KATE'S MAKEUP SECRETS! + Why her makeup was controversial!

[@pearliegirl2870]

Where did you get your beautiful white top? I can’t find your link.

[@BeebsKelley]

bit.ly/44z7bU3

[@lilcajunqueen888]

Catherine wearing the gold ensemble for the Bond premiere was perfection.

[@barbraluce5706]

She looked smashing at the Earshot Prize Gala in Boston

[@fibanocci314]

Alexander McQueen and Catherine are a guaranteed success combo.

[@juliethompson340]

Oooh that gold dress was perfection. Prince William liked it too. Every woman wants her husband to look at her like that. Absolutely stunning.

[@vickicarreno8932]

Nice to see one on Catherine instead of the Other One.

[@ilove6kies]

She who must not be named haha

[@betmo]

catherine doesn't make as many mistakes 🤷‍♀️

[@ellevillamor4454]

Agreed

[@carolyndymond4065]

Yes I love Catherine.

[@WanjiruKimani]

Videos about ‘the other one’ get over 50K views. This one has 24K views. Talking about Meghan drives Beebs’ traffic and makes more $$$ 😝

[@mimib95]

I applauded Catherine for applying her own make up on her wedding day. What groom wants to see a complete stranger standing opposite him on their special day? And the gown was so perfect that it didn’t need too much more.

[@BeeLane-qr9fn]

Yes, her hair was nice, tidy, and appropriate, it always is anyway, not straightened and messy and overdone

[@ninabooker2904]

I never look at Princess Catherine and think about her makeup, I just see that she looks naturally pretty. She is so classy and chic.

[@chexpression2822]

Isn't it refreshing! Why do so many young women wear so much makeup? I'm not a fan of the Kardashian look and I hope it loses it's popularity.

[@micheleparker3780]

...and to me, that is exactly the point of makeup...

[@limlaith]

That's what makeup should do! Unless you're on a stage giving an address to people at a distance, makeup shouldn't be hat people notice. It's like if you're looking at a picture in a museum and what you notice is the frame, then it's been framed wrong. You're supposed to see the picture and hardly notice the frame. Princess Catherine looks gorgeous with very little makeup. The way she wears makeup only makes you notice her personality and how she shines. The former Duchess of Drama always wears makeup as though it's been applied with a trowel and she's hooking in Alphabet City.

[@lydiapicano8806]

@@limlaith Duchess of Drama, love it !

[@vbachman6742]

In other words, she's professional and classy. She is a royal princess, after all. We don't want her to look cheap and trashy. She's beautiful without having to tart her face up.

[@martyn8116]

Perfect! 👏

[@hl6876]

I agree Catherine looks perfect 99.99% of the time, it is natural occasionally she get's it wrong. She is human afterall.

[@tm0855]

Also, I love it when you call her Catherine, Princess of Wales instead of Kate. So many don’t call her Catherine.

[@judywright4241]

Which would be okay if it was evenly done. However, I’ve noticed those that say ‘Kate’ will call Harry’s wife ‘The Duchess of Sussex’, which means the diminutive is meant to be disrespectful.

[@juliethompson340]

In my opinion they call her Kate as a form of endearment. She is so approachable that it is said in a friendly way. I'm glad that they don't refer to her as Kate Middleton anymore. How many years was she married to Prince William and they still called her by her maiden name. That was very disrespectful.

[@sueb3747]

@@juliethompson340 although we are used to royalty and aristocrats here I think the press don't like to acknowledge people who rise up in the ranks.

[@ParkAvenue34]

It is the same thing with Prince Harry. Why do people [who ought to know better] continue to address him as Prince Harry. He is NOT Prince Harry. There is no such person as Prince Harry

[@limlaith]

Yes! I try very hard to do this even in my comments. 😊

[@RLW369]

I think Catherine possesses a natural class and dignity, and she has learned how to use makeup to enhance her natural beauty without overwhelming her face. I admit I found her “Coronation cheeks” a little jarring, but with your explanation I understand the reason behind it. Thanks for spotlighting a Princess we all admire!

[@catalinaortoljo2821]

Catherine's makeup emphasizes and highlights her beautiful, classic features.

