ScanNCut vs Silhouette vs Cricut: Which Machine is Right for You?

[@shystrohl9018]

I want the one that doesn’t keep charging you to use it after paying hundreds to own it..

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

If only ... Lol.

[@sonshinesunflower]

THIS!!!!!! @Shy Strohl

[@cocoscabana]

SCAN N Cut is the way to go...no subscriptions

[@djb570]

No kidding.

[@djb570]

We do not need general info. We need the detail because you can't find it.

[@kenm2679]

Something as an FYI on the Brother Scan and Cut that I started using for a Makerspace is the that if you have sheets of paper models (2d to 3d) that you want cut, I found the scanning and then the cutting feature saves a lot of student time. So, for example, a paper tiger which has a lot of folds and cuts, that would take 3 hours, the kids can cut that time down to about an hour and change by using the scan and cut. The machine looks the the paper, and then gives you options on how to cut it, so it does a pretty nice job doing all the cutting in minutes. Pretty awesome! It's also great in making sticker stuff. Find a design and scan it in and then cut it out with various borders (or no borders). Incredible.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

What a great suggestion about scanning in paper models. Not something I've used it for but I have no doubt it is a serious timesaver! I also agree that nothing beats the scanner for stamped images, sticker images, etc. and then easily adding an offset (or not) and cutting them out. As I mentioned in the video, if you are going to use the scanner, the ScanNCut is the machine for you!

[@midgetsmommy]

One thing I think you could have mentioned is, with Cricut, if your internet is down your machine is useless. You are also up a creek once they make your machine obsolete as they have done in the past, by not keeping the software/program available. At least with Scan-n-cut you can use it free standing as long as the machine is good. With Cameo, the program resides in your computer, so as long as you have a operating system that will run your software, your machine is usable.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Excellent points that I missed. Thanks!

[@huyked]

That is lousy of Cricut to do. Wow! Forget it then. They won't have my business just for that reason. With that business model, you aren't really buying something to actually own. You're basically renting until their service is obsolete. Ridiculous. No thanks. Thank YOU for bringing that point to light.

[@alphasxsignal]

@@huyked That is to bad they do that at Cricut.

[@justinashley7616]

i just googled using cricut without internet. did they change this or something, because im seeing that as long as your designs are on your pc, you can still use the machine. i dont have one, im shopping around now so i dont know for sure, but literally everything im seeing is saying u can use cricut without internet

[@imadish5356]

Frankly, I've never had to try it offline as DS doesn't go down very often. BUT if your internet connection is iffy, forget it. Go with a Cameo FOR SURE! I've got so much sunk into my Cricut Maker it's difficult to back out now, but I am doing it. The biggest negative for me is their proprietary approach --you can't export YOUR OWN projects or creations out of DS. It stays there, and only there. Who does that these days? Nobody but Cricut. I now use Silhouette's biz software to create my cutting projects and export them to my computer for safe-keeping and to use on my Cricut. ($50 forever license on sale.) DS has corrupted/choked on more than a few of my projects so I don't trust it anymore. If you only use projects and images etc out of DS, you're fine. But if you create your own designs -get the Silhouette software. I do prefer Cricut's ease-of-use for cutting, but I'm getting better at my Cameo so I'm using that more and more. Cricut is a great starter, but I'm pretty sure you'll move on to a Silhouette Cameo if you stick with the craft. Good luck!

[@LilStampBug]

I have all 3 and in my opinion the ScanNCut is the best one... keep in mind I'm a Cardmaker so i use it alot to scan my stamped images and cut them out. But it can also do everything the Cameo and Cricut can...and it also works without the internet 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 it is pricey but i feel its worth every single penny 🥰🥰🥰 and definitely is quieter than the other 2. Ok, there's my 2 cents ;) thanks for posting this video 🤗🤗🤗

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I agree that if you are going to use the scanner, there is nothing like the ScanNCut. Totally worth the price for stampers to cut out images. It's a very high quality machine!

[@neroliash2968]

i only have a scan n cut and bought it for scanning stamped images and cut. love it

[@JCcreates927]

And on top of that they do have the free designs online if you have access, no store to buy designs on.

[@marvelenia6702]

May I please ask you which machine is the best for cutting stencils, like sturdy vinyl? I am not sure which of the 3 would be best for that...

[@debbiewhite3270]

@@marvelenia6702 I have the Scan n Cut and it cuts stencils beautifully. I don't know about the others.

[@GKPortugal]

Thank you. I've watch some videos about these machines and you were probably the most objective and clear host of them all. 🙏

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thank you very much. I try my best to remain objective so I'm glad you found it helpful.

[@judyevans9884]

Thank you for taking the trouble to compare all these machines, I have enjoyed finding out the differences between them and can see that different machines would really suit different types of crafters. I have a ScanNCut for all the reasons you mentioned and find the scanner an absolute marvel - anything you can draw or find a picture of, you can cut and being able to cut out stamped images without dies is fantastic. You mentioned as a negative, that the ScanNCut cuts the outside of your pattern first, if that is the case, you just need to reorder them in the programme layers and it will cease to be a problem, you can choose which parts the machine cuts out first very easily (thank you YoutTube). Thank you again for your great comparisons.👍👍

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks Judy! I know if you reorder items on separate layers in Canvas Workspace it will cut things out in that order, but what if the design is all on one layer? For example, I have a card front design that has intricate cuts in the middle with a rectangular border around the outside that is all on one layer in Canvas Workspace. Is there a way to get the machine to cut the inside of that single layer first instead of the rectangular border? If so, I haven't been able to figure it out and would love some guidance if you know a solution. That's the kind of thing I was talking about in the video. Thanks again. - Elena

[@judyevans9884]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts hi Elena, thank you for replying, I can see what you seem! I am not really an expert at all, but have been trying to figure things out (which as you know can be very time consuming), as I have come across some tricky files too! This might be a very long winded solution, so it depends on how much time you can spare, but I think I would import the file, duplicate it a few times, then select one and divide it, remove the middle bit (using the nodes delete to get rid of any odd little bits that also need removing) and then weld that outer bit all together. I would then use one of the duplicates to remove the outer bit (either using a square to delete the overlap each side, or using the long winded divide and re-weld option). Now you have two separate pieces, I would then place the inner piece inside the outer piece, Centre and group, making sure the right one is the top layer in the layers section on the right of Canvass WS and then cut. Gosh! Sorry that reads in a very complicated way. I am away abroad for a while, but if you can send me a pic of your file, I could have a look and see if here is another way I would go. Loved your video and so pleased to be part of a craft that loves to share ideas and help each other. All the best, Judy

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

@@judyevans9884 Wow! Thanks for the detailed explanation on what to do in that situation. To be honest, that is way more work than I'm willing to do hence why I view the cutting order on the ScanNCut in this instance as a negative for me since my other machines don't cut those types of layers that way. But, I'm very blessed to have access to more than one type of machine. I really appreciate your help. Enjoy your trip!!

