BBC HARDtalk on location in Manila - Cardinal LUIS ANTONIO TAGLE

Stephen Sackur interviews Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle in Manila.
11 March 2015.
producer / director: Ian O'Reilly.
Lighting, camera & sound: Justin Mills.
This material is BBC copyright, it has been uploaded to KZbin for the benefit of contributors and other interested parties.

[@ronneliangarcia7301]

Tagle and Sackur are speaking from two different perspectives, to which once could not simply and readily agree upon. i agree that the Cardinal has some lapses in his way of answering. i also agree that Sackur brings to the fore some important and well-grounded realities that must be faced by the Catholic Church and the hierarchy. the beauty of this interview, however, does not come from one-sided sentiments. rather, this interview tickles and wakes the mind of people up in relation to the sensitive but nevertheless necessary issues.

[@chrisbernal5164]

You are precisely correct there. It is like looking at honesty under a microscope. Sackur is the microscope, and Tagle is honesty. At best, it is an illustration of intellectual exercise.

[@Luminosity94]

But people dont undertand your comment. 😔 i hope they do instead of thinking they know better than both of them.

[@jonsnow-nk8th]

WELL DONE Stephen Sackur! Once Again you have proven to us that you are not a Bias Media Outlet like what we have here in the Philippines.Very Well Researched! Nicely Done!

[@blacketer3]

I am half English, and half Filipino. I am definitely more English and far more westernised since I was raised the UK; but that would never be the way I'd choose to act to a cardinal. Clearly the interviewer said himself that there is no provision to law or divorce, but there is also the ability to annul a marriage, and things that are both lawful both of the land and in the eyes of God. This revealed one of the typical stereotypes to being British, snobby and stuck up. Unfortunately it went overboard on this interview without concern to the culture of the Philippines; two very culturally different countries.

[@realleoputong]

The wisdom of men does not improved the condition of life especially for the poor peace is still very illusive even to the rich and powerful proving the observation of great American President Thomas Jefferson that if the world will be ruled by the teaching of Jesus Christ and apply those teachings in their way of life the world will live harmoniously and love will be the main binding force and peace will be enjoyed by all inhabitants in this world.

[@msbamarivic3729]

Very rude interviewer Has no right to insinuate his views or his beliefs

[@msbamarivic3729]

Is this the kind of "successful" media personalities we have right now?

[@summabiotech9586]

science and common sense does not pay tribute to culture

[@ramonjosegarcia8812]

Stephen seemed shocked by some of the answers.

[@jesuscastanares4968]

Please, obey the Church moral norms: FEAR THE LORD ! PRAY TO THE BLESSED MOTHER! No divorce ( be kind to each other; don't injure or abuse; don't spend money for gambling nor for drinking. Try to improve or repair home) No contraception ( observe only calendar days) No abortion ( anytime) No trafficking! No drugs! Find jobs for the young and for neighbors ( help each other to find job and to keep it) Help your parents and family.

[@virginiaperkins5981]

That is the best interview ever. Thank you Jesus for Cardinal Tagle.

[@dhyowiify]

Cardinal Tagle is just echoing the stance of the Roman Catholic Church when it comes to abortion, divorce, contraception and marriage. He is just being consistent with Jesus Christ's teaching.

[@maemorales9376]

😂😝😂😂😂😂

[@joelobe187]

tagle is a NOTORIOUS jorge bergoglian satanic baphomatic ilk.

[@cherirose4463]

Mr. O’Reilly, The church is not the only one that’s rich. THE PHILIPPINES IS RICH That’s why the western world won’t leave us alone!

[@archie2473]

This topic is will go on and on and on and on and even our lifetime is not enough. Never the less, we are gifted with Intellect and Free Will, we're entitled with our opinion as part of the "Free Will"; however our opinion must not be destructive with the people and community we're living with. We don't know these people personaly nor we never live with them under one roof for us to conclude about who they are and what they do. I think it's better to improve our selves positively as a contribution to our selves, Family, Friends and community.

[@MichaelPhilipMaunes]

A nice interview with Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, former archbishop of Manila and now working with the Roman Curia with Pope Francis in the Vatican. He is also fluent in Tagalog, English, and Italian.

[@sachier3414]

removing a clergy from their service is not enough for Justice to be achieved. But the case is priests are always not held accountable.

