BFDI: What If the Squishy Cherries Chose Teardrop Instead of Snowball?

This has always been a moment that never made sense to me. Despite her alliance choosing Teardrop, Pencil chose Snowball, and thus got Teardrop out, putting her in 18th place. But what if Pencil instead elected to bring Teardrop in? Well, we're about to find out
All music belongs to their rightful owners, by the way