Behaviorsubject vs Subject rxjs - What to Use?

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

WATCH NEXT: Beginner's RxJS Tutorial: Dive Deep with RxJS Crash Course - kzbin.info/www/bejne/r3vHmWSVe8enoLcsi=qhsqP7Eu3Nd7_hIU

[@riketscience]

you are THE MAN!!!!! I am really glad I stumbled upon your channel. Everything you say is concise and exactly matches my digestion speed. I am going to learn a lot. Huge thanks and praise 👏👏👏👏👏

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Welcome aboard!

[@ferran-ramirez]

Nice video! The most important thing to get from it is that a BehaviorSubject holds one value regardless of when it was added (with next() or initializing ). When it is subscribed it emits the value immediately. A Subject doesn't hold a value, the value has to be set after something is subscribed to it.

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Yes exactly

[@sfspmusic]

Дружище, у тебя талант нормально оъяснять + ты вкладываешь много труда в каждое видео, спасибо тебе огромное!

[@advance5189]

Your tutorials are out of this world! Thanks

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Glad you like them!

[@viniciusbernardo2112]

The best explanation that i heard so far about behaviorSubject/Subject. You just earned another subscriber (not the observable hahaha)

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Welcome aboard!

[@vvmaas]

Excellent content, the pace and eloquence of your speech makes it so much easier to absorb the ideas.

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Glad you think so!

[@ganesanvasu1835]

Thank you. Your way of explaining things were much better to understand..

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Glad it was helpful!

[@alexandersmotrikov9007]

Thanks, Alexander! Nice, short and clear.

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@LukeAvedon]

I was just pondering this! Glad you made another excellent video on the topic.

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Glad to hear that!

[@hugo-onzakorderra8851]

I love to use BehaviorSubject for all variables used in templates!

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

Yeap that's a flexible way

[@john_yeager]

yeah but with behavioral subject if i dont put initial value the 3 component i try to show the value break i think

[@SrinathJog]

Thanks for this clear understandable video. My question is , Can we use Behavior Subject instead of Subject everywhere ? I mean do we need to replace subject with Behavior Subject completely because Behavior Subject has initial value and we can have value of it anytime unlike subject. Or we have some unique scenarios that we have to use simply Subject in place of Behavior Subject ? What is the significance of both. Thanks in advance

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

If you don't want an initial emit than BehaviorSubject is not a good idea. Othen then that you can.

[@hamza201183]

Hi Oleksandr! What do you think could be the consequences of Signals on NgRx? Many thanks!

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

I already replied such concerns. Hi hamza, That's a great question which I looked for myself as I want to update my Angular/NgRx course and make it with correct choices :) So Signals will be dominant together with standalone components (and full projects). In NgRx github core contributors wrote that they will use signals under the hood with no changes from ngrx state packages. Additionally they will make ngrx signals package similar to ngrx component store which will be limited to a single component.

[@CodingAbroad]

It makes you think why Subject exists in the first place. I’ve never found a need for it

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

If you don't want an initial trigger and you don't want to store data inside. Something like notification system fits well

[@JBuchmann]

I recently was using BehaviorSubject and it was causing a problem for me because on subscribe I'd get 2 values. The default first and then the one I needed after (from the "next" call). I thought I had a bug and tried unsuccessfully to do some workaround hacks. Then I realized all I really needed was to use a Subject instead. That was an "ah ha" moment that solidified my understanding of the difference between the two

[@DD-vc7fq]

@@JBuchmann I get it that using subject is the best solution here to skip the initial emit, but why didn't subject.pipe(skip(1)) cross your mind?

[@JBuchmann]

@@DD-vc7fq I did for a while resort to skip(1) and it worked for one part of my app. But somehow a different part of the app required the first emission. It was unreliable for my specific situation. For my situation, skip(1) was a bad bandaid and not what it's meant to be used for.

[@MrJeszam]

I agree. Subject or plain subject is stupid and useless.

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

The are some usecases for Subject like notifying that some action happens when you don't really need to store data inside.

[@JBuchmann]

@@MonsterlessonsAcademy perfect explanation. I always wonder which is the best one to use and my decision is based on if I need to emit a default value. But what you said here is just as important.

[@uaplatformacomua]

Awesome. Thank you

[@MonsterlessonsAcademy]

You are welcome!