Bato Dela Rosa's heated exchange with a student leader at Senate ROTC hearing

Subscribe: / @rappler
More videos on Rappler: www.rappler.com/video Follow Rappler for the latest news in the Philippines and across the globe. Senator Bato Dela Rosa flares up after Raoul Manuel, President of the National Union of Students of the Philippines, made a pass at the former Police chief during a Senate committee hearing on mandatory ROTC proposals. Manuel hit Dela Rosa for supposedly allowing the possible release of a "rapist mayor" while the poor are killed in "Tokhang" anti-drug operations.
Full story: www.rappler.com/nation/238307...
From cartoons and animations timelapses, to newsroom tours, to Live Jam sound checks, get access to Rappler’s MEMBERS-ONLY content here: / @rappler
_
Follow Rappler on Social Media:
Facebook - / rapplerdotcom
Twitter - / rapplerdotcom
Instagram - / rappler
KZbin - kzbin.info?sub_...
SoundCloud - / rappler
Google+ - plus.google.com/+Rappler/
Tumblr - / rappler
www.rappler.com/ Follow Rappler for the latest news in the Philippines and around the world.
Support independent journalism. Help us stay free and independent of political pressure and commercial interests: r3.rappler.com/crowdfunding Follow Rappler for the latest news in the Philippines and around the world.
Support independent journalism. You can help power our investigative fund by donating to our crowdfunding: donate.rappler.com/

[@mijaqui7985]

THe student remarks are mundane and irrelevant. He should have stuck to the issue and apposite to the agenda of the quorum.

[@martindonato8024]

I took the basic ROTC for 2 years. 3 semesters with Air Force and 1 sem with Navy.

[@normaalvarez1713]

Kumuha ka ulit,may 1billion budget..hihihi

[@mamoninashiraishi2294]

@@normaalvarez1713 pagkapera pinag-uusapan ang bilis ng mga dilawan.....gustong kamkamin lahat .......makikita mo naman, maraming project hindi tap0s inumpisahang lang.para magkaroon ng budget.asan, palibhasa gawain nila.

[@litojumadiao7245]

Bakit kc ibenoto yan salut sa gobyerno at mamayan pinagpipilitan nila yon adhikain nila n communists country i love martial law rotc cat mabuhay bbm sara

[@user-gn6kd7ox1s]

no one cares

[@hexfart4562]

Ako basic ROTC for 1 year lang sa ARMY

[@felmanembalsado3787]

How can Bato be so offended with his own statement?

[@lebronjames4903]

Lol

[@eleuterioflorendo469]

Senator Bato is right. The student representative is injecting ideas away from the topic. She should talk only on ROTC period!!!!

[@haruchii25]

His not offended, galit lang sya kase nililihis nung bata ung topic

[@orphab.5536]

Totoo naman kasi hindi na alam ng ibang politiko kung saan sila lulugar.

[@teofiloabucay2914]

I had undergone complete training primarily Boy Scout, secondarily PMT and finally ROTC for the love of our country

[@salviotolentino5316]

Ako din ... Pero mas maganda siguro kung mandatory military service na May compensation and benefits like other military personnel/officer. Kawawa nga mga reservist, masyadong discriminated ... Parang saling pusa lang sa formation. Ang daming draftee & out of school na pwede rin nilang tawagin to undergo military service and training ... Marami rin graduates ... Just like in US, Korea, Singapore and many other. Wala sa school. nasa military training camp. May suweldo at benepisyo ... Ang laki-laki ng pondo ng military at pnp.

[@cleverallan]

Although I commend for the Student Leader's stand on this topic, but ONLY A FOOL GOES TO A DUEL THAT HE KNOWS HE CANNOT WIN.

[@u777dn]

this is truly the representation on how boomers actually silence the younger

[@anym236]

wag kasi puro katangahan ang sinasabi pra hindi binabara. at matutuong rumespeto.

[@marcmg4234]

If he was out of topic, then the Committee had every right to silence him.

[@Leczy]

please the statement was so irrelevant, Wake up and stop justifying your stupidity

[@joeldeleon2891]

Bka nabulungan ni hontivirus yan

[@glenmichaelwong517]

i saw youth doing crimes

[@aidalarroza6243]

Sana maibalik na ang ROTC, sa High School Boys from 3rd to 4th year Students also Girls Scout 3rd n 4th din HS also, tnx

[@jente74]

I underwent CAT training in high school and became an officer. Our training taught us discipline and it was good.

[@mariahsdeafeningwhisper6190]

Pero bakit maraming kawatan, mandarambong, mamamatay tayo, drug lord na nasa hanay ng kapulisan at kasundaluhan kung nagbibigay pala ng disiplina ang ROTC? 😊

[@glendasimbajon1431]

True, its a nice experience lalo na pag tactical inspection.

[@zemirahskynakamura4941]

Exactly!

[@archtiquette]

But ROTC is different especially when there are a lot of fraternities in colleges or universities. The intention is good but if the system is abuse then will it truly benefit the students? It would be great if it was similar to how Korea does it for mandatory military service but we're not capable of having such credibility to be like them.

[@rowenadinsmore1]

I guess for you it worked. Sabi nga not everyone is called for a task. Kanya kanya ng trip. I never liked someone screaming and lording over me.

[@futureeducator4715]

"Dapat may ROTC para madisiplina kayo" Diba trabaho niyong mga MAGULANG yan? HAHAHAHA o walang mattrigger ah hahaha

[@wowtv59]

true inamin nila na wala silang kwenta

[@princerolandmolera4772]

FYI lang po. Hindi po lahat ng anak ay nagagabayan ng magulang gawa ng karamihan sa mga magulang ngayon ay nagkakanda kuba na kakatrabaho para lang mapag aral ang mga anak nila. Again, hindi po lahat pantay pantay at pare pareho ng situation na kinahaharap.

[@hawkeyestone2122]

So,ang magulang nung student dito ay di dinisiplina ng maayos? Good analogy, tama din. And if you think ROTC is equal to Familial discipline, you're clueless. As Bato said, goes to really show we need ROTC, speaking for myself as I am 16 years old. Andami ng flawed logic, too entitled, this generation is full of softy spoiled brats. Finally, this will happen.

