Adani Group का Himachal Pradesh में सीमेंट कारखाना बंद होने का पूरा मामला क्या है? (BBC Hindi)

हिमाचल प्रदेश के सोलन और बिलासपुर ज़िलों में पिछले तीन दशकों से चल रहे दो सीमेंट प्लांट्स 15 दिसंबर 2022 को अचानक से बंद कर दिए गए. इन फ़ैक्टरियों का अधिग्रहण अदानी ग्रुप ने सितम्बर 2022 में ही किया था. जब ये प्लांट्स बन रहे थे उस वक़्त स्थानीय लोगों की ज़मीनों का अधिग्रहण हुआ था. इन इलाक़ों के लोगों को उम्मीद थी कि अपनी उपजाऊ ज़मीन इन प्लांट्स के लिए देकर वो ये सुनिश्चित कर लेंगे कि उनके बच्चों को रोज़गार की तलाश में कहीं दूर नहीं जाना पड़ेगा. इन फ़ैक्टरियों में रोज़गार तो मिला पर सिर्फ़ गिने-चुने हिमाचलियों को. जो हज़ारों लोग पिछले कई सालों से इन प्लांट्स के साथ ट्रांसपोर्टेशन के बिज़नेस में जुड़ते चले गए थे, वे भी आज मझधार में फंसे हैं क्यूंकि इन प्लांट्स के बंद होने से हज़ारों ट्रक सड़क पर खड़े हो गए हैं. कैसे बनी ये स्थिति? यही पता लगाने की कोशिश की बीबीसी संवाददाता राघवेंद्र राव ने इस ख़ास रिपोर्ट में. वीडियो: शाहनवाज़ अहमद
#Adani #CementPlant #HimachalPradesh
* जिन खबरों, तस्वीरों और दावों पर आपको हो शक, हम आपके लिए करेंगे उनकी परख. बीबीसी फ़ैक्ट चेक है आपके साथ. बस भेजिए WhatsApp मैसेज 9811520111 पर. बीबीसी फ़ैक्ट चेक यानी सच की कसौटी.
* Corona Virus से जुड़े और दिलचस्प वीडियो देखने के लिए यहां क्लिक करें : • Corona Virus ने दुनिया...
* कोरोना वायरस से जुड़ी सारी प्रामाणिक ख़बरें पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करें : www.bbc.com/hindi/internation...
* ऐसे ही और दिलचस्प वीडियो देखने के लिए चैनल सब्सक्राइब ज़रूर करें-
/ @bbchindi
* बीबीसी हिंदी से आप इन सोशल मीडिया चैनल्स पर भी जुड़ सकते हैं-
फ़ेसबुक- / bbcnewshindi
ट्विटर- / bbchindi
इंस्टाग्राम- / bbchindi
बीबीसी हिंदी का एंड्रॉयड ऐप डाउनलोड करने के लिए क्लिक करें- play.google.com/store/apps/de...

[@varunshine]

That's why Tata Group is one of the Trusted Brand in India

[@dyalsaraswati3915]

MODI KE AISE SATHIO K SARE KAROBAR BAND HO .ZO KI AAM ZANTA KI PROPERTIES S ISNE GHOTALE S BNAE

[@ghumakkadpratap]

Tata kya free me deta hai kya koi admi factory band nhi hota hai bich ka rasta nikalna tha truckers ko manmani karni hai

[@akshaypgl6469]

यह हिमाचल प्रदेश में कांग्रेस सरकार बनने का एक इफेक्ट है, इसे सिर्फ बानगी समझें।

[@akshaypgl6469]

@@ghumakkadpratap यह हिमाचल प्रदेश में कांग्रेस सरकार बनने का एक इफेक्ट है, इसे सिर्फ बानगी समझें।

[@rajeshkumarbhagat]

@@ghumakkadpratap tata is not run by greedy bania brahminical rss

[@AbhishekThakur-bl1mf]

बड़े मंच पर इस गंभीर मुद्दे को प्रकाश में लाने के लिए बीबीसी न्यूज़ का धन्यवाद.

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@mayankthakur7070]

Bhai truck union ban h mn h.p. se hi hoin or ye truck union wale the

[@mayankthakur7070]

Apni mn mrji ke rate mang rhe h or uprse agr company truck bhr se bola ti hain to unko dmkate hai, y h.p. hai pr dhir dhire ye mirzapur bn rha hai

[@aakashgusain4282]

@@mayankthakur7070 kya man marji 8 rupee per km to car hi pi leti h hills me to wo truck 10 rupee per km kya galat h ...plain me or pahado me farak hota h gobarbhakt

[@sourav5041]

Abe worker log company ka chutiya kat rhe hai paise mil rhe the inko acha nhi lag rha tha worker log bahut sare chor hai 😂😂

[@devrajmartolia7579]

समझदार को इशारा है, वोट नही तो रोटी नहीं, एक प्रकार का बदले की राजनीति, समझे 🙏🙏

[@rajahir4620]

Right bro Aisha hi hona chahiye

[@sanjsham9564]

Haan tujhe bada pta hai wahan ki situation

[@sanjsham9564]

Wahan ye fight union or plant k bich ki hai wo b kai salo se

[@hollywoodsortvideo3998]

Sahi bol rahe bhai

[@TodaysG.K.]

Roti ab vote se milegi🤣😁🤣🤣🤣kya gulam h ???acha h chle gaye...vikas krte to vinash hota..joshimath

[@rajnishsharma6903]

Nice reporting. I am from himachal and it is good to see that bbc is covering the issues of common people of small state like himachal. I hope that new government will take some initiatives and this issue will be resolved soon.

[@priyalpatel4250]

Idiot.......Let the industrialists do their job........of making india rich country...... They love Elon Musk over there and they want you to hate indian industrialists........ Know their game.....

[@msagardk]

Lekin chammche khus hai bc

[@hiddenhimalayas]

New govt has closed it by notification at 12 am.. cause sukhu works at night I don't know why ..

[@manmeet447]

जो बच्चे कम पढ़े-लिखे हैं वो खाना नहीं खाएंगे; एक माँ के सच्चे दिल से निकला सवाल 🙏🙏

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Bhai par unn baccho ko khud ke pairo pe khada hona padega. Agar kam padhe hain toh koi kaam sikhe. Ghar baith kar toh koi bhi na toh kaam dega na roti dega. Baahar nikal kar apne ko kuch sikha kar taiyyar karna hi hoga. Apna bhookha pet toh apne ko hi bharna hota hai. BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027. BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@hdhhnfbjdv8424]

Ok ji

[@abhinandanpangotra9431]

This the difference between a business man and an industrialist.. Adani, Ambani are Business man who are always seeking for profit. But there is only one industrialist who is promoting the public welfare is Tata. # the most trusted and oldest brand of India..

