Billlie | 'RING X RING' M/V

[@peachwillows1191]

I don't understand why people don't see it as a solid debut song!? When RING X RING is played on their first concert, everyone will scream so hard! Bet my words!

[@cinnamaricat]

it's literally so different from other groups debut songs and sets them apart amazingly i couldn't be happier with this song for a debut

[@belllievewalwalforever3215]

Woahhhh definitely YES !!!

[@35nuggetsisalotofnuggets52]

for some reason people don’t like newer sounding songs. This song and O.O by nmixx are two songs that i’ve liked since the beginning. i don’t know why people don’t like it. and Billlies concept is awesome 👏 😌

[@adrianamarcelabohorquezmor7061]

This song has it all, great debut and shows the members so well

[@orange1293]

its a fucking musical and conceptual masterpiece people just cant stand anything thats not the norm

[@heejinscementbrownies1385]

i will forever be a defender of this song. ive liked it since first listen and haven’t gotten tired of it.

[@hanibolenzski]

YESS

[@ancientsoul101]

I can't say the same thing. This song slowly grew on me because at first I just like the chorus.

[@goodietwoshoes7238]

@@ancientsoul101 same

[@miudoll55]

FORREALLL

[@yvesuslovesyou]

SAME

[@_Eunoia_]

Comforted to know that Suyeon (Sheon) will get to debut with her friends instead of needing to wait for new trainees to form a group. And I'm glad she has Moon Sua as the debut leader, someone she has worked with before and will be comfortable around. Billlie will take good care of Sheon. :)

[@sallyseashelly8821]

This is a cute comment. I like it.

[@BeomgyuIsJackieChanSon]

However, I think that Suyeon image is too soft for this group. How will she’s gonna fit in with the other 6 image?? Even Haruna looks tough and fierce and she’s the maknae of the group.

[@leeknowisgod6053]

@@BeomgyuIsJackieChanSon i don’t think suyeon’s image is soft, i think she has rather a stronger image

[@caibingoffbeatkween1842]

@@leeknowisgod6053 you should see her the eve performance

[@jokhaomar7413]

@@BeomgyuIsJackieChanSon have you seen her performances on Gp999 she can be rly fierce she wasn’t rly known as being soft or cute

[@highhighslowlows]

Ring x ring is still THAT song and we don't talk about it enough.

[@remyp.7374]

Say it LOUDER!!

[@Honey_strawberrycake]

YAS

[@viywx]

real

[@remigal899]

Fr I was obsessed with this song for weeks

[@elliotfletcher3614]

Been so overloaded with stuff that this one slipped my radar but.. IT IS SUCH A JAMMITY JAM, YO.

[@MinUniverse]

for some reason this song sounds like it could be a nightmare but then yet it feels comforting lol idk why it feels like that but one of my favorite songs from billlie

[@cinnamaricat]

it's about a friend going missing that's probably why :)

[@alvareo92]

That's why some people hate it because to them it just sounds like a nightmare

[@alvareo92]

THat's such a good description tho and that's exactly why I like it so much!

[@cloviosity]

yes that’s just how i feel too! it’s haunting and a little creepy but the chorus sounds hopeful, and it kind of fits in with their lore where they’re finding billlie!

[@A94-c5z]

whoever produced this song is an absolute genius

[@GenesisJames]

EDIT: I'm glad people liked my thoughts/analysis! I reviewed the entire mini album on my channel if anyone was curious about my thoughts on the other tracks, too!! Yo, this was pretty slick! That weird, crunchy electro-styled beat is pretty unique for k-pop right now, and I loved how each element was weaved into the main instrumental. The verse and chorus transitions are SEAMLESS and the rap bridge along with the breakdown were cool pace-breakers. Good vocals too, and I like how they balance the subtler dark sounds with the lighter, twinkly ones (especially in those synths). Hard to believe that this is a debut. This is a group to watch!

[@dvwnte]

Couldn’t have said it better , like this song is so impressive

[@jessicajessica4392]

It's weird, but in a good way? Very unsettling, but a lot of part are so hunting / catchy. The beat is amazing all throughout the song is amazing, the vocals and rap are carrying the song amazingly well. That's risky but it really pays off.

[@Im_Charizzma_boss_baby_Ricky]

That’s SM for you

[@dvwnte]

@@Im_Charizzma_boss_baby_Ricky it’s not really SM tho , they are a sub of SM but SM isn’t directly involved with this group … if they were we’d be seeing Billlie x Aespa tiktoks and stuff but I don’t think we’ll ever see that unless the group becomes really popular

[@zoengo7110]

@@dvwnte sm definitely made this weird crunchy style beat popular even back in the 2000s with shinee and f(x) which were groups that were used to put out experimental type beats. then they're passing it on now to nct and aespa and RV because it just works so well. can't forget the iconic i got a boy by snsd which is literally the legendary experimental-type song

[@rhkddus516]

no one ever mentioned that this song was produced by Lee Min Soo, who made multiple hits like IU's "good day" and many many others for Brown Eyed Girls, Sunny Hill etc. He always likes to mix unexpected music elements together, thats why this song is so different but good.

[@aries2117]

ooh that's so coool

[@miu869]

Woww makes sense, this gave me strong Sunny Hill vibes from the get go

[@OneDotLeader]

oh then he must have played a lot of bdsp when coming up with this- (looks at release date of ring x ring, then at bdsp) nope 9 days too early still sounds like a pkmn battle theme tho

[@lucyandecember2843]

o.o

[@pstvtycrnr99]

This was the most unique debut last year and I'll never get over it. I would love to see them have a comeback in the future with a similar sounding song!

[@helianthusangel5506]

Tysm. Hope to see you this July 14 comeback

[@estereofobia]

Is impressive how each girl has a distinctive personality and aura without overshadowing each other.

[@mil1975]

i'm so happy suyeon will debut here!! this is an unique group and the girls have amazing skills

[@tb07]

When will she join ?

[@mikelosei382]

@@tb07 they said she'll start activities as soon as the end of November! There's also rumored to be a surprise appearance maybe earlier than that :)

[@BelllieveWav]

She was training with them before she even got on GP999... billlie has always been OT7... if GP999 didnt happen she would have debuted with them...

