Black Pearl VS Flying Dutchman VS Queen Anne's Revenge VS Silent Mary-(POTC:Battle of the ships.)

[@64_jhex]

Dutchman: Forward Triple cannons Queen Anne's: Forward Flamethrowers Silent Mary: Forward Devour ships Pearl: Forward

[@daryon_intheend9315]

queen anne's revenge win in this a dialogue

[@pseudo2009]

Tu à écrit néerlandais au lieu de hollandais

[@pseudo2009]

Le hollandais volant à bien plus de capacités que sa

[@ktanoli._]

Where is the ship of east india

[@limbytes]

Pearl can forward misty step :O I believe in the first film it looks like she creates mist and fog from the front

[@IcedCat559]

Flying dutchman: a submarine that can also summon the kraken Silent mary: can go on top of other ships to destroy them Queen anne's revenge: can shoot fire and burn ships Black pearl: *s p e e d*

[@T.Riker_]

Lol

[@sciron3730]

The kraken died

[@JustDougGG]

@@sciron3730 so did Davy Jones. And Black Beard. We aren't getting into the who is dead at what point because none of this would make sense anyway

[@FredricSimpson]

Speed + a crazy captain jack = unknown result

[@daryon_intheend9315]

queen anne's revenge has rapid fire

[@thefoxter5276]

Silent Mary: *Goes above Flying Dutchman Flying Dutchman: *Sink no jutsu Silent Mary: *Nani?!*

[@11op65]

If flying dutchman leaves the kraken then no one can be dutchman

[@darkbladeofdoom22rosario97]

Lol so true also flying Dutchman: summoning jutsu summon the kraken All other ships: fuck we are all dead 💀 Flying Dutchman: wins flawless victory ✌

[@jordankairos]

@Revolusi Leonel Alif wtf cannon rifle?? I think u mean the triple guns

[@firstelementofdark2486]

@@darkbladeofdoom22rosario97 Kraken hates fire and that's what revenge have

[@captainmonopoly5586]

@Revolusi Leonel Alif The Greek Fire is on the Queen Anne's Revenge not on the Dutchman.

[@MrFool-rm7nu]

Contenders and Characteristics (IN PRIME CONDITION) The Black Pearl (cursed state) -Fast with the wind -Nimble -Ability to create a mist to escape into, as is shown in POTC 1 -Commanded by cursed mortals (cannot die, but can still be physically broken) The Flying Dutchman -Immortal -Fast against the wind -There is always a Capatin -Has the blessings of the goddess, Calypso -Ability to summon the Kraken -Ability to submerge underwater forever -Guardian of the sea -Commanded by cursed crew, forced to be loyal (part of the crew, part of the ship, absolute control over crew with the sole exception of Bootstrap Bill Turner) Queen Anne's Revenge -Specializes in black magic -Ability to shoot fire -Unbeatable in onboard crew battle -Commanded by mortals and zombified deck masters (threat of mutiny, may or may not be successful as can be seen with Jack in POTC 4) Silent Mary (cursed state) -Durable -Specializes in close range combat -Ability to bite and tear into enemy ships -Pet undead sharks -Commanded by undead crew (can walk on water as if it were solid ground) Winner: Thr Flying Dutchman Explanation: -The Black Pearl did not win, no. Jack Sparrow did. It just happened to be his ship. It was fast and nimble, perfect for escaping, which is a match for Jack's personality. That's why he's always fought for it. It was also destroyed by the Kraken along with a betrayed Jack Sparrow as is in POTC 2. -Queen Anne's Revenge is strong in frontal attacks and onboard combat and that's it. The Black Pearl can out manuver it and attack it from behind. Silent Mary is not affected by fire and its crew cannot be killed by sword or fire. -Silent Mary is a strong ship, but it has no cannons whatsoever after it was destroyed at the Devil's Triangle. Therefore absolutely no long range attacks. -The Flying Dutchman has proven itself the be the representation of the sea. It was blessed by the sea goddess herself. Should Captain Jack Sparrow not exist, the Black Pearl would have fallen against the Flying Dutchman. Queen Anne's Revenge is a strong contender, but let's be honest, the Dutchman can always sumberge while Revenge sticks out like a sore thumb. Plus, come on... Kraken. And finally, the undead ship. Silent Mary is strong and durable but the Dutchman can heal itself to full health if it ever gets damaged. The Dutchman can also keep their distance as it is the faster of the two, and attack from afar. The Silent Mary will sink. It's just a matter of how long it will take. Plus, the Captain of the Dutchman guides the dead into the other world. And cursed they may be, an undead crew is still dead. And also..... KRAKEN!!!

[@generalgrievous2720]

My man I respect you for the giant explanation i tip my hat to you good sir

[@PbK-sl8kt]

I have never seen such a long comment

[@plakshyasunako5866]

duchman in the bottle would look funny

[@matemate9149]

But the Pearl was rebuild in POTC 3 and fight the flying Dutchman and it was a tie so the Pearl has a higher chance of winning because her the black pearl has the max speed of 48 with the wind

[@1nmkop]

silent mary has a cannon

[@jdjgaming4300]

Black Pearl: *Speed *Immortal Crew *Smart Captain Flying Dutchman: *Kraken *Immortal Crew *Powerful Cannons *Unsinkable *Can go underwater Queen Anne's Revenge: *Fire Breathing *Snake Ropes *Zombified Crew *Triton's Sword (Can curse ships) Silent Mary: *Immortal Crew *Can sink ships easily *Undead Sharks and Crows P.S I don't know who will win but my favorite is the Black Pearl.

[@aikrisgamer5689]

Dutchman is dominant

[@mrnobody3982]

Kraken died

[@Noname-mt7gd]

FatTaterChip yes he have only when the slavery finishes the crew isn’t immortal anymore

[@jacobhogan380]

FatTaterChip if they get stabbed through the chest and don’t die that’s pretty immortal. They are always expanding their crew and ( most of the time depends on how much time they owe ) most of the crew are there for at least 100 years, they have the kraken, and their ship can go under water :/. So I think that the Dutchmen would win but the silent Mary is also a very powerful ship and crew

[@jannatibegumruma7271]

@@mrnobody3982 thx man

[@Twizzly_Fizzy]

Well Black Pearl is only the Fastest ship , Queen Annes Revenge has Flamethrower and the Sword of Triton , Silent Mary is a ghost ship ,The flying Dutchman is a legend of sea.....two ships will sunk and two ships will battle eternaly

[@timoteus5062]

Good point

[@The_Warrior_Poet]

Greek fire on revenge is located on it's bow, it could be argued that in a straight up battle it's role would be from very small to almost non existent, the weapon is for chasing ships not battling them. Furthermore pearl is bigger, heavier, more agile and a lot quicker with virtually no downs, this would give the pearl a severe advantage in maneuvering over qar which is slower without the sword and keep in mind that the sword of Triton is not a part of qar, it is a magical standalone artifact, think of it as a leash for a dog, you can use it on a dog but it is not a part of it. I find pearl vs revenge a very complicated battle but without the sword I do not see qar beating the pearl. And as for The Dutchman vs Mary, this is a tricky one, there are many things about the mary that are BS like catching up to the Pearl (Which is the utmost horseshit of a plot point) and see mary could not beat the pearl even given it's invulnerability, if you remember tdmc The dutchman dominated the fuck out of pearl which imo is a pretty good indicator of the power gap between two ships. Those who say mary can not be destroyed, go away. To assume that Salazar's ship is indestructible is no limits fallacy, (Assuming that a trait or an ability is infinitely potent, another example of the fallacy would be to assume that Barbossa's sword could control the dutchman). According to Occam's razor the assumption that a ghost escorting ship tasked with ESCORTING GHOSTS could probably beat a GHOST ship( Plus Jones has some weird matter manipulation hacks and the ability to bring ships back to life, I mean he could bring Mary back to life and destroy it? It's kinda weird ).

[@piratelord5803]

Well let me guess flying

[@mutoprime5693]

Black pearl and Queen Anne Revenge will sink Flying Dutchman and Silent Mary will battle eternaly

[@asherpikesgoldenmoralcinem5770]

Matthew Vargas no the Dutchman woudnt need to fight they would escort the ghost ship to locker

[@latervader8876]

The Flying Dutchman for sure. You can't exactly sink such a ship...