[@bharatgaurav9528]

Business is always done for profit. Profit word has long been made a villain. If I go out to run a business then I or anyone will look for profits else why I shud run a business. It's just a Math. However the Congress state government cud have resolved it, but their prince has already made Adani a villain.

[@abhinandanpangotra9431]

@@bharatgaurav9528 I respect your p.o.v but for attaining any profit the central idea must be promoting the public welfare and when the decisions of profit maximisation impacts huge no. of individuals in negative manner then the decisions must be critically reviewed again. Either on government level or on Company level..

[@sherlokholmes7578]

@@sahilsyed2850 तुझे किसने बताया

[@tubusingh]

@@abhinandanpangotra9431 yahi socialism desh ke har ak industry ko le doobega !! 🤡

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@ramchranbajya2713]

सरकार में दम है तो किसानों को अपनी अपनी जमीन वापस दिलाना चाहिए

[@mohdbelalsiddiqui5978]

हिमांचल के लोग मन के साफ़ होते हैं. छल कपट नहीं करते, इसलिए किसी पर विश्वास कर लेते हैं और धोखा खाते हैं. अल्लाह उन लोगों की मदत करे.

[@vishal7731]

Kis galat femi me ho bhaisaab

[@babajantehai2847]

tu ja Bhai unki madat kr de

[@amitvohra2504]

Hats off to the BBC ... 🙏 For highlighting such critical issues ... which other media doesn't covers

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is a fraud news organization. BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@mayankthakur7070]

Because BBC shows propoganda as it's funded by west atleast increase ur brain cells..

[@parambhartiye]

Happy to read ur coment.. aj bhi achi example hai

[@indianocean1010]

इतना अमीर हो के भी दुसरो का रोज़गार छीनना पड़े तो लानत है ऐसी अमिरियत को...

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Bhai thoda deep mein sacchaai dekho please- BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@dharmarajdandsena8054]

These is called Capitalism

[@chanchaljindal5716]

Not only in Himachal, the monopoly of local truck operator unions is hurting the businesses badly. what’s the sense that an outsider vehicle is forced to return empty and the local vehicles demand exorbitant fare…. and ironically at destination this vehicle too is forced to return empty…. A colossal national wastage at the expense of consumers…

[@rudrakshajha3190]

सच्ची पत्रकारिता के लिए आपको धन्यवाद 🙏

[@Rajeshagrawal98]

हिमाचल के लोगों का व्यवहार बहुत अच्छा और शांत है।

[@sanjsham9564]

Ye Bihar or w.b ki tarah ni jo har baat pe aag lga de

[@siddharthgite6313]

और गुस्सा शांत लोगो पर ही निकलता हे.☹️

[@polite_lady0]

@@sanjsham9564 uncle state wise discrimination Krna chhod digie

[@vivekgupta1979]

Pahadi bahut harami hote hai bhai maine Himachal ke logo se mila hu

[@sanjsham9564]

@@polite_lady0 chutiye lode mai himachali hun samjha gandu to yahan bhok mat 😂

[@gkplus2877]

खुद की समझदारी ही अहमियत रखती है, वरना...अर्जुन और दुर्योधन के गुरु तो एक ही थे !! 🏵🌷🙏🏻🏵🌷🙏🏻🏵🌷🙏🏻🏵🌷

[@harinder2479]

fr tu ki krdaatha bc hr thaa ahi coment

[@iamsandhu8664]

bohot khoob bhai

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@lalitjangid2226]

इस प्लांट को सरकारी घोषित कर दिया जाये.. जो देश के साथ धोकाधड़ी करें उस भ्रष्टाचारी के साथ यही ,सुलूक होना चाहिए..

[@RituAvi619]

525 INR, per bag in H. P , as compared to another states, that's not fair. Prices must be reduced becuz they are using our land and materials

[@narayanpurty3513]

चिंता न करें सब षड्यंत्रों का चाल है जी कुछ राहत जरूर मिलेगी

[@anilsinghal2312]

हिमाचल सरकार प्रभावित परिवारों को दस हजार रुपये महिने दे और प्लांट अडानी से खरीद कर खुद चला ले.

[@anupamsharma1335]

@@anilsinghal2312 Ha ha , govt kharide ! ! Joke of day . Govt going for disinvestment , not otherwise.

[@narayanpurty3513]

@@anilsinghal2312 सरकार तो अतिग्रहण कर सकती है भई उसके पास ताक़त है जनता को मायूस होकर नहीं रहना चाहिए

[@explorashwanithakur2941]

@@narayanpurty3513 tere ghr ko kr le sarkar atigrahan to kya hoga fir

[@anilsinghal2312]

@@narayanpurty3513 तब तो हिमाचल सरकार को यह प्लांट तत्काल ले लेना चाहिए जिससे वहाँ के लोगों की रोजी रोटी और रोजगार की समस्या ही समाप्त हो जाये.

[@Mohithing]

अडानी और उसकी team इतनी ना समझ तो नही कि वे किसी ऐसी company का अधिग्रहण करेंगे जो उन्हें घाटा पहुंचाए । इस डील के पीछे अडानी का कोई और मकसद हो सकता है क्योकि दो महीने में घाटे और नुकसान का क्या पता चल पाएगा? लगता है यहां अडानी ग्रुप कुछ और काम करेगा।

[@OO_727]

Cement ki supply kam hogi Tabhi to daam Jyada milega.

[@sammyjain5024]

@@OO_727 😂 ch#tiya he kya? Cement industrie Or uske market ke bare me janta v he kuch? 150 se jyada companies he india me cement ki , inka pura cartel bna hua he sab mil ker rates badate Or ghatate he , ambuja cement ke ek plant band hone se rate kese bdenge? Or cement ka sell depend hi isper kerta hi ki ek company apne dealers ko kitna fast or efficiently cement phuchati he , ek plant band hone se sabse jyada ghata company or uske dealers ko hi hota he

[@fakhritrading9374]

Himachal me adani ke najayaz baap bjp ki sarkar nahi he ab isliye badla liya jaise NDTV ko le liya..