[@MelindaKingPolitini]

She looks like a kind, healthy, real woman. Not an Instagram moment. Thank you for your wisdom, Beebs! Always a pleasure to enjoy your videos.

[@elizabethsmith9777]

Catherine is pure class.

[@BarbItalia]

Catherine is just so lovely.

[@kateg7298]

In the beginning circa 2011-2012, Catherine stayed with dark kohl eyeliner and she went a little heavy on the blush. But she did lighten up her makeup as she became more comfortable in front of the camera. She's a professional and she treats her public appearances as a job. It's part of her philosophy that it's the cause that's important - not her appearance.

[@thaismacedo8124]

Catherine is a natural beauty and has great skin. Her makeup is appropriate for a princess❤

[@minnauyeda7339]

I like Catherine’s natural, full brow shape and her overall approach to emphasize her features. Great color choices, too.

[@infin8ee]

Catherine is a refreshing change to "the other one" and her makeup,like everything else she does is always on point . I do remember the talk in the media before her wedding was about her "heavy handedness" with her blush but I ve always thought she looks lovely. Certainly no shining clown nose like she who will not be named 😂 The photo you showed of Catherine at The Queen's funeral was everything , beautiful but not trying to be over the top. I think another reason that she doesn't wear a lot of lipstick etc is because she actually talks to people and doesn't want to worry about having her teeth covered with product etc. Her whole persona is also a more sporty,natural (within the parameters of the event ) and her makeup look suits that. She has grown into herself so beautifully and rarely gets anything wrong. Stunning woman inside and out! BTW you look really lovely today and the top really looks beautiful. Have a happy day 💛

[@BeebsKelley]

💛💛💛

[@bettyandrews9571]

At least Catherine knows how to apply makeup. Meghan needs a tutorial. Her makeup was horrible at invictus games

[@ryannt]

I think she does listen ppl who give her advice unlike some ppl

[@rlabarbera]

Unlike some Oompa Loompas who don't own an iron.

[@sambright3719]

​@@rlabarberaNor a hairbrush. ☺️☺️☺️

[@mjustjeanette7026]

Being able to do your own make-up has the advantage that you don't have to ask the public to fund your make-up artist's expenses along with your own when travelling... not thinking about anyone (cough, cough, Invictus) in particular.

[@amazinggrace5692]

The public is not funding Meghan at all. She lives in the US, so it makes me wonder why you all still think of her.

[@mjustjeanette7026]

@@amazinggrace5692 exactly who paid for her trip to Invictus again?

[@amazinggrace5692]

@@mjustjeanette7026 what makes you think she didn’t pay for herself?

[@dominaevillae28]

@amazinggrace5692 Megan demanded that the charity pay for her expenses and pay to redecorate her hotel room (which was denied). For a previous Invictus Megan got them to pay thousands for her wardrobe.

[@amazinggrace5692]

@@dominaevillae28 Haven’t seen that anywhere

[@ZackRekeSkjell]

I love her makeup, and I love the fact that she often does it herself!

[@amylouise9853]

I am not someone who usually watches makeup videos but i enjoy your combination of both professional analysis and down to earth attitude. My biggest makeup challenge is needing glasses, which makes it more challenging to do complicated eye makeup evenly but I work around this buy just making red lipstick and simple eye my signature look.

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

I have to wear contact lenses if I've decided to do make-up...I have thought of buying those glasses that you can flip down one side then the other, because magnifying mirror doesn't work.

[@DrinkYourNailPolish]

I am visually impaired and I found rhe best way to get around this is to do a light shade in the inner third of my lid, a midtone shade in the middle and the darkest on the outer third and blend. This can all be done with fingers with cream shadows and I can use any color family.

[@5joanner]

You look especially beautiful today Beebs!

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you so much 💛

[@micheleparker3780]

Catherine 's makeup 💄 is on point; she knows not to mess with perfection. Your top looks LOVELY 😍.

[@MicheleOverton]

I have found that I LOVE the way women with thinner lips look!!💖 I emphasize this because you also look at the way women with thinner lips age. Kate Jackson, Cheryl Tiegs, Farrah Fawcett, look at the women, Shelly Hack, look at those 70's women and models, how clean and fresh and youthful they are. The thicker, pumped lip generation might look glamorous but they don't have the clean fresh youthful appearance that thinner lipped women have. So I love the look.💖

[@jmarie-nw8jf]

You look so beautiful today, Beebs! I love your top; the lace, the sleeve length, so feminine and pretty. Loved the video. I've always appreciated the light touch and balanced makeup that Princess Catherine does and it was nice to hear your evaluation.

