BLACKSWAN(블랙스완) - Karma @인기가요 inkigayo 20230521

BLACKSWAN - Karma #SBSInkigayo_EP1183
블랙스완 - Karma #BLACKSWAN #Karma
SBS Inkigayo(인기가요) is a Korean music program broadcast by SBS.
The show features some of K-pop artists’ performance every Sunday.
Check out this week’s Inkigayo Line up and meet your favorite artist!
🔗bit.ly/3epKoUp

[@Crazyswan4]

This Karma stage is always iconic. It never gets old. Let's rock BLACKSWAN. Looking forward to new MV.

[@Jam_e_jonna_om]

케이팝에 대한 열정 하나만 가지고 먼 타국에서 넘어와 도전하는게 너무 아름답다.. 멤버들 모두 응원하게되는듯

[@mnaoitb1]

what a beautiful message!!!!!!!!!!

[@skyhideaway]

I'm not a fan yet but it's really nice to see korean comments appreciating these girls, despite them not being korean or fitting the ever-popular beauty standards. it shows that k-pop has the potential to improve and put aside impossible standards to appreciate talent and celebrate diversity.

[@2120musiclover]

I mean, they’re gorgeous and super thin, and one is mad pale so, they seem to fit the beauty standard to me. Lol at least general beauty standards

[@skyhideaway]

@@2120musiclover korean beauty standards are a lot more specific than that. i was talking mainly about the complexion. dark skinned idols were not a thing at all in the past, so this is an improvement.

[@haejeegwon9774]

Just ignore the standard of Korean beauty. It seems to me that it is too exaggerated. It's just an obsession of some Korean communities. And in the past, dark skin color was popular. Such trends change all the time

[@7mmalltheway]

@@haejeegwon9774Girl group idols don’t fall into typical Korean beauty standards. Everything has evolved to maximize their dance movements and camouflage or enhance their weakness of their body shape, just imagine ballerinas. And they habe to perform not only on the stage but before cameras. Whether welcome the fact or not, it’s inarguably true that K-pop fans get mesmerized by their shape, moves and style, and they are to worship unconsciously. Where there is a demand, there is a supply. If you look at K-pop from a business point of view, it becomes very easy to understand everything related.

[@Flying-Chicken]

Worry about foreign fans hating on them for no reason xD

[@user-pr2kd5xr6q]

네명 다 핸드마이크에..발음 좋고..춤 잘추고 표정 좋고..컨셉 잘 잡았다 ㄹㅇ

[@gaelillanes5436]

Una pregunta ya que eres coreano,que opinas que hayan idols extranjeros no coreanos,no asiáticos?

[@123_ive_love10]

@@gaelillanes5436I think I do

[@angelbaby5759]

It's hard to believe that its debut stage for Sriya, Nvee and Gabi.They gave us such powerful performance. And of course our queen Fatou nailed it. Her deep voice gives me goosebumps. Can't wait to see more live performances of Karma. Fighting Blackswan & Lumina.

[@sdjamaay3021]

Because this is not their debut stage, they had several other stages in India in January and before that in Belgium and after one for a commemorative event in Korea 💗

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much better than them.😌 trust me

[@keiarahroop6530]

This is not their debut stage sriya and gain debuted in 2022 and nvee debuted at the hockey performance

[@jaysingh947]

This is not a live performance they are not singing live or rapping

[@starrynvee]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY bro you sound like an 8 year old💀

[@joecamel3891]

이게 바로 케이팝의 정석이지. 한국인은 없어도 한국어로 노래하고 케이팝을 사랑해 한국에와서 도전하는 멋있는 케이팝 걸그룹. 진심으로 응원합니다!

[@qksksks]

@Skyeye ㅇㅋ 중에 하나라 하셨으니 한국어 있네

[@joecamel3891]

@Skyeye 뭐야 이꼰데는

[@zovor96]

@@qksksks ㅋㅋㄹㅇ

[@qksksks]

@Skyeye 중의적으로 표현 하셨네 2가지 의미가 있네요 당신 스마트한 사람이니?

[@user-ds3jh3nn4w]

@Skyeye 그게 kpop이냐 국악이지

[@KGmobillity_jaechul_YOO]

젊은청년들이 한국와서 얼마나 고생을 했을고... 꼭 성공해서 프로가 되시길...

[@E____M____l]

I don't know this group , but their voice, oh my God, is so amazing and the song, everything about them is amazing

[@fsam5937]

Blackswan

[@E____M____l]

@@fsam5937 thanks

[@BlackSwan_Lumina78]

They are blackswan one the best rising KPOP group

[@user-iw9il7mh6l]

Wer are you From

[@E____M____l]

@@user-iw9il7mh6l Algeria

[@swaggyhijabi]

This group has ALL skin tones - fair, light, medium, dark. Im in LOVE.

[@EIIy]

Damn yes! it's like when we see all the shades swatched in makeup branding, maybe all the arms together belongs to girls in the same squad 👀

[@mayisabela8234]

They are perfect for makeup brand sponsoship

[@user-gh6zh6dx7m]

where are the korean members

[@scenery1313]

​@@user-gh6zh6dx7m No están. Salieron del grupo

[@Kanija5]

@@user-gh6zh6dx7m not there?