[@Q_QQ_Q]

apple deal off .

[@bigangad]

Bjp ki chal hai kyoki Adani bjp dono mile hai

[@sanjon6681]

Transporters can not dictate rates of hiring unilaterally, it should be negotiated between both the parties, mill owner and transporters

[@dekkanageshwar1924]

Mera bhi transhpot ka business hai mai ish line mai 1999 se kam kar raha hon meri salah hai ki Gadhi malik Transport rate ke bare mai ache se vichar kar ke Ek naya rate plante ko Dena chahiye union baji se fayada nahi hone wala ishme truck se judne wale sabhi ka fayda hai Adani group wale ko bhi waha ke local public bare me soch kar kuch naye vichar ke sath plante jald se jalda chalu karna chahiye sab ki bhalai ishi mai hai Ram ram ❤

[@prakasherankar2887]

BJP lost assembly election in Himachal Pradesh immediately Adani closed his cement plant

[@ILLUSION-qu3iz]

Wrong statement

[@belcofalcon4279]

Fact

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Please understand the situation fully first- BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@manniboy5979]

Husiyari hai government. log nhi fyeda jada jaruri hai

[@BaljinderSingh-xy6iu]

Yes yahi hua. Sab bjp netaa log aur adani ka khel hai . Always murdabad adani n bjp. Ye adani b malya ,nirav ki tarah bhaag jaayegaa. Sab gujrati hai bhaagne wale. Sab chor.

[@sohildhavle7217]

I really appreciate the BBC news report. Our aajtak / Zee news /India tv are still discussing hindu muslim.

[@raviprajapati8738]

Ok katve

[@MehakKiDuniya5Official]

जो सच है वही तो दिखा रहे है सब मीडिया.

[@monum2398]

🤔🤔

[@sherlokholmes7578]

तो नहीं दिखाना चाहिये क्या

[@parasthakur1776]

Thanks raghvendra g 🙏

[@anitasnatu813]

Really gud to hear such a issue on BBC...TQ so much...from Himachal

[@Sahil-tg1xq]

Tata desh ki ek aesi company hai agar nuksan bhi hota to logo k liye company kabhi band nahi karti, salam tata groups ko🙏🙏🙏

[@mahavirbhansali6201]

सब ट्रक ऑपरेटरों की हेकड़ी निकाल दी अडानी ने

[@faizullakhan8500]

Afsoos Garibo rozi chali gayi

[@runout2220]

@@faizullakhan8500 tum log hi to chillate ho ki modi adani ko support karta hai magar aaj tak Google nahi kiya ki wo kitne logo ko rojgaar aur kitna charity fund me deta hai😠😠😠😠😠😠😠

[@jaspreetgill8789]

These people have only 1-2 trucks and operating costs are very high. NO BIG BUISNESS HOUSE WILL BUY A LOSS MAKING PROJECT. I THINK YOU HAVE GOT MY POINT. 🔥

[@kulbeersinghkulbeersingh2181]

I am too from HIMACHAL PRADESH, and this pause of plant has led to great loss and unemployment in our area☹️

[@Ayesnakhan]

Gunda giri Congress ke karan se hihe hua hai 👎

[@nariansinghbajwa9921]

Waheguru ji

[@tintinlouis8808]

What an incredible description of problems of localized people and situation they're facing which of they unaware about I hope they'll find a way... 💪🏻🙏🏻

[@jinendrajain5906]

राहुल गांधी मुफ्त में खिला देगा प्रियंका खिला देगी खिला देगी प्रियंका की मां खिला देगी बेरोजगारी भत्ता तो प्रियंका देने वाली ही है 10 हजार रुपए महीना

[@jinendrajain5906]

राहुल खानअडानी की बुराई करता है अदानी देश में पैसा लगा रहा है उससे लोगों को काम मिल रहा है कौन कहता है राहुल खान कहता है सीमेंट की बोरियों के दाम कम करो उस से अडानी को नुकसान हो रहा था उसने फैक्ट्री बंद कर दी

[@devverma609]

Agar BJP Ko vote nahi Dia to KUTTA Bana degi BJP pura India k logo Ko. Samjha bey Sab Kira makora log. Chalk modiji ka jutaa chaat. Adani ji ka jutaa chaat

[@nikhilgoyal178]

Bina sar per ke transportation k rates hain. Supreme court ne truck unions ban ki hai. Fir bhi illegaly yaha truck unions kisi baahar ki gaadi ko bharne nahi dete aur manmane rates lgaate hain. Wo kisi ko nahi dikhayi deta. Plant band krna badhiya decision hai. Ek baar truck unions ko akal aa gyi apne aap plant chalu ho jayega.

[@globetrekker777]

बड़े साहब ने तभी तो बोला था की और भी कठिन समय आने वाला है

[@asifalli4918]

बड़े साहब का सुझाव होगा !

[@anilsinghal2312]

हिमाचल सरकार को चाहिए कि बेरोजगार हुए लोगों को कम से कम दस हजार रुपये महिने दिया जाना चाहिए. क्योंकि यह लोंगो द्वारा चुनी हुई अपनी सरकार है.

[@globetrekker777]

@@anilsinghal2312 इस हिसाब से भारत सरकार को भी सभी लोगों को पंद्रह लाख देने चाहिए क्योंकि जनता के द्वारा चुनी हुई सरकार है और इन्होंने पंद्रह लाख देने का वादा भी किया था

[@somnathde8680]

Informative.

[@purnimasharma2400]

Thankyou bbc for reporting on this problem

[@manmohansharma6665]

बीजेपी की सरकार आ जाती तो प्लांट बंद नही होता ।। अतः सब राजनीति चाल है

[@Crauniverse]

It's not all about BJP it's company owner decision if they couldn't make profit from plant so they have right what they want and it's also responsibility of union take example of cotton Mill of mumbai .in Mumbai Before union not formed everything is ok but in 90s so many union go on strike and there is no cotton Mill in Mumbai now.

[@pradeeptudu9072]

किस आधार पर आप कह रहे हैं कांग्रेस की वजह से बंद हुआ कहां से ऐसे लॉजिक लाते हो व्हाट्सएप यूनिवर्सिटी से हा हा हा हा अंधभक्त

[@RaviKumar-vu8cv]

Sahi pakde ho bhai

[@vaishalijain6885]

Ye sab BJP ka hi Kara Dhara hai

[@VikasTiwari-zd9dg]

@@Crauniverse what you expect ? That a worker should work 10-12 hour to get bread and cotton mill worker live like king it's example of MD , the alternative to this should be giving the plant to rival company and instead of 6 as lower limit the transportation in hilly area to be increased up to mark of 8.50 because giving up to adani will once again start the rule of company in India.

