Kurram:What is behind repeated episodes of violent & sectarian clashes in this district? - BBC URDU

[@thoms346]

Humain bahir k dushmanoo ki zaroorat nahi he. Hum musalmaan kafi hain apnay liye.

[@AliImam-v6k]

Aaye India me mil jaye ❤❤❤.

[@thoms346]

@AliImam-v6k sure. The name of the new country would be Pakistan. We have no objections.

[@dhananjaigiri]

​@@AliImam-v6kkya jarurat hai india me Milne ki

[@noshabaakhatoon4236]

افسوس ہے کہ مسلم ایک دوسرے کے دشمن بنے ہوئے ہیں ،

[@muhammadsarwar9691]

Muslam hi aik dusray ke dushman hotay hein apni history padho.

[@muhammadsuleman9328]

Ahal sunat is not SUNY they r dubandi vahbi we ahal sunat did not hate Shai people ❤🇵🇰

[@anfalkhan2490]

​@@muhammadsuleman9328 ھمیشہ اپنے گناھوں پہ پردہ ڈالنے کے لئے ۔۔ وحدت مسلم ۔۔ کا پرچار شروع کر دیتے ھیں ۔۔ ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ ھم 1400 سالوں سے کہہ رھے ھیں ۔۔ کہ وحدت ھی کی خاطر ۔۔ صحابہ کو گالیاں نہیں دیا کرو ۔۔ کہتے ھیں یہ تو ھمارا دین ھے ۔۔۔

[@HammadHammad-xj6uj]

Shia Not Muslim Okay

[@noshabaakhatoon4236]

افسوس ہے کہ مسلم ایک دوسرے کے دشمن بنے ہوئے ہیں ۔

[@fakhrisayed6113]

Ye Zamini Tanaaza nhi Hai😡😡 I am Parachinari, ye Bazaher Firqawara hai likn Asal mai syasi hai... Lakhoo Fouj moujood hone k bawjood 🖐️🖐️🖐️ Aj tak logo ko Security na de sake, Jaha kahi qatal hota hai, Waha Du sec mai Fouj Hazer hoti hai,,,likn yaha Lako log Qatal hote hai likn Hukoomat Aur Fouj Soti rehti hai.... Parachinar aate jaate waqt jo Vehicle Targeting hoti hai, Us ko b Zamini tanaza kahoge😡😡😡

[@samadnasar2700]

Lakin yahi Fouj jab security dena aaye, to b log is k khilaf hojate hn, awr kahte hn k bas fouj hi fasad lata h, fouj yahan se chala jae??

[@Tariq-v5w]

اگر یہ سیاسی مسئلہ ہے تو پچھلے گیارہ سال سے کے پی کے میں ہی ٹی آئی کی حکومت ہے تو کیا پی ٹی آئی بھی یہ مسئلہ حل نہی کر پا رہی جبکہ پی ٹی آئی سے تو بڑی اُمیدیں وابستہ ہیں لوگوں کی۔

[@firozhussain7768]

G apne sach kaha hai 💯🇮🇳🥹

[@fissionaire]

Haan apni nalaiki fauj pr daal dou. Kia fauj tu. Kogoon ko majbour krti hy ky Iran ki Zainibiyoun brigade mien shamil ho kr Syria aur Iraq mien larnay jao? Fauj jab tum logon ko violence sy rokti hy tou phir fauj pr ilzaam lagatay ho ky vo tumharay mukhalif ko support kar rhi hy. Jin. ka motto ho ky "Topak zama qanoon dy" vo phir fauj ki kahan sunti hy

[@fakhrisayed6113]

@@samadnasar2700 yaha Shru se Fouj moujood hai, itne kisi jaga pr nhi jitne Yaha Parachinar mai hai, jagah jagah posts hai Likn uske Bawjood agr Security nhi hai, Tu kia Awam ko ghussa nhi ayega Fouj pr

[@Waqar.Ali010]

BBC News اردو آپ نے بھی سچ نہیں بتایا، یہ زمینی تنازعہ بالکل نہیں ہے

[@mudasirbashir5736]

Then wat

[@loverking8233]

