Bad Apple but AI Generated (used MMD as reference for it)

!! Go watch the Original MMD and show support !!
YT: • MMD6 - Bad Apple (3D a...
Nicovideo: www.nicovideo.j...
Hopefully I can make a better version using the black and white original at some point. This version used the MMD which Is a large part of why its consistent.
Never expected this to get more then 5 views, just thought it looked interesting. Thank you for watching
Made using Visions of Chaos Stable diffusion Web UI ebsynth extension and controlNet extension
SD Model: Anything v4.5
Extra program: ebsynth
Other versions:
Reconstructed from the music: • Bad Apple but Reconstr...
Papercut: • Bad Apple but Paper Cu...
Fruit: • Bad Apple but it's Sli...
Chibi: • Bad Apple but CHIBI
Unreal engine thing I made: • I'm making a Deep Sea ...
AI Visualization of Everywhere At The End Of Time: • AI Visualization of Ev...
Once I get monetization, all profits will go directly into helping my girlfriend get out of where she lives and into a safer environment. It’s not much but I hope it can help her.
Thank you so much 💕
Twitter: / manshoety
VODS channel: / @manshoetyvods7086
My Discord tag is manshoety
I DO NOT OWN ANY MUSIC IN
THIS VIDEO IN ANY WAY, SHAPE,
OR FORM!
#stablediffusion #stablediffusionanimation #aivideo #aianimation #badapple #touhou

[@manshoety]

I just want to mention that this was made purely to see if stable Diffusion could make it look more like anime instead of CGI. In no way is this an attempt to make it "better". I love both the original black and white, and the 3d animated version (which this used as a base when generating) and in no way am I trying to be better or replace them. I thought this was a fun and interesting thing to try. I kinda feel like the attention and views this video got should’ve gone to the original MMD (top of description) so please go check that out and like it if you see this. Personally I feel like this video is a little too close to the original MMD and would’ve preferred if it was more unique. Also, I am making no money whatsoever on this video. Ads are because the song is copyrighted, so all revenue goes to the copyright holders. I completely understand the issues people have with AI. I personally don't feel I am doing anything unethical with this video, but you're free to have your own opinions on that. I expected this to get like 20 views like my other stuff. There was no ill intent in the creation of this video. Thank you for watching and I hope you have a great day! Also, regarding a tutorial on how I made this, it's been so long that honestly I've forgotten half of how I made it. And as of now there are so many new tools to use so the tutorial would be very outdated. Maybe in the near future I can make videos showing the process of experimenting with stuff like this and show the full process of how I make it, using new tools and strategies. Might soon try an AI version from the black and white version. I think the technology exists now to do a decent (probably still janky) version. But it will be more of a full video with me experimenting and explaining what I’m doing. Just need to make sure I’m doing my college work first. - edit from 9/8/2023 The rest of this comment is from a while ago. Thank you so much for getting this to nearly 100k views! That’s insane! Bro what now 1 month later it’s at nearly 200k Thank you so much! I get like 25 views on my other stuff lmao

[@assburger4696]

certified gaming moment 🎉

[@1ue999]

This deserves it. We see that it is frame-by-frame, but it it really good (is it fbf?)

[@manshoety]

frame by frame every 5 frames or so. Then the other 4 frames between each generated frame is interpolated

[@Dadjoke_sigma]

Can i ask how many fps

[@manshoety]

honestly I forget. I think either 60 fps or 30.

[@TamTroll]

as a non-tohou player, this is the first time i have any idea what any of these characters are intended to look like outside silhouette form.

[@Ubermenschgaming_]

Join us.

[@manchaselgato5036]

Join us

[@BierBart12]

As someone who somewhat knows how the characters look like, I thought some of them were someone completely different

[@CusterdCrange]

same here 💀

[@arsongamer1510]

This is my first time realizing Bad Apple is from a game 💀

[@jannyboi260]

this animation will never die

[@manshoety]

Bad apple is immortal

[@jannyboi260]

@@manshoety bad apple best apple

[@virtual_mew]

​@@manshoetyfr

[@pmmm712011]

It'll probably be the standard benchmark for AI-animation. 1. Its super famous 2. Its Touhou characters have extremely plentiful data to fine tune on 3. Its camera angles and expressions are very dynamic, challenging the AI 4. The original has no details, allowing the AI to reinterpret it freely. The original, and the AI versions, are both works of pure passion. Who knew Bad apple will be relevant a decade onwards.

