Best and Worst 2024 Magic Sets for Commander: Full Ranking! | Magic: The Gathering

[@TaunaMTG]

🎴 Support the Channel and Buy Singles: (partner.tcgplayer.com/tauna) 🎬 Subscribe: (www.youtube.com/@TaunaMTG?sub_confirmation=1) 🎬Become a KZbin Member: (kzbin.info/door/YApRr1grtMxARLYi8Ev5aQjoin) Giveaway: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pnLIh32LgaqGiKM

[@angeldillemuthactor]

Duskmourn and Bloomburrow easily the best sets followed by foundations Jumpstart

[@aggrend]

I think we all know how memey and silly tier lists are and its all in good fun but I gotta say, Duskmourn getting an S while Bloomburrow and Foundations getting a B actually blows my mind. No shade on you, but that definitely raised my eyebrows.

[@TaunaMTG]

This is why I went into depth as to why I gave the rankings to hopefully explain it!

[@aggrend]

@@TaunaMTG Yeah I respect the reasoning and they aren't bad takes at all. Some of your cons were pros for me (i love whacky tribals for example) but I do see where you are coming from and your reasons were very solid.

[@thataccount1]

I think its a CRIME to put Outlaws of Thunder Junction into A teir.

[@KeepTheKitLow]

You can think that, but the two bonus sheets plus stuff like Bristly Bill and Vein Ripper made it a much better set than the likes of MKM

[@TaunaMTG]

The bonus sheet is doing a lot of carrying

[@plengtattoo]

I feel very lucky that I got into Magic as thunder junction was released. I wasn’t interested in the world of assassins creed so overlooked it but every other set has been absolutely amazing for a new comer and has sucked me right in. So I totally agree with your rating, thanks for putting this all together

[@TaunaMTG]

Thank you!

[@SquamatoHD]

assassins creed was an amazing set for commander i built a whole ezio deck just with cards from the set

[@TaunaMTG]

It's great for singles, really not worth picking up boosters

[@japoniano]

I had completely forgotten about "Ravinca Clue"... simply pathethic that it doesn't include ALL the new cards in a box and people were expected to buy multiple boxes for completing their collection

[@Snoop-b5k]

Karlov manor has some amazing black cards, the extended art of victimize is pure art. Duskmourn is probably my favorite this year tho, recently picked up Funeral room, Whitering torment, unstoppable slasher and Gloomlake verge for my deck. Personally I'm fine with foundations being reprinted for five years, makes a lot of staples accessible for new players.

[@Gosagen93]

I can see that we are very aligned on what we think of this years sets!

[@ERealslimshady]

I pulled that exact balemurk in my collector box :) favorite card I own besides my old gnaw bone

[@brentmiller9520]

Jumpstart 2024 was great but I wish it had the unique art land like the original just to combat then land bulk apathy from longer time players

[@TaunaMTG]

Agreed

[@Travel3r5]

Out of the 4 duskmourn sets, which did you like the most personally? i'm hearing some good things about endless punishment and miracle worker. But the price for endless punishment is crazy.

[@dafruk1]

I'm new to magic and came across your channel because of your commander precon recommendation videos. Maybe it's because of not having a background in magic but I don't understand why would I buy any of these over picking up a precon that looks fun and just upgrading it with singles? The foundations jump starts being the one possible exception as they appear to provide a similar route into specific deck types.

[@TaunaMTG]

Kinda. It depends, because there isn't a precon for every kind of deck you'd want to build so you'll need A LOT of singles. Sometimes it's also just fun to crack packs, so best off cracking the best ones to get to upgrade for them

[@XxpatirrioxX]

Heyy!! What do you think about the phyrexia all will be one set?

[@japoniano]

The problem with everyone in OTJ being there and wearing a cowboy hat was that we never got an explanation of WHY. In the whole wide multiverse WHY does everyone choose to be in a plane that seems to be empty and with nothing of value. If there's no native culture, WHY is everyone cosplaying as cowboys instead of wearing their own normal clothes.

[@CobaltCG]

I will say that the kindred stuff is nice when we havent gotten a kindred driven set as much recently and its support to creature types that dont have as much presence is great. Especially when its a first visit to a new plane. Plus the limited environment is really fun and its a great beginner set. I think kindred is a major pro even if its not loaded with universal adds to lots of decks

[@TaunaMTG]

It was definitely nice, and I LOVE building Kindred decks especially from Bloomburrow. It's more that their value in non-BB decks isn't gonna be great.

[@VincentVBR]

Duskmourne has been my fav set too good to see you love it soo much!! ❤

[@CobaltCG]

I don't see how the foundation set for new players being reprinted a bunch is a con, i do agree its not an S set given how its not exciting, but it does seem aggressive to knock it to a B when its great at what it does even for long time players. I agree duskmourn is as S as you can make it though

[@TaunaMTG]

It's mostly B because it will be reprinted for ages. If you can get it on clearance/cheap, its worth picking up but I wouldn't suggest it anytime soon as the cards in it will continue to go down in price IMO as people open them for the next 5+ years

[@CobaltCG]

@TaunaMTG fair enough

[@thataccount1]

Freerunning seems to me like a more balanced version of ninjutsu.

[@TaunaMTG]

It kinda is? Or maybe a more balanced Prowl

[@moderneaux]

I loved the Assassin's Creed set. I thought it was the sleeper hit.

[@TheKreve]

Murders is actually a decent set. Gets way more hate than it derserves. It is unique which is better than a lot of sets.