Black Holes, Time Travel, and the Origin of the Universe | Dr. Brian Keating | EP 348

Ep. 348
Watch Jordan Peterson's "Vision & Destiny" on DW+ bit.ly/3KrWbS8
Peterson draws upon his extensive research and relatable real-life experiences to illustrate how to develop attainable goals for intimate relationships, meaningful friendships, and your career. Transform the chaotic potential of the future into actuality - with a vision.
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson and Dr. Brian Keating discuss long-held theories of cosmology, from the big bang to the expansion of the universe, and why we might be totally wrong.
Dr. Brian Keating is a cosmologist, inventor, author, academic, and podcast host. He focuses on the exploration of the big bang, prodding current theories, and building arrays to test them. He has published two bestselling books: “Losing the Nobel Prize” in 2018 and “Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner” in 2021. Keating is the inventor of the BICEP and BICEP2 Array, which are used to study the inception of the universe, and he holds multiple patents for components found within these systems. Keating also hosts the podcast “Into the Impossible,” which boasts Nobel Prize winning guests, renowned scientists from across fields, and a continuous top ten spot in the science category.
Dr. Peterson's extensive catalog is available now on DailyWire+: bit.ly/3KrWbS8
- Sponsors -
Shopify: Get a $1/ month FREE trial with full access to Shopify's entire suite of features: shopify.com/jbp
Elysium: Save $50 on your Index test! Use code JBP50: www.elysiumhealth.com/index
NEFARIOUS Film: Opens in theaters nationwide starting April 14th. Buy your tickets today at www.whoisNefarious.com
- Links -
For Dr. Brian Keating:
Please subscribe to Brian’s KZbin Channel: kzbin.info...
INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE: briankeating.com/podcast
Social Media
Twitter: / drbriankeating
Instagram: / drbriankeating
Facebook: / briankeatinguniverse
Read these books by Dr. Brian Keating
Losing the Nobel Prize: amzn.to/2sa5UpA
Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner: urlgeni.us/amzn/TLANPW
Galileo Galilei’s Dialogue: BrianKeating.com/dialogue
AND DON’T FORGET to join Brian Keating’s mailing list! The first 100 subscribers will get a REAL 4 billion year old meteorite! Just follow the special link below!
briankeating.com/jordan
From the Discussion:
Hawking Hawking (Book): www.amazon.com/Hawking-Sellin...
Answer to Job (Book): www.amazon.com/Answer-Job-Col...
- Chapters -
(0:00) Coming up
(1:30) Intro
(3:14) Keating’s research, proving everyone else wrong
(5:55) Telescopes are time machines
(8:04) Webb telescope, invisible light
(13:49) Blue and red shifts
(15:30) More than one galaxy
(17:04) The universe is becoming more diluted
(18:35) Olber’s Paradox, Edgar Allen Poe
(21:45) Hubbles Law, Hubbles Constant
(25:42) Stephen Hawking, expansion and contraction
(29:25) Einstein was wrong? Dark Energy
(33:01) Precision cosmology
(38:41) Going back 13.8 billion years
(44:00) Cosmic microwave background radiation
(47:55) Gravitational radiation
(51:44) Three properties of light
(54:04) A consequence of dust
(56:03) Father figures
(58:05) BICEP, almost conclusive
(59:20) A brief schematic of time
(1:01:50) How the periodic table emerged
(1:05:24) Plasma, the forth state of matter
(1:07:40) AI and Einstein’s happiest thought
(1:09:57) Entropy and unexpected emergence
(1:12:02) Everything hinges on curvature
(1:14:13) Deviation from symmetry
(1:15:29) Detecting the smoking gun
(1:18:00) Inflation, infinite potential
(1:20:05) Theological Cosmology theories
(1:21:09) Mirror universes and the multiverse
(1:23:10) Sea of probability
(1:25:29) Lean into that which would devastate you
(1:29:50) When you recognize your dragon
(1:33:00) Scientists and religion
(1:38:09) Teaching teaching
(1:40:50) Most discoveries aren’t real
(1:45:40) Meteorites and magnetic illusions
(1:49:50) Systematic contaminates, how to mitigate
(1:52:28) Moses and the edge of perception
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Newsletter: mailchi.mp/jordanbpeterson.co...
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life: jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Blog: jordanbpeterson.com/blog
#TheJordanBPetersonPodcast

[@af4396]

Man, Peterson is such a good interviewer. In most interviews, Brian is asked more nuanced, but less interesting questions to anyone that isn't in the field trying to find specific answers to their own interests. Peterson understands that the vast majority of people don't have a deeper knowledge of even just the basics (wavelengths, waves vs particles, the different theories that came up in the last couple of decades to either counter or augment the BBT etc.) He pulls a lot of valuable information out of his guests to increase the general knowledge of everyone listening AND is able to tackle the nuanced questions once the foundations have be laid out. Other interviewers often either go way too basic, way too specific, or way too conspiratorial and/or imaginative. Peterson has a structure, where he makes the guest lay out the foundations so everyone starts on the same page, before moving on.