[@federicoeveza9656]

Nice to see your interview with a Filipino Cardinal all the way in Manila . Thanks for the interview

[@jjal6209]

the host of the segment hard talk truly a real hard talk host because the questions he ask to the cardinal are really hard and it makes the cardinal squeeze his mind specially on some important matter

[@fauxmanchu8094]

jj Al Because the cardinal is not so bright and it shows in the way he answers. He really does not know how to answer the interviewer!

[@nac2k9]

I think you need God in your life... God bless your soul...

[@donmichael512]

He is a straw man (the interviewer) who is willing to offend the cardinal. A journalist who represent the left at best. He was not asking question to get an answer but he already made a judgment call. His goal was to uphold his polemic nuances to portray the church as an insensitive church and make a claim that it was out of touch of the realities faced by the poor community. You are journalist so I assumed you have not done charity work. Maybe you're the one out of touch of what you have assumed.

[@mariatagalog2180]

@@donmichael512 cardinal Tagle was excellent answering all his questions and the interviewer could not say anymore comment at the end.

[@ferdiedeleon5145]

@@fauxmanchu8094 I think you did not listen carefully to what the cardinal is saying. He maybe smiling, and may have stuttering voice, but he answered the questions, .. The interviewer intended to be sort of intimidating when asking the cardinal. Cardinal is soft spoken and the way he talks is very light.

[@peterlukecabusao6166]

Cardinal was the Archbishop of Manila when this interview is held

[@avatarroku7955]

So the Catholic Church is to be blamed for the social issues of the country? I think the interviewer should direct those misleading questions to the Philippine Government, not the church. And to people saying Cardinal Tagle is stupid, evil or whatever. Wash your mouth and try to make a research. This priest is extremely brilliant.

[@dud898]

someone else no brilliance seen in this interview. On the contrary.

[@608assassin9]

What is your source of information saying "natural family planning doesn't work"?

[@jescruz5465]

Yes, it doesnt work based on human behavior and impulses

[@hapdane5938]

@@jescruz5465 Billings method has a failure rate that goes from 0% to 2.9%. If you can't resist to take your pants off is not a failure of the method. You know, responsability, being an adult, all these stuff.

[@jescruz5465]

@@hapdane5938 Idealism and all for the greater good but we're talking about people who don't care if they have a dozen children or more, while enjoying their unemployment and gin. Scientific studies concluded Natural "Family Planning" has a high failure rate due to the possibility of conception from pre-ejaculation fluid released during intercourse.

[@user-zs7nj1ys4c]

I love watching Cardinal Tagle his masses his interviews his speeches even till 3Am with no sleeping. By the time of 6Am of our zoom Praying every weekdays sometimes I m late ⏰ even with alarm clock 😂Praise God Allelluia.You’re in our Prayers for good health & long happy life & be our next Pope.Amen

[@ririyuri7290]

Sachurs reaction to Tagles “the victim might also be shamed” at 19:00 Priceless

[@biensantos1132]

The smile of Tagle every after statement is more priceless. The smile of Judas

[@777yogi2]

sachurs savage👏😊

[@jingovidal3545]

Funny and very hypocrite priest. Hahahshhs

[@brillanteslaw2921]

@@biensantos1132 you judge a person simply by his smile and not by what the stand that a person has taken on on issue?

[@brillanteslaw2921]

@@jingovidal3545 your basis? \

[@franciscodeolfacryingdam-bq2ll]

Oh yeah proud pilipino cardinal tagle ok honestly person to God servants k

[@johnpatrickongo7652]

I'm a devout Catholic and I admire Cardinal Tagle very much but I'm quite disappointed on how he answered the questions about sexual abuse by clergy and the wealth of the diocese of manila. He seems unsure on how he would answer those sensitive questions.

[@ramonjosegarcia8812]

Agree. It's actually embarrassing. Some of his answers were none sense at all. All opinions. No facts. Interviewer was even shocked by his nonsense answers. Then he was smiling like a boy who's trying to evade serious topics. He may be good at prepared sermons or speeches. But the real him just showed in the interview. Sorry to say this, but it's like he lacks intellect.

[@brillanteslaw2921]

@@ramonjosegarcia8812 may you please identify the nonsense answers?

[@angeloreanguico576]

You can be a unbiased interviewer without being rude!

[@cristinat5622]

Thank you for doing this interview as I have not seen it before. It is also nice for people to come back to it after years have past, far removed from that moments/time. Some of the answers Bishop Tagle gave were not that great or convincing.

[@brillanteslaw2921]

Which answers did you find not convincing?