[@Obsidian_Iris_]

This was very helpful, thank you! I had originally considered getting a Cricut but I remember there was a huge brouhaha about either charging for the design space when it was supposed to be free or maybe taking popular features from the free tier and moving them to the paid tier. Whatever it was, the accusation was they were being mercenary with the design space and had broken a promise, even if the promise was implied. I’m one of the people who doesn’t like buying dies for every stamp set I purchase and neither computers nor software intimidate me so I was considering the ScanNCut. I honestly don’t like the number of additional accessories that go with the Cricut. I know I don’t have to buy them all but there are some products that appear to have been created strictly as a vehicle for an unending number of consumables that could have been made a part of the machine. As an example, why does the Cricut need so many different blades when the ScanNCut needs only it’s one factory installed blade to cut different materials (except vinyl if I remember you correctly. I think you said you had to buy a $60 vinyl blade for either the ScanNCut or the Silhouette). I understand things like foil and vinyl, but not tools like blades. As for pens, I wonder which would be most economical; an ink head and ink cartridges or pens. Since the cartridges allow for an almost unending array of colors, I would thing the pens potentially cost more when factoring in creative possibilities.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Honestly, most of the machines have a bunch of extras you can buy. Even ScanNCut has extra tools for embossing, a rotary blade and thin fabric blade for fabrics, the vinyl autoblade, several different mats and two types of pen holders and more plus third-party accessories for foiling and engraving (as you know). Silhouette has as many add-ons too - knife blade, rotary blade, pens, pen holders, mats, etc. so I think all of these manufacturers are guilty of banking on added extras. But I understand where you're coming from on that. There is a lot of extra "stuff' that you have to buy to get the most out of any of these machines. In terms of the pens, I'm not sure you need a lot of different pens for any of these machines unless you intend to go to the extra effort to have the machine fill in the letters or shapes you're drawing with the machine. Basic colors like black and gold seem to work pretty well for me for outlining. Then I just hand color in whatever outline was drawn by the machine with other markers I already own. Not sure what you are referring to with an ink head and ink cartridges - a printer? something else?

[@revann33]

Thank you. You just sealed the deal on the Brother for me. All my sewing machines are Brother and I have had my eye on a Scan n Cut, but all these Cricut owners have been telling me I was wrong. I do a lot of leather work, and for what I want to do, the Brother will be perfect!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I'm glad I could help. Have fun creating with your ScanNCut!

[@birdinagy660]

Has the Scan and Cut worked well for your leather? I'm considering getting one for this purpose too!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I have cut thinner leather with the ScanNCut and not had any problems. But, Ann J will know more since it sounds like she works with leather much more regularly than I do.

[@revann33]

@@birdinagy660 I have only cut oil tan so far and it has worked great! Just be careful to watch how deep the blade thinks it needs to cut. the first time I had to stop mine so it didn't cut through my mat. I am currently trying to figure out a way to tool veg tan...LOL

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

Go with whatever machine you need think suits you best. I have a Cricut Maker but I just bought a Silhouette Cameo 4. I needed a second machine because of doing a lot of stuff and I wanted to try something else.

[@alothaiqi]

I bought ScanNcut I feel it is suitable for my work style

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Glad the ScanNCut is working for you!

[@inkshop963]

I went with the Scan and Cut, older model the CM650, hoping it does the half cut for vinyl. Though I'd imagine you can just manually change the pressure. I got this for stickers and business cards. I have a 36" plotter/cutter but this seems like a better fit for smaller jobs, easier for set up, can be on a desk, and I love the scan and cut feature. I want to get into customer stickers and this affordably does that. Plus I can now easily make up shirts as well. I also want to try it for paper art projects. Like paper cutting projects.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

It sounds like you made a wise choice for how you want to use the machine. I'm pretty sure the older CM models don't have the half cut setting, but like you said, you can manually adjust the pressure. Have fun with it!

[@debbiewhite3270]

TY for an excellent video. I have the SnC and love it. I had to learn the basics of Cricut to help a friend learn hers. I really liked it but didn't like that we couldn't swap designs. I used my SnC to scan my designs and created svg's to give her to use. Unfortunately, not the other way around. I have cut fabric, cardstock, leather, vinyl and felt. Felt was a mess and I will not do that again. There are more videos to learn the SnC now. AllBrands has broad lessons and Power Tools with Thread focuses on the fabric. I have the rhinestone kit and want to learn that next.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I agree the ScanNCut videos and resources are increasing. Yay! Since Canvas Workspace or even just the machine itself doesn't let you save SVGs out of it, how are you doing it? Do you use a program to change the CWPRJ file or FCM file to SVG? I'd love more info.

[@debbiewhite3270]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts I do now. I bought Embrilliance and I can bring in a vector graphic which is what Snc & Cricut create. When I save it there, it converts to an svg , a working file and a stitch file.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

@@debbiewhite3270 Thanks! That is great info.

[@cookiessewingstudio]

Thank you for a great review. Scan and cut is a good complement for machine embroidery applique cuts and quilters. The mats have a code on them that is not recognized sometimes but there's a workaround. I also own the Maker and only use my ScanNcut for my sewing projects.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I've always heard that the ScanNCut was great for sewers and quilters. I'm not one myself but I'm glad to hear the rumors are true. Lol!

[@RenataBka]

Great video! one of the best comparisons by far. Thank you

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks so much! I hope it helped.

[@Askcyeda]

Many thanks - the ScanN… is the best for me - a machine I didn’t even existed before watching your video-again many thanks!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

That is fantastic and I'm so happy to hear that I helped you discover it. Have fun with it!!

[@jacquibain6821]

I won a maker 3 so learning how to do it

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Wow! Lucky you! What a great thing to start learning about. It can seem overwhelming at first, but it's so fun. Enjoy!

[@jacquibain6821]

I’m trying I have made a pattern on a teeshirt so far for my grandson

[@JazzyJae88]

I have had the Cricut Maker for the last 2 years and recently got the Silhouette Cameo 4. Silhouette software is something. It’s like design space on steroids. Cricut is very user friendly. Anyone who can turn on a computer can use it. But Silhouette? You need at least a degree in computer science to use this program with ease. I’m forcing myself to only use my Silhouette so I can learn the functions. Last week I used it to cut circles for a project I was doing. Circles!! All so I could practice Silhouette Studio.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Yes, depending on your techy experience/knowledge that is a good or bad thing about Silhouette Studio. It is NOT easy to learn or intuitive at all unless you have previous experience with programs like Photoshop or Illustrator (also not intuitive or easy). Even then there is a serious learning curve. But, it is very powerful because of that and can do lots of things. Good for you for taking it slow and learning just the basics one step at a time. I agree that Cricut is much easier to use right out of the box but Design Space has its limitations. They are regularly improving it though so who knows where it may be one day.

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

I just bought the Cameo 4. I’m going to sit down and learn their system. I have the Cricut Maker and Joy. Unfortunately, my machine will not calibrate the way I need it to. I just needed another machine because of the amount of stuff that I do.

[@JazzyJae88]

@nicolejones3654 I will say using the Cricut with an iPhone is limiting. You won’t get to use all the features.

[@JazzyJae88]

@@arleneaugustahair8393 I have the Maker and the Joy too. I have no used calibrating so that sucks this is happening to you. I hope you enjoy the Silhouette Cameo. I love mine so far.

[@rosegriseto3282]

I have only own silhouette, and I downloaded design space and found it so confusing. I find silhouette so much easier. So I think it's all in what we are used to. Learn the program it is amazing what it can do. I am still learning after 4 years. I will also learn design space so I know both. I see Ciruit as an iPhone and silhouette as an Android. I am an Android person.

[@vampiregoat69]

I have the explore air 2 after seeing the Brother it makes me want to get one instead. The brother is 400+ if you want more things with it and cost goes WAAAAY up

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Yes, the ScanNCut can get pricey. There are models that are over $1K. But, if you'll use the scanner, it can be worth it - especially the lower end models that are similar in price to the Maker 3 and Cameo 5. But, it totally depends on how you'd use it.

[@lisaforbes7325]

I hadn't heard of ScanNCut sp.? until today so thank you.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Well, I'm happy to introduce you to it. It's a cool machine if you need a scanner for your crafts!