[@bo_jelin]

I'm so happy that Suyeon/Sheon is going to join, i hope the fandom will accept her

[@sallyseashelly8821]

I hope so too. I didn’t watch GP999, but I plan to welcome her with open arms! I heard she’s got killer stage presence, which makes sense if she’s gonna be in Billlie. The Mystic Story girls have awesome presence! (: I just hope it doesn’t turn into people only talking about her and none of the other members. Because quite a few of the comments were already about her before anyone knew if she’d be in the group. I’m sad that some people didn’t check Billlie out purely because they didn’t know if she was gonna be there or not. I saw a couple of comments pretty much implying it

[@AIVILO_444]

@@sallyseashelly8821 Yeah same, there's def going to be a popularity gap between Suyeon and the other members

[@itreasurr]

she's welcome in the group ♡ plus i know her since she joined gp 999

[@_Eunoia_]

@@AIVILO_444 I don't think it'll be such a big issue to be honest, Moon Sua in particular already had a fairly big following from her Unpretty Rapstar days, and being Astro Moonbin's younger sister means that a lot of Billlie stans are also Arohas here to support Sua in her new group (because Binnie has been talking about her training and upcoming debut for a while now). Almost all the members have pre-debut activities that have given them some sort of fan following before joining Billlie, and now that they've debuted and gained a lot of popularity before Sheon even joins, I think there won't be too much disproportion with biases. Also, coming as a fan of other groups with members from big reality shows (Weki Meki, WJSN), it doesn't take long to fall in love with the group as a whole even if you only come to support your original bias. I followed IOI and started stanning Weki Meki at debut for Yoojung and Doyeon, but my biases are now Lua and Rina. :P

[@_Eunoia_]

@@haizatulnadhrah4307 You're not even a Billlie stan lol, you're just here to troll.

[@hayralouro]

the chokehold this song had on me when it came out. one of the best 4th gen debuts fr

[@lienuhhhh]

forreal

[@Kalidreamine]

holy crap this sound is NUTS. it sounds so different from other kpop in a really good way!! it’s so atypical that i couldn’t tell what the song structure was at first listen. AWESOME SONG

[@-stayzen107]

This song might not be everyone's cup of tea as it has a very unique structure.... Feels like the instrumentals and the vocals are running in the opposite directions , but after 3-4 listens it all falls into place !!!! Idk why I felt the 2nd gen & 4th gen vibes were mashed together in this...... Am looking forward to more of their songs !!!! Fighting Billlie !!!!

[@suzie8043]

YESS it reminds me of t-ara songs

[@heyyy_iris.m4204]

Billlie*

[@daveadrian2104]

as expected from SM entertainment, you get addicted after listening to it for at least 3 times

[@vanescenze304]

@@daveadrian2104 huh SM?? it says they from Mystic entertainment

[@yirenn6935]

@@vanescenze304 mystic story ent part of sm honey

[@ohjunseok5430]

This song is so weird but in a good way. There should be more k-pop groups like them.Experimental music is a need for the K-pop industry.I wish Billie will dominate the world.

[@timmieng554]

Its the same for BugAboo also a song which is very out of the box which i love since i really care about experimental songs which its not typical K-pop. I love this track sometimes a song doesn't need to be catchy to pay attention or that needs a typical melody vibe to remember the song well like most of the K-pop songs.

[@itgirl.is_heaah1794]

I agree

[@jksjksjksjks]

well experimental = SM jsksks just check their groups out if you want to hear more like this (btw billlie is under SMs sublabel)

[@sowhat6061]

@@jksjksjksjksI like this more than SM experimentalism. They really throw random noises together sometimes. The production of this song feels way better than sm experimentalism. Also I feel like the sound SM employs isn’t AS experimental cause lots of groups kinda do noise music (Stray Kids… EG… ETC)

[@ricardo8252]

BILLAGERS LATINOS APOYANDOLAS❣

[@ionlylovehan]

No one can understand how I love Ring X Ring

[@sinisterpanda2738]

I thought 2 million in a week would be difficult. But 2 days in, and we're almost there~! 🔥 Center : Siyoon 0:44 Leader : Moon Sua 0:56 Main Vocal : Haram 2:17 Lead Vocal : Suhyeon 3:22 Main Dancer : Tsuki 3:02 Diamond Maknae : Haruna 0:35 Some Fun Facts : Mystic Story is a subsidiary of SM entertainment and Billlie was also trained by 1MILLION Dance Studio. There's a dance performance of Billlie on 1MILLION channel. Moon Sua was a YG trainee & ASTRO Moon Bin beloved sister. Suhyeon was on MIXNINE & A-Teen, a famous webdrama. Siyoon is a model for a japanese magazine. Tsuki was a former SM trainee known as Ravi. She's friends with Ningning from aespa.

[@wiu7507]

Haruna?

[@sinisterpanda2738]

@@wiu7507 the 2006 baby Haruna doesn't have many details revealed about her yet.. I'm sure we'll learn in time. She's pretty good at korean & her role model is Seulgi~ Btw they don't have an official leader yet. So they rotate it. But seems like, most of the time it's Moon Sua.

[@MaryNuttyy]

Who is 2:30-3:46???

[@uwuinternallyscreaming7644]

@@MaryNuttyy Actually there's 2 ppl! The first is haram, and the other is siyoon

[@uwuinternallyscreaming7644]

Tsuki was from a Jpop group called magicour as well, and her stage name was taru-chan

[@peachwillows1191]

RING X RING is a heavy song, meanwhile GingaMingaYo is much lighter than this but still has that EDM. I love these two songs. I wonder what's the next thing Billlie will show us. Anyway, I can feel 2022 is Billlie's year!

[@sophiegathercole7025]

And Snowy night is a ballad-like song

[@dimitra8569]

i like both songs but ring x ring is so good

[@lucyandecember2843]

o.o

[@lucyandecember2843]

@@sunjaylovers_1 i didn't even say anything, how tf am i racist?