[@lilcosmicbutterfly]

​@@manshoety you could say bad apple ... will never go bad

[@awesomelink2347]

Love how the AI thought Yuuka's umbrella at 3:03 was the moon.

[@ChocoMagic-lf9dv]

I didn’t see that, oh my god that’s funny

[@StarOf.Martyrdom]

Lol

[@jorbur7773]

Xdddddd

[@𝚒𝙸𝙸𝚞𝚖𝚒𝚗𝚒𝚘𝚞𝚜]

Lmfao I was just at that part

[@unyielding37]

i noticed AI guessing some moons on spheres, hmm is that lore friendly?

[@mariusdiaz5816]

0:53 The ai made her wink and smile was adorable.

[@DanielMemeSmith]

Ikr I was expecting her to look scary but she ended up winking cutely lol

[@YamashiroTakane]

She tried making it but girl clicked the wrong emoji at the end 😂

[@tam_69420]

250th like :D

[@wedmunds]

​@@DanielMemeSmithit's impossible for colored flan to look scary. She's too good of a girl.

[@iso6628]

Fun fact: her mouth movements after that blink are synced with the music

[@BierBart12]

This feels like a "Bad Apple but I dreamed it after spending too much time looking at Touhou fan art"

[@rumiaiskawaii1930]

0:56 Og: scary Ai: kawaii

[@Chromoxylograph]

obviously because that's what flandre would do (lol)

[@MAX330]

The wink was cute :D

[@CountDooku420]

2:46 is a moon jumpscare.

[@Arthur01907I]

0:27 Bruh Became Human 💀

[@phuonganhnguyenngoc1745]

Transition A P P L E C H A N

[@user-ls9yr8md2j]

It's Patchouli

[@slycreature972]

The remaster we deserved. But seriously, this AI coloured animation is finally looks somewhat closer to original fluid movements and transitions!

[@johnsonlenney5174]

Still just a bit stiff

[@naxzed_it]

​@@johnsonlenney5174It's generated from the MMD version

[@lunarkomet]

This is is just the MMD version with a filter! Nothing to be excited about at all

[@dystotera77]

​@@lunarkometOnly a person that doesn't understand the implications could say that

[@MsTatakai]

Use a monochromatic filter and it looks much better by the way

[@luxion8376]

The fact that the AI generation (which I believe makes the animation frame by frame without trying to create a link with the previous frame) clicks the character’s design during the movements is surprisingly very smooth, I love it!

[@HyperVanilo]

That's because this is based on MMD version

[@GraveUypo]

it doesn't just click automatically, it was probably trained and prompted to do so also this isn't made on top of the black and white version

[@lumineani]

Maybe LorAs of the characters were used manually throughout prompts

[@chheexse]

Epic improvement

[@Handsomefella911]

Bro this looks like it’s on the ps2 for half the vid lol

[@chheexse]

@@Handsomefella911 i saw his first try

[@bunnylove2945]

Bad apple moment

[@n8thanwithan8]

Original’s MUCH better

[@chheexse]

@@n8thanwithan8 im sure the original would be better compared to an ai generated video. I just think the improvement compared to his first attempt is good

[@gensoustudio4703]

Imagine if a competent artist did this but more so used it as an animation tool and touched up every frame to make it make sense and flow better, it would be so awesome.

[@manshoety]

I was thinking of doing a thing where I poorly drawing the keyframes but even that would take me forever

[@gensoustudio4703]

@@manshoety Yea but still probably way faster than traditional animation.

[@VOlDNOVA]

@@manshoety art does take effort and a heck ton of time, but even if you take the AI mishmash and draw/polish every frame by hand, it'll actually make it look good, because AI doesn't have a brain and a pair of eyes to really do it alone and judge if it looks or feels good/coherent/proper. Right now, this AI animation, even if limited by certain aspects, it still is sloppy and flashy (in the bad sense) enough to provoke epilepsy symptoms on people.