[@mariadineros4395]

Ang galing ni Cardinal Tagle. Salamat sa Dios!

[@JosephJoelCruzReyes]

"To one who has faith, no explanation is necessary. To one without faith, no explanation is possible.” St Thomas Aquinas

[@sofiajustol7677]

He is now the prefect of the evangelization of the peoples and a member of the Vatican's treasury. I am more curious to what actions he had planned in his ministry and also the answers from this interview that he would give now. 4 years ago, around the time this interview held, Tagle and other bishops were actively participating synods on the family (2015), for the youth (2018) and the pan-amazon (2019). We are exposed in depth about the underlying issues, presented with questions that are similar from this interview. I'm disappointed for a different reason. To be able to answer all of that on this limited amount of time is absurd and his answers are dissatisfactory. The synods are only the beginning and the dialogues from these type of gatherings are more fruitful than this fast-paced setting. But one thing I noticed are the counter statements where he does not diverts the subject. He would either recuse the idea of both himself and the questions of the interviewer or give insights to the abstract factors which are typical for a reformist, a scholar, and an evangelist. His behavior and candor that we saw here are in alignment to what he manifested in most of his talks and seminars.

[@boyyg547]

i'm a catholic and my faith is really wholeheartedly towards god.. But i see issues with the church too. Problem is, they know there is something wrong. they know that issues do exist, but their still full of talk.. no hard help has been done yet a part from preaches. not being okay with birth control is okay but stating that is wrong is another thing, kumbaga e kung di ka makakatulong wag ka na lang din mamerwisyo...

[@christianjamescollado9822]

Sir, the Charity of the church is not publicized, actually maraming organization ang natulong sa mga issu na ito, yung mga tao ang ayaw magpatulong, see the church within not without

[@mariadineros4395]

The Catholic is vocal regarding free will. If u don't agree with the stance of the Catholic church, exercise your free will. Ultimately the matter is between your conscience & you God.

[@jonbobis]

Not all popular are morals, morality is not a popularity contest. Right and wrong is not a people's choice.

[@ParablesUnboxed]

This is probably the most hostile interview I've seen for the Cardinal.

[@howard-fr7ik]

Im a catholic i believe in god but i dont believe in priest, bishops etc.

[@roquelowelllacaba5312]

The 267th Pope will be Pope Ignatius (Luis Antonio Cardinal Tagle) from Manila, Philippines. He will become the 5th Asian Pope after Peter the Apostle from Bethsaida Israel, Evaristus from Bethlehem Palestine, Anicetus from Homs Syria, Theodore I from Jerusalem Israel.

[@elionelcaral7413]

Cardinal Tagle is one of the bias Archbishop here in the philippines..

[@dickheder4940]

great interview... Cardinal Tagle aint no progressive, he's a traditionalist and a conservative. he is a great communicator

[@priscocajes6796]

I believe that the good Cardinal is really cautious towing the Church's teaching on the being responsible parents using the natural method with Christian principle and not giving in totally to the government sponsored family planning without Christian principle.

[@clericjin]

It's religious people like this that makes me lean towards being an atheist...

[@abelwoods9363]

Then you are a fool

[@clericjin]

@@abelwoods9363 better a fool than be corrupted and use vulnerable people's beliefs to control them.

[@peterlukecabusao6166]

I guess cardinal tagle answered very good and in a very polite manner. Good job the Archbishop of Manila

[@ireneclemente5932]

What a lame answer... The reason why priests who commit crimes (raping or molesting women and young children ) are not brought to the courts is to protect the victim from shame! The victims are not the guilty here...why would they be ashamed to seek justice?

[@RolanGenel]

that's Philippines!!!

[@sopaslomi8706]

Maggandang magbasa ng bible at makinig sa pari o pastor man pero magandang buksan din ang isip sa ibang aspeto

[@jonsnow-nk8th]

TAGLE USES CALENDAR METHOD TOO! THAT'S WHY HE COULD EASILY SAY IT IS VERY EFFECTIVE :)

[@vincentarriesgado8565]

nice one

[@travelismyhappypill.6623]

I am glad to see the injustices of religion. I am now a non believer. And I am free and I feel better.

[@humphreybena3565]

You're free from accountability?

[@JeffMaturan]

People = The CHURCH Building = the church building Priest = leader of the church/people Who do you give your help?