[@lucyandecember2843]

@@sunjaylovers_1 okay, apparantly o.o is a song, didn't know that. Just wrote it to find the comment again cause i liked the comment. Idk how im racist tho lol

[@sssourwav]

The way the chorus just slides in without having a proper entry note really threw me off on the first listen but I've grown to love how it's structured. It's not built like a typical KPOP song, it's unique in both the sound and structure aspects and with the storyline they have the eerie feeling just works so well. Wishing the best of luck to these girls!! Congrats on your debut, BILLLIE!!! ❤

[@XxwalaweixX]

Idk, it feels like a very long verse to me, the song doesn't allow me to breath or process. I'm gonna need a few more listen, this song is very unorthodox 😅

[@sssourwav]

@@XxwalaweixX it is very unorthodox, but I think that's why I love it so much. It's so out there and "crazy" which is refreshing in a way since its a sound you don't get alot of in KPOP

[@XxwalaweixX]

@@sssourwav I get that, and from their company point of view, they definitely planned this to stand out... Especially with many promising rookie this year

[@jlim1]

Revisiting this song 2 years later. The singing and dancing skills of this group is off the charts good. One of the most unique sounds and visuals in Kpop. One of the few groups where I can listen to their entire albums all the way through without skipping a song

[@rosyeon3163]

ahh this sounds and looks like a 2nd gen song it’s amazing. the scenes with the flashing lights reminded me of t-ara’s sugar free and that was the song that got me into kpop so it feels very nostalgic. billlie manages to find their very own sound that makes them stick out of the many new groups these days. this is an amazing debut i’m rooting for them! also siyoon is so awesome im in love with her

[@gwenmloveskpopandmore]

Well their company used to manage Brown Eyed Girls

[@irisa198]

@@gwenmloveskpopandmore also the duo that wrote this song and its lyrics also made a lot of songs for Brown Eyed Girls and other 2nd gen artists

[@luquint1718]

Of all the "experimental" songs released lately idk why some people dislike this one in particular, its production is immaculate, the instrumental is amazing, they knew how to play with the vocals, and so on. Maybe they didn't like it because this song is not* as easy as the other ones? idk

[@andreasecha]

I agree, I hope they keep this sound in the future. Some songs lately have been sounding "generic"? Don't know if that's the right word, but this song was definitely refreshing.

[@khyalis]

Maybe it's just because it's the latest? As in "No, not another one!" Although I perceive it to be quite unlike what had been there before. It has a sort of energy, though, which might not always fit the atmosphere. I don't know. I like it.

[@kalamay]

They don't like this because they have limited musical tastes. Haha

[@xXInfinityDiesXx]

Yeah this is true experimental. Not just splicing two different sounding songs together (I mean this without diss, I love aespa and other groups who do this. It's just not as experimental as people think). This is using chord progressions and tritones never done before in kpop, it's instrumental is fundamentally different

[@yeonkie8i109]

I just don't like the voice of the person who sings the chorus

[@yo2992]

This almost sounds like nu-metal to me. It's honestly the coolest and boldest thing kpop has done in a while. I also love the Juni Ito-esque vibe it gives off. Stan this group already.

[@Rebe8d89AH]

I wasn't going to bother with Billlie (I'm not really listening to new kpop right now) but this song is interesting!

[@geogass]

I love this song and I love Junji Ito but don't really see or feel a Junjo Ito influence in this song. What are the elements in the MV or song that feel you this way ?

[@yo2992]

@@geogass You can't me that Haruna doesn't look like Tomie? lol But idk, I just think the creepy and unsettling vibe matches Ito's aesthetic. Also, if you see the cover art for the, "Billage of perception" mini album you can tell that the artwork is VERY Junji Ito inspired. Mystic Story knows what's popular which is why I think this group is going to succeed.

[@nnayquahh]

junji ito, numetal wtf are you talking about

[@yo2992]

@@nnayquahh I said what I said Mr. Anime profile picture.

[@I_am_a_villain75]

난 진짜 빌리 곡 중에서 이 노래 제일 좋아한다.. 발매 당시부터 꽂혀서 못해도 50번은 들은 듯.. 빌리의 정체성을 대변하는 레전드 데뷔곡 진짜..

[@sunwoodior]

debuts are the ones that define what a group's personality is going to be. billlie's debut is no joke. i really love it and i just know that they have great potential to be successful in the future

[@joshuamateo]

I don’t know how people can hate this song, it’s literally so good and on repeat!!! Give it a few listens and that i’m sure that chorus will be stuck in your head. Not the instrumental necessarily, but the chorus reminds me of 2nd gen kpop ? Idk how to explain it, it just has this familiar structure to it.

[@kitnopsia]

Addictive does not mean good

[@ozziekins_]

@@kitnopsia and your opinion isn’t the majority’s.

[@kitnopsia]

@@ozziekins_ Sadly it is. This group gain a lot of recognition because of their mysterious concept and a lot of people were anticipating their debut but then got disappointed because of how the title track sounded like. Why do you think everyone in the coments is saying that a lot of people critizice this song? even fanbases disliked it. However they're getting attetion again because some girls planet 999 former contestant just joined them. Besides, the girls seems talented and the rest of their album is not bad so i'm not hating on them or anything. Just gived my opinion. Sorry for my english.

[@ozziekins_]

@@kitnopsia the fact that you’re trying so hard… i didn’t even say anything about the group’s popularity? i’m just talking about the song? why are you so determined to bring them down?

[@kitnopsia]

@@ozziekins_ Lol I just said I have nothing against them. I actually love their concept.

[@pebblesvalval]

After so many years I can finally see Sua's debut and I am so proud of her and Billlie, they are really talented girls who deserve recognition.

[@mariadain2266]

wait is that moon sus? yg trainee?

[@pebblesvalval]

Yep, ex yg trainee

[@nandaraghunath9865]

@@mariadain2266 yess!!!

[@wyn3214]

@@mariadain2266 sus!

[@sinisterpanda2738]

@@wyn3214 AMOGUS! Typo jokes aside.. I'm so happy Sua is finally debuting! Omg...

[@elllisgrey]

this song is a prime example of the ones who get it GETTING it. billlie is one of my fav 4th gen groups and this debut encapsulates them perfectly.

