Best Carry On Luggage: 8 Soft Side Carry-Ons Tested Head to Head

[@asianguitarmasta]

My wife and I took our Briggs and Riley ZDX 21'' spinners on a trip to Italy last year and they performed flawlessly. The build quality is excellent and the wheels roll very smoothly. They also fit easily in even the smallest overhead compartments.

[@zapotoskykalynn]

I was in Turkey recently and had a empriente multi pouchette with me. They show me a *hotdups* bag and it looked just like it.

[@johnlebeau5471]

I see a lot of Briggs and Riley fans in the comments. I am a retired pilot, 33 years at my airline, and I would put a lifetime of normal use on my suitcase every year. My suitcase was never fully unpacked, and never stowed away in a closet. My first was a TravelPro, junk within a year. Then I splurged for a Zero Halliburton. I loved the suitcase, but this was before rolling luggage, and I decided I needed wheels. I then bought a Briggs and Riley. Used it for about 10 years, had it repaired (for free) twice, and finally decided a new suitcase was in order, although the Briggs was still functional. So about 10 years ago now, I bought another Briggs, an improved model, and it is my suitcase to this day.

[@TheBourbonWrench]

Word of advice for anyone complaining about price. Over our summer trip to Italy, I brought a fairly cheaper budget checked bag I got from a big box store. Once we made it to Italy, it must’ve landed on a wheel and it got caved in a bit. It was still manageable, but not very convenient. In a mad dash to one of our trains, it landed on the same wheel running down the stairs and exploded off while also crushing another wheel. The walk from the train station to our next hotel was absolute hell in the July sun. I ended up buying some luggage from a random shop, which I ended up replacing with something much sturdier. You get what you pay for, and often times buying cheap means you’ll be replacing it off. Up front cost is much better than replacing it every year, or being absolutely miserable on your trip.

[@ManateeMentality]

Buy cheap, buy twice.

[@USA-CANADA1480]

@@TheBourbonWrench sure but I certainly won’t buy a luggage worth as much as my round trip ticket considering I fly once per 10 years 😆. Moderation cost is the key. 🔑 American Tourister or Amazon Basics are the ways to go.

[@deborahsharpe4090]

One of the most important things for me is a handle on the bottom and despite the high cost of these, I didn't notice a handle on the bottom of any of them. picking up a heavy bag for a woman can be difficult without a bottom handle

[@rickhicks06]

Back again - and knew what my favorite was before watching the video. Glad we agree on Briggs & Riley. My travel career has been Samsonite -> Travel Pro -> Briggs & Riley. I have a different model than the one reviewed here (older model Baseline) and bought it for its innovative CX expansion feature (kinda makes the entire suitcase a compression cube!) and because I'm a suiter nerd. My personal belief is a 'suiter' is a feature more travelers should take advantage of. I got used to it when I was traveling on business with suits. Even though dress codes have relaxed, and I do less business travel, I still find it incredibly useful. All my tops on hangers (wire) rolled up into the suiter (with a few undergarments to occupy the space above the hangers) - its like a packing cube built into the bag. Then when I get to where I'm going, all of my tops are hung up in the closet in 5 seconds. So satisfying.

[@zapotoskykalynn]

*hotdups* purse pieces are unique and classic. they are not the typical luxury designer bags that we already seen from the other collectors

[@dawnm2184]

I was just given a TravelPro by a flight crew member who didn't want it anymore. It is so sturdy! I love it.

[@rbrad848]

I had gotten a travel pro set 15 years ago or so. Only travel occasionally. Last year bought an expensive tumi bag for my first international flight with latest and greatest features. But I tend to go back to the travel pro with its lid opening vs the tumis clamshell. Get to the hotel and put it on a luggage stand with a compact form factor. Compact form factor seems better than the extra organization that clamshell gives. Nothing essentially wrong with the Tumi but also nothing wrong with travelpro either.

[@a.e.7988]

​@@rbrad848I am tempted to splurge on Tumi. They are gorgeous but a little bit heavy.