[@jaykaysdimple9718]

Whoever did did Fatou's makeup and hair deserves a raise!!!

[@caaarolynj4733]

Probably Her

[@mikks3733]

Her outfit fire too

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and my vocals are much bettee than her. Trust me😌🙄

[@ARajantara777]

​@@caaarolynj4733 😂😂😂 🔥🔥🔥

[@neodxlso]

@@caaarolynj4733 no she has a makeup stylist and she has a wig sponsor

[@user-zf7me3hr9v]

블랙스완이 k팝의 미래 모델을 제시함. 외국인들이 한국을 근거지로 삼아 세계에서 활약하고, 한국이 케이팝 만큼은 본고장이 되는 그런 모델이 케이팝의 미래가 되기를

[@zhanselkkk]

Yes.

[@donlee4105]

님말씀이 맞습니다. KPOP은 하나의 장르로(노래+춤) 이미 외국인들에게 받아들여지고 있습니다. BTS 정국이 "세븐"이라는 영어로 노래를 불럿지만 kpop으로 받아들여지는것처럼,인종 언어가 중요하다고 보지는 않아요. 다만 우리는 미국처럼 엔터테인먼트 산업의 주도권을 잡는게 중요하다고 생각합니다. 오히려 남들이 따라오기전에 빠르게 세계화시키면서 좀더 팬층을 확대하고 하이브,와이지,제이와이피,에스엠같은 기업들이 미국의 워너브라더스나 디즈니같은 엔터계의 공룡이 되는게 현명하다고 봅니다

[@YOU-ph1lz]

지금 한국 반응도 많이 올라왔는데, 소속사는 방치하지말고 최대한 빨리 컴백했음 좋겠음. 그리고 예능 좀 많이 나가서 얼굴 좀 알렸음함... 어서와 한국은 처음이지도 있고, 최근 여행 예능도 많이 나오는데 전원 외국인 멤버라는 장점 좀 살렸음. 일 해라 소속사야. 되는 그룹이다 진짜....

[@user-ri8yn7yo1chonig]

동네스타 함 나오면 좋을듯

[@user-vf2fr2br6l]

예능 출연했으면 좋겠다.. 소속사가 예능 출연시킬 수 있으려나ㅠㅠ

[@RadhikaSolke]

@@user-vf2fr2br6l Every successful group starts with a small company, take BTS for example

[@fun22smile]

​​@@RadhikaSolke방시혁은 이미 그때도 유명한 사람.. 회사가 작았을뿐이지 방시혁은 탑. 고로 시작이 다름

[@winoveruu]

​@@RadhikaSolke ew blackswan y r they even there such koreaboos

[@sleek4546]

Im so happy for them. Being number 7 on genius Korea charts isn't easy as a nugu group and they've worked hard for this and I hope more people will support them.

[@daldacare7973]

Yes ❤🔥

[@daldacare7973]

Genius charts is a big thing right ??there!!great

[@sleek4546]

@@daldacare7973 I don't really know since I don't follow charts that much😭😭 but yes I think it IS big because this is their debut at no 7 beating ppl like seventeen so yeah I consider it big.

[@daldacare7973]

@@sleek4546 absolutely blackswan new era is amazing 🤩 i hope they continue like this more 🔥🔥more success to them

[@dontunderstamitethepowerof2295]

@@sleek4546 actuallly many nugu group charted #1 in genius korea even tho it's not that a big chart but still they did great and i am sure this is just the begining

[@lisafiets]

모든 멤버가 다 좋지만 파투 진짜 아이코닉해서 계속 눈길이 간다... 목소리 나오자 마자 그 순간부터 계속 눈에 들어옴. 케이팝에서 보기 힘든 독특한 목소리 👍

[@Appl12e]

bts rm 보는거 같드라고요^^

[@maeumah]

This performance on a VMA stage would have shook the house. They were so well coordinated and the dancing and expressions were perfect. Everyone shone bright here. Love you Blackswannnnnnn

[@catdogis]

I think this version of Blackswan is truly the most unique. They really have their own colour and concept and their charisma is insane. Even people in the audience couldn’t help but cheer seeing how they were killing it. I hope we get more and more of Blackswan succeeding in the future 🖤🦢

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much better than them. Trust me

[@devyanisonkeshri1816]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYbla bla

[@nadines.3453]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY nop...

[@melomanicnightingale]

Why are you literally everywhere 💀

[@Ellie_Bond]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY tell me your entire account is for trolling without telling me loooooooool 😂 You must be really bored with life 😂

[@exssomin1465]

GO BLACKSWAN. WE BELIEVE IN YOU!

