What Churchill Thought About the Palestinians and Jews

[@BloggingTheology]

My mistake in the video: the author of the book is Tariq Ali not Tariq Ramadan!

[@Student.of.Knowledge]

Love you bro

[@nizamm4908]

That was an honest mistake, I believe. Thank you for the clarification brother.

[@philnewton3096]

Music. Imes from the auditory memory as does language.

[@BWFAIZANSRD]

I believe you interviewed him also not long ago.. which was another brilliant discussion on the future of Muslims in Europe.

[@aali1811]

Perhaps you could put a correction insert in the video, every time the Tariq Ramadan is mentioned.

[@rose-marietrembloy243]

I remember ( I am 94, ) that during the war destroying a town with carpet bombing was called “Coventrisieren”! It tells enough.

[@gerhardheydrich3146]

The English verb: to 'Coventrate' was a word created after the destruction of central Coventry, however, the destruction of central Coventry was a pale shaddow of what the 'Allies' did to Dresden. Dresden was re-built in the manner that it had been before its destruction and is beautiful. Coventry was rebuilt in modern 1950's style and is a very ugly place.

[@Golfer-rn7lh]

Actually your claim that it tells enough is confusing since Germany targeted Coventry because it was the manufacturing center for the British War machine

[@butragenjo007]

Are you Delboy's and Rodney's uncle?

[@davepowell7168]

You have access to Wikipedia and so l would suggest that you know that is inaccurate or it's just chatbot rhetoric. Personally I don't believe you 🎉

[@BlancmangeDoh]

Germany retaliated to British civilian bombing only after 3 months of British bombing by Churchill

[@LynetteA68]

As an indigenous American my blood is BOILING right now just hearing the way he speaks of my people and other non white indigenous people!!!🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

[@Gail-ux2ly]

Absolutely right! Churchill was a monster!

[@stevejames9531]

well he did not like the common white English he was taught by is mother s family they were above he sent troop to kill welch miners with no regret

[@JulieLevinge]

A savage fascist! Afraid UK don’t teach us any true history of our catastrophic colonial empire in all its depravity!

[@richards085]

He repeating what’s been written down by Churchill.

[@robertdraco8404]

When the Whites showed up in North America many Indians were cannibals or worse.

[@LambsyLamb]

Churchill was no hero and he hated the working class!

[@pamelamorrison4086]

Hated by Scots, for good reason. An evil man.

[@augustindurand4157]

He hated all brown and black people,that's a scumbag for you .

[@andym9571]

If you knew even the most basic facts about him you would know that is not true

[@margaretbrown9478]

@@andym9571if you knew the basic facts about him you would know that it is true.But history has airbrushed his image

[@andym9571]

@margaretbrown9478 I have read his WW2 diaries/ memoirs. Have you ?

[@yusrialtamimi1570]

One interesting fact for you Paul: Marmaduke Pickthall, the famous British writer, translator and Muslim convert who was born in 1875 was a "classmate and friend" of Winston Churchill at Harrow School, the prestigious boarding school in England. They both shared a similar "social" status as members of the "upper class", however, they had very different views on politics, religion and culture. Pickthall, being a devout Muslim, was a sympathizer of the Ottoman Empire and also the Indian independence movement (Did Tariq Ali mention this?), while Churchill was a staunch imperialist and colonialist.

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

Churchill was the butcher of Bengal, watch the video of Dr Shashi Tharoor regarding Britain's crime

[@paulamarsh1]

Churchill often had to choose between the lesser of two evils. Of the two men, it is Churchill who will be remembered.

[@aftabnaveed]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn so whatever Shashi Tharoor says is right? Famine happened in 1942 and Churchill was fighting world war II against a monster.

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

@@aftabnaveed lol your name is aftab.. he even gave remarks against Islam and you are supporting him? He was a monster who was fighting against another monster... The another Austrian monster was lesser evil than Churchill because Austrian painter knew about je ews traitors who backed western allies at that time... 3-4 million Bengalis died out of starvation because he diverted essential supplies from the civilians in Bengal to sturdies Europeans... When People writing to him that people are dying he replied why hasn't Gandhi died yet? He compared Indians with animals and he also said that there was nothing wrong in colonization of America Australia he said that a greater race took over another... Is this your favourite?

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

@@paulamarsh1 for me Churchill was worst than hit ler...

[@pepp4560]

Following the game plan laid out at the British 1st Imperial Press Conference of 1909, and representing Rothschild interests, J.P Morgan proxies purchased the top 25 most influential publications in the United States in 1915. They then used their editorial control to drive U.S. public opinion into the First World War on the side of the Allied Powers. As a reward, the British cabinet approved the Balfour Declaration promising Baron Rothschild it would endeavor to create a homeland for Jews in Palestine. Now, jump forward to the 1950’s, when the CIA used Operation Mockingbird to penetrate U.S. media, as well as various USG, state, and even certain metropolitan agencies. Today, nearly all U.S. legacy media is controlled by just five conglomerates, all of which are ultimately controlled by the Deep State, which came to power behind the scenes via JFK's assassination in 1963. That is why the JFK assassination is regarded as the Third Rail in American Journalism. The Democratic Party has become its political wing, and the MSM is now little more than its propaganda arm.

[@Utubexpert-kx7ew]

an excellent explanation of events

[@glennjames7107]

All sounds about right, exept that the Democrat party isn't the only political wing of these powers, they both are. They just switch back and forth depending on what serves the current public narritive. The idea that there two competing parties fighting for the people's wishes is an illusion and has been for some time.

[@ruidadgmailcanada8508]

Well done folks, thanks for sharing. ❤

[@EddieED711]

Japheth the beast is the father of them all. The people that came of Japheth are as Daniel 9:26 say they are. The People of the PRINCE OF THIS WORLD! They made the word of God desolate in man and in the earth. They have constitutions of man and reject the Royal law of God kingdom which he gave to man. The commandments are the Royal law of God kingdom. Can you see the destruction by war to come upon the nations? This is the day of the LORD. Jacob will be saved out of this war.

[@pepp4560]

@@glennjames7107, since the beginning, the Deep State operated behind a duopolistic uniparty façade until Donald Trump's 2016 candidacy. Feeling threatened by the self-funded candidacy of a man it had not vetted and over whom it had little control, the Deep State threw all in behind Hillary Clinton and the Democratic Party. To be sure, several GOP leaders remain its tools, but the Dems effectively became its political wing. In 2020, it successfully deposed Pres. Trump through massive election fraud, judicial intimidation, Deep State/Big Tech censorship, and media gaslighting. Having failed to neutralize him by destroying him through lawfare and dismantling his business empire, it has again resorted to murder. It fears RFK Jr. also, for obvious reasons. The Deep State operates much like Iran’s Council of Guardians as an unelected, unaccountable, self-styled fourth branch of government, neutralizing threats like Martin Luther King, Jr. and Bobby Kennedy, Sr., backing its own globalist candidates like GHW Bush and Barack Obama, and, to ensure profits from endless wars, manipulating the American people and world events through its Mockingbird media and false flag operations, like the second Tonkin Gulf Incident, the attack on USS LIBERTY, 9/11, and J6. The Deep State does not serve the president or the country except to the limited extent that they share the same interests with the oligarchs who lie behind it, many of whom are not even American. It is treason that must be extirpated root and branch.