[@jomariecallueng9220]

@@hawkeyestone2122 Haha sinabi mo pa

[@glovicescolano3938]

Tama

[@asianjudas3999]

I have nothing against mandatory ROTC napagdaanan ko siya and okay naman siya even foreign countries implement mandatory ROTC. The only problem is when there is an abusive officer, mandatory ROTC is okay as long as there will be assurance na walang ma a-abuse na student

[@christopherlorenzo328]

I agree. Been there

[@leonardtinoy9801]

I agree, tapos sana mga walang babayarin o hindi dagdag gastos sa magulang.🖋️

[@hermosotablason3501]

hindi lang sa ROTC mas marami ngayon na walang ROTC sa eskuela ibatibang abuses ...

[@elyracraquin8858]

Ano ngaun Manuel pahiya k non sense kc pinagsasabi m yan ung tinatawag n kalawakaw

[@ogiegorospe7609]

@@elyracraquin8858 ayaw nyang mag ROTC kase halata na eh😅😅

[@weirddad99]

I'm pro ROTC. It is a very good platform to train the young Filipinos discipline and prepare them for the ugly truth of war. However, I disagree with how the student here was treated. It is true he brought out topics which are far fetched and will just delay the proceedings, but he should not be ganged up by the senators like that. The senators, being our role models should bring him back to his place by teaching him how things are done in these proceedings, not shout at him and warning him. They are driving these kids away. I applaud senator Cayetano's approach. She called out the student's mistake but did not discourage him to continue to participate.

[@believe3402]

I was a CAT Corps Commander during my high school days. Then I took ROTC as a pre requisite in college. It is a part of our training to discipline ourselves. As a man it is our duty and responsibility to help our military to defend our country. I love my country Philippines and proud to be a Filipino!

[@armandotorres6860]

Umalis ka sa senado bato, para kang maton sa kanto, rotc pahirap sa students, kahit mag survey kayo!😅

[@ysaganiybarra6661]

@believe. Tell us what did you learned sa 2 years cguro of ROTC and CAT respectively?

[@Capt.mactavish3]

​@@armandotorres6860 Ang pahirap sa estudyante displine Yan sguro now kadin 8080

[@dyessasesisosu9191]

raise ur argument not ur voice

[@segundinamagtanao8527]

Abnormal ang tao na hindi magalit sa ganyan kaisipan.

[@bellcramell5207]

Ang taong yan takot sa ROTC kasi barbie yan... Walang disiplina sa sarili.... at walang respeto sa ibang tao... Kaya change topic agad..... Nakakahiya yang taong yan... The topic is hearing on mandatory ROTC... kaso iba ang issue ang sinabi nya..... ROTC is all about discipline to ourselves and also to others on how to respect yourself and another person and so on....

[@Hungaryholdingkft]

aanhin mo yung ROTC kung 4"11 lng height mo tatanggapin ka kaya ng Afp,bjmp,bfp,pnp. uto uto lng ito sa mamayan ang Rotc para sa Qualified lng. dahil gusto pala ni senators bato yung Mga Rotc ang ipadigma sa china,

[@normaalvarez1713]

Idaan nyo kaya sa poll,kung saan magtipon ang gusto ng rotc at ayaw..

[@normaalvarez1713]

Isama ang mga parents sila ang gagastos eh

[@mannymarquez1513]

Hahahaaa.. Correct

[@rafaelvargas5333]

@@Hungaryholdingkft tanga ka ba? training yan para magkaroon ng respeto at magka-knowledge ka about military activities hindi naman sinasabi dyan na gagawin kang impleyado, alam mo ang salitang “RESERVED” ?

[@Haileys_Adventures]

I experienced CAT in high school but I'm only on the medical team because of my health condition and it's really good for students ‘cause you will know how to do first aid and basic skills to protect yourself .to be responsible, how to be a leader and other many learnings for you to be a better person

[@jacobosoriano]

ROTC useless yan kung di natin kayang paalisin ang tsikwa sa kalayaan Island, yung utak ni bato wala

[@zenaidaaraos1662]

ang anak kung panganay 46 na at ngaun..at laking pasalamat ko nakapag ROTC ..nakita ko sa kanya ang pagiging disiplina at di naakit ng mkakaliwa..

[@AxxxYxxxS]

One good reason to bring back ROTC? Para yung mga taong walang disiplina (di pa pinag sasalita, sumasabat na), walang modo (disrespects a Senator during a session), at bastos (nananalakay ng personal issue at hindi related sa topic ng pinag uusapan) na tulad ng guest speaker na ito ay mawala o mabawasan.

[@hypnos4545]

The resource did his purpose of triggering the senator. On the other hand, the senator lost it, finger pointing is not very senator like. I wonder how many more outburst like that could trigger a stroke. Even the choice of words is very street like

[@jackgibbs8678]

@@hypnos4545 while that self proclaimed "whatsoever representative leader of the students" was talking like an animal, disrespectful and his concern is out of the blue, out pf the galaxy. Fvck u

[@hypnos4545]

@@jackgibbs8678 he’s a student, young, immature. He was obviously placed there to raise eyebrows. The senator on the other hand is an elected official, paid by the people’s tax. Represents PH in other countries. You really wanna compare both? You’re mother must have raised you well with that dirty mouth

[@yowitselliegirl]

i agree with you@@hypnos4545

[@dannynuez3316]

Kaya dapat ibalik na talaga ganyan na ung kabataan na sinira Ng nga university

[@NYXthetherian11]

It was a memorable time in college... Strengthened our bond with friends na kapwa nag-a-ROTC din.

[@rev_up_the_engines]

I am 23 years old and have not regretted ROTC it made me who I am today, discipline is everything 😊

[@jorgereinante8493]

I am a proud ROTC graduate. I favor the return of ROTC. However, let us learn from the past so abuses of the past will not happen again.

[@patrickd.3553]

Hindi naman nawala ang ROTC. Voluntary na nga lang at may ibang choices naman like CWTS at LTS

[@50sthankful]

I'm 53 yrs..my batchmate had CAT and ROTC,,and never regret had that experience where we been partly and indirectly feel the essence of allegiance to our country and discipline ..iba na talaga tubo Ng kabataan ..di Rin naman kami nakaranas Ng abuso...yun mga gustong mga officer sa amin yun Ang mas naka experience Ng initiation..