[@ryss335]

I think they going with the whole Brown Eyed Girls route like the experimental sound (like their song sixth sense, abracadabra, kill Bill etc) and unique storyline (eventho the mv is pretty different than what we imagine coz we have such high expectations from their incredible movie-like teasers recently) but I'm still excited to see their music in the future coz I think they're going to be a really unique group

[@irisa198]

Funny you should say that - the lyricist/producer duo that made Ring X Ring actually also made Sixth Sense and Abracadabra!

[@jade-dk9hu]

you got me at brown eyed girls. i’ll be keeping my eyes on these girls :)

[@keayannadavis9836]

i personally think the flashy dance parts of the mv ruined everything. i would've been on bored with the song and everything if they did the dance parts like outside in school outfits like in a saturated kinda creepy soccer field

[@hyn_km]

the writers and producers are from sm who made music for sm artists.

[@irisa198]

@@keayannadavis9836 I liked the flashy dance part as a concept, but the same set in two different outfits was maybe a bit much, yeah. Then again it's already pretty cold outside, so I'm probably more glad that they didn't do that, even though it would've looked amazing.

[@yeojin4thgenmainslayyer898]

i feel like they're exploring the more risqué side of experimental music, in a sense that the song doesn't follow a more likeable structure, but I guess that's the essence of experimental music. Congrats on debuting, Billlie!

[@everyyxy8425]

you can say nct

[@lizm3979]

Not surprised. Their company’s parent company is sm after all. I’m glad they adapted that neo sound too. Their vocals are nice to hear and suit this song.

[@allinks5262]

@thats a long ass ride nop NCT has the most experiment and unique sounds and that's the reason people tried to drag them

[@rameldalit708]

@@allinks5262 f(x) too.

[@yones6958]

I came back here. I'm so happy they're slowly getting recognition. To those who say the song was weirdly mixed or weird in a way, they actually used dissonance to create an unsettling effect since the song is about a friend missing and possibly murdered. I actually love it.

[@kyo-qe8nb]

yess i love the part when there's a build up in the chorus but we never actually get a resolution !!

[@taeblends]

That's what it's about?! What a unique theme for a kpop song lmao

[@helianthusangel5506]

@@taeblends Hello there! Yes. Their whole concept also revolves on Billlie Love who went missing

[@justamultifanperson]

This is literally one of the unique kpop songs and I really love this debut.

[@MZNO]

Comforted to know that in some years this will be recognized as a masterpiece that was ahead of its time

[@NaztyNydz]

Hello future person! It's the year 2022. Thanks for liking this in your timeline!

[@eunchaecutiee3319]

Exactly

[@strawberreena]

yes

[@pdqbs]

yuppp

[@Lili-ey1nd]

Lol definitely not they took different styles and put it together nicely , but nothing new just abstract

[@joyboy6472]

i applaud them for being this risky with this kind of unusual sound esp for their debut like damn.. i love it lol this is already one of my fave kpop release this year! hope they stay with this experimental sound for future comebacks

[@loverboyjk5819]

THIS SONG IS LITERALLY SO GOOD WHY IS EVERYONE HATING ON IT

[@tilibibel]

there are ppl who hate this song??! whats wrong with this song

[@zarvhalter2224]

The song is growing in me tho it's getting better the more I listen to it

[@mvng06]

i dont think anyone is hating on it. its just that the instruments in the background are loud.

[@thursdayistheday]

I personally doesn't like how loud the instrumental is. It's distorting their great voice tbh

[@_jinirxtt.]

I LOVE THIS SONG HOW ARE PPL HATING?? I LOVE EVERYTHING ABT THIS SONG

[@hyn_km]

the concept, the choreo and the uniqueness of everything in this mv deserves more recognition and appreciation. THIS IS THE DEBUT SONG.

[@nikoleta.]

Siyoon 0:44 Moon sua 0:56 Haram 2:17 Suhyeon 3:22 Tsuki 3:02 Haruna0:35 There is also another member,whose stage name is sheon.she’s from the survival show gp999, please give her lots of support !

[@billliealim]

Not to be rude but it's Haruna* not Haryana hehe

[@billliealim]

@키ᄐ whoa whoa whoa no need to cuss out....i was just correcting the spelling of a name which people in my country find rude

[@diyar8161]

@@billliealim is haryana a cuss word there. In india, it is a name of a state.

[@nikoleta.]

I’m sorry,it was autocorrected,I never saw it

[@keiiah]

@@diyar8161 they said that in their country it's rude to correct someone, they weren't saying that the name is rude in their country

[@xcore914]

I think the reason why many people don't like it because it's different from the usual kpop sound!! I think trying something different is good and I personally find this song weirdly addicting, I just wish the vocals were louder than the instrumentals.

[@faizdz5472]

yess, that what I thought too, the instrumental is too loud

[@BunniLilac]

it reminds me of dreamcatcher, same vibes

[@ilikemangos5109]

I personally really enjoy but yes, agree the instrument is too loud

[@KpopDragon53]

@@BunniLilac 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 It literally sounds nothing like Dreamcatcher.

[@gendatsgendats1492]

yes, the synth on the verse part especially. the notes are dissonant, makes uncomfortable to listen. but i think that's what makes this song special

[@wbyk9773]

i just listened to this because im a fan of suyeon from gp999 and i heard she's gonna join them and im honestly so glad she didn't make it into kepler now because those girls are amazing and the concept is so interesting i can't wait to see her with them

[@Mary-jb5wf]

I just discovered this song, I’m a music major with a love for dissonance and never have I heard a kpop group with the type of musical oddity I love so much. Pushing the boundaries of what music can be will always be a big Win in my book

[@AGGIDilimanto]

The bridge and the dance break slapped so hard, I feel like there's a hand print on my face right now. The level of sass and swagger is on another level.

[@rawda422]

the aave and cracka is strong in this ..

[@mp-fx8nt]

They ended itzy

[@nuranaaliyeva]

@@mp-fx8nt Toxic go away pls They just debuted and Itzy is more than 2 years old Why are you comparing?

[@brennathecatlover4360]

@@rawda422 the song is fine

[@vNilleframboise]

@@brennathecatlover4360 they meant the comment not the song

[@ElGatodelasWeeeklyKpop]

Their dance skills are so good! ╥﹏╥

[@IcedBoBaTea]

Omg hii

[@ganeshbabu9782]

Ikr !!