[@marookhan9714]

if you dont like priest be it thats your opinion

[@solidsbg]

DURING DISASTER DONATIONS ARE MOSTLY COMING FROM PRIVATE GROUPS AND INDIVIDUALS COURSED THROUGH THE CHURCH NOT SOLELY BY THE CHURCH. ITS NOT THE BIGGEST CHARITABLE INSTITUTIONS. ITS THE PUBLIC DONATIONS.

[@ramonjosegarcia8812]

Yes. True. If they really want to help, they can give their assets to the poor. Nobody is given money when they go to the church asking for help. It is the parishioners who donate money to the church instead. Money is always used for church renovations instead of giving to the poor.

[@tamiyamorados8028]

???????? lot of good point by Mr.sackur.

[@aldscabrera2947]

Amen

[@eddiedeleon2425]

good afternoon Sir Stephen ... just as interview your host ... enter my mind for one common search today San Luis Obispo a place in California and a church in Lucban Quezon ... thank you

[@JosephJoelCruzReyes]

It is not the Church who is out of tune but the People who chooses not to follow Christ teachings through the Church who holds those teachings, but rather follow their own immoral ways to suit their lifestyle. The Church is the guardian of Christ teachings, it is the people that needs to change, not the Church. In my view Cardinal Tagle is being pulled both ways and in a lot of ways being pressured to conform with the secular ways of life. We pray that he remains faithful to the teachings of Christ our Lord. 🙏

[@concepcionnicolas6962]

God bless us all thank you Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle from Philippines

[@TTko4KKmo]

Last time I checked Timor Leste 🇹🇱🇹🇱🇹🇱🇹🇱🇹🇱 is also predominantly Christian country and its in Asia too.

[@dank1280]

Seriously...? He says at 7:45 that abstinence doesn't work? Name the last couple that got pregnant without sex? It may not be the most attractive manner of preventing pregnancy, but it does have a 100% success rate. You can't impregnate what you don't touch.

[@jedreston]

Have you heard of the Virgin Mary? Hahaha... Good point, but you might want to lower the success rate to 99.99%. Hahaha...

[@rainereigns3031]

But the so called Catholics and Christians and whatever religion know PRE MARITAL SEX all too well

[@madelyneverett3520]

"Shame on this priest..." He is living in the very lavish church, and by funded by the people. s the interviewer mentioned, " You can walk a mile from here and you'll see million and millions of Filipinos living in the poverty. Sorry, I can't stand the church or any religion. Religion, Money, Power and Politics are the reason why humanity are being ruined.

[@fauxmanchu8094]

Madelyn Everett Unfortunately, my not so bright countrymen love their corrupt priests n church. They cannot think for themselves n live in a cocoon and la la land. No wonder the country is in a huge mess. I always laugh when I see huge, glittering churches everywhere in the Philippines while the poor live under the bridge with a dozen children. But the Filipinos see no irony in this. The rest of Asia think we are dumb!

[@adoseofmax]

Madelyn Everett I agree,but not all priest but most of them are living a comfortable life while common filipino's are suffering from poverty,sad reality and sickening at the same time.

[@archie2473]

Madelyn Everett did you live with Cardinal Tagle in one roof?

[@crimsonred3956]

Archie the reality is there are just so many judgmental idiot with moronic non-sense general comment against the cardinal and the Church. they specifically target the church and put blame on its members for anything that is wrong in humanity.

[@etrnlygr8tful87]

@Crimson Red....don't you find it funny how it is that those who are quick to accuse, blames and judge the RCC for having beautiful churches, adhering to its teachings on life and contraception and other things aren't even Catholics? The church being "funded by the people", sure, but people who belongs to the Catholic faith. If anyone has the right to complain it is us Catholics not any of you non Catholics, especially those who do not even believe in God. Those who don't contribute to the building of our churches or do not contribute to its outreach then don't make it your business to complain about how it distributes the money it collects. Oh well...nothing is new, I have no doubt that Jesus knew that the 1 Church He will establish will face persecution, otherwise He will not say "the gates of Hades will hold no dominion over it". So nothing is new, the Church has faced persecution since the first century to the present day, and will remain till His return.

[@dud898]

Omg. This interview exposes a lot of things local media would dare not tread on. Tagle lives in a bubble. So put of touch. Am shocked that this is how the church thinks. Sad actually.

[@nmrd88]

am I the only one who is not impressed by tagle's answers?

[@ramonjosegarcia8812]

Same here. Not impressed. All based on opinions. Most of his answers were vague, even some were none sense at all. It's embarrassing.

[@franciscoenriquebambajr.7409]

Why is he keeps on smiling and smirking. Hypocrite.