Yes you right It is absolutely lying and it has shared a side view shia

[@aliya2510-x7v]

Stop Shia Genocide 😢

[@MereMehboob-dr2df]

کسی کو مارنےکا کسی کو حک نھیں ھے

[@Code_Catalysts]

وجہ ہمارے مولوی جنہوں نے عوام کو ایک دوسرے کے فرقوں کو دشمن سمجھا ہے اور دوسری وجہ جہالت ہے

[@SyedMuntazir-gy4zb]

Isn't it a shame for Pakistan that people have to fight against terrorists

[@iqeelkaimkhani]

Best reporting

[@Sindh0123]

Musalmano😭🇵🇰 please do take extra care of each other 🙏

[@goldenflute]

Thanks for raising our voice to world

[@medico1273]

دونوں کے درمیان ایک معاہدہ ہؤا تھا اہلِ سنت اور طوری شیعہ کے جو مری معاہدے کے نام سے جانا جاتا ہے اگر اس پر عمل درآمد ہو جائے تو یہ مسئلہ مکمل حل پائیں گا ۔۔۔

[@shafiquerashid234]

Ya ALLAH Muslims ki madad farma

[@kapwarakashmir5628]

I am a journalist and have spent over a week during my visit to this area in 2021, BBC has ignored many facts. Sunnis have never attacked Shias in this area but always Shias are exploiting the situation by abusing greatest Muslims of all times, while Muslims can't even think of insulting Hindus idols let aside insulting any Shia Imam who are equally respected for Muslims.

[@muhammadsalman9980]

hahaha AAP ne bohot bhondi research ki hai. jab ke reality ye Hai Ke is area ke Sunni bohot ziada violent aur TTP aur SSP ke members hai. Yaar Jahan ambulances par patrao Kiya jae kam az kam wo insan kehlany ke haqdar nahi

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

kpk banegi Afghanistan inshallah

[@primordialarchetypes2927]

@@AstralProjections-oy8ue inshallah.........muktibahni coming soon to help you

[@kapwarakashmir5628]

@@muhammadsalman9980 Ma Musalman hoon Shia nahi, or ma sach appnay against bi hide nahi karta. SSP, TTP ho ya Zanibiyoon ya Fatimiyoon terrorists are simply terrorists.

[@kapwarakashmir5628]

@@AstralProjections-oy8ue Pehli baat yeh hai keh hum KPK walay yeh kabi honay nahi dain gy, or dosri baat tum jesay Indian agents kam ky liye kahan jao gy, smuggling kahan karo gy, chori or dakay kahan dalo gy?

[@YFi-Pk]

Totally diagree agree ye Zamini tana hota tu hal howay baghair qhabi ye jhang na rukti common sense ager use karein. Or jb Parachinar ke awam ko shehar sy bahir raston mein target keya jata hy tu phir keya logic hy ap k pass??? Or jb dosray areas sy baqaida lasher bana kar lashker kashi karwai jaye Ya Taliban, TTP or degar dehashatgard tanzeimein barah e rast mulwais ho jayein tu phir keya jawa hy ap k pass? Jb k on record yahan k log qbahi b kisi or area tu door ke baat Afghanistan mein mudakhilat nhi karty. Bal k jb US ne afghanistan py hamal keya tu Talibans ko Pakistan mein Govt. Or authrities ke planning sy inhein laya geya or wahan k logon ne safe passage deya mager afsos ye namak haram b hein qk inki ideology Yazid ke hy. Yahan jitne b jhangein howein ya inteshar phelaya geya un sub mein state barahe rast mulavis hy or yahi is bar ke larai ke b wajha hy. Or sub sy bara saboot unki khamooshi, media py pabandi or ghair mojoodgi hy. Pori dunia k muslim countries mein shia sunni ka qoye issue nhi yaha taq k India mein b sirf or sirf Pakistan he q? Qk yaha namak haramo ke or israel or us k talway chat hein. 'Eid Nazar' jis sub jantay hein ko aj taq security idary q nhi pakar sakay? Qk vo intelligence ka banda hy.