[@Bmwdiagnostics92]

you can force it to sink if you have the Davy Jones heart ;)

[@emanuelhrenka4899]

I'm not agree with you

[@lifted.5916]

Well depends how bout the silent marry

[@BlackKnight-th8ml]

Fling Dutchman and silent mary are ghost ships so black pearl and queen annes revenge are dead. So. Fling Dutchman destroy the silent mary

[@urban__1190]

Got to point out the Flying Dutchmans got nothing 5o shoot with it's cannons there nothing left of the marry if anything it will end up in a crew vs crew fight and if that is so we've already seen the made us crew completely destroy crews

[@ramzanmelethil7942]

Flying Dutchman is best but at the end black pearl is on sail

[@mackluther9316]

Nah man queen annes revenge, with the ability to shoot fire and the magic sword that can control the ship the queen Anne’s got to be the best

[@stormyrift116]

@@mackluther9316 Tf Problay the weakest Ist Immortal

[@justthinking650]

@@mackluther9316 davy jones summones kraken, queen anne is dead

[@justthinking650]

@Seth Stafford yeah you can't trust anything on quora

[@whatsfortheboys5201]

@@mackluther9316 ok but it's the ship its self not the people controling it so lets say each boat has a crew of equal skill then we see which boat is better

[@aeureus]

So basically, you're comparing: - *I'm Fast af Boi,* - *Immortal Submarine,* - *Hell's Kitchen, and* - *Legit Sea Food.* I wonder which would win :O

[@Litl_E]

Hell's Kitchen I'm dying.

[@POLO....2]

Init hells kitchen 🙈🤣

[@Luke-tp3xm]

Well the fast boi lost against hells kitchen and won against the immortal submarine and supernatural shark

[@slavczerwo5845]

Honestly this fight isnt possible, there aint no winner 😂, none of the ships can catch the pearl, the dutchman is as you said, an immortal submarine, queen annes revenge is basically a floating flamethrower and the silent mary is a flying shark basically yea 😂😂

[@remirickard]

@@Luke-tp3xm immortal submarine never died to fast boi. They both lived on. In the 5th POTC Will Turner is sailing the ship just as Jack is sailing his

[@ravscraves5416]

We all seem to forget that the pearl is crewed by the damned and captained by a man so evil that hell it self spat him back out

[@charmingman20]

An we are all forgetting the fact that the Queen Anne revenge has a zombie crew and his captain can literally give life to a ship and putting it on its command or freaking turn an entire ship in a bottle

[@putra7362]

what about silent mary? that ship can *EAT* another ship

[@charmingman20]

I know right, There are a lot of possibilities, The Flying Dutchman *CAN* be damaged, in at the end of the world The black pearl fought the Dutchman without any problem

[@charmingman20]

SNACK BOX ONE True, The Flying Dutchman is imposible to sink but it can be contained

[@charmingman20]

SNACK BOX ONE There is no way to break the bottle unless Blackbeard does it

[@angelrainnn6193]

The Flying Dutchman escorts the dead to the afterlife. The Silent Mary is a dead ship with a dead crew. There you go, badabim badaboom.

[@jawbreaker2524]

_But The Flying Dutchman and Black Pearl crews are immortal, right? So the one is disadvantage is the Queen Anne's Revenge, but the sword that controls that ship, can trap another ship in a bottle, so it's not really easy_

[@francissosa6661]

The Dutchman is corrupted, the sword of blackbearb can trap the flying dutchman? I think not, davy jones and turner can teleport and the ship can go underwater.

[@jawbreaker2524]

_idk, but maybe you're right_

[@danielcardoso20000]

Francis Sosa Exactly and not only that it can repair it self the crew with the curse can’t be killed just like the crew of the Pearl with the curse and Salazar too and don’t forget if the Queen Anne’s Revenge is next to a ship it can literally use it ropes to trap the crew and Blackbeard like that can do whatever he wants no wonder the Black Pearl lost and Barbosa cut his own damn leg what a badass when it comes to battles curses etc it’s tough to talk about it since there’s many ifs and who knows since we didn’t get to see for example the HMS Endeavour battling for real which is a shame with its 110 cannons

[@docsaaid2939]

Is after life underwater 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@monteiperier]

Who would win? The captain of the flying dutchman, an immortal ghost ship which can go underwater, who got bested by Jack Sparrow The captain of the Silent Mary, an immortal ghost ship which has destroyed fleets worth of pirate ships along with a disciplined crew, who got bested by jack sparrow The captain of the Queen Anne’s Revenge, a big powerful ship with a legendary captain and zombies on board, who got bested by Jack Sparrow The ship of Jack sparrow, the Black Pearl

[@Prince_Artic]

Dear sir it is Captain Jack Sparrow

[@k-132_44]

With logic, Flying Dutchman win With plot armor, Black Pearl (That ship already sank twice but rise again because it needed for the movie story)

[@TheBlueGrinchofSurgery]

@@k-132_44 plot armor? You sure? Black Pearl has alot of firepower

[@ahmetakifbozkurt6156]

Captain... Jack sparrow

[@tomcarpenter7821]

Blackbeard was bested by Barbossa, not Jack.

[@thomaselliott7901]

Black pearl: can sail away Flying Dutchman: can’t sink, can summon the kraken, can summerge underwater Flying Mary: can go on top of ships to sink

[@feliperuiz7458]

is silent mary

[@MikfinityPog]

Couldn't the silent mary eat the flying dutchman though? That would break it into 2 pieces, probably wouldn't be able to move after that

[@markiv2361]

no, the dutchman would go submarine mode

[@Forgotten_Ghostboiii]

RIP Kraken

[@nametime8938]

@DrCrunch WasTaken I see you took a joke from the top comment

[@computerinsurgent1204]

Flying Dutchman is the winner, even without the Kraken. I will explain. Queen Anne's Revenge and the Black Pearl are no match for the Dutchman. Yes the Black Pearl survived a fight with the Dutchman in POTC3, but only because the Dutchman's captain Davy Jones was killed. The Dutchman can repair itself. So if the fight would last longer, the Pearl would have sunk. The same goes the Queen Anne's Revenge. This ship's only powerful weapon is it flamethrowers. But if the Dutchman is set on fire, it can dive like a submarine and put out the fire and repair itself. The Dutchman will then rise to the surface again and sink the damaged Queen Anne's Revenge. And at last, there is the Silent Mary. Silent Mary's deadliest weapon is its ability to bite and break other ships like a monster. However I don't think the Silent Mary can catch up the speed of the Dutchman, plus the Dutchman could dive to avoid being bitten. Plus the Dutchman has the ability to bring the dead to the afterlife. And the Silent Mary is commanded by a dead crew. So yeah, the Flying Dutchman is here the clear winner!

[@alexwhite2377]

Well if the silent Mary can’t catch the Dutchman, we already know the pearl can outrun the Dutchman. SOOO Pearl is the winner.

[@computerinsurgent1204]

@@alexwhite2377 Just the speed is not the only thing that decides which is the winner. Black Pearl only can sail faster if it has the wind in its back. But against the wind, the Flying Dutchman is faster. If the Black Pearl and the Flying Dutchman were in a bay, and the wind was heading towards land, the Black Pearl cannot escape. Plus if it did escape, it would still have suffered more damage than the Flying Dutchman.

[@alexwhite2377]

Computer Insurgent oh is didn’t say the Pearl would win, but it won’t lose. And why would it skirmish in a bay? No ship does that unless there assaulting a port or landing troops or something.