[@DrBrianKeating]

JP is first among equals

[@frederickvandenheuvel479]

@@DrBrianKeating So how exactly is Job related to any of the physics you clearly explained? Come on. Peterson is a first class sophist. He's patient and waited you out. Stop inadvertently promoting jackasses like him.

[@martiakatz8442]

That is why we love him

[@RWin-fp5jn]

Yes this was an amazing interview! Brian is perhaps the most gifted and brave experimental cosmologist around. That said, the next time he sits down with Jordan, I would like for Jordan to project the allegory of Plato's cave onto cosmology, because it seems cosmology as a whole is not willing to accept the reality of the actual outside cosmic world that our latest telescopes images are depicting (Event Horizon telescope, Webb space telescope). What's going on? Well, starting some hundred years ago we saw two unexpected phenomena; Stars at outer galaxy arms that appeared to move too fast (for which we decided to invent dark matter) and galaxies that all appear to move away at ever faster speeds, rather counter to what gravity should do (for which we decided to invent 'dark energy'). Now, 100 years later NEITHER dark matter nor dark energy are confirmed as actual physical phenomena. We can do 2 things now; we keep on hypothising ever new fixes OR we accept the only other explanation for both, namely that our observations are not real; more precisely; that our galactic plane may be DISTORTING any light coming in from its exterior. In other words, we are only seeing 'shadows' of what is ACTUALLY going on outside of our galactic plane. The most prominent evidence that our galactic plan is indeed fundamentally distorting incoming light, is the recent EHT picture of our galactic core (Sagittarius A* black hole) which we SHOULD have see edge on, but instead we see HEADS on. That is impossible. In fact, that kind of distortion we would only expect to see in the Quantum Physical World, where at tiny apertures, light becomes inverted (Fraunhofer effect) AND where the arrow of time becomes inverted (Quantum eraser effect). So then, is this what we are seeing at the grander scale as well? Well, let's see; If we have also see an inversion of the arrow of time, that would confirm it. Do we? Well, the light from our own glactic plane has a slight blue shift. If indeed we see the world beyond our galactic plane in na inverse arrow of time, we need to see a red shift of what actually is a blue shift. Do we? YES! We see the galactic core in a redshift (it is yellowish) suggesting a cut-off situation form our galactic plane. More over, we AGAIN see outer galaxies ALSO in a read shift, which the law of gravity suggest would actually be a blueshift. So in 2 additional cases we have additional evidence that for 100 years we got everything in cosmology upside down, trying to find physical solutions for mere cave shadows of reality. But, what about the CMB then? isn't that evidence of the cosmic Big Bang? No, in this scenario, the CMB would mark the moment our galaxy formed 13,7 billion years ago (centered around the Sag* black hole) and thus the moment we started seeing all outside light (of our core and of outer galaxies) in reverse. Not that this would necessarily disprove any big bang per se, but we just don't have an age limit for it now. So next time, could we pls discuss this?

[@IndependentThoughts911]

@@DrBrianKeating Why does he Censor comments that don't fit his narrative?? Weak.

[@dutcherism9643]

I love technology today. The fact I can sit and listen to brilliant minds express their discoveries from my office is so amazing. Great podcast JP!

[@DrBrianKeating]

Thank you, very much ❤

[@ko7305]

Warchild, refugee and legal immigrant here. kina virus released to fk up the elections...millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues...evil know no bounds, 100% intentionally released...just to get one man out of office, one man they could not buy/control. I have seen what communism will do to stay in or get in power. Anything! Chinese killed 30+ million of their own for power less than a century ago. It was a crazy conspiracy theory that FBI smoked Kennedy and now we know it is true. It was a conspiracy theory that kina virus was manmade but now we know it is true. MSM/Big Tech working overtime to censor/ban. This was intentionally released to fk up US election and for the Chinese to get protesters of Hong Kong streets because if Hong Kong goes so do commies in China. Win-win for commies and US dems....millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues. Godless people will always create hell.

[@brodythornton4044]

i love that i can read comments from so many people across the world

[@aubree455]

​@@DrBrianKeating❤❤😅❤❤❤❤😅❤😅±++

[@aubree455]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤a

[@kylewatson7639]

One of the best interviews ive ever watched. Without Jordan asking questions for clarification this guy wouldve lost me. Keating is definitely a good teacher cause he can relate complex ideas to simple observable concepts. I love how JP takes notes in real time for questions.