[@gregabreu292]

Thanks!

[@BloggingTheology]

Many thanks!

[@pen8101]

Our uncle served in Palestine after WW2. He said they were not terrified of the arabs but of the terrorists on the other side. The murder of British squaddies and then the booby trapping of their bodies to inflict maximum mayhem and murder had something to do with this but also generally having potshots taken at them constantly. They came out of WW2 having fought Nazism and were exhausted. Why on earth are those squaddies and the ones killed at the King David hotel not commemorated each year on Remembrance Sunday? Britain is losing its sense of self these days.

[@khaledkhatib5116]

I am a Palestinian 🇵🇸. I lost my uncle in the king David hotel in 1946. Rip. The Zionist terror started way before 1948

[@jefffeldstein]

@@khaledkhatib5116 "I am a Palestinian". In what sense exactly? "The Zionist terror started way before 1948" I know. The terror of buying swamp lands Arabs didn't want at inflated prices, only to then be invaded, raped and murdered by Arab marauders. But let's not call them Arabs. Let's call them "Palestinians". Why not take credit for those murders, as Hamas gleefully did so recently?

[@jefffeldstein]

Considering Britain's betrayal of the Jews in British created Palestine, who had just seen millions of their own people exterminated in Europe, I'd be a little afraid of the Jews too. There is just so much Jew hate the Jews are going to put up with from antisemitic ingrates. As for the title of this little video screed, no one really used the expression, "the Palestinians and the Jews" during the Mandate, because "Palestinian" was a "national" category invented by Britain, and not really accepted by the Arabs of that time, but embraced by the Jews of the mandate. And of course before the British creation of Palestine, no people ever called itself the "Palestinians". BTW, with all due respect to your dead uncle, the Arabs had committed plenty of violence against the Jews, not just during the mandate but long before, even there in the land of the Jews, i.e., the Land of Israel, as its true indigenous people called it long before the European empire known as Rome imposed the name of another people of European derivation, the Philistines, on the land of the Jews. And as for the use of "Palestinians" to describe the Arabs of Palestine in this video? That's an alleged people was actually invented in the 1960s by the Soviets and the Egyptian, Yasser Arafat.

[@A2717]

An inconvenient truth for the “only” victims of World War II

[@patward1610]

COLONIALISM Colonialism COLONISER COLONIALISMO Colonial COLONISER Colon

[@ricardosmythe2548]

The title is disingenuous tbh. The Jews Arabs and Christians who lived in the territory of Palestinie were all Palestinians. The labels we apply to these groups today give a misleading impression of the reality of that

[@ouafa-nrw2007]

Yes, that's true. They are still jews with an old palestinian passport.

[@Change_II]

You're not Palestinian if you don't consider yourself Palestinian. Look at that fool mossab.

[@ZafarIqbal_1947]

Good title.

[@markrossow6303]

#Yep

[@Suresh_Kamath]

But there's absolutely no doubt there was a deliberate migration of European jew in order to change the demography of the region so that they could create a country of their own.This was before Holocaust.😊

[@mamnoona]

Arab Christians, Muslims and Jews lived in peace until the end of ww1 as I remember reading various examples of their collaborations for freedom before and during Ww1

[@elisabethmeziane5003]

Not true. Many criminal acts perpetrated by both

[@georgeh8937]

no noona. under turkish rule muslims would fight with the jewish minority and the turks would not intervene.

[@rolasaid1701]

@@georgeh8937 Jewish were happy and respectful in the arabic lands, there were no problem at all untill the Zionism project appear under lies and false alligation. then the Zionism made conflict in other arabic countries (such as in Egypt zionism bombed a Jewish cinema and pretend that the arab did it in purpose to obligate the jewish to leave Egypt) to obligate jewish to leave their countries and come to Palestine. as many jewish like other christians and muslems considered that they are living in their countries and did not want to move to Palestine. Even in Palestine there are many strories how the jewish lived side by side with the Muslims and christians like brothers before the Slavians ( Russia, Ukrania and other east and west european jewish) come to Palestine and steal the land and ID as Semitic. take a look in the KZbin what the real jewish says ( jewish anti zionism, Naturikarta, JVP. etc.

[@rabbidcrazy787]

That's false. Might wanna do more research.

[@TruthOrDie-h3w]

@@elisabethmeziane5003 Was it a crime to kill Jesus for no reason?

[@jonathonhunt935]

Thank you so much for reviewing the issues raised here and for your scholarship in referencing material that puts Ali’s narrative in context. I’ve learnt a great deal and had my tentative conclusions about Israel’s foundations confirmed❤

[@eleghari]

Churchill 1937: "I do not admit that the dog in the manger has the final right to the manger, even though he may have lain there for a very long time. I do not admit, for instance, that a great wrong has been done to the Red Indians of America, or the black people of Australia. I do not admit that a wrong has been done to those people by the fact that a stronger race, a higher grade race, or, at any rate, a more worldly-wise race, to put it that way, has come in and taken their place."

[@judgedread5835]

He’s hitler’s twin!

[@Jesus_the_Muslim]

Churchill was racist

[@weeshirley5934]

😳

[@whatsup9260]

the fact he wrote ''i do not admit'' says a lot on how the elite view themselves versus the restr of the world.

[@beanovofilgueira1584]

Ahora descubrís qué Churchill era un hijo de la g p..a ? Un tipejo con unos aires de superioridad moral , simplemente porqué era un aristócrata y veía a los demás cómo inferiores. Un fulano que jamás tuvo que trabajar para ganarse el pan y lo único que defendía era su estatus de privilegios para seguir pegándose la gran vida . Un " señor " , responsable de la masacre de jóvenes soldados en Gallipoli , mientras él se atiborraba en su poltrona de whisky de malta , champán y se ponía morado a comer los víveres más exquisitos .Un racista asqueroso, nacido de su visión clasista del mundo, dónde los trabajadores nacieron para mantenerlos a él y a otros muchos parásitos, disfrutando del esfuerzo de los demás a cuerpo de rey . En resumen,un asco de persona.....

[@desmondmccarthy6408]

I watched that interview with Piers Morgan and he acknowledged that Churchill was flawed, did some bad things. By no means did he portray Churchill as whiter than white as you are suggesting. He spoke to thex3nd world war leadership he provided and acknowledged that. And winning that War was indeed an heroic thing for the people of this country.

[@ilamilam9154]

Stalin defeated the Germany too, does it make him a good person? Unbelievable argument.