[@khalidraza1913]

Hamara media to dollari media hai

[@SalmanMuzammil-mw4zw]

سنی شیعہ اسمیں کیاھے ھم سب اللہ کے بندے ھے بس یہی کافی ھے انسان خو د اچھا ھوناچاھیۓ دوسروں پر انگلی نہ اٹھاۓ

[@babycare539]

Right brother

[@imtiazdar7787]

*عُلمائے سُوء نے فرقوں میں تقسیم کر دیا، یہی وجہ کہ آج پوری دُنیا میں ہماری شامت ہے، حل؟ واللہ اعلم، فوج 1 بار سُنی شعیہ کو برابر کا بھاری اسلحہ دیکر سائیڈ پہ ہو جائے جب دونوں کم ہو جائیں تو ان میں زمین بانٹ دیں کہ زمین کا سائز نہیں بڑھ سکتا پر انکا سائز چھوٹا ہو سکتا* 🇵🇰ZB

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

Why doesn’t Allah solve the problem which has existed for more than 100 years

[@muhammadsarwar9691]

Very good solution.

[@mitraabbasi6064]

​@@VictimHood-qv1hxwhy does not your ram speak if he existed more than 10000 years

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

@@mitraabbasi6064 a Man becomes GOD by his deeds as per Hindu religion. We bow before our parents as we consider them God. You will never understand

[@mitraabbasi6064]

@@VictimHood-qv1hxa man become human becouse of his good deeds and left evil things u will never understand

[@ihsanalin5289]

پاکستان کی ریاست کا کھیل ہے سب ۔

[@zafarkhan3172]

اس کا ایک ہی حل ہے پاکستانی فوج کو وہاں سے نکال دیں امن قائم ہو جائے گا

[@alijan7956]

Ur Right I m from parachinar

[@Rbird44]

It's not all about land disbute.... Because many innocents were killed through bomb blasts in Parachinar. Killing Parachinar innocents on roads in lower Kurram even ambulances have been hit since 2007. Now govt fights with Parachinar people even Parachinar wants peace forever.

[@hassankirlani1412]

ماشاءاللہ زبردست رپورٹ تیار کی ہے,,

[@khalidraza1913]

Bbc thank you

[@asifjamakzai6712]

I see your program from afghanistan live in Singapore

[@IrfanHussainDoctor]

Thank you for amplifying our voice to the world. Your efforts in bringing our message to a wider audience are deeply appreciated. By highlighting our concerns and advocating for our cause, you are making a significant impact. Your support is invaluable, and we are grateful for your commitment to raising awareness and fostering positive change.

[@caderbavahmuhammadsiddick384]

Thank lots for sharing 😮

[@abdulghafoor424]

شیعہ سنی مسئلہ نہیں مسئلہ کرائے جاتے ہیں

[@salahuddinayoubi3320]

بی بی سی اردو کی بات ہی الگ ہے ❤

[@rabnawazkhan7935]

This is all lying 🤥 behind all of this is is fk

[@mirzakhurramabbas1230]

Zamini tanaza koi nhi hai. Shia dushmani hai.

[@atifqamar2300]

Correct reporting by BBC

[@zainabraza9369]

Madam apko bataen me mout q ai Kay Buses se utar kar shiao ko mara gaya aur teachers Jo the wo bh Shia the ..... Nafrat sab ko bht hai

[@fatehmuhammad3143]

اللہ کی ذات سب کو ہدایت دے۔۔۔

[@MacsRoshni]

پاکستانی افواج کیا کررہی ہے ۔ سیاست چھوڑ کر کہان امن پیدا کرے

[@imbasitali]

Yazidi log hain jo shia khilaf hain.

[@muhammadmuavia-gn8of]

or jo sunni k khilaf he wo kia he . ?