[@dianezimmerman1979]

The Scan N cut is the best value! The scanner is the absolute best! You can save files to a USB or wireless. Many softwares will save as .fcm or .SVG and it reads both. Well worth the money. AND IT'S QUIET!! 😊

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I also love the ScanNCut! It is by far the quietest machine. Glad you love yours.

[@tradnux5848]

Great job on breaking down pros and cons of these cutting machines. I think I am happy with my Cricut Maker 3, my issues with it is while you can use the software fine without subscription, the full freedom of customization requires knowledge of 3rd party software for editing SVGs to import whichever fonts you want to use and of course design your SVG drawings. My issue as of now is that I have this somewhat 4mb .svg file I produced from Inkscape (It was a printable n-scale train railway buildings papercraft pdf, that has bitmap textures in it) and Design Space just refuses to load it. I guess it's an edge-case, and that it is maybe too complex of an SVG composition not meant for Design Space software. The workaround I am thinking of is maybe to just export into .png format to get the detailed texture, and recreate the shape to be cut and the scoring lines, and import separately as an .svg to Design Space then align them together for score, print and cut operations.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Your work around of splitting the textures out from the cut lines seems like a great idea. I think that would fix it for you. Design Space can't recognize.bmp files so changing them to .png for print then cut, should work. And then separating the rest into an .svg should have you covered. For fonts, all you have to do is install them on your computer and then you can pull them up in Design Space by choosing System Fonts in the font menu - no extra program required. I hope that helps. Design Space is pretty limited in terms of truly customizing designs. There are work arounds and they have added features that greatly improve its functionality but I personally would never try to design a complicated project using Design Space. There's no way to edit nodes/points and since you can't export your designs from the program, I don't view it as a viable option as a professional design program. It's really geared toward the hobbyist and allowing Cricut to keep control of everything that's made in the program. Their customer base is mostly casual crafters, so I doubt that will change anytime soon. The ScanNCut program is similar in that you can't export SVGs from it, but you can edit nodes/points. Silhouette Studio can be a full blown SVG design program but requires a $100 upgrade to export SVGs out of it. That's not too bad in comparison to options other than Inkscape. I always design SVGs outside of it and then upload them and Design Space works great for me without having an Access membership. But, like you said, it's another program and another expense for full functionality. 8-)

[@tradnux5848]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts Ooh yeah, that "System" tab, I didn't saw it the first time, I completely dismissed the whole font select UI when I saw pricings of fonts on the default tab, Thanks for the tip. I can see "Save for Offline" option, I thought it's cool that not all in the Cloud. But then I tested turning my internet off and I can't see the project I set to be "Save for offline", which is weird. I restart the software, now it asks for login which in my opinion defeats the purpose of "Save for offline", maybe it is still beta feature, I am not sure.

[@salvationbeyond6839]

I appreciate your information you shared.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks! I hope it was helpful.

[@brucethomas4718]

Great vid.. a lot of info and individual features. Is there or do you have a side by side chart of pluses and minuses? Thank you

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I don't have a chart per se but my blog post does list all the features I mention for each machine as bullet points and then I have my pros and cons for each as bullet points. You can print or pdf a nicely formatted version of the blog post if that would help by clicking the little green button at the top of the post on the right. You can find it here - www.blacksheep303.com/scanncut-vs-silhouette-vs-cricut/

[@rd-gi6jw]

Not sure if it was mentioned in the comments. If it was, I failed to notice it. Namely, both Makers can cut up to 2.4 milimeters thick, not 3 milimeters as you said in the video. I personally tried with 3 milimeters thick material but it can't pass under the bar and I don't believe the Knife Blade would be able to cut through anyway.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

You're absolutely right. That is a mistake in the video. Thanks for pointing that out.

[@rd-gi6jw]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts You are welcome. It's a great video nevertheless.

[@BethBujak]

Scanncut is my favorite. I have 2. I hate the Cricut. Silhouette and Xtool are my 2nd favorite.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I'm happy you figured out which ones work best for you! 8-)

[@rebeccadees2300]

I’m thinking of an entry level machine that. I’ve never used one before so I’m not sure what I would need.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

It completely depends on what kinds of projects you want to make with it and how tech savvy you are. I thought I outlined the differences in the video pretty well but if you have a question about a specific machine, I should be able to help.

[@nancyloomis3046]

Thank you for this very helpful info. I'm in the midst of deciding whether I want to invest in a bigger and more expensive cutting machine. I'm a pretty experienced crafter & fine artist so I would make use of it it, but I'm wondering HOW much I would actually use it other than just for fun and maybe for other tasks. I bought a Joy maybe a year ago... Barely touched it and then started using it a couple months ago . I've been having a lot of fun and finding I can use it a lot....even making some signage for my little vintage collectibles booth. Was kind of dismayed when they came out with JoyXtra and thought "darn" that would have been so much better for me. Then I started thinking instead of just going up to a JoyXtra, why don't I just go ahead & get a machine that will do so much more, like a Maker3. So with the current sales going on, I'm thinking I'll just go get ahead & take the leap. Maybe. I have looked at the ScanNCut a little more seriously because of its standalone feature and scanning but those $35 mats eek! And I do have the Cricut Access subscription and am enjoying it a lot , so staying with Cricut is more practical for me at this point. Maybe a JoyXtra would be the more practical & less expensive solution for me. And I would save $200. Still thinking 🤔 in Maryland! 😊

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I can so relate to what you are going through. It is really hard to pick one machine. I have a Joy Xtra and I love it. It is the perfect size for 99% of what I do. But, if you think you will one day want to cut or engrave thicker materials, then a Maker 3 may be the answer. I mostly do paper crafts so the smaller machines work well for me (especially with some of the third party adapters for scoring, engraving, etc.) but I also think looking ahead to crafts you may want to try in the future is a good idea. The ScanNCut can do all the thicker materials and if you would use the scanner as an artist, that may be a good choice. I've also started thinking about a laser for some of those thicker materials...too many choices. Sorry if I'm making the decision worse but good luck! At least we are fortunate to have so many options. 8-)

[@kathleenwiles9197]

Outstanding comparisons! I really appreciate your detailed reviews of each machine!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thank you very much!

[@Jack-vz9hf]

Great helpful video, thank you.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks.

[@zina6581]

Thank you so much for all of the information.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Glad it was helpful!

[@djhouma8622]

Super Super Super Super Great Review! Thank you Sooooooooo Much! You're A Darling!❤🙏🏿💕

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Awww, thanks! I hope it helped you.

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

I cut way too many things. I have a Maker. I just got the Cameo 4.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Nice! I like having the option to use the different machines for different things. I'm guessing you do too. 8-)

[@tertiafourie8003]

Can the Maker 3 cut wood that is 3.6 metres long?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I don't know for sure, but I doubt it. Generally speaking, you need to put wood, like balsa wood, on a mat in order to cut it with the Maker 3 and the knife blade and that would be too long to fit on a mat.

[@EriKaizen]

Hi Elena, I was thinking of getting a scan and cut for stickers to make it easier to cut different designs out without worrying about setting up the trim seperately or rely on wifi connection. What would your recomendation be for a cutter if I was mainly using it for stickers or vinyl?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I do think the ScanNCut is the least amount of work for making stickers since you can print them out, scan them into the machine and cut them really easily without worrying about the software and any print then cut settings. But, you'll need a DX model so you have the half-cut setting if you want to make kiss-cut stickers. In my experience, the ScanNCut is hit-or-miss on vinyl cutting. I personally think you should invest in the special vinyl autoblade with the ScanNCut if you plan to regularly cut vinyl with it. It made my life a lot easier but it's not cheap (around $60). The Cricut does an amazing job cutting vinyl but you will have to deal with print then cut settings and calibration for stickers and the print then cut sizes (even recently increased in a beta version) won't give you a full 12" x 12" mat if that is something you need (but it can do almost 11" x 15.5" in length with larger paper). If you do go with the ScanNCut, you don't need the super fancy and expensive ones for stickers and vinyl. The SDX 85 or DX125e will work unless you want to be able to scan a 12" x 24" mat, but how often would that be needed for stickers? I'm guessing, not often at all. I hope that helps!