[@geofftoase3855]

As a figurehead he excelled. Unfortunately he fancied himself as a military strategist. Tens of thousands of British servicemen were sacrificed on the altar of his hubris.

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Well he wasn't great for black people so who exactly is he a hero to?

[@mjh5437]

@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 If Britain and the Allies had lost WW2 to Germany,when the Nazis had finished exterminating the Jews they would have exterminated the entire black race too,so there`s that🤣😂🤣😁

[@TheDublin47]

If it wasn't for the Russians you would be speaking German after all they lost 22 million men in the 2 world war and they kept the Germans bussing on the eastern front so the American and British could get to Germany.

[@rayaquaza1]

Really important video in context to Mohammed Hijab's recent debate.

[@TawhidCodex]

Yo my namesake

[@anneeq008]

Yh he should research more into him. He didn't know the figures well enough in the debate with Schmoly

[@rayaquaza1]

@@anneeq008 At least he did not make it up like Unholy Scmuly.

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

it shows when people do not know real history. Muslim people have always been in Europe!

[@jason-s8c]

I’m not a big fan of church hill because of things done in India

[@normsky5504]

His comments wouldn't have raised an eyebrow during his time. Right or wrong, attitudes and standards were different in his era.

[@kitemanmusic]

Yes you could speak your mind in those days!

[@EwanCummins]

But his comments did draw objections in his own time. By no means did everyone agree.

[@gdaoud65]

This was the best I heard för a long time. Thank you Sir

[@jiddasaid4456]

Your reading is very lucid. Thank you.

[@AL-ku1zq]

I wonder if the esteemed historian who wrote this book about Churchill will write the equivalent book about other leaders of the past. Maybe some historical figure from the Middle East? Not sure why that area came to mind. There must be historically important leaders from there, although none come to mind immediately. Doubtlessly none from there ever did anything ruthless or killed anyone. Very peaceful area after all.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@ntdisciple]

​@RussianFans-vn6cj Galatians 5 10 I trust as to you in our Master that you will NOT consider OTHER BELIEFS, but that the one troubling you shall bear the judgment, whoever he may be. xref-2 Galatians 4 9 But now, knowing Elohim, but rather being known by Elohim, how do you turn again to the weak and poor principles to which you desire again to come under their bondage (note) xref-1 These were people who were before patterning pagan cultic practices and now came to faith in YHWH and are now known by YHWH and were turning back to the former pagan practices. Galatians 1 6 I am surprised at how soon you have turned to another good news, away from Messiah who has called you to grace.

[@cathiemarvellous]

Maybe because Churchill is put in a pedestal and Britons are still living in a delusion that they are somehow civilised when in fact then murdered, pillaged and looted more than most other nationalities.

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Your comment just proves your lack of education

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Yes, that area was peaceful until Europeans...anything "wyte" people touch gets destroyed. They are the literal authors of confusion

[@sibyllelugo447]

Thank you for your great content and interviews on your program. I've been following sometime.

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad you like them!

[@tektables6635]

its wrong to assume that Churchills views were those of the English workingman, they werent, he was appointed during the war because extraordinary times require extraordinary measures, but when he was elected PM in 1950 and it came down to policies the British public couldn't get rid of him quick enough, i read his biography (or one of them) and he seemed an incredibly self aggrandizing character, I was expecting every chapter to end with, "naturally, I had the last laugh and they were sorry"

[@PMAB8]

These are the views of the British government and laws. This is part of your history all over the world. You believe that you are better than everyone else in the world. Look where your country has been they is miserable conditions xenophobic bigotry racist white supremacy nationalism agenda. America 🇺🇸 Africa, Latin America, Asia and Australia 🇦🇺. Your greed for power enrichment of your country in the name of your racism in the name of god save the king.

[@robertscott6930]

You are correct. My late father (1920 - 2016) disliked Churchill for his politics and his class. However, my father begrudgingly accepted that Churchill was the man for the moment in WW2. Its always worth noting that early to mid 20th century Britain was, across all society, racist but not in a violent way more of white Britains are superior sort of way. It was normal. Now things are different.

[@WesternPatriot-v8m]

Churchill zionist traitor to Germany Europeans Americans controlled false opposition to Jewish communists

[@elbmw]

In the interests of fairness we should also recall Winston Churchill's secret fact finding mission to Cyprus in 1907, which upon his return to Britain wrote a secret memo to parliament ('Condition of Cyprus.' Memorandum by Winston Churchill) lambasting the colonial office for the maltreatment of the Cypriots and urging parliament to intervene. His motivation appears to be more about Britain's prestige than the plight of the Cypriots but it's well to know that it was so damning that the memo remained secret for 100 years. It can be found online at the National Archives (UK) if one wants to fact-check what I said.

[@MrFernandesb]

Churchill was a child molestor

[@sigmanfloyd7179]

~ "...his motive appears to be..." Can you prove that? If not, please keep your theories to yourself.

[@elbmw]

@@sigmanfloyd7179 Have you read the document? If not, please keep your ignorance to yourself.

[@davidwebber8028]

rather ironic that open borders in Europe has led to unfetter Muslim settling of swathes of countries. Where again the wishes of the existing inhabitants has been ignored and dismissed.

[@gordonflash8976]

ya great numpty, he just gave you the sorce of his comment which contains the proof. It is nonsecical to then ask him to prove it. To make any sence you need to read it and fact check it in order to counter his claim. What you have done is to ask for proof of the proof when that is as good as it ever gets in the way of proof even in court. Historical documents, first hand accounts, eyewithness reports. History as you know it is build on such that may not even be that good. @@sigmanfloyd7179

[@puffingtonsmythe8690]

Tariq Ali, good old British name eh 😂😂😂

[@CW130J]

Was looking for this comment. Not disappointed lol

[@Kyth-g9u]

I am very interested to hear of Tarik's opinions on Stalin, and Muslim leaders . And also why he is not living and writing books in his native country

[@dovbarleib3256]

Before 1935 The Jews were called Palestinians and the Arabs were called ....... Arabs or the places they came from: Egyptian Arabs or Syrian Arabs.

[@dallasreid7755]

Not the ones who lived elsewhere.

[@subtitelingyou]

@@dallasreid7755 u mean azkeNAzi´s? the ones that funded and created neo0nazi's.? now we know what happend in ww1 and ww2.... Zionism!!!

[@dovbarleib3256]

@dallasreid7755 Yes of course. There is 4000 miles of Arab conquest west to east from the Coast of the Sahara Desert on the Atlantic Ocean to the ancient border between Babylon and Persia. That distance is about 4000 miles.