[@tammiemoore6055]

Actually I understood very little up until the point of anxiety... that I understood deeply. I lost my son a year ago and I wake up every morning with anxiety and wishing an earth quake will take me out of bed instead of having to crawl out and face my uncertain day. It is true. I need to go back to grief share.

[@mattjack3983]

@@tammiemoore6055 The part about anxiety is the only thing you understood?! Seriously? Who sits and watches/listens to a video for over an hour and a half when they can't understand the vast majority of whats being talked about? If thats true I feel sorry for you then, because as stated, Keating did an excellent job at breaking it down to very simple concepts that are very easy to grasp and understand. Easy and simple enough to understand that my 12 year old daughter was able to follow along and understand it. (Although it kinda seems like you just saw an opportunity to be a contrarian, while simultaneously indulging in some self pity about your own losses in life, that don't even remotely have anything to do with anything that was said in the video.)

[@tammiemoore6055]

@@mattjack3983 really? I was simply making a comment.

[@dgh5760]

Dr. Keating is a phenomenal teacher who explains things simply and clearly. That is the mark of a true expert who knows his subject matter well enough to make it understandable to anyone. Thanks Dr. Keating!

[@mrschnider6521]

JP did some moon rock with this guy at his house lol. Thats pretty rad. 1:50

[@JimDaMan924]

Even though I know he was trying to dumb it down, trying to follow the conversation felt like I was back in high school on the day that my teacher used letters AND numbers in math for the first time.

[@isonlynameleft]

​@@JimDaMan924 I like Brian Keating but he can be pretty hard to follow sometimes, too many digressions, trying to put in too much information at once.

[@MrGreasem]

keating and peterson find connection between aspects of our known physical universe and our human consciousness in a way that is inspiring.

[@sirslaughter2092]

Meat riding

[@williambillycraig1057]

What I like most about Dr. Brian Keating is his blend of intellect and humanity. A good balance between the two is hard to achieve.

[@laattardo]

A scientist with humility is rare. I treasure them

[@ko7305]

Warchild, refugee and legal immigrant here. kina virus released to fk up the elections...millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues...evil know no bounds, 100% intentionally released...just to get one man out of office, one man they could not buy/control. I have seen what communism will do to stay in or get in power. Anything! Chinese killed 30+ million of their own for power less than a century ago. It was a crazy conspiracy theory that FBI smoked Kennedy and now we know it is true. It was a conspiracy theory that kina virus was manmade but now we know it is true. MSM/Big Tech working overtime to censor/ban. This was intentionally released to fk up US election and for the Chinese to get protesters of Hong Kong streets because if Hong Kong goes so do commies in China. Win-win for commies and US dems....millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues. Godless people will always create hell.

[@DrBrianKeating]

Thank you, very much

[@PsyllyViews]

The universe is not expanding but it maybe growing a tiny but only to a certain limit not infinitely growing. Same is true to the potentiality of the universe.... it is deterministic not hedonistic appropriation to suppose the presumption of the expanding universe is valid theory! It may look like theres infinite ways to get there but one must need to apply deductive reasoning aka common sense to be able to achieve it! Ex. Electricity... it is what we use to power everything. So our technology is not expansive of its potentiality outside the realm of electrical phenomenon to power all of our electronic components and systems! Saying things as if facts? Is getting ptrtty old already... and still remain shameless! Typical trait of pseudo intellectuals tho! lol Anyway, i beg to differ to the claim the stars and galaxy are drifting away from us.... since the constellations, the big dipper and small dipper remain exactly the same shape and size! Its not growing bigger or fading out for the last 10,000 years. The giza pyramids were arrange like the star formation of the stars as the orion's belt or fasces. So... its literally JP's guest have no tangible proof to back to what he claims... they only make it as a factualized maybe to suppose big bang took place lmao

[@mioh23]

@@DrBrianKeating i appreciate deeply for the example doctor, even i am not a physical scientist, the attitude of yours will very much contribute for my future behavior.

[@billydoyle6919]

You have to appreciate genius level people who can explain their expertise in simple, relatable terms and inside our understanding of the nature of the world, yet open our minds to the degree that we actually learn something really fundamental without feeling like what I've learnt will dissipate so quickly there really wasn't any point listening in the first place. Keating is clearly a phenomenal teacher. We need more thinkers like him.

[@hacorn96]

Totally. I was surprised how easily I was able to understand everything he said about such a complex topic.

[@shrinivasganti90]

Brian is such an animated speaker. Love to see his genuine excitement for science shine through

[@susanr.lynn-butler7488]

I so agree. You can feel Dr.Keatimg's passion.... and he smiles simultaneously! Enjoy watching him share his knowledge,!

[@a59x]

The humility Dr. Jordan shows during this interview is so admirable.

[@mrsniiper]

Jordan Peterson is one of the most influential men to ever embrace this planet. An honest man. Jordan, thank you for changing all of our lives in ways you will probably never know. 👏🏻

[@deependdiver9737]

Outer space is literally an unprovable hoax put on the public to manipulate our minds.