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

No. Believe in me. My songs and vocals are much better than them

[@Ao.shinoax]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY Who tf are u flop lmfao

[@Meliiinedah]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYyou are weird

[@nilakhipatracutipie5086]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY show us 😒

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

@@nilakhipatracutipie5086 go listen to it. My vocals

[@user-bh6us4bm8k]

너무 위협적인데 외국인 최대장점 얼굴작고 팔다리길고 여기다가 안무 칼각에 보컬실력까지 ㄷㄷ;;

[@dopaminergic1]

저 빨간단발 흑인언니 존나이쁘네 ㅋㅋ 음색도 인상깊음

[@user-yr9pw9uv6x]

That's fatou,leader,main rapper

[@WarzenTKO]

@@user-yr9pw9uv6xi think he talking about the other black women

[@yaoi2lover]

I seriously think this new lineup , this song, and concept is a great step for BLACK SWAN as a whole. I’m really impressed with their vocals and charisma on stage! They have my support all the way and I wish nothing but the best for all of the members! This is your year! Good luck Black Swan!

[@MB-px7en]

i think the stage was great and doing much better than earlier days of their group - but they were not singing live as you couldn't hear any breathing or volume fluctuations based on mic positioning.

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and my vocals are much better than them. Trust me🙄

[@karamau8653]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYgood for you

[@meromaria]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY i believe you, am a fan

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

​@@meromaria thank you love🤍🖤

[@OOOImannuelChristwo]

I think this is the best performance they ever have since the first debut they done. I mean, it seems like the company really prepare it so well, for the song and choreoghraphy especially. And it makes me believe that they can grow up as long as the company have good intention to do it. Fighting BLACKSWAN, YOU ARE SPECIAL!

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much better than them. Trust me😌

[@kylepop4371]

it’s a shame it’s not live vocals

[@Omgits7ito]

Dont give the white swan account ANY CLICKS the second you click their account or watch their videos you help promote them. I’ll spare you the effort and curiosity. All they do is take other artists music and speed it up and pass it as their own. One of them being Karma. It’s not good it’s not creative and it’s not original.

[@Omgits7ito]

@@kylepop4371 i agree , mind you. Almost all k pop groups lip sync on their first comeback stage . So I’m not surprised. I did however assume they’d do full live vocals to really show the haters up. I’m sure they’ll follow the formula that all comeback cycles do. Lip sync the first two to three performances and then start hitting us with the live vocals towards the end of the promotion. The reality is that they’re going to be performing this song a lot in a very short period of time . They have to save their vocals.

[@kylepop4371]

@@Omgits7ito it’s becoming less and less lately especially with Inkigayo, which usually almost always live vocals.

[@user-fn6kc8oe7e]

인종이 무슨 상관이야 그냥 한국어 가사로 된 노래 부르면 그게 kpop이지 정말 멋있음. 앞으로도 이런 그룹들 많이 나왔으면 좋겠다.

[@donlee4105]

예전에 jyp 인터뷰 중에... 한국사람이 한국말로 부르는것이 k-pop의 목표가 아니라 외국인들이 그들의 언어로 부르는 k-pop이 나와야 진정한 세계화가 된것이라..

[@user-xv6oq6ob1w]

마이크 하나씩 든거 보니 라이브 같은데 발음하며 노래 춤까지 얼마나 연습한거 너무 잘한다 다들 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 예쁘고 멋있고 다 가지고 있구만 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@jinain]

ㅋ좀 작작ㅈ붙혀라 어디 아프냐

[@heunchae3562]

노래 좋고 진심이 느껴죠 한국말 배우는게 쉬워? 저건 진짜 인정해줘야 됌 피프티 그런 퍽킹개년들보다 훨씬 좋아 피프티 개년들아 똑바로 들어 간절함이란 니들이 잊어버린거 누군가에게는 인생의 전부

[@user-tn4wk2bt9o]

​@@jinain넌 ㅈ좀 그만 붙혀라

[@twinkle5008]

02:03 I love love love this dance steps, her expressions, her makeup and dress omg. Sriya you look so great in this clip. Seriously this single dance made me her fan. Its THAT GOOD.

[@Inisprintynal]

케이팝은 인종을 아우르는 포용력을 지녀야 발전가능성이 보인다.. 더군다나 소중한 한국어 가사😊

[@user-ju6xz7oy7y]

ㅇㅈ 한국에서 활동하고 한국어로 노래 부르면 다 kpop이죠 뭐ㅋㅋㅋ 외국인 멤버들이 한국 와서 활동해주서 고맙네요 오히려ㅎㅎ

[@user-vf9pk7lb5r]

인종을 아우르더래도 중국인은 제외하는게 좋을듯

[@heunchae3562]

노래 좋고 진심이 느껴죠 한국말 배우는게 쉬워? 저건 진짜 인정해줘야 됌 피프티 그런 퍽킹개년들보다 훨씬 좋아 피프티 개년들아 똑바로 들어 간절함이란 니들이 잊어버린거 누군가에게는 인생의 전부

[@darkani5665]

한국어로 노래 불러줘서 너무 고맙...... ^^

[@zhanselkkk]

amazing..

[@beel1952]

최고의 걸그룹 ! 앞으로도 더 보는걸 바라야 🤎

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much better than blackswan. Trust me🙄😌

[@amouryong]

​@WHITE SWAN Official sorry but wtf it's going on with the cover of your first video 🤨

[@christy3047]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY you are obsessed..like legit obsessed

[@niabrown6817]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYyou suck 😂

[@anamikasingh7606]

1:39 ❤

[@dddddd-yz6zd]

This is literally history in the making. I love it! Been a fan of kpop since 2008. ❤️

[@user-tn5xe1qp7c]

당신들을 진심으로 응원합니다 타국에서 고생이 많으십니다 한국인은 이모습을 이쁘게 볼겁니다

[@mnhr6828]

gabi's vocals and visuals are truly stunning...