[@jundekatropanglaaganadvent2264]

No Pain, no gain. Dahil sa ROTC nging positibo pananaw ko. I develop patriotism and self discipline

[@claritagabornes2512]

Why are against CAT,ROTC but when are forcing the youth to be npa ndf to be teroirist magkano ang bayad mo

[@user-uu7qz9jf6x]

Nakakatawa Raoul 😂😂😂

[@perryfelizardo8347]

CAT at ROTC natututo ang kabataan ng respeto at paggalang sa kapwa.

[@arnoldferrer2184]

Not only the armed forces of our country is the defender of imminent danger but us the Filipino Citizen of the Republic of the Philippines.

[@allanis_the_great]

exactly! pag nagkaruon ng war between ph and cn, anong gagawin ng mga pinoy, mag titktok?

[@CreepyEngkwentroTV]

sarap kya rotc 2 yrs lng nmn un masaya pa

[@treechada8196]

2 years? Sobrang haba naman 🤨

[@CreepyEngkwentroTV]

@@treechada8196 oo te 4 semester un twing linggo lng nmn

[@marsamsacab3060]

Nung elementary ako pangarap ko Maka experience NG C. A. T. it's because para lge tayong handa sa sarili natin may desiplina din Tayo sa sarili natin at Para narin sa pang self defense at protektahan ang ating bansang pilipinas. Pero pag dating NG high school during 2000 wala NG mga ganyan Para akong nalungkot at nadismaya kasi gusto ko talagang mag traning, mag marching Na nakasoot NG uniform na ganun.

[@jerrynailon8625]

ROTC is very important ,,,we must have a reserve officers for our country ,,,👍👍👍

[@rasheedabs3111]

Giatay man Ka dzae nganung ikaw man ang nag represent diha 😂😂 dapat didto unta ka sa pageant 😂

[@mariel98210]

basta mga Rasheed nga inanag nawong kay bigot

[@lordbyron0850]

When i was in college most students preferred NSTP than ROTC. But students still have the freedom to choose which one they are comfortable with.

[@GabbyVersoza]

That's what we want too. Ok lang kami sa ROTC. Pero ang gusto kasi nila Sara Duterte and Sen Bato, MANDATORY ROTC Meaning required. Mapa anong edad mo, may sakit ka man o wala, may disability o wala, may trauma o wala, kailangan mo mag ROTC kasi required. Doon po kami kontra, kasi karapatan ng mga estudyanteng may sakit, may disability at may trauma na mag-no sa military service.

[@goddycarino6747]

@@GabbyVersoza Dati naman na pag may medical condition ang isang Estudyante pwede syang mag submit ng certificate mula sa Doctor o kung anuman ang sakit nya ,tulad nung High School kmi, may CAT pa noon yung mga sakitin na Estudyante umattend parin naka uniform parin pero dun na lang sila sa isang tabi,kahit nung College sa CMT/ROTC ,basta may medical certificate ka at kung anuman ang condition mo ay pwede ka naman ma-exempt, pero kaylangan parin na ienroll, kasi mandatory pa noon sa amin, at pwede kapa rin umattend,hindi ka na nga lang mag marching or mabilad sa araw na naka formation, mga ganun ba na instances.

[@goddycarino6747]

Masaya nga sa CMT/ROTC, astig pa ng mga uniform namin.

[@acidpolgaming7445]

During my college days I'm so proud to Choose ROTC than NSTP CWTS even ROTC is not Required for my Course. Because I want to serve on our loving county

[@bernalitotejano3610]

@@GabbyVersoza are they really required for the disability to join ROTC? are you sure? yong may sakit pwede pa kc in my time mostly sa may sakit di naman pinipilit pag di kaya at saka di ka naman papatayin sa ROTC, atleast yong isip nila is na tetrain not to give up easily,

[@dreamon_777]

Napagdaanan ko rin ang rotc, mga ilang taon na din akong pabalik balik dyan. Pero kung patungkol sa disiplina ang pag'uusapan dito, ang masasabi ko lang. Rotc is not enough... at para dun sa student leader, marunong lang siyang mag'english pero... malayo sa topic, kung magaling ka, dapat straight to the point ang usapan..

[@Rj-yp4ux]

I’m ok with ROTC but let us go back to the reason why ROTC is not mandatory now.

[@roseterrado7297]

bisdak lapid and bato

[@reiseva247]

when other country invades us.. your mouth wont save you.. but your awareness on training how to defend oneself for survival..

[@benitaponciano412]

POGO with CHINESE pouring in IS NOT INVASION?

[@suarezvincentj.6519]

Why do we invade our country?

[@richieheins6825]

Merisi! Tagam! Feeling alam na ang lahat

[@tammytamtams2674]

Instead of ROTC, bakit hindi na lang palaguin ang Science, Math, extracurricular activities like sports at something related sa environment. Magkaroon tayo ng marami pang EJ Obiena sa pole-vault, sa tennis Alex Eala. Yung ROTC kase maraming ways para ma-abuse ang isang estudyante. Mas magandang palawakin ang pagkaintindi sa kasaysayan, linangin ang kaisipan at maging Critical Thinkers na members ng society. Para magkaroon naman tayo ng mga specialists.

[@marcelinamaraasin7281]

I am 62.....1977 I was 3rd YEAR HIGH SCHOOL..and gone thru CAT....we enjoy our cat training days I WAS a platoon LEADER....this group of people against the ROTC...dahil takot sila wala ng ma recruit ng NPA🤣

[@howyadoin3535]

Bato, hindi lang ang pag serbisyo sa PNP at AFP ang paraan para magpakita ng pagmamahal sa ating bansa.

[@arjonbetaaphio1682]

Parang ROTC naman pinag uusapan sa clip na to? Pano napasok yung PNP at AFP?

[@IamGreya]

@@arjonbetaaphio1682 kaya naka drugs siguro sya! Parang yong batang kausap sa hearing ang layo ng sagot.

[@charlesnoelvillanueva13]

Sa panong paraan ka magpapakita ng pagmamahal?magpapabebe ka habang may giyera?

[@JonathanSalazar-cn6zq]

Akala ko bato laman ng ulo neto bato pala talaga. Wala ka talaga bato de la rosie.

[@berniesantiagodo7762]

Agree ako na maibalik ang ROTC at pati narin ang CAT sana maibalik nadin para magkaroon ng disiplina ang mga kabataan ngayon. At matuto silang mahalin ang atin bansa at wag labanan ang gobyerno natin.

