Bee Gees - I Started A Joke (Live in Las Vegas, 1997 - One Night Only)

Join the Bee Gees on
Facebook - / beegees
Twitter - / beegees
Instagram - / beegees
From the album & film 'BEE GEES - ONE NIGHT ONLY'
BUY THE FILM ON BLURAY
Amazon USA amzn.to/17nlV6O
Amazon Canada amzn.to/1dGNfyd
Amazon UK amzn.to/1aulCJ4
Amazon France amzn.to/194GPLG
Amazon Germany amzn.to/18pHtUN
Amazon Spain amzn.to/13A4U4K
Amazon Japan amzn.to/16Lf30N
BUY THE FILM ON DVD
Amazon USA amzn.to/1dGMK7v
Amazon Canada amzn.to/15KjZUf
Amazon UK amzn.to/1bL0i3y
Amazon France amzn.to/1brrg1G
Amazon Germany amzn.to/1aun0eU
Amazon Spain amzn.to/15oR9ZL
Amazon Japan amzn.to/18pHPL6
BUY THE CD
Amazon USA amzn.to/18myobU
Amazon Canada amzn.to/1aTaDN4
Amazon UK amzn.to/14hyWAw
Amazon France amzn.to/18myyjC
Amazon Germany amzn.to/14hBcIf
Amazon Spain amzn.to/18pHEPX
Amazon Japan amzn.to/18mzbcU
DOWNLOAD THE ALBUM
iTunes itunes.apple.co...
Amazon USA amzn.to/1bL0zn7
Amazon UK amzn.to/15KiCoE
Amazon France amzn.to/1bL0K1Y
Amazon Germany amzn.to/13maMTA
Amazon Spain amzn.to/13mblN6
Amazon Japan amzn.to/11ZzsD1
STREAMING ONLINE
Deezer www.deezer.com/...
Grooveshark grooveshark.com...
Last.FM www.last.fm/mus...
MySpace myspace.com/be...
Rdio www.rdio.com/ar...
Rhapsody www.rhapsody.co...
Slacker www.slacker.com...
Spotify open.spotify.co...
© Manx Productions Inc. 1997
℗ Barry Gibb, The Estate of Robin Gibb and The Estate of Maurice Gibb, under exclusive license to Capitol Music Group

[@SoftRockMusic83]

I believe that somewhere in the world, there are people who feel the same emotions that I feel when I listen to masterpieces like this song.

[@user-hz5yb4bh5v]

Maybe

[@RedDevil-hh2ud]

Surely😢 like me

[@antoniopereiradouradodoura6483]

Concordo plenamente com vc linda demais essa música como vc falou uma obra prima show

[@darrenhawkins3014]

I do

[@darrenhawkins3014]

Some art tells a secret

[@ste9071]

The Joke was never on you Rob, the joke was on those whom laughed when you fell, because unlike them, you got back up and kept pushing forward, they didn't. RIP buddy, such a hauntingly beautiful song, ❤

[@Ivorytickler12341]

Do you know why this was written?

[@jerryc8978]

Why is the audio fucked up?

[@eileenbussey6926]

Robin was such a sweetheart. The best voice of the group. He sang from his heart. God I miss him. ❤

[@gaylasmith5279]

Robin had such a gift!❤

[@MarizeteOliveiradasilva]

Ele já morreu?

[@LeandroMoraes-h6b]

​@@MarizeteOliveiradasilvasim

[@nostromo7928]

Robin's voice could wring tears from the coldest heart. I'm so sorry that poor Barry had to soldier on without his brothers.

[@Renata.06]

​@@MarizeteOliveiradasilvasim, em maio vai fazer 12 anos 😢🕊

[@LeslieMor]

As a 53 year old man that never caught on to the Bee Gees until two months ago. My goodness. This performance reduces me to tears

[@govikes689]

58 here buddy - this hit deep to me too ... hang in there!

[@maxinenapoli470]

It was such a great concert!😊

[@henryshu6265]

I'm a 23 year old who loved vintage songs since 8 years old, every single piece of knowledge I know about Bee Gees and artists from the same era are by searching on the internet, and I have to say older songs really are the best songs!

[@henryshu6265]

@@govikes689 I'm 23, and I'm absolutely obsessed of almost all of their work as well! I grew tired of new songs since I was around 18, because I've discovered an absolute treasure ever since!

[@dojeitoqueeufacoj.alvessp5978]

eu amo essa música ele cantava com o coração ❤️ saudades 😔

[@gjsjk8787]

Don't be sad that there is only one Beegee remaining. Rather be happy that you got the chance to know them and got to listen to their amazing music.

[@heiket5136]

Schöne Antwort… Ich bin auch gerade nostalgisch… und froh, mit dieser Musik den großen Teil meines Lebens verbracht zu haben ♥️😇

[@michelleadams1212]

I believe the girls are with us as well.

[@danielpatton3810]

Q​@@michelleadams1212

[@gilbertojesuszapatacervera]

0pñpll O 0:12 ñ😂​@@heiket5136

[@NicolasDifroscia-jc8sn]

Well said ❤️

[@loreleilee453]

My husband and I attended this show. Robin’s beautiful song/voice made me cry. All 3 of Barry’s brother’s are gone, but their music will live on. ❤️💜❤️💜❤️

[@josevicenteoliveira4423]

ok

[@susanrimmington5067]

Loved the beegees x

[@margamuller5596]

Tpöl

[@ms.guanajaylover3714]

One is still alive.