[@junelarcala4205]

that is really how he is moron

[@ggand4_GGA]

Correction.... the Philippines is NOT a Christian country -- it is A Catholic country! Christians are people or a country who follows CHRIST only (nothing more, nothing less), & is NOT religion but an intimate & personal relationship with CHRIST.

[@jerryuallera3437]

the interviewer is the typical englishman: snooty and stuck-up.. There are many ways to stay in this world

[@fauxmanchu8094]

Jerry Uallera You have it the other way mate. It's the cardinal who is stuck up n snooty with his stupid answers. This man of the church is embarassing! I'm Filipino so you u cannot tell me to get lost!

[@viridian9673]

yea the cardinal is a disgrace and a knobhead

[@mariatagalog2180]

Yung dalawang respondent dito typical anti Catholic and anti-Priest

[@armenciocampo2085]

Air of arrogance from the interviewer, cutting in while the cardinal is still speaking. ..strikes me as rude and haughty...

[@juanadelacruz6708]

What a very humble Cardinal. I pray to God that he would be the next Pope.

[@alpacinocapon3249]

gago humble ka pa pagsiya ang pope demonyo ang boung mundo

[@saintlouis4313]

I am a Roman Catholic, but I do not totally agree with Roman Catholicism teachings. Much of which were to please the Roman emperors. And the church to my opinion is too materialistic like any other Italian then and now. Life is good, but tying yourself on beliefs that do not seem to make your life any better to me is not the way to go especially that life is so short. Be kind, honest and good to your fellow men and that should be alright.

[@etrnlygr8tful87]

@Saint Louis..If you call yourself Catholic and do not agree with its teachings, them it is time for you to learn more about your faith then, because you are obviously misinformed. If Jesus think that just being kind, honest and good to your fellow men is all we need and that should be alright, then why do you think He needed to build His Church? Why did He say "do this in remembrance of me", as he share bread (his body) and wine (blood) among His disciples. He could have just told His disciples to just teach being kind, honest and good, that for sure would have been much easier to compile and distribute to people instead of the Bible we currently have. Imagine a 3-5 pages Bible? "...tying yourself on beliefs that DO NOT seem to make your life any better" ?? Care to give an example? The RCC is the true church, please do not ever doubt Jesus for if you doubt the Church, you in turn doubt Him.

[@andrinaja5097]

People calling themselves a Roman Catholic but does not follow it's teaching... wow is that the new trend... lol

[@crimsonred3956]

Andri Najaroma they are called "roaming catholics" if they don't like the teachings, they roam around to fit their lifestyle. lol

[@ligoligolamang9796]

Cafeteria catholic?

[@jamiesy1731]

Nominal...

[@jmdomingo2012]

Everyone of us knows the Acient board game called "Chess" . Are you aware that this game represents war against two empires? And "bishops"play a big role in manipulating strategies of war. Now you have a clue....

[@crimsonred3956]

Jœm Domingo you have been playing too much chess! get life dude!😂😂😂

[@gemmajess007]

@@jonsnow-nk8th members I think?

[@kimtamara669]

The answer to all the qyestion leads to one word RESPONSIBILITY

[@snowgarrovillo3822]

rhetorics and sophistry=catholic level

[@brillanteslaw2921]

Where is the sophistry?

[@thelmalaguilles8675]

Interviewer does not understand cultural context

[@jongricafort4]

The wisdom of the world vs. the Wisdom of the Servant of God. All worldly question was answered in the light of Church Doctrines, how can you argue if it is based on the Word of Christ written clearly in the Gospel. The Philippines is the only country left where satan cannot touch to infect with the sin of abortion, divorce and euthanasia. Philippines is protected by Mary the Mother of the Church.

[@bloodraven9977]

Jong Ricafort yes, this is the only country which was not been touch by satan, because satan is the head of the catholic church. Watch it clearly how agitated the cardinal is during in this interview. Review 15:05 on how he tries to protect his minions. The reality is when a catholic priest have a case in any part of the world especially in US, they will be reassigned here in the country to hide from their crimes. MAKE SENSE?

[@renatoano9550]

religion is providing only "the illusory happiness of the people," so cardinal tagle must stop hypocrisy and corruption in Ph.

[@ferdiedeleon5145]

First of all, Cardinal is not a corrupt person nor a church leader. I would like to ask you one instance that he did that made you think he is corrupt. And if for you religion is an illusory happiness of people, well that's your opinion. It's a way of living and a way to express your faith in God, so there's nothing wrong about it. What's wrong is judging a person without personally knowing him.