[@kapilsinghmalhotra1255]

Thanks to BBC for covering this Topic

[@hemathakur3289]

Have they not carried out any feasibility study before buying the plant.

[@lawleshsingh2506]

Privatisation ka yahi fayda hai ki aap jab chahen public ko road par la sakte hain.

[@FFgamer-hu5yk]

Adani ki sarkar nahi bani

[@yasirrather4692]

Correct sir.. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙉🙉🙉🙉

[@yasirrather4692]

Sahi kaha sir.. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙉🙉🙈🙈🙉🙉

[@Rohan-hz2zn]

Lol acc or ambuja kab sarkari thi

[@FFgamer-hu5yk]

@@Rohan-hz2zn ye andar ki baat hai keval samazdar log samazhte hain.

[@Travallover_anil]

BBC news...nice reporting... बदले की भावना हैं shayad नई सरकार के खीलाफ... लेकीन इससे सामान्य लोगो का नुकसान होता दिख रहा है... सरकार को कडी कारवाई करणी चाहिए या जमीने वापस ले लेणी चाहिए

[@peniyalaaradhanabhavanlach175]

Bilkul sahi kaha

[@shivmohan2982]

chutiya, thek se sun leta problem truck union ki vajah se ha

[@rajatsood7994]

I am from Himachal pradesh, these truck union are full of goons and they exploit fundamental rights of every person and all business are very fead up because of these goons.. Great step by adani group

[@akshayagrawal5114]

Jaake school mein padhaayi kar

[@hardeeprana9031]

BBC you are best ❤ covering and giving every insight of news 👍

[@rmagns03]

सर, नेहरू जी ने कहा और किया कि निजी उद्योगो के साथ साथ सरकारी उद्योग भी सरकार के नियंत्रण मे चलेगे ताकि किसी की मोनोपोली देश मे न रहे । आज भाजपा की सरकार जाते ही , हिमाचल मे अडानी ने अपना सीमेंट का कारखाना बंद कर दिया है इसलिए आवश्यक है कि इस भाजपा सरकार को जल्द से जल्द सत्ता से बाहर किया जाये । यह पूजीपतियो की सरकार है इस मे मानवता की कोई जगह नही होती है ।

[@railfan_neon]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@railfan_neon]

pan aur chai ke thele bhi sarkar ke niyantran me hona chahiye.. har chij sarkari honi chahiye

[@jd4434]

Air India Kheridena Tha 😆 Behut Loss Mey Chul Reha Tha 😂 Keha Chup Gaye They ...... 😂 😂 😆 😂

[@rmagns03]

@@railfan_neon A chaiwala is running the Govt, you can't blame him. You mean he should not come in Govt.. You can imagine his condition before and after coming in Govt. You may not in favour of Govt. Organizations but Modi Ji wants to remain in Govt. . It is better to advise him to start parental business rather than to be in Govt. Hope you will understand what you say.

[@railfan_neon]

@@rmagns03 write a coherent statement first 😂😂😂

[@swetasinghc4047]

People of Himachal and factory workers should get justice

[@vkv7477]

you should employ them

[@anilsinghal2312]

अडानी ने घाटे के कारण प्लांट बंद करके शानदार काम किया है.

[@greatentrepreneur3587]

Your vote decide your future...so vote wisely ...

[@sanjaylalverma7840]

Pappu khus hua

[@MohdZakir-xp8im]

@@anilsinghal2312 अडानी के बाप की संपत्ति है क्या , संपत्ति हिमाचली लोगो की है लाइम स्टोन उनका है जमीन उनकी है सरकार को अधिग्रहण करना चाहिए

[@pratibhathakur594]

We want justice

[@alokgurung140]

Sad news for workers..

[@ntom79824]

ऐसे धोखेबाज व्यापारीयो से सावधान रहना चाहिए

[@sumit2302]

Puri video dekh lo chutiyo

[@ManojkumarYadav-ix5dy]

Desh ke sare sansadhn to inhi ko saupa ja rha hai

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Nhi pehle samjhe isse- BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@turtlecreek6043]

Now people will understand why the farm laws were opposed... Adani and Ambani's are not industrlist but they are Capitalist...Salute to the Farmers who had stood against these Crony Capitalist who have government in their pockets.

[@pakka_bevda7382]

bina ambani adani jaise udyogpatiyo k desh nhi chalne vala manyavar

[@xoxo3165]

Wese bhi kya hee ukhad liye farmer law wapas hoke Agar tum gaon mey rehtae tab tumhe pata chalta 2 bigah jamin sae koi kisan nhi ho jata Aur india mey 70 % farmer kar pass 2-3 bigah sae jada jamin nhi hey

[@aashubansal1593]

@@pakka_bevda7382 ye dono nhi honge toh desh nhi chalega kya kaisi baat Soch rhe ho yaar ye blackmail kr rhe hai aur Kuch nhi government ka haath hai inpr jis din government thodi bhi sakht hogayi ye kya iske toh baap bhi plant chlayenge.

[@rahulnandy3277]

Kuch bhi😂😂

[@pakka_bevda7382]

@@aashubansal1593 Bhai agr ye log na ho toh itna rojgar kha se paida kroge jo ye dere h

[@bengalibabu9797]

100% True statment: समझदार को इशारा है, वोट नही तो रोटी नहीं, एक प्रकार का बदले की राजनीति, समझे I

[@pahadidriver7020]

Holcim was forced to sell ACC & Ambuja to Adani, its a part of larger game to get Monopoly over Indian Cement Industry. Now you will see Cement prices will reach Rs. 700 per bag

[@AshokKumar-mb3mw]

निजी कंपनियों, पूंजीपतियों से सरकार को सावधान रहने की जरूरत है वह कभी भी धोखा दे सकते है ? जब नहीं चलाना था तो एसीसी और अंबुजा सीमेंट कंपनी को क्यों खरीदा ? अडानी NDTV को भी बर्बाद करने के लिए खरीद लिया नही है क्या ?