[@boogieboy1974]

@@josevicenteoliveira4423 amazing response 👍🏻

[@user-yt2xc2bf4t]

An absolute masterpiece, robin. You and this song belong in the music hall of fame. Barry, you make sure that happens. Don't stop until it becomes so. Let's put it to a vote. Hands down, this song is unmatched in performance and songwriting. Robin certainly deserves this long, overdo recognition. Such an immense talent. And it all came so naturally to him. 😢 Rip

[@MelbaSmith-kv6fd]

Wow I couldn’t have said that better !!! It should be one of the great songs of all time. Robin sings like an ANGEL. RIP. 🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋

[@mariepoivey3388]

Magnifique ❤❤

[@jasoncheriton1836]

I miss Maurice, Robin and Andy… all legends in their own right! Thinking of you Barry! Some of us still struggle to believe too! ❤

[@tracyw1123]

There is no comparable voice (then or now) to Robin's soulful vibrato. He was able to convey more emotion in a single song than most musicians can wish for in a lifetime.

[@georgealurac6688]

Aloha hienz57 says I wanted to tell him you did love

[@thewolf81lobo86]

Tracy, Roy Orbison

[@lindseyhart4562]

Yes he is missed

[@marthaakamartiwhipple7093]

Rest in peace Robin. I agree completely Tracy ... What a performer

[@JanWhorton]

Robin's dancing was legendary too to me.

[@beatlesqueen341]

Robin Gibb truly had the voice of an angel, and I really love this song!

[@leahelam6073]

Me, too! I loved Robin! How could anyone not?

[@rommeleduardoumanzor5818]

Barry had a such beautiful voice too I mean Has, because he is Still Alive

[@melodytanguin5767]

breadvdiary

[@marciapavanello7044]

Concordo, a mais linda voz, não há outra!

[@barneyronnie]

He started my heart beating, and I finally fell totally in love with Robin to this very day. RIP you dear human being!

[@saraalba3324]

I miss your beautiful voice...may you rest in peace...😢

[@RichardRoberto-n5s]

Hello there,I guess you must beca huge fan of the bee gee too 😊

[@tomw.5074]

This song has been playing in my head for last few days after watching Baby Reindeer. I never realized til now how profoundly sad this song is.

[@juanmingot1094]

This song's been in muy mind for decades. Think over why ir is that you discovered this song recently, wh😂y people do like It NOW,.and why this version.... Think It over....

[@donovanshepperd9209]

I always knew it.

[@margretmoorkamp9547]

Ich auch 🫶🫶​@@donovanshepperd9209

[@cindygoodpaster1776]

It’s about suicide…Robin wrote it on an airplane.

[@donovanshepperd9209]

@@cindygoodpaster1776 Wow I didnt know it was about suïcide 😯. But did Robin had those feelings than?

[@luxurylinr56]

A beautiful song that conveys so many feelings dealing with life’s choices, regrets, losses, pains, confusion, disillusionment. Mr. Robin sings it with such sincerity and love, that it actually ministers to hurting souls and brings comfort thru relating to our common plight as human beings.

[@helensomeone6167]

Beautiful......

[@belindairvine1666]

Yes, this 🙌

[@peteryoungren688]

There is hope in there as well.

[@igorxamas5116]

Beautiful words

[@silentwatch1]

Robin was a very mysterious and talented man gone too soon ❤

[@SheilaMatthews-zu6lm]

I love the respect Barry showed by turning his back to the audience giving Robin the chance to be front and center. Which was rightly owed. R.I.P Andy, Maurice and Robin ❤️

[@moffat2028]

He always did that.

[@EvanFrenchMusic93]

That says a lot about Barry and just makes me love the beegees even more! Not only were they brothers on stage, but they were brothers OFF stage too! They never let ego, fame, or anything else EVER break that brotherly bond!

[@user-eg5lg7tq2b]

Carambameuperdiermeunamorado

[@user-xr7wb5mx3g]

E ainda fez isso com estilo de profissional que era

[@Castymiss1]

Robin and Barry did have a falling out over who should be the main singer. ​@EvanFrenchMusic93

[@pheinkens5986]

The voice of that man... Could make the biggest baddest cry like a baby

[@jonfletcher147]

So true!

[@DEOO100]

Must be at least three generations that sadly have missed out on these fabulous lads, I am lucky enough to have followed their career from day one.

[@janerigg9358]

Me too. But anyone interested in exploring music knows them, their progression, the history of the time etc.... as much as anyone can.

[@teresahatfield4521]

A beautiful man with a beautiful voice. He is missed so much!

[@Sconzette]

I loved Robin's voice back then and still do now, his voice only got finer like wine with time!

[@renatonunes2550]

This is the BEE GEES' song I like the most. ROBIN sang it so beautifully and the lyrics ( he compsed the song and wrote the lyrics are so soul wrenching ! He was a beautiful Human Being. R.I.P..

[@gunnarlinde9781]

Awesome best voice from the 3 bee gees

[@Shall721]

I listen to this song everyday. Wish I saw him sing this song. Beautiful

[@nostromo7928]

He sang so beautifully. "I looked at the sky running my hands over my eyes" and those last few descending notes give me goose bumps! He lands, shimmering, on top of those notes. A supremely beautiful voice and talent. ❤️

[@JanWhorton]

Their Mother also said Robin had the best singing voice out of her four sons! Mothers always know!

[@DRTrans100]

Will never forget the first time I heard this song, I was a young teen and my mom had bought me a 5 album set, basically the British invasion, the song moved me then, and still does, the song had so much hurt in it!