[@user-ei8rb7sj6c]

I read a review on Amazon about the Travel Pro Patriot Blue and Tan soft side. He said it wouldn’t stand up on its own if you let go of it so he returned it.

[@RG-wd6qs]

With more then 750+ flights over 25 years of travel for work and leisure, Travel Pro has been my go-to luggage, averaging over 200 trips between replacement. I picked up Travel Pro following the lead of flight attendants over 20 years ago.

[@meloescher]

I'm here looking to finally replace my 25 year old TravelPro Platinum-2 bags. Also business traveler with over 800k miles (basis my FF programs) on these boys. Either buy new ones and upgrade or replace the wheels, which are the only thing wrong. Trying to decide. Same intro here, noticed all the flight crews with these.

[@maryannd3651]

I love my Briggs and Riley for international travel. I have used them for over 10 years and they have held up well. Purchased a larger travel pro for longer car travel because of the price difference

[@gelkins2]

I’ve been a road warrior since 2006. I love my Briggs and Riley. They are tough bags and when stuff finally does break they fix it no questions asked. I bought a cheap spinner years ago, it broke on the very first trip. The repair cost was almost as much as the bag. I threw it in the trash. I agree not everyone should spend $500 on a bag. But if you’re on a plane 20 times a year for work I’m going to assume you can afford a quality bag.

[@andreaeisenberg8851]

I was so happy the Briggs and Riley was included in this roundup. I've been vascillating for a few days, there are some negative reviews about its wheels out there. But I admit, cost is not that much of a concern and I wanted something that looks great and is light. For me, the single deciding factor is the outside mounted handle. I am so tired of rolling up small stuff to fill the gaps around the handle poles.

[@andreaeisenberg8851]

Great video, Nik. So glad you included the Briggs and Riley. I've been obsessively researching for a few days now. After watching, and reading the comments, I went ahead and ordered it in Hunter. I actually still find my sturdy old eBag nearly perfect, but a few things bugged me and the flat inside of the Briggs was the deciding factor.

[@LeannaRuthJensen]

My softside Olympia carry on that I bought before my wedding 23 years ago barely has any wear inspite of international travel and decades of family trips. It is a two wheeler so, not on your list and obviously I cannot speak to how they are made now or price, but I am so glad I got it. It is 1/3-2/3 clam shell which I like. If I had to get a new one I would like a charger port and flat bottom/external handle, but otherwise it does the job. I enjoyed your review and appreciate the research you did.

[@zapotoskykalynn]

the *hotdups* would be super cute during the fall with a nude or tan or even tonal outfit! i’m thinking a tan wool coat with that bag!!

[@crrizello5157]

I have the TravelPro Maxlite and really like it. Very lightweight and sturdy. It does get a bit tipsy sometimes but not too limiting

[@awaytogether]

My Dad has that bag and swears by it!

[@ScholarFromTheHoller]

I am so glad I found your channel. You both seem very authentic and transparent. Thank you for great content..

[@ElPandaWarrior]

I have two Briggs and Riley bags... built like tanks, functionality like no other and that lifetime warranty. I also have a Tumi carry on that I owned for 10 years and went all over the world with me. Then the handle broke and Tumi refused to fix it. I spent some time in the Briggs and Riley store and learned why Tumi no longer honors its warranty. I will never buy a Tumi again. Briggs and Riley for me.

[@lululee1653]

Tumi was purchased by Samsonite so that’s probably your answer

[@ElPandaWarrior]

Yes, I wasn’t going to name names but yes, that’s the reason. I’m not against samsonite, they make reasonable products but for $900 I’d expect much higher levels of quality and service.

[@littlegoobie]

@@lululee1653 Samsonite also bought Hartmann...probably over 10 years ago.

[@bakewithela8327]

Tumi will repair your handle, just take it to a store and they will send it to a repair center with a shipping fee of $25. They will send you an estimate of the costs :)

[@kris_5]

After doing a ton of research a few years back, I concluded the Travelpro Elite offered the best balance of function and value. I was glad to see you came to the same conclusion. I'm not concerned with status and labels. I don't really care if my luggage gets noticed. In fact, I prefer not to carry brands like Tumi, I think they bring unwelcome attention in many parts of the world. Travelpro is high quality, but won't lead bystanders to make assumptions about what's in my bag or wallet.