[@gemmapaglinawan]

So what happened now the bishop supports yellow yard as the Hughes politician said. ?

[@anndeeherrera7545]

Open your mind, for god sake.

[@armenciocampo2085]

Prejudiced interviewer....

[@bernardyoung1356]

cardinal Tagle should be the next Pope, if there is another one.

[@vjsinugbuhan359]

How Rich is the Arch Diocese of Manila?

[@tententententententen9191]

About $ 3 to 500million

[@kingleo7281]

Just like what His Eminence said you can look that at Securities and Exchange Commission of the Philippines

[@hyperloid2143]

Inggit kayo pera nyu saaan napunta sa pastor nyo.... Ang daming charity programs ang Katoliko ayw lang nilang televised para walang masbi....

[@estebanlipa6320]

Rude interviewer. He kept on cutting his interviewee. This is no way to interview a Prince of the Church. I am no fan of Cardinal Tagle but this biased interwee conducts himself like an uncouth pedestrian Protestant. The Cardinal's answers are lightweight though.

[@alexroman1258]

crazy tagle

[@leonbaylon1892]

How is he crazy, kaibigang Francis?

[@milarosenas6298]

Ngpakita ka lng na bastos mg comment.masyadong mapaghusga.

[@ireneclemente5932]

Kung kriminal ka pala at ayaw Mo na makulong, dapat mag- pari ka. Masarap na ang kinakain mo, $150 soup pa lng tapos Mercedes Benz pa Ang service mo, tax free.

[@zarglaizaellazo641]

I' ve watched this interview many times most especially when people have serious questions to some church social and moral teachings. This interview have a lot of things to say with regards to the questions on morality. For the record, those who question the millions that the church owns, i think the good cardinal answerd it well. The millions or billions that the church have, are not kept by one person or own by one person or not own by a bishop. This is owned by the church. Yes, the church have also engages in business but this engagement does not or did not to gain money for arrogance or luxury. The money the church gained in business was used to sustain and shoulder the pastoral ministries of the church like orphanages, charitable instituitions, schools, hospitals and apostolates. No one has supported us financially. Not like the government which annually they have budget allocated to finance their charitable institutions. And mind us, to help uplift the poor is not the first concern of the church. The church is a spiritual instituion. However, because of its social responsibility, the church takes the challenge to help the poor out in their dire situation by providing them for free or less accountablity in their respective life situation. With regards to contraception and abortion, these teachings are not barren or foolish. Look, if we are anger enough to search the dire effects of these methods suggested by the western countries which even to my surprise, they themselves gradually abondoned it. And now they are trying to plant this unrealistic idea to us. The church teaching reagrding this matter has stood up for centuries and it was proven many times that this teaching is accurately and deniably right. After all, thid teachung dearly hold by the church is actually the teaching of Christ, and we know christ will never be wrong!

[@mariatagalog2180]

Natural nag se Serbisyo ka sa Diyos at ang mga donation ay sa simbahan ng Diyos at lahat ng ginagamit ng mga Pari ay Pagaari ng Diyos na mayari ng simbahan.so wala kang karapatan para punahin yung kung ano ginagamit nila Dahil hindi nila ninanakaw yun. How about you bakit ka naiingit sa mga donation sa simbahan ng Diyos? Di ba kasalanan malaki ang mainggit lalo na mga bagay na in o offer para sa simbahan ng Diyos.

[@kingleo7281]

Hahahhaa shuta ok ka lng po kayo? Bilis mag conclude tas gusto mo ng maayos na Justice System eh ikaw po sa self mo nanghusga na agad at nag throw ng walang evidence

[@howard-fr7ik]

Archbishop of Aquino family.

[@gianalphonsuscallado384]

questions are not answered. blaah. just answer honestly and direct to the point, you're lost because you kind of try to find words to cover up.

[@kingleo7281]

Even if the Cardinal answered the questions directly and strongly you will still hate him just because of his stand and maybe hate him more because of being rightful to thing he thinks more right

[@beaworriornotaworrier3835]

Tagle the next pope

[@ireneclemente5932]

I never find any of the topics funny. I wonder why the cardinal is always laughing.

[@ramonjosegarcia8812]

Because he cannot answer objectively. All his answers were just based on his opinion. Even some are of no sense at all. Interviewer was shocked by some of his answers.