[@libertyfighter76]

Wonderful...Robin had such a passionate, captivating and soft spoken singing voice that Bee Gees fans can all relate to. Bee Gees music will never fade away, age or be forgotten. 😄❤️

[@patriciaswitzer3634]

I can listen to his voice day after day . Loved them in my teens and still love them to this day. Over 50 years have passed.

[@christineterpens3136]

I feel exactly the same, never tire of these beautiful songs.

[@MarkZook]

Me too, Patricia

[@josimarplaenge7794]

Eu ti amo.

[@user-kt8rv6zt3o]

Yes over 55years

[@210sjourney3]

Legends never DIE!

[@hilaryashen9746]

The tone of Robins voice especially in this song is so beautiful it always brings me to tears...🌹

[@alexfrankie9142]

Same here. his tone is so heavenly, I love it. ❤️ What part of the World are you listening from?

[@andrealmeida1987]

Wow, simply wonderful, exceptional and fantastic …

[@ksb9469]

Same here. I can listen again and again. I listened to their music as a teenager from another part of the world and still listening living in North America.

[@mariececile3973]

The same for me.

[@RichardRoberto-n5s]

Hello there,I guess you must beca huge fan of the bee gee too 😊

[@spearsrhonda56]

Robin truly had the best voice of the group . He was the most under appreciated of all.

[@strangeuniverse1199]

I never cared for their falsetto voiced Disco stuff but I enjoyed everything else they did.

[@marknewton6984]

Not by me.

[@Rose-bf9oz]

I find that the most underrated of them was Maurice.

[@JanWhorton]

Mothers know best too; and she'd said Robin had the best voice of all!

[@belleferrar8898]

I heard this song after Massachusetts (1967) and I was in love with the Bee Gees. This song and Massachusetts will always hold a special place in my heart. Can never go wrong with anything this group ever sang ❣❣❣

[@kansha3503]

I wonder if Barry still listens to all these tracks. Especially ones like this. He said he misses them everyday If I was him, I'd cry a river.

[@MikhaelAhava]

IcantPickaBias Well.

[@dianaverbeek5549]

IcantPickaBias. Your so richt!!! Best voice! So glad i ham see him ilive. in Rotterdam. Good time!!!

[@carkal9906]

But nice he was so close with his brothers. Have one sibling who is manevolent, worse than stranger. Always longed for close family.

[@williampashak1641]

IcantPickaBias so sad Barry.

[@sarahramnath4929]

Listening to Robin's voice takes me to another dimension. I always reflect on my childhood days with these songs, truly magnificent.

[@gedeondiasdasilva7381]

Ouvi essa voz é como parar no tempo, porque outra igual jamais ouviremos

[@rloornelas5043]

Me also It just reaches so deep. Kinda crazy

[@dianeh.4287]

True

[@let-the-light-shine6543]

Same here and yes, truly magnificent

[@franciscaalbuquerque4682]

Maravilhosa

[@ancadinu5302]

Awesome! I never was a big Bee Gee's Fan, but as I mature I become more open to different talents and find myself listening for the special talents like Robin Gibb and I am amazed by his voice.

[@IsabelleLima-iy4gg]

em 2024 quem ainda ama essa musica da um like aqui .. e olha que só tenho 28 anos!

[@rosegelindon2561]

Baby reendead When I started a joke

[@antoniomarcio9043]

A música é tão linda quanto você meu amor ❤ te desejo toda felicidade do mundo ❣️

[@antoniomarcio9043]

A canção é tão linda 💕 e ouvindo ela é como um sonho de inverno em seus braços de ternura e amor.

[@JoseGijon-il4vd]

Te saludo desde Argentina.amo está canción con la vos más genial de Robin

[@user-sr5zf8ms9z]

いいねぇ!

[@lilac408]

I never, never get tired of listening to their amazing music. I'm here in November 2020 to escape the madness engulfing our country at this sad and scary time.

[@beth3175]

J'aime cette musique! Eu amo esta música!!! Eu também nunca vou deixar de ouvi-la!!!

[@robstone8013]

Here with you. We will survive & come back better than ever. Hang in there.

[@pamelawagner3507]

I’m here with you

[@suzettebavier4412]

I'm with You, Lilac(my dear departed Mother's favorite color)😭😭😭😭

[@guntherwheeler_]

fuck trump

[@guaporichard]

Big Bee Gees fan all my life. Didn't get Robin's voice till I heard this song. I now love it for all its magnificence and vulnerability. Great rendition!

[@samuelbruyneel]

I love how Barry turns his back to the audience during this song, to give Robin his time to shine. In "For Whom The Bell Tolls" Robin shines as well.

[@dianasills-bailin3731]

I’ve always loved Robin’s voice. Actually I felt it had a poignant quality that I don’t hear in other voices. We miss these guys so much. Sorry that three of the Gibbs Andy, Maurice and Robin died when they were so young. God bless them and all the beautiful songs they left us

[@33whiskey69]

Robin's talent will not be duplicated. How one family could have so many talented singers is amazing.

[@michaeloconnor3396]

I just love this song and the joke was never on you when you died the joke was on us r.i.p robin Gibbs gone too soon and never forgotten

[@veronern]

Same here. I just wish he knew

[@susanroxas1583]

Here after my Dad passed away still the best song he always loved. 2024 🥂

[@JanWhorton]

Sweet memory of your Dad.🎵❤‍🩹

[@rmoore1686]

This song will keep Robin in people’s hearts always.