[@tkozikow]

B&R ZDX is easily the best bag I have ever owned. Perfect size and features for our 15 day trip to Italy last May. Pricey, but worth every penny if you amortize the cost over a lifetime of use.

[@awaytogether]

Amen - great perspective!

[@JoelSc14]

any regrets going zdx vs baseline ?? or for the price the zdx has been great ?? (what color did you choose ?? holding up well ?? ) liking the zdx the more I look at it... thanks for your time

[@tkozikow]

@@JoelSc14 TBH I never really looked at the Baseline...I follow a couple who are full-time travelers and I think that they have two of ZDX. No issues at all and as I noted in my comment with the right packing it can easily work for a 2 week trip. I have the hunter green, but would have purchased the ocean if it was available and I think that P2 will be getting that color.

[@JoelSc14]

Awesome, thanks so much!

[@JoelSc14]

(green has held up color wise checked?) all 3 seem nice

[@rainfall3946]

As always, a super informative review! Thanks for your time in making these

[@thebubbacontinuum2645]

Thanks for all these great videos. I married a foreign lady, and we had to make a lot of overseas trips before she got her green card. We still have to travel sometimes. I always used a giant Tumi bag because I had to bring her things from the US. The bag would weigh 40 pounds when I left and 20 pounds when I flew home. Now that she's in the US, we can pack less. Air France and Aer Lingus literally stole my wife's bag, and insurer Heymondo refused to pay, as did the airlines. We are looking for ways to avoid checking bags, and I'm going to try the Travelpro Platinum Elite.

[@Maggie-tr2kd]

I bought the Travelpro Crew VersaPack Global Carry On Expandable Spinner last year and I couldn't be more pleased. Sturdy telescoping handle, excellent spinner wheels that are well-constructed and move smoothly through the airport and on the plane going down the aisle, high quality ballistic nylon protected with stain resistance, etc. . . Total price was about $235 including shipping and tax and I did purchase it when I could get a small discount.

[@daveeastman1633]

Still using my Tumi rolling carryon I bought in 1998. I’ve used it on hundreds of flights, checked it when necessary without a second thought, and it’s a top open (no clamshell) newer bags have more features, but this beast just works. I kind of want to replace it, but I just can’t justify it.

[@scooter5940]

Yep. I have a T-Tech (made by Tumi) bought at Costco for a song almost 20 year ago. It’s a clamshell, two-wheeler, international size carry on. Travelled heavily for business until retirement last year. I want to replace it for one with newer features, but it’s still in such great shape, I just can’t.

[@ronsantos2962]

Hello, I have 3 TUMI carry-on , just loved the style and innovation they put on each luggage and more option in color and material. Thanks for the different review on the every brand.

[@awaytogether]

For sure! They are high quality and such a respected name!

[@bliss6495]

As a frequent traveler myself, TUMI is a NO. It's heavy. Samsonite is for me. Light, durable and easy service center.

[@Quiltify]

As an older woman who travels solo the last thing I want is an expensive brand of suitcase. No use adding a larger target to my back. On top of that, once you get to 7 lbs, the weight is more than I want to drag around or lift overhead. I've had Hartmann before, but got rid of it years ago...strange measurements. Briggs and Riley are excellent if someone is moving countries for a year or so...but not as a carryon but as a medium sized truck. My heaviest carryon, 2 wheeled, is an Eagle Creek Tarmac at 7.5 lbs, but it is for car trips where I don't have far to move it. My Rick Steves wheeled bag is great, had it 10 years, looks like new, weighs less than 6 lbs, is still reasonably priced, but sometimes you just want a new bag. I find my age has drawn me to a Travel Pro, maxlite 5 compact spinner at 5.1 lbs. It moves well loaded and is so very light. The total weight, packed for me, is 15 lbs. It holds all I need. While I have always enjoyed offering to check my carryon at the gate, I will no longer offer due to its light weight, at least until I'm more confident with this new brand for me.