[@Avastidas]

What language was used by those Palestinuan Jews ? didnt they speak Arabic ? 😂 Why they created the New Hebrew in Russia in 20th century ?😂 Who were Palestine Christians ? Didnt they speak Arabic? 😂. Palestinans were Arabic speaking Jews , Christians and Muslims . Among Palestine muslims lived also few percent of Arabs . Even King Herod was an Arabic Jew. Arabic Ghassanid Kingdom in Levent was The oldest Christians Kingdom on earth long before Roman pagans accepted Jesus and created their version of Christianity. Lmao

[@Avastidas]

Oooooops . Oooops . Oooops . Palestine Jews spoke ARABIC language before Zionist Israel created . Very few spoke Aramaic. Polish/ Russian Zionists created the new Hebrew in early 20th century . 😂😂😂😂.

[@Toni-ho9db]

Thank you. From Australia and new to your channel.

[@jaialaiwarrior]

Muslim world The practice of wearing special clothing or markings to distinguish Jews and other non-Muslims (dhimmis) in Muslim-dominated countries seems to have been introduced in the Umayyad Caliphate by Caliph Umar II in the early 8th century. The practice was revived and reinforced by the Abbasid caliph al-Mutawakkil (847-861), subsequently remaining in force for centuries.[2][3] A genizah document from 1121 gives the following description of decrees issued in Baghdad: Two yellow badges [are to be displayed], one on the headgear and one on the neck. Furthermore, each Jew must hang round his neck a piece of lead weighing [3 grammes] with the word dhimmi on it. He also has to wear a belt round his waist. The women have to wear one red and one black shoe and have a small bell on their necks or shoes.[4]

[@austinrules9385]

Source: trust me bro

[@ricardorvb]

And the extra tax for non muslims groups.

[@dj1NM3]

@@austinrules9385 We can clearly see the Wikipedia reference note numbers copied and pasted with the text. ...but I wouldn't trust you or your "bro".

[@Harley-ir4er]

It's astonishing how the British press and Media refuse to discuss the Balfour declaration that has put the Palastenians and the Jewish people on a 75 year collision course. Not a single Journalist. TV channel or newspapaer wants to discuss it.

[@HabaneroTi]

It's actually often brought up but usually just in passing because they realize that most people won't have the patience or interest in learning about the entire history in all of its details, and prefer to stick to their preferred narratives.

[@גרשוןפרלמן]

Being that "Palestinians" were only concocted in 1964, relegates your proposal to nothingness.

[@karlgreene2177]

How do you know being an American?

[@CarlinConnolly]

excellent point... how many conflicts are a direct result of arbitary lines drawn up by imperial powers to suit their own purposes... too many.

[@jimseltzer2002]

It is astonishing how you would make a statement with no basis in fact whatsoever, and declare it with zero proof.

[@susanpotter9720]

Tbh people will make up their own minds and remember him the way they chose he was a man of his day,.like so many before and after him from all nations and faiths.let he who has no sin cast the first stone.or better still don't throw stones in glass houses..

[@valentinamilashkina3424]

you should judge any person by the laws of time when that person lived. It is not proven yet that the norms of our time are irreproachable.

[@newaccent1973]

good point and i'm by no means reverential towards Churchill.

[@robertcampomizzi7988]

6:05 Why was the Ottomon Empire good but the Britiah Empire bad? Did the Ottomons ever consider giving a state/self rule? I didnt think so.

[@Marya2476]

The Ottomans respected private property and did not seek to displace them with a Turkish population…

[@youtubeaccount3230]

Bruh the british were like a snake devilsh

[@robertcampomizzi7988]

@Marya2476 the jews came in and bought property legallly in the 1880's... in the 1900's BEFORE The British arrived there were already problems. So there is that.

[@georgeh8937]

@@Marya2476 oh marya. must you invent excuses for islam? the reality was the palestine region was not important to the turkish rulers. it was pretty desolate. palestine had 200,000 people. the empire had 20,000,000 people. so a hundred times more.

[@dianazaharieva5293]

Ottomans ruled not on basis of other nations but religious confessions. And Yes they were all independent from sultan and islam. Just taxed additionally if no muslim

[@khalid2010ification]

Dear brother, could you devote a video to talk to us in some detail about the positions of Arab leaders regarding the plans related to the establishment of Isr ael?

[@kirstyduncan408]

Why don't you just pick uo a book and read it??? Why would they be happy about europan zionists wanting to take their land??? Arab jews were happy living there since the fall of judeah.

[@MDJ-f7k]

"There is a heated debate over whether Winston Churchill, the British Prime Minister at the time, was responsible for the deaths of thousands of Indians during the 1943 Bengal Famine: Some say Churchill was responsible A study published in *Geophysical Research Letters* says Churchill's policies were a "complete policy failure". Some say Churchill denied food supplies to India to help the Allies in the Mediterranean. Others say Churchill prioritized white and European lives over South Asian lives".

[@maymunahsydow6276]

Wow very very interesting Paul, tx for the History lesson! Precious that we know this! What is so amazing is the many myths that managed to survive so many years! Time for all to recealed! Tx so much for ur enormous contribution so much much appreciated! On random opening of the Quran i came across a Surah LIX titled Hashr or the Gathering or babishment! Should make for some interesting reading! Tx Paul and God Bless!

[@jaialaiwarrior]

Thanks for the selective history. I notice how quick jihadi apologists are to point out the case of Spain, as if that's supposed to be representative of the larger Arab-Muslim world. In all likelihood Spain was distinct in being the only part of Western Europe conquered into dar al Islam. The Ummayad Caliphate would have had a vested interest in presenting a more tolerant policy there that was different from other areas and probably uncharacteristic when it came to their treatment of the dhimmi minorities given the fact that all Spaniards were ahl al kitab rather than kafirs. It was in their interest to be less brutal.

[@youtubeaccount3230]

So ur saying the muslims were less brutal because of the Jizya? 😂 did u also know that if the muslim cant protect them they got to give the Jizya back right?

[@darrenwithers3628]

"Some Arabs hated Jews". So what? That doesn't change history or make Zionism better.

[@omarjabaly5516]

My friend, concerning the part where you mentionned Lebanon, Lebanon has existed since since the dawn of time and its name is mentionned 17 times in the bible. Even under the ottoman empire where damascus directly managed by the turcs, Mount Lebanon had its autonomy inside the empire and maronite patriarch at its head. Lebanon has never been part of Syria and there are 2 chains of mountains as high as 3000 meters that sperates them if you have ever been in the region and the relation of Mount Lebanon with France are since the 12th century.

[@JessJoanne]

When you say 2 chains of mountains, is that Lebanon and anti-Lebanon? I never understood 'anti-Lebanon'.

[@HS-dw5ee]

actually the whole middle east was whole until Britain and france decided to break it apart and each took a piece of the cake. Britan had this rule always, divide and conquer and they followed it to the t.

[@marcellogenesi6390]

Never liked the man, dispensing judgment, on people and event, the result of which nobody could ever had imagined. But the reason i detest him the most is that he finds compelled to dismember, (so to speak) the leader of a nation that educated him, and choose to reside in, for his intellectual self gratification, when all he stated as facts can be reasonably challenged. ONE QUESTION: WHY THIS FOUNTAIN OF KNOWLEDGE LIVE IN THE UK, AND NOT IN HIS NATIVE SUPER INTELLECTUAL PACKISTAN? NOBODY WOULD MISS HIM.