[@rebm7505]

ikr?? she looks like a living doll! I'm also impressed by Fatou's looks here, she looks amazing!

[@TussyCatz]

She improved a lot

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My vocals and songs are much getter than her😌

[@snehagodar3704]

Agree

[@leialatrice]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYwhy is you everywhere?-

[@yj070520]

와 래퍼 중저음 어디까지 내려가는 거야 단어 하나하나 타격감이 상당하네

[@dafihale7139]

This line up is TOP NOTCH.. it’s giving little mix. Giving strong girls vibe. Even though i wish there’s at least 1 korean girl here but still. No complain. The agency should start considering to focus on international market

[@nandinigupta5474]

They have really stable voice while dancing. .and very good stage presence

[@user-xn5yd7]

진짜 블랙스완 대표, 사장한테 경의를 표한다..포기하고 싶었겠지만 이 팀을 살려내네ㅎㄷㄷ.

[@user-pl8qt6fv3h]

이제부터가 더 중요한거같아요. 한국팬들의 화력이 더 붙었으면😅

[@yorkdenny]

이 회사 출신이 베이비복스인걸 아신다면 베복이 어떤 처우를 받았는질 아신담 사장한테 경의는 차마...ㅠ

[@suesue4848]

베복 마지막에랑(그래도 베복이면 성공 대성공이긴 하지만), 베복리브랑 라니아는 거의 다 말아묵고 ㅠㅠ 이번엔 잘해보자 화이팅!!!

[@jakechoe2011]

이런 다양한 인종의 케이팝 그룹도 잘됐으면 좋겠다. 다들 진짜 잘하네요. 파투가 이렇게 가장 오래된 멤버가 된게 대단하네요. 별다리연구소나 여러 예능에도 좀 내보내고 하셔요 ㅠㅠ

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much better than blackswan. Trust me💅😌

[@bunnyfxg]

⁠@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYIt’s the way no one asked nor gives a shit

[@beaitgirlguide]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY lol

[@rossy5114]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYsong let me see

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

​@@rossy5114 go listen to my amazing vocals

[@user-jr7su5io2p]

블랙스완 대박 예감.

[@why.you_]

쇼츠보고 따따따에 중독되서 왔다 래퍼분 포스가 쩐다 따따따안하면 죽여버릴거같네ㄷㄷ

[@Scarlett9718]

I know right! They are so awesome but understand :(

[@swanniegurr02]

THEY ARE #7 ON THE GENIUS KPOP CHARTS YOU GUYS!!

[@princessemimi1093]

Amazing , i'm so proud❤

[@user-zk4sj1he5t]

i am prouddd

[@L....F]

Wow 😳

[@durlabha1769]

Really 😳wow🤩😍🤩🤩😍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤🦢

[@amnedits4898]

OMFG REALLY?? IM SO PROUD 🔥❤️

[@user-tm2ot3qk8q]

솔까 한명 한명 겁나 매력적임. 한국인 없는대도 KDA느낌난다.

[@user-li3bz9dm6j]

저도 그생각했는데 무슨 케릭터같은 느낌😮

[@juztkei]

This is a really good comparison actually

[@Dear_Name-]

와 넷다 장신이라 안무 출때마다 박력이 장난아니네... 진짜 신선하다

[@Crazyswan4]

They all are above 169cm ;)

[@clementekhonde7329]

​@@Crazyswan4fatou and sriya are 173cm

[@Crazyswan4]

Sriya is 170cm. She said it herself in ask me anything section🙂

[@mayagaming2438]

No she is 172 cm

[@Crazyswan4]

@@mayagaming2438 Fatou is 173cm

[@wassupp_]

All of their voices are so unique and go together so well it's magical !!

[@lopez082]

Sriya is such a strong dancer

[@user-zk4sj1he5t]

yesss and her EXPRESSION SHESS THROWING THEM AROUND LIKE A PRO

[@poojadawadi7331]

@@user-zk4sj1he5t Let me just mention her live is so table like this needs more recognition than some other groups

[@user-vd8nz4gu7b]

격세지감이다.. 비록 30년 좀 넘게 산게 다지만 전원 외국인 멤버로 한국어 가사로 부르는 K걸그룹이라니.. 와.. 새삼스럽네. 그리고 잘한다.

[@user-mq8fe7wl4m]

새삼스럽다는 표현은 이미 과거에 겪었던 상황이나 감정을 다시 느낄때 쓰는 표현이라 이 상황과는 안 어울리는 표현같아요.