[@DaveM-FFB]

As a road warrior for the last 30 years, I've owned all of these bags except Hartmann. Today, I would only purchase B&R, Travelpro, and Victorinox (in that order). Although the latter is not always known for size compliant bags. Tumi "was" built like a tank. Heavy, but beautiful. Sadly, the clamshell doesn't work well for me on luggage racks, and it's simply too expensive (even on sale). Great video.

[@Ros44]

And what about Samsonite? Do you have some expirience with it?

[@DaveM-FFB]

@@Ros44 Sorry for the delayed response. I would prefer Travelpro over Samsonite (for quality of spinners and handle), as long as the Travelpro is size compliant for your airline. They should both be in the same price range.

[@Ros44]

@@DaveM-FFB Thank you for you reply. ❤

[@kixxoff928]

I’m using an old Wenger carry on 6.17 lbs (2.8kg). Built perfectly. Very large inside due to 2 wheels. Checked it in a few times, used as cabin bag a ton of times, it’s good for Ryanair and Wizzair “large” cabin bag. And it was very cheap - around 50 eur. I don’t see it going away any time soon😊

[@nailekara]

Thank you for the detailed review ... I travel quite a lot and i´ve been using my Samsonite carry on for a good amount of time ...My previous one was a purple 2wheeler that I retired from service after 9 years of use ( but in perfect shape) , and 2 years ago I upgraded to a purple 4 wheeler ( also Samsonite) ...can´t remember the model but it has expansion ,TSA lock , handles on all sides and a good size front pocket for my laptop. I´m not fan of built in additions because I have my set of perfectly sized cubes( honestly just meassured the interior of my bag and browsed on Amazon until I found some that fit like a glove, in vertical position )

[@cynthiaannacutler5721]

Thanks!

[@78Mkv]

Great video that I was just looking for! Wish you covered the Briggs Riley Baseline essential for comparisons.

[@BlainFurgerson]

you’re literally my comfort person i love you kislux !

[@mkphilly]

Used my ZDX & cargo backpack for the first time : great travel duo!!

[@JoelSc14]

still enjoying the zdx ?? thinking that might be the line we choose for multiple pieces as well.. thanks for your time

[@regtowers4914]

Lipault carry on- the lightest and easiest I’ve used. The wheels are great and sturdy.

[@lisaatp]

The external handle track on the Briggs & Riley so the inside is flat for packing! Why don’t ALL suitcases do this?!?!

[@awaytogether]

Right???

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

Most manufacturers use cheap, flimsy aluminum in the handles, so they need them to be inside or they will bend. Briggs and Riley uses aircraft grade aluminum so they can put the handles outside.

[@David-nx2vm]

Because you give up some interior space. The space between the rails on the inside is good for smaller items. It’s a trade off. That’s a main reason I don’t use 4wheel spinners for carryons. All that air between the 4 wheels counts against your 22x14 size restriction but it’s useless.

[@geepismyname]

I may be in the minority but I prefer the slightly extra packing space by having the track inside. Then the full outer size of the case gives you three more cubbies inside the bag

[@geepismyname]

@@David-nx2vm this

[@martylovejoy]

Almost 3 pounds lighter and more than 10L of extra volume to pack in, the Travelpro Maxlite 5 Softside Expandable Upright 2 Wheel Carry On for $145 is THE WAY TO GO!!! You chose the right brand, but they have an even better bag! Check it out! We’ve taken it all over N America, Ctrl & S America, Africa, SE Asia & Europe - still looks and functions great!

[@kirstenveneziano1205]

Great review, thank you for sharing! I'm interested in seeing a review between hard-sided and soft-sided carry-on and what works better.

[@awaytogether]

Thanks! Check out this video! kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZnuToXavo8mMb7s

[@mlrpreis]

Another benefit of Briggs and Riley is that they are one of the few companies that still make a two-wheel model. I had to retire my Travel Pro after I could no longer repair the zipper - again - and the wheels graduated from comically musical to embarrassingly annoying. I travel to a lot of off the beaten *smoothly or even paved* paths, and while it’s not the model you reviewed, I compared many of the same brands and very few have a quality two wheeler. Regardless, if you prefer a two-wheeler I suggest you look into your options quickly; even Hartman doesn’t make one anymore.