[@videosyouweresearchingfor6126]

It would probably be easier to make the thing from scratch rather than have to deal with whatever the AI spits out

[@peepawfart]

​@@videosyouweresearchingfor6126 you'd probably have to redo like 80% of the frames to make it flow consistently anyways lmfao. Not even the colors match between frames. Better to animate from scratch

[@Mars-nx7lx]

This is gonna take awhile but here we go 0:01 Reimu Hakurei (I like how sometimes she Change expression’s and of course not too sexy side view ,since the 3D/MMD ver has her side boob exposed luckily the Ai actually censored it in a way) 0:15 Marisa Kirisame ( she has a cute happy expression , but i think she’s missing her leg / invisible leg) 0:29 Patchouli Knowledge ( this is not bad but of course the ai still messed up the hands In some frames) 0:35 Remilia Scarlet ( Lego hands lol 😂 but In a way her hands still in place just the ai having trouble with the object is hilarious) 0:43 Sakuya Izayoi ( I don’t find any problems on her so far , as expected from the “perfect” maid) 0:50 Flandre Scarlet ( she’s actually gives you a cute look instead of the whole psychopath look which make sense now since she’s no longer the psychopath people think she is , just a bit destructive and lonely ) 0:58 Youmu Konpaku (her clothes keeps changing colors and she did 360neck turn..dam that’s creepy) 1:04 Yuyuko Saigyouji (she actually almost hard to see on the youmu sword scene until the camera focus on her and in some frames she changes her eye color , overall not to messy ) 1:11 Komachi Onozuka(she only gets messed up if the camera isn’t too focused on her , overall nice shading by the AI) 1:18 Shiki Eiki ( just like komachi she gets the special shading ) 1:24 fujiwara no mokou(her hands in some frame is funny and also her head at the end looks weird but overall it’s insanely good) 1:32 keine and her hakutaku form ( they exchanged glasses lol) 1:38 Eirin (i think she stared at my soul) 1:46 Kaguya Houraisan ( her objects got screwed up a bit but overall it’s good) 1:53 primsriver sisters ( in some frames they change colors but the object doesn’t get messed up that much ,good) 2:00 - 2:06 Chen , Ran , Tewi , Reisen , Momiji (all of them looking good ) 2:08 Sanae Kochiya ( she’s actually got the special shading which is cool I guess) 2:11 Hina ( not much of a change really) 2:13- 2:19 Kanako and Suwako ( holy this is good I like how kanako doesn’t express that much and suwako happy face is cute) 2:20 - 2:35 yukari yakumo , tenshi hinanawi(they actually looks so good woah) 2:37- 3:34 aya , suika , alice , nitori , yuuka , Elly , pc-98 reimu and pc98 Marisa , windows marisa , windows reimu( they all look so good in their own way , maybe suika having mouth problems and pc-98 reimu and pc-98 marisa turning into windows in some frames) Man that took like 20 minutes 😂

[@manshoety]

I loved reading this! Thank you and have a great day!

[@Mars-nx7lx]

@@manshoety have a nice day too

[@NovasGreat]

on sakuya, for a split second, her head looks like its facing upward

[@mytally17]

How you Write this long

[@Mars-nx7lx]

@@mytally17 sorry for the late response , I just write as I watch (hope that clarifies it eheh)

[@goldenboxen6430]

the fact the ai picked on the the designs so well is crazy also 1:01 the ai did have a problem and switch between making her head look like a shrine cause of her moving around so far back

[@HyperVanilo]

Well, this is based on Bad Apple MMD, so...

[@Diego-ym4rx]

She looks like a building

[@BatBitesTheBat]

LOL

[@Nitosa]

Oh god for a couple of frames you can see her face on the back of her head. ☠️

[@MsAmber82]

Don't be surprised if that girl ask for a "sorcerer's stone" later

[@huyenmon12]

3:03 like how her umbrella turns into the moon somehow

[@kr3mlsche]

AI generated videos are like what it's like to dream or try to remember a dream but it's not vivid enough of a memory

[@justusapelt637]

the speed at which ai technology is progressing is scary

[@luisgalizien]

I am very hyped on when one of them finally gains sentience

[@kingwilbertagbayani6480]

It's because Stable Diffusion is open source along with a huge bunch of people developing it because they like it, and not closed behind a paywall and a certain amount of employees developing it, unlike DALL E-2

[@zdzdhhfdzhzdhdzheherh33]

yes but its only 30 frames per second

[@VOlDNOVA]

it still looks reassuringly bad though

[@NK-ns1bp]

@@luisgalizien an AI can never achieve awareness or free will. Since AI can't understand emotions, and human can't put emotions in the AI because we don't even fully understand that as well. in order to create a sentinel AI, we need it to have the ability to think like Neurons, but how can it be possible to do that with just a series of electronic being off and on? it's just impossible

[@Ultimaniacx4]

I love that Flan actually winked.