[@softyechan]

true

[@ethan17113]

@Jennie Kpop Queen lol

[@ihsanpeaches]

@Jennie Kpop Queen man but… why are you dragging itzy in the comment section? all right at home?

[@noemiea.2652]

I love the 'strange' vibe this song gives off! Kind of catchy, kind of creepy, kind of hard to pin down. It makes me want to listen to it over and over because I feel like I can discover a new side to the song each time. Hope for lots more from Billie!

[@pinkapinnalabels-d5972]

The most unique and the best debut of the 4th generation.

[@krizziaudtohan2154]

I hope SM Ent. would give more budget and support to Mystic Story. This group has a potential to be big. These girls are good and the song is unique. Happy to know they added Suyeon in the line up. Her popularity from GP999 is helping Billlie have their spot in the industry. Haram, if you can read this, I love you. I really like your voice.

[@nattyism]

is mystic story a sub label of SM? I didn’t know that.

[@nakahara_chuuya_is_hot]

@@nattyism yes it is

[@vraiieee]

@@nattyism division. They're basically under SM

[@wiu7507]

Mystic story is a Sublabel of SM entertainment. It is a actor/actress acapella, music entertainment. It was found 2011. They have a bad names Lucy and want to debut a boy group in the next years. I know that mystic story have enough money to promote this group and I don’t know how SM support this company.

[@cloudy6317]

@@wiu7507 how it can be a sub label of the biggest company but still have low quality mv and songs ?

[@gram7354]

This song sounds almost bizarre but I feel it encapsulates what we should expect from Billlie. The sound of Billlie. Very mystical indeed heh. This song was so interesting to listen to! Can't wait for more!

[@heyyy_iris.m4204]

Billlie*

[@Sonar_125]

The harmony in the chorus gives me SM vibes. And the experimental vibes feels like something f(x) and red velvet will release. Overall this is definitely a grower.

[@STAARDUST]

isn't billlies company a parent company from sm ent??

[@angela4375]

@@STAARDUST yes they their company is under sm ent. label

[@onyourm_ark271]

Their company is a subsidiary of SM entertainment

[@Kisaragi_eki]

Mystic is subsidary sm

[@farhanaazmi4512]

My thoughts exactly. I immediately thought of F(x) when I heard this

[@powsvalentine]

i hope they start making music that sounds like this again. and every song on the billage of perception chapter 1 was literally so good when r we gonna go back to that. the album cover was sooo unique.

[@maoperez4228]

This is a song i was definitely not expecting to sound like this and I found myself enjoying throughout all of the video, wow, it's nice to watch groups taking risks these days !!! i love the song

[@umm233]

not really lots of groups take the risk of releasing shitty debut songs these days like its a competition!

[@umm233]

@고양이 새끼 more than 4 replies oh that struck a nerve!

[@stanateezstanseventeenstan5408]

@고양이 새끼 Tearing down Itzy, BP and Twice was completely unnecessary and now puts you in the wrong too.

[@cleobells]

@고양이 새끼 oh you was just waiting to drag them because nobody mentioned them

[@flowerldi]

this is billlie! this is their debut song, give the whole mini album a listen 0:45 - siyoon (kim siyoon) * born february 16th, 2005 * former popteen model * dancer, rapper, vocalist 0:57 - moon sua * born september 9th, 1999 * sister of astro’s moonbin * former member of future 2ne1 * participated in unpretty rapstar 2 1:08 - haram (kim haram) * born january 13th, 2001 * incredible vocalist * won sm’s everysing contest and performed a duet with chen from exo 3:03 - tsuki (fukutomi tsuki) * born september 21st, 2002 * former popteen model * former member of the group MAGICOUR 3:22 suhyeon (kim suhyeon) * born january 15th, 2000 * participated in produce 101 * participated in mixnine * was in a drama called ateen 3:34 haruna (osato haruna) * born january 30th, 2006 * she’s been dancing since she was young please support billlie, they’ve been waiting on their debut for so long and now they’re here!

[@debbie.c]

also kim suhyeon was in ATEEN and i think a lot of people would recognize her for that (if you wanted to edit your comment, although its already very informative) :D

[@kaylamaritza3454]

OMG IM LOOKING FOR THIS TY!

[@kaylamaritza3454]

Also moon sua participated on unpretty rapstar season 2!

[@navirv2450]

Thanks for this comment!!! I decided to be a fan

[@navirv2450]

@@debbie.c What was her role I watched the drama but I can't remember I'm embarrassed 😭

[@oneiz7076]

*Is no one gonna talk about the dance break, they literally nailed it and all of them seems to be a great dancer*

[@traducella]

miss this kind of songs to BILLLIE, and PLZ CONTINUE THE LOREEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@피터팬-d2o]

At first I thought their song was weird, unique and interesting. After a few listening I feel the great amount of hardworking and efforts they made for this album. And now I realize this is not a coincidence because the main manpower of their company "MYSTIC" are all famous for their musicality.

[@chennyboo]

*It's just kinda unfair that people already considered this as a bad song just because it sounds weird or experimental, but when it comes to famous groups with weirder song arrangement, they defend it so much. I mean there is nothing wrong about it but I hope that people will treat this song the same as other famous experimental songs, like give this song a chance by listening more than once. I honestly didn't get this song at first listen. I only liked it after 5 listens especially when I found out how good the chorus is, and now, i can't last a day without listening to RING X RING. And the fact that I am not into "noise" music but still liked it...* note: I didn't even know Billlie, this MV was just recommended by KZbin. I was even shocked that Suhyeon and Moonbin's sister are members of this group lol

[@jessicajessica4392]

Despite the experimental arrangements, the song is actually coherent in its sounds, everything fits pretty well together, and it's extremely well produced. After my first listen I was like: That's super weird, it has some catchy parts, and I was confused half of the time, but already knew it would grow on me. Props to the members for selling the song so well, and props for Mystic for producing and taking the risk to release this song as a debut.

[@nctzendeulgi1154]

As a fan of SM's weird musics. I like this song at first listen.