[@glendadio9977]

That's an opportunity to ask why not answer it properly??

[@eugene65yo49]

In Taiwan all males are required to military training for two years and they received allowances and free meals and lodging inside the military camp

[@MP-pi3mj]

In Taiwan, their people really need to have military training because of the threat to their security in their country..It has been a long time plan of China that they will subjugate Taiwan as part of their country but the Taiwanese govn't does not agree with the plan.

[@rolandoalfechejr.4476]

I love ROTC

[@florantemore360]

ROTC is good but not enough. Why not have a state-funded 6-month military training in army/marine/naval boot camps for all able-bodied 18-year old Filipino men and women plus 1 year service prior return to civilian life. With this, our AFP can have a ready competent personnel reserves for either limited local or unlimited mobilization in the event of a national security threat - just like what the small Israel has been doing since it became a state in 1948.

[@angelitoastejada7337]

I am the one of product of CAT during my highschool time,even I am a member of pwd..I'm proud that I survive CAT that time..

[@henecia_azonkim9104]

I myself an officer of CAT during my high school.. and I’m proud of it ❤️👏👏👏👏👏

[@sadik1588]

Bakit c bato noon binubully tayo ng China wala Syang kibo noon binangga ng China barks ng mangingisda maynagawaba sya Salado bibig nyan

[@junbaldoza5667]

@@henecia_azonkim9104 CAT really changed my perspective.....one thing it gave is DISCIPLINE.....and this virtue helped me a lot in my student life ....and even until now in my work even here in the US!

[@ronnief4]

totoo naman kasi na need ng rotc ng student its also part/ option to recruit students as soldier or police.. kesa sa marecruit sila sa NPA diba?

[@charlenepedring9702]

tama para madisiplina na rin ang mga kabataan

[@dorkyderpterio8649]

Or y'know, instead of military based discipline why not advocate for community building and letting students be disciplined through community service or acts of service? Wouldn't that curve the NPA recruitment better since it benefits the youth and the people?

[@ronnief4]

yes sir you are correct but this can be done while rotc is also mandatory. Ano po ba ang reason bakit ayaw ng rotc?

[@timothyyy9789]

@@ronnief4 Nagiging source of corruption, impunity and abuse? and hindi nationalism and patriotism ang blind obidience.

[@sisyphusmike8488]

Discipline, integrity and patriotism the corner stone of being a citizen of the state the sole purpose of ROTC...

[@seimichaelmotocartips3052]

Paano d ma re recruite ng mga ulupong nila miyembro

[@Charlie-fk4ly]

Why should I learn to fight for a state when I'm just gonna leave the place anyway? If they want us to be patriotic then they could start by making our lives better, not force us into a program that would only increase our already heavy educational duties.

[@noyou427]

​@@Charlie-fk4ly don't bother asking for that as they'll just leave you with some nonsense fuckery

[@hindimoalam2322]

Education? Heavy ? Come on , you don't know what ur saying

[@kid_wanderer]

@@Charlie-fk4ly YOU NAILED IT!!!

[@chonaduremdes9733]

I like very much about the Hearing today,I enjoy Watching Trice

[@erniepingol4409]

Bkit naging senador yan

[@mrv8960]

May mali ba na maging senador siya??

[@genebadon1866]

@Lyrical Mood mali rin na nagComment ka dito. tatlong senador(Dela Rosa, Gatchalian, Cayetano) na ang nagsasabi na irrelevant yung punto nya(Manuel)... WALA SA HULOG!

[@mengqing1449]

TBH i don't see any problem with ROTC in fact during my time in highschool students were looking forward to join ROTC. And then this so called student leader came into the hearing of "MANDATORY ROTC" I don't know why he/she brought up other stuff in this hearing.

[@juansonbaysen9102]

I am a reserve rotc grad..dati nagdropout ako niyan dahil sa wala akong hilig mag uniporme..buti na lang nakiusap ang erpat ko sa school rotc commandant para ituloy kundi ay nadraft ako bilang isang trainee for 18 mos sa fort bonifacio..baka kung nagkagayon at isa ako sa nadeploy sa mindanao ay baka sa kabilang buhay ako nanonood ng mainit nyong debate...

[@mengqing1449]

@@juansonbaysen9102 You don't understand, He's in the senate to discuss MANDATORY ROTC, He shouldn't have brought up other proposal that does not include or does not have anything to do with Mandatory ROTC.

[@mengqing1449]

@@juansonbaysen9102 In your case, I don't understand why you guys hate wearing a uniform, you'll only be wearing it during your ROTC Duty during the day. Also, about dropping out on ROTC they won't draft you just because you drop out, because my cousin also dropped out and nothing happened to him so stop telling lies.

[@dominadorlabayug2380]

@@juansonbaysen9102 paano ka nakagraduate ng Reserve ROTC kung wala kang hilig mag oniporme , saka di naman lahat ng pupunta ng mindanao mamamatay, saka kung namatay ka doon isa kang bayani, pero paano kung namatay ka sa bundok dahil sa pakikipaglaban sa gubyerno tingin ko yun ang nakakapanghinayang.

[@salviotolentino5316]

Pero mas maganda siguro kung mandatory military service na May compensation and benefits like other military personnel/officer. Kawawa nga mga reservist, masyadong discriminated ... Parang saling pusa lang sa formation. Ang daming draftee & out of school na pwede rin nilang tawagin to undergo military service and training ... Marami rin graduates ... Just like in US, Korea, Singapore and many other. Wala sa school. nasa military training camp. May suweldo at benepisyo ... Ang laki-laki ng pondo ng military at pnp.

[@adurableee]

"wala kaming pakialam sa'yo" hahahahahaha. coming from some who should serve this country. "senador ako", pero hindi ka diyos. "mas nakakatanda ako sa'yo" so dapat laging tama ka. these senators could just stop Manuel and say his arguments are irrelevant to the topic. haysss. our senate... mahal ang bansa pero hindi ang mga tao. 🫠

[@ysaganiybarra6661]

Kudos to Mr. Manuel for admitting he was out of line.

[@sersoisoimedia8494]

Give the student an option. If they want ROTC, The Literacy Training Service; and The Civil Welfare Training Service. Natatawa ako na aatakihin tayo ng China where in fact ang tatay niya ay kaibigan ng China. Anu ba talaga Senator Bato? Kaaway ba natin ang China or Kaibigan? Anu ba talaga ang purpose ng ROTC? Para ba talaga makipag gyera sa China?