[@JessJoanne]

@@HS-dw5ee Many tribes divided and conquered over and over there. And other ancient kingdoms. There was always war there. People just always seem to talk about the light skinned people differently.

[@mikehenson819]

@@JessJoanneyeah! The White interlopers. Lol

[@BOOTBOSS1]

Since England was fighting Nazism it only stands to reason that Churchill would take a pro Jewish stance at that time. You have to read between the lines of political rhetoric. The fact that the Arabs themselves where mainly nomadic tribes also figured in Britain 's and Churchill's decision to back a Jewish homeland that would also act as an ally in the region.

[@CarlinConnolly]

err i think England had some help from Wales, Scotland Northern Ireland, Free Poles, Free French, ANZACS, Indians, South Africans, the Gurkhas.... all there from the start. The main consideration was Oil and it is fair to say that the post WWII terrorism in Palestine probably rushed the decision and the settlement. But remember that Britain had already screwed the Arabs after WWI so they had already lit the tinderbox before they poured the petrol on.

[@philhufnagel4255]

Churchill himself is responsible for the bombing of London. He was a shockingly bad guy.

[@dankoppel6271]

Next week's discussion: how the 7th century Arabs came out of the Arabian peninsula and how they conquered and colonized the Levant, all of North Africa, and southern Spain.

[@jeangordon]

And murdered those who refused to convert to Islam.

[@theearlybirder-videos]

And east to India.

[@enlightenlife2840]

Thereafter no such thing as colonised the levent 😂 Petra,hatra,emesa, dilmon,midyan where all arsb civilisations and kingdom with pagan arab gods in the levent before the advent of prophet muhamed. There were even Roman arab emperor's such as Phillip the Arab, Caracallah,Elagabalus. Sorry to tell you that as an arab myself, I can understand old Hebrew which is another arabic dialect similarly to Sabean/himyar dialect. Also ugarit the old syrian dialect that's another form of old arabic. You westerners no nothing of our region. Yours jealous that our islamic civilisation created Algebra, the basis for darwins theory he git inspired by Aljahith's theory of discovery. Also the great andalusian civilisation we created. While your colonialism was racist and shit ours brought the nations we led a new creative progress civilisation. Most people who visit India go to see the islamic Taj Mahal and the mutual empires work. You guys ruled Africa and brought nothing, ruled India you bought nothing but push the caste system further. You went to the middle east and brought the nazi zionists. Wherever a white man rules a non white nation it's disastrous.

[@enlightenlife2840]

​@@theearlybirder-videos Muslims brought hygiene and great poetry and architecture to India. You're foreign tourists go to see the islands icon Taj mahal and mughal arts.

[@PowerJazzEnsemble-cw2xi]

@@enlightenlife2840 So you use the same excuse as the Western colonists, Muslim invasions and taking over other lands by bloodshed because they felt superior and improving on the inhabitants. "By the 4th and 5th centuries, under the Guptas, a renewed Hinduism based on devotion, rather than the management of ritual, began to assert itself.[110] This renewal was reflected in a flowering of sculpture and architecture, which found patrons among an urban elite.[109] Classical Sanskrit literature flowered as well, and Indian science, astronomy, medicine, and mathematics made significant advances.[109] "

[@mkshffr4936]

History is rarely as simple as we are lead to believe.

[@zlatkogospojevic7719]

It would be very simple if history is not written by the winners

[@mkshffr4936]

@zlatkogospojevic7719 The actual history would likely still be complex but the understanding of it would not doubt be easier to come by. 😊

[@Leon-jp7ch]

There is a small island community in the Atlantic Ocean. This small island community saved the lives of many Englishmen during World War II. Winston Churchill said something that unfortunately seems to have been forgotten. He said we will never forget you*****-******** What was the name of the wonderful island community that Winston Churchill was so proud of?

[@busterbiloxi3833]

Azores.

[@Leon-jp7ch]

@@busterbiloxi3833 No Unfortunately. You are going in the wrong direction. The Azores are located around Portugal. I am talking about the island community located at 62 degrees north latitude. This must have been forgotten in history since no one knows what it is except me. I know because I am a native of the isolated island community in the Atlantic Ocean

[@robtherub]

@@Leon-jp7ch tell me tell me?

[@Leon-jp7ch]

@@robtherub Winston Churchill said never forget the Faroe Islands. That is exactly what the English have forgotten.

[@robtherub]

@@Leon-jp7ch ah ha, i shall have to look them up on both a map and the history books. Care to tell me more? How is it there? Why did Winston say that?

[@celinesleiman6001]

6:53 the thing is when sykes-pecot drew the borders between the lands / countries of Shem or sham as in arabic, sure that will makes new countries, but these countries were existed but under one name "not the english name that brought from french" the levant 1497 but we were the lands of Sham.

[@nikkibonbon1600]

Has anyone heard of the kafala system? The system in saudi arabia, kuwait, jordan, regions in the middle east...run by muslims who are recruiting poor women from africa and asia. As house workers. Its modern day slavery. Those woman and sometimes children have no rights. The people who bought them take thier passports. They are not allowed phones or to leave the house unless someones with them. These woman gets abused, bought and sold like animals. And kuwait has the best laws towards it in the region. Hopefully that changes some day.

[@elisabethmeziane5003]

Yes, disgusting.

[@austinrules9385]

Source: trust me bro

[@onmykneesforYehova]

Yes, I have a friend who escaped. She stole her passport back and slipped out of the house when the 2 children came home. She was being worked to death. She was cuaght a few years later and brought back to the house. She escaped again the same night by jumping out the window into the bushes. She found a black community. From then on, she found foreigners who she worked for and they helped her get her passport back and her freedom. We live in Jordan. The woman and her 2-year old are from Kenya (Christians). She has told me this happens by the hundreds or thousands. In Saudi they are locked in the "secret room". They can have any kind of crime done to them including begin killed. In my building where I lived for a year and a half in Amman, A woman was kidnapped, locked in a room and when the door was open by mistake she ran out but was thrown over the balcony to her death. No charges were pressed and the man continues in his shop on the same street and the whole community knows - espeically the immigrant women. Also these women often have their passport and cell phone taken away and kept under lock and key. But some have managed to post on facebook telling their story and showing the bruises from beatings.

[@stephengeorgerobinson8962]

That is appalling. But what is your justification commenting on it here?

[@stevejames9531]

Saudia Arabia is not the topic here as a none western nation

[@ColinJarrett]

I'm all for this provided folks from other 'cultures' turn the lens upon their own barbarous histories too. As for the remarkable Churchill? We can give him a pass for any transgressions because of the abuse he suffered at the hands of his extremely neglectful parents. That 'get out of jail free card' seems available for the feral youth of the inner cities, lets be sure to apply it equally.