[@computerinsurgent1204]

@@alexwhite2377 Pearl would minor loose as it would be more damaged. Flying Dutchman can just repair itself. But maybe it can be that the Pearl has to visit a bay for supplies or another adventure. And than the Dutchman shows up and the Pearl cannot escape anymore. In real life it happened that a battle was fought in a bay. Look here. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_in_the_Bay_of_Matanzas

[@alexwhite2377]

Computer Insurgent I didn’t deny that a battle in a bay would occur and btw, the Matanzas bay is massive and I know that because I grew up near it. Yea your right (I’m just being annoying with you) I know the Dutchman would win, my point is the fastest ship in the Caribbean (world) is the Black Pearl

[@valenting7150]

1. Dutchman with Davy Jones 2. Mary with ghost mode 3. Pearl with ghost mode 4. Revenge with Blackbeard

[@maxpain4084]

Dutchman with jones and kraken

[@honixczen8644]

Sure not, revenge have the sword of Triton

[@beansowles]

@@maxpain4084 kraken is dead however

[@ff-rs3ji]

Blackbeard dead and the black pearl curse not work anymore

[@markzomer1335]

@@ff-rs3ji you idiot, they mean when the curse was there and blackbeard didnt died. Then davy Jones ship won with the kraken

[@gOd_Marquitus]

I’m wondering how the dying gull will defeat all this ships...

[@zackattack2307]

Oh yea

[@RealD8]

🤣

[@purplewhalrus0716]

Just by intimidation

[@whitesnake6655]

The answer is simple. They got a jar of dirt

[@ghostlaughter9978]

It doesn't Jack uses it as a distraction and trap for Salazar do to how much he wants him dead Jones does not fall for it because of William telling him to just watch as the trap un folds

[@TheNoseungFace]

This is exactly what we needed in Dead Man Tell No Tales. Jack bringing back the Pearl, Will commanding the Dutchman, Barbossa in his full glory with the Revenge, introducing Salazar steering the Silent Mary as a new villain. I would have wet my pants seeing all ships on screen, and it would have easily outmatched the Portals scene from Avengers Endgame. Perhaps Barbossa might even turn on the heroes but join them in the very last moment. Instead, we got a disappointing treasure hunt no better than On Stranger Tides. Shame.

[@BillPlunderbonesTew8]

Oh my yes, i wont forgive the 5th for many things but not including a scene with all 4 of the mightiest ships in the series NOT together is just the definition of missed opportunity

[@TheZamaron]

@@BillPlunderbonesTew8 I mean yah we had that opportunity, though I don't think the Black Pearl would have been much of a match against the other ships unless Jack cursed it again, But yah we have the Queen Ann's Revenge under Barbossa, the Black Pearl under Jack, and the Dutchman under Will Turner, I would have loved to see Will know his son was in danger and bring the Dutchman in to fight Salazaar, maybe the 2 ships could have been fighting and giving time for Jack to get the Trident and break the curse, with that we then see Salazaar stop for a moment and become mortal again and the Dutchman's cannons then finish of the Silent Mary for good. After that scene we then actually see the curse on Will get broken, instead of an end credit scene of his nightmare.

[@ZapDon777Tutorials]

@@TheZamaron MANNN! That was exactly what I was expecting when I was watching the cinema lol

[@miquelcanosasanteularia1678]

on stanger tides was a great one, but the last one not really

[@callumkristofer7793]

@@TheZamaron actually, if will fought Salazar, it would be over fast, he can lift the curse himself, with his authority as davey Jones II.

[@valeriobertoletti44]

My favorite ship is the black pearl, because it’s the fastest

[@BlackKnight-th8ml]

But it's the weakest

[@stormyrift116]

@@BlackKnight-th8ml It is not

[@stormyrift116]

@@BlackKnight-th8ml All the black pearls Crew Are immortal

[@hopelfreyamikaelson9348]

@@BlackKnight-th8ml who said ?

[@luanlinhares1707]

@@stormyrift116 black pearl have no curses on it,its just the fastest ship on the sea

[@dannyjames8894]

"The Dutchman sails as its Captain commands-ah!"

[@TheUnboundedAngel]

...and it's captain is to sail it as commanded...

[@donsullivan1256]

I would’ve thought you learned that when I ordered you to kill your pet

[@JayRicoche]

😂

[@mordecaismopstick]

The immaterial has become...IMMATERIAL

[@Lena-vy9vf]

This is no longer your world, Jones.

[@morganchoat75]

Flying Dutchman: can summon kraken and also is a submarine Queen Anne's revenge: Is a flame thrower and is pilot by the most fearsome pirate of all time silent marry: has a zombie shark army and can bite down on boats destroying any thing in its say black pearl: I am fast boi

[@slim7406]

You forgot the most important part of the ship, who's the crew. A crew of the dead, a crew of zombies, a crew of ghouls, and a crew of sealife that would have to serve an eternity on their vessel. All of those are fairly even since none of them can technically die, so we look at Captains, and Jack and Barbosa had beaten each of the other Captains. The Pearl may not be able to go toe to toe with any of these ships outright but we do know it fought on par with the Flying Dutchman and we know the Dutchman could fight on par with the other ships or even beat them.

[@beaujaques1090]

1. Dutchman 2. Mary 3. Revenge 4. Sadly but the pearl Dutchman can sink and come right back so there is no possible way to beat her, it makes sense that the British armada sailed away after will and jack took the devastator as the Dutchman is the only true immortal ship

[@donnacooper8994]

Beau Jaques 0

[@hurricanehusky287]

Yup.

[@The_Warrior_Poet]

I wouldn't agree with revenge beating pearl, pearl is bigger and faster with bigger fire power(even with greek fire). Queen Anne's revenge is outmatched in every way, the reason Barbossa lost against Thatch is beause Black pearl turned on Hector and his crew due to the influence of Triton's sword, weilded by Black Beard. Again, it is hard to say which would actually sink the other as we don't have exact details and nearly enough info, we know that pearl was a galleon and the revenge was a frigate, so technically speaking pearl is a heavier, more agile, stealthy and more heavily armed vessel that also has unmatched seed which is it's magical property, where as revenge is a frigate that boasts heavy arms, 30 twelve pound guns and greek fire at ship's bow (although it would be arguably useless against pearl as the battle in my opinion would not turn into a chase) again my opinion, you're free to disagree.

[@leonelrosa7531]

Beau Jaques f

[@hugoholmquist2974]

But silent Mary cant sink tho

[@combineadvisorwithinternet6040]

I think the Dutchman would've won after some point, because: 1 - It cannot be sunk, it repairs itself under the water. 2 - Only way to kill the Davy Jones is to stab his heart and the heart is buried in an island. Crew of the Silent Mary can't step to land so they can't kill Davy Jones. 3 - It's crew are immortal as I believe, they always seem to come back every time they got stabbed or fell from the ship. 4 - Silent Mary and it's crew are dead and the Dutchman escorts the dead to afterlife, Davy Jones have an advantage. 5 - Dutchman can go underwater, so it can escape Silent Mary's ram attack.

[@mutilateadolldreamworriors6274]

But not the sharks

[@Roachcock_]

Mutilate a doll Dream worriors the kraken would get them

[@michaeljamesmate6993]

To kill Davy Jones you have to stab the heart

[@sovietunion7202]

U are forgeting that they have every curse so they are either alive nor dead so better luck next time

[@askova7445]

Don't take it seriously man, Davy Jones literally devil of the sea. He ferrying dead soul to the next world

[@thecreatoritself]

*"Jackdaw"*

[@palmiroboss5059]

Edward kenway

[@NPCLIVESMATTER723]

So nice to see this name here...

[@yeos2363]

Alright you have beyond the limit

[@crizsha7977]

Captain Pissoff?

[@Joeptoulouse]

CAPTAIN EDWARD TEACH WAS BLACKBEARD MOR THE BEST SHIP IS THE QUEEN ANNES REVENGE

[@jacktheripper3524]

I think the Ducthman wins because none of the other ships can shoot the dutchman if it´s underwater, what makes the Ducthman almost impossible to hit. The Ducthman can suprise any of those ships by appearing at their side, shoot the cannons and dissapear again. The only disavantage of the Dutchman is that it gets slower with the wind, but it´s faster than the other ships when it travels against the wind. In concluison: Flying Ducthman vs Black Pearl - Dutchman wins because has more firepower and can go underwater, while the Pearl it´s just faster when has the wind on its side. Flying Dutchman vs Queen´s Anne Revenge - Black Beard´s ship has more fire power and can cast big waves of fire, but that wont be a problem to the ducthman because it can go underwater, also the Ducthman can suprise it anytime, shoot and dissapear again. So i give the win to the Ducthman. Flying Ducthman vs Silent Mary - Silent Mary is just a rotten ship and the only special thing that Silent Mary has is beeing able to sink ships by literaly climb on them, but that´s useless against the Ducthman because Silent Mary has to aproach the ships to do that and the Ducthman would just fire and then go underwater. So i also gives the win to the ducthman Besides, we are not considering the most op hability of the Ducthman: summun the f*cking KRAKEN! POC Kraken is not as big as the tails and legends say, but still can attack any ship with extremly violence and sink it in minutes. So yeah, Ducthman defenitly wins this war

[@tropictitan8531]

Silent mary can summon its sharks and go after the dutchman while the dutch man is underwater

[@jacktheripper3524]

@@tropictitan8531 Sharks, really? The Dutchman can kill them with canon fire and can summon the fucking Kraken lmao

[@thomashaeyen6942]

@@tropictitan8531 thats an extremely dumb idea. First of all, the sharks can't do anything about the flying dutchman. And second, the flying dutchman is NEVER underwater, it actually teleports to the realm of the dead.

