Vocal Coach reacts to U2 - With Or Without You (Bono Live)

The first 1000 people to use the link will get a free trial of Skillshare Premium Membership: skl.sh/bethroars07211
This video is sponsored by Skillshare
📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
☀️ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" 🐺 on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bet...
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: / bethroars
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vocal Coach reacts reaction to U2 - With Or Without You (Bono Live)
Original Video: • U2 - With Or Without Y...
I hope this video helps you understand your voice and what you can do to grow as a singer
Book a lesson with Beth at www.bethroars.com/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Social Media
Facebook: bethroars
Twitter: @bethroars
Insta: @bethroars

[@paulschirf9259]

Bono's voice in the Unforgettable Fire days was off the scale. I left a concert hall in 1985 and saw a thousand people crying as they made their way back to their cars, all still singing the encore song.

[@stevemercer6976]

Must have been '40'. I caught them on the same tour. I'll never forget the crowd still singing in one voice all the way out of the venue and on to the street.

[@mysticedge4]

@@stevemercer6976 it was 40, 40 is the only song you can keep singing while going back to your car! (Also I believe U2 ended every show on the unforgettable fire tour with 40)

[@CatsnCoasters]

How long.....to sing this song.

[@wheelz8240]

That girl's gonna remember that night for the rest of her life :)

[@xxmrbrooksxx]

More Bono. Especially 90s Bono, when his singing was the best. My honest opinion.

[@Hockey-gn2tj]

Great opinion I agree he was better in the 90s

[@brettshackles3657]

Especially lemon

[@xxmrbrooksxx]

@@brettshackles3657 I agree especially Lemon. Bono had a great falsetto/head voice.

[@sbuttonblossom9286]

Every Breaking Wave acoustic shows he gets better with age.

[@rawzuccsauce4202]

@@sbuttonblossom9286 It's actually kind of crazy. Listened to the live version of that song recently and I'm still impressed by Bono's voice.

[@ZOOTV-1976]

I love Bono’s vocal performances but it’s not just the vocals it’s also the emotional support to the vocals. What he can bring to our hearts.

[@eboethrasher]

Emotion is the key for Bono, 100%. That's what makes him the awesome singer he is, and why he says he can't double his vocals in the studio because he never sings them exactly the same twice.

[@seanohalloran384]

Her future cuddle partners have a lot to live up to. I never considered how Bono goes from talking to singing in this song. Great video!

[@chicken2jail545]

Right?! Dude: I'm way cooler than the last guy you cuddle with. Who was he? Girl: Bono Dude: I'mma head out.

[@qthelost]

I just recently watched the video of U2 performing the song "Miss Sarajevo" in Milan with Bono singing the Pavarotti part in Italian. It was amazing.

[@justincredible.]

Bono's voice is all character. He is the most emotional and powerful singer around!

[@Datalore]

Oh man. I love this. If you’re keen to do another u2 song where Bono’s voice is pure emotion, please do All I want is you / Where the Streets Have no Name, live from Slane Castle 2001. Stunning, goose bump stuff

[@DesireeStamat]

Yes

[@davidtroy1701]

Amazing

[@agusg.t.8950]

Her face shining. Her eyes brighting. That’s U2. Amazing video

[@cobainkleynhans4737]

One of the best vocalists of all time for sure. Awesome stuff 😎

[@corwin32]

Wow, man. Those cries. Rips my heart out of my chest every version, every time.

[@mykebreeden]

His father literally had just passed away a few days prior. But he chose to still put on the show, a lot of his voice that night was actual legit pain and sorrow, if you notice the edge gave him a bro understanding his pain look a few times and the band had a somber emotion

[@robolsons9042]

I was wondering why he didn't sound very good

[@jordijub9276]

No, his father passed away some months after this show, before the show in Ireland, Slane Castle, during the european leg.

[@OfficialMyxomatosis]

Michael you are lying.

[@OfficialMyxomatosis]

@@jordijub9276 I was at a show not long after his father's death and Bono's acting for this song is the same.

[@mykebreeden]

@@jordijub9276 for some reason I was thinking this was slane Castle concert couldn't really tell from watching it on a phone but I stand corrected.

[@Cornerboy73]

All in all, I thought he did pretty well here considering that they usually play this towards the end of the show. I personally always get nervous leading up to that falsetto piece at the end; it's like "is his voice going to hold for it tonight or will he crack?" LOL. But hey, he always tries and at, what, 61 now, I guess we can't ask more of him than that. He'll always be one of the very best singers to ever rock a stage and not just from his generation either. Thanks for the video !

