BLACK HOLES ARE STORING INFORMATION? - TommyKay Reacts to The Information Paradox

[@Sev7.]

Kurzgesagt the intelectual: The universe could be a 2d plane projected onto a 3d reality caveman dommy: ''BLACK HOLE = MANGA? POG U'' 18:05

[@rushyscoper1651]

Once a degen always a degen

[@molotov6844]

When tommy was talking about the blackholes being attracted to a random location. Here's an alternate view. Everything in the universe is attracted to each other. A star a billion light years away pulls you, and you pull it back, the force is reduced by the distance, but theoretically, if dark energy doesn't mess us up, at sone point all blackholes would combine.

[@alvingillarlera]

Yes, as poetic as the universe closing in on itself sounds, it will probably sadly not happen. Current findings favor the big freeze death, where the expansion of the universe will prevent everything collapsing together. Eventually, the last black holes of the universe will die, and long after that, energy and heat will be distributed evenly throughout the universe, making it so that nothing can ever happen, again.

[@molotov6844]

@@alvingillarlera theoretically no, if dark energy has a decay rate, then eventually gravity will start to pull the universe back together.

[@molotov6844]

@@alvingillarlera point is, we just don't know enough to make a conclusion yet

[@alvingillarlera]

@@molotov6844 There is no evidence for that.

[@nikita424]

you forgot the forever-accelerating expansion of the universe. Two objects that are far enough from each other would never collide due to the space between them expanding faster than the speed of light

[@Ch-ew9tm]

It’s incredible how we are so insignificant incomparison to the size of the universe.

[@justtheaverageone3840]

Too late to explore the world, to early to explore the galaxy :(

[@gabrielgrimes8297]

Naw, I got a spot of the bezos space ship pleb

[@feenyarf1133]

You don't say

[@bamms5395]

The question "Wasen't there also nothing Pre-Big Bang?" is very interesting to me. What if, hypothetically, there was a universe before "our" big bang? And a universe before that. Maybe when the universe begins to die, everything begins to close in and explode, creating a new big bang. It basically proves the multiverse theory. I could also be dumb, but it would explain how the big bang came to be, correct?

[@RandomAutist]

i mean its really something beyond our reach of understanding to be realistic. not even a scientist, mathematician, etc. could get you any closer to the answer, which is why we can only create what our minds can grasp. i dont think we can possibly figure out that without destroying our minds. it would be like an ant trying to understand what society is. you know...

[@RandomAutist]

@@myfairlady343 i think conciousness is an human trait, maybe only an animal with a strong enough nervous system. so existence isnt an human thing per se, but the universe has no "conciousness" you know what i mean. like its just things, existing, without any will or idea. like a rock. think about it.

[@justtheaverageone3840]

@@myfairlady343 it might be existing, but it would be essentially meaningless since we wouldn't have any way about knowing that other universe

[@Deady4u]

More likely that the singularity before the big bang is the entire universe itself compressed into a single point. Infinitely hot and infinitely dense and basically infinitely unstable. When it started to expand that's when space was created (like literal space as in the space between stuff). That allowed for stuff to cool down and form into stuff like atoms but cuz of gravity, stuff likes to stick together and make stars etc. but thats only in the higher density areas of space, space itself is still expanding and will continue to expand until space is so infinitely spread that atoms will never be able to interact with one another again. If you cant imagine that then just imagine yourself in a room with that rooms volume of air. You can breathe normally but imagine if that room were to become a warehouse but with only the rooms volume of air. Suddenly you cant breathe because you're basically in a vacuum right now and eventually you die

[@Gray777333]

Then how was the first, original, universe created? After the complete consumption from a black hole and it dies, but it creates a new universe how did it originally come to be the first time? If out of nothing came something and something was destroyed by a black hole which was destroyed and started a new there still is an absence of the beginning.

[@newromanianmappernrm4420]

Tommy: I've connected the dots! Aquikiss: You haven't connected shit! Tommy: I've connected them!