[@cyclops8939]

再現度高すぎて、なんか懐かしくなって泣けてきた 子供の頃からずっと見続けてる

[@Alex-mw8qz]

Not being in the touhou fandom it's cool to know what these characters look like.

[@user-tp7nd6hz1o]

2:28ここの天子 めちゃくちゃ天子らしくて凄い

[@Yvel_Project]

this Flan's wink got me fr

[@ceruleanrush3315]

0:56 That wink was adorable!

[@VasalisErretti]

The way the colors of the character's eyes shift slightly is mesmerizing to look at. Not 100% in the touhou rabbit hole but if I'm not mistaken for some of those shifts was cool cause the character is sometimes drawn with either of the 2 eye color options. If am wrong on that is still very well done as most of their designs are pretty on point throughout the frames despite it being ai generated.

[@HyperVanilo]

This video is based on MMD version, look it up

[@WhunderCh]

Rainbow eyes

[@what_homework]

3:32 I absolutely love that the ai made the dark side the moon and the light side for the apple, it just adds more to the themes of the animation. Also I love the fact that every character had facial expressions that matched their personalities (the original literally had no eyes to base anything off of). The transitions were surprisingly nice as well, it seems ai has a weird way of effectively doing it better than most people when using color.

[@CherrySongbird13]

okay this is just my fever dreams with how it constantly shifts and evolves lol

[@user-ez6zc3cj6x]

影絵→CG→AIイラストという一連の変化に時代の流れと技術の進歩を感じずにはいられないよね

[@Sibunafan221]

I'm sure the original creator would appreciate if you linked the MMD version in the description!!

[@manshoety]

Top of the description. It’s just that KZbin’s new embedded linking makes it not stand out. I’ll try to make it stand out more

[@lunarkomet]

​@@TheColorOrange- people still think this is the b/w version colorized so it's more than needed!

[@manshoety]

unfortunately yea people seem to be confusing it for the black and white version. I’ve changed the title to say I used the MMD and pinned my comment that includes that I used the 3D MMD version as a base. Also it’s in the description. Hopefully people read it

[@sxteya]

​@@lunarkometblah blah blah 🤓🤓🤓

[@Hammerheadworm]

1:55 blowing the violin and bowing the trumpet how nice

[@tanqs789]

1:02 scares me

[@MetalX34]

the ai wobbling shapes and colours around with every frame reminds how these same characters have been depicted in thousands of different artstyles and fanons. how poetic.

[@phrygianphreak4428]

I love how the AI was able to recreate the subpar animation on the 3D rigs EDIT: I wrote this to be harsh on purpose for the comedic effect. Considering the circumstances the original animators were working with I can understand the quality. It's great for what it is :) Take a chill pill yall!

[@DollaZep]

Subpar? The animation was created 13 years ago, so it's not gonna compete to animations nowadays. Also, it was (and still is) an amazing animation

[@manshoety]

I agree it’s a really nice animation And it was made 13 years ago which is amazing

[@nyxie2877]

Subpar? Bad Apple is artistic genius

[@tri--light]

guys he means the animation on the REMAKE, not the original.

[@nanamacapagal8342]

Remaster might be the right word here, this feels so much more fluid than the rigid 3d colorized original Don't get me wrong, the original 2008 version is revolutionary (I still don't know how the transitions were that smooth for a video that came out in 2008)

[@user-hr1hn2tx7l]

色がキラキラかわるのかっこいい…

[@exrage2000]

I like the fact that the animation style is always changing, its more abstract, like the original black/white video

[@jspiral360]

2:11 i got goosebumps

[@iich.bin.sway.]