[@JimStanfield-zo2pz]

Not even close. Just a highly articulate charlatan with a large following of disaffected angry young men looking for a father figure to give justification to their anger and confusion.

[@roberjohnsmith]

​@@USAandokay you sound like a chatgpt bot regurgitating nonsense. Do you have an original thought inside of your head?

[@kimvannote5024]

Jesus Christ is the most Influential Man that ever lived, and what is sad and tragic, is people don't want to know him. If they only knew.

[@Vandalle.]

@@USAandokay That's a ridiculous thing to say, our entire human society is built upon learning from others, society wouldn't exist without learning from people around you. If a human being grew up without reading, without learning, without experiencing society as it is, we would be no different from the humans that first evolved 200+ thousand years ago. Society is a collective history of knowledge learned and passed down over thousands of years, and your criticism of Jordan is that he learned from others? There isn't a great mind that's ever existed without learning from others. What makes a great thinker and teacher is their wealth and depth of knowledge, and their ability to use that to really think and challenge ideas and concepts in order to create knew ones and move us forward. I don't know many people alive today who are better at that than Jordan is.

[@jmjr4all]

I have always felt intimidated by most of the topics that Dr Keating spends his life thinking about. Listening to him makes me comfortable and curious and has left me wanting more! What a gift this conversation is!

[@DrBrianKeating]

So delighted to hear! ❤

[@davidsykes7251]

Well I think he knew my Nan who said "Stand up with your shoulders back" bit that generation were strong, hard working and wise. Today,by design they Have there devices between pupils and teacher,BY design source Charlotte Iserbie I'll have to check spelling aid and school system to POTUS that job is to keep the agenda rolling on.

[@kenjr3405]

The one thing I am most impressed about is throughout all JPs interviews covering ranging from simple to extremely complex topics, he has the ability to articulate it in a manner that allows people who are not as accomplished intellectually to comprehend, follow and actually be interested in the topic. I have never known anyone with that ability. Since the very first video I saw of his I can wholeheartedly say I have grown a few brain cells and totally changed the way I think and communicate for the better. And it shows! When I speak to people they listen. Not because I have authority or that they have interest. But because I make what I am saying compressible and intriguing even if it’s something quite mundane. This man is a genius and should be protected at all costs

[@ttues]

One of the best interviews, ever. Jordan was clearly out of his league discussing these topics. He handled it extremely well. Let the expert talk his talk and interject good questions. Very well done!

[@janegolson237]

Please have Dr. Brian Keating on again! This discussion was truly mind expanding!

[@conrad6604]

Dr. Brian Keating has a powerful brain!

[@nirupampratapgiri1348]

One of the most insightful and invigorating conversations I have ever witnessed. Dr Keating is an erudite and mesmerising scholar that is truly a master in his chosen field. I also love how he takes the time to clearly and succinctly explain complex concepts to the layperson in a captivating manner. Thoroughly enjoyed this episode! 🎉

[@DrBrianKeating]

Wow. This is Simons Observatory delightful to see

[@susanr.lynn-butler7488]

This 71 year old RN agrees! What a gift Brian is to our understanding! 🙏🏻

[@betterchapter]

I can't express just how much I respect this man.. His vulnerability, his humility, wisdom.. What a man!

[@joshsims7286]

Thank you Jordan. Your lectures have changed my life! I feel so much better. I started my own business! Everything seems to make a lot more sense now. Also when I choose what's hard in life, positive things just flood my life afterward. I can't thank you enough. I wish I could give you a hug! I hope you and your family are doing well Jordan. I can't imagine the weight on your shoulders; you are carrying the world. We all love you Jordan Thank you from the bottom of my heart.

[@redriver6541]

👍👏

[@wisernow624]

Thank You for sharing your heart with Dr Peterson & audience ❣️

[@Rabbitunderground]

What an inspiring comment. Thank you

[@ko7305]

Warchild, refugee and legal immigrant here. kina virus released to fk up the elections...millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues...evil know no bounds, 100% intentionally released...just to get one man out of office, one man they could not buy/control. I have seen what communism will do to stay in or get in power. Anything! Chinese killed 30+ million of their own for power less than a century ago. It was a crazy conspiracy theory that FBI smoked Kennedy and now we know it is true. It was a conspiracy theory that kina virus was manmade but now we know it is true. MSM/Big Tech working overtime to censor/ban. This was intentionally released to fk up US election and for the Chinese to get protesters of Hong Kong streets because if Hong Kong goes so do commies in China. Win-win for commies and US dems....millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues. Godless people will always create hell.