[@jericosarmiento4140]

China lang ba? Ang kalaban dami jan sangayon ako sa sinabi mo na bigyan na lang ng option

[@boogeyman9973]

It should not be an option. It is out duty to the nation. Thats why we are left behind by other countries as we neglect, forget and do not recognize what made us strong in the first place. OUT NATIONALISM.

[@brianb2208]

ang mga opaa nyo nga mandatory pero rotc lang iyak2 na kayo. Tsee

[@dimalantadarryl9619]

@@boogeyman9973 tama ka kapatid. yung ibang kabataan kasi mas gusto mag rally nalang kesa magsilbi sa bayan..

[@johnbryantolosa]

Isa ka dn sa mga mahihina ang pngUnawa at mkitid ang utak, it's just an example. Makahanap ka dn ng ibubutas e.

[@jcs6954]

Sayang ang pera ng bayan dyan sa mga yan..tanggalin na kasi yang partylist na yan..

[@joeaby71]

Good arguments, it brings out the best among them.

[@bongcalugas3544]

Ang kabutihan asal ay unang natututunan sa sarili nating mga magulang at tahanan,,,ang pangalawang lugar na ito ay natututunan sa ating mga paaralan ang nakakalungkot lang sa ilan nating mga paaralan kung saan dito ginagamit ng makakakaliwa ang kanilang pagtuturo ng idelohiya kung saan ito ay sumisira sa kaisipan ng ating mga anak at maraming kabataan.

[@elmop76]

Ang paaralan ay may academic freedom at ang usaping hinuhubog ang mga estudyante upang maging makakaliwa ay argumento ng mga .mang mang.,saan kayu nakakakita ng paaralang may subject ng Bachelor in bla bla major in leftist,NPA,CPP,NDF?kung ang lahat ng Pilipino nag iisip na ang rebellion at pagka terrorist ay natutunan sa school pwes huwag na tayong mag aral, kasi mga mang mang na tayong lahat,kawawa at nakakahiya sa ating mga matatalinong mg bayani na namatay para ipagtanggol ang bayan o Republika ng mga mang mang

[@renewed5670]

And the best example in this video is Raoul Manuel. Strongly indoctrinated. Talks gently but spews venom and rubbish. A victim of deception but now enslaved to attract more victims. And he sits in Congress. What a danger to our Motherland.

[@alfonsoeslawan8899]

Napahiya tuloy buti nalang suri kaagad

[@robertnoble7554]

We all hated ROTC growing up, don't you guys be a hypocrite, dahil lng naka graduate na tayo kinalimutan nyo experiences nyo sa ROTC! Im proROTC by the way, it's a means of safeguarding our country.

[@boogeyman9973]

Totoo sinabi mo noong nakasalang tayo sa ROTC. Ayaw ntin mabilad sa init. Pero masaya, naturuan tayo sumunod, makisama at makipagkapwa. Kahit mga gagong gaya ko. Sunod d umubra yabang ko. We only get to appreciate it nung makagraduate and maapply ilang bagay na natutunan sa ROTC in real life.

[@jestonyjuliano6638]

Mga Bastos at tamad na kasi ang mga kabataan ngayon!

[@robertnoble7554]

@@jestonyjuliano6638 Entitled na mga kabataan, ayaw maghirap pero gusto lahat ng pribilehiyo.

[@faizzhen755]

KAW LANG ANG AYAW , KAYA MADAMING BASTOS NA KABATAAN NGAYON EH

[@conradorepel1664]

@@robertnoble7554 nauso kasi sa pinas yang magreklamo kahit wala naman dapat ipagreklamo. Taenang mga bata yan dapat yan di pinapaaral ng mga magulang e

[@jorgevillanueva3719]

It appears that the people in charge of the meeting is bending over to accommodate Sen. Bato. It's almost like it's Sen. Bato's group against one student leader. That's a sham meeting with these people scared or groveling over the senator. The student leader is not allowed to defend his side while Sen. Bato is permitted to repeat his statements over and over again.

[@mariejohnson1891]

I believed it is the politicians mostly who need to have discipline . ROTC is not relevant to character building in relation to what the politicians and those in the police and military are showing today. Corruptions, EJK and riding in tandem, red tagging, abuse of authority and human rights violations.

[@saltNpepper952]

But its not like they will listen to us if we tell that to them won't they? They'll yell at us and go back to their usual arguement that kids need discipline. They all believe that because they are the authority and the adults they need to be followed. Politicians and police are public servants, they should be the ones serving their people and not the other way around. At this point it's so hard to love this country already.

[@Estilo766]

Ang taas nga ng respeto namin noon sa mga senior sa ROTC sa school dati.

[@suarezvincentj.6519]

Dati lang yun

[@yasouedit2432]

@@suarezvincentj.6519 Wala siguro tung respeto hahahaha

[@dobo1216]

Love your country...hahaha prng c hudas LNG din humalik ky jesus pro bininta na pla nya..yan din ngyari I love may country pro binigay na sa china yun mga island hahahaha

[@ruthlosariamokamad8400]

You asked the liberals who initiated the moves in selling Kasi that was a pass on problem of the previous liberal admin

[@salviotolentino5316]

Namumuwersa na naman sa malayang talakayan ...

[@eduardomarcelino5621]

Bakit kaya di pa Ipakulong yang si manuel

[@kyzerfernando4920]

He thought he did something.

[@norlinemariano5640]

he didn't tbh :))

[@flavianoaguanta2694]

During my time, year 1963-65, I took ROTC and finished my cadet officer course..I was a platoon leader and one of my achievement is to instill discipline on my men, respect them and in return I reaped the fruit after the graduation. When we had a reunion and chatted I learned that they became responsible citizens and successful in their profession...

[@cruzaldelouis6272]

Sana may mag sulong nang batas na kasuhan yang mga bastos na Yan..

[@gapyow8599]

Never had any regrets taking NROTC during college (CAT was stopped during my elem days).