[@jamesmacoisdealbhaigh9904]

The best vocals Bono ever done was on Clannad's song "In a lifetime" in fact the vocals of both Moya Brennan and Bono in that song are pure emotion and spine tingling 👌

[@zakarialaouira]

Very underrated song and One of my fav songs of all time "In a Lifetime" Huge U2 fan from Algeria

[@daflotsam]

Agreed.

[@CristhianDalmazzo]

Indeed

[@IreneAtzori]

Yess, pure magic!!!

[@ragayomama]

Thanks. I'll look that one up.

[@vaughnnewman8903]

Goosebumps. Every time. Doesn't get more legendary than this.

[@Bad_Wolf_Media]

I know this video/channel is all about the vocal styles and techniques, but that harmonic resonance sound, nearly theremin-like that Edge is getting from the guitar at the beginning...Another master at his craft in this band.

[@robertcronin6603]

Def

[@megsley]

edge's guitar style always makes me think of big cathedral church bells and that sort of holy reverence - which is probably the point 😉

[@eboethrasher]

I believe he is using an E-Bow (a guitar tool that causes a string to vibrate infinitely so that you can play notes on it without having to pick it, similar to how a strings player uses a bow, rather than using a pick) live, but it is an Infinite Guitar (actually a prototype at the time), created by Michael Brook used on the album. An E-Bow simulates it fairly well. Much like how the part on Heroes by Bowie was not played with an E-Bow either, yet can be approximated by one very easily.

[@eboethrasher]

You can see him using an E-Bow during the sessions for The Unforgettable Fire on the behind the scenes documentary.

[@davidburke2132]

@@eboethrasher I think by this point he’s using a Fernandes Sustainer system in the guitar (from the clips in this video with The Edge in the distance he doesn’t appear to be holding an EBow and his picking hand movements wouldn’t be consistent with the stability needed to use an EBow to get the sounds he’s getting at that point). It’s basically the same technology as an EBow but integrated into the guitar itself housed within the pickups. It facilitates the same sounds and playing techniques as an EBow with the added flexibility of leaving your picking hand free and being usable on all strings simultaneously if you want to do that. Ed O’Brien of Radiohead has the same system installed in his signature Fender Stratocaster. Edit: it’s definitely a Fernandes Sustainer system. If you pause the video at 9:36 you can clearly see the Fernandes neck pickup with its characteristic ‘blade’ rather than polepiece design.

[@con2mms2000]

I've been listening to U2 since 1997. I became a fan like in 2001. They are sooooooooo good. Their shows are incredible and Bono's voice is amazing, even now that he's much older.

[@ktwashere5637]

Let's face it, this is one of the best songs ever written. People think the 80s was all about Duran Duran but it was so much more.

[@Larissa_aus]

It was about everything BUT Duran Duran 🤮🤮🤮

[@corrymichelini]

I was at this concert. U2 is one of the best live bands.

[@dianehappydaystudios9509]

I was, too!! Best concert ever and I’ve been a dozen U2 concerts. :-)

[@trevacassidy2231]

Same!

[@christianreynolds9252]

Great reaction video . The emotion side of Bono is what sets him apart from every other frontman. Such an unbelievable performer. See miss Sarajevo live from Milan Bono sings incredible in that. Also Bad from live aid is another one of Bono’s best vocals. He has unbelievable vocals but throws in unbelievable emotion at the same time 👌

[@user-nt1wk5uh2m]

Bono is a master of belting

[@leandrepascualbouys7648]

This performance is awesome , vibing voice and energy

[@alfie9718]

This! This is so great to see you reacting to U2 just as thousands of us do every time we watch their live stuff! Raw emotion ❤️

[@sceneanuerebelrebel9244]

It's a poem that you whisper to your intimate other under your breath and lips just brushing her ear baring the soul to your love ...

[@PeterSchank-rp3qo]

I admire your optimistic way of being, you burn optimistic energy

[@BethRoars]

📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop ☀ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" 🐺 on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bethroars/power-of-the-wolf 🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars

[@williamquigley6857]

I love your huge, genuine smile whilst listening in the beginning.

[@bodies2magenta]

Wonderful analysis, utterly enjoyed your reaction/summary of this U2 - most specifically Bono's performance. Thank You, Beth.

[@johnbassett7963]

You should definitely do All I want is you/Where the streets have no name live from Slane castle. The emotion in his voice is amazing. His father had not long died

[@MartyLoose]

Simply OUTSTANDING... Your heartfelt reaction was nearly as heartfelt as this masterpiece song.

[@chicken2jail545]

Great Reaction Beth! I saw U2 live back in 87. Such Good Times.

[@lindaclad2218]

Thank you Beth! You always pick the best songs of the best groups to react to. Love every one of them !!! Well done!

[@davidwebb6556]

What you don't hear in these live versions is that the crowd will be absolutely belting out the song. When you are in the crowd, you can barely hear the band so it will be the same for bono.