[@AqeelHussain-w1b]

Ihl sunnat k log shion k zamino per Qabza Karty aur shion ko zinda zabah Karty hai

[@sociological512]

Thank you for the report

[@gulkhitababbasi5391]

9 may saniha hy logo ki zindagi saniha nahin pak boj siasat kar sakti hy logo ki jaan ki hifazat nahin

[@NoumanaliNoumanali-b9n]

😢😢😢😢😢

[@sabirshahjaji8136]

ساری رپورٹ جھوٹ پر مبنی ہے

[@harun1857]

Each of your videos are short but full of information

[@loverking8233]

Sham

[@loverking8233]

I belong to Basheer myself, this is all lying

[@saimmalik361]

Sunni ek deshatgard qom hy or Al Qaida or TTP Ale Sunnat main se hi hain jinho ne deshatgardi karky 85,000 Pakiatani shaheed kiye hain.

[@arjunsharma3925]

100%ryt from j&k india

[@witchcraft2437]

Shia ho ya sunni kise ne teri sis ko nahi buxna​@@arjunsharma3925

[@Malik-lh4jh]

Lindu

[@asifahmed3076]

Right bro sour ki olad h yazedii hai

[@Gay.shre_rand_sita_rundi_sali]

اہلسنت والجماعت ذندہ باد 🇵🇰

[@AbdulMuqset-l8f]

❤❤

[@muhammaddawood3436]

بوشہرہ پاکستان کا غزہ بنادیا گیا ، سچ بتایاجائے

[@toseefellahi9122]

Allah khukamran KO tafeeq dy insaf Ki Pakistan ma development Ki Ameen

[@muhammadimran-gt2sg]

Apki report sahi nahi ha

[@human8267]

100 %right .

[@shakilangan]

ماشاءاللہ ہیئر سٹائل بہت زبردست ۔۔۔۔بلا مبالغہ۔۔

[@imtiazwali6002]

Thanks bbc by providing cogent argumentative comments

[@MubarakKhan090]

Wrong info ❌❌❌❌

[@mohtashamali5245]

Baat itni hain pak Army khud TTP or Al Qaida ko Shad dati hain or yaha Sirf Qurbani ka Bakra Shia bante hain jo Aman chate hain. Or Pak Army ko Sirf Paise say Pyar hain.

[@ij421]

Apki report hamesha incomplete kiun Hoti hy

[@uzairawan634]

SHe is so cute .... I like you anchor BBC .... Your speaking style is awesome ❤

[@muttalibkhan9641]

اس پہ سے اپنی نظر ہٹاؤ یہ میری مال ہے

[@Asfan-w8x]

Jaha ..wasail Waha...masail....samajdar k lia sirf Ishara kafi ha..🤫😏

[@KamranKhan-x8w]

I live there all info is wrong

[@misszainab339]

Dont share Incomplete information. Its not always about the land dispute. The wahabi group is always killing shia people there just because of their sact. The people who are being murdered in the busses, ambulances, market, masajid and imam bargahs are shia people. If you dont have courage to call out their names who are killing the innocent shia people then dont make any incomplete report to mislead the people who dont have any idea about this issue.

[@akmalnafees292]

حکومت یا فوج اپنی رٹ قائم رکھنے میں ناکام ، ان فسادات کو بڑھاوا دینے کیلیئے اکثر و بیشتر غیر ملکی ایجنسیوں کا ھاتھ بھی ہوتا ہے ۔

[@SaeedAhmad-rm8sl]

بہتر ہو گا فریقین کا موقف سن کر رپورٹ پیش کیا کریں

[@fahmidamallah2579]

Its wrong information.

[@UsmanAli-jm7jp]

YA ALLAH AS 😭🤲🕋🤲😭

[@MuhammadAli-ug3hx]

Jhooti report such is k bar aks ha

[@ghulammujtaba3360]

Parachanar ma zainabioun ka nam sa shioo na force bani houi h jo sham aor iraq ma suni musalmano ka khilaf Qatal o garat ma mulawis h ino na Fc par b bohat attack kiy han ya hi fasaad ki asal jarh han

[@saimmalik361]

Q k suni deshatgard qom hain, sunio ne Pakistan main deshatgardi karky 85,000 Pakistani shaheed kiye hain or FC or Shia ek hi hain Parachinar main Air Force ka base b hy or Pakistan bnany wala b shia hi hy so hamesha Pakistan ko nuksan pohchany waly Ahle Sunnat hain TTP or Al Qaida b Ahle Sunnat hain.