[@BruceKraftJr]

@@thomashaeyen6942 it does both

[@thomashaeyen6942]

@@BruceKraftJr true, i forgot that.

[@godzillacc5]

The pearl and the queen are just particularly special ships, with some magical properties, but they can still be sunk. The Dutchman and the Mary are cursed ships and potentially imposible to sink, so they for sure

[@elkplays107]

Um the pearl has a curse two

[@itsyaboi9127]

The pearl has a curse and colypso

[@thebeansinthebackofyourfridge9]

The crew of the pearl is cursed, not the ship

[@vernnax4290]

@@thebeansinthebackofyourfridge9 Thank you.

[@thebeansinthebackofyourfridge9]

Your welcome Plus calypso is in the sky remember? They freed her

[@SNIPERGAMING-ml7pe]

It wil be an undecide battle between the silent mary and the flying Dutch man

[@ΣταθηςΑποστολιδης-ψ4ε]

Not exactly if you notice that mary's crew is consisted of dead warriors and Jones seem to have some kind of influence over the dead . Plus the fact that I don't believe that salazar would attack the one who can take them to the afterlife .

[@jar3987]

Or they’d all just team up ok jack sparrow being that he fucked them all over at some point

[@ameygupta9264]

@@jar3987 language 😝😝

[@mariorosario1323]

Ok

[@Francinator]

I didn't know Dutch men could fly

[@ezekieltang470]

I love the 3 shot cannon on the Flying Dutchman

[@danieledwards2819]

"Let them taste the triple gun'' -Davy Jones-

[@Rand0mYTuser01]

@@danieledwards2819 yea lol

[@infinitybattlegrounds0206]

Me too...❤️🏴‍☠️

[@keanu9328]

Black pearl... Legend

[@kontvladimir3929]

Süppermen black pearl sadece hızlı

[@Amai-Kurvi-Tasch]

Süppermen but it doesnt have front and rear cannons which make it hard to chase and escape enemy ships

[@BlacklightProgramming]

PZ.wiking .5 blackpearl is good at escaping, just like Sparrow 😂

[@BlacklightProgramming]

Ethan Schmid Yep, it's a main hero of the movie :). My fav. too anyway. But look, pearl is fastest, Sparrow always escapes somehow too. It's just a joke don't take it serious ;)

[@leandrowski_9]

Vingança Da Rainha Anna existiu de vrdd e o Holandês Voador tbm

[@michaeltanner2666]

1: Flying Dutchman 2: Silent Mary 3: Black Pearl 4: Queen Anne's revenge

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAINS OF THE BLACK PEARL: MARIO & DONKEY KONG

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAINS OF THE QUEEN ANNE'S REVENGE: BOWSER & KAMEK

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAIN OF THE SILENT MARY: KING BOO

[@Timmygaming10003]

true

[@dripgetathestardustcrusade8777]

Capitans of the Flying Dutchman: King bom-omb and Luigi

[@amarko24]

Flying Dutchman win

[@hurricanehusky287]

Amar Smajic I agree on so many levels.

[@SunilKumar-fy9bk]

Black pearl is the best ship in the world

[@leandrowski_9]

Queen Anne Revenge

[@Daniel2005-u6h]

@@leandrowski_9 Lol!

[@Daniel2005-u6h]

@@leandrowski_9 Ih, fala português rsrs.Acha mesmo que o barco do barba Negra consegue ser mais forte que o holandês voador?

[@chilldeen4590]

it's sad that Queen Anne's Revenge didn't get much love here, i know it's a normal ship with no super power whatsoever, but it's an actual real life ship at least (apart from Flying Dutchman which is kind of a tale)

[@AcManoloxkasha]

Its not A Tale

[@AcManoloxkasha]

Its a Nightmare

[@scratchfivek3355]

The Flying Dutchman was a real ship, it's more the myth behind it that can be seen as a tale.

[@sureshop6969]

@@scratchfivek3355 yes

[@sukablyat1770]

Yeah a real life one, but irl it was not really great as it looks in the movie. Flyng dutchman is in my heart

[@tarakokun2551]

Silent Mary :comment Flying dattiman :good

[@dylanheyer3599]

Kun Tarako silent mary

[@dylanheyer3599]

Silent mary

[@jacky9262]

Flying dutchman

[@hausuandim1193]

Flying duch man

[@volkerspieler3060]

Flying Dutchman my Favourite ship

[@michaelkeaton5394]

The pearl it's the fastest and the last real pirates threat of the Caribbean...

[@danielcardoso20000]

I mean the thing about the Pearl is it’s history the Captains that used it and it was very powerful with the curse but when they don’t have the curse it’s nothing compared to the power of the Queen Anne’ Revenge or the Flying Dutchman there’s no comparison there the only things the Pearl can get a upper hand is with their man if they are more skilled in battle and that’s pretty much it other than being fast or the HMS Endeavour 110 cannons it’s a shame we didn’t get so see it’s power since it has so many cannons and talking about cannons the Flying Dutchman even has the front cannons for chasing ships so OP but yeah when it comes to fan favorite etc etc and my Favorite is the Pearl since is there since the beginning so it has a special place in my heart

[@michaelkeaton5394]

@@danielcardoso20000 but even without the curse it's still the fastest ship of the Caribbean, she can clearly distant the flying Dutchman, and if the QAR revenge got her it's probably by some kind of trap and not by purchasing it

[@josephdediesbach9994]

@@michaelkeaton5394 The black pearl is only faster than the flying dutchman as long as she has the wind in her back, otherwise the Flying Dutchman is faster

[@real_mushroom_hunter]

The kraken catches up anyways

[@nametime8938]

@@michaelkeaton5394 being fast doesn't make the pearl stronger, it just makes it good to sail for your life in

[@armandoidzerda7058]

My favourite ship: Black Pearl The coolest function: silent mary The biggest ship: queen anna's revenge The best and strongest ship: Flying Dutchman. My favourite captains: Jack Sparrow, Salazar and Will Turner

[@aftabjunaid1683]

And Barbosa Hector

[@mirry3498]

the silent mary is bigger than the queen annes revenge

[@jbeaup159]

@David AZ doesnt matter the pearl is the fastest and has the hardest curse to break out of all of them.

[@jbeaup159]

@David AZ doesn’t matter bro the pearl has the hardest curse to break. It’s a stalemate between pearl and silent Mary

[@jbeaup159]

@Infinity Op you’re* but ya I’m dumb lmaoo if u actually know what you’re gonna argue about speak up or don’t say nun at all

[@enclavehere.7995]

All I have to say is: “Let them taste the triple guns.”

[@real_mushroom_hunter]

The pearl pearl has a habbitat of strangely always finding a way to stay sailing the sea's, it can't die.

[@roigergoololo3966]

Oh, you mean the plot armour? In that case, the Pearl always wins.