[@normanleroy1874]

Always loved the bass in this song, especially in the beginning.

[@mynythunder9]

Thank you for doing an all time favorite songs!

[@megsley]

when the boston concert DVD was released I was in high school - I think I watched that concert like twice a week for months 😂 this part especially was like omg bonooooo please sing this to me!!

[@peteroneill5426]

Absolutely beautiful video Beth! Thanks so much for covering this absolute classic, from Sabaton to U2, you've my taste in Music covered!

[@willemvandebeek]

yin: The number one, primarily used in Scotland and Ulster For the people who thought Beth said 'chin'....

[@leighhaynes]

I thought she said ‘tune’.

[@salishseamermaid]

I've seen U2 live about a dozen times, and I'm always amazed at how much raw emotion Bono puts into his performances.

[@dannyrodriguez1044]

MORE Bono. PLZ

[@justincredible.]

I love your enthusiasm!

[@MrMatt-sm5mi]

Yes, please. More U2/Bono vocals

[@travisbunce7334]

My favorite version of this song is on the Rattle and Hum Movie. All 4 of them nail their performances, but Edge just takes it to 12 with his Solo.

[@jaffaholland4039]

I was blessed to see U2 opening concert at Madersin Square NY for this, mind blown

[@dylans2376]

U2 is the Best concert I’ve ever seen live 👌🏼

[@mystery1317]

I had never thought of the vocalization parts of this song as anguished cries but it makes SENSE and it really comes through in this performance. I love it!

[@Wisdawms]

thank you for this amazing experience..

[@yo_guillote]

Bono love ,thank You

[@fabior3199]

You have to do "Love is Blindness" + "Can't help falling in Love" from Sydney in 93 by them. Absolutely stunning!

[@chad7081]

Agree, though I loved that entire concert and many other done by u2. One of the if not the greatest bands live and studio of all time

[@erikmardiste]

Was at the 360 tour in Brisbane Australia mid 2000s remember belting the out with 60 000 fans. He stopped half way through we took over, was awesome.

[@alexeyovriakh2450]

Beautiful.

[@thelastholdout]

I love this reaction vid. I would love to see you do a reaction to the live version of Every Breaking Wave. Bono basically carries the song with little more than a piano behind him, and it's beautiful beyond words.

[@Finnan189]

I love your enthusiasm.

[@michaelpiche929]

Great song,true classic

[@Clara-mm2yi]

You could check out the band Inhaler, the lead singer is bono‘s son and their voices are sometimes very similar.

[@andresacostaescobar]

Finally! U2. Bono makes more amazing vocal performances on other less popular songs, though (red hill mining town, a sort of homecoming, bad, moment of surrender, among others)

[@mystery1317]

Red Hill Mining Town is a song I didn’t really appreciate until I experienced it live and his vocals really pop off, even nowadays with the songs being in a lower key!

[@user-nt1wk5uh2m]

Bono masterpiece vocals !!!!! Master of belting !

[@chrisfairbarn9908]

Fascinating

[@gzz8551]

Beth, you really need to look at Bono singing ‘Kite’ from U2 live at Slane Castle in 2001. The emotion is insane. Bono sings it for his father who passed away a few days earlier. It will destroy you. 🥺

[@68Warpigs]

Zooropa 1992 at old Wembly (proper Wembly) was the greatest gig I will ever go to my whole life, come what may.I was 2nd row and Bono sounded amazing, the whole show was larger than life.

[@GayJayU26]

My favourite song of all time, lots of memories

[@bellies1000]

Ok i can only click that like button once but if i could i would still be liking this right now!:):):) Storytelling, interacting with a crowd, engaging people, questioning themselves and other people way of living, getting a viewpoint across,etc,etc . This is what i mostly miss in the years now where everything is based on that quick notion of haste, getting your high as fast a s possible. This band will forever be there in my heart and i am so glad that i have grown up and have been able to listen to their music and watch them live! A real treat and honor! Maybe technically not the best example but if you want to explain to people how you should make music and above all how you should tell a story and perform this definitely is one of the examples how you should do it!! (would love to see a special on Bono. What makes him great? Or maybe not because i allready know what makes him great!:):):):):):):))

[@aprild9577]

U2 is a bucket list band for me. Unfortunately they haven't come near where I am yet. I keep hoping they do some time

[@RodRuth]

I believe it's more about connecting with your audience emotionally, and passionately, and less about being technically correct. The greatest performers / vocalists, past and present, are natural masters at this. Nice analysis Beth..........

[@AzaleaLuna]

I love Bono. He gives it all.

[@kpodonnell7924]

Great performance and loved the reaction. You should check out U2’s Sydney performance of Can’t Help Falling in Love With You. One of Bono’s finest and most interesting vocal performances.

