BFDI: What if Pin could pick first?

[@abronilo]

I'm surprised that despite this huge change in the lore, the show ended with the same 4 finalists. There are canonical events that cannot be changed ☠️

[@robloxsubtochasecalebERROR666]

A verified again?

[@Wiser193]

FR IM LIKE 👀 👄

[@abronilo]

Lol just by seeing pngs of the characters and some texts I'm already imagining the whole series that way, I even got excited and cried a lot, I loved it 🎩🎉

[@PixeledPuffball]

The writers would not put Spongy up for elimination in the episode he rejoins against more liked contestants, they're smart enough to realize that.

[@cyborgprogemgamer3533]

He shouldnt rejoin at all

[@V0ided-v1f]

Thats not true at all 😭. Flower rejoined and she ended up being up for elimination in the same episode lol

[@PixeledPuffball]

@@V0ided-v1f That's because they probably thought they could survive against Rocky and/or because Flower was voted by the viewers, not the writers. They would likely give more bias to Spongy because he rejoined because the writers wrote him back.

[@RealBlocky]

@@cyborgprogemgamer3533i feel like they gave him a chance

[@Micah_YT]

I like how you're saying "the writers" when it was just cary and/or Michael lol

[@Spitiphone]

I honestly might prefer this over the original elimination order (aside from TD) and might even prefer the teams! good job and you did well on this video.

[@Spitiphone]

But there's one thing I'll like to say, I think TD would get eliminated instead of Pencil, Pencil was a very liked character and was a very good character, also the reason Rocky got out was due to being bland, so I think TD would get eliminated for the same thing, but I can see Pencil getting eliminated.

[@JaeFresh504]

Gotta give bro respect for mentioning Sam 💀

[@stevenhumenny816]

David getting visualized before Sam is ludicrous

[@CyanPlushCaptain]

honestly this is a very realistic alternate timeline for this show. it’s pretty cool.

[@PowersUprising]

“We’ll just say Pin pushed Leafy off before she could complain” If that happened the entirety of Battle For Dream Island wouldn’t have

[@Fitnessgramtmpacertest]

The fact that it still ends in the original top 4 is crazy

[@JacobFiveash]

I love how Firey defends Bubble in BFDI 23.

[@Kiro_KLTNBRBOSCF]

BFDI what ifs in 2030: “BFDI: What if Coiny and Firey were friends?”

[@goodboi7026]

That isn't a bad idea, though.

[@baileybhamjee8080]

@@goodboi7026I mean, it sorta negates their whole personalities.

[@thejizzman69]

that kinda explains the bfdi 25 part where firey and coiny hug

[@zgui2763]

who is gonna tell him

[@thejizzman69]

@@zgui2763 what?

[@trahnier5360]

Firey being alliance with bubble is a menace like two really good finalists 💀💀💀 also this changes are really good i kinda like this better than the cannon one. The only thing I don't like is spongy being eliminated after he rejoined, viewer's will not likely vote a contestant just rejoined. Lastly, leafy definitely steal dream island without any remorse. Since leafy give her immunity to firey and just firey to take side on bubble.

[@Abdullah-mon]

5:11 I hate how everyone says “spongy is useless” like bro he isn’t, he actually did the challenges, he did well, he was used as a boat. People voted him for either thinking that or the more likely option that he is fat

[@bruhmomentum_]

actually by BFDI 2 in this universe his only contribution was trying to get past the obstacle course and failing, he wasn’t even used as a boat since his team didn’t throw him overboard, he never even went on a boat actually

[@circjit]

i love how you include sam

[@ricarditothebest7500]

Leafy: this makes no sense pin:cry about it

[@Cashy2763]

Who knew such a little thing could change the whole contest

[@jampi_2008]

Outside of spongy elimination, everything seems pretty good

[@YoshiForevz]

This was my favourite what if to watch, it was amazing!

[@AndrewmationsStudios]

Idea: What if the “Contestants not present may not compete” rule didn’t exist?

[@IshaanGames1]

That's actually a good idea

[@thatleafyfan]

37:35 HELP THE MUSIC GOES PERFECTLY WITH NEEDLE GOING BACK 😭🙏

[@R2M_Productions]

I actually think Rocky would win over Spongy in that bread contest. Rocky would vomit bread like he did the maroon balls. And I think Rocky would survive for longer than Spongy did in this scenario.

[@EpicUniqueWill9]

This makes sense because Pin won the Rock Paper Scissors game.