Hi! Im thinking about buying one of those. Thank for this really instructive video! One question : we work with originals design so, we want to import these design in the machine, adjust set up and cut and maybe, do it again... For sure, I prefere to NOT have to paid for a subscription. I already have Illustrator. So my question... IHow does it work with original design and which machine is the best for my needs? Have a good day!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I also only work with original designs and all of the machines will work with them. You don't have to have a membership to Cricut Design Space if you're only working with your own designs. You just upload them to the program, which is what I do with my Cricut machines. ScanNCut can easily open your own SVG files in the software but cannot save them if you make changes to them in the program; you'd need to make all the changes in Illustrator (also what I do). Silhouette requires the upgrade of the software to Designer Edition or higher to open SVGs and Business Edition to save files out of the program as SVGs. Without knowing more about how you plan to use your original designs, I can't really give you a good recommendation for a specific machine as all of them can work with original designs. But knowing that they all work with original designs, I hope the video can help you narrow it down.

That's a good answer! Thanx!@@BlackSheep303Crafts

[@abshuss2110]

Hi thanks for the great video. I need something that'll cut out my own designs on plastic sheets, Which type of machine would you recommend. Much appreciated

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi! Are your designs digital or hand drawn - do you need to scan them into the machine or can you upload them as SVGS or even image files to the cutting software a machine uses? How thick are the plastic sheets you want to cut? If you need to physically scan the designs in, then the ScanNCut is the only one that can do that. If you can upload them as SVGS or image files, then the ScanNCut, Silhouette Cameo 4 or Cricut Maker series can all work with them through their software programs. The Silhouette and Cricut machines may need to be able to print them on your plastic sheets, though, if they are multi-colored image files and I'm not sure how that would work, especially if the plastic sheets are rigid. The max thickness the Cricut Maker/Maker 3 can cut is 2.4 mm, the max a Silhouette Cameo 4/Plus/Pro or ScanNCut DX can cut is 3 mm. None of these machines are super great cutting thick-ish rigid materials - it takes a long time and isn't always successful. You'd need the plastic sheets to be fairly thin and bendable in my opinion. If your plastic sheets are thicker than 2.4 - 3 mm or you are doing A LOT of this kind of cutting, you may want to consider something like a laser cutter/Glowforge-type machine instead. I hope that helps.

[@shudodo]

Super helpful video!👍

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks! I'm glad you liked it.

[@johng4093]

Can you use a USB connection between PC/tablet/phone and Maker machines, as an alternative to Blue Tooth?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Yes you can. I often have to use a USB cable to get my Mac to talk to my Maker when the Bluetooth connection decides to flip out. 🙂

[@shaonthedaily]

Which do you think would be best for making small product/gift boxes?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Do you want to be able to change the sizes and customize the cut files for the boxes a fair amount? Or are you more interested in just getting them cut as quickly as possible with not a lot of extra work? If you want to do it quickly and don't need to do too much customizing, I think a Cricut Maker/Maker 3 is the way to go. That's because it can cut thicker materials if you need to cut boxes out of chipboard, cardboard or something like that. Cricut also has the easiest software to work with as long as you're not needing to change the design you're cutting too much. If you want to do a fair amount of customizing of the files you're working with (like altering the placement of cut lines for example) you may want to consider a Silhouette Cameo. The Silhouette Studio software allows you do do a lot more nitty gritty customizing/changing of design files than Cricut and the Cameo can cut thicker materials too. I hope that helps! If I'm missing something about what you need to do with a machine, let me know and I can try and narrow it down further for you. Good luck!

[@kathleenseligmytatterednto8560]

Idk about the others but if you live in a rural area cricut software only works if you can be online and have the bandwidth to use it. My maker say for 2 years until I finally have it to DIL. Sadly $350 blown. Do either of the others not require online large bandwidth to use?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

That is such a good point. I'm on of those who's guilty of taking the Internet for granted being close to a large city. Sorry about that. Both the other machines - Silhouette and ScanNCut have desktop versions of their software programs so you do not have to have Internet access to use them. BUT I think you would need Internet access to be able to download the programs. Not 100% on that - there may still be a way to get the upgraded versions of Silhouette Studio (that you have to pay for) on a CD and maybe Brother could provide a CD for Canvas Workspace too but I'm not sure...

[@kathleenseligmytatterednto8560]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts getting somewhere to download once is doable. Having to have it every time to use it...not so much. Library's or friends in town who will let you bring a laptop to do a download or upgrade is feasible for many. Heck McDonald's normally has free wifi for customers. But cricut you had to have net every use. I just wish that was explained by cricut. It was our fault for not researching that aspect, but most things say internet connection required. 🤷‍♀️

[@GreggLandry-h3k]

Thank you for this video! I have a Cricut Explore Air 2 and I have a very difficult time getting smaller letters to release onto my surfaces. I'm not sure if this is an issue with all the cutters or some are better than others at this?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Without knowing what material you're cutting small letters out of, there are generally 3 different things that could be the cause of the problem. The first one can be the material you're using; with cardstock for example I have to use smooth, lightweight (65 lb/176 gsm) cardstock to get very small or thin letters and designs to cut correctly. Some materials will never cut really thin or small designs just because of the nature of the material itself like certain fabrics, balsa wood or faux leather. It's just too thick to cut those kinds of designs with on any machine except something like a Glowforge laser. The second problem can be the design itself. Much like some materials, certain designs aren't well suited to these types of cutting machines or can only be cut out of vinyl or really have to be drawn and not cut because they are just too thin or too delicate. It could also be the setting you're using to the cut the material. With an Explore Air 2 I would set your dial to Custom and then use something like Cardstock for Intricate Cuts if you're trying to cut cardstock, for example. You can also modify the material settings or set a custom material in Design Space that allows you to adjust the pressure or the number of passes. I've done that with several of my cardstock settings (changed the number of passes from 1 to 2 as an example) to help me get a clean, full cut when I use certain weights of cardstock. Generally it's probably not the machine although the Explore Air 2 isn't designed to cut thicker materials and uses less pressure than the Maker series or the Silhouette Cameo or ScanNCut. But if it's not a thicker material you're struggling with, I'd guess it's one of other things I've mentioned. Worst case scenario, you can replace the blade and make sure you're using a pretty sticky mat for thin cuts but those things don't tend to be the main problem in scenarios like this. I hope that helps!

[@jessicay8207]

Can the cameos actually cut up to 3mm? I’ve heard of people having difficulties with this and it’s making me wonder if I should choose cricut. I’ll be using it for book covers, vinyl details, stencils and embossing around 3mm thick

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

They can with the special 3mm Kraft Blade but it's not the easiest thing in the world. Depending on the material you're trying to cut, there can be a lot of manual adjustment of the pressure required for multiple passes (book covers might be in this category). Melissa at Silhouette School Blog has a great post about this here: www.silhouetteschoolblog.com/2019/11/silhouette-cameo-4-3mm-kraft-blade-beginner-first-cut.html. Honestly, I think the Cricut Maker is the better choice if you don't want to have to think about it too much. It's slow to cut thick materials and can need adjusting too but it's a lot less than the Cameo in my opinion.