[@cleliapereira2353]

Linda ❤🎉 música

[@deborahaughtman2936]

There will never be another voice like Robin Gibbs. Never

[@jefsomar1534]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gICwXmyYqruobNU

[@laureldevine]

True.

[@estelleschneider9033]

One of a kind

[@timhall8805]

so true never . Bee gees ruled the day . never will be forgot

[@debbiedonaldson1722]

NO THERE WONT!

[@lawrenceseow7252]

His natural vibrato voice is pure genius. A most unique voice which is hard to imitate.

[@iremarmaverick5323]

Meu Deus ... ouvindo essa musica , paro e penso .... " Será que os outros que a ouvem também se identificam ? " ... Incrível , é tipo uma revelação . Extraordinário !

[@hpkeong]

If I die, I only wants this song to be sing for me. Whenever I visit any pubs. If I sing, this is the only song I sing without looking at lyrics... It is auto input to my lips

[@liza7581]

Sim, com certeza é maravilhosa toca até na alma

[@lindaebert789]

I think of Jesus 🛐✝️♾️💜

[@renancostavenancio3495]

Pra quem é Melancólico com certeza 😅

[@jaimemarzionna649]

Eu me identifico demais. Tenho 75 anos e não esqueço aquela época. Para mim é o maior conjunto de todos os tempos.

[@GaryWells-sr2rf]

I have been listening to you all since you started singing. I’m 69 now and I’m still listening!! ❤❤

[@anthonyvaracallo3490]

me too

[@JanWhorton]

Bless you. I'm a 66 year old female fan; and haven't stopped listening to his solos every night. 💖🌹🌌🌈

[@kenhatchett7645]

Feel so lucky to have grown old with these guys never get tired of listening to the bee gees

[@fredtolode9782]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gICwXmyYqruobNU

[@charlessutton9588]

Too true Ken

[@paulopereirarodriguesperei6054]

Saudades

[@susanbehring8309]

Me too

[@leneschrder5569]

Me too ❤️❤️❤️

[@vitorlucena1183]

Cara, esse cara NASCEU para cantar. A voz dele é melhor que terapia. MARAVILHOSO!!! Meu Deus!

[@jeanalzaidi908]

Yes he had the voice too move your heart

[@MaxAlcantara-mc3qi]

So.k.anma.sabe.ovalo.du.muzica.filozofica

[@paulbrouwer4717]

Beautyfull human also

[@trunglufu]

R.I.P Robin. One of my favorites songs of all time

[@silentwatch1]

Anyone here NOT because of baby reindeer but because you have good taste?

[@kats-r1781]

Me!

[@debroselle8877]

Me too 😢

[@annap.4204]

:-))))))

[@terijones5673]

I don't know what baby reindeer taste like?

[@debroselle8877]

@@terijones5673 like nostalgia 😁

[@hopeausbyn1734]

Crying my eyes out. This is a song that touches me deeply. Bee Gees Forever!

[@mery5188]

Amazing snd beatiful😢

[@oscarrodriguez-jc9xr]

ME ENCANTA ESA CANCION🥰🤩🤩

[@jerryplatt-ji3oq]

Love this so much. Grew up with The Bee Gees music! I too am moved by this song.

[@jaureguikevin]

It's amazing how they wrote their own songs and turned them into international hits, which artist from today does that? no one. The Bee Gees were not only amazing singers, but truly artists that knew how to convey feelings through their lyrics and wonderful vocals

[@JansenHardage]

Bruno Mars writes all his songs and writes several hits for other artists as well. But I agree with you. No one does that as much anymore

[@zGrover402]

+Kevin Jauregui The most of the artists do that, stop being dramatic

[@martind586]

+Kevin Jauregui .....Not to mention they were doing it BEFORE the Beatles!

[@revolver1209]

true true

[@yumatoma9010]

+Kevin Jauregui Now this was talent and people did not appreciate it, then. A unique group, what a shame they are no longer with us.

[@cacildapaulino1588]

Que voz linda ❤ impossível esquecer Robin e seus irmãos BeeGees. Alguém ouvindo essa música em 2024? 29 07 2024.

[@adrianadomingos7088]

Linda música e a voz então é maravilhosa 😍❤

[@inesdelmonte5962]

Yo la escucho muchas veces... siemprr.

[@MatheusFernandes-vw1kh]

Me lembro de está na casa da minha vó final de semana coloca no toca disco que sdds

[@JorgeLuiz-mu8np]

eu muito linda

[@EarlHutton2030]

"And I fell out of bed hurting my head from things that I said" -- that lyrics just gets me every time I listen to it.

[@hmackie6823]

Note how Barry turns his back to the audience to Give Robin the full audience attention,,,he's a great Brother

[@NKhan-sk9ko]

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!So true.

[@elainebuist3887]

Yes. Wonderful. He often commented how painful his missing Robin (& Maurice) is.

[@gjsjk8787]

What a great comment. Only realized now. So beautiful

[@suegeren9347]

They had so many arguments, broke up and stop speaking over who should sing the lead, Barry said each time one of them passed away was during a time when they were on bad terms and if possible he would give it all away just to have one more day with his brothers. He said their best days were before they became famous.

[@Sconzette]

Respect!!

[@hamdanjantan399]

The voice from Robin Gibbs when singing this beautiful song was indeed came from his heart, full of sadness. Life is so short.

[@nickprica3127]

yes you got to make the most of it but with songs like this its worth living every moment

[@wilsonwalker1181]

@@nickprica3127 Hello. How are you doing?