[@ruthradford897]

Super helpful! Thanks for all your efforts with these reviews!

[@springsogourne]

I love my soft sided Kipling bags, I’ve had them for years, and they still look like new. Lightweight, wheels are fantastic, handle is sturdy, they look great too.

[@dpmu1977]

The Max Lite 5 by Travelpro 19 inch great international carry on. I also have the Swiss Gear 18" 4010 that has been on both transatlantic and transcontinental both as checked and as a carry on. It's held up well but the Travelpro is much better.

[@kschmidt1967]

Briggs & Riley user here. Worth every cent.

[@clawrence6190]

I have the TravelPro Maxlite and so far it has been great. Holds a lot, rolls along easily, sturdy handle.

[@ahjaymacd4867]

Thanks for this. I may be the odd one out, but I always use a lightweight 2-wheel bag. Mainly Travelpro brand - currently their Maxlite 5 at 2.5 kilos. The 2-wheelers have more space for the same dimensions. I have bought spinners, but wheels often break. For 30+ years I usually take 20-30 flights a year, so they get a lot of use. I am probably on my 7th Travelpro. I have a Tumi given to me but it was way too heavy at over 5 kilos.

[@ericl29]

That Briggs and Riley bag is available through Costco for $380. We have a travel pro and really like it. But we are considering this B&R bag for a second carry on bag.

[@awaytogether]

That's a GREAT price! Wish we had Costco around here.

[@mitchk2981]

You get what you pay for. Briggs and Riley, Hartman, Travel Pro are expensive but have been around a long time and are built to last with features designed based on years of actual use. I personally use a Hartman because I got it on sale about 15 years ago.

[@hadaskalish4822]

I'd love a review of 22inch carry-ons up to 2kg, they're important for the European Airlines with an 8-10kg weight limit

[@claudiamiller7730]

Most important for me is a handle placed on the bottom of the bag, between the wheels. Makes it a ton easier to pull the bag out of the overhead bin.

[@DianeCardanoCasacio]

great video. I picked Briggs and Riley for the flat surface, !! I did not know that.. thanks Again

[@JohnDoe-sr1dd]

I've had the same Travel Pro for a decade. Awesome suitcase, darn near indestructible. Had the Samsonite, zipper crapped out after a year.

[@wannabedal-adx458]

I am leaning toward the TravelPro or the Samsonite. I need to replace an Embark(??) bag and a swissgear. I am not as heavy duty traveler as most, but want to balance carry-on bag with a roller "personal" or computer bag. Thanks for the honest review.

[@Mommaslew]

Love this review! Ty! I am happy to see the one you recommended is the one I own…and love!😊

[@timothylehr6927]

always has excellent content

[@Joe-lb8qn]

I bought a bag with two wheels (relatively hard to find now because 4 is the fashion) because the wheels are partially built into the case which means that you get more internal space than in a 4 wheeler because the external size of the 4 wheelers include the air underneath the case !

[@DoReMeaCulpa]

I agree with you, and my preference is also a two wheel bag. They are also better if you are stopped on an incline, as a 4 wheel bag can roll away in you, but not a 2 wheeler.

[@LesliePenczek-x4x]

I REALLY enjoyed listening to your presentation. Very informative 🙂👍🏻👍🏻🇺🇸 and… your speaking skills were very good.