[@regiefelarocena6481]

Walang mapapala sa pakiki pag usap sa mga sinungaling

[@MinimiMini510]

So sad of youngster today , I have done ROTC and it was great experience nothing wrong at all. Really cool and hard training it shows we can help our country in case of war. Children are No Respect at all they have so much Freedom They take the freedom for granted now

[@ekylediaz9822]

I have taken my 2 yr ROTC training and I think the experience is right. There is one thing that was wanting in our training. We didn't have the needed equipment for the training. We had the obsolete Springfield rifles used on our training. It was only before what they call tactical inspection that we were shown how ti dismantle some guns like Carbine, Thompson and Garand. We were shown how to operate a Mortar, (all make believe actions), with all the theories supplied. I believe including ROTC in college is good But be sure, the AFP personnel in charge of the training are competent enough and there must be sufficient equipment and training materials for the training. Moreover, the officials in charge of training should not be arrogant as what we have had during our ROTC days.

[@salviotolentino5316]

Ako din ... Pero mas maganda siguro kung mandatory military service na May compensation and benefits like other military personnel/officer. Kawawa nga mga reservist, masyadong discriminated ... Parang saling pusa lang sa formation. Ang daming draftee & out of school na pwede rin nilang tawagin to undergo military service and training ... Marami rin graduates ... Just like in US, Korea, Singapore and many other. Wala sa school. nasa military training camp. May suweldo at benepisyo ... Ang laki-laki ng pondo ng military at pnp.

[@shairasophia9206]

Gusto ko yang prangka c Bato

[@AeHbkuZztV]

related lang sa pinag uusapan ang dapat pag usapan.

[@samobedicen8070]

sa gobyerno sa senado patapangan nlng pag nasa posisyon,

[@vrinceharold1942]

Mabuhay ang Kabataan Partylist Mabuhay ang Kabataang Makabayan!

[@djganata2952]

HOW DARE THIS "STUDENT LEADER" SAY THE AFP DOESN'T SHOW INTENT IN PRESERVING NATIONAL SOVEREIGNTY?! MANY SOLDIERS DIED SERVING OUR NATION, AND MANY MORE RISKING THEIR LIVES FOR THE SAME REASON. THIS IS COMPLETE DISRESPECT TO THE AFP. STUDENTS BADLY NEED CONTEXTUALIZED EDUCATION AND SOME DISCIPLINE; WHICH BRINGS THE TOPIC OF MANDATORY ROTC RELEVANT.

[@junbaldoza5667]

that's very true....siya kaya ang ipauna or mag-solve ng very complex situation sa security! ang yabang nitong bata na ito

[@domedino3916]

ROTC hindi na Dapat ibalik paano Kong Meron na namang Mamatay.dagdag Pahirap lng yan.

[@ediwow2823]

Bakit ganun?Di sila umaangal sa mga narerecruit sa bundok para pumatay at magutom. Di naman mas mahirapa ang ROTC at CAT.

[@francinelieto8899]

This period of history is different, many civil wars and unrest is happening simultaneously. ROTC is a preparation of unexpected if ever a war will happen near or inside the country. Even South Korea have mandatory military service. It is important to be prepared as discipline may lessen casualties if war happened.

[@francinelieto8899]

Just this year, there was a reported recruitment of Hamas happening in Mindanao. Don't Filipinos think that being prepared is important?

[@denciolombos2510]

Oo nga.. kahit nga mga celebrities dun kusang sumasabak sa military training lalo pa border lang pagitan nila sa north korea

[@elmop76]

Ayaw nga lumaban ng AFP at PNP sa China ROTC pa?what a foolish argument.,ang ROTC paraan lang iyan para ma justify ni Sara Pot pot ang malaking funds kuno para ma justify ang legal corruption.,aminin...

[@salviotolentino5316]

Mas maganda siguro kung mandatory military service. May compensation and benefits like other military personnel/officer. Kawawa nga mga reservist, masyadong discriminated ... Parang saling pusa lang sa formation. Ang daming draftee & out of school na pwede rin nilang tawagin to undergo military service and training ... Just like in US, Korea, Singapore and many other. Wala sa school. nasa military training camp. May suweldo at benepisyo ... Ang laki-laki ng pondo ng military at pnp.

[@Mus-salOmar]

"Ang tibay mo bata" iiyak na nga yan, halatang pikon. Pinaiyak ng 1st nominee Raoul Manuel😂

[@jackspicer455]

Kagagong pag iisip mong yan🙄.

[@isaiahjohntualla5192]

@@jackspicer455 edi wow

[@jackspicer455]

@@isaiahjohntualla5192 hahahaha

[@JohnnySins-zf4fb]

- sabi ng miyembro ng kabataang makabayan

[@IamGreya]

Eh di wow! porke ganun ang tone

[@edgaryap8641]

Yes...

[@reynaldomacabenta4506]

nasa pag papalaki ng magulang o gurdian yan at nasa sarili mo yan... kahit may rotc o nstp pa ang samahan mo kung ikaw mismo...wala kang disiplina sa sarili mo...marami nga dyan mga opisyal ng pamahalaan..mga tiwali...

[@fernandomaligaya6875]

It's not disiplina lang Ang nakapaloob sa ROTC. About sa awareness how we defend our country. About survival pag may mga di inaasahang mangyayari.

[@saltNpepper952]

Natatawa naman ako dito. Senator is loosing his cool while the student leader keeps calm. Student made a mistake sure but it became a lecture instead of a hearing, who's wasting time now? Student leader was still in the topic by the way, he simply mentioned Sanchez to prove a point. Also, in a debate setting senators would be noted on using fallacy arguments already. Nag aral ba talaga tong mga senator natin? I'm loosing hope in the future of this country if the adults seem this dumb and prideful. You want the kids of this generation to listen to you? Listen to them first and understand why they are so frustrated about the state of your country. Also, as someone who's taking ROTC in college myself, ROTC isn't a bad thing for as long as the government ensures that there is no hazing and abuse. But as of now I don't think the government is even that adept to implement such program with a proper system. Fix the important issues first, like education, transportation, inflation, etc. Then only then maybe ROTC can be implemented once more. I can assure you that ROTC isn't for everyone at all because we all want to serve our country differently. It's a different time now compared to your time in the past, please stick with the call of the times and stop trying to wind us all back into our history.