I get goosebumps from ai

[@rainiertolentino6362]

THIS ANIMATION BRINGS ME LITERAL CHILLS

[@rodrigoterrein4599]

0:22 from an evil mansion to a Half life 2 beta looking combine citadel, epic

[@Jasontrehiurgdugfiudsufhdudhdi]

Nah it’s the twin towers /j

[@Ravyaan]

1:02 ayo, her head broke!

[@Monday_.just_bored]

This is the best animation I've ever seen for AI Generated

[@VoidySan]

Bro. I had no idea what any of these characters looked like before this. But the only thing I got right was the chick who shot the finger gun had purple hair.

[@MONOCHROMEZ]

0:46 MY FAVORITE

[@svyatovrat4071]

1:41 AYO 💀

[@Astreious]

HAIL HI-

[@NU555]

ALL HAIL

[@sentryinventor]

🤔

[@probobcat861]

WW2

[@iich.bin.sway.]

????

[@Revenge-fm9tt]

I kinda love this style actually. The way the textures and shading details change randomly but smoothly. Great visual for a music video!

[@kahvipaputyyppi]

This is the first time I actually see the characters! Thank you! 🤩

[@HyperVanilo]

You already can see the characters from a video 11 years ago, search Bad Apple MMD

[@fntthesmth423]

Weird how this is one of the most unsettling versions i've ever seen. Adding color and definition detracts from so many of the stylish transitions; genuinely interesting to see how much the monochrome silhouettes truly make Bad Apple as great as it is

[@はりーー]

すごく自然！！！めちゃくちゃ好き

[@cryztalite]

The fact that it’s like weird 2.5D models is so cool!

[@randyrandom3358]

now we just need an animator to reanimate the entire thing and it'll be *french kiss* 🤌

[@urassari]

pause right at the beginning at 0:01, (I'ts a weird glitch!)

[@urassari]

and also 3:38.

[@HerobrineLolz]

True

[@koisandz]

I like how some eye colors change, the two I could actually eye though were Yuyuko and Tenshi

[@user-fi6zp9gq1g]

This is actually nice.

[@Linguistic1]

Y'know, ironically, this gives the video more life than it ever had. I never really viewed the characters as overly distinct.

[@scrunklybonk]

God damn this is mind blowing

[@N0bdi3]

Wow never seen AI good actually some AI just tend to make curse in the video but in this one it was smooth and perfect and kind of smooth like dang.

[@edd3892]

Where is the good AI?

[@N0bdi3]

@@edd3892 I mean kind of smooth I guess.

[@MyFictionalChaos]

Well it is using something as a reference, similar to cosplay videos where they use the cosplayers’ movements as the video reference and add in the character as an overlay/filter almost. And AI is constantly growing so it will look much smoother today than a year ago

[@morgue502]

bad apple but they turned the lights on

[@that_ball]

0:55 this part is really cuty idk why 😊

[@tranminhnguyen6217]

This deserves more view. I can't wait to see a fully colored version and polished version of the original animation!

[@HyperVanilo]

"Colored" version already exist

[@CasandraRodri-jh7sk]

​@@HyperVanilo i have a crush on you

[@Astreious]

@@CasandraRodri-jh7skThe hell…💀😭

[@Astreious]

@@CasandraRodri-jh7skyou’re probably the only one

[@CasandraRodri-jh7sk]

@@Astreious are u ok

[@lordyhgmofficial5186]

POV: you said the edibles ain't shit

[@DexNathan]

This would be a coloured remaster if it was actually animated and did correctly.

[@its_venezianotvenice]

guys, this version uses the 3D colored version of Bad Apple as a base, that’s why it is colored an coherent

[@lunarkomet]

Yeah, this was such a letdown

[@flowerfloofs]

🙃 Loving how people are hyping this up! So I'll say it. Ai art is theft. The person who created this video did no work. They're profiting on other artists work.

[@manshoety]

Completely understand that view. I did this because I thought it would look interesting, not for any kind of monetary reason. I’ve made no profit off of this. All money from this goes to the copyright holders for the song.

[@laysthechip3356]

Frr like it's all made out of stolen art idk why anyone wants to keep that theft ball rolling :/

[@dfgd2402]

@@manshoety Disliked for AI. It's just the characters for the MMD version being randomly generated every second. You are a thief.