[@maryjodurivage1941]

Amen!! Love this guy.

[@dsfatelamasarasidmpodestin3864]

DSFATELAMASARASI DMPODESTINAXIXIIISTELLARISSADA DSFATELAMASARASI DMPODESTINAXIXIIISTELLARISSADA 1 second ago AUTOMATICMEDIASERVICEBFIDE2025[@]ZEDDIEMC2.GROUND2050747ITB[@]SDDSXXAPRILIANEZPLM65SPARETIMEPAZERI2025[@}ROMEOBLEEDINGLORD OF WAR2100[]MEMBER YMI-ITB.DAGOPARK DR.NOBELIHINDIA2005PLANNINGPEACEWORLDDISCOCERI2016[@]SERA2020X21ZPLM65LAND21X2020SERA@GMAILCOM[]NS2000SETTISIEZACANNALISTANILESETTIITB1978[]

[@maiqtheliar_]

Bee Gees is the greatest and most talented group ever

[@JanWhorton]

You were always the best! We’ll never forget you😂❤❤❤😂 May God rest your soul!❤ 2:54 2:57 3:01

[@souksouryachak5003]

Very underrated group. Definitely one of the greats

[@cliffbovingdon8980]

That sang magically in harmony, No singing lessons whatsoever, Thier voices are pure, John Farnham is the same.... Never forget any of them,,,

[@justindesouza9662]

No Robin... the joke was never on you. Thru' the years you made us happy, you made us smile with your beautiful voice. The day you died.. the world cried. The joke was on us.

[@jmsg_PR]

Wow... that was heart-touching and you’re right, the joke’s on us

[@lastsurvivor6406]

Justin De Souza very touching

[@marlicastro2712]

Justin De Souza is true

[@JimJams304]

Wow your great

[@videosdeportivosymuchomas4177]

You got It when he died we cried

[@proudgram61]

There has never been a voice like Robin's. So appreciated by fans and very much loved and missed...

[@9675775]

I'm old enough to remember seeing Robin on TV in the 60s singing this so touching song. Even today it brings tears to my eyes.

[@SamtheMan0508]

@@9675775 Me too. Of course back then it was rare to see them on TV. I think we only had 3 stations and were lucky if all 3 came in clearly.

[@aliceandrade4364]

This song. Always. Forever. Wow. What's particularly beautiful about this video is they've grown up -- no antics on stage, no trying to steal the spotlight from the one singing. Just 3 men making beautiful music together on stage.

[@jameshawkins8966]

In all honesty this man right here is one of the most UNDERRATED GREATEST MALE VOCALIST EVER

[@reginalimoso7847]

I agree with u sir..

[@donnaleone9895]

I read their biography & it said that Robin had a "plaintiff vibrato" voice. I love his voice.

[@laiabarbosa9896]

Lindo demais eu amo

[@carolegibbs8856]

I never thought he was underrated.

[@amigarcia1959]

@@donnaleone9895 hi what does it mean by plaintiff? Mam may I know which biograply who is the author?

[@crotalusatrox7931]

This song so meaningful to me as a youngster back in the 1960's. 2022 now and I'm an old man and this song more meaningful than ever. Music is Life!

[@augustusmamaril2003]

TIM, you're so right. The BeeGees have been around when we were much younger. I'm old too but very much in love with their music. Why do you think is that so, Tim?

[@paulburick1506]

You got that right ,Tim!. I extract more from this song now at age 68.

[@mycharnie]

@@paulburick1506 lying here in 2022 listening and loving this still at 67yo

[@markneedham8726]

Gotcha. Yup 74, gets that way. Memories, friends, moments, times. Most just that, and no going back. Lifts the heart. edit:- Oh, and the year I married. Still together. Still mates. 54 years of love.

[@bunkertons]

That's beautiful, Tim! Thanks for sharing.

[@silvioantonio5798]

Alguém do Brasil ouvindo 2024??🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@alexandreprestesboffa2283]

Pela trilhonésima vez...

[@adaomendes7656]

@@alexandreprestesboffa2283 Eu stou ouvindo

[@andrearodrigues710]

Euuuuuu

[@darlancrepaldi279]

Yeah, digo, sim

[@susanacabeleira7325]

Guauuuuuu. No puedo parar de escuchar ❤❤❤❤

[@Christina-uh8xk]

Robin's voice was so amazing!

[@andrewvincent5472]

This song and voice rips at the inner core of my soul.

[@mccellen]

I agree, Andrew..what IS it about Robin's voice that has millions of us in tears..and will always love him the most..

[@valquiriasantos4900]

euuuu aqui🙌

[@rebornnowami2013]

Mine too, Andrew. Mine too. Miss him so much.

[@jeremyvargas5819]

Just magnificent

[@miguelbahena6524]

I miss him he was a good man he always something about his voice makes us cry sometimes.🤔😭

[@heijnsdijk1]

The best song and voice! That's the way to expres your feelings. Robin, thank you for that! Rest in peace, we won't forget you!!!