[@colonelsnoopy805]

Ikaw nah

[@jielcm2726]

I never had ROTC only ended up with NSTP but I know such curriculum will shape youth as better citizen and love for thy country. Good thing about NSTP I was part of Gawad Kalinga projies and think I might have built 2 houses for the less fortunates before such emotional moment for me when I saw the family moving in.. And for the argument sake I am taking side of Bato in this one, that young fella doesnt know what representation he's doing clearly show's all youth right now are well off living social media status no sense of civility and responsibilities for our nation.. just my 2 cents

[@boogeyman9973]

Tama ka jiel.NSTP was more of linis linis lang ng community, ROTC gives you pride specially pagsuot mo ung uniporme. Disiplina kahit baril n kahoy lang ang hawak. Pagkakapantay pantay, noon iisa lang gupit ng lahat, dahil gusto ipabatid sa amin n hindi ito tungko sayo, kundi sa pagkakaisa ng lahat. Iisang kumpas, iisang utos, sabay sabay na paggalaw.

[@Raymund38TVM]

Kailangan talaga ang ROTC Mandatory sa college, at Mandatory din dapat ang CAT sa High School, dagdag pahirap sa students oo pero yung desiplinang makukuha nila dun maiaapply nila once they are graduated, unang una respect the persons na may mataas ang katayuan sayo specially police, military, teacher, attorney, etc that having a professional degree holders and passing a license, nangyyre kasi ngayon kahit graduated na at may license na ang isang professional na tao wala pa din silang alam when it comes disciplines, kaya ang ngyyre pataasan ng pride bawat professional kasi nga nong umpisa palang hindi na sila na desiplina, pero kung magiging mandatory ang CAT at ROTC magkakaron ng desiplina ang bawat estudyante bukod jan maggng reservist sila lahat when he/she finish rotc trainings, tipong dapat hindi sila makakagraduate ng wala silang CAT at ROTC dapat implimented yan hindi lang para sa may gusto dapat lahat, not issue yung may sakit o mahina katawan di yun excuses kasi pwede naman gumawa ng rules para dun at anong gagawin sa ganong persons like hanapan nila ng medical certificate na nagpapatunay na hindi nila kaya yung trainings at gagawa sila ng letters para sa students para mgng exempted yung CAT at ROTC sa mga kabataang may sakit o may desability yun lang yung dapat exempted yung mga normal hindi dapat exempted.

[@bethmatias6528]

Polokololll LL l

[@nirvash241]

if Bato is the definition of a responsible citizen then wag na "sarap buhayyyyyyyyyyyyy" wala nmn saysay din pinagsasabi nila rito dinaan lang sa DRAMA at IYAKAN para kaawan sya ng tao

[@lizmendoza6662]

Pls stop recruiting students. You do not represent the thinking of majority of the youth. Iisa lang ang goal nila ang ibagsak ang govt at sila ang magtake over. Hulihin na yan.Walang laman utak nyang si raul na yan. YES TO ROTC.NO TO NPA RECRUITMENT!!!!

[@FelipeLopez-tz5go]

Sir Raul mag ROTC being Kung. Ikaw ay Pilipino mag serbisiyo ka Bayang Pilipino .

[@marwinp.collado6057]

For discipline purposes yan at malaking bagay sa buhay Ng isang tao na magiging disiplinado at magiging maayos Ang utak

[@watchjikjinbytreasure8076]

naoffend ata sa example ng student representative. also, patapusin muna daw si sen bato bago magsalita yung representative pero kapag yung representative yung nagsalita ayos lang na bigla biglang sasabat si sen bato? lol, equality where? and also, respect what? pero nasigaw si sen bato?????????

[@peacebewithyou1989]

boomer momints

[@aldrietiktokvideo4805]

Out of context😂

[@TheZephile]

Out of context, irrelevant opinion. Frfr trash this comment.

[@rivershen677]

Fatherless behavior

[@lorieannetejada2885]

Know your place

[@eddames9839]

This composed student leader acted and sounded more honorable and respectable than the hysterical Bato in this hearing.

[@U-May07]

It's all about the frustration, of the hypocrisy of these Terrorists.

[@jaizernadal]

Composed but kulang sa research. May point din na if may death penalty, sana di na pardoned si Sanchez 🤷 Pero no to ROTC parin lol

[@WosesoM]

It is all but empty words. Bato's was from the heart and with reason

[@deniceapalisok4329]

Agree po ako sa CAT at ROTC, malaki po naituro sa akin, gamit na gamit sa everyday life kahit ganito na ako katanda.

[@grazeldekina9639]

Isa ako sa welling ibalik ang ROTC PARa sa deciplina ng mga kabataan,isa ako nakaranas Rotc ang saya😀😀 ibalik ang yan💪💪💪

[@alco7117]

Bato fail to understand that ROTC will not develop the discipline that this country needs. Kasi kahit Generals na iba walang disiplina, kahit si Bato mismo ay walang disiplina. Basurang Bato Ang bilis niyang mag react sa sinabi ng studyante, tangina na offend ka don? You went ballistic on how supposedly irrelevant his statement was instead of proving him wrong. You are a senator, you can defend yourself. Nag tataas ka pa ng boses “ganito pala ang studyante ngayon? Walang desiplina, kayang sagutin ang isang senador”, sir for your info, kahit sino po pede kang sagutin kung tingin nila mali ang sinasabi mo. You’re just a senator, we’re the people.

[@akbariadzhar5535]

Narinig muba sinasabi mo..wala nga sa hulog ang comment..mismo SI Mr chairman nagsabi walang respito..NPA ka ata.kong wala dsplina diyan mging general.muka mo🤞🤞🤞

[@alco7117]

@@akbariadzhar5535 ​ @Akbari Adzhar Naririnig ko sinasabi ko, ikaw ang di ma gets kung ano sinasabi mo. Ang tunay na disiplina nag sisimula sa tahanan, sa tamang pag papalaki ng magulang. Ang disiplinang binubuo ng ROTC ay galing sa takot, kaya hindi yan matibay. "NPA ka ata" pwe. Yan nalang ba alam niyong sabihin? Pag wala kang argument na matino yan nalang sinasabi mo. Kasing tanga mo at ni bato ang mga NPA sa bundok. Ang alam lang na sagot sa problema ay dahas, gyera at pag patay.

[@akbariadzhar5535]

Anak ka Ng nanay mo...baka ikaw untogin ko..oo alam ko Kasi pinalaki Ako Ng maayos Ng mga magulang ko...kita nalang Tayo wagka puro dada jan.wala kanamn natulong sa olipunan..nkita mulang Mali ni sir bato..saka sya pa nga ngdsplina...