[@Comet_373]

@@roigergoololo3966 lol

[@mihalyschneider9866]

Dutchman and silent mary cant die, the pearl can sink

[@typicalyoutubegamer3775]

Pearl never sunk the Dutchman the Dutchman revived the pearl and the Dutchman whas just destroying it easy

[@tomatornater6513]

The kraken beat the pearl but it cam back

[@ShubhamKalra-xm6jd]

Black Pearl A legend ship, No ship can catch it 🏴‍☠️🚢

[@jouzu2477]

Running from your opponents is not exactly winning

[@ДжонатанГонсалес]

Incorrect you are thinking of The Flying Dutchman

[@alistrong00]

and the flying duchman div down

[@keeganjohnson9151]

Your think of the Flying Dutchman

[@ma.angelicarodriguez2798]

No hes right but the queen could catch it

[@itsrainbowsteveplays]

"Nothing could stop the Silent Mary" but in all seriousness I’d say Pearl.

[@memewrld9117]

Pearl Here’s why Jack will win, I mean have you forgotten he Captain Jack Sparrow. And he’s already brought the pearl back three times. He loves it too much so he’ll never leave it behind, and he’ll bring it back. That leaves the Pearl the last one standing. Boom Oh the Dutchman can stay but only because Jack loves Will too much.

[@brotherbarbatos8981]

The Queen Anne’s Revenge is probably my favourite ship. But it’s really just a floating flamethrower. The whole rope tentacles thing wouldn’t be possible if Blackbeard didn’t have the Sovereign Sword. So the only supernatural thing about The Queen Anne’s Revenge is that it’s captain practices black magic and uses said magic to manipulate the ship.

[@Bako751]

I'm gonna get Hate for this. Queen Anne. Hear me out. So the Black Pearl is legendary and we all love her no doubt. But the ship it's self has no curse. The crew did. The Flying Dutchman and the Silent Mary are both indeed unsinkable, immortal ships you'd think would be locked in an epic battle for the rest of time? Yeah that's true. Now the Queen Anne's Revenge is another technically "mortal" ship, and can physically sink, however Black Beard can control not only the Queen Anne, but any ship he wants with the sword of Triton. He'd be able to take command of all three other ships, and if he wanted to, slap them in bottles and be done. People disregard Blackbeard because he's the non immortal one. But hell, there is a very valid reason in the movies he was even stated as the most feared pirate.

[@bluestingray8955]

The sword only works on mortal ships so the Dutchman and Mary are immune to it

[@Bako751]

@@bluestingray8955 interesting. Do you have a link to evidence? I never heard it was uneffective towards cursed ships. I'm pretty sure black beard had cursed ships in bottles though

[@korekcsaba8853]

Forgot the kraken, i mean if u count the sword then u have to cout that aswell. Neither is realy the part of the ship or both.

[@Bako751]

@@korekcsaba8853 would be part of the package. Also the sword would let Blackbeard take control of the Dutchman anyways thus the kraken would never be released. Never in the lore have I seen where it says the sword won't work on cursed ships, so I'm counting it lol

[@hausuandim1193]

@@Bako751 Salazar could just jump of the ship And walk all the way over to blackbeard on water And for davy jones He can teleport Which means he can teleport to black beard And in my opinion He is a lot more skilled in fighting Plus immortal

[@uncle5486]

The Dutchman would kick the asses of most of the other ships, except for maybe silent Mary, but I still think The Flying Dutchman would win against the silent Mary as well.

[@wyattschaffer2528]

The silent mary is by far the worst ship in the franchise

[@hharley5f594]

The Dutchman has the ability to bring the dead to afterlife BOOM.

[@anshumansingh9814]

Dutchman is the best ship and it has potential too win every battle , if the caption play it smartly

[@rewardunkind4541]

And the queen Ann’s will burn them

[@Mapbim]

@@wyattschaffer2528 I agree

[@Europechampion]

Who here want pirates of the Caribbean 6 all curses 1V1 and we will see the winner!!!

[@fengar4551]

I'd say: Davi Jones, because his heart is already gone. They can let him explode, but How?

[@doubledropking9979]

I wonder what they would do if they made a POTC6?

[@lolz_gamer3246]

@@doubledropking9979 some dumb shit, they say they might remove johnny depp as jack sparrow and maybe even a new female lead, they are screwing everything up

[@gingerkittenwithahat9836]

I do

[@kasperihankonen]

The Flying Dutchman would win, even without the Kraken. I will explain. The Black Pearl is no match for the Dutchman, even at the cursed state. The Black Pearl survived in the maelstrom fight against the Dutchman, yes, but only because Davy Jones was killed. If the fight would have last longer, the Dutchman would have won, and even if both ships have sunk into the maelstrom, the Dutchman would have won, as she repairs herself underwater, but the Pearl is not unsinkable. Also the Pearl's skeletons can be apart if they are exploded and the Dutchman's crew is more durable. The same goes with the Queen Anne's Revenge. The Revenge's deadliest weapon is the Greek fire. But if the Dutchman is set on fire, she submerges, repairs herself underwater, then resurfaces and destroys the damaged Revenge. Plus I don't think that Blackbeard's sword can affect on the technically undead ghost ship. Then it comes the Silent Mary. The Mary has the ability to crush the ships in half like bite it like a giant shark. But I don't think that she can crush the Flying Dutchman when she goes underwater. And also, the Silent Mary is already a dead ship with a dead crew and the Dutchman has the ability to ferry the dead souls to the afterlife.

[@thebossrealm]

I will say they are technically cursed and as we have seen the dutchman can’t break the curses.

[@picallo1]

You forget the Black Pearl while it was cursed had the same healing factor. Many times we saw it damaged only to be fully repaired shortly after. All of that being said, Queen Anne's revenge will ALWAYS win because BlackBeard can take control over your own ship, as Barbossa described. No crew can fight the QAV with BlackBeard sailing it.

[@duckzhunfis8950]

Black pearl is the fastest. It also has Jack and Barbossa the two clever and bravest captins there are. The Flying Dutchman has many cannons, and two great captins. The Flying Dutchman also has the kracken.

[@blah777]

Well in the second part kraken sucked the black Pearl with Jack sparroww sorry captain jack sparrow then in third part kraken was already dead and in end black Pearl won

[@Not-ElBarto]

@@blah777 Well the kraken only died cus of Lord Beckett

[@Not-ElBarto]

@@ruinnatione No I think that's the Dutchman, but yes the mary definitely has the most cannons

[@sparkodiaofficial1373]

@@Not-ElBarto Silent Mary has "CANNONS" at its front which no other Ships possess. - Very Great 👍👍👏Advantage. 💪💪💪

[@sparkodiaofficial1373]

@@Not-ElBarto Sorry! I'm wrong, it's no Silent Mary but ✈ Dutchman. 😓😓😓😞😞😞😞😥.

[@jakelaw3597]

Flying Dutchman

[@hurricanehusky287]

Jake Law Yes. I agree.

[@CaptainDavyJones_YT]

The Flying Dutchman would win all

[@Bako751]

Would tie with Silent Mary. Both are immortal and unsinkable

[@kasperihankonen]

Reasons why the Dutchman would win: 1. Davy Jones has the ability to break the curses of others and ferry the dead to the afterlife, and the Silent Mary, her crew and captain are the dead. 2. The Dutchman is unsinkable, she repairs herself underwater.

[@littleumbrella1763]

HMS Victory

[@velociraptorgod110]

@@kasperihankonen lol, sins when is Jones able to break curses? Did i miss something

[@jbeaup159]

@@kasperihankonen this is why the pearl would win: say we are in the timeline of the pearl in its prime with the undead curse. the Dutchman cant go on land and same for salazar. The pearl could just scatter the gold pieces and their curse would last longer they find the heart and kill davy. its between the Dutchman and the Pearl.

[@andymarino2371]

Strongest or not, i think Silent Mary along with the captain/crew has the most badass villain in all POTC

[@picallo1]

Personally thought it was kinda lame. Instead of zombies it was ghosts.................whoop dee doo. I love Salazars actor though.

[@TheBlueGrinchofSurgery]

@@picallo1 100%. The actor did a phenomenal job at playing him. But hey, their designs were pretty cool and so was the ship. Ofc, the story they made up was super lame tho.