[@Ratel_777]

​@@user-mq8fe7wl4m a 시기에 하던일을 b 시기에 안하다가 c시기에 새삼스럽다~ 이런걸 얘기하시는것 같은데, 새삼스럽다는 꼭 과거 경험이 아니어도 사용 가능해요

[@user-vl9zb6hk7t]

진짜 오래 살고 볼일이네요 한국k팝이 정말 자랑스럽군요

[@MitzoYam]

1. 이미 알고 있는 사실에 대하여 느껴지는 감정이 갑자기 새로운 데가 있다. 2. 하지 않던 일을 이제 와서 하는 것이 보기에 두드러진 데가 있다. 그냥 새롭다 ㅡ 가 나았을지도요

[@jinain]

@@MitzoYam 어차피 번역기에 New 라고 해석되니까 외국인들에겐 신경쓸일은 아닌듯

[@Crazyswan4]

I still can't get over this stage 🥲

[@agbaimaribella2228]

Same❤

[@skyy1368]

블랙스완 케이팝아이돌 인정 케이팝의 정의 하자면 한국인이 없어도 한국의 가사(언어)가 포함되야 진정한 케이팝이지

[@whysoserious3002]

THEY LITERALLY ATE THIS WOW !! I have to say for three new members who didn't have much time to trane this is so professional and just amazing. Finally i can actually say DR Music actually put something amazing out ❤.

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs are much better than them🙄

[@tapaswirajalaxmi4671]

​​​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYwho are you??🙄😒

[@photophoto7354]

​@@tapaswirajalaxmi4671 Troll.

[@vitaseila9873]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY Who are the people credited for your songs? What’s the recording process like?

[@devegas4910]

Where do I even start? - This was definitely the perfect song for BLACKSWAN to come back with and the perfect first single for Sriya, Gabi, and NVee to debut with. - The outfits and choreography were perfect! - everyone sang wonderfully! I feel like, after all that BLACKSWAN as a group has been through, this is such a perfect new beginning for the group

[@erisylveraj8692]

What happen to the old members?

[@devegas4910]

@@erisylveraj8692 whew Chile that’s a long story. - Hyeme left back as soon as the group debuted as BLACKSWAN. One part contract ending. One part of alleged fraud - Judy and Youngheun “graduated”. I say it like because that was officially, but there was a bit of drama surrounding… - Leia. She’s back in Brazil for mental health reasons, but unofficially, she’s gone and the group needed a fresh start

[@barhorovitz2134]

Yes

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and my vocals are much better than them😒

[@devegas4910]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY put up or shut up

[@rakhijha2917]

This is my their's fav stage performance of karma. This one's so powerful

[@user-jm2rn5je8e]

우연히 블랙스완이라는 그룹을 알게 됐고 노래를 듣고 너무 제 스타일이라서 Karma 노래는 제 플레이 리스트 맨 앞에 있어요~ 항상 출근할때 이 노래를 들으면서 아침을 시작합니다!!ㅋㅋ 힘내시고 활동 활발히 해서 자리 잘 잡으시길 바랍니다^^

[@HOPE-wg5pb]

Glad you like it :)

[@ralos6629]

와 래퍼 목소리 개멋있다

[@fairylesbyaintdve6536]

래퍼 언니의 이름은 파투입니다 ❤❤

[@user-he8ui1rq6w]

리더 파투❤

[@user-op9gg4tj8l]

한국인 없는 케이팝 걸그룹 이지만 열심히 노력하는 그룹 케이팝의 정체성을 유지하기 위한 한국어 습득과 문화에 대한 이해 소속사와 멤버도 최선을 다하는 게 보이고 소규모 해외 공연에서도 먼저 한국어로 인터뷰.. 케이팝 글로벌화에 많은 정성과 노력을 하는 그룹이라서 많이 떴으면 좋겠음 블랙스완 화이팅!

[@user-ri8yn7yo1chonig]

이런 글로벌 캐이팝그룹이 떠야한다..!

[@miguel.malvarezandrade3019]

😮Y de de dónde son sus integrantes 🤔

[@queencard447]

yes

[@katiliannalopes3290]

concordo plenamente 💟

[@nitirxx]

​@@miguel.malvarezandrade3019 одна из Бразилии, другая из Индии (вроде), а другие я не знаю

[@worldsdairy6696]

Not really a kpop fan but after seeing those performance it just makes me to dwell into kpop world... love to see it more in upcoming.

[@priyan_an3]

This is the most viewed Karma stage🔥.

[@andyandys5356]

The first one

[@Neon-C]

한국은 우리의 멋진 BLACKSWAN을 환영합니다

[@Queenrihanata]

Thank you❤ please if you Can support them 🎉

[@user-wj7ht2ss4z]

와 연습하느라 엄청 고생했겠다 무대 완성도 높네요!!

[@0o926]

감해가 새롭네. 막말로 한국 시장이 큰 것도 아니고, 굳이 한국에 와서 한국어를 배우고, 한국어로 된 노래를 할 필요까지는 없었을지도 모르는데 Kpop을 사랑하는 외국인이 한국시장이라는 크지도 쉽지도 않은 시장에 나서서 이렇게 멋진 무대를 만들어 주니 느낌이 묘하다. 이전에 일본인 정도의 외국인 가수 이외에 그것도 kpop으로 한국무대를 메인으로 삼고 나왔던 가수가 있었던가. 감사하기도 하고, 뿌듯하기도 하네. 잘되서 성공하시길

[@user-ht3dj5fs4o]

감회

[@haandyou908]

감해면 오타도 아니고 진짜로 감해로 알고있다는 건데

[@annabelle7123]

전세계 k pop 시장이 커짐.