[@roxanneonthemove4187]

We have several pieces of luggage, funny how luggage like clothing things come back “in style”. Suitcases used to be hard sides, remember Samsonite commercial with the gorilla tossing the suitcase around? I have had Delsey, American Tourister, still have Samsonite 26” soft sides, 2 wheels & 28” hard shell 4 wheels, 21” carry ons hard shell 4 wheels, TravelPro Crew9 (21”or 22”) 2 wheels, Samsonite 20” soft side 4 wheels and we have have other numerous ones I don’t remember so probably not worth thinking about. Our backpacks are Briggs & Riley and Peak Design. Each one bought for a specific purpose at the time of purchase. The ones we favor the most though are the 2 wheeled Samsonite 26” and the TravelPro carry on. Why? Because we can pack more in them when we need to, sometimes our travels are only a few days in one place before moving on, the way softsides open is a smaller footprint so easy to find a place to open it and not having to maneuver around it. I’m now looking for replacements for our 26” bags as they have taken a beating and finally wearing on the corners.

[@silvahawk]

I'd pick soft luggage over hard shell mainly for weight, but most of these are even heavier than the hard shell ones

[@marylou9584]

Great video, very informative review. I never thought of the other brands, but this video is very helpful for me to decide if ever I need to purchase a soft sided carry on.

[@Dr.Schlitz]

I have the travelpro bag and it has a major design flaw. It expands outside the footprint of the wheels, kind of like a beer gut, which makes it unbalanced and prone to tipping over.

[@redtestarossa]

I have flown euro carriers and have had my carryon bags weighed. I like nylon backpacks and my thin Tumi canvas bag.

[@dailyequanimity]

Adding one more comment that I am looking at three different TravelPro items. The one you showed above really measures 23 inches not 22 inches. I’m undecided on either the platinum elite carry-on spinner versus the Crew classic compact carry-on, expandable spinner versus the Crew versapack Global carry on spinner. Hello, I am coming to this late, but I really need help figuring out which TravelPro carry-on luggage to buy for two upcoming international trips. Right now I’m looking at The Travelpro platinum elite carry-on, spinner versus the Crew classic compact carry-on expandable spinner versus the Crew versapack Global carry-on spinner. Like you I get concerned about that 1 inch and half inch extra size that goes over the 22 x 14 x 9 international requirement on the Platinum Elite, which has the most positive reviews. I know the Platinum Elite reviews say that it seems to work on international flights, but who wants to stress at the gate once there. I also want to know about the inside dimensions since I do pack a lot but I want to make this work for my 12 days. What to do! Which one of these three! I’d love to know what you ended up choosing. Thank you.

[@cindydecker57]

I”m too looking at the same TravelPro bags specifically for international flights. I am leaning towards the Crew Versapack Global spinner. Which one did you end up buying?

[@JonhyFerlisi]

En el momento en que vi el bolso kislux , supe que tenía que tenerlo.

[@ShelinaV]

Awesome breakdown, thank you!

[@Rose-qr4xn]

Excellent review!!! As an “occasional” traveler, I would pick the less expensive brands.

[@dorothycline9439]

My pick above all these is the Plume Cabin Size Spinner Lipault. At 4.8 pounds this bag has great spinner wheels and I've taken it on 4 international trips and many in the US. It has held up great, fits the international plane sizes for carryon, and is under $200. Why are you not reviewing it?

[@benn2go]

Very helpful but do you have any videos for best soft side checked baggage? Thanks!

[@k3ttt]

What about Brics? Saw them at the luggage store. Are they any good?

[@anneyeh9474]

Great content! I hope you will do a similar review for international carry on roller bags too

[@SUSYDEHORTA]

excellent video now for a international travel which would you recommend, thank you

[@jeanbjones1]

What about eagle creek carry on?

[@stevebaker9346]

Not included on you list is Ricardo of Beverly Hills. I traveled over 150k by air before I retired and my Ricardo carryon lasted me over 12 years of business travel and now I use it for pleasure travel during retirement. I love the garment bag compartment!

[@AnnSarasvati]

I never see anyone comment or review the Ricardo carryon with 4 spinner wheels. I have probably had mine 9 or 10 years and have done quite a few international and USA trips. It still looks fairly new and has held up well.

[@schw0373]

I just bought the Briggs & Riley, and while I like the compression system, flat bottom, and ease of rolling, it's so dang heavy at over 10 lbs. I haven't gone on my trip yet, but I'm seriously worried this carry-on is going to throw out my back, esp since I'll be wheeling it around all day long. I'm thinking about returning it and getting a different roller that weighs under 6 lbs. I just haven't found any that seem very good so far...I only want soft-side, so if anyone has recommendations let me know. Worth mentioning, I already bought and returned the TravelPro because it doesn't steer very well, esp compared with the Briggs.