[@Houthiandtheblowfish]

yeah their own barburus histories lol as if it is comparble and they wouldve done the same thing

[@peterfreeman1585]

Absolutely no excuse for the continuous callous decision making that marked Churchill's life. Like today's recalcitrant youths poor upbringing should not be used for their humanity - it should make them (or made Churchill) into a more compassionate soul.

[@cathiemarvellous]

You want to compare a grown man in power & privilege to inner city kids? 😅 And you refer to mass murder as "transgressions". Would you refer to the loss of British lives as mere "transgressions".

[@cathiemarvellous]

Why is cultures in inverted commas? What is that supposed to insinuate?

[@andycallaghan5975]

True......Hitler had a terrible childhood 😢

[@hussainanoordeen5754]

Winston Churchill lived in an era where in my opinion at that juncture of history, he did what he did to the best of his ability for the benefit of his country. As any patriot would. To the white British he will always be a hero and one cannot blame them. Love him or hate him, he was a military and political genius who gave his all for his nation.

[@jamalraja6621]

Following watching the video that’s your genuine conclusion?

[@atydedominika3058]

Yes, he was a traitor, and very easy colaborate with Hitler and Stalin.

[@Divocwax]

I got the impression early in the video he is using a book review to make a speech.

[@ahsanmir8676]

The light of god always eliminates darkness. No matter how dark it always overcomes darkness.

[@thedragonflygate4587]

The Church of Rome; the facade for the continuing colonial Empire of Rome, has quite a lot to answer for. So many countries down the years have carried out it's premise and still do: It is about time it came to an end.

[@ccahill2322]

@thedragonflygate4587, What a maroon. What a complete numbskull troll. I suppose according to you it's the "Church of Rome " that's bombing, slaughtering and genociding the people pf Palestine. You are as ridiculous as Hertzog with his Amazon in Arabic "Mein Kamp" found on the "body of a Hamas fighter" in pristine condition, no dust and so on. You guys are desperate. Netanyahu, Hertzog and Gallant are all Catholics. The Pope is a member of Hamas. The Pope blew up the Nordstream Pipeline. The Pope overthrew the elected government of Ukraine in 2014. The Pope and Putin are card playing buddies. O, and yes JFK who was murdered sixty years ago tomorrow committed suicide because he was a member of the Roman Empire?

[@joselugo4536]

The same can be said of the current Synagogue of Satan.

[@damoncunningham]

Rome was destroyed but the SPIRIT OF ROME IS TRULY ALIVE

[@Ghurshah]

1:47, 4:11, 22:30, "Tariq Ramadan" is said where "Tariq Ali" was meant.

[@BloggingTheology]

oops!

[@FiveLiver]

2:59 Britain did not do this first. The Germans bombed Warsaw and Rotterdam as they invaded Poland and the Netherlands. It was only a matter of time before they bombed Britain. The Germans started the war and started the aerial bombing. To lay that at the door of Winston Churchill is absurd and dishonest.

[@hopplahoppla9328]

France and Britain declared war on Germany, that’s how WW II started.

[@FiveLiver]

@@hopplahoppla9328 Low resolution understanding events. Hitler knew that if he invaded Poland, he would not just be at war with Poland but with Britain and France as well. He had lied to Chamberlain, a red line was drawn, and he crossed it.

[@hafidkouloun6405]

Britain did that first to Germany! They cannot excuse bombing German civilians because Germany bombed Polish civilians.

[@FiveLiver]

@@hafidkouloun6405 Yes they can Germany was the aggressor.

[@kakpraat18]

You are mislead. Learn your history.

[@nijadbahnam9859]

GB played a double game promising a nation for both sides in same area and when shit hit the fans they bailed out saying it isn't their problem.

[@georgeh8937]

hey nijad. rather than blame the brits ask why didn't the arabs in the mandate start planning for statehood? after twenty years was any arab group ready to form a government? quote "In December 1920, Palestinian Arabs at a congress in Haifa established an executive committee (known as the Arab Executive) to act as the representative of the Arabs. It was never formally recognized by the British and was dissolved in 1934. However, the platform of the Haifa congress, which set out the position that Palestine was an autonomous Arab entity and totally rejected any rights of the Jews to Palestine, remained the basic policy of the Palestinian Arabs until 1948." seems like arabs wasted decades trying to keep jews out of the region rather than build a functioning government.

[@andym9571]

That is a far too simple thing to say. No context

[@andrewtrip8617]

Are you forgetting that Britain had already given Jordan to the Arabs .(commitment fulfilled) then when they tried to partition the remainder of the mandate it was the Arab s that refused to accept the existence of Israel .

[@andym9571]

@andrewtrip8617 Britain didnt partition what was left ...that was UN Resolution 181. Besides why would anyone agree to leave their homes and land to make way for immigrants ?

[@unibks4382]

The British Empire was using aerial warfare in Kurdistan and Waziristan before WW2. Channel 4 produced a documentary called 'Birds of Death' so it must be true.

[@Raelven]

The painting of Islam and Muslims here as guiltless and victims is disingenuous, at best. Tariq Ali's writings border on propaganda.

[@WesternPatriot-v8m]

Jewish empire royals are actually Jewish Rothchild

[@austinrules9385]

​@Raelven source: trust me bro

[@afzalshahid3884]

This is very deep. It was very slow process and now it's impossible to reverse things. But all is possible for Allah. Thank you br. Paul for sharing this gem info.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@dalew801]

@@RussianFans-vn6cj Mohamed . . . you are confused !

[@rick4electric]

22:22 - This supremacist view was very convenient for the people who held it! After all they benefitted profusely by it!

[@jimhitchcock2383]

Churchill was heavily interested in the maintaince of Britan's Naval and world trade "empire". I note there was no mention in your post about the worlds 4 Naval checkpoints. Prior to the opening of the Suez and Panama Canals there were two. The straits of Singapore and Gibraltar. Churchill probably didn't want to call attention to Britan's interest in "controlling" lands on both sides of the Suez canal openings. He probably hoped the effect of Britan "helping" the Jews would "secure ' east side of the Suez opening to the Med..

[@FncyPntsPikachu]

The Germans did it to the French first but apparently this geezer is ignoring that

[@marcoseliash]

No youre wrong. Dresden was the first city.

[@arta106]

Listening to this fellow, It is possible to understand why London and the UK go to the seed. It is not about Churchill, it is about woke ideology and its application to the history and daily practice. Cry the beloved country.

[@stevenrevins]

did you watch more than a few minutes of this 30 minute thing?

[@Bynggo]

I was reading your comment until you used the new yank word Woke. Do you even know what woke means? Gotta throw it in there for some reason. Plus, if London has gone to seed, as you say, imagine how the rest of Europe is fairing. I think London will survive your concern.