[@PremSingh-vz9fy]

Absolutely correct bro

[@jd4434]

NDTV n Ambuja Are Private Co They Can Sell To Anyone They Want Or At Any Price It's Not Some Govt Organization Any Sarkar Has No Right To Interfere In Private Co Decison Neither In India Or Any Part Of World You Should Have This Much Knowledge

[@AshokKumar-mb3mw]

@@jd4434 अगर निजी कंपनियां पर सरकार ध्यान नहीं दे तो मजदूरों का खून चूस लेगी । ठेकेदार या निजी कंपनियों में मजदूरों का शोषण करते हुए दिन रात में देखता हूं।

[@Used_to_music]

@@jd4434 now railways and airports are privatised also ................what will happen if they shut down the railway................and say ticket price should be 1000rs for general coach ............

[@Rohan-hz2zn]

@@Used_to_music so what's the problem with it you should say that you are not able to earn enough to pay 1000 rs this indicates your incabability

[@buntymeena607]

Thanks ratan tata ji for helping people in covid period ,he understands his employer problems

[@Dharmendraverma1991]

Thanks BBC

[@FirozAlam-nz7mp]

जब सरकार के चहेते उद्योगपति होंगे तो ऐसा ही होगा क्योंकी उन्हें अपने फायदे से मतलब होता है

[@sufaidalam1071]

अब राज्य सरकार को खुद अधिग्रहण करके इसको चालू कर देना चाहिए क्योंकि उनके पास कोई चारा नहीं है रोजगार

[@asifalli4918]

केंद्र सरकार कर सकती है राज्य सरकार की मदद यह संभव है !

[@chandrapratap9273]

U r right

[@anilsinghal2312]

अडानी को जब घाटा हो रहा है तो बंद करने के अलावा कोई चारा ही नहीं. जो लोग बेरोजगार हुए है तो उन्हें राज्य सरकार द्वारा हर माह कम से कम दस हजार रुपये महीना दिया जाना चाहिए.

[@anupamsharma1335]

@@anilsinghal2312 Berojgari bhatta dena chahiye congressi sarkar ko 👍

[@satyamevjayate1866]

@@anilsinghal2312 हराम का खाने के अलावा कभी मेहनत की बात भी कर लिया करो।घाटा वाटा कुछ नहीं हो रहा,राज्य सरकार bjp की बजाय कोंग्रेस की आ गयी है इसलिए अपने काले कामों को छुपाने के लिए फेक्ट्री बन्द की जा रही है।ये तो एक फैक्ट्री की बात है लेकिन जब पूरा देश बिक के इनके हाथों में आ जायेगा तब तेरे जैसे अंडभक्तों का क्या होगा।

[@MyB624]

सोंच बदलो जब तक सीमेंट प्लांट चलेंगी तब तक सारे जमीन पर एग्रीमेंट चलेगा ।प्लांट बंद तो जमीन की एग्रीमेंट भी खत्म हो जाना चाहिए ऐसा कानून लागू किया जाए तो आप और आपके बच्चे तब सुरक्षित रह सकेगा ऐसे ऐसे व्यापारी से

[@azadkulfiicecreembar1433]

जमीन तो मेरे पास 18 एकड़ है लेकिन कोई उद्योगपति मेरी जमीन पर इन्वेस्ट करने को तैयार नहीं है किस्मत वाले हैं जिनको यह सीमेंट प्लांट मिला है अब राजनीति की भेंट ना चढ़े और समझौते करके अपना रोजगार शुरू कर दें और ना सरकार तो कुर्ते निकालकर भेज देगी और अब कांग्रेस के पास कुछ है ही नहीं ठोको ताली ठोको ताली करते रहो अब

[@rajansharaf2223]

So sad and emotional 😭

[@ravinderchopra7222]

Thanks BBC news,

[@ilovemyindia-mo3om]

व्यापारी व्यापारी होता है वो सिर्फ फायदा ही देखता है जनता के खून पसीने की कमाई से mtlb होता है उसको उनकी परेशानी से मतलब नहीं

[@parveenbishnoi1560]

Business man hai bhai Bina profit ke kaam karega toh 1 year mein hi bohot loss kar dega

[@kumars9844]

bhai wo truck wale jo manmani krte h...unka kya

[@ashokkumarpareek7784]

मजदूर किसी भी व्यवसाय की जड़ होती हैं , अच्छे मजदूर , अच्छा व्यवसाय

[@anilsinghal2312]

घाटे की वजह से प्लांट बंद करने का अडानी का फैसला सही है. हिमाचल सरकार को चाहिए कि प्रभावित परिवारों को कम से कम दस हजार रुपये महिने दे और प्लांट खरीदकर चलाये.

[@sunnythakur8411]

जो लोग कल तक छाती पीट पीट कर अदानी और अंबानी का विरोध कर रहे थे वो भी यह सवाल पूछ रहे हैं कि अदानी ने यह प्लांट क्यों बंद कर दिया।

[@samanwaysanket12345]

Haan, toh galat kya hai???? Koi ehsaan kar raha tha kya adani Majdooron par??? Tum yeh dekho, ki apne munaafe ko bachaane ke liye yeh lootere kisi bhi cheez ki parwah nhi karte. Koi jaroorat nhi hai aise logon ki tarafdaari karne ki. Sarkaar, thekedaar, court, police inki jeb mein hain.

[@MANNI13187]

30 saal se sabh sahi chal raha tha, jab adani ne takeover Kiya, tabhi se panga hua Bhai.

[@samanwaysanket12345]

Adani ambani desh ki sampatti loot rahe hain, isiliye virodh hota hai. Aur yahan factory mein Majdooron ke rojgaar ki baat hai, isiliye sawaal bhi poocha jaayega. Tumhe inn dono baaton mein kuch virodh dikh raha hai toh woh tumhaari samasya hai.

[@famousman3714]

@@MANNI13187 ghanta ye union wale phaltu ki dadagiri krte hai..aur ye union ke leader bhag jaate hai

[@anilsinghal2312]

घाटे की वजह से प्लांट बंद करके अडानी ने समझदारी का काम किया है. अब हिमाचल सरकार को चाहिए कि बेरोजगार परिवार को हर माह दस हजार रुपये महिने दे और प्लांट को खुद चलाये.

[@Nikeshgirnatwar3]

Transport rate should be based on fuel consumption and risk involve to transport the material.. Businesses man real earning is employee less cost..