[@MoonKhan-dg5hj]

Bilkul 💯 .Iran ki shytani ha

[@naveediqbal8324]

True

[@villayavillaya8748]

​@@MoonKhan-dg5hjshatan tum mai he tha.aur yazeed lanaati b

[@FromShiaToMuslim]

true , bilkul ese he ha. main ex shia hon ye shia he fitna o fasad ki jarr hen. mene apni shia life men kbi Kisi sunni deobndi wahabi ko shio ki buzurg hastio ko bura kehte nhi suna.. lkn jab tak main shia tha meri subah b abubakar o umer o ayesha rz pr tabarra krny aur nafrat se shuru hoti thi. har majlas me in hastio ka mzaq urany walo ki hosla afzai ki jati ha 😢😢 shio me achy log b hen ko 5% se ziada nhi baqi saare nafrat aur hasad ki aag me jal rahe hen aur inki pehchan ye ha k ese log na ALLAH ka nam khud lete hen na kisi ko lene dete hen bs ali ali hussain hussain aur sahaba o umahat ul momineen pr tabarra yehi inka saara deen ha aur yehi log aksarist men hen.. ALLAH swt muj samajt sab ko hidayat de aameen

[@imranbangash7713]

یہاں تنازعہ زمین کا نہیں۔ ضمیر کا تنازعہ ھے۔۔۔۔۔۔۔

[@hajrabatool8189]

2007 Sy hamry sath ye ho Raha hai ye koi zameeni tanaza nhy hai.yha firqawareyat k name py khoon bahaya jata hai

[@abdullahafridi3363]

Kisy zameeny tanaza nhi ha...halya larayi malikhel aor boshehra mey zameny tanazy say shoro nhi howa kiya?.... tehran turi kuly am bushera walo dhamkya deta ta jisky bad masly nay firqa awran rang ikhteyar kiya

[@muhammadhashim-lk1gn]

Thanks for this important information

[@learnwithusman-01]

Nice work ❤

[@muhammedqasim3169]

وجه۔محترمه۔وھى۔پرانى۔۔۔جرنىلى گروپ۔دوسرا۔گروپ۔۔مد۔مقابل۔ھے

[@mohammadkhalid569]

Good research based informative news report as a credible senior journalist of bbc Islamabad stay blessed with happiness peace and success in your professional life - Mohammad Ali Khalid freelance journalist Chicago Illinois USA

[@shamshadahmad6725]

After long time I am listening you.

[@mashkoorahmad4119]

I Requst Please reveiw this report

[@munawarqaziqazi9738]

بہترین رپورٹ فرحت جاوید نے تیار کی ھے۔

[@Saadkhan-hf8ii]

Shia mu s lim zindabad. Quadi -e-azam jina shia the.ins all ha shia mu s lim qamyab hongy..

[@shafiqanwar80]

Zindabad ka nara lagane sey phly tehqeq kro phly hey shia ney army k saat melki zelay mey kaam sunni abade ko b dakhal keya hey 50 gao sey sunni abade chle gaye hey apne zameen sb kuch peche chor k ab ek gao reh gaya tha os pr b shia ney hmla keya os k retalition mey hey sunni ney un pr hmla keya hey aur afghanistan pr ilzam lagane sey phly history dekho jb shia ney sunni abade ko nekal deya zaley sey tu sunni ney road bn keye tu shia afghanistan k through hey peshawar aate thy

[@nasirali-wj6kj]

😂😂😂 Shia Muslim kb se ho gae

[@Saadkhan-hf8ii]

@@nasirali-wj6kj All ha ki sabse pyre, nazdeek s hia hote hy, ye Ali.

[@nasirali-wj6kj]

@@Saadkhan-hf8ii koofey walon ka ALLAH ko pta he muafiqon ka

[@Saadkhan-hf8ii]

@@nasirali-wj6kj YA ALI MADAT subhan All ha haque Bayani.