[@mjustjeanette7026]

Her make-up choices effectively are, also, about making the people she meets in her professional roll the focus rather than "look at me".

[@janejones7638]

I agree with you about the make-up she wears. Usually it's very natural in the day to day looks, in her fancier looks it's still pretty similar except as you said it's darker and underblended.

[@jesssobad6241]

I think Catherine does her own makeup and has a hairstylist on hand. There have been engagements where she shows up with her natural texture (beautifully curly) and she has mentioned that shes terrible at doing hair. She does what she knows but leaves some of it to the professionals and thats why she always looks stunning.

[@musanyathi2298]

She went for a beauty course prior to marriage. She generally does her own hair and makeup for events. Did her own hair and makeup for her wedding.

[@vanglo3945]

Catherine, the princess of Wales is a beautiful and a classy lady! Such an example of a dignified woman.

[@MsMorganGirls]

Love your look today, Beebs! Love the lace dress, it's very flattering.

[@janejones7638]

I agree 100%. I like Beebs make-up and find it looks nice in every video. Her style is quite like Catherine's. It's there but not in your face.

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you so much

[@sandraray3731]

Love the detail and length of the sleeves on you!

[@madeyed2702]

Love how your make looked today -- glamorous yet not looking tacky or too much. Sad, I have monolid eyelid and glasses, so can't do much with it 😒 Can't recalled ever seeing Catherine with bad make-up. She is a beautiful lady inside out, and she can look natural or super glamorous without much effort. Her photo during late QEII funeral (black outfit + black hat) is the most iconic one. It gives me chill everytime I saw that photo. Regal like a future Queen should look like!.

[@77andsunny]

Catherine looks like a million bucks. She’s a natural beauty.

[@melindariddle6042]

Adore Catherine's makeup less is always better ❤

[@myahriddell739]

so many videos lately this is awesome

[@lizhorton5333]

I think Catherine wears makeup to enhance her features and look pretty and attractive. I don’t think she wants to “play” with colors as they may not be flattering. The browns enhance her green eyes and a lighter lip color is best as her lips are rather thin. I think her makeup makes her look beautiful.

[@tooma4886]

I've always wanted to see her use a nude color on her lid next to her lashes and keep the brown above the crease. I have deep set eyes, and it's amazing how much that lighter shade can open up your eyes and make them look bigger! And a note to all those who have allergies, there's a thing called an "allergic shiner." It is a description of the very dark circles that allergy sufferers have. No amount of skin care will help alleviate these circles, so go get some concealer that has a peach tone to use as a color corrector and also get a regular concealer to use over that. That combo works beautifully for me.

[@alimacdonald2924]

What an interesting and knowledgeable discussion, Beebs. I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned so much! Thanks for sharing! ~Ali (Nova Scotia, Canada)

[@BeebsKelley]

💛💛💛

[@alisade127]

She always looks beautiful. Whether she’s really going for it or very natural. She really knows how to do her makeup and dresses for every occasion. Catherine is Perfection.

[@karenr716]

Love your top today. So pretty!

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you!!

[@Ciao_Bella]

Yes, your top is lovely, Beebs! You look wonderful today. Thank you for shining a light on the stunning POW.

[@phineas117]

I personally thought the wedding eye makeup was a bit heavy. she could use some Light green in the eye makeup to play up her green eyes. other than that (I admit to being picky. sorry Catherine), she's beautiful and her skin is glowing. THE "other one"....honestly, a five year old could do better.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I thought Diana’s was too. It might have been because she did want to be noticed by everyone

[@phineas117]

@@catherinelynnfraser2001 on Diana...I really didn't like the heavy blue eyeliner. her eyes were beautiful without that.

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

I thought the weight of who she was marrying and what her future will be suddenly hit her, she looked 10yrs older in the pictures before, than when she came out of the church....it showed how seriously she took it, how much she understood the role she was taking on and that her life would no longer be hers..... unlike bubble-brain MM, who just thought she was going to strut around like the Queen of Hearts in Alice In Wonderland screaming "Off with their head"!!!