[@lukeelijahchua8215]

The queen Anne's revenge is curse here is why have you ever seen a ship controlled by a sword

[@honixczen8644]

1. Flying duchman 2. Silent mary 3. Queen Anne s revenge 4. Black pearl

[@werreb7282]

Honzísek LP no

[@honixczen8644]

@@werreb7282 and how u mean that

[@werreb7282]

1 silent mary 2 flying duchman 3 black pearl 4 queen Anne revenge

[@honixczen8644]

I mean not cuz dutchman cant be sinked and black Pearl isnt better than revenge

[@honixczen8644]

Because blackbeard defeats pearl

[@TuxedoLipe]

i Guess it depends on which version of the ships were talking about, the pearl, while cursed, the Mary after it sunk would be just as immortal as the Dutchman, plus the Anne`s crew is in possession of one of the great treasures of the seas, which gives black beard control over not only his ship but also opponents ship, as we saw with the pearl, as such i must say that even if the other 3 ships are neigh indestructible/impossible to sink it wouldn't matter, since the Anne could just seize control and have the ship kill its own crew and then be placed into bottles.

[@yasuo9839]

You should remember that Davy John said The Dutchman only listen to its captain so the Triton sword cant control it I think The Dutchman will win

[@Raioh]

felipe galesi The sword of Triton does not work on other cursed ships, however against a cursed crew it can plow

[@typicalyoutubegamer3775]

The Dutchman is a ship black beard feared if he did not he would have gotten it before Jones came for jack or after but he did not because he could not control the ship that controls the sea

[@user-jr4pz5td2r]

But it says all curses are activated meaning the Dutchman still has control of the kraken so even the Mary could just be crushed to pieces the Dutchman wins

[@hakatapawa7115]

@@yasuo9839 Do you know who Triton is? if so how do you think anyone can go against the powers of an actual god?

[@KINGAMIT5]

Black Pearl ship is the best because his captain is best jake sparrow

[@timhuang2312]

Flying Dutchman for sure , but l like Silent Mary the most because I've never seen any other ships like this, this is the special one and I even have Silent Mary lego at home, it's a great decoration in my room!

[@theboogieman9352]

The pearl is unfortunately the first to go, if it’s taken as it is from the first movie, not so easily defeated. It’s the only ship faster than the Dutchman so keep that in mind (and with an immortal crew it’s pretty formidable). The queen annes revenge can shoot fire and has pretty crazy rigging, the black pearl lost because Blackbeard used his sword and turned the ship against the crew. The Silent Mary has a dead crew and can eat other ships, that’s about it. The Dutchman has a crew who can travel through things from one ship to the next, it’s the second fastest ship, it can go under water, apparently it can repair itself, and the kicker, it has the kraken. Final tally 4. The black pearl 3. The queen annes revenge 2. The silent Mary 1. The Flying Dutchman How the battle ensues The pearl lost to the QAR in the movies so same will apply here against all the ships. It’s fast but doesn’t have much else consider all crews in this situation are immortal. I doubt Blackbeard’s sword can take over a cursed ship and the flamethrowers don’t measure up to the other two remaining ships so it goes next. In a one on one the silent Mary loses and here’s why, if Davey Jones is smart (which he is) he would never let the silent Mary get close, and he can do that because after the pearl the Dutchman is he fastest ship. Other than being able to devour ships the silent Mary doesn’t measure up to the Dutchman in anyway. Even if it’s close (which it’s not) the Dutchman always has the kraken. I rest my case...

[@alvarezlany]

Smart, but what if the silent mary ate the Dutchman first. 🗿

[@aviationlba747]

1. Flying Dutchman 2. Silent Mary (cursed) 3. Queen Anne’s Revenge (w/Sword of Triton) 4. Black Pearl

[@christianpanchorivera9765]

Don't you dare to forget the curse of the black pearl, mate

[@captainwing5218]

The pearl can still be sunk as the crew is cursed not the ship

[@ZoSo_x]

It's a damn shame we'll never get to see all 4 of these ships on screen at the same time, but we were fortunate enough to see both The Black Pearl and Flying Dutchman battle it out and team up in the 3rd movie. The Black Pearl is my favorite ship 🙌

[@jherman6132]

Silent Mary be like- “crunchy crunchy floating cookies”

[@jherman6132]

@الجيلالي من عهد الكوازاكي agreed

[@allusive2903]

OM NOM NOM NOM NOM!!! all jokes aside shes my favorite too.

[@minecraftycraft2787]

You made my day hahaha

[@mohammadahmadrocks]

A battle is won not by the might of ship but by it's captain .... and jack is the most badass captain.. so winner is BLACKPEARL !!SAVVY

[@Mapbim]

The Flying Dutchman wins by far. It can hide underwater, it can summon the kraken, it has triple cannons, it can repair itself and it could beat every ship, even the cursed ones.

[@tahmeedansari4226]

When did the flying dutchman repair itself?

[@herewegoagain-d7n]

1-Flying Dutchman strength:-56 cannon(variable weights)+mutant crew+submarine ability+nearly indestructible+ kraken 2-Black Pearl strength:-32 cannons + "SPEED" +long oars+ Captain Jack Sparrow 3-Silent Mary Strength:-Opening mouth+100 cannons+ghost crew+killer mast head+resistence 4-Queen Anne's revenge strength-30 cannons+zombie crew + Greek fire+ sword of triton

[@mishaeledwincruz7789]

the flying dutchman only has 46 cannons

[@lukeelijahchua8215]

Silent Mary goes above Dutchman arrives from underwater Black Pearl comes front the fog full speed

[@nathanquinn7053]

Black Pearl, The Flying Dutchman, and Silent Mary win Black Pearl: immortal crew, unsinkable (remember... He said that it's the cursed version) Silent Mary: immortal crew, unsinkable The Flying Dutchman: immortal crew, unsinkable

[@captainmurph1463]

Dude you can sink the Pearl it's a normal ship but not a normal crew Blackbeard isn't normal neither is his ship really cause it has the fire at the front and he uses the ropes as snake and he has a magical sword Dutchman will win for sure

[@Poly-vo7st]

And you can kill Jones crew just watch third movie

[@Comet_373]

@@captainmurph1463 the whole rope snake thing is because of the sword which isnt part of the ship so I dont think it should be included and the fire is useless agasint the Mary dutchman and perl becussr all crews are immortal and the ships are unsinkable

[@Comet_373]

If even it wasnt cursed version of the pearl, it's still the fastest ship that has some leeway right ?

[@captainmurph1463]

@@Comet_373 this was 3 months ago

[@userWCFL]

1. Silent mary 2. Flying dutchman 3. Black pearl 4 queen Anne's revenge This is just my opinion

[@DingleDangle66]

Your opinion doesn’t make sense for the Revenge being last, as the Revenge took control of the Pearl.

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAINS OF THE BLACK PEARL: MARIO & ORIGINAL BOWSER

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAINS OF THE QUEEN ANNE'S REVENGE: DARK BOWSER & DARK STAR

[@felixmariobros5198]

CAPTAIN OF THE SILENT MARY: KING BOO

[@realta721]

Black pearl's abilitys : fastest pirate ship and got oars for helping Flying dutchman's abilitys : have the kraken, can go underwater and have triple front canons Queen anne's revenge's abilitys : crash fire , have a sword to control him and capture other ships Silent mary's abilitys : have ghost sharks, have canons towers, can go over the other ships and cut them , have figurehead alive

[@joosecreations]

I want to see a huge spin off battle like the one at the end of POTC 3 - The Black Pearl with Immortal Skeleton Crew + immense speed, The Queen Anne’s Revenge with Flamethrower + Blackbeard and his sword, The Flying Dutchman with Underwater travel + huge cursed sea creature crew, The Silent Mary with cursed crew + huge mouth and zombie sharks as pets.

[@Kuba25088]

Don't forget the Kraken.

[@snemelc270]

The Flying Dutchman wins. Because: It is immune to fire and the Silents Mary „crush attack“ if it goes underwater.

[@c.stegenga607]

The video is only counting the ship

[@user-uo8mx3cv5k]

@@c.stegenga607 all of what he said is a part of the ship's ability, what are you talking about?