[@clivekahn4305]

Tariq Ali is a Pakistani-British political activist and a member of the editorial committee of the New Left Review. Winston Churchill was a British patriot that saved the free world from Nazi tyranny. Paul Williams, the presenter of this video has also presented videos "My journey to Islam", and "Becoming Muslim".

[@mireillelanglois6947]

Merci, ça m’éclaire!

[@franciscosaldana2879]

I am a Catholic and recognize the great injustice in Palestine, you do not have to be a Muslim to be aware of this injustice.

[@clivekahn4305]

​@franciscosaldana2879 The Roman's called Israel Palestine after they conquered our land some 2000 years ago. More than half the current Israeli Jewish population consists of Jews expelled from the more than 20 Arab States surrounding Israel. There are over 400 million Arabs living on morecthan 13 million square kilometers of land in the middle east. The injustice to the Arabs of Israel is perpetrated by the greater Arab community. Only when you understand that can you begin to understand what drives the so called Israeli 'Palestinian' conflict.

[@Val-g6g6n]

@@franciscosaldana2879 Correct there are Christians that stand with Palestine due to non-reading of the Holy Bible and ignorance. Read the Bible to know God's plan for Israel. You are not with the true God, the Father Almighty. The Gazans supported terrorist Hamas. Children in Gaza were used as human shield. You are blinded by dark forces. Islam is evil

[@clivekahn4305]

​@@franciscosaldana2879 YES INDEED, there has indeed been injustice. It began when Titus the Roman conquered Israel, besieged and destroyed Jerusalem. Of those Jews that were not killed, the vast majority were taken into slavery and/or exiled. The Romans wishing to destroy all trace of Israel renamed their conquered territory Palestina (there is no "P" in Arabic, hence Arabs call it Falestina). Subsequent years saw a variety of conquerors, Arabs, Mongols, Crusaders and finally Turks who included the territory in the Ottoman Empire whilst we Jews languished in Europe, Russia and North Africa. But Ottoman's side with Germany in World War 1, their empire destroyed and the British victors were granted the "Palestine Mandate". The British gave the the Husseini's 88% of "Palestine" for siding with them in the war. The remaining 22% was to be divided between the Jews that had returned to our land ad the Arabs that had migrated into these territories (which by the way was largely a neglected backwater under the various empires). The UN Special Commission on Palestine recommended partitioning Palestine into Jewish and Arab states in 1947. The Jews said yes the Arabs said no and declared war - Egypt, Jordan, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon invaded Israel - but they lost the war. Note that at that time there was no "Palestine" - only Arabs and Jews. Some 700,000 Arabs fled Israel to surrounding Arab states. Later in the 1950's some 850,000 Jews fled Arab states , most of whom went to Israel. So I agree with you --- their has been much injustice on all sides -- however I think you look to the incorrect source of this injustice ---- Israel comprises less than 28,000 square kilometers with a Jewish population of barely 7 million people (plus another 2 million Arab citizens that enjoy full human rights.- on the other side of our borders there are more than 22 Arab states with more than 400 million people on over 13,000,000 square kilometers of land ----- Israel absorbed it's brethren who today comprise more than 50% of the Israeli Jewish population. The Arab states refused to absorb their brethren keeping them refugee camps with little or no rights keeping them as permanent refugees. Christians attempted world domination but today settle for what they have and have Rome as their capital. Muslims are still on the march and whilst mecca and Medina are their spiritual capitals there are those that insist that any territory that they once controlled are theirs ----- this includes Spain, Constantinople and with the help of 'understanding' people like yourself could well be Paris and London etc as well ----- Our home is Israel, Judea and Samaria from as long ago as 3000 years ago when King David and Solomon built our temple in Jerusalem ---- we welcome people of good faith to the holy land ----

[@superlinux]

The title of the book is bold and blunt saying (his crimes). that's seriously shocking. It's a public accusation.

[@AllTenThousand]

How strange, that after eight minutes you haven't mentioned the collapse of the ottomans and a real need for an analysis of what areas were capable of "self rule" and which would collapse into murderous chaos in the vacuum.

[@RichardRaphael-yq3ot]

"All of the four great powers are committed to Zionism" (Circa 18:00). How is no one talking about that admission? Who were they? UK, US, China, and Soviet Union (now "Russia"). I thought China and Russia were the enemy. When do you get approval from an enemy? "I'm not upset that you lied to me, I'm upset that from now on I can't believe you." -- Friedrich Nietzsche

[@dj1NM3]

The USSR did vote "yes" to UN Resolution 181 in December of 1947 and was the first country to officially recognise Israel on 17th of May, 1948 (three days after their declaration of independence), voting for Israel's application for UN membership on the 4th of March 1949 and again for Israel's membership of the United Nations on May 11th, 1949. ...but they did a "heel turn", both voted to create UNRWA in 1949 (to create permanent, special hereditary "refugees" of the Arabs who fled at the behest of the Arab League states , to perpetuate the 1948 Israeli War of Independence) and created the "Palestinian Liberation Organisation" in 1964 as their proxy army (lead by Egyptians and given a Ba'ath Party [founded 1947] flag to wave) to harass Israel with, most likely because they rejected the USSR's demand they join her "sphere of influence", chose liberal-democracy as their political system and allied with the USA.

[@BruceMullen-iv8hx]

Churchill seems to have been influenced by his American Jewish mother, Jenny Jerome , the daughter of a very wealthy Jewish New Yorker.

[@DevorahC]

so then by Jewish law, Churchill would have been considered Jewish.

[@annysons]

So what ? You dirty antisemite….Western civilization is based on Judeo-Christian values never on Islam (Thanks god)

[@mathewZimmerman-zx5sd]

Not according to Wikipedia.

[@jamieb0nd]

Jewish law is man's law. None of it was handed down by Moses. The Bible and the Torah clearly dictates Jewish generations by their fathers.

[@oakenarbor2046]

French Huguenots, not jewish. Protestants. Curious name biased association seems evident. Facts are more helpful.

[@ahmeda.3198]

Strange that he came ahead of Isaac Newton. Do people not recognize the achievements of Newton? What a crazy world we live in.

[@tonyd7601]

Thanks for the video. No good deed goes unpunished.

[@Maryam-gt7bj]

???

[@tonyd7601]

@@Maryam-gt7bj Who got helped and who hurt who. The ones who were helped hurt those that helped them.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@drmodestoesq]

The Quran verifies the Old and New Testaments? That's an interesting take. No Muslim believes that though. @@RussianFans-vn6cj

[@z2arshad]

People from the subcontinent have known about his crimes of course, having been on the receiving end. Its amazing how revered he is in British culture. The only solace is that hes already met his Maker.

[@davidatkinson5858]

So give us some specifics on "his crimes" and let's have a good faith conversation about it?....and all the important context involved

[@elfinia]

Of course Churchill is revered. Not amazing at all. We are a free people and not Nazis. Why not read the books Churchill wrote himself ?