[@janejones7638]

@@catherinelynnfraser2001 Diana's body language on her wedding day is quite sad. She looked like a lamb being sent to slaughter. I was very young when she got married and I thought she was just shy at the time. I wonder if she knew her marriage was a sham from the very beginning.

[@spiritmatter1553]

I didn’t love her wedding day makeup either. My issue was with her frosted lipstick which l always see as so aging.

[@barbaragibson612]

When I was in theatre/drama, we needed to use heavier, underblended makeup so the lights didn't wash us out. For someone watching from the seats it looked perfectly fine. Reminds me of the "Clueless" Monet quote.

[@joydoy4042]

She is gorgeous!

[@sharroon7574]

Catherine has great style but she could blend her makeup a bit more.

[@Heidi51616]

What a contrast to the other one.

[@CassandraCarrAuthor]

She's gorgeous and also an asset to the BRF.

[@sharonfindlay7721]

Have you seen the photo of the princess of Wales wearing a tan trouser suit?? Girl knows how to clap back 😂❤

[@HollisDuty60]

Thank you so much! I have similar coloring and I have all of her Bobbi Brown makeup. This is fascinating. I’m getting them all.

[@ChomalocoLoco]

Can you talk about how Kate wemt from less modern styling when the late Queen Elizabeth was alive and how she is dressed more mordern now or if it was influenced by Markle and megxit? Theres clearly a change in styling

[@karennogaski1473]

Those 3 portraits of Catherine look nothing like she usually does, or is it just me?

[@thedevilandhertrumpets4268]

Not just you! I think we are all trying to cock our heads and make them work lol.

[@Grade10science]

I thought the same a few years ago when they first came out... then I thought the same again when watching this video! I thought it was just me! So nice to see I'm not alone!

[@sharonalbanese8084]

She always looks beautiful, and, as you said, appropriate for the occasion. Love your top ❤❤

[@bejbimama6689]

Catherine makeup is great as a business makeup.If you can be fotographed Your makeup depends on light, sometimes its impossible look great in natural and atrificial light the same time.

[@DeborahWohlfeld]

Very nice video showcasing Catherine PoW. As usual- you look great!

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you kindly!

[@TechieTexan]

I think she is gorgeous and her makeup is appropriate to her current role and future role in the monarchy. Plus, with the cameras following around, it would make sense that she needs to look professional while making appearances in supporting various causes. Love her simple yet classy look. 😊

[@SheistyLady00]

Her makeup keeps her looking young. The other one is looking old prematurely

[@MonicaGarcia-sk3do]

Queremos mas de la Catherine, Princesa de Gales. Es una mujer elegante, con mucha clase. Hermosa en toda la extensión de la palabra. ❤❤❤

[@kellypearcemoore9074]

She’s perfection

[@PH-rm6ok]

I like to smudge a bit of darker purple or navy in with my neutrals at the outer edge That tiny bit of color blends in and doesn’t stand out The only makeup I did not like was the Earth Shot makeup with that awesome lime green dress and emerald. I felt the makeup was too strong and the colors didn’t look right …just off from other glam makeup she normally does that I like, the Bond movie premiere was great! I wondered if she had someone she’s not used before do her makeup. I actually bought the color from Bobby Brown she was said to wear on her wedding day It’s really pretty and rosy Meghan seems to do makeup tricks from mid nineties early 2000’s That C shape for bronzer or highlighter isn’t for everyone You need to do makeup for your face shape!

[@connienana1623]

Nice top! Good video on Catherine aPrincess of Wales!

[@robb2biago]

Catherine, Princess of Wales, is so amazing. She needs to be ready for day, night, inside, outside, rain, shine, natural light, super high intense flash. By doing her own makeup, she’s not dependent on another, in various places. And she’s a Mom. My mom and godmother had their eyebrows tattooed on at 80. It saved them so much time. And they both lost their eyebrows after chemo. Cheers! I wear a light glossed lip, it makes me feel fancy, ha!

[@voices_vary]

Your hair looks so beautiful, Beebs!!!