[@alfredbernasek]

FÜR DIE EWIGKEIT TRAUMHAFT SCHÖN

[@user-ho6er5ny8b]

I'm here , the 1999 girl who loves this song since I was 6 :")

[@katysarahyortega2089]

Yo conocí a los beegees por mi papá, le encantaban todas sus canciones pero no hay otra canción cómo "I started a joker" que le llegaba al alma, y hace unos dias falleció y como su último deseó pidió que en su sepultura se le pusiera está canción y así fue...🕊️✨

[@BasketCase420]

I started a joke Which started the whole world crying But I didn't see That the joke was on me, oh no I started to cry Which started the whole world laughing Oh, if I'd only seen That the joke was on me I looked at the skies Running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed Hurting my head from things that I'd said 'Til I finally died Which started the whole world living Oh, if I'd only seen That the joke was on me I looked at the skies Running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed Hurting my head from things that I'd said 'Til I finally died Which started the whole world living Oh, if I'd only seen, oh yeah That the joke was on me, oh no That the joke was on me Oh, no, no, no

[@gersonfernandes3138]

Obrigado 🙏

[@user-ir9vh8kr9t]

OBRIGADO. PELA ATENÇÃO DA LETRA​@@gersonfernandes3138

[@tangwong9542]

I can’t find any one can replace them after so many years, I would say thy are even much better than Beatles (in my opinion)

[@renzocaldato4651]

Unici si ballava stretti stretti che......ricordi questa è musica..... Continuo a sognare

[@bear-qe7ep]

respect+

[@leoniesalmon1203]

far better than the beatles

[@amribrahim5468]

For sure they are better

[@HarryJ123456789]

I was 15 and had to listen to my fathers idol Neil Diamond, now I am 60 and love to hear him sing all hij beautiful songs

[@jennymilenaleongomez8860]

No me canso de decir que es la versión inigualable de una canción entonada con sentimiento, nadie la ha podido igualar, menos superar 💖🥰🇨🇴

[@alritehamilton]

Such a unique voice, doubt there will ever be anything like it again. Beautiful!

[@northernlad9424]

Nanci Toerper no never

[@mariodaniloalvesdasilva4004]

voce e luz

[@timothyjoseph6586]

The joke was on us. RIP one of the greatest singers of all time

[@rosegelindon2561]

Never reendead 😢

[@user-cm5xc2yx4t]

Indeed!

[@charlesbruno3111]

IN MY YOUNGER YEARS ALL OF THEIR SONGS WERE ALWAYS ON THE RADIO AT THE BEACH,, AND EVERYWHERE YOU GO.. IT'S A TIME THAT'S LONG GONE.. AND IT MAKES ME SAD

[@filippodaragona.4749]

No autotune, just pure class

[@cleliapereira2353]

Linda música 🎉❤

[@JanWhorton]

He was in every way pure class! Love him!

[@mccellen]

Robin's voice brings on tears...RIP sweet soul...you are terribly missed and still loved.

[@terrymarshall3474]

Love this song brings a odd tear or 2

[@ChelseyWinnie101]

Best of the voices of Bee Gees. Robin's voice is unmistakable.

[@wilsonwalker1181]

Hello Laurie Flood. How are you doing?

[@user-yt2xc2bf4t]

Oh, what can said about dear robin? Of course, the voice of an angel that turns you inside out, and like his brother, barry once said, 'no one sings like you", rob. That sums it up for me, and of course, the emotion and 'trance-like state' he puts you in with his god-given vocals. Truly magical. Definitely 'hall' worthy. An unforgettable piece of music by the master, robin gibb. "I started a joke". Upon hearing the first few bars, you know the 'magic' is beginning, and so it goes, and everything is right in the world for the next few minutes. Thank you, robin. Your 'famous" and we're grateful.

[@cowboys68]

The only singer in the world who did this song justice. A song the each individual will interpret they're own individual way.

[@ClaraLV878]

I seriously feel Robin’s emotions here, so sad😢2021 still loving this song

[@maurohenrique6009]

I

[@stevetorrez4390]

Me too. 😥

[@jadamills4082]

2021,me too

[@ludwiggraupe7571]

Love this Song forever... And i am shure in hundreds of years somebody loves this Masterpiece. All Masterpieces from the Bee Gees. LG from Vienna Austria

[@divinecapones4415]

the emotion of the songs very memorable..still watching...jan14,2021... my fav...

[@softmusic9437]

*2022 and still here, what a beautiful song. Too much love for everyone who listening to this songs. May God keep us healthy into this pandemic.*

[@tipakongphan3250]

🎶😍

[@softmusic9437]

@@tipakongphan3250 hi

[@tipakongphan3250]

@@softmusic9437 🎶😍🌍🌎🌏🇹🇭💐

[@softmusic9437]

@@tipakongphan3250 hi

[@jwhn06]

I am 15yrs old and i love listening their songs too😍🎶

[@menmen2924]

I started a joke which started the whole world crying But I didn't see that the joke was on me oh no I started to cry which started the whole world laughing Oh If I'd only seen that the joke was on me I looked at the skies running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed hurting my head from things that I said 'Till I finally died which started the whole world living Oh if I'd only seen that the joke was on me I looked at the skies running my hands over my eyes And I fell out of bed hurting my head from things that I said 'Till I finally died which started the whole world living Oh if I'd only seen that the joke was on me Oh no that the joke was on me

[@An-Astral-Plane]

Robin's mom said he was the best singer of her boys. Yeah, she said it.

[@JanWhorton]

Wow! Mother knows best.💔💟🌹

[@hi_is_me_ben5738]

I love the way Barry turns away and lets the entire spotlight highlight just how great Robin was.

[@jefsomar1534]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gICwXmyYqruobNU

[@RichardRoberto-n5s]

Hello there,I guess you must beca huge fan of the bee gee too 😊

[@JanWhorton]

See my reply above about Barry's severe arthritis please.