[@calebbecker1237]

pov: tommy finds out about the big crunch 13:50

[@noneofyourbusiness3288]

9:43 we kind of do something like that. It is called Pyrolysis-analysis. Usually with Gas-Chromatography-Mass-Spectrometry (GCMS). Pyrolysis (meaning "fire cleavage") is a process of heating a sample to the point where it disintegrates, in an inter atmosphere (to avoid burning it to CO2 and stuff since you loose a lot of information if you just make everything into CO2). The pieces that larger molecules in the sample break down to are characteristic for the molecule. You then inject the gaseous pyrolysis products into a device to analyze them (usually CGMS, GC separates different gases based on their interactions with a polymer coated tube and MS separates molecules based on mass). It is actually a very common technique and can be a powerful tool in analytical chemistry.

[@emperorofnothing1]

Oh no, not my 75 gb of information...

[@sherlockhomes840]

What Tommy and everyone in Twitch chat and KZbin comments are explaining: the donut theory. It ties together many theories on the subject and could explain many other theories.

[@heyathereboi]

Honestly, everyone who is interested in this whole thing should read Kaufman's "The Cosmic Frontiers of General Relativity". Good explanations, images and fun stuff (that's semi-confirmed btw) about time dilation near (and inside) black holes and travelling to other universes and a lot more.

[@thehunter8714]

Videos like these just make me anxious because I try to wrap my mind out of it, I overthink it or can't fully understand and that just leads to a massive panic attack, death terrifies me but also interests me, because when I die, where the hell will my consciousness go? Where will my soul go?, does my consciousness get reconstituted into a new being in a new world or universe? These are answers I would love to know because it would bring me such peace of mind

[@Its_Seven7]

Who would win? Leading world scientists or tommy in mspaint?

[@cyberneticbutterfly8506]

Laypeople discussing black holes always wind up reasoning from similarities as if they were connections. "This reminds of this *OH MY GOD I'VE FOUND SOMETHING* "

[@thomas.3650]

Poor tommy doesn’t know that your body replaces all of your cells every 5 years

[@amerashi1111]

not all of them

[@anonymousmyvern8927]

All your atoms, not all your cells because neurons aren't replaced

[@thomas.3650]

@@anonymousmyvern8927 ehhhh, more or less

[@thehunter8714]

They are still there, death is just another state of being

[@pumpkinking8221]

dude my mind cant fathom that knowledge 6:57

[@정재욱-h5x]

Can spacetime exist without matter? Because if it doesn't, when all the black hole consumes all then dissappear completely that sounds like exactly the same as the state before big bang

[@Boretheory]

My theory is that when all the matter gets concentrated in one big black hole and nothing is left, the black hole explodes and the universe start again. -Emperor of China and Germany Weilian

[@hammerinoslpslovakia8995]

Well, hard to tell but spacetime is our 3D + time, when you open animation program with empty space, no mass does the space there exist ?

[@daroth7127]

google Conformal Cyclic Cosmology, thats the offical name of this theory

[@elijah4666]

technically speaking before the singularity there wasn't anything, but at the end of the universe there will still be space. because before the universe there was no space as I understand it

[@thomasskrning2675]

11:51 hmmm, is Black holes almost like NSA And CIA?

[@MasterMarcon]

Its pretty much guaranteed that no theory we have is correct, and what black holes do is irreconcilable with our current interpretation of physics. This is what happened with quantum physics and general relativity, and we still can't fully reconcile them to this day. We are but humans and while we try to rationalize exactly how the universe works, the reality is that we will never reach full understanding.

[@DeathDefiant]

A singularity is a divide by 0 error

[@oi2837]

So basically a time period between bing bang and death of last blackhole is lifespan of 1 universe and it will keep on repeating, every repetition is called an Aeon. This is but a theory though

[@thehunter8714]

In 10,000 years time "Muuuummmm! I need a new black hole drive!!"

[@noneofyourbusiness3288]

6:48 well according to our understanding "before the big bang" really does not make any sense. As time started at the big bang, there is no before. Similarly, when the "heat-death" of the universe is complete, time looses its meaning, as there no longer are any changes in entropy. The increase in entropy is what gives the "direction of time" meaning, so no change in entropy => no direction of time.