[@tennesseedreamermusic]

Hey hey! Thanks for this awesome video. I am leaving for some long, slow, indefinite travels through Europe soon, and some of the smaller airlines I am flying with (like Turkish Airlines) have a depth requirement of 7" max - not 9" or 10"! Do you know if this is common? I'm finding that most "carry on" bags are larger than that - so I'm pretty frustrated trying to find the perfect bag

[@tennesseedreamermusic]

I also wonder...if a soft shell bag is 9" deep - perhaps it could be squished down to 7"?

[@vancouverboy72]

Are there any bags that are easy to repair? The wheels on my carry on bag just broke again. I've bought so many bags over the years and usually some minor damage occurs to the wheels or handle, and there doesn't seem any way to repair them. I've seen videos online of people fixing their bags, but when I try to repair mine either there are no parts that fit or the bag gets destroyed trying to remove the broken parts. Which is such a waste when it's something simple like a flat sided wheel or stuck handle.

[@BardWannabe]

The higher end TravelPros are probably worth it, but I bought one of their lower cost Maxlite bags and my extension handle got stuck extended when I was trying to check in in Athens. They took it and did something to force it down, but now it’s stuck down. Even if I get it fixed under warranty, it will be hard to trust it again.

[@charliekempner1714]

Great video, thanks! What are your thoughts on trolley style carry-on bags, particularly as a way to haul a backpack or second bag via hook for low center of gravity?

[@snowbike8032]

Condor requires a depth of no more than 7.8" and ALL of the bags we've seen are 9-10". Can someone comment on this discrepancy? Thank you so much for the excellent video!

[@AeroTravels]

Great report! Thank you. Greetings from Munich, Germany

[@onestarabove7027]

Having worked at Hartsfield Airport in Atlanta, just be aware that your luggage gets treated brutally in the loading process. Bags are all dumped together and tossed around.

[@TLhike]

Been using Eagle Creek forever & been across world w them. Fantastic quality, warranty & cust service. Price is only an issue in the absence of value!

[@markshard]

I have something called a rucksack picked up through Rick Steves travel site. fantastic design. soft shell. expandable. backpack straps or handle. no wheels but small enough to not be a burden. I take the one bag for 3 days or 3 weeks.

[@malaconway2645]

Can you suggest the lightest carry in bag, please. Strong as well.

[@kathygann7632]

The Hartman weighs almost 10 pounds which means you could only take 15 pounds of clothing and toiletries. I had a Tumi, but on a trip, the handle wouldn’t retract and stayed stuck out. That shouldn’t happen to an expensive suitcase. I only used it occasionally for about 3 years

[@acbc3543]

I’m not attached to brands . I got an extra piece of luggage in Liverpool and it cost me £59 for a midsize luggage . I’ll take it again to my trip next year . If it survives my marathon then it’s a winner . I’d be scared about spending $895 on a Tumi but I also have a pacsafe bag for my passport , documents and money that I consider the best investment for a safer trip .

[@barakdarak3503]

I am 6'7" and need a bag with a longer handle that I can carry on. Are the handle lengths all the same on the bags you reviewed? I like the Briggs & Riley.

[@Kuanyin3]

How long does it take to recharge the charger in the travel pro?

[@mauricioweber8879]

Why don’t all have shoes compartments? Specially the expensive ones? How do sho compartments look like in the first ones?

[@edgarchambers4397]

YES! To Briggs & Riley. Well built, well sized, incredible warranty I have had to use a few times. The only problem is if you want to use as carry on for flights with carry on weight limits, they run a little bit heavier than some other brands like Samsonite. NO! No! No! To Tumi! Nice bag, but warranty is NOT honored. Had one for just over a year and the handle broke. Tumi said their warranty didn’t cover the handle - Huh? Wife’s Tumi bag had a problem with the wheel 6 months later and again, no warranty coverage. They claim an all inclusive warranty but it is not honored. Threw the Tumi bags away.

