前無戲拍 葉德嫻：無人會搵我倒米！
bit.ly/2aPVpd7
--------------------------------------------------
下載Hong Kong Toolbar 手機應用程式
收聽商台節目直播 收看視電台
iOS流動版本: www.hongkongtoolbar.com/ios
Android 流動版本: www.hongkongtoolbar.com/android
Windows Phone 流動版本: hongkongtoolbar.com/windowsphone
Facebook專頁
881903.com： / 881903com
my903.com： / my903

[@makiechan9112]

睇過 葉德嫻嘅演唱會, 佢對藝術真係好有要求

[@Yan668]

葉德嫻小姐，唱歌好有味道👍

[@jacklee1257]

支持你啊deanie 姐有原则👍

[@Rocket-Man]

不听她说起这个往事，都不知道原来罗是那样的人。还有罗的助手，怎么能对叶说出那样的话呢？

[@H.K.Tang2023]

嫻姐＂幸運是在手裡＂🌹

[@kamheichow6043]

完全認同，浪費咗隻歌。

[@kinglam8205]

未滿意都咁正 🤔 勁！

[@user-gi4xe4il9j]

最緊要我聽完後說。。。頂瓜瓜👍👍👍👍👍

[@jjlee1529]

喊果個演唱會,唱得出果次D感情 感覺 音樂 同 聲線表達得好正...可惜...真係喊靜咗ㄧ部份... 祈盼待 德嫻修女 更正嘅赤子

[@raylee1912]

嘩！……：(甸妮姐呢首赤子,唔滿意都有咁既成績,旬妮我永遠都會撑硬妳)牙吓！……P！……👸💜👍👍👍👊

[@hualucy9352]

RAY Lee 我也硬撐她

[@Michaels581312]

What do you say?

[@kkleung2549]

德嫻姐，你曾是我偶像，法內-中-外情，經典之作，如真有此事，奉勸一句，遠離羅姓人仕，，，你應該知另一位是誰

[@yyyyyyyyyyy9]

罗嘉良

[@tttt-co3vo]

羅袖大

[@joerover]

我地外人聽呢首歌好正！好TOUCHING ! 睇落似"夾硬上"，但內裡有可能葉大姐夾雜大多個人立場....? 又或者借用甄妮另一首佢自己反感一首熱爆歌"夢想號黃包車"！這可能就是主觀與客觀上既感覺分別吧！

[@dtc9874]

幾喜歡佢呢種港女, 有咩直接講, 有自己立場, 但又好平和, 而家佢呢種舊式港女已經少咗好多

[@cracklover3133]

羅大佑仲諗到人會攪佢，但其實DEANIE姐係未滿意個PRODUCTvbm 姐

[@gothiccsatlos]

我永遠的歌后

[@PaulPaul-yj4tj]

如果冇簽約又冇收錢, 点解唔告佢 ? 如果真係事實, 只要出ㄧ段廣告話 “保留追討法律權利” , 對方都唔敢亂來, 成件事或有可能係“羅生門” 事件。

[@junlianglin8547]

Paul Paul 岩，事情无甘简单

[@waiyeekam7898]

一定有人攪壞好事，令好的藝人空間自然縮小，箇中原因可能日後才大交代！

[@user-xu2yb9kn4d]

不要以為台灣人品格較好，樹大都有枯枝

[@felix6905]

華人地區，道德最高的就是香港人，可是現在香港已經被赤化，香港的道德直線下降。

[@cananfisek5203]

谁说以为台湾人人格好

[@echris00]

She's performed this song with new arrangements several times in the past few years at different concerts. In most cases, it seems that she opted to take a much more evidently dramatic approach to the performance. Specifically, she takes long phrases between the phrases, at times she would start the beginning of a phrase at a slower speed only to build toward a greater intensity toward its close. The musical accompaniment also tends toward a much more dramatic flare. This approach to the song can't work very well for its official recorded version though. It would be much too excessive and theatrical to the extent that one might not want to listen to it repeatedly. While I understand her reservations and agree that what the producers did was unethical, I prefer the official version. To me, it is more understated and seems to exude the perspective of one who has accepted what's happening and is introspective about life, rather than one where the singer is still very much grappling with a state of intensity and conflict.

[@GlowingTree]

Very reasonable.

[@billchancanada]

Yes concert version should be different. The thing is if she didn't feel the song was good enough they should not use the opportunity to "steal" her voice for the project just because she couldn't afford to sue them. As a friend or a good producer, it is unethical. He got a song out of her but he lost a friend by doing so.

[@mybouquetisonly4u]

I don’t know 😅 For me (Foreigner),I think her version in concert has smoothen . I like 👍🏻

[@tttt-co3vo]

.表面不錯的羅生.如果真的如他的助手所說的是事實.咁就人面獸心了

[@irisng451]

专业精神

[@Keith-im7sv]

Free Hong Kong. Free China. Free the Earth. Demoncracy now. Be water. Life is value.

[@SWToDi-qc8hb]

WHO IS STILL LISTENING TO CRAPPY HONG KONG POP & WATCHING LOUSY HONG KONG MOVIE AFTER 2000 ???!!

[@lewislam5773]

吾比錢就好卵吾啱咯

[@dallas5735]

滿？满？

[@kennyyu5450]

佢兩隻食指攣咗 ！

[@nelsonkwok8240]

U.K. I'm

[@Keith-im7sv]

Free Hong Kong. Free China. Free the Earth. Demoncracy now. Be water. Life is value.

[@DickyWong99]

咁賤都有？

[@user-rb2ps2kn5i]

總覺得羅大佑不是不講信用的人，更不會口出渾語傷人，整件事很可能是一些不肖的香港商人從中作梗又吃了唱片利潤，才會導致合作的雙方彼此誤會的。

[@edwardasner5322]

葉德嫻和羅大佑應該是溝通不良吧。 羅大佑才華洋溢，對音樂本質的重視可能高過歌唱技巧的表現，思維不見得同於一般歌手。

[@siusiuchiuchiu]

人地都講埋成件事出黎，你唔知頭唔知路仲好意思去9UP？

[@Michaels581312]

外國人!

[@bochan8748]

首歌大紅大紫有冇多謝羅大佑？

[@billchancanada]

That's not the point. The point is, she didn't want the song to be released. He didn't care because he knew she was too "poor" to sue him. That is unethical.

[@user-fw8il2tx6m]

對華人音樂貢獻最少批評最多 卻給自己人封號最誇大的是那裏人呢 莞爾一笑吧！

[@SWToDi-qc8hb]

I know who she is !!

[@angelyu3582]

我被你善良嘅外表呃左😡😡

[@lionking38]

真真正正的巨星，根本不需要擺架子，去數人家不是。

[@dsetm6072]

on9

[@rage8kage]

分明就系为咗钱啦 香港人嗰啲passive aggressive bullshit 低俗