[@youngoden4106]

He would love futurama

[@helmaksi]

BelgianButcherX The greatest scientifical mind of all human history

[@Lord_Khan]

14:08 No that doesn't work because black holes won't suck in all the information before the last one dies there still will be protons and energy everywhere (if our current understanding of dark matter and proton decay doesn't prove us wrong)

[@novmaq7604]

what if actually when blackhole is created a universe is created and all the information they collect from our universe goes into these other universes and makes them expand like ours and after a really long time the universe stops expanding and the process repeats itself

[@Logan0o]

My head hurts

[@LuanMower55]

With all due respect... GOD DAMN IT TOMMY STOP TALKING OVER THE DAMN VIDEO

[@WatzUpzPeepz]

Watch the original if you don’t want commentary...

[@ohno6528]

@@WatzUpzPeepz we are here for the commentary, but when tommy talks over the video he misses stuff and thats why he got lost in the end of the video

[@LuanMower55]

@@WatzUpzPeepz i am saying he can just pause dude, like if you're gonna comment on something while speaking in a hushed tone, PAUSE THE DAMN VIDEO SO WE CAN HEAR

[@lultopkek]

recent computer simulation showed that spacetime is a torous. so the universe is not infinite and if you go far far away you gonna be at the same space in the past.

[@kornsuwin]

that's infinitely disappointing

[@lultopkek]

@@kornsuwin yes there is only two things who are infinte, the stupidity of humans and the disappointement over the fact there is no such thing as infinty outside of maths

[@peanuts4723]

My theory. Black holes suck up information, one day one of them gets so big it eats the whole universe, there's an information diamond inside it that leaves when it explodes in the emptiness and then universe starts again

[@chem3615]

Possible because the matter might have turned into black hole matter

[@yawn3764]

Imagine if black hole just wait till the u inverse dies then they combine and create a new universe?

[@nacelnikprosiak1260]

Atheists: uh so basically we are 2Ds pictures in giant 3D circle inside of another 3D circle that stores 2D pictures and smaller 3D circles because yes Theists: God good, Life good

[@ibroplatin4915]

Agree

[@kevinbaltzell2949]

Idk what it all means but it sounds cool.

[@3NC3PH4L0N]

13:31 and inside this space is everything possible because it is EVERYTHING and our galaxy only contains 0.00001% of all the information that exists and that is our possible reality and boundry :) The church of DOMMY can exist now! We have ANSWERES! \o/

[@thegodking2759]

What about that one black hole that’s left in Tommy’s theory

[@inkyboi685]

Tommy be getting more and more arrogant each day

[@CivilizedWasteland]

i dont think the 2d theory really makes sense since there's no reason for data to be "projected" to 3d if were already 2d. I think something similar but with 3d and 4d could make sense though.

[@decomposedcorpse5186]

How do you know there's no reason?

[@interneteris]

What if were already inside a black hole

[@totalwar008]

Tommy is like crackhead Einstein.

[@nuuttilahikainen6020]

tommy thinks that he solved everything :)

[@kdubs9111]

Highly recommend taking an edible before watching this one bois :)

[@edgyguy7084]

Do you wanna get mingfked even more? The black sphere you "see" as the black hole is only a visual diametre. That means, if u have a basketball big blackhole, just for scale, its physical mass might just be the size of a sandcorn in the middle of the basketball. So u could say that a black hole is the ultimate poser.

[@raynaldiyudhistira4851]

The universe is made out of IKEA furniture

[@yyhhttcccyyhhttccc6694]

the video length ___________________ the video length if he dident pause every second __

[@cyberneticbutterfly8506]

This video has so much metaphor in it's explanation. Infuriating.

[@saltboi5411]

Tommy would love exurb1a

[@DomNicky]

What a way to start a video, eh?

[@cyberneticbutterfly8506]

To your philosophical rant: There is no more meaning in the atoms we are made of being from something ells before than there is in the atoms from a nail you just shed that is no longer a part of 'you'. 'We' humans are whatever consciousness is. The body is just a structure. If you lose an arm, the arm is just dead on the ground. No meaning to it. Molecular machinery. Conscious life is what matters. All other 'life' is simply mechanical machines. Atoms repelling eachother and moving about from the force fields they have, and warmth and electricity causing movement. Neural networks of atoms can however make awareness, consciousness. For whatever unknown reason. So whatever meaning you find in our bodies atoms previously being part of some other thing in history that meaning is just in your memory. It is you mistaking a meaningful association between your memories as a meaningful connection in the physical world. It aint there.

[@Torodes23]

Dummy k

[@nav_101]

you all are NPC's im a real human in a simulation man