[@alco7117]

@@akbariadzhar5535 Isa ang buwis ko sa bumubuhay sa bansa, madami din akong volunteer works. Diko alam sayo, pero malinis konsensya ko sa pagtulong sa lipunan. At narinig mo din ba sarili mo? Parang gusto mo kung patayin ah. Yan ang pagkakaparehas niyo ni Bato at ng NPA, agad kayong nag reresort sa violence. Galit kayo sa mga pagpatay ng NPA, pero kayo din tong gustong pumatay. Double standard ipokrito. Pwe.

[@treechada8196]

Bakit tinataasan ni bato boses niya? Triggered sya? This is a formal conversation. A senator should remained calmed and poised.

[@SphyxGreifing]

Did you watch the video? Did you understand it? Bato was calm before hand pero siya tinira specifically ng student which is also irrelevant to the topic at hand. Wouldn’t you get triggered too? Why did the student act in an informal way? I agree it should be a formal conversation kaso the student acted unprofessionally. He got the an unprofessional response.

[@JanJan-cu7kw]

Treechada cguro dika makabasag ng pinggan, o kaya dikapa napagalitan ng magulang, Dahil cguro mabuti Kang anak, o kaya masunorin sa magulang, pero Kong ikaw naman nagkamali sa iyong magulang di ka ba napapagalitan kahit isa manlang? O kaya kapg pinapagalitan Ang Isang anak Dahil sa pagkakamali diba tumataas Ang bosis ng magulang? Siguro Kong dika nakaranas nito, dmo maiintindihan Ang sinasabi ni senator bato. Nagkamali Ang student leader kaya nga Siya humingi ng paumanhin. O kaya Kong ikaw man ay may anak na kapag nagkamali Ang iyong anak dmo ba sya tataasan ng bosis? Kong Hindi mabuti Ang pagpaplaki mo sa iyong anak, pero Kong taliwas naman maiintindihan mo Ang ginawa ni sinator bato, formal hearing dapat formal din Ang gagawin ng studyante

[@treechada8196]

@@JanJan-cu7kw pero their both in a professional meeting. Tsaka Di naman sya anak ni bato para pag taasan ni bato ng boses. This has nothing to do about being the older one correcting the younger one. The older one which is bato literally acted far from his age. His a crybaby. His tone should remain low cause this is a formal conversation.

[@lymarabello3768]

I mean why not. I remember the Late Senator Miriam Santiago also raises her voice when she is having her point. l mean all can express their emotions freely as long as you're not violating the senate rules.

[@lymarabello3768]

First, the word "triggered" is slang therefore it is informal and it is also not objective. It depends on the person who is perceiving an emotion by another individual so the word "triggered" is subjective. Second, I can't recognize that only Senator Bato is being "triggered" in the video. The student, in the first place, made a passive aggressive which is an indirect insult from a person getting offended or hurt. In short, the student is also "triggered" and he is the first one to be "triggered".

[@rosalindaayad3673]

YES NICE TO HEAR IBALIK ANG ROTC . " BE PREPARED " LAGING HANDA . WHAT EVER HAPPEN WE R PREPARED .

[@florquiling6746]

The The BEST AOTC AND CAT STUDENT SCHOOL IN COLLEGE GOOD JOB SER SENADOR BATO GOD BLESS YOU SER

[@teodoroagulto1879]

Those who doesn’t want to attend ROTC instructions, so be it. Don’t let them attend then drop them from the roster of active cadets then declare them evaders and require them to undergo trainee instructions. During our high school days we have PMT 3 we are the last bacth then we are the first batch of CAT and the last batch of ROTC then it became CMT. We never complained of anything because we know it is our prime duties as citizens of the Philippines to at least prepare our youths not just in times of war but also during disasters and calamities. In fact, in Israel, it is not just ROTC but real Military training to both male and female abled citizens. The only people I know who are against it are the leftest/communist because they want the youth to be trained as cadres and let them fight against our soldiers.

[@doloreslaigo6774]

pahiya c raoulo

[@salviotolentino5316]

Mas maganda siguro kung mandatory military service. May compensation and benefits like other military personnel/officer. Kawawa nga mga reservist, masyadong discriminated ... Parang saling pusa lang sa formation. Ang daming draftee & out of school na pwede rin nilang tawagin to undergo military service and training ... Just like in US, Korea, Singapore and many other. Wala sa school. nasa military training camp. May suweldo at benepisyo ... Ang laki-laki ng pondo ng military at pnp.

[@teodoroagulto1879]

@@salviotolentino5316 Ang trainee instructions Salvio may sueldo ina for the duration of the training. That is for the period of 6 months equivalent to 2 years basic ROTC training.

[@rianarilla9420]

exactly super duper agree with you..

[@patrickd.3553]

We have voluntary ROTC. If students don't want it, the can choose NSTP.

[@rulebreaker9930]

I was a platoon leader when i was highschool and had taken an advanced rotc course. This course helps me discipline a lot inside and outside of our country. Enjoyable also hahaha

[@junorongan360]

ROTC, PAANO UNG MAHINA ANG KATAWAN, MAHILUHIN,BIGLANG MATUMBA, HOLOG UN, PAKTAY UN, SA AMINGANON

[@boydiskartingvlogs]

Tanggalin yan mapanira sa sariling Bayan

[@marionilobaltazar7031]

Mabuhay ka sir bato.......go go go ROTC

[@ronaldlaput1990]

I was a Battalion Commander during CAT,,, I graduated my college passing the ROTC...

[@reyjoeyquilloy5411]

So sa UP summer camp

[@davidlucas5017]

I’ve done CAT when I was in high school that’s was in the 90,S us well in ROTC when I was in college because it’s a mandatory you can’t graduate if you don’t finish that course…but I love it even though it’s really hard n though but I sudgest they should bring it back

[@aidaellenberger4150]

.

[@ricardoagpalo3802]

SALAMAT KAY LORD MAY BATO TAYO

[@werdxua1989]

Dapat ibalik ang rotc para mabawasan yang mga npa sa school.....

[@fushiguro9200]

Ano connect

[@gaspargrejarte3685]

dapat mandatory rotc both private and public

[@patrickd.3553]

dapat voluntary, hayaan na yung mga may gusto na lang ang mag enroll.

[@nrem7611]

@@patrickd.3553 true, para di sapilitan