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you!! 💛

[@lenoreweston4193]

You are looking great as usual. 💕💕

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you so much 💛

[@annestep6741]

one thing I notice is that her left eyebrow is higher than her right one. She quit doing lower eyeliner when so many people commented on how not so attractive it was. She did it very early on and quit at some point after the wedding. Love your top

[@fibanocci314]

She had brain surgery on the left side, just inside her hair line beside her temple, when she was a child. Maybe it has something to do with that?

[@annestep6741]

@@fibanocci314I knew she had a scar there but didn't know she had brain surgery. Yes it could have changed the nerve on that side of her face. I think that she could use product to make the other match better but maybe it really doesn't matter. Just something I noticed. She is so gorgeous it is of no consequence

[@Ciao_Bella]

And what do you think of Catherine's 70s-ish recent middle part and curtain bangs? I think it really suits her and is a nice change of pace.

[@detectivefiction3701]

I don't like middle parts generally (I've always had a side part myself) and don't know if I care for it on Catherine. In my opinion, almost everyone looks better with a side part.

[@paulinecastle1138]

It depends. My hair has waves, they don’t do centre partings. Doesn’t mean that I don’t think others shouldn’t have centre partings if they want

[@Ciao_Bella]

@@detectivefiction3701 I agree about the side parts, actually. But I think Catherine (like Jaclyn Smith, etc.) makes it work. Maybe the shape of her face? Beebs would know, lol.

[@parkerbrown-nesbit1747]

​@@Ciao_BellaI'm not positive, but it looks to me that she has a classic oval face shape.

[@ef2512]

Your top is great and looks really good on you

[@BeebsKelley]

Oh thank you!

[@MissWishes]

⭐️🏆⭐️ You said it perfectly, Princess Catherine glows! Also, you’re very beautiful & your makeup looks amazing! I’ve noticed you apologize for what you’re wearing quite often. I don’t know why because you always wear cute clothes❣️

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you so much!! 💛

[@krisy-in-italy]

I love the way Catherine the Princess of Wales does her makeup, so natural, accentuates her good looks. That is what makeup is supposed to do, unless you are a clown and we have an example of that in Harry’s wife.

[@martyn8116]

You sound like a real master of her art when you talk make-up, Beebs. I saw you mentioned having a make-up background a few vids ago. But, you must be some kind of elite make-up artist.

[@kathyevans2968]

You always give good advice and explain in a logical way, Beebs! You also look amazing today with your hair, makeup and very flattering top! By the way, is Beebs a nickname/ short for something or a name I’m unfamiliar with? Love it either way!

[@adneenmourin7359]

I'm no make up expert. Other than BB, eyeliner and lipstick I hardly use anything else. But to me Princess of Wales seems perfect in every single appearance, from head to toe. ❤

[@paulinecastle1138]

Makeup and clothing choices should make you look and feel good, as well as healthy. It should enhance you, not be something that people remark on. It’s a case of the person wearing clothes/ makeup, not the clothes/ makeup wearing the person, or just being a coat hanger

[@annatjienilsen539]

Royal News Network did a program on that a wh8le ago. Was quite interesting

[@lbc517]

I think Catherine's makeup always looks beautiful. Wish we knew what specific products she used.

[@stargirlofantares9053]

Even before you came back to the hair up, big earrings, gorgeous makeup pic… I had it in my mind all the way through. I’d never seen it before & think it’s one of the most stunning pictures of Princess Catherine that I’ve ever seen! I have her exact coloring, except her brows are darker. Do you think she lightens her hair? I’d never noticed her brows are so dark before. She just always looks so lovely!! Thanks Beebs! ♥️ Jessica

[@sarajack2620]

You are a wonderful communicator and your natural warmth shines through.😊

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you! 😊

[@anne-marie2972]

Princess Catherine is so beautiful ❤. May I ask can you laminate your eyebrows at home ? I have very stubborn eyebrows and I would love to laminate them. How can I do it 🤔 ?

[@thirstaefortae5057]

You can find kits for laminating your brows at home

[@BeebsKelley]

Yes you can! I linked a kit or two in the products tab!

[@anne-marie2972]

@@BeebsKelley Thank you 🙂.

[@kate2create738]

Thank you for covering Catherine’s look, she has some similar features that I replicate with, so it’s nice to see a review of her make up look (in my opinion she seems flawless).