[@jessicay8207]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts thank you for your response (I will check the link out now!) and thank you for your opinion, it is highly valued. After some further research I agree, I’ve decided to go for the Cricut as I’ve seen many videos cutting 2mm thick materials on the cricut with usually no issue at all and it didn’t require any back and fourth. Thank you again!

[@mpetersen6]

I can think of an application that might be a little unusual for these machines. I know there are people using these for scale modeling. One application in this field is card modeling. Building scale models out of card stock. The scan and cut sounds perfect for this.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Great idea!

[@mpetersen6]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts There's already people doing it. Anothe novel use is cutting out gaskets for older pieces of automotive engines, industrial or farm equipment.

[@sueharvey4747]

Have scan n cut and Cricut maker, use both but my main disappointment with the scan n cut is their awful mats that lose their stickiness just by looking at them!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I know exactly what you mean. I re-stick mine with Zig 2-Way Glue to get longer use out of them, if that helps.

[@YourUNKus]

There is another machine the Janome Artistic Edge Digital Cutter which I have sort of looked into in the past. It seems to be an online only order from Michaels and has gone in and out of stock at times. The advantage apparently to this machine is it's ability to import and export all sorts of different file types and it's not proprietary. Do you have any experience or knowledge with it?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

No, unfortunately I don't. It sounds interesting though. Janome is a great brand for sewing and embroidery, etc. but that's all I know. If you get one, let us all know about it please. 😃

[@mikeyc7878]

I'm looking for a machine to cut sewing patterns for stuffed toys that I am developing. Which machine would you recommend to cut patterns on fleece fabric?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Both the Cricut Maker/Maker 3 and the ScanNCut are great at cutting fabric. Make sure you use the available rotary blade for fleece with either machine.

[@nicoleali7431]

Thank you so helpful

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks Nicole!

[@Angelswed]

I have the Cricut joy and Cricut maker 3 just got the brother scan n cut today (love the idea of the scanner and being able to scan mat to use scraps)and will invest in the vinyl blade , when I want to cut balsa woood do I need a special blade for that too?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Yes, there is a Deep Cut Blade and holder that you should get for cutting anything thicker than 2 mm with a ScanNCut. The item number for the blade itself is CABLDF1, the holder is CAHLF1. They're not too expensive. Hope that helps!

[@Angelswed]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts thank you!! 😃

[@maggiehamiltonpei]

Can I cut vinyl on the scan and cut without a mat ?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Yes, if you have a model that works with the accessory roll feeder. Julie Fei-Fan Balzer has a good video that shows how to do it here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/epvLp5KXaqaJndE

[@Minutepollution91]

Hi, do you know which machine can cut big slogans and tape on the bus or van? And waterproof? I want to design my own so i want to purchase a machine but there are so many .

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I have the specific cut sizes that each machine can do in the video and on the blog post. Most of these can cut about 11.5" W x different lengths, varying from 70" L to 75 feet L. The only machines that cut significantly wider than 11.5" are the Silhouette Cameo Plus (cuts 14.6" W x 10 feet with the roll feeder) and the Silhouette Cameo Pro (cuts 23.5" W x 10 feet with the roll feeder). As far as waterproof goes, that would be a part of the material you are cutting, like outdoor permanent vinyl as an example and all of these machines can cut that. I hope that helps!

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

For that, you can use any of the machines but I think the Cameo 4 Pro would most likely be the best since it’s 24” wide. As far as the vinyl for outdoor use, I use Oracal 651. I put it on my mailbox and it is the best. It’s extremely sticky so it’s best to use it with soapy water for air bubbles.

[@olivia8979]

I know this is an older video, but I am just seeing it. I found you at the Cardmakers Success Summit. This was very useful to me. I am a cardmaker primarily. I have a Cricut Maker and occasionally make vinyl and other projects. But I am currently more on the cardmaking side. I have thought about the Brother Scan n Cut. For one thing, I have been very confused about the different models and which to consider. So you have clarified that for me. But I think you also clarified for me that I may truly be better off just sticking with the Cricut and not adding to it. I do like it I don't love the subscription aspect of CDS, but I do use their designs enough that I want to keep the subscription. I have on occasion scanned a stamped image and finagled it in CDS to cut the shape with a small offset. It works but is not a super fun thing to mess with. It is much easier to find a similar image in CDS or typing out the sentiment and then creating the offset shadow layer. I'd love to see more Cricut cardmaking videos. Not the out of the box Cricut projects, but some more advanced techniques that meld "traditional" cardmaking techniques with Cricut.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Olivia! I agree that it sounds like you don't need to expand your machines. If you were going to scan in stamped images regularly then the ScanNCut might be a good idea but that really depends on how often you would actually use the scanner. It's not cheap so probably not worth it if you'll only use it every once in a while. I'm glad to hear you are interested in more Cricut cardmaking videos. I'm actually working on a project that is specifically just on Cricut cardmaking (and mostly not on the Cricut products). It will be a few months before it's done but I hope you check it out. I will also be adding more to this channel soon. Thanks for watching and commenting!

[@giasilvermonroe2442]

So your preference is brother?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

It depends on you and how you plan to use one of these machines. If you're going to use the scanner on the Brother ScanNCut (to cut out stamped images or scan in hand drawings or other uses) then the ScanNCut is the way to go. If you're somewhat tech savvy and not intimidated by a complex software program then Silhouette may be your best choice. If you're a beginner to electronic cutting machines and not very tech savvy, then Cricut may be the way to go. Unfortunately, there is no one right answer for everyone - even for me.

[@VanTekConsulting]

Thanks for taking the time to do this comparison. I have both the Cricut and the ScanNcut. I owned the Cricut Maker for 6 months, had to have a machine replaced and because the software and firmware is auto updated, a bug rendered my Cricut useless for two weeks (it was cutting off line leaving inconsistent borders). So the Cricut (in my opinion), has a reliability issue. That said, the mats on the ScanNcut are way too expensive and don't seem to keep their adhesive properties. You will have to be willing to do some hacks to overcome this issue. But, the ScanNcut will do things that the Cricut is not capable of, and doesn't require connection to the internet to function (like Cricut). Thanks again.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I had a similar problem with my original Maker - had to have it replaced but the new one has been very reliable for me ever since (for years). I agree about the ScanNCut mats but I just restick them (my hack - lol). I'm glad you like the ScanNCut. Great point about not needing the Internet for it too.

[@dpfb1263]

What are the hacks you use to overcome the adhesive issues on the ScanNcut? I am leaning toward that machine and will mainly be using it for fabrics.

[@VanTekConsulting]

@dpfb1263 There are some adhesives you can "re-tack" the mat. Some folks cut out the 12x12 and replaced it with an aftermarket mat. I ended up.with a Silhouette Cameo 5, in my opinion, it is better than both the Cricut and the Scan-n-cut.

[@NerdRage7]

Thank you so much for taking time to make this! In depth comparison plus pros and cons without getting too technical or confusing. I also appreciate the time stamps, that makes it easier to find which part of the video mentions the specific products. I'm getting my very first cutting machine and I want to make sure I get the right machine for the job. I'm mostly going to be making vinyl stickers and decals that are hand drawn or designed on my computer, you helped me confirm I made the right choice to go with the Scan n Cut. Now to just go buy one haha. I also love how active you are in the comments, keep up the great work :)

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thank you so, so much. I'm glad I was able to confirm your choice of the ScanNCut. It sounds like the right machine for how you want to use it. Good luck with the machine and your stickers!