[@dfgd2402]

@@manshoety, it's not just the song, but also any art that OTHER PEOPLE made.

[@user-ez6zc3cj6x]

天子と紫のパートかっこよすぎる 鳥肌立った

[@jorgezerovsterran527]

absolutely perfect!!! wooow, new record!

[@user-bf8xh9ib6i]

Flandre's part is an ABSOLUTE. MASTERPIECE.

[@rison02ge]

Yuyuko's eyes: 🔴👄🔴🔵👄🔵🔴👄🔴🔵👄🔵🔴👄🔴🔵👄🔵🔴👄🔴 All jokes aside this is the best Bad Apple in color so far that's pretty consistent AND really nice to look at. I really like it! Flan so cute

[@lomen2734]

1:42 🤨

[@bandu278yearsago4]

The animation is smoother than my life

[@lav-kitty]

really uncomfortably stiff tho

[@Icewave1fnaf]

bad apple forever

[@Nintendogs08]

I like how the characters looks keeps changing, makes it feel like a dream

[@sif3398]

Damn, this may be the only bad bad apple version

[@EvilNeuro]

I think your only saying that bc it’s ai lol

[@ChameleonAI]

Mad respect for the amount of expertise and work it must have took to get it to look so good. I'd love to see more about how it was made.

[@seiwaseiwa]

新しい時代が到来した感じですね！

[@DingusTheCat.]

The first actually good piece of content from ai

[@AnApple-xg8lm]

Bad apple is a masterpiece

[@user-jz3nw4rz6g]

クオリティ高っ！

[@heavyoak]

this has no right being this good

[@_care.]

fat upgrade than some of the bad apples

[@BobChess]

The animation is so smooth!

[@mizukiplushoffical3505]

I like how Flandre winked at us!

[@blossomnosleep]

That's flandre was the most adorable thing I've seen

[@Theunknowndarkness]

Me eating an apple watching this: My brain: THROW IT ON THE GROUND

[@rzdnx]

So smooth

[@touhoulunatic8128]

The improvements are very visible this time, and I can get why I see so many illustrations from danbooru that have been uploaded throughout the years. Becuz the AI program was trained on Pixiv and Danbooru. Though a nice effort for compiling the video :)

[@shorge37]

good apple?

[@chaosminecraft3399]

That is pretty stable for an AI

[@billiboi122]

One hell of a difference from like a year ago

[@TheREALsillySUNDAY]

Guys...... AI IS GETTING SMARTER 😨

[@Tuberbone]

Wait a minute! This film is actually stitched together frame by frame? If it's so smooth, how long did it take you to make it?😲😘

[@yamatanoorochi3149]

Even the credits are ai generated

[@eye_cancer]

💀

[@Astreious]

HELL NAHHHH😭😭😭😭😭😭💀💀💀💀

[@jaoiwandanax564]

So good, you are genius. Keep going

[@LHWK_RHC]

Flandre's smile is cute rather than creepy in this version. 0:55

[@TheHuTao.]

I’m glad stable diffusion is free to use and open source giving us and developers the opportunity to super elevate AI

[@littleblueleaf3110]

WhaT. THIS IS A MASTERPIECE, really nice

[@jasonzawtun]

Flandre's chest just got sliced.

[@igorgiuseppe1862]

i think the classic bad apple is perfect as is, it cant be "improved", that said, this version is quite fun too, one interesting thing about the original is that its a bit abstract since you cant know how the characters would look like in color, on this version, on the other hand, you know but at the same time you dont, its abstract despite the fact that you can see, since the shape/colors change/morph all the time and your brain cant really process what he is seeing.

[@SleepyHorse]

What do you think about the 4k 60fps version instead of 720p 30fps?

[@Yuyuko_Patriot]

0:59　幽々子さん　てんどんマンになったりロボットになったり城になっててくさ

[@VanAkita]

Flandre smiling and winking instead of looking menacing is the most adorable thing.

[@𝕺𝖗𝖉𝖎𝖓𝖆𝖗𝖞𝖒𝖆𝖌𝖎𝖈𝖎𝖆𝖓98]

It is impossible to coloured flan to be scary tho.

[@Pyxied]

crazy what ai can do

[@artce]

Вау, классно. Очень много огрехов но прогресс на лицо.