[@user-hb2ms8sh4m]

이 언니들 진짜 멋있어서 잘 됐으면 좋겠음

[@akakang678]

시원한 여름노래 내주면 대박날듯.. 다들 시원시원하게 생겨서

[@TheBlueClover2012]

Why do I feel so weirdly proud of them??? Omg the stage presence, charm, swagger. They got it all down. They look so confident n cool. I wishhhh this comeback will go well! I wish so bad. Does anyone know how many weeks will they promote this song on music shows?

[@gabic6174]

Promotion time is usually just two weeks on music shows and then normally proceeds to interviews and stuff

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and my vocals are much better than them. Trust me

[@thedarkestpath7464]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY nobody asked

[@hahhsshs]

It seems like the South Korean agency professor really understands this, that there is a new force in the K-Pop world dimension, namely "blackswan"

[@somlee8822]

잘됐으면 좋겠다 해외에서 반응 좀 오는거 같던데 소속사는 해외 중점으로 미는것도 나쁘지 않을듯 국내는 대형 기획사들이 너무 꽉잡고 있어서 중소 아이돌이 주목 받기가 너무 힘듦... 노래도 좋고 멤버들도 잘하고 소속사가 힘 좀 써주면 더 잘될거 같아요!!!화이팅❤

[@roar5853]

한국에 와줘서 너무 고마운 멤버들. 자랑스러운 kpop 그룹이에요. 한국인 유무는 중요하지 않아요!

[@DARK-SIDE92]

Your thinking is very good Thanks for supporting them girls are really talented☺☺

[@user-ze2pm5lq1u]

그런말 하다가 중국인 맴버로 된 그룹 나오면 또 말 바꿀려고

[@goodboyyang292]

​@@user-ze2pm5lq1u 중국인은 지들이 욕들을 짓을 하니까..글치..응..중국인은 예외..ㅋㅋ

[@goodboyyang292]

@Ryujinsshoulders 케이팝에서 중국인들은 배신의 아이콘들이다..최근 중국인 멤버들이 줄고 일본인멤버들이 느는 이유지..일본인 멤버들은 성실하고 최소 배신은 하지 않거든...난 인종차별하는것이 아니라 중국인들은 자신들이 욕먹을 짓을 해왔기 때문에 케이팝 그룹에 중국인멤버를 넣는것을 반대하는것 뿐이다...니가 한번 조사해보라고..물론 전부 그런것은 아니지만 중국인 케이팝 멤버들이 어떤짓을 했는지..그것이 한국인들이 케이팝그룹에 중국인 멤버를 넣지말라고 반대하는 이유다...잘 모르면서 쓸데없이 옹호하지마라..

[@angel127_]

@@user-ze2pm5lq1u ??

[@longiepooh]

this is the debut stage for sriya, nvee, and gabi but they absolutely nailed it!! fatou doesn’t disappoint as always. this is their best lineup and i hope it stays that way

[@keiarahroop6530]

This is not their debut stage gabi and sriya be bebut in 2022 and nvee debut at the hockey performance

[@longiepooh]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@keiarahroop6530 you only count korean music programs as debut stages, not those

[@valarieistoocute]

@@keiarahroop6530 that would be their first live performance. a debut stage means the first time an artist performs on a korean music broadcast, like inkigayo, music bank, etc

[@makeitright3810]

@@valarieistoocute that’s not necessarily what a debut stage means. It means the first stage that an artist has, which they already had.

[@TeeTop_]

@@makeitright3810 first music broadcast stage then 🥴

[@hihihi1203]

4명 다 외국인이니까 퀸카로 살아남는 법에 나온 축제 무대처럼 하이틴 컨셉 제대로 잡고 나오면 진짜 하이틴 컨셉 중 레전드 찟을 것 같은데 ... 다음 컨셉은 하이틴입니다 ㅠㅜㅠㅠ

[@user-pr2kd5xr6q]

이거다 제발 봐주세요 소속사님덜...

[@KpopNmore]

이게 배댓되야하는데!!!

[@user-ft6be5nc4i]

와 ㄹㅇ 영화같을듯

[@hk-vs1xt]

아 제발 회사가 이걸 봐야한다..

[@windy7183]

소속사야 뭐하냐 빨리 이 댓글 확인해라

[@Swann1997]

Imagine this stage performance at mama awards ❤

[@anny__29]

For that Next comeback should get more than 10 million + views within atleast 3 months n should be trending all over the world so it can happen let's make it happen 💪🏼💪🏼

[@Dawnflo_]

뭔가 K/DA 느낌도 나는 거 같고 외국인 분들로만 구성돼서 되게 돋보이네요!! 무대 너무 멋져요 응원할게요!!