[@lindak1819]

Scan and Cut best feature is that you do not have to subscribe to any design workshop

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I agree that is a great thing about the ScanNCut which is why I mentioned it in the video.

[@jessicay8207]

Also this is one of the first times I’ve ever actually watched the entire video. This was insanely helpful and so informative thank you so much

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks! I'm glad you found it helpful.

[@Velereonics]

It seems like as long as I'm willing to deal with the annoying process of finding vendors for the different brother accessories, the annoyance of having to figure out how to use it through either trial and error or finding Reddit posts or whatever, basically the time investment and potentially just waiting time to use it. It's a better machine, like a way WAY better machine than the other two. It's not gouging you with a monthly subscription (i hate that s*** so much), so automatically it's better than cricut, but the scan feature makes it better than cameo as well, even though I don't have as much against cameos business practices. I've been told the cameo will cut the entire 12 in width, but usually people are going to be printing something that's within 12 inches. Even if it's like a 2 ft tall thing, they're printing two rows that are slightly less than 12. Or, cutting, i mean. I have a 24-in printer that prints like 23.7 or something inches, and I think it's the same thing. There's three brands of 24 inch printers basically, there's HP DesignJet, Canon image profraf, and Epson surecolor, and one of them, I think it's Canon will print the full 24 in. It's actually weird how many parallels there are between wide format printers and these machines, the cutters. Like the always online thing, HP is like that and then Epson is kind of in between where you get more freedom and privacy to use the machine, but I think canons is the one where you get freedom from proprietary inn cartridges as well. So again, it's like three machines with this exact stratification of freedom... its very weird. Like they saw the cutting machines and then used that as a model to decide where there was an angle in the market that they could capitalize on.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

You may be right about the printer - cutting machine parallels. Great info too. Thanks!

[@hettiekenny5185]

I’m ready to buy a cutting machine and appreciate your expertise. This is so helpful as I’d heard nothing about the one Brother makes prior to researching.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Hettie. I'm happy I could introduce you to a new machine. If you have a use for the scanner, it's definitely worth considering. Thanks for the kind words!

[@DonnaJo3452]

Thanks for the comparison! I am glad that you talked about who you think would benefit from each machine. I hear lots of people say, which brand should I buy? It is of course everyone’s own choice, but to have someone who is familiar with all three brands express their opinion of whom they think would be best served with each machine, I think that’s invaluable. I will definitely refer people to this video if they are considering purchasing an electronic cutting machine!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks so much! I'm always a little nervous to give my opinions since many people may disagree (and sometimes get pretty angry about it - lol) so I'm really, really glad to hear that you liked that part of the video.

[@debbiewhite3270]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts Everybody can have an opinion. I feel yours is a more educated one than mine, lol. There is certainly no reason for anger. That immediately disqualifies that person's opinion about your video. Freedom of choice deems they can watch something else.

[@lizjohnson1174]

I know this is an older video, but very well made. I'll agree with everything you said when it comes to Cricut. Great job! I would like to add a caveat....I obviously use Design Space to cut on my Cricut. But you can definitely use Silhouette's software to make the SVGs (as long as you've purchased the software to have all the features), save as an SVG outside of Silhouette Studio (again, you have to purchase the software) , and then cut on the Cricuit. You have so many more features on Silhouette Studio than Design Space, which is why I use both. I will also say, that if people are willing to learn some basics on Inkscape, you can definitely create SVGs on that software (which is free, by the way, which means you do not have to purchase Illustrator) and then upload onto Design Space. Just a thought. But thank you for the video.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I agree with you completely and believe I made some of those same points when talking about Silhouette Studio during this video, but it's been awhile. Inkscape is a great program for beginners with SVGs.

[@beckydeacon185]

What a fantastic video, thank you for taking the time to share such a comprehensive comparison😊

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

My pleasure! I'm really glad you liked it.

[@juliebarrettpainting]

Thank you, this was so helpful. One thing I was looking for is using the silhouette for printmaking / silkscreen stencils and being able to go up to 24” or cut pieces for fashion and textile design /stencils for artmaking, drawing and painting series work. All very helpful points and a great overview video - thanks again.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks Julie! I'm glad the video was helpful. It sounds like the Silhouette Cameo Pro will do what you want as far as 24" stencils (I'm assuming 24" x 24") and since it's the only one that can go that wide, I think your decision is made. 8-) Have fun with it!!

[@49lucky]

I have them all because each one does what I do in my arts and crafts.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Me too. Each one has its strength that fills some need and each one has its weaknesses too.

[@elizabethholmes1070]

Appreciate the time you took to explain and give pros and cons in a basic format!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks!

[@JCcreates927]

I have a scan and cut and silhouette. Have had several cricuts and sent them back, they just don't cut like the other two and the software for the other two is much better than cricut. The scan and cut, you can use without a computer, it has all software on board and if you do have online access there are so many free designs for you to take advantage of, yes I said free no store to buy it in.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I’m glad you’ve found the right machine for you in the ScanNCut!

[@huyked]

What a great overview. Thank you SO much! 16:48 If your mat is no sticky anymore, I heard people say to buy Aleene's Tack-It Over & Over Liquid Glue to reinvigorate the mat, after cleaning it. There are tutorial on KZbin if you search for it.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thanks! I actually have a video on how to re-stick the ScanNCut mats here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rX-wemyHeNhsb7s I use Zig 2-Wayy Glue but I've heard the Aleene's works well too.

[@lauratarbutton4912]

Thank you for the great comparisons! I am trying to decide between the Brother and the Maker 3. I REALLY need the machine to cut mat board (which I am measuring to be 2.5mm), be able to cut stencil material from a custom hand drawn image, and cut stickers. Can you please let me know which machine you think would work best for these items? The scanner on the Brother is very interesting, but can you get the same results by scanning myself and importing the image into Illustrator and creating an svg file to import? Thank you so much!!!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Laura! Yes, you can get the same results, probably better if I'm honest, by scanning a hand drawn image with a regular scanner, bringing it into Illustrator and turning it into an SVG. It will take more time but then you have it forever and can use it in multiple programs. The scan into ScanNCut really only works on that machine. There are ways you can get the scanned file from the machine to your computer but Canvas Workspace doesn't have a way to save files as SVGs. You can open SVGs in it but not save them out of the program. The Maker 3 can only cut up to 2.4 mm thick according to Cricut. It's knife blade can cut mat board but you may run into a problem with the thickness. ScanNCut says the DXs can cut up to 3 mm thick, so that may be your deciding factor. I personally think Cricut is the easier software but if you know how to use Illustrator then you'll do fine with any of these machines. The Cameo can cut up to 3 mm too and might be a good compromise if you don't need the scanner on the ScanNCut. Like the Maker, it has a knife blade that will cut materials like mat board. All of them can cut stencil material and stickers so I think your main consideration is how much will you realistically use the scanner on the ScanNCut? If it's not much, then I'd seriously look at the Cameo 4 or take a risk with the Maker 3's thickness limitation. If that's what you do, I'd suggest buying it from a place with a really good return policy like Costco or HSN. So if it turns out the Maker 3 doesn't work with the mat board, you can return it. I hope this long winded answer helps!

[@galeem713]

I bought my explore used and it just died. I’m getting a maker. The smart materials you use matless are very hard to separate from the backing.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Too bad about your Explore but I'm sure you'll love the Maker. I agree about the smart materials.