[@a.r.r.5626]

I purchased my carry-on in this size from Costco in 2002. This thing is a durable beast! Over 20 years later, it is still my go-to travel suitcase. The wheels still spin just fine (I silicon lube them occasionally), the zippers are still in tact and the inside is still just fine. NOTHING has gone wrong with this carry-on and it has been probably over 250 flights. Kirkland Signature travel equipment rocks! Am taking it to Germany next month for 2 weeks as my only suitcase. I am sure it will serve me well once more.

[@eladbari]

Can those soft shell bags support a 14kg / 30 pounds Backpack resting on top of them? (Hooked to the handle)

[@margaritasmirnova]

In the beginning you said watch out for external size and then offer travel pro elite 21 inch. Its external height is 23.5 inches. The 20 inch version external height is 22.5. So what do you recommend then?

[@samaruti9446]

I'm looking for a good carry-on suitcase similar with a removable garment sleeve similar to the Tumi Continental Dual Access 4 Wheeled Carry-On but I'm not interested in spending $1000. Does anyone have any ideas?

[@backlogbusters]

WOW! Didn’t expect Ron to get roasted in a luggage review hahaha!

[@awaytogether]

Hahaha #neverforget

[@baronvonhypnosis]

I really wish you would have talked about how tipsy these are when packed.

[@rebeccar1036]

Confused that the video starts off stating all carry-ons reviewed fall within the 22x14x9 requirements yet the very first one, Swiss Gear exceeds those measurements. Neither does the Delsey. Is “close enough” good enough to get past the airlines?

[@secretariatgirl4249]

My "brocade" soft side from about the 90's meets international standards, has an EXTERNAL handle setup like the expensive one and a J hook and, frankly, it's probably is as good as anything out there now. It was part of a set (I sold the bigger ones). Has 2 recessed ROLLERS that really don't take up interior space and little feet and stands strong. Not a clamshell, either. Great zippers which can take a lock. I'm not feeling that enticed by most of the stuff being sold now...esp.at the prices on some of these things. Also, some of what I've researched as "lightweight" are nearly or actually heavier than my approx. 8 lb bag! And a lot of them are actually bigger than the optimum 22 x 14 x 9 in at least one measurement.

[@autumnernst5582]

Thanks for the video! Very informative! Now my real question is after buying 7 hard shell luggage and all these carry ons - do you return the ones you don’t like? Or do you have a garage full of carry on luggage?😂

[@laurisa0318]

My pet peeve with the cheaper carry ons is the flimsy telespopic handle. The 4 wheel spinners is the trend now, but you are losing a day’s worth of clothes that you can otherwise pack with those higher wheels.

[@MARKRYDEN2world]

profession and useful suggestion👍

[@waldograde]

Very helpful!

[@bradsimpson8977]

The Briggs n Riley design, quality and lifetime warranty makes their luggage well worth the price.

[@michelleevans9869]

Nice review…any thoughts on the Solgaard carryon closet? Seems like an interesting concept for around 350.00.

[@awaytogether]

Thanks! It's on my list to review! I've been asked about it a lot

[@michaelball7868]

@@awaytogether Solgaard gets some serious quality control negatives in reviews.

[@darrylk808]

Soft side is top open. There are no hardside top open luggage that I know of. Delsey had one once, but I can't find it anymore. I have one 22" Delsey hard side top open. I fell on it and bent the handle tube. I can't find a new one anywhere. Top open is great for sharing a hotel luggage shelf. Clamps shell opening means you can't leave it open if you travel with someone. Softies also have outside pockets. Expensive bags make you a target..."rob that guy." 😂

[@diannedeloose5173]

Does the power pack come with the suitcase? If not, which power pack do you recommend to purchase? Great info Nik! Thanks

[@awaytogether]

No unfortunately not. Here is a power bank I like amzn.to/3rltS0h (affiliate link)

[@philiphwong9044]

Does the BR ZDX fit a 15" laptop?