[@davidsykes7251]

Nice personal comments and fair play on the post

[@DemandAlphabetBeBrokenUp]

Born agnostic raised Catholic like many grew to be atheistic and then agnostic again. However, right around 1 hour 5 minutes give or take a minute or two. Dr. Peterson begins to explain ideas and concepts that made me a know-er of God's existence. Physics has convinced me of the reality of God. I say know-er because life's tragic gamesmanship had already restored my faith. Physics cemented it in such a tangible way. That know-er is simply the best way possible I can conceive of to explain the feeling.

[@Schweini_1983]

Jordan Peterson is the last person on earth i would go to for anything related to science. Period.

[@istvancsendes5680]

i might have to watch this twice. Sorry the English is my 3rd language and i have to digest this material, but i must say since i watch JP and his guests in the past years i expanded my knowledge and vocabulary by hmm 1000 fold! I wish this way of learning was available back in the days in Hungary when there was no internet or even copy machine. We used to walk to the city library for school project material, find the book and handwrite the subject. This new generation has it all in hand right here .. !

[@KevinS47]

I am starting on my masters degree in Theoretical Physics this year, and despite this being a simple conversation (for someone who has already been introduced to all these concepts), I found it extremely interesting nonetheless. Dr. Keating is truly an incredible person, he has clearly mastered the subject, but I am blown away by how much he knows about other things that are more culture or social related for example! I can only dream to be that fluent and versatile in things outside of my field !! Amazing conversation, thanks for this!

[@natethegr8230]

Well...I'm glad someone understands what they're saying. These two are giants among men.

[@jamesmares4206]

Very helpful for me personally to understand how to cope when catastrophe happens from the largest of scales down to incredible smallnes of my own consciousness. This helps me to find a way to deal with my own tragedies in an honorable way. Thank you Jordan

[@karouselkar3149]

Best of luck to you in pursuing your master's!

[@jacksmith3095]

I am also in a Physics masters degree at the moment; I can completely relate to your statement. Good luck for your studies and God bless! 👍

[@user-fc6yp1xq1i]

I know nothing about physics but you can tell he’s excellent at what he does by how fluent he is in explaining these concepts and in a simple manner too! He’s clearly brilliant!

[@elsterp7837]

Question: WHY we have only ONE person like Jordan Peterson? We shpuld have at least 20 to 50 people like him, it could literally change the world!

[@Trapstar305]

Jordan b peterson is the modern day Albert Einstein 👏

[@analysisonlight605]

I am about 3/4 of the way through and all I can think is, I wish I could take a class taught by Dr. Brian Keating.

[@DrBrianKeating]

youll be able to soon... stay tuned for me and Peterson Academy

[@Happyheretic2308]

@@DrBrianKeating I’m so excited, I’m agog!

[@JasonWild-kk3lm]

Deep respect to Dr. Keating for his intellectual rigor and integrity.

[@vladradu9966]

I love how Dr Peterson asks clarifying question so even the average man can understand and how Dr Keating has the patience and willingness to give simple explanations. I feel like I did learn something today and not wasted time on KZbin for nothing.

[@jonathanmeyers633]

Jordan Peterson is on a class all by himself. He's one of the greatest minds of our time. I can't imagine a world without his insights and we'd be far less educated in the ways of the world without him. Stay healthy and live long, we're going to need you.

[@sarahjones753]

My thoughts exactly, I pray he lives a long life. We need teachers like him who are brave enough to speak out.

[@WilliamRNicholsonLST-1195]

I was so very grateful that Jordan beat his addictions & kept his somewhat limited sanity available to all of us ! He's a most generous man & the love in him for others is what saved him. I pray he knows Jesus The Christ. Nick , NavyBlueSmoke , LST -1195

[@Punchable-Face]

Well everyone dies, my only comfort is knowing at least we have his videos and lectures... for that I'm very, very grateful... hope that helps some.

[@JohnDoe-zg6fn]

His name will echo through the halls of time throughout human history. He will always be remembered, spoke about, and studied for the rest of human existence.

[@biteyourfreespeech7582]

I never say things like that just a Clever Guy noting more

[@MTech07]

It is a little hard for me to keep up, but Dr. Peterson questions help me to understand the main point. Great conversation

[@manskiptruck]

I’m a physics undergrad in 4th year and wasn’t expecting you and Cosmology to collide. My project was on dark energy and my report is being submitted very soon

[@laattardo]

Good luck, I hope your paper is well received

[@manskiptruck]

@@laattardo thank you!

[@laattardo]

@@manskiptruck you're very welcome

[@Chris-eu2ls]

Goodluck brother. 🙌🏾

[@anthonybrett]

Proud of you! Keep searching mate!

[@craighart9278]

Thanks Dr Peterson. I appreciate you so much 🙏

[@rosscorlett1877]

So amazing to have two equally brilliant and eloquent men together. It has been a privilege to listen to them both and my knowledge has increased as a result.