[@kristenlauster3746]

Thank you. This was very helpful in deciding what type of machine I will need. My main focus is fabric as I am a quilter, but I am now designing my own art quilts and I need a machine to help with the intricacies of my own designs.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks! As you know from the video both the ScanNCut DX machines and the Maker/Maker 3 do very well with fabric. I'm not really a sewer but I know the ScanNCut has a lot of extras specifically for quilting. Good luck making a decision and with your great art quilt designs!

[@annspires8380]

I want to do journaling and do some things with replicating my great grandmother's and grandmother's quilts and wall decor that have been done in embroidery for my kids/grandkids as keepsakes. But I don't want to hand embroider that many duplicates so I thought that art prints and stickers would be a cheaper and faster option to share these family treasures and have everyone be able to enjoy their artwork for years to come. I like the Brother's ability to scan in designs.

[@LibertyForAll1]

Very helpful video! Thanks very much. I’m looking for a machine that will cut leather for leather for small leather goods and also for bags and purses. Would these machines hold up if I was cutting on them for and hour or two everyday? Are any better for using with leather? Thanks for any feedback. I’ll look at your other videos on your channel.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

My best guess is that the Cricut Maker would hold up well cutting leather for several hours a day. My next choice would be the ScanNCut just because it is a heavy duty machine. The Silhouette Cameo has a knife blade that would work for that too. My only hesitation there is that the machine itself is so lightweight that I'm a bit worried it may wear itself out faster. Just a guess but I hope it helps.

[@lkphillips1456]

Thank you! I've watched so many review videos and this is the first one that was really helpful regarding cameo vs scan 'n cut. The cons of the Brother machine are truly unfortunate. Sure wish Silhouette would add the scan function, it would make it so much more useful.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

The ScanNCut is a great machine just a bit tougher to work with in my opinion, especially the software program for non-techy people. But, if you are going to use that scanner, it is worth it. Just scanning and cutting directly without going into Canvas Workspace isn't too difficult. It would be cool if Silhouette came out with one with a scanner.

[@allysonmasters9321]

Thank you for such an honest and comprehensive review. As a paper crafter, that is, I dont need to fabric or design embroidery patterns as higher end Brother Cut n Scan machines allow, I am finding the expensive and short lived cutting mats a notable problem for this machine.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Allyson. I agree the ScanNCut mats are expensive. I clean and re-stick mine regularly so I get a lot more life out of them. I don't have to buy new ones very often as a result. I have a video on how to do it - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rX-wemyHeNhsb7s if that will help.

[@Princess_karen]

With my scan n cut I save everything on a flash drive then insert it into the machine and cut everything from there

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Smart way to go!

[@jennbee6758]

I bought the maker 3. It is A LOT quieter than the original maker. Great comparison video!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Good to know! Thanks!!

[@xChikyx]

really informative video 👌🏻👌🏻 is the silhouette software one time purchase?

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks. Yup, the Silhouette software is a one time purchase, no memberships or monthly payments or anything.

[@galeem713]

In cricut, you can put a flag on the card stock you use most, rename it and change the pressure etc.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Absolutely. I didn't really have time to get into all that in this video but I do have a tutorial on creating a custom material in Design Space.

[@carolakemistern]

Hi! Thank you so much for the information :). Does Brother work well for delicate fabrics like silk organza and or silk? Thank you so much!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Carol. The ScanNCut can absolutely cut delicate and thinner fabrics like silk organza, satin, silk, rayon, etc. (I've tested it) but you will have to apply some kind of interfacing/backing to the fabrics to get a good result. That's not always the case, but it helps quite a bit. Also, The Fabric Mat is what I used when testing and it is super, super sticky and some of the really delicate fabrics like lace and organza can tear when trying to remove it from the mat, so I'd try a standard tack mat instead for very thin, delicate fabrics. I hope that helps!

[@carolakemistern]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts Thank you so much fro the information!

[@rainbowbudgies1129]

Thank you very much for such an in-depth comparison. Your review was extremely helpful.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I'm glad you enjoyed it and I hope it was helpful. Thanks for letting me know!

[@galeem713]

I was talking to cricut and they said the maker is a stronger machine the 3 cuts faster but scans the whole mat before cutting.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Don't all the versions of the Maker and Explore series scan the whole mat before cutting? If not, how is that better for the Maker 3? Probably obvious but I need some clarification on that. I mentioned the faster cutting for both 3 series machines.

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

They all scan the entire mat before cutting. I have the Maker and the Joy. You can cut fast with the Maker but you just have to click it on the machine. You can also use the smart vinyl on the Maker. I use it with my Maker. It just grab the sides and go straight through with no problems whatsoever.

[@arleneaugustahair8393]

Um I have a Cricut Maker. I definitely can cut without a mat. I have used the Smart Vinyl in my machine. It will just grab the sides of the vinyl and go straight through.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Good to know. I suspected it worked but haven't actually tried it myself. Of course, Cricut officially doesn't endorse that with the original Maker but as far as I'm concerned, if the warranty's expired, why not try it?

[@brucewilliams6292]

I really appreciate your going over these cutting machines.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

No problem. I hope it helped you. Thanks!

[@poodlebone]

I have a Cricut Maker, Cricut Joy, Silhouette Portrait 3 and Scan N Cut DX. I use my Cricut machines the most. I use the SNC for things where the scanner makes the job easier than doing print then cut, or for using small scraps of material. I rarely use my Silhouette. Their autoblade has never worked for me. The software may be the most capable but takes too long to set up every cut. Cricut Design Space may drive me crazy at times but it is by far the most user friendly. I've had Cricut machines going back to the old Expression with cartridges so I'm used to how they work.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I use my machines in very much the same way. I agree you with on basically everything you said. While I like the Silhouette, it's probably the machine I use the least. I know what you mean about Cricut Design Space being annoying sometimes but I also agree that it's the easiest to work with. I use my Cricut Joy the most because I mostly make cards - love that little guy!

[@runesvensson1244]

Thanks :-) There is an overlap of "womens" and "mens" hobbies regarding tools and materials. Eg., there are lots of "womens" hobby shops within 100 km from were I live (central Jutland), but almost no shops for scale modelling. I wish hobbyists and shops would combine there interests, we both need to print and cast stuff in 2D and 3D as well using differential kinds of paints and materials (paper, cardboard, styrene, fabric etc).

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I agree that would be great! We have Hobby Lobby in some parts of the States that does that but even they have a limited selection in each area. I guess that's what the Web is for now. Lol!

[@BettyDavis-zf6nv]

Need help. I have a Brother Stellaire Innov is xj1 machine. Embrilliance and Enthusiant are my software. Which Cutting machine is compatible with my machine. Thanks advance

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Betty. I am not much of a sewer nor a Brother sales rep but a Google search shows me that your Brother Stellaire sewing & embroidery machine is compatible with the Innovis ScanNCut models, SDX325 and SDX330D. For more detailed info I would contact Brother customer service (www.brother-usa.com/contact-us) or better yet, contact a sewing machine dealer that works with both the Stellaire and ScanNCut Innovis machines (moores-sew.com, sewingmachinesplus.com and allbrands.com are a few from the web). If you purchased your Stellaire from a sewing dealer/store, you might also try them for specifics on the SDX325 and SDX330 machines. It looks to me like you can transfer files in between the machines wirelessly and that the Stellaire is able to read .FCM files, the file type the ScanNCut uses, and the SDX 325/330 machines come with embroidery software, but a dealer would be able to fill you in on all the capabilities I'm sure. Good luck!