[@blairhunt1424]

I love you Beth🥰

[@AnthonyPerez-ju2cc]

Could you do U2 - All i want is you! Please!!

[@chrisberol]

I love how much you loved this song!!! I am a massive U2 fan from Argentina and love your reactions and lessons on singers, please keep reacting to U2. I also would like to recommend you to react to an Argentinian singer called Abel Pintos, particularly to the song El Adivino live. Thanks and love!

[@elroyaston6277]

You are very sharp ma'am. Chapeau.

[@rogerlacaille3148]

Would love to hear/see your reaction to Echo and the Bunnymen Killing Moon! They are/were so underrated!

[@FreelancerND]

Joshua Tree. An absolute legend of an album. The ONLY thing I could add to it is Van Diemen's Land, because Edge is such a good vocalist.

[@jeremiahrose4681]

Have you done Extreme; "More Than Words" - love the vocals.

[@Sean-hi5ec]

I know nothing about singing, but appriciate good singers. I love your honest and passionate reviews. Keep it up....loving your channel. Would live to see a review of Matt Bellamy and Muse!

[@johnsouthwell1869]

i saw this tour in PHX - the girl was sobbing (and i don't blame her)

[@renssy78]

Love your page ❤

[@BethRoars]

Thank you!

[@luizfkc8694]

His Miss Sarajevo in Milan is amazing

[@rockonileva]

From this very concert, the version of Bad/Where the Streets have no name... my favorite live music moment EVER

[@robertbeck1922]

Mine too! As well as "CLOSE YOUR EYES AND IMAGINE JASON MACATEER!"

[@deejd3160]

Grande análise Beth! Gosto muito da música "Sometimes you can't make it on your own" onde Bono entrega tudo em homenagem ao seu pai. Ao vivo, sua voz nessa música se transforma em ópera de tanta vontade de quebrar os limites físicos para chegar até ele. Emocionante!

[@dougdoug9268]

2021 and beyond still the biggest band on earth

[@leonelvillalba8506]

Beth es hermosa 😍

[@renssy78]

My first fave band @ 7 -I want one of their songs as my goodbye song when it comes time , also just found out i am 48% Irish ☘️

[@TheLaidOffFounder]

very nicely done. Try Every Breaking Wave by U2 at the MTV Awards :-) One of my fave of his vocals. Or Miss Sarejevo from Milan (when he goes for the Pavarotti bit).

[@1010abcdefgh]

Clannad "In a lifetime " with Bono, two amazing voices for the price of one..

[@vanlevy2008]

Great explanations. I understand Bono's talent better.

[@dizzle7558]

Their live performances of "Where the streets have no name" are so amazing🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@mystery1317]

A personal fave is the Rose Bowl concert from the 360 tour because it starts with a rendition of Amazing Grace which then fades into the intro riff in the most satisfying way!

[@Evan-yw4zn]

if you plan on doing more u2, i definitely recommend reacting to the live rendition of Sunday Bloody Sunday from rattle and hum. probably their greatest live performance

[@pj1995____]

Bonos pronunciation of "you" as "chew" is an Irish thing, its part of a lot of Irish accents and bono says this in his normal speaking voice also

[@robertkelleher1850]

Please please please, have a listen to Every Breaking Wave from the MTV EMAs.

[@robertot.m.8747]

Amazing! Thanks for your analysis. And you should do another video of Bono, there are hundreds of better performances by him, including falsetto voices etc. I will suggest Mysterious Ways in 93, it has all he can do with the voice :)

[@christianreynolds9252]

You have to react to u2 every breaking wave live from the EMA’S 2014 . One of Bono’s greatest vocals ever . Unbelievable performance. Spine tingling

[@DatuakGaming1001]

Wow

[@jonnyz5772]

for all the guitarists THIS is how u dial in a stratocaster - the contrast it provides under the vocal is almost chilling

[@barbaravs1814]

This is amazing, I forgot Bono did/does that type of thing. You should react to Keane if you haven't. And I know you already reacted to Depeche Mode but there's a live version of When The Body Speaks in Paris that is not perfect but idk I'd like to see your opinion.

[@birkinater1139]

🤩😍❤

[@OfficialMyxomatosis]

I love this song. It means everything to the band... It is about them almost breaking up.

[@leftytwogunz3951]

A great performance is Hands That Built America during the Oscars. Even Daniel Day Lewis emotional.

[@Larissa_aus]

My favourite U2 song has to be "Where the Streets have No Names". 😍💖

[@guitaleleoeuvre]

Beth, I'm a songwriter/guitar player, not really a singer. But, I have been trying to teach myself how to sing along with my guitalele. Even tho wishes are fishes!