[@lyn0055]

Well I really love 127's songs at first listen even Sticker that many didn't accept well and to be honest this song, I didn't love it at first listen since the vocals is more on the background but I'm still here now since I gave it another chance and ended up loving it... If only their vocals are more louder, I could have loved it at first listen...

[@OND7430]

This song actually was already amazing for me from first listen maybe because I'm an sm Stan but it sounds like an anime opening I really like it Idk why some people hate it

[@streamwjsnunnatural4105]

THISSSSS !!! sad fact the popular group always get 'good song' labels even the song is just cringe or something. and they fans think its just hate if someone says LOL

[@kuyakeem]

Billlie really proves us that their debut will be unique and watching this as a fan of kpop for so long, It's new and I'm amazed that they already made their own sound. I can't wait to see more from them. Congratulations again to them specially to moon sua, youve waited this for so long.

[@liz-ed2ys]

Moonsua my bias

[@kuyakeem]

@@liz-ed2ys yep sua is the only trainee that I waited for so long.

[@BelllieveWav]

@@kuyakeem Moon Sua This Gens ACE... she was always been my ULT wrecker my ULT Bias Dara...

[@kuyakeem]

@@BelllieveWav the amount of time and effort to wait for her and it's all worth it.

[@BelllieveWav]

@@kuyakeem yes... and finally all of Future2NE1 have finally all debuted... and damn that YG dungeon...

[@hwabyulsingji2076]

I really love the musicality of this group, their songs are 'experimental' but they feel so cohesive and are so satisfying to listen to

[@Kpopsegye]

The concept, MV and song confused the hell out of me. It feels very Jpop inspired. If that was the plan….well it worked cause I’m here for the long run.

[@rooninety4558]

It feels like a WACK group

[@Kpopsegye]

@@rooninety4558 hahaha yes I feel that

[@daphdad]

I wish they were styled differently

[@pv6631]

@@rooninety4558 thanks for giving them a view and comment! 🙏😊

[@babymilksnatcher]

@@rooninety4558 this is how Wack would sound like if Matsukuma Kenta wasn't writing the same song all over again with different vocalists. kinda has an early BiSH album song feel to it.

[@marcom8919]

I searched for this MV because I heard the leader, Moon Sua, trained for over 10 years! Goes to show hard work always pays off. Wanted to support her and the girls and damn… i was amazed! It doesn’t sound like the typical kpop song, its very fresh and give me weird Jpop vibes which I love. I might stan!

[@BelllieveWav]

And as per their interview they have no leader they take turns with introductions....

[@bdengene8402]

The group doesn't have a leader

[@alexss3661]

Why is nobody talking about how cool the choreography and dance break are???

[@kevs3745]

becuz it sux

[@kanoelani3425]

@@kevs3745 Kisses you

[@haewonized]

@@kevs3745 oh it’s Opposite Day?

[@soshi-805]

this was a BOMB of a debut track. explosive and impactful production, very unconventional bridge/dance break, very strong concept and performance too. like they really said let's make a STATEMENT!

[@januaryrosales2042]

The totality of the mv, song, dance, beat, vocals, visuals, and rap, was not what I was expecting. In fact, it exceeded my expectations! This is not just a girl group. This is "THE" girl group. Needless to say, I am here to stay. Keep it up, BILLLIE!

[@toanlamtrieu2254]

Ok ok anh

[@toanlamtrieu2254]

Ok ok anh đi

[@toanlamtrieu2254]

Em có số của chị ạ

[@toanlamtrieu2254]

Ok ok em có bạn trai

[@toanlamtrieu2254]

Ok ok là có người

[@djfatih93_ver23]

As someone who like SM experimental sound, I would say this song is soooo good to be true. This song is really appealing to me. The sound really fresh and they have good vocal. Even the dance routine is really energetic and I like it as it complement the song. Wish all the best for Billie.

[@1CE.]

Fr I don’t get the hate. I guess people just love girl crush and retro too much to give this a chance. Shame It’s SOOOO GOOD

[@krystalangels7860]

This song is so unique, something about the melodies makes it sound creepy idk I love it

[@kartunanimasi7440]

Naevis photo

[@hyn_km]

hello nævis

[@mobina1248]

Me too

[@uh-no1464]

tell the æ’s to stream this please

[@jessicajessica4392]

It's like a club song, with creepy vibes, never though the association would work but it does.

[@chrisrouse1387]

This song will never get old for me.

[@gabrielvitorsantossantana153]

This group has a lot of potential, the choreography, concept and visuals are great and the music is strangely catchy! Esse grupo possui um potencial enorme. A música é estranha no começo, mas com o tempo vai te envolvendo; o visual, coreografia e conceito são excelentes, eu escutei o álbum e ele é também é ótimo; assistindo os Stages dá pra perceber que elas estão com algumas dificuldades, mas com certeza com o tempo elas irão progredir nesse aspecto; estarei acompanhando o grupo e espero que dê tudo certo pra elas.

[@braulio771]

the best coment

[@lime8135]

RingXRing sounds like opening anime and FLOWORLD sounds like a ending

[@bluebicycleclub]

Agree!

[@justfaith1]

Yes

[@dydanimumskycrusher]

an anime horror opening song

[@laureiishon]

No, wtf?🤔

[@Madelope]

@@laureiishon WHY DOES IT BOTHER YOU SO MUCH, literally gatekeeping weaboo culture lol

[@홍성주-l9t]