[@jkleist5911]

Thinking of upgrading from Cameo 3 to Cameo 4….currently having issues with print and cut not recognizing my uploaded photo. Not sure if that has to do with Mac Photos or my machine. Or maybe I should add the SNC for cutting stamped images…..🤷‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Sounds like you've got a difficult decision to make. I haven't run into the print then cut problem but wouldn't that be related to Silhouette Studio and not the actual machine? Not sure without more detail. There's nothing like the ScanNCut for cutting out stamped images. That was one of my original reasons for buying it. Lot's for you to think about. I hope my video helped. Good luck!

[@claudiasoriano8610]

Outstanding. So glad I came across to your video for I was considering the Brother ScanCut. I already have Cricut Air 2 and It's is sad that I have yet to use it to it's potential. I'm going to pass the Brother machine and focus on the Cricut Air 2 that I already have and not give up easily this time. Thank you and I look forward in seeing your other videos. Claudia

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Hi Claudia! I'm glad to hear you're going to give the Cricut machine another shot. Honestly, I think it's the best financial decision just because these machines are expensive and the Cricut ones are easier to learn in many ways. The Explore Air 2 can't do quite everything the ScanNCut can, but before you spend $300+ on another machine, why not try figuring out all the great things the one you have can do? There are great resources available all over the web in addition to KZbin and my blog. I am currently focusing on speaking at online Cricut and craft summits, which I think are a fun and a free (or inexpensive) way to learn to make a bunch of fun projects with a Cricut. Good luck and enjoy!

[@Velereonics]

I've started to use a laser to cut paper. I just run it on very high power, very fast with maybe 2 cycles.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

That makes me a little nervous because of the potential fire hazard but I have very little experience with lasers. You know what you're doing so that's awesome!

[@angelamckinleyangiesmateri8779]

With SNC you need to remember to stack your designs the order you want them cut if you would like the details first.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Do you mean on the Layers panel - reorder them so the details are higher to have them cut first? When I mention that the SNC cuts the outside first, I'm talking (mostly) about things that are all together on one layer and not spilt between an outside layer and an inside detail layer. Or, am I misunderstanding what you are talking about? Because it sounds like a great tip...

[@craftylady11]

I have all three of them and a Siser Romeo. I use them all and have not had any issues with either of the or the software.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

That's great! I had to have my first Maker replaced but after that, smooth sailing with all three for years. We should probably count our blessings - lol.

[@candya9971]

Hi Can you please clarify what you mean by the SNC will cut Vinyl with a backing without a mat? Do you mean just with the roll cutter? Smart Vinyl? You say it while showing the actual sound and cutting of the SNC in the beginning - no mat is needed? Thank you =)

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

@@candya9971 It’s what is commonly called “matless cutting”, just like Cricut machines can do with Smart Materials. So, you can run vinyl through it using the roll cutter or without, but no mat is needed.

[@Jr-nd9kd]

I have cricut and scan and cut and I use my scan and cut alot more

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Sounds like you found the right machine for you!

[@Princess_karen]

I love my scan n cut, I have a Cricut maker 3 but prefer my scan n cut

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I'm glad you found a machine you love!

[@DebraRandolph-j4s]

This was very helpful. thank you really appreciate it!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thanks!

[@conniecox1253]

Can u use Apple I pad with the brother ? Thank you so much hugs

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Sort of. Brother has an app called Artspira that you can connect to your ScanNCut machine. I haven't spent much time on it, but it looks pretty limited. You can send cut files to your machine but it doesn't look like you can design anything on the app or really edit things. But, I am far from knowledgeable about all it can do so you may want to check out either Julie Fei-Fan Balzer's channel (BalzerDesigns) or the GentlemanCrafterUK for more info on Artspira.

[@fablewalls]

Very helpful video thanks! I used an older silhouette cameo for years at work - I'm happy and confident with illustrator / Affinity Designer and a few other .SVG creation apps but I want to cut thicker card to make decorative card boxes. Looks like Cricut vs Scan-n-Cut or even the new LokLik.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I think even the older Cameos can cut materials up to 1 mm with the standard blade and then up to 2 mm with the deep cut blades. Don't know if that helps but I'd check it before buying a new machine, just in case. Of course, if you want to cut thicker than 2 mm, then you'll need to. Only the Cricut Maker series will cut thicker materials of the Cricut machines, just so you know. Good luck!

[@fablewalls]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts thank you for that! I didn't know about the limitations on the Cricuts and thicker materials.

[@rivergate950]

what do think would be the best one for an elementray school for busy teachers to cut out bulletin boards and class projects? i'm guessing only a quarter of the teachers woudl use it and most of them are too busy to learn the software very well.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Well, all of the machines have some learning curve with the software but generally, Cricut is the one I recommend for non-techy beginners. You don't have to subscribe to Cricut Access for $10/month if you can use the tools in the software to create your own text/signs, etc. But if you want access to lots of pre-designed projects you would need to subscribe (or individual teachers can subscribe if they need to). Cricut machines DO require Internet access. ScanNCut has the most built-in free designs and doesn't require Internet access, but they're Internet software has lots of free projects too. It could be fun for teachers to be able to scan kids' drawings into the machine for possible projects too, which you can only do with a ScanNCut. There is a steeper learning curve with the ScanNCut software as well as using the machine without the software. Their mats are pricier and harder to get a hold of on short notice (not usually sold locally but there are exceptions) so those are down sides to ScanNCut. I hope that helps. These machines are a great idea for an elementary school!

[@rivergate950]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts thanks so much. appreciate the in depty reply. leaning towards scanNcut, but might go cricut if teachers already are comfortable with it.

[@uprayup]

Thank you for your video and honesty about the scan and cut.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

I hope it was helpful. If you’re going to use the scanner, the ScanNCut is a great machine.

[@astran242]

Sorry, I’m still kinda at a loss as to which will be best for a small home based cake decorator. It will probably be used mostly for cake toppers and cards.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Assuming you're not super tech savvy and aren't planning on scanning in hand drawn designs or something, I'd suggest you take a look at the Cricut Joy Xtra (not covered in the video). It's a newer machine but kind of hits the sweet spot in terms of cut sizes (can cut up to 8" x 11.5"). That size should cover most cards and cake toppers. The only thing you might be limited on would be some sizes of envelopes for large cards. If you want the bigger 12" x 12" size you might look at the Cricut Explore Air 2 since it is less expensive than most other 12" x 12" machines and can easily cut paper, cardstock and vinyl. I'm suggesting Cricut because in my experience, those are the easiest for beginners to learn and use the fastest.

[@astran242]

@@BlackSheep303Crafts Thank you for responding 😀. I’m not up to date on a lot of things craftsy but can be once I’ve had time to play around and research an item. I was leaning towards that particular printer, seeing as though I’m a newbie into toppers etc and working on a semi small scale. I’m not to worried about the limitations pertaining to the cards, as I will be mainly using it for toppers. So thank you so much for your input and advice . I will do some further research on the joy xtra 😊

[@ashleeroe6348]

This was extremely helpful. Thank you so much

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

Thank you!

[@paperkraftd1]

I don’t like cricut’s planned obsolescence policies. Early adopters of all things Cricut really got burned. I spent thousands on now useless tech.

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

If your talking about all those cartridges, I can totally relate. Unfortunately, anything technology-related moves so fast that obsolescence is inevitable. Cricut is far from the only company that does this. Most computers, tablets, phones, etc. aren't supported after a certain number of years. Same with Silhouette and ScanNCut machines. But, I admit, Cricut has a sneaky way of constantly changing things in Design Space too to try and force you to shell out more $.

[@ntur117]

I’m team scan n cut alllll the way!

[@BlackSheep303Crafts]

ScanNCut definitely has some advantages, if you use them, and a very loyal following. I’m glad you found a machine you love!