[@user-rd5zk1lq8u]

헐 맞네 무슨 느낌인가 했는데 이거다

[@user-dw2ko3qd3o]

완전 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래스타일이 게임뮤비같어요

[@KatBlaque]

I also got a K/DA vibe

[@peachealry4298]

나랑똑같은댓글이네 ㅇㅈ

[@madeanaccountjus2say]

@@KatBlaqueomg fancy seeing you here! I also was feeling the K/DA vibe, i couldn’t put my finger on it until you all said it lol 🤭💖👋 hope you’re well Kat wishing you all the best

[@user-rj1br8oq2f]

스타일링 진짜 멋있음... 장신구가 많은 것도 아닌데 적당히 심플하고 화려한느낌이 나

[@user-he8ui1rq6w]

그러니까요 모든 무대가 헤메코 미쳤어요 진짜 다 너무 이쁨 중소고 다 외국인들이시다보니 각각매력 살리기 쉽지 않을텐데도 스타일링하나는 진짜 안빠짐 뮤비도 너무 이뻐요

[@Eu_0991]

미친.. 멤버들 각자 다 개성있고 개섹시한데 춤선은 시원시원하구 노래하고 랩 할 땐 ㅈㄴ 멋있어ㅠㅠㅠ❤

[@KeyNaz-jk4xx]

Its my first time seeing them! DAMNNNN its was amazing omg! The rap line was insane

[@MollaYT5185]

Did you attend the show?

[@melii0802]

if i didn’t know blackswan and u were to tell me that this is 3 out of 4 members debut i wouldn’t believe u… they performed like they have YEARS of experience!! SEASONED.

[@keiarahroop6530]

This is not their debut stage

[@keiarahroop6530]

@Bella🤍 nope it’s just their comeback they all (3) have debuted a long time ago

[@swati2899]

​@@keiarahroop6530 they officially debuted with their own song .

[@TussyCatz]

@@keiarahroop6530actually those were only concerts, they hadn’t debuted yet cuz it was their stage

[@keiarahroop6530]

@@TussyCatz omg look up the definition of debut it doesn’t matter if it was concerts they still debuted

[@koko-dn8os]

래퍼 보컬톤 미쳤네 타고났다.

[@ss21380]

This group is so underrated Their performance is great

[@ARA-fv5r]

나 이그룹 새음악 나오고 티비에서 자주 봤으면 좋겠다. 이런그룹이 있다는것도 최근에 알게됨

[@user-squick]

아니 래퍼언니 매력 대박.. 진짜 요즘 웬만한 여자아이돌 랩 담당보다 훨씬 잘하는거 같은데

[@niraassan]

그녀의 이름은 파투 입니다

[@ruby0727]

와 저도 지금 우연히 봤다가 래퍼언니 간지 대박이다 보이스 진짜 섹시함

[@gotji2771]

약간 리사 바이브느낌? ㅋㅋㅋ

[@out8Iuck]

A perfect performance. Sriya proving again she's an all rounder, Gabi impressing us with her clear voice and dance moves, Fatou remaining the queen of rap and NVee being the most amazing singer! Lots of love from Italy🇮🇹💖💖

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs are much better than them. Trust me

[@daldacare7973]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY 😅😅😂😂 joking

[@PaolaHernandez-dh7pd]

alguien puede decirme que paso con la otras? recuerdo que eran otras

[@Dred0n]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYNobody Gives A Damn😒

[@manishasamal3874]

This AKM or whoever is commenting the same thing literally on each and every BS related content... I guess she/he is more obsessed with BS than us... Kindly ignore this person.

[@kevinkim7617]

아니 다시 소환 된거냐고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저 부르르르따따따 중독 되어서 플레이리스트에 듣고 있었는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 응원함다 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@LibesJoe]

블랙스완 의상 중 이 의상이 멤버들에게 가장 잘 어울립니다.

[@Eu_0991]

진짜 이름처럼 블랙스완 그 잡채..ㅠㅠㅠ

[@user-th3sq9gg4z]

오.. 근본이다.. 맴버들 모두가 외국인이지만 한국어를 하고 kpop에 속해있다.. 멋지다!!

[@user-qb6pi7ru5l]

님 근본뜻모름?ㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-wx2jq1es4t]

근본 뜻을 모르면 사전을 찾아보세요

[@user-pz1tt9mn4l]

한국어에 의미 두실거면 케이팝이라고 하지 마시고 가요라고 하세요

[@shan-nialewis3873]

Once again I’m blown away by their performance. Blackswan has been through so much challenges yet they never stopped being amazing and constantly did their best. All their hard work is paying off and we all couldn’t be anymore proud

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs are much better than them🙄💅

[@daldacare7973]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY who are you

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

​@@daldacare7973 we are WHITE SWAN. 5 member group

[@Yujuchingu]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY flopped

[@Starliet]

​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY you're like way too much obsessed like you're literally in every single video of them 💀 touch grass fr

[@jesusinyourarea]

이 얼마나 아름다운 광경이야.. 내가 본 영상중 제일 완벽한 정치적인 올바름이다.... 다같이 즐기면 그게 음악이자 예술이자 원초적 즐거움이지.. 브르르 따따따! 가 너무 상큼해서 좋고 저 랩파트도 너무 멋져.. 그리고 옷이랑 헤어도 찰떡이고 ㄹㅇ 사랑스럽다...

[@jesusinyourarea]

포토카드.응원봉 언제 나와 빨리 사야되는뎅ㅇ!!!!!!