[@gregoriojrludivese5518]

Your concern is not for the church

[@kaiseryohannballecer9638]

Stephen Sackur asked weighty questions but I was surprised on how flippantly Cardinal Tagle answered these. His cassock is wanting of solemnity.

[@leonbaylon1892]

Flippant? Come on, Kaibigan Yohann. Which answers?

[@ofwlaton1996]

CAN NOT SPEAK CORRECT THIS BISHOP BUT ONLY USING SMILING TO DESTRUCK THE INTERVIEWER HA HA HA HA.

[@roytee5072]

Tsk tsk tsk...ironically they are the richest institution millions of dollar yet philippines or just Manila..you cannot see churhes building shelter for the poor..what is given by them are also solicited..tsk tsk tsk

[@arjunatienza124]

Account for the crime of your priests. Stop lying.

[@RhodelVPana]

no match ang hard questions ni Mr. Hard talk sa intelligence ng isang spiritual leader. Haha.

[@summabiotech9586]

Either bishop tagle is grossly misinformed or he is just lying through his teeth. If he is not lying and he was working in the private sector, he would be lucky to rise beyond the position of an entry level clerk.

[@nardsvlogs7446]

why the cardinal is laughing with his answers? irritating!

[@halyup]

Bern Sigue , because he's lying

[@sakuraake5167]

i wonder too....why he keep on laughing....

[@marcogaming2099]

Sackur: We can walk just a mile or two from this LOVELY LARGE BISHOP'S HOUSE(MEANING GRAND, RICH, AND BUILT FROM THE MONEY OF THESE POOR PEOPLE THE CHURCH WANT SO MUCH TO MULTIPLY!!!) and we can find the most DESPERATE slums and poverty and children living on the streets! Tagle: Yes.... For heaven's sake! Give the billions and billions of money to the poor. Give them education, give them livelihood. YOU WILL BURN IN HELL IF INDEED THEIR IS HELL FOR ALL YOUR HYPOCRISY AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY!!!!!!

[@etrnlygr8tful87]

@tlinc.......you are barking on the wrong tree here...are you for real? Do you even know how many charitable organizations the Roman Catholic Church runs? Caritas' affiliated charity organizations are present in almost every country, assisting the elderly, in hospitals, in prison, in schools, in orphanages etc? Why not say that to the government,those who can actually give them the job, those who can actually fund them to go to skills workshop, those who can build housing for them? Not because we have nice churches or that the head of the RCC lives has nice accommodation, it is not his own, we as Catholics owns it, Cardinal Tagle can't sell it, bec it isn't his. Have you ever looked at where your gov't official lives? How many cars they have? How many properties they own? So why not direct your rants to them? How about you, would you sell your home and give all the profits to them? After when the money you gave them are all gone, then what, will you ask your parents to sell theirs too? If you really want a better country, vote for the people you want to lead this country, because every Filipino has that ability. Stop with your prejudice towards the RCC, stop persecuting Jesus.

[@benjaminfortunado9220]

etrnlygr8tful Jesus Christ is not the RCC where in the bible you dig that?! RCC is different from Christ body wich is the true Church my friend.

[@crimsonred3956]

tlinc you are just plain stupid blind and deaf idiot, quick to judge moron and sub human specie! Sackur must have said "this is a luxurious place" but he said a "lovely". Do you know what is the difference between a luxurious place and a lovely place? Sackur which i believed his first time coming there mistakenly said this large bishop's house which is actually an office building of the Archdiocese of Manila. Knowing Sackur for his bully tactics misdemeanor, and intimidating bias journalist, he'll make the statement "this is a bishop luxurious house" if he really see how grandeur the place is. I bet you haven't been in that place. The camera does not even lie how simple is the living area which are for visitors were chairs are not even comfortable sofas and the floor is not even made of granite tiles? YOU ARE FOOL IDIOT BLIND! if you can't see that.😂

[@erwinpaneza4357]

Same Old friars in the Philippines , Spanish friars "hypocrite's"

[@mariatagalog2180]

Eh ano naman kaya mga Church Leaders ninyo at kayong. Mga members nila kailan ba kayo nag pakatotoo sa mga mata ng Diyos? Kung makapagsalita kayo tingin nyo wala kayong bahid ng kasalanan. Pwe! Kadiri kayo!