[@ianstevenson3628]

Estimates of German deaths due to Allied bombing (US , British and Canadian ) are in the range of 300,000 to 500,000. Not a million. Deaths due to the Soviet invasion are much higher.

[@alexsonego151]

Very compelling and unbiased, thank you so much. I wasn't aware that the "jews" who predate both Christianity and Islam are a culture that materialized out of thin air in unknown areas somewhere in the world.....I don't know where? What was life like during the Ottoman empire for native Christians and jews? Awnser they were lucky to get out. They were colonized and displaced. Maybe Churchill had negative views of the former allies of the Nazis. The allies won ,Churchill although far from perfect he helped save the world from fascism and allowed the native jews who were ethnically cleansed from they're homeland to return. He was not considerate of the Arab population but considering the alliance to Germany in both wars it would be false to think he wasn't biased. They fueled the German army and during ww1 and performed ethnic cleansing in the ottoman empire when noone was looking and after the fall of the ottomans in ww2 they assisted Rommel in north Africa where Britain under Montgomery fought a costly desert war and earned every inch of the allied victory with the lives of thousands of Englishmen. The Vichy French in Syria controlled the airfields used to supply Rommel who was unfortunately probably one of the best generals in the history of war. Churchill both sought to undo the injustice of the jews being removed from their lands and marginalize the former allies of his defeated enemies. The crime in that is that he should have learned from the effects in Germany of the treaty of Versailles after ww1, England and France marginalized the Germans creating the perfect conditions for extreme fascism and the rise of his greatest adversary Adolf Hitler who managed to radicalized every day normal and good poeple to do atrocious things in the name of the regime.......Islamic extremism grows from the seeds of revenge and marginalization. Solutions are difficult to agree on, misinformed opinions are viral and the polarized perspectives of this conflict are nearly impossible to overcome. But there is always hope so long as both sides come to terms with the whole truth of their actions and histories. No one is 100% correct, no one is 100% honest and transparent and no none is perfect in this world. Only God knows the absolute path. We should all remember that even though we worship along different paths we all believe in the same God, maybe then we will stop unleashing hell. Life is a test of faith and conscience....these atrocities are the results of us failing to reconcile that fact.

[@achitophel5852]

Thank God for Churchill. Without him it would never have been possible for this rubbish to have been published.

[@johnxxx5085]

Yes nothing impartial about Tariq Ali nor for that matter this revisionist historian. Pretty clear to me that there is a hidden agenda that is not very well hidden in this video.

[@coreyham3753]

@@johnxxx5085 Hmmmm .... guess you deny the historical fact that in 1891 in Palestine, Jews owned only 1% of the land and Arabs-Palestinians owned 99% of the land. Guess you deny that in about 1900 there was a tiny Jewish population in Palestine and that 96+% of the population was Arabic-Palestinian. Those are just historical facts. Moreover, the Jews and the Arabs lived in relative peaceful co-existence in 1891 and 1900 in Palestine. The basic root cause of the never ending war in Palestine is that the Palestinians have had their land taken from them and mostly reallocated to Jews. One doubts that you would accept such if it happened to you personally.

[@Grock66]

@@coreyham3753where do Jews come from?

[@coreyham3753]

@@Grock66 ok, why don't you tell me.

[@johnxxx5085]

@@coreyham3753 A crash course on history of the PALESTINIAN STATE: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state. 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.

[@sufnaan1221]

Very well done Paul, JazakaAllah, the world conflicts are mainly driven by supremacy vs subdues

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤

[@alnon6304]

​@@RussianFans-vn6cjbuullshit.!!! Todos fanáticos asesinos.tres religiones un mismo diablo 👿👿

[@georgeh8937]

hello cookie gamer. is not islam all about arab supremacy? ever since muhammad and his companions conquered arabia for allah?

[@sufnaan1221]

@@georgeh8937 that’s all about your illusion and delusions, Islam is universal religion , Messenger of Allah Prophet Muhammad PBUH was sent to establish the religion of Allah, Islam doesn’t allow oppression or supremacy or inequality.

[@georgeh8937]

@@sufnaan1221 hello suf. how do you explain away the crimes of 1) islamic expansionion and 2) muhammad and 2) the palestinians waging war on israel?

[@Evilzionistbabykillers]

Very good, informative 💯

[@zuzana3901]

Indiánske rezervácie v USA sa podobajú v podstate koncentračnému táboru zvanému Palestína, Gaza. táborom v Gaz

[@AngelaPugliese-zb5oz]

I am learning so much. 🙏

[@r.p.vanloon6403]

Not here, my dear.

[@nickgent9949]

I am a serious student of Churchill….not only was he a deep humanitarian but also a founder of the modern welfare state. When he became Prime Minister, in May 1940, he stood alone, not only against the Nazi threat, at a time when Europe was collapsing (the US did not come into the war until December 1941) but also within his own class who wanted to parley with Hitler. Our situation was nothing short of desperate. In case this is not enough to assuage his critics, they should have a look at the eulogies following his death in 1965. They could not be more laudatory and were highly moving. I’m going to quote an extract from Attlee’s tribute. He was Churchill’s deputy in the Coalition Government during the Second World War as well as his great political rival, Churchill losing to him in the 1945 General Election “.......I do not think everybody always recognised how tender- hearted he was. I can recall him with the tears rolling down his cheeks, talking of the horrible things perpetrated by the Nazis in Germany. I can recall, too, during the war his emotion on seeing a simple little English home wrecked by a bomb. Yes, my Lords, sympathy-and more than that: he went back, and immediately devised the War Damage Act. How characteristic! Sympathy did not stop with emotion; it turned into action......... Then I recall the long days through the war-the long days and long nights-in which his spirit never failed; and how often he lightened our labours by that vivid humour, those wonderful remarks he would make which absolutely dissolved us all in laughter, however tired we were......and I recall, too, as the most reverend Primate has said already, that when once the enemy were beaten he had full sympathy for them. He showed that after the Boer War, and he showed it again after the First World War. He had sympathy, an incredibly wide sympathy, for ordinary people all over the world.....He saw himself there as an instrument. As an instrument for what? For freedom, for human life against tyranny. None of us can ever forget how, through all those long years, he now and again spoke exactly the phrase that crystallised the feelings of the nation. My Lords, we have lost the greatest Englishman of our time-I think the greatest citizen of the world of our time. In the course of a long, long life, he has played many parts. We may all be proud to have lived with him and, above all, to have worked with him.....” There are too many examples of the perpetuation of time-honoured myths (often the fault of “copy and paste” writers masquerading as historians), built on the very shaky foundations of ignorance and prejudice and calculated to denigrate the Churchill legacy. It is high time that these myths are laid to rest. Detractors - please note. If anybody should be “judge and jury” of Churchill, it should be Attlee, the much-respected, long-serving Labour leader and Prime Minister (1945/51), who got to know Churchill so well during the war years. Churchill was a colossus in standing up, almost alone, to tyranny, he should therefore be judged a