[@moniinkota4056]

Being an Indian I'm so happy that those girls are praised by Korean people's and world wide ❤

[@ryeo000]

진짜 이런식 느낌으로 딱 2번만 있으면 그냥 뜨겠다... 이번 곡으로 입소문 좀 날 느낌 멤버들이 느낌이 너무 좋다.

[@makmak_42]

I'm so proud of this group. I'm a Filipino and I'm a fan of any group with diverse members, especially when a group has members with different colors and race. It makes me feel more proud and happy to see them making a beautiful work together.😍💙

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

No one cares, my songs and my vocals are much better than them

[@seraraujoo6932]

Sou do Brasil e amo isso também ❤

[@nctzenlia]

❤❤

[@daldacare7973]

Yes blackswan very good and amazing

[@makmak_42]

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY No one also cares about you spreading hate towards the girls, so what's up now?

[@Luminaready12]

The banger, they served in the karma era and left no crumbs

[@user-rx7wf5es2y]

피지컬이 어나더레벨이긴 하구나.. 목소리도 매력적이고 퍼포먼스도 좋고 잘됐으면~

[@user-yh2yz1ss1q]

실력만 따지고 보면 kpop 다 씹어먹을듯

[@brrr792]

와 데뷔 무대 본지가 몇년 된거 같은데 그새 많이 연습하고 많이 발전했네. 소속사도 더 투자 많이 하고 연구한게 보인다.

[@user-zc3ff1oz3i]

ㄹㅇ 멤버들 실력 개늘음

[@user-zk4sj1he5t]

Yess Dr is into senses finally , they found a good bucnh of talented humble and hardworking people❤

[@Damayanti_Hazra]

This group really natural not for fake❤ And all girls of fire 🔥🔥🔥🎉

[@catholic2448]

구멍없고 모든멤버 스탯높고 노래도 잘뽑았는데 왜 난 이제서야 알았는가ㅠㅠ 라이브 최고..블랙스완 분명히 뜬다 응원합니다!!!

[@jimin_iology]

I’m so proud of Blackswan🥳. I just wanted to quickly say that their dance break at 2:03 was absolutely perfect, and I really loved the ‘Karma’ performance. Nvee, Gabi, Sriya, and Fatou’s hairstyle and outfits looked amazing + their vocals were stable🤍.

[@himanshushekhar58]

It's sriya not syria😂

[@jimin_iology]

@@himanshushekhar58 Thank you for the correction, I will re-edit my comment💗

[@WHITESWAN_SWANLY]

My songs and vocals are much much better than them😑🤬

[@imstannigapigsixhumansyk]

​​@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYWill you stop your nonsense, you literally ruined their song and then later you'll say that you didn't commented. So better stop all this nonsense because that's definitely not your music

[@PuhLiz]

@@imstannigapigsixhumansyk this guy is a troll , she literally covers blackswan's songs and then proceeds to say " my songs ...." how funny🤣🤣

[@lll__]

i wish for nothing but these girl's success. being a lumina was honestly the best decision i ever made. let's work harder luminas to give blackswan their first win! and thank you to everyone who has given time to check out this stage and their music. you won't regret it! ❤

[@user-wc4hu4zd8w]

이분들은 흥 해야함! 조회수 폭주하길..🙏😌🍀

[@annabelle7123]

개인적으로 처음 블랙 스완보다 지금 멤버 구성이 더 맘에 듬. 피부 색도 다양하고 진짜 다양성, 열림을 대표하는 느낌! 성장하고 성숙하는 모습 보여주길~!

[@RORO-js9zf]

와 랩 포지션......목소리 뭐야 대박인데.....

[@fairylesbyaintdve6536]

그녀의 이름은 파투입니다😊😊😊😊

[@jacobzeon921]

중저음 목소리 진짜 카리스마틱.

[@alexl0890]

인도 제시같다 ㅎㅎ

[@user-dl8ox4lt3k]

국힙 90%정리

[@user-fn4hs8wz2o]

연습 많이 한게 보임. 전원 외국인 멤버로 음악차트 1위하는 최초의 팀이 될꺼같음. 곡도 그전보다 임팩트도 있고 잘 나옴.

[@idkjshssbvVs]

Blackswan paved the way for a2k and dream academy to exist

[@SJ-ue6bo]

블랙스완 제발 흥해라 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@JH-lq1qf]

일단 라이브가 오진다...😮 더 떳으면 좋겠고 승승장구 하자

[@Neon-C]

BLACKSWAN의 사랑이 한국인들에게도 전해져서 루미나가 더 많아졌으면 좋겠습니다.

[@emmaadewole3252]

I'll never forget when this stage first came out I was obssessed haha, this was definitely an era to remember

[@user-in4zd5km3e]

예쁘게 잘 커스텀한 심즈 같기도 하고 요즘 유행하는 버츄얼휴먼 아이돌 같은 비주얼일만큼..넘 멋있고 비현실적인 ㅇ아름다움이 있다 실력도 독보적이고....곡도 잘 뽑았네

[@Seoul_Korea_]

이번 노래는 세계적으로 대히트할 것 같음🎉❤