[@hyperloid2143]

@@mariatagalog2180 sulpot nagbasa nng bibliya na compiled ng Katoliko nagtayo ngbsekta ito mas masahol yung iba 10% ng sahod binibigay sa church tung iba pa atm pa ang malala mali mali pa ang turo at panay paninira at pinapaklat ang kasinungalingan tungkol sa Katoliko

[@jorax-rb9fw]

people if you think that tagle is full of bullshit you're absolutely right.

[@jedblanco8058]

wehhh, concerned ang catholic church priests sa mga mahihirap? talaga lang huh? o baka mas concerned sila sa mga abuloy.... mabuti pa ibang katolikong pari sa ibang bansa mas ginagawa nila ang kanilang tungkulin

[@ignaciojosefernandez6114]

The church asks their congregation for donations. To help in disasters

[@manuelgalang9921]

HAY NAKAKAASAR PAKINGAN ITONG PARING ITO SAGUTIN MO DAW YONG ALTAR OF SECRETS?

[@sopaslomi8706]

mahina ang argominto ni fr. tagle.. kasing hina ng pananaw at pamamalakad ng simbahan para protectahan ang mga mahihirap na kababaihan ,kabataan, at pamilya. .. dapat mag give way sya sa mga pari n may maganda at bukas n pananaw... tama nga si jesus makinig k sa misa nila pero wag mo silang gagayahin..

[@ferdiedeleon5145]

If you would closely listen to what the cardinal is saying, his arguments are rooted in the teachings of the church. He mentioned it multiple times, some statements given by other bishops or priests do not necessarily mean the same with how others would approach the matter. Infact he said he understood the mind setting of the bishop who said a specific statement that contraception is corruption. He would have used a different word he said. And yes the Church has an obligation to protect the people of faith but not to a point that it will become a government. It is the job of the Government. The church serves as a "consciousness" of the government where in, the church will speak whe. Morals and values and faith is at risk. Always remember that Church and state should go hand in hand in serving and leading the people both spiritually and politically.

[@alanyamaguchi7930]

To hell with that bishop. He is corrupt.

[@gilbertlicanda2263]

22 Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, ROMANS 1:22 KJV " This is so called senior of cardinal in PH but He is OUT OF TUNE teaching and FALSE PROPHET base in Jeremiah 23:16, Luke 6:26 ,Matthew 24:24 ......OUT OF TUNE SPIRITUALLY AND SOCIALLY ....

[@br.lorenzodelavelasj1236]

geraldo lopez The liberating things is to claim control of your ill-emotion, your bad attitude, your negative reaction to the whole panorama of your sexual experience.

[@ginaimbo5828]

pinakamahal na hospital -- catholic pinakamahal na school - catholic how come u are helping the community lier tagle

[@kevinvinas7565]

sigurado ka? haha mema

[@ginaimbo5828]

@@kevinvinas7565 Ohs talaga bakit ikaw may alam ka

[@ginaimbo5828]

@@kevinvinas7565 ito ang may masabi lang .... saiyo ... kalbo ka kasi

[@humphreybena3565]

Huh? Mag isip ka naman

[@alpacinocapon3249]

la salle ,la consolation college ,iyan ang mga catholic school na sobrang mahal gongvgong

[@cherubimcherubim9515]

Cardinal Tagle's papabile

[@paolocabaral9891]

TAGLE'S ANSWERS SUCKS, its just so unconvincing. Tsk2. Does the church help or hinder development? After after watching this, id say it's no not helpful.

[@jingovidal3545]

For a bishop to say something like he doesnt know how to manage his life is very laugheble and weird because they are suppose to be shepherd of men. What's wrong with our bishop for saying that. And yet still appears in political scene.

[@petarjelinic2876]

Do not criticize the Church and do not give lessons to, fro their faults.

[@heneraldodzz4978]

Ulol wala kang alam kung gaano katarantado ang simbahang katoliko sa Filipinas.

[@victoriavendiola5529]

Cardinal Tagle answers like a lawyer and like Jesus..

[@mackymacky9138]

Ipili t mo pa tagle 🤣🤣wala kamg kwenta

[@mariatagalog2180]

Palibhasa hindi na interview church leader nyo pero pasalamat kayo at hindi Dahil kung mangyari man maraming ka sinungalingan ang isasagot

[@ferdiedeleon5145]

Pano mo nasabi na walang kwenta, eh hindi mi naman inintintindi maigi sagot nya... Tingin ka sa salamin baka makita mo sa salamin yung ainasabi mo

[@kingleo7281]

Ikaw din ipilit mo yung hatred mo, so sinong mas may kwenta ngayon?