[@aamirnawazkhan2191]

Afsos

[@top10m.speakers69]

I am from Parachinar

[@uzairhussain4571]

Please reveiw this report

[@muhammadmutiuurrahmandanwar]

i am want urdu or english subtitle

[@abduljamil3220]

hokomat kaha hy? awr jb b generals ko jb b larai ki zarorat ho yany paisy ki tu wo aisy masail pida kr lity hy awr ab sb janty hy yeh kon kerwata hy

[@samihassan2359]

Sittam Tu yeh hai k riyasati diffai idaaray khud he shiddat Pasand tanzeemon ki sarparasti Kerti rahi hai. Jesh e mohammed, Lashkar e jhangvi, TTP, TLP Sab he foj k banaai hooway dehshatgard tanzeemain Hain,, inhon ne riyasat main qatal or khof k siwai or Kuch Nahi kiya

[@saamahmood1]

Hum duniya Ki behtreen fouj hain aur humara siasaat say koee taluq nahi 😢😅

[@shahchan7915]

Iss sari report m saf pta chl Raha k JB lari shoro ki takferiyoun n ki shia n nhi lkin dafha zaroor keya Jo haq BNTA h

[@attamohammed5139]

کچھ لوگ بلکہ بد حواہ جان بوجھکر اس مسلے کو حل کرنا نہیں چاھتے۔ کوئی بھی مسلہ حل ھو سکتا ھے۔افسوس

[@anmolshrivastava4179]

Anchor is beautiful and elegant. Not here for news only for her

[@MuhammadYasin-of2qq]

ایک اچھی رپورٹ سننے کو ملا ۔ جو کسی کا طرف دار نہیں تھا

[@zadcourt]

You called sunni Muslims into TTP Al qaida but all shias when killed sunnis Muslims your words are silent

[@jaanali8193]

Bohat zayada afsos Hy ye Sach Hy k him ne apna nuqsan kr rahe Hy

[@fahadbaloch2221]

Riyasat kidhar he?? Kya zameeno ka record rakhna private logon ka Kam he?? Ye Ac DC sirf tamasha dekhne ki tankha le rhe hain?? Lumber 1 Kahan he??

[@bachoogranger]

Ye zamini tanaza nhn hai . Zamini tanaza hota rou taliban sarhad par se akay maryar goloon se shias par hamla na krtay. Jab jirgay ne shia qabeelay k haq mien faisla de diya tha tou phr zameen ka bahana bna kr hamla kiya gaya.. ye shia sunni masla nhn. Hamla awar takfiri wahabi hain jo apne ap ko sunni kehla kar un k peeche chupne ki koshish krte hain. BBC kiyun nhn bta rha k woh takfiri molvi koun tha jis ne masjid k loud speaker se shias k qatal ka fatwa jari kiya aur jhooti baten phelaen. Ye pehli dafa nhn hua takfiriyun ne hamesha agreement ko touda hai. Ab koun shuhda k wursa ko insaf dilaye ga. Koun gardanen katne walay qatiloon ko saza de ga??

[@ShamasAbbas-vf7ct]

یا رحمان یا رحیم

[@AdnanAbbas-ib4hv]

پاکستان کا کوئی ایسا کونا بتائیں جہاں پر زمین پہ اتنی لڑائی ہوتی ہے اور اتنا تناظرہ ہو تو

[@durjan7997]

جبکہ ملک کی حکومت کے قانون فوج کے سربراہ ہوتا تو ملک کے یہ حالت ہو گا

[@shehnilsaba3940]

Sari duniya minority pe zulm o sitam Q hote hain 🤔 nihayat afsosnaak baat hai

[@quqnuz]

Fact Check. All the Sunnis were driven out by force by Shia majority from Parachinar. Boshera village is a small one having around 200 households and all around is thousands of Shia majority.

[@jawadahmad-ju4lu]

Okay

[@sabirshahjaji8136]

پارچنار جامع مسجد 18 سال سے بند ہے

[@LailaZafar-h4c]

Who will settle these land disputes?😢

[@fizanasif4625]

I've stayed in kurram agency,sadda,hangu and other agencies like Khyber,orakzai, North waziristan when I was in military . But Alhumdulillah I'm safe and civilized