흔적이 없대 is she dead dead? 알려진 게 없대 can we talk talk? not anymore (la la la la) not anymore (la la la la la la la) 흔적이 있대 is it blood blood? 말라붙지 못한 이건 뭘 뭘 말하니 뭘 (la la la la la la) 어딨니 넌 (la la la la) it's alright 아니 괜찮지 않아 will be fine 아닌 걸 잘 알잖아 ring ring a bell, ring ring a bell ring ring a bell, ring ring a bell come find the missing 구해줘 cuz I'm risky 외로운 희미한 수많은 이름들이 온 힘을 다해서 울리는 마음 소리 넌 거기 그대로 기다려 널 내가 구하러 나가겠어 oh oh oh oh 너의 벨이 울리면 it's true 알 길이 없어 where did she go go 고양이도 없어 아주 멋진 여행인가 (la la la la) 잠적인가 (la la la la la la la) 취미는 뭔데 매일 밤 밤 누구랑 놀았대 알지 못해 그 누구도 (la la la la la la) 아무것도 (la la la la) 사라져야만 앞다투어 질문 늦은 거니 come find the missing 구해줘 cuz I'm risky 외로운 희미한 수많은 이름들이 온 힘을 다해서 울리는 마음 소리 넌 거기 그대로 기다려 널 내가 구하러 나가겠어 oh oh oh oh 너의 벨이 울리면 it's either yes or no either stop or go but we got no rules like april fools cuz we're in wonder years 불투명한 시선 속 사이 가려진 발자국 그냥 지나쳐 그 순간 또 벨이 울려 ring a bell ring ring a bell, ring ring a bell come find the missing 구해줘 cuz I'm risky 외로운 희미한 수많은 이름들이 온 힘을 다해서 울리는 마음 소리 넌 거기 그대로 기다려 널 내가 구하러 나가겠어 oh oh oh oh 너의 벨이 울리면 it's true 흔적이 없대 is she dead dead? 알려진 게 없대 can we talk talk? not anymore

[@user-ks2ir5an1qa]

なぜか懐かしい感じがする。 この曲が出たときに聞いたのを思い出してるわけじゃなく、別の理由によって。

[@annak7062]

I feel like every kpop stan would be talking about Billlie if only they knew of their concept because it has to be the best one out of all the groups. Billlie's concept is finding out what happened to their friend Billie on the 11th day (of November?). She disappeared from the village and the girls think it's because she saw or knows something. The hints are in the lyrics. I mean is this not the best concept you've ever heard of or what???

[@kitnopsia]

I don't know if the best one but definetly one of the best.

[@gowonthestallion851]

And what if one of the members might be kidnapper or killer in the storyline i have that feeling

[@New_catnip]

@@gowonthestallion851 its tsuki

[@gowonthestallion851]

@@New_catnip yeah thats what i was thinking

[@emily_36]

giving me pretty little liar vibes

[@j4yd00n]

this was literally a breath of fresh air. so different and futuristic. congrats on your debut!

[@rozeecheeks3132]

OKAY BUT THEY LITERALLY SLAYEDDDDDDDD i was expecting a soft/aesthetic concept but what can i say, billlie always does the unexpected. i can tell they worked hard. congrats on your debut! i can tell that you'll make it big

[@sangmin11463]

데뷔곡 너무 좋음

[@tigerex777]

Yes! We need this type of unique sounds! Kpop can be so predictable and formulaic to the point where it becomes so mundane sometimes. That's why I've been a Red Velvet fan for so long; they were the unique group with always a non-conventional sound. This group's concept seems like that too. I hope they keep it up and not suddenly become cute or sexy.

[@fudgecake76]

Same reason I loved Red velvet and now this group

[@plazxerk]

I’m just starting to get into kpop and I’ve realized all the popular songs in per say twice (no hate to them) mostly have the same formula where it’s like a cute song then there’s a little rap section and it feels repetitive

[@Sonnenanbeterin1991]

Thats why ateez and Stray Kids are popular too

[@Neuroprophet]

The same with Red Velvet, my ultimate group.

[@Rrrtija]

También Pixy , 3ye, Purple Kiss, Majors , Nature, Dreamcather

[@sallyseashelly8821]

I hope the people coming because of Sheon, Kim Suyeon from GP999, get to know the other girls too. Everyone was talking about her in Billlie’s comments before she was even in the group… which makes me sad because there are other members too. They’re all so cute together and Sheon is gonna be cute with them 🥰

[@namusam8117]

I'm sure they will shine together perfectly 💖🌹🔥

[@cantyouseeme698]

There's really something different about them ..the way they dance , the vocals everything is very different and unique ❤️

[@Kisaragi_eki]

Ikr

[@moonbinlight3388]

Agree!

[@mp-fx8nt]

That's what people say about every new group 😃

[@dotokidoo]

New genre unlocked by Billlie!

[@woulddoanything4chxnuggets494]

every kpop stan be like when a new group debuts:

[@chrythe]

THIS GROUP IS LIKE SLOWLY GONNA BE ONE OF MY ULTS LIKE I SWEAR THEYRE GROWING ON ME SO FAST

[@helianthusangel5506]

Welcome to Belllie've! See you on July 14

[@shokoscigar]

yea bro i started stanning them last week

[@ashsash4478]

The song. The power. The voice. The dance. Everything is perfect.

[@boredd_isa244]

This sounds like it would be a theme song for a cool magical girls series!

[@uwuinternallyscreaming7644]

I can strongly agree with you- Like those type of horror magical girl anime 😭

[@multistansdonthaveiteasy]

@@uwuinternallyscreaming7644 THIS IS SO TRUE😭

[@annaferns1840]

@@uwuinternallyscreaming7644 would fit in with madoka lol

[@c4ramelbrowniee]

@@fl0pZ3 I think that person did it to tell the people that using emojis does not increase the mv views.. many ppl do that misunderstanding that they're haters...

[@aerisom1651]

sua waited for 10 years for this. so proud of u, bub!

[@BelllieveWav]

12 actually 10 in yg 2 in mystic

[@celiadavids1239]

Which one is she? Sorry I'm new here

[@BelllieveWav]

@@celiadavids1239 short hair first rapper

[@SVIVI-rz1lv]

Ig she have the longest training

[@odaxne]

She's only 22. You mean she was in YG with only 10 years!?!?!?!

[@that_strawberry_girl]

I seriously love the energy in the choreography And the instrumentals is literally fire!!!!! Go BILLLIE!!!!!

[@euce5440]

I think the girls are really talented and the song becomes more captivating the longer you listen to it. It's definitely experimental and confusing and I'm feeling so many things while listening to it, but I'm looking forward to see more from this group. P. S. I just wished they added more storyline to the MV. I really love the concept photos so I wanted to see more of it in the MV.

[@Kisaragi_eki]

Ikr there is to much dance scene they should focus more on the story!

[@expressmoonenjoyer3667]

no cause this is one of the most amazing experimental songs ive heard it's really good!

[@_Eunoia_]

Right? It's such a breath of fresh air to hear a different style in 4th gen!