[@DrBrianKeating]

I appreciate that !

[@guyfromnj]

How great is Brian Keating? He’s great. I don’t agree on everything but he’s just a very likable guy. Great talker and explainer.

[@gerharddeusser9103]

It's not very common for a psychologist to transcend his own field of expertise in order to have a scientifically meaningful conversation with an astrophysicist. Jordan is in perfect shape these days.

[@DrBrianKeating]

agree!!

[@curtisbryce5096]

Why? Isn't it possible that they are on the opposite sides of the same coin?

[@realistool78]

Agreed. Dr. Peterson is a rare person. To be perfectly straight, Jordan Peterson is an example of what happens when you pay attention, think before you speak and watch the outcome For such an interesting, and intelligent man, it must be hard to have the majority of the modern society telling you your views are wrong. I'm amazed at his composure every single time I get the pleasure to watch him educate an ambushing Journalist. We need Peterson for President.

[@mb3799]

@@curtisbryce5096 Perhaps, but still uncommon.

[@KarmaEmbodied]

I love how fascinated Dr Keating is with his work. He's like an excited little kid. 😂 It's always refreshing and uplifting to see passionate people doing the work and being compensated for what they love. Keep up the phenomenal work Dr. Keating!

[@youlig1]

Jesus also said we should remain in our hearts as open and innocent as children. Its important to take this child like curiosity with you into adulthood. It generally makes you a nicer person

[@jeffcarter5805]

He is the perfect Teacher to have and would transfer his love and excitement of the cosmos to you.. Very enjoyable discussion!!

[@keyron4]

this was such a GOOD conversation

[@Dr.Harvey]

Keating is hell of a lecturer.

[@thabangduncankgaditse7629]

Yoh after watching this i felt like i was watching two Jordan Peterson talking to one another. I love Dr. Brian Keating he doesn't stop when his talking even Peterson has to disturb him and ask another question. This was an amazing episode

[@Therysin]

JP is the man.

[@OpDwagon]

you're the first btw lol

[@tonyhabedem7422]

Who suffered a lot

[@themightypen1530]

I get to see him speak live next month. I am excited.

[@tnmtnmorning1178]

🍻

[@davidsykes7251]

JP is the man that points you raises you up to help you move forward look forward not at JP kudos to JP!

[@bassimprovjams3772]

This was such a great conversation! I was lost at times but not so much I couldn’t understand them they both explain stuff in such a logical manner.

[@ShaunPrince]

What a fantastic guest. This is not one of your typical discussion topics, and I think you will gain a new audience with these conversations. Thank-you, and god bless.

[@sweebos]

Ive said this several times, but I cant express my full gratitude for bringing these discussions to an accessable place for me to listen, learn, and enjoy. I really enjoyed the path that this conversation took. Many thanks to the both of you for your time.

[@RoseThea]

I could listen to this for probably six hours. Thank you gentlemen for the absolutely delightful conversation.

[@jeremyzimmerman5603]

I think this might be one of my favorite JBP episodes. Beyond the lofty topic that helped me transcend the petty strifes of the day, the contagious childlike sense of awe Dr. Keating exudes and his amazing ability to simplify complicated concepts gives me hope ... as well as perspective into which my troubles seem quite small and the opportunity exceedingly large. Thanks so much to you both, Drs. Peterson and Keating!

[@michaelcunningham5120]

I worked drilling rigs and pipeline construction for 20 yrs. Things change with age. Especially what you are interested in. Jordan Peterson is badass. He has made me want to wake up the next day and carry on for that I am very grateful

[@IndependentThoughts911]

Part of seizing other Americans' private property for export pipelines? I'd be ashamed.

[@Mmmmkaaay]

I will definitely need to listen to this about three more times to grasp even half of it. Thank you🎉

[@1AvrgJoe]

Don’t you love how Peterson tells the expert scientist how things actually happened in the early universe. I love a know it all.

[@iDiGiiTaLi]

The thought of Jordan Peterson not being with us forever forces tears to my eyes.

[@jimmy5353]

I gain so much knowledge everyday by listening to this channel. Thank you Jordan!!! You have positively changed my life so much!

[@squirrelgang965]

I've been a fan of Keating since I heard him on Lex Fridman's podcast/channel. Thanks for having him on, I enjoy your way of conversing with your guests. ❤

[@MaddatMatt]

I knew I recognized the speaker! Ty for confirming.

[@DrBrianKeating]

@@MaddatMatt lol thanks

[@ko7305]

Warchild, refugee and legal immigrant here. kina virus released to fk up the elections...millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues...evil know no bounds, 100% intentionally released...just to get one man out of office, one man they could not buy/control. I have seen what communism will do to stay in or get in power. Anything! Chinese killed 30+ million of their own for power less than a century ago. It was a crazy conspiracy theory that FBI smoked Kennedy and now we know it is true. It was a conspiracy theory that kina virus was manmade but now we know it is true. MSM/Big Tech working overtime to censor/ban. This was intentionally released to fk up US election and for the Chinese to get protesters of Hong Kong streets because if Hong Kong goes so do commies in China. Win-win for commies and US dems....millions dead, billion+ with heart/organ issues. Godless people will always create hell.