[@c.stegenga607]

j. There was a comment above me that was talking about the crew

[@drdevil2833]

Buddy its take at least 30 seconds for the Dutchmen to fully submerge and for the mary it only take 5 seconds to close that jaw with gravity I've done my homework

[@luanlinhares1707]

@@drdevil2833 if the dutchman gets sunk,it ll repair itself with the water,so it would be still good to fight,also the ship can summon and control de kraken

[@memebigboi5330]

One runs away. The other is fucked. And the last 2 are fighting for eternity

[@ekerslithery5955]

Let me guess: black pearl runs away, Queen Anne’s Revenge is sunk, Dutchman and Silent Mary fight for eternity

[@zuned9730]

Flying Dutchman is the father of all ships

[@2103ADI]

Black pearl,Flying Dutchman and Queen Anne's revenge are my favourites and same with their pirates so I will support them

[@danielteisner4567]

1.Flying Dutchman and Davy Jones 2.Silent Mary 3. Queen Annes Revenge 4. Black Pearl

[@4dc229]

Flying Dutchman and Davy jones or Will Turner

[@baconskistudiostm7981]

I’d rather change your list 1. Flying Dutchman 2. Silent Mary 3. Black pearl 4. Queen Annes Revenge

[@blackhole3963]

Each ship has its own advantage: Black pearl - it's speed Silent Mary - it's ability to crush ships Flying Dutchman - the ability to go underwater Queen Anne's revenge - idk

[@somethingsaucy1776]

nelson sy the queen annes revenge shoots fire from the skeletons on the front

[@squegy349]

The flying dutchman's advantage isnt that it can gi underwater, it's that it can't be sunk.

[@corinnehemish5788]

The Queen anne's has the same firepower as the black pearl (The Queen anne's Beat the Pearl between the ending of the 3rd and beginig of the 4th movie ) The only way the revenge can win is by putting the Dutchman, Mary, and Pearl, In a Bottle

[@MISTERX_5890]

The silent Mary is just as fast as the pearl

[@Mapbim]

Flying dutchman would win I am 100% sure

[@barathrum3107]

I'm telling you! The Black Pearl with torn sails is the sickest design a ship can have. It looked cursed, damned, dangerous, evil. And at the same time it looked beautiful.

[@mdib2001]

Flying Dutchman : "let them taste the triple guns" Queen Anne's Revenge : "Operates by a sword" Silent Mary : "Zombie Sharks" Black Pearl : "Fastest ship in the world"

[@MISTERX_5890]

Wrong in 5 the silent Mary and the British ship catch up to the pearl and the Dutchman is faster underwater

[@mdib2001]

@@MISTERX_5890 with the wind black pearl is unbeatable And don't slip that underwater concept, its only acceptable for the Dutchman

[@captainwing5218]

@@mdib2001 he can slip it in as it's still valid, in the maelstrom the Dutch man was gaining onto the pearl and even if the pearl were to 'zoom away' then Jones would have ordered to summon the kraken.

[@Lasha-Zasokhashvili]

Black pearl fans like here

[@ธนาแก้วสุวรรณ510เลขที่12]

Black pearl : speed tech Flying Dutchman : ultimate war machine - submarine tech Queen ans revenge : cyborg automatic flame thrower tech Silent mary : supreme predator Grinder tech

[@Unknown-nx7hg]

What if Will turner fighted the Silent Mary with the Flying Dutchman?!🤭

[@carterman1025]

Fought*

[@Dylan-yn8sm]

Death

[@julienpreil842]

It would be the best film ever

[@infinitybattlegrounds0206]

@@julienpreil842 true ❣️✨

[@nikitaheredia416]

The Flying Dutchman wins, it has powerful cannons and goes underwater. Not even the Black Pearl under her cursed state could do that.

[@NoCommunism]

Blackbeard : have a magic Sword Bardossa : is a Skeleton Salazar : is a Zombie Davy Jones : IS THE SEA. Davy Jones win.

[@marzenamachnik9763]

Salazar is correctly a ghost but your correct that Davy Jones will win.

[@lukastanojevic4502]

Also Davy: Where did i put mah kraken?

[@mukkamm6352]

And also Jack sparrow: is a legend

[@dhardesh]

Ahhh yes blackboard

[@dhardesh]

And of course bardossa feared writer of songs

[@adheeshkaushika6259]

I like black pearl and flyng dutchman but black pearl is fast and super cannons flyng dutchman is super cannons dut win black pearl

[@amateurapple]

So here how it would go (Since the curses are involved, I would also take the Kraken on the Dutchman's side, but it wouldn't matter anyway).Queen Anne's Revenge tries destroying the Black Pearl, but it's no match in speed. The Silent Mary comes from behind and eats it(Flamethrower can't work rip). Unfortunately, the Mary is faster than the Pearl(It's a ghost ship, so it can do that), and so it catches up, only for the Dutchman to come out of the water underneath the Mary and rips it. The Dutchman's only chance of beating the Pearl is if the wind is against the ships(The pearl is the fastest with the wind and the Dutchman is the fastest against it), or with the Kraken. If the wind doesn't change, remember the Dutchman can go underwater and ambush the Pearl. Oh and the Dutchman is the only one that can repair itself and can't sink. The Dutchman will eventually win in any case

[@picallo1]

You forget BB simply can take control of the Silent Mary or the Pearl or the Dutchman at any point. Meaning your explanation falls apart immediately. Barbossa described it when the Pearl turned against them. QAV will win. Kinda sucks but is what it is.

[@aegon4047]

Well there will only be one true winner Imagine this fight in your heads The black pearl and the queen annes revenge will have to team up against the dutchman and the mary While the 2 non immortal ships plan The 2 immortal ships fight Salazar makes his ship rise up But davy makes his ship go down So now its 2 against 1 Blackbeard shoots fire While jack and barbossa fire cannons The silent mary takes a little bit of damage but then giant tentacles rise up grabbing it and pulling it to the depths where it belongs So now its the dutchman against the pearl and the revenge The dutchman fires at the revenge While jack and barbossa try and counter but the kraken grabs their ship and drags it back to the depths of the sea After some hours later the revenge finnaly falls Leaving the dutchman the true winner

[@cmphotography8977]

Kraken is dead

[@citir3]

True kraken dead

[@captainwing5218]

@Forji Gaming so? They are all pirates, they always cheat in a battle to win

[@captainwing5218]

@@citir3 that would means that the curse of the pearl is broken which means that the Black pearl would lose

[@vernnax4290]

This all depends on the time this would take place, Would the Kraken still be alive? Remember just because we're at the 5th movie does not mean I takes place after the 5th movie, This is a alternate timeline.

[@velusamy9419]

The legand BLACK PEARL🚢⛵⚓🔱🔥

[@v.igowtham2395]

Black perl and flying dutch man the power full ship

[@Ties420]

The flying dutchman here’s why…… The flying dutchman goes above the black pearl Same for the queen annes revenge Because of the kraken. For the other two The black pearl can set sail away so thats the hardest task But the dutchman can still pull up a kraken the silent mary can kill the kraken but eventually the dutchman is faster so here you have it

[@noahalexewell5190]

the pearl would beat the Dutchman she's the only ship that can outrun it

[@Ties420]

@@noahalexewell5190 true

[@someonesaucy9937]

I love the black pearl, its a cool ship, but we can all agree that the flying Dutch men is the winner

[@kentorobbins7850]

I think it might not be that easy. The Pearl lost to the Queen Anns Revenge in the 4th part by beeing trapped in one of Blackbeards glasses. So why doesnt he do it to the Dutchmen? And since Davy Jhonnes isnt there anymore the kraken would be free.

[@Kuba25088]

@@kentorobbins7850 1: The kraken died. 2: Davy Jones returned. 3: Blackbeard wouldn't have a chance since the Dutchman crew could easily destroy him

[@harry176]

It’s the Dutchmen. It can go toe to toe with even the LARGEST battleship with its canons, it’s crew cannot die, it can summon the kraken. AND go under water

[@jackthegermanshepherd8499]

But black pearl already defeats ..Dutch man

[@Reichthoff]

By largest battleship you mean?