[@aeodzk]

What a reporting hat's off

[@sajjadarts7286]

Temparay close hai. Hamari team ACC ka network dekhti hai. Mujhe pta hai, Mai yaha NOC engineer hu Internal me kaam start hai, soon open ho jaaega. Don't worry. Darlaghat and gagal acc ka important plant hai.

[@mdsuhel597]

Adani having easy money as loan from bank he have no knowedge about running all business he just trying all sectors with free money from bank by supporting of modi goverment cement 5G airport energy electricity all done by goverment end handover to adani with all easy money

[@unicornminds5163]

This temporary close hurts most to those people who do not have savings and depends on monthly or even weekly or daily wages. I condemn this act, it is against the spirit of good governance.

[@sajjadarts7286]

@@unicornminds5163 agree bro. But truk union and ACC ko milke baat karna hai chahiye I hop kuch solution nikle soon.

[@surajchoudhary9639]

Jobs bhi de diya kro

[@akshitdadhwal]

Koi bhi industry local logo ko nhi rkhti .. so it's a myth that industry aane se naukri milti hai .. sirf dhaba hi chala skte ho ..

[@yasirrather4692]

Correct..

[@shubhamchaurasiya8076]

Bhai aur bhi faida hota h Room rent pe uthta h Shop vagaraha khol sakte h Industrialist ki burai karne se kuch ni milta Tum hi socho ek dukan khologe jab usme kamaoge tabhi to kisi ko kuch khila paoge

[@yasirrather4692]

@@shubhamchaurasiya8076 aray chaurasiya... Kehna kya chahtay hoo.... Industrialist tera papa lagay kya....

[@shubhamchaurasiya8076]

@@yasirrather4692 ni bhai tere bap h Tere jaise logo ke soch wajah se aadmi strike karte h fir bhukhe marte h Ek choti si industry bhi kam se kam directly indirectly 10000 logo ka pet palti h Industry ek country ke backbone hoti h Wo na rahe to pakistan Afghanistan ke jaise halat ho jati h

[@abhijitmahanty6687]

@@yasirrather4692 abe katwe puncture sata tu jaake gyaan kam pel

[@anoopnand]

Thanks BBC 🔥🔥

[@mahfujali.47]

Bbc ek documentry hamary yaha ki factory ka bana do bahut sari factory band hai jisme ek sail ki hai jo band padi jo ki sabsy badi hai jisme lagbhag 50k worker kaam karty the

[@kartikmandal8695]

हिमाचल वाला को जो बड़े-बड़े गुजराती व्यापारियों है और सावधान रहना चाहिए

[@lalithadoraisamy4497]

Tu de de job kanjar kaamchor

[@sumit2302]

Bhai kaam bhi to yahi dete

[@chandrapratap9273]

@@sumit2302 enki property ki sahi se janch kraye tax kitna di sb jaanch krk enko priory ko sarkari kr de

[@sumit2302]

@@chandrapratap9273 adani highest taxpayer hai india ka around 20% acording to data

[@chandrapratap9273]

@@sumit2302 apne baap k ki prpoty se tax pay krta he

[@RAJEEVKUMAR-bt9ks]

इसीलिए आवश्यक हो जाता है कि परिवहन में होनेवाले घाटे को सरकार कम करने पर विचार करें। क्योंकि इसे बंद होने से सिर्फ एक ग्रुप को हीं नहीं बल्कि स्थानीय लोगों पर भी नकारात्मक प्रभाव पड़ता है।

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@RAJEEVKUMAR-bt9ks]

@@FaithStudyandPractice मैंने आपके तर्क को ध्यान से पढ़ा व समझा और मैं इससे पूरी तरह सहमत हूँ। मैं भी यही कहना चाहता हूँ कि सरकार को परिवहन खर्च को कम करने की कोशिश करना चाहिए।

[@RAJEEVKUMAR-bt9ks]

@@FaithStudyandPractice लेकिन, यहाँ BBC की कोई भूमिका मुझी नहीं नजर आती है। क्योंकि, इसने अपना कोई राय व्यक्त नहीं किया बल्कि, दोनों पक्षों की जानकारी को रखा।

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

@@RAJEEVKUMAR-bt9ks - bhai issi ko kehte hain hoshiyari se dono sides ko ladaana. Truck wale jyada profits ke chakkar mein plant walo ko loss nhi de sakte. Unko bhi sabka sochna padega. Bbc truck wali ki galti nhi dikhayi bas plant walo ki galti dikhayi. Ye chalaki hai bbc ki. Isliye bbc fraud channel hai

[@mukheriasamsunggalaxyf4192]

क्या आपने sahi reasons मालूम किए कि plant क्यूँ बंद किया गया??

[@samraboy822]

07:54 🥺👍

[@ageless1003]

5:32 - अदानी खुले बाजार की बात करे, मजाक लगता है 🤣

[@sanjaylalverma7840]

Pappu ata hi Himachal ka gand maar diya

[@ageless1003]

@@sanjaylalverma7840 अदानी किसका दोस्त है बताना तो 🤪😆

[@ageless1003]

@@sanjaylalverma7840 साहेब की गांड़ में आग लग गई तो अपने दोस्त से कह कर प्लांट बंद करवा रहे है । ये है तुम्हारे साहेब की असली औकात ।

[@niranjanruparel8584]

मालिकों की मनमानी पे अंकुश लगे। सरकार मध्यस्थी करे।

[@AkshAk-ed9my]

यही दुख है निजीकरण का।

[@javidpatel7516]

😔😔😔

[@ShayeriRoad]

Thank you BBC🙏🙏🙏

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@neerajsrivastav3246]

यह स्थिति भारत में सरकारी और निजी नौकरी के अंतर को समझने के लिए पर्याप्त है

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Bhai itna negative mat hoiye. Sach baat poori samajhiye- BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@neerajsrivastav3246]

@@FaithStudyandPractice मैं आपके विचार पर तब तक प्रतिक्रिया व्यक्त नहीं कर सकता हूं जब तक पुरानी पेंशन से न्यायिक जनप्रतिनिधि भारतीय सेवा के अधिकारीयों को मुक्त नहीं कर दिया जाता

[@paulm9464]

Why acquire a loss making Plant in September and shutting it on December??

[@TravelFoodz]

Oho

[@evanmadly2206]

This plant will not Restart. Same thing happened in Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan. The cement factory closed in 90s. Factory workers are still living in the factory quarters with hope that it will reopen someday.