[@MarkOakleyComics]

The most inspiring part... Keating learned he was wrong about a precious discovery, and shouted it rather than hid it. That takes uncommon guts. That's a man worth paying attention to.

[@peck4933]

What an awesome interview! so much in here, thank you for the interview Dr's!

[@FahadZahr]

After watching numerous videos on these topics, only today I definitely understood them crystal clear. Thanks You Doc 🫡

[@carissa2323]

Thank God for Jordan Peterson. My life is another changed for the good.

[@akshaynair1843]

I love how this podcast tries to intergrate psychology and consciousness with the science of our cosmos for the common listener. I'm so glad i live during a time this is just available for consumption by just anyone. The only pre requisite is curiosity

[@robsrockinout]

This guest is fascinating. Great interview. Wildly brilliant.

[@muazarooj7769]

Just clicked on the notification right away. This is going to be brilliant.

[@Artofwarthebookof5rings]

38:41 is where the fun really starts. Im very glad the topic piont has reached peterson. Incredible conversation thus far. Its a good mix of psychological evaluation regarding cosmic concepts and the current/ modern physics and mathematic literature.

[@xbemos]

That’s exactly my sentiment. Thank you for the time stamp 💪🙌

[@Artofwarthebookof5rings]

@@xbemos Your very Welcome John!

[@stephentranquilla7785]

I had to listen to this several times. Absolutely well done. Good interview and Dr Brian Keating does a good job of making this "simpler".

[@polpol2739]

this was amazing, learned so much, i hope he becomes a regular guest on your podcasts

[@paultaylor7947]

Jordan sums up my philosophy on life. Lift myself up and try to be a force for good. He is able to express himself more eloquently as well as being inspirational

[@UranHexx]

As an experimentalist myself i must say that proving things wrong equals proving things right, amazing talk.

[@JSabh]

Great conversation Dr. Peterson, I enjoyed the subject matter. I hope and pray that you and your family are doing awesome and overcoming every trial with joy. You have been such a powerful source of information and insight. I appreciate you and your work very much for the good it is doing in humanity as a whole, thank you for following your dream and sharing the wisdom you have learned with us all.

[@mikenelson8409]

For a regular Joe Blow like myself to have such easy access to this coveted information outside of a university lecture hall is powerful and exquisitely satisfying and beneficial. Thank-you very much Dr. Peterson! ❤

[@HypocriticYT]

Brian will be known for an exceptional breakthrough in cosmology given a couple decades 😊

[@DrBrianKeating]

hopefully sooner i'm 50 already!

[@HypocriticYT]

@@DrBrianKeatingtechnology has to improve and hopefully sooner than later. Better detection is always improving 😊

[@HypocriticYT]

@@DrBrianKeatingI’m over 60 so 50 isn’t old. Just a blink of an eye is all we have to search for meaning and universal truths.

[@jukeman57]

Fascinating conversation. Thanks to you both, Dr. Peterson and Dr. Keating.

[@ramaiyer9348]

Prof Keating , you were excellent.

[@kevinwalden4288]

This was one of the coolest freaking podcasts I've listened to

[@jurajsekej1174]

This is just stunning! Thank you so much for this!❤️‍🔥

[@arthurjohnson7473]

I love how he got so wrapped up in a conversation about the universe itself that he forgot where in it he was, exactly. I loved the conversation, too, of course.

[@DrBrianKeating]

[@arthurjohnson7473]

@@DrBrianKeating Thank you very much, Dr. Keating! I wish you all the best in your work and on your podcast that you mentioned.

[@agustinguzman1428]

My goodness. The first 10 minutes are already amazing.

[@MrLendran]

Been listening to this while working, what a blast. Fascinating stuff, very well put together and easily explained.

[@debramulcahy9979]

Thank you both. Wonderful topic. Enjoyed this dialog immensely.

[@yonason6047]

So happy to be able to eavesdrop on this delightfully thought provoking and informative conversation.

[@JustSSaiyan]

I dont think ive ever listened to someone explain something so clear and understandable. Wow

[@raven5875]

Man, I love this concept of the event horizon. Thank you for the talk.

[@DM_Curtis]

Always great to hear Dr. Keating!

[@matti5395]

Amazing work. I'd love to hear more from both of you

[@rocksalittle]

Such a blessing you are Dr. Peterson. The words don’t exist to tell you how profoundly you have enlightened my life. 😊 🙏

[@rogertorgersen9995]

Dr. Keating is great at explaining some complex and fascinating things. I learned more in the first 30 minutes of this conversation than in years of physics.