[@mycatsnameiskaren8253]

Girl, I am wide awake and came back to this video with 2 brushes and a 4 color palate trying to do this and improvise!!! I think I'm gonna have to try this multiple times before I can do it like you. You make it look way too easy! ❤from Florida. 😳 ❤

[@BeebsKelley]

💛💛

[@MoonLightt57]

Would loveee more makeup and hair videos from you! ❤

[@dawnbeaird5183]

Hi Beebs ❣️ thank you ❣️

[@BeebsKelley]

Hi Dawn! Thank you!! 💛💛💛

[@ShakerMaker1980]

She is so beautiful ❤

[@lisacasey2826]

I want her nose, its the cutest !!!!

[@himurahaibara1459]

If i'm not mistaken i heard that the royals are expected to appear more professional and neat, so no heavy makeup. Any type of filler, hair transplant, cosmetic surgery and those type of changes are frowned upon on royals, those fall into unnecessary spending and lean towards celebrity lifestyle instead of royals. I do love professional style especially when it comes to Catherine's coats and suits.

[@MK-cc5ve]

This was great, seeing makeup on Kate in a variety of settings and how the techniques were adapted to different occasions. As far as state occasions with gowns and tiaras I am often surprised to find I am impressed with Q Camilla’s makeup. Hint hint.

[@SaudadeCB]

It's ok to call her Kate. It's clear that you respect her as a character. Some people are just tiresom and fanatic.

[@francesharmon1223]

1st, i love your videos including the "how to" (how to dress, how to do your make-up) and i do love the top you are wearing! 2nd, rumor has it and i am beginning to believe that catherine (i prefer 'kate' just as i prefer 'di" to "diane" because both were so approachable and not formal--- they were and are the people's royal- the people's queen and princess) anyway, i have heard that she uses botox. when you see early pictures of her, she had more expression lines near her eyes and 11s. now, her face is really smooth. i am curious to hear what you think about her using botox--- does she or doesn't she..... the other thing i love about catherine/kate is she is like me--- she had acne when she was younger and really struggled with it. unlike kate, i still struggle with it even at 60+ . for some reason, knowing she had to deal with acne and had to find her self confidence despite acne makes her even more endearing to me. anyway, i would love to know your thoughts about the botox.

[@addieleo6382]

A story has gone around that Catherine began tweezing/grooming her eyebrows after experiencing bullying at school. Perhaps she is sure to have them professionally cared for.

[@stephanyfaycohen3842]

Thank you. GOD bless you.

[@monatinnell4570]

Great job girl! You also apply your makeup perfectly! Love your suggestions ❤

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you so much!!

[@Rando15]

Your top immediately caught my attention. It's lovely! It was interesting to hear about the eyebrows. I'm jealous! Since chemo (I'm in remission), my eyebrows have not grown, although my hair is growing. I considered getting those fake eyebrows but I'm not sure. What do you think?

[@nightmareoracle]

Princess Catherine is so perfect tho🌹❦ ♡

[@AugustDeb]

I thought I heard on Caroline Hirons YT channel that British MUA Hannah Martin did Catherine's wedding makeup but Catherine ended up adding more eyeliner like she was used to wearing. Hannah had a softer take than Catherine wanted.

[@renekirebornrenekireborn4777]

Great video, you look stunning today. Catherine is so cool. Can you do an update on Meghan's InGriftus makeup pls? What has she done well and what mistakes she keeps making. I keep seeing the blush on her lower cheeks.

[@chrisf1202]

Thanks for this.😊

[@analissapritos6462]

Catherine doesn't need much of makeup anyway. She is already beautiful and I mean when I say beautiful it is an understatement. ❤️🌹

[@annagervas9197]

lovely Beebs!

[@BeebsKelley]

💛

[@daracolakoglu841]

I think Princess Catherine is faultless.

[@iamneverwrong1]

No one is. But she's pretty darn close!

[@suteerap9286]

Love natural look! ❤

[@DrinkYourNailPolish]

Love this video!!

[@BeebsKelley]

Thank you!!

[@AnisaSev]

For her wedding makeup, I think she should have used maybe a dark brown eyeliner on the lower lash line instead of black. I think the black was too harsh. Overall, she looked pretty but that was the one critique I had.