[@pushpendrasingh-yd9lf]

Chutiye waha wild life sanctuary hai is wajah se band ki hai, tere cement se badi waha tourism industry hai sanctuary ki wajah se.. aur waha koi nahi rehta may waha dekh kar aaya hu,muh se kuch bhi mat bola Karo

[@MohdZakir-xp8im]

Government should aquire all such closed mills and plants ,how we can let so called industrialists to hijack the state resources

[@utarkumar6530]

It was Rajasthan bro ....This is himachal pradesh vo bhi darlaghat .. It'll restart ..

[@Old__boy..]

Both plants will restart in near days..

[@nkj3985]

जेसे सिंगूर से टाटा नैनो का प्लांट बंद हुआ था। उसके बाद से पूरे बंगाल में कोई बड़ी कंपनी इन्वेस्ट नही कर रही।। बेसा ही हिमाचल के साथ हो सकता है।। एकानामिक ग्रोथ सरकार और उद्योग के बीच सामंजस्य से होती है। ना की सरकार के लड़ने और उद्योग पति के अड़ने से। कामन सेंस लगाओ की एक झटके में प्लांट 2000 लोग बेरोजगार हो गए।। कोई भी उद्योगपति या दुकानदार घाटे के लिए वेंचर नही करता।। वो अदानी हो या बिल गेट्स या एलोन मस्क।। अतः इसे मुद्दो को वैसे ही हैंडल करना चाहिए जिसे गुजरात, कर्नाटक, तमिलनाडु में किया जा रहा है।। इसलिए इन राज्यों में इनवेस्ट मेंट लगातार ग्रो कर रहा है।। हिमांचल सरकार ऐसी हरकत कर या मुद्दे को मैनेज ना कर हिमंचल के भविष्य के साथ मजाक कर रही है।

[@kundanpandit3266]

Factory band hua kyoki double engine ki sarkar nahi hai

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@shahidrizvi8521]

Good report

[@surajsalunke4125]

👍👍👍

[@bhanutripathi]

और लेलो अच्छे दिन,,अभी तो और ऐसे ही बहुत अच्छे दिन देखने को मिलेंगे।।

[@sumit2302]

Congress ke ate hi hua hai

[@bhanutripathi]

@@sumit2302 इसे ही अंधभक्ति कहते हैं 8 साल से कांग्रेस सत्ता से बाहर है,,लेकिन तब भी कांग्रेस जिम्मेदार है,,इन 8 साल में आजादी के बाद की सबसे ज्यादा गरीबी, बेरोजगारी,, अतिमेहगाई,,ठेकेदारी,, निजीकरण,, अशिक्षा,, किसानों की लागत हुई है,,लेकिन तब भी कांग्रेस जिम्मेदार जबकि कांग्रेस आज खुद बिखरी हुई है।।

[@sumit2302]

@@bhanutripathi lol garibi ghati hai rojgari badi hai mehgai badi hai lekin america UK jitni nahi waha 10 % hai aur india ki 5.9 aur economy 5 position pe hai tum librandu kya paste ho pata ho pata nahi lagta hai tum TV ki news ya communist newspaper paste ho 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bhanutripathi]

@@sumit2302 तुम अमेरिका में रहने लगो न रे,,अमेरिका में महगाई बढ़ी है लेकिन वहां न्यूनतम मजदूरी ज्यादा है,जिससे महगाई का असर नही होता,,ये तुम्हे पता नही,,,अपने भारत मे न्यूनतम मजदूरी 2014 से नही बढ़ी,,जस की तस है,,किसान की आय 27 रुपया प्रतिदिन की रह गई जबकि 2022 के जुमले के अनुसार किसान की आय दोगुनी होने वाली थी,,जब सच्चाई पता न हो जबरजस्ती दोंदना नही चाहिए।।और तुम्हारी भाषा तुम्हारे संस्कार बयान कर रहे हैं,,कि जो संस्कार माताजी पिताजी ने तुम्हे दिए हैं,,उससे तुमने शिष्टाचार सीखा कि नही।।

[@bhanutripathi]

@@sumit2302 2014 से पहले 14 करोड़ लोग गरीबी रेखा से ऊपर आए थे,,आज 8 साल में वापस 22 करोड़ लोग गरीबी रेखा से नीचे चले गए,,और गरीबी न बढ़ी होती तो फिर आज 80 करोड़ लोग मुफ्त के गल्ले पे निर्भर कैसे हैं,,जुमलेबाजी और झूठ नही बोलना चाहिए।।

[@himanshugautam3405]

Market rates charged by other truck operators should be analyzed and then should be seen if rates charged are fair or not, be it rs 6 or rs 10 or something else.

[@tellychakri]

Transporters kya krein.. Petrol or toll tax ka price itna Bad gya ..charges to bdenge hi... Upar se police bhi vasuli Karti hai... Why there isn't GST ON fuel??

[@ww7308]

All credit goes to Rahul ji for Adani mukt Himachal Pradesh . 🙏🙏🙏 Congratulations 🎉🎉🎉.

[@creativebanda354]

@@ww7308 andhbhakt

[@ww7308]

@@creativebanda354 Andhnamazi madarasachap bhag yaha se.

[@ASHISHSHARMA-iy1tx]

@@creativebanda354 tu andh bhakth hai . Adani close due to over rate charged by local truck operator

[@bilalganaie8496]

History repeats itself

[@Er.RamanMehra]

If the matter is cost, then i can assure that it is because of transportation

[@shantidutbansode2]

Should have asked some questions to those transport Unions too to see what they have in their defence

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@shantidutbansode2]

@@FaithStudyandPractice you from the same region?

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

@@shantidutbansode2 - No I am not but I am aware of this situation and was surprised to see this story being given a wrong twist by BBC.

[@gajanand.phadakale284]

Government should think in future that land sale on Lease only & not on Outrate. So title of land possession itself with owner. This is big Solution for all.

[@kumarmanubrat2076]

Solution is punish those who does dirty politics due to which business suffers . 450 rs bag in Rajasthan is right but 370 is not for congress. Either increase 5 rs or decrease 5 rs of state tax

[@kumarmanubrat2076]

And fact is after proper compensation the previous owner has no claim.

[@mayankthegod]

This sale of land is based on lease till 2050

[@kumarmanubrat2076]

@@mayankthegod no can't be bcz no company will lease a land less than 100 years and even after lease expires it becomes government land. Ultimate proprietor of all land is either state government or central government or certain temples or religious institutions.