[@JuanLpianist]

His ability to explain is breathtaking

[@cheryldekeyzer323]

Fantastic interview. Should Dr. Peterson have Dr. Keating as a guest again I already look forward to it.

[@anthonymoses3697]

What a truly wonderful conversation.

[@kha7705]

I absolutely enjoyed this to the fullest. Very clear way of explaining complex material for the lesser gifted among us. I am eternally great full for this peace of insight Sirs.

[@kha7705]

@@slevinchannel7589 🤓

[@lifearttimes]

WE the “Phenomena“, are living within a phenomena. Great dialogue Jordan & Brian.🌟

[@damadefuego]

This podcast is blowing my mind. Literally ⭐️✨🧘🏻‍♀️

[@agonaapell665]

Fascinating interview! Thought I would listen for a few minutes and return later in the day. In the event, I watched the whole interview nonstop. If I visited an observatory, I would pivot the telescope to watch Dr Keating's lectures. Fluent, eloquent, humorous.

[@mikesmz]

A Lot of things could be said regarding this wonderful conversation we are presented with here. But I think it can be simply summed up with: Wow! Bravo gentlemen! This is the most concise, informative & entertaining explanation of "Life the Universe and Everything" that I have ever witnessed! Thank you Daily Wire for bringing us the best content on the internet. And a very special thanks to Dr. Jordan and Dr. Keating for gifting us with such an amazing and enlightened exchange! - Cheers!

[@melissawentlandmoreno4559]

@@DanicaDeVrieshaha. That comment says everything

[@Ybasd]

Yoooo I subed for Dr Brian for a long time, good to see him here!

[@marshalanderson7039]

I always love your content! Thank you for doing everything you do, sir!

[@notavailable2628]

When you read the comments on this and other Jordan Peterson videos they are all so well written and well thought out. In most comment sections its rare to find a comment that has more than 5 poorly written words, but here the majority of the comments are very detailed and so far as i have read all very positive positive. I honestly didn’t know there was a place like this left on youtube. Btw i havent watched the video yet i just saw the comments and wanted to pint this out.

[@jennymcgowin9140]

I listened to this podcast two times in a row last night because it was so complicated. In the end , I think I have a pretty good grasp of this absolutely fascinating information! Good job men! ❤❤

[@gldn2092]

Unbelievably interesting, thank you both!! Good luck!

[@RichWards-Wins]

Much love to JP and his beautiful family. God bless in him.

[@violetorchy3910]

OMG, I screamed when I read the title. This is exactly what I am into right now. Can’t wait to watch it!!!!

[@3hh73ya6]

In a long line of fabulous interviews by JP, this has been the best. Every word by Keeting was a fascinating exploration of how little I know. His enthusiasm for his field is infectious and makes you want to know more.

[@debhadden205]

You both should really read The Pearl of Great Price! It scripturally validates this whole discussion! And you have helped me to understand why maybe I chose as a pre-existent spirit to live in a challenging situation on earth.

[@melissawentlandmoreno4559]

This man needs a QHHT session

[@kholemlangeni1373]

I’m listening to this podcast for the 8th time. Very informative to a novice such as myself

[@alejandroungaro4488]

THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO BOTH OF YOU FOR THIS AMAZING CONVERSATION!!! 🙏

[@pauliewalsh6875]

The existence of conciousness before the universal genesis is the only way I can wrap my head around the creation of anything without going into a full blown state of existentialism! Thanks JP🙏

[@jimj9040]

Consciousness is an awareness of a state of being. Without a state of being there would be no awareness of anything. Therefore, it perplexes me that your head seems to get it exactly backwards. There has to be something first to be conscious of it, thus consciousness must be made of what already existed.

[@Beederda]

When i play the mind game of expanding out from ones self to infinity. I am sitting than i am looking at myself sittin than i am above my house and on and on till i come to the edge of the universe my mind than returns to the self as if a loop happened if you expand to the edge you reach that consciousness and it starts from the centre of the self where i started its strange i just can’t imagine past the edge of the universe when i do i return to the singular point of the self somewhere behind eyes in the middle of your ears.

[@pauliewalsh6875]

@@jimj9040 Are you familiar with the theories in biocentrism?

[@pauliewalsh6875]

@@Beederda Have you ever tried experimenting with DMT?

[@Beederda]

@@pauliewalsh6875 i would love to. i currently only do psilocybin mushrooms as i cant find trustworthy source for dmt but yes i want to try it i have questions for that realm if i get the chance to send myself there

[@joannadziaduch2138]

A very informative meeting of two brilliant minds. Dr Jordan's questions were so thoroughly researched it made listening to the conversation a pure joy. Thank you.