[@Lomiop]

I wish your video gets millions of views because you have great content. Try running ads for your channel using some kind of system.

[@cloudyxmatch]

canon will always be my fav but this is still a good au!

[@dustincook1831]

19:14 I don't think Match has ever called Needle "Needy" as well. There was an episode where Pencil called her "Needy," and Match said to not slap her since she said, "Needle." I guess it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things, though.

[@rosasessa2399]

Alt title If Coiny And Pins Friendship Begin Eariler

[@Perfectlypurple-mc6qz]

Why does the alliance match? (Pencil is patting bubble but bubbles concerned about whatever match is doing.)

[@ForthatIlikeYou]

Yeah, this makes more sense because pin won the rock paper scissors

[@Abdullah-mon]

You should’ve made needle get like a middle of the bunch score so she isn’t so far ahead of everyone, the writers would probably do something that has the announcer sabotage her

[@NovaAzurite]

Genuine question, what is the song you used whenever a character is eliminated, I really like it

[@bruhmomentum_]

@@NovaAzurite HOME - We’re finally landing

[@NovaAzurite]

@@bruhmomentum_ tysm

[@MinecraftBenYT]

Snowball needs to be on the same team as his friends! Leafy loves Firey!

[@tayjutsu584]

Not Spongy getting the TDI Eva treatment

[@NebeerOfficial]

BFDI what ifs in 2050 be like: *_what if Firey's asset didn't have an animation?_*

[@ezracohen3859]

What if pen and tv were in bfdia install of golfball and gelatin

[@Glob-Gaming]

and people dont worry about the tiny things

[@Rulex_OF]

I like the golf ball png like watching flower LOL

[@พรศักดิ์บัวรพา]

So basically what if the cherrys switch places with grapes

[@Ben-geograhpy]

Pin would pick Coiny, needle, or Td

[@ilplolthereturn7525]

I would love to see a BFDIA version

[@lycubing78]

How would Teardrop advocate for Needle? I think Pencil would be picked next and needle would go onto Leafys team

[@bruhmomentum_]

pointing, also just having that happen would mean the teams stay basically the same, which is kinda boring

[@radicaldryix]

Nice if you do start a bfdia, the only changes is that SB would most likely made it.

[@ParaballAyCaramba]

All the others songs that are not made by HOME was made by Kevin MacLeod, not YOYLECAKE

[@bruhmomentum_]

holy crap thanks for telling me I was half asleep when I posted this, I fixed it now, thanks again!

[@beixu5737]

When it's leafy turn crossed,tb and gb choose flower,but there something I want tell... Tb is my 1st favorite,flower is my 2nd favorite and gb is my 3rd favorite😮😮😮

[@cloudyxmatch]

butterfly effect is crazy lmao

[@Shilypoptartwolf279]

what if gelatin,yellow face and puffball were in bfdi???

[@zackattackvideos9291]

Nice video

[@Carlestgamings]

Can you do if pin had her bfdia personalits in bfdi?

[@RobertMartinez-wt1rf]

How do you get all of this just from pin picking first-

[@SuperHario-hi]

43:56 ruined this video for me. I'm sorry but I can't be having this

[@GlobalMapperGuy]

I Think Snowball And Woody Would Switch

[@Nonya._.]

match looks like she wants to eat the text lol

[@broooo884]

I would choose Needle to leave over blocky as needy would just continue to get more hate

[@linorder22]

pin did win rock paper scissors tho

[@Spookin2763]

Please make a part 2

[@CommonSense1993]

Needle wasn't athletic in BFDI

[@oddballer5950]

Coolio

[@wormosc]

nice!

[@EpicRandomness11]

"TD advocates for needle" With what words?

[@OmarEssawyGD]

pointing

[@whatdoiaddhere]

14:37 home - resonance

[@materialgirl4454]

why no crying contest

[@Warhead7199]

why does pencil vote leafy for who they want to win when pencil could've voted bubble or firey.

[@bruhmomentum_]

because in canon she switched to leafy after everyone threatened to slap her

[@Warhead7199]

@@bruhmomentum_ oh mb

[@alexanderslounge-pv6ih]

Than pin would win the island if pin pushed off leafy

[@bouvet_]

butterfly effect

[@YourLocalSpookySun]

And sam

[@Ottergaming26]

33rd like!😅

[@Lomiop]

like get 4 views

[@ForthatIlikeYou]

Yeah, this makes more sense because pin won the rock paper scissors