[@alexandrinamaria680]

Quanta falta faz está banda..eu os Amo desde criança..ainda bem que com a tecnologia de hoje, podemos ouvi-los qdo quizermos.😭

[@silvioribeiro4261]

Nem fala

[@miguelperes2124]

Top

[@claudiarejanbaptistaalexan3597]

Verdade😭😭😭

[@roseoliveira8364]

Alexandrina Maria vc é muito especial por gostar dos meus bee Gees... amo bee Gees

[@rmoore1686]

Robin died too soon but I’m just thankful that we had him the short time that we did. I was a teenager when the BeeGees became famous and I’ve loved them all my life.

[@carolinerangen478]

I have loved the BEE GEES for so long!! I love their music and also dont forget Andy Gibb!!!thesebrothers adapted so many times with their music and always made us love them more!!

[@RichardRoberto-n5s]

Hello there,I guess you must beca huge fan of the bee gee too 😊

[@Arfabiscuit]

It's not the song it's the voice that breaks your heart . RIP Robin great singer

[@ericviking1632]

could not agree more

[@naddyjamilrullah3565]

indeed....i repeat again and again.so in love with his voice.

[@jesusaguilar502]

exacto

[@antonioaguilar2922]

damn when did he die? I did not know :(

[@WoodJack99]

2012 he had suffered from poor health for a couple years

[@cosmosabinodossantos3977]

Belíssima música. Sua letra, seu sentido, sua melodia, interpretada por uma bela voz.

[@anapossenti5099]

Essa vai fundo na alma!😢

[@mhenriquem2913]

Letra é bem reflexiva Mas entendi que o cara se matou, e assim todos puderam viver sem se preocupar com ele

[@candlelight3232]

What a man, what a voice, what a song, what a feeling, what a time than he created this song ... So sad, this time will never come back, but so happy that I've lived in this time.

[@nostromo7928]

I love his "awe, shucks" grin as the song ended and the audience erupted in cheers. So glad they gave him so much love. Robin was special. 🥲

[@LisaButterfly-lf7vb]

How MUCH can we love Robin?? Every year our hearts expand more to receive the love he gave the world. Love you Robin.

[@jefsomar1534]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gICwXmyYqruobNU

[@omegalgo297]

Thanks...you're right 👍

[@kerry-anne39]

💧💧💧💧💧💧💧

[@phennigan]

In a 1,000 years people will be still listening to this song.

[@jp-mc2bp]

yup

[@bananaohohoh]

Love this sung so much❤❤❤I always sing this in vedioke while im alone and drinking and 😢

[@lalainedoronila4621]

I'm one of them.

[@Popculturememe]

Even in this year 4029 we still listening

[@jotasoares1920]

*A VONTADE DE CHORAR É TÃO GRANDE QND OUÇO ESSA MÚSICA.* *LINDA DEMAIS, GRANDE ROBIN GIBB, NO VOCAL, VOZ INCOMPARÁVEL, UMA PENA TERMOS PERDIDO ELE EM 2012, DESCANSE EM PAZ.* 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾 Jota Soares, Aracaju/Se

[@JoseCarlosEstopa-qs2mp]

Espetacular, espetacular simples assim mais uma vez direi espetacular

[@Valennnnm]

Their vocal harmony and the feeling they have when singing is really fabulous...it gives me goosebumps!

[@Valennnnm]

Hi!​@JamesRolls49 fine, thanks for asking. I'm really a fan of music in general, not of them specifically, but I have to admit that it's nice to listen to them!

[@Valennnnm]

@JamesRolls49 Not really, but I would have liked it.

[@Valennnnm]

@JamesRolls49 Chile

[@brandy012173]

The BEST rendition of this. This performance was the first time I'd heard it, and it just sounded so sad and painful and tragic, like only some experienced adults could know. I can picture someone standing outside late at night drenched during a downpouring rain, just standing there, looking straight up, with hot tears running down their face just as fast as the cold rain is. The truth is that I watched this performance on TV with my dad as an adult. He loved this song. My parents got divorced when I was little and it kind of destroyed him. I remember one late night with him sitting on a kitchen chair wearing his black leather suit jacket, his hair still wet combed back from a shower, and all of his clothes in a black trash bag on the floor next to him, with his eyes looking at mine trying to explain to me why his was leaving, with tears running down his face. I was 4 so I was confused. Then when I watched this with him so many years later, I realized how he felt way back then when he listened to it. Then I saw his face that night that we saw this; I felt his pain, *even though he was smiling while he watched it*. We were both very sentimental people. And one of the biggest things that we both loved that we had in common is that we both LOVED the Bee Gees. No one else we have ever known will ever get that. He never remarried again. He's gone now. And unfortunately, I now as a mature adult have gotten to experience something like that personally for myself. It's just life. Robin did a beautiful job at portraying beautiful tragedy. And ironically, *it makes me smile too* .

[@wes_knapp23]

Gosh thats a very open and honest comment. So sad but thanks for Sharing. Sorry for losing your dad too.

[@aghwesilver1131]

Hello friend

[@timothylewis2450]

Thanks for sharing your story. Sounds like you two had a close relationship. The love comes through.