[@georgeafg9252]

@@jackthegermanshepherd8499 When did the Black Pearl defeat the Flying Dutchman? You mean on their ONLY fight where Calypso evened the playing field for both of them in the Maelstrom the goddess created? If you think the Flying Dutchman was defeated for the reason that it was swallowed by the maelstrom... Then it seems like your perception of the fight could use some adjustment. Davy Jones was defeated by getting his heart stabbed, yes. But the Flying Dutchman itself did not lose the fight. The ship itself literally has a high repairing factor making it nearly invincible to be able to tank the inmense pressure, the intense water currents, and abuse of the maelstrom after being swallowed by it. And it still managed to get out of the intense currents, and resurface with minor damages here and there after going through all of that. Even with the crew, and Captain Turner apparently intact. I would even go as far as to say that it's frame and most of it's husk is extremely durable. The Pearl itself pulled out of the fight after they had gotten deep enough to the point where both ships were almost at risk of being swallowed by the maelstrom, right after they had killed Jones. It would of pulled out much earlier during the battle, if the Dutchman didn't keep it there unintentionally when both ships got stuck through the yardsails from their main masts. If both ships had gone into the maelstrom, it is more than certain that the only ship to be able to handle the intense pressure of the maelstrom currents without getting destroyed, get out of those currents, and resurface with it's crew intact would be the Flying Dutchman just like how it was shown at the climax of the third movie. However, if the Black Pearl were swallowed by the maelstrom, the pressure and the intense currents would rip it to shreds, and the crew would be crushed after the maelstrom swallowed them deeper and deeper until it reached the breach of the maelstrom. There is a reason why no ship wanted to battle the Flying Dutchman. The ship is literally invincible with it's extremely high healing factor! That was the main reason why a fleet Armada of 300 ships from the EITC which hugely outnumbered the Pirate Armada, retreated right away after realizing the Flying Dutchman was no longer under Becketts control and was now fighting against the EITC. Just sayin'...

[@kasperihankonen]

@@georgeafg9252 you are right, the Black Pearl technically defeated the Flying Dutchman. If there wouldn't the maelstrom and Davy Jones's heart, then the Dutchman would have won.

[@werieawesome8530]

Harry you are right because if you veat the crew and the captain you beat the ship🤷‍♂️

[@Memecheckpoint]

Black Pearl beacuse there is no ship that can catch her

[@willemboele2079]

you can, iddono... SHOOT IT

[@valentinkambushev4968]

You know that the pearl was captured by The black beard.

[@DmonicHollow]

Valentin Kambushev they were ambushed that’s why remember there was no warning or even an ounce of parley as said by Barbossa himself

[@valentinkambushev4968]

How can someone be ambushed at tho open sea?

[@DmonicHollow]

Valentin Kambushev the hell do you mean how can you be ambushed at sea you think it’s fucking clear skies and nice weather 24/7 at sea

[@ronaldsan2667]

Seems like silent Mary might be faster than the Pearl. They were able to catch the Black Pearl even after sinking that British ship.

[@sharibashah1706]

You cant beat the flying Dutchmen

[@gingerkittenwithahat9836]

Nor the silent mary

[@resthav0894]

I'm so obsessed with ships after watching potc

[@UchihaMadara70]

The BLACK PEARL SHIP win because it has CAPTAIN JACK SPARROW.

[@captainwing5218]

That makes no sense, just because a ship has a main character doesn't mean that the character will win the fight, or survive for this matter

[@mariorosario1323]

Jack will find a way to win

[@Zio_1939]

the black pearl is better because in a film they say it is the only one capable of plucking the flying Dutchman. so the Pearl is the best

[@drw_predator]

"Flying Dutchman" will always come out of water in the end of all battles, with curse only Since all cures have been broken in POTC 5, now it's even match between Queen Anne's revenge

[@meltemkul604]

tia dalma : I cannot say. There is an evil on these seas that even the most staunch and bloodthirsty pirates have come to fear ---> dutchman

[@CaptaIn_JS1]

meltem kul best comment!

[@michaelamancio4971]

thats gotta be the best pirate i ever seen

[@christianjudeberbano7613]

So it would seem

[@movinduperera1255]

but a pirates greatest fear is salazar

[@saradoka4539]

Black Pearl yaaaay!! 😄👻👻

[@whoami9586]

Black pearl ...because in the movie even they said that black pearl is the only ship from which davy jones is afraid of

[@YukiXKohaku]

Davy Jones tried to sink the Black Pearl in Dead Man's Chest, the Black Pearl managed to escape because of it's speed. But later on it was destroyed by the Kraken. Jack dies and the ship sank. They were later rescued though. And I don't think Davy scared at all from what I've seen.

[@whoami9586]

@@YukiXKohaku I think u just believe on visuals....check once again ..when they capture shao fins boat ....after that

[@georgeafg9252]

They never mention in any of the films that Davy Jones was afraid of the Black Pearl. If he were afraid of the Black Pearl, then why would he make a deal with Jack and resurface it after it was sunk 13 years before the events of the second film? What they say about the Black Pearl is that it is the ONLY ship to OUTRUN the Flying Dutchman. And just like Mr. Gibbs mentions in the second film when they are being chased by the flying Dutchman before battling the Kraken, going against the wind the Dutchman would catch the Pearl, but going in the direction of the wind, the Black Pearl outruns the Dutchman.

[@YukiXKohaku]

@@georgeafg9252 Exactly, Dutchman can sink the Pearl with ease.

[@tommytommy7535]

the pearl is the fastest , so she will just run away forever :D

[@Maxoelgoat]

Mary is faster

[@Maxoelgoat]

@Abhijit Pathak yes way faster, have you watches the movie

[@kyrohehe2555]

tommy tommy a ship is a she...

[@britishsoldier1585]

so how did the revenge take then

[@captainwing5218]

The Dutch man can gain easily on the pearl but if they still got away then Jones would summon the kraken. Common sense if you have watched the movies

[@madhuchhandamondal544]

BLACK PEARL WILL WIN BECAUSE IT HAD FOUGHT WITH ALL THE OTHER THREE SHIPS . THOUGH ONCE IT WAS CAUGHT IN A BOTTLE IN THE SHIP OF ANGELICA BUT , IN PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN ( DEAD MAM TELLS NO TALES ) IT HAD FOUGHT WITH SALAZZAR'S SHIP AND ALSO LASTED TILL THE END , AND IN PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN ( AT WORLD'S END ) IN THE LAST WAR BETWEEN FLYING DUTCHMAN AND BLACK PEARL , BLACK PEARL HAD SUNK FLYING DUTCHMAN UNDER WATER AND THEN WILL TURNNER HAD BECOME THE CAPTAIN OF FLYING DUTCHMAN . MORE OVER SALAZZAR'S SHIP COULD HAVE DESTROYED THE SHIP WHICH ANGELICA HAD SAIL AT ONCE , IF BARBOSSA DID NOT REQUEST . HENCE , BLACK PEARL SHIP WILL WIN IN ALL THE BATTLES .😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀

[@biswanathmondal3668]

I AGREE WITH YOU .

[@biswanathmondal8015]

I AGREE WITH YOU

[@ussr6642]

flying dutchman

[@Yetasolipyeay]

To me flying Dutchman is gonna win! There is like hundreds of cannons! THERE IS ALSO GATLING CANNONS!!!!

[@chrisigoeb]

Actually the flying dutchman doesn't have that many canons. Its a dutch flyeut with like 50 canons. Yet its gonna win since well its cursed to be unkillable

[@4shura__shura]

The Dutchman has around 50 cannons, even the Silent Mary has much more. But both are unsinkable so there is only a stalemate

[@Broxy93]

@@4shura__shura the mary has no canons since its cursed, but it is unsinkable. howEver, the dutchman takes the cake. even the silent mary cant take triple guns

[@darknerd8332]

Either Dutchman or the Mary. From the movies i think the Mary is more durable and I dont think cannons will destroy her nor the dutchaman. Plus if the kraken finally sinks the mary and the crews fight each other, im pretty sure Salazar's crew is going to win because they are literall ghosts unlike Jone's crew who have encrusted skin and barnecles for armour. But also,lets say the kraken isnt included cuz it was forced to be killed by Jones,like in the actual movies. The dutchman will probably be focused on fighting other ships either The pearl or the Revenge. If the dutchman is battling other ships, the Mary could sneak up behind or beside them and do her eating ships ability. My conclusion: The dutchman and the Mary will be equal victors

[@darknerd8332]

Wait i just saw the clips again. The Mary did not catch fire, break pieces off, or even did not break the stern mast of. So i think The Silent Mary will be the victor