[@crashbandicoot5636]

Not gonna lie, this is kinda a Bop. It's like if YG debut a Dreamcatcher group of sorts, but that just goes to show how unique these girls sound. Congrats on the debut!

[@whitefox7369]

You mean SM?

[@ymymoodlielybizy2934]

@@whitefox7369 there's an “If" ..

[@symaegan]

True, a somewhat YG trained Dreamcatcher

[@RayInSomnie]

For me it's like Gfriend and Dreamcatcher in a single group

[@jksjksjksjks]

their experimental song screams SM I mean they are under SMs sublabel jsskk

[@user-sd5kh7lr2l]

해외팬들이 빌리의 진가를 알아주셔서 항상 너무 감사합니다. 심각하게, 한국인들은 작은 회사에서 나오는 그룹들에 더 주목을 해야합니다.Thank you for supporting our girls.

[@dov_tzukkura]

Apoyándolas desde Chile, Billlie me fascina.

[@richiently.]

*The chorus is very catchy and their dance skills are totally amazing. This is a great start for them, hoping that Billlie will grow more in the future*

[@stinkape3417]

I didn't expect to like this so much, but this song is so pleasing to the ears and brings this odd satisfaction. I will support them!!

[@vNilleframboise]

i can’t be the only one that genuinely loves the song like it only took me two listens. the instrumental is so good and it feels magical/mystical, i love the vocals, the bsides are also very good!! i just wish tsuki sang more 🥲 edit : i can’t stop listening to this pls 😭

[@alkongdalkong0126]

it only took me one listen PLEASE i loved it the moment the instrumentals kicked in right off the bat

[@zzihanahizr]

where did you hear the bsides? I've looked for it on spotify but can't find it ╥﹏╥

[@MonicaGarcia-bw6sr]

i actually really liked it from the first listen, the chorus is really catchy and unique

[@syasyatt2768]

@@zzihanahizr i donno if u have found it or not, if u haven't, try searching by the album name 'the billage of perception'

[@papa_gowon]

I always love this concept and I absolutely loved this song first listen. Reminds me of songs like Girls by Nature.

[@JazyyWazyy]

absolutely beautiful one of the best songs ever made perhaps

[@chennyboo]

*Okay but the chorus makes me so happy!!! The tune is so catchy and unique, it's something I've never heard before, didn't remind me of anyone... I hope this song and Billlie will be recognized.*

[@aangkurosaki9824]

All this group needs is Aespa level marketing and they can pretty much overtake any group Edit: forgot I made this comment A bit more clarification to what I meant by Aespa level marketing Both Aespa and Billie have unique sounds and lore associated with them but because Aespa comes from an agency with more money and influence they get more appearances and attention. Both the groups have good songs and we can all have different opinions let's not put down any of them. Also Billie is part of Mystic story which is a subsidiary of SM so I hope it gets better for Billie. Don't forget to watch them and Le Serafim on Knowing Brother

[@eo0-g9j]

Vespa literally make robot sounds and label it as 'music' and still be successful, big3 curse is stupid

[@sugarcookies_07]

@@eo0-g9j Maybe becuz their music doesn’t same like the same 3 shit sounds all other kpop groups sound like 😟

[@user-nb3ez2zj9c]

@@sugarcookies_07 can you just not...

[@sugarcookies_07]

@@user-nb3ez2zj9c yk maybe if the other person woulda kept their mouth close i wouldnt have too 💀

[@user-nb3ez2zj9c]

@@sugarcookies_07 omg i meant the person who said that not you sorry💀😭

[@COTMashups]

I livee for this. It's such a refreshing take on kpop, I love how groups aren't afraid to go experimental anymore and looks like it's paying off. Can't wait to see what these girls do next

[@noahfan2719]

the instrumental is the perfect mix of fun and haunting i've been looking for. big fan of the bells.

[@loveamia1319]

Billlie is a intriguing gg. I liked the song. I think the background sound was jarring but I know the second listen it will get better. These girls are talented; i have followed their pre-debut stuff so I know they are a strong gg and they all can dance! I am looking forward to more BILLLIE music and hopefully we will get to know more about their concept because I really like it! Kudos to the girls for a strong debut :)

[@rjvlad4659]

I love it. This is my vibe. You said jarring, but I was hooked instantly and I was hoping that beat just wasnt for the intro 😂. I knew nothing of this group until just now, I actually saw their Music Bank stage before coming here. I love the stage. I think it's the dance in the red jumpsuits for me. And Tsuki's(?) move in the dance break is *chefs kiss*... Huge love and support for these girls 🖤❤️ ring the bell🔔

[@neokolitan2212]

This is literally the most unique and interesting kpop debut I've ever seen. Everything was unexpected and I loved it!

[@miriii_6066]

Hi this is so unrelated but omg a shera fan 😭😭

[@jackiejonesjefferson]

So unique and yet so risky i really hope it's worth it and people will love them more

[@izznhakim]

this is the type of song that the more u listen to it, the better it gets 😳

[@giselleakgae4100]

Tsuki comeback #1: Rotates spine to get public attention ❌ Tsuki comeback #2: Makes facial expressions to get public attention ✔

[@listen_gracie]

I love her on the first time (: for the spine xD

[@ijbolso]

she broke her spine for nothing:(

[@nakoringtheproudorbit6412]

I wouldn't say this song is so good for the first listen but Billie has their own style and is unique. It gives off some old highschool punk rock vibe and their dance reminds me of jpop. Overall, it's very creative and of high quality. I think I will keep tuning on this song over and over again. 👍 I wish them good luck in their career journey

[@brennathecatlover4360]

It sounds like a Mario kart song to me lol. I feel like it sounds empty like it’s missing something but it’s not bad

[@kholidamsolikhah0373]

ITS so j pop

[@yuka4076]

デビューおめでとう💐✨ みんながこれから素敵な花道を歩けますように⸜🌷︎⸝‍

[@azisdarker3507]

Love this group's sound because it's not the typical kpop sound we heard these days. I think this is one of the best debut this year.

[@wizone5625]

This song is addictive, I keep singing "흔적이 없대". I love it. Billlie fighting! 수아야 힘내.