[@elenadelarosa1042]

Wow! I am so sorry for everything you and your father went through. I think this song hits us all,in different ways and I do believe in our inner self we all have experienced such pain all in diff. Ways.I cannot start to began to tell of my terrible chilchood,meeting my mother at her funeral for the 1st time. How do we overcome such pain? Meeting my biological father at my mothers funeral threw me into unexplainable feeling that I think did ok holding all this anger inside,and attempted to instead put it down into poetry...pass 18 some years later those poems I never attempted again. Why??? IDK too old too many excuses? Yes! My life a BIG...?...I know good luck with that?? No one has been helpful to me all these years...everything shoved under the rug...everyone is dead or dying!!! Wtf??? Now what?

[@brandy012173]

@@elenadelarosa1042 Wow, thank you Elena, but it's all good. Well, of coarse not all good. But we loved the Bee Gee's together for good reason, and that's the moral of the story. We're not cheap customers. The Bee Gee's deserve all of their praise very honestly. ☺

[@andreaamadzogolo9753]

Rest In Perfect Peace Robin... the world is now a joke... still Loving your voice in 2021.....

[@bogusawkolesnik975]

Słucham,słucham i będę cluchac

[@zuaomedeiros3448]

@@bogusawkolesnik975 ⁰l0ĺl

[@zuaomedeiros3448]

0l

[@zuaomedeiros3448]

0ĺ0lĺ00

[@bmxultra2333]

I... looked at the sky... rubbing my eyes... over Biden's lies....

[@user-zt8wd5kh6z]

Thumbs up if Baby Reindeer brought you here.

[@stephmorais5884]

It brought back my childhood 😂

[@Sconzette]

who or what is "Baby Reindeer"?

[@scouser19a]

Thumbs up!

[@user-bx8wf9fp7o]

​@@SconzetteUK Netflix drMa

[@user-bx8wf9fp7o]

@@Sconzette uk netflix drama ost

[@cathypage6189]

This is the saddest song ever and is also one of my all time favorites❤

[@teresagilding9188]

Robin's voice was sublime. This is my favourite Bee Gees song, however, they were , as a group second to none.

[@mattsypersma6418]

Me too. I really liked the earlier songs more. I didn't like the disco thing, but after watching HBO special, I realized they were cast into disco. I never hid it from anyone that this was my favorite song from them. I wish I could sing it.

[@igorxamas5116]

I totally agree with you.... Love from Italy

[@vinniedidonato8495]

early b gees where so good

[@manojkbaishya5851]

@@vinniedidonato8495 that's my favourite song.

[@seanade3900]

I don't like this song but he put another of effort in it

[@ArthurMeyerdirect]

One of my favourites from a man with a special talent and a special voice

[@rickynuena6943]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gICwXmyYqruobNU

[@gedionmesfin1821]

No Body lasts forever, but your songs last forever RIP❤️

[@eddieagnich1875]

I've been listening to the BEE GEE's since early 60's! How lucky to have this music? I was a little kid and I can't believe i'm 67 what the hell happened? TIME! Love you all!

[@JanWhorton]

Same here as a kid who was a teenager also when the fabulous bee Gees came onto the stage! We were so blessed!

[@blackjack0226]

My Dad's favorite song. He passed away last year and today is his first year death anniversary. Miss him so much.

[@josi0719]

My dad played this song too. My dad passed in February. Miss u dad, why I'm listening to this 💕

[@andahtheo4237]

My condolences

[@jericabunao9821]

my dad's favourite song too 💔 he passed away last june 💔😭

[@clarewelter2207]

I am sorry for your loss. This is a beautiful song.

[@ritawalrath8557]

In

[@jeanbowlan2394]

The voice of an Angel. He still makes me cry....... there will never be another Robin Gibb.

[@peterturley2960]

Jean Bowlan - the resonance of his voice is on the frequency of spiritual love, that is why we cry! The voice of an Angel- always makes me cry too!! God Bless dear Robin- love you mate! xxx.

[@subhashchhabria148]

Jean Bowlan u have so aptly summarised the feelings of thousands for robin gibb

[@tarakaduaindo8975]

Aku suka beegees... Love !!!

[@emmanuelarmena4107]

Lifetime music !love you beegees!

[@jeewanjee]

I started a war, that started a war .... that made the whole world cry if I only saw that the joke was on me. I ignited a conflict, kindling flames across gaza, Where laughter once echoed, now only the sounds of strife. In my hands, a spark, that set the world alight, But in its glow, I see the error of my ways. The battles I began, a chorus of discord ringing, Underneath the stars, once bright, now dim with sorrow. In the echoes of the night, I hear the cries for peace, A plea for harmony, in a world torn by my hands. I wish for a return, to days of gentle whispers, Where swords turn to plowshares, and hearts are mended whole. In the quiet after the storm, let there be a solemn vow, For peace to reign supreme, in a world once lost to fight

[@nostromo7928]

Dang! That was a wonderful reinterpretation. Do you play the guitar too? Your rendition deserves to be heard. ❤

[@louieregaladoponce5007]

Your memories is always be remember since we are high school and now i'm 60 years of age and love the song together with my other 3 classmates because we use to sing your song during our high school life and they even called us the Little Bee Gees

[@marygarner5249]

How can any one give this Man a thumbs down all he ever did was to bring a little joy to this world

[@briancanning9291]

Ya effin rite but there is some cunts out there matey

[@de4323]

only heartless & soulless ones.

[@MissLinas]

@@briancanning9291, Oh really? Cunts? Well let's not forget the dick heads too shall we!

[@briancanning9291]

@@MissLinas hey that's why your a miss and not a Mrs 🤭🤭🤭🤭😭😭😭🥳🥳🥳

[@Iwilldestroyyoo]

brian canning ZING!!! That was hilarious! 😂