[@manchikantimurty7375]

Gautam Adani present wealth Rs. 10,94,400 crores became first wealthy person throwing Mukesh Ambani to second position. Average growth of Adani has been Rs. 1612 crores daily. In one year growth has been 116% ,(Rs. 5,88,500 crores). During the last 5 years growth has been 1440%. This increase in wealth of Adani is attributed to the benevolence of Modi 72. Do you think Modi has been a better PM than Manmohan Singh, PV Narasimha Rao, Lal Bahadur Sastry, Mrs. Indira Gandhi, and Jawaharlal Nehru and other PMs of our country. If so, you can vote for Modi in 2024 as well. God save our country.

[@hemraj625]

Please start this plant

[@Kuch_bhEE33]

Could be relate with south movies???

[@arunnayak2454]

सरकार को आगे आकर ईन फेक्ट्री यों का आधी ग्रहण कर चालू कर कर्मचारीयों को राहत देना चाहीए

[@marshalLannes1769]

Sarkar ke pass paise kha se ayenge arigrhan ke liye?

[@anilthakur5429]

सरकार ही कंपनी है ।

[@desihoonyaaron]

BBC himachal must have some future plans for more new news and issues especially related to himachal at a bigger platform than local news channels, Good to hear about himachal problem at a bigger platform 👍

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is a fraud new channel. It is stooge of the British government in India to destabilise India.

[@abdullavohra1970]

Kyo bandh hua?

[@the62_vlogger]

इतने भी नासमझ नहीं था अडानी जब कंपनी लिया था तो क्या देख कर लिया था।

[@srinivasvaranasi1645]

With cement one of the materials required for infra, is this suggestive of a recession? Why did Adani buy it? Did they not understand costs OR this is their method to squeeze costs?

[@saiarjun8714]

It is so sad to hear this :(

[@vimmiroy9139]

Himachal govt. do not want to open cement plant govt. increases the diesel price so now it is almost impossible to start factories again at any price

[@surinderpalsingh4600]

Yeh to uski chall hai????

[@yogeshgarhwali1769]

सरकार, उसके अधिकारियों और अडानी को कुछ फर्क नही पढ़ने वाला फर्क पड़ेगा तो सिर्फ और सिर्फ वहाँ के नागरिकों को जिनका परोक्ष या अपरोक्ष से रूप से मिलने वाला रोजगार गया सरकार को इसे शुरू करने के लिए जल्दी है कदम उठाने चाहिए और नागरिकों के हित के बारे में सोचना चाहिए। राहुल गांधी को लड़ने दो अडानी से पर लोगो के रोजगार के बारे में पहले सोचें।

[@mdsuhel597]

Adani having easy money as loan from bank he have no knowedge about running all business he just trying all sectors with free money from bank by supporting of modi goverment cement 5G airport energy electricity all done by goverment end handover to adani with all easy money

[@ageless1003]

राहुल गांधी की लड़ाई अदानी से रोजगार दिलाएगी । सस्ते में सरकारी संपत्ति को अदानी को क्यों बेचगाया ?

[@sunilyadav-ke4br]

Pappu rojghar nhi dega. Jaha jaha pappu ko jeetoge jitna rojghar tha wo band hojayega

[@anilsinghal2312]

अडानी ने घाटे के कारण प्लांट बंद करके शानदार काम किया है. अब हिमाचल सरकार इस प्लांट को खरीद कर खुद चला ले. और हर बेरोजगार को कम से कम दस हजार रुपये महिने दे.

[@chandrapratap9273]

Sarkar ko ese jbt krk sarkari goshit kre fir sarkar ese chalaye adani ko desh ki property khridne ka Sauk he ,laal kila v chla rha he faku apne baap ki smpti smjh kr desh bech rha he jiss din satta bdli sudhare jayege 1969 ko indira gandi iron lady ne 14 bank fir 1980 me 6 total 20 bank ko sarkari bnayi aur v sarkari institution bnayi essi trh se nirv , modi vijy malya , chauksi and bHut sare he bjp k help se khrbo me bank ka paisa lkr bhage he sbko sampti jbt krk desh k logo ko di jayegi

[@prakritighodki1192]

Thanks BBC news team for informative video. 🙏

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@sunny12884]

We want cheap and economical finished goods but we want height labour cost heigh transportation cost good salary.....hoz that possible

[@babasonar9108]

💫☺️

[@rohit9832571162]

Even Day : Boycott Adani Odd Day : Why Adani is closing Factory

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

😂 BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.

[@criscrosxxx]

Dimag km hai kya? Randomly unannounced aur just after power change pe factory bnd krdi . Waah be goyal .

[@jaybhudia913]

@@criscrosxxx Kyu re be, dhimak🤯 to tumara sahi nahi he, Rohit ne bilkul sahi👌 kaha he.

[@deepakkumarsingh7083]

Uska mn wo jo chahe kare 😂😂😂😂

[@sainiamarjeet]

Cement is not cost but delivery cost and unless cheaper or competitive than other cement brands than can't sell the cement. The best way is to take over the cement plant by forming a people's co-operative to operate the plant like AMUL dairy processing plants in Gujarat

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

BBC is hell-bent on dividing Indians and creating an environment of mistrust against the industrialists. The real issue and situation has not been shown here or only briefly touched by the BBC. The local truck operators have formed a union and dictate prices to the cement plant and do not let any outside truck operators to work here who are ready to work at Rs 6/- rate. The goondagardi of the local truck operators has been hidden here. They had earlier threatened the plant management several times to comply with the rates fixed by truck union otherwise they would not transport for the plant nor would they allow anyone else to operate here. This goondaism is not correct. The rates that the cement plant wants to pay has been decided by the Himachal Pradesh government itself. But HP government has not done anything in this regard. No industry can work taking losses. Those of you who do not know are saying why has Adani bought this plant when it was incurring losses. The answer is that Adani has bought the whole cement business of ACC and Ambuja Cement which has got dozens of plant. It has right to close those plants which are mired in union politics and thus running into losses. No body is bound to bleed money from its pockets. The HP government should buy these two plants from Adani and run themselves. The officer who was interviewed by BBC was very cleverly shifting all the burden on Adani Co and also linking the move to close cement plants with arrival of the new government. He was trying to wash hands off this situation because the government has come to power now and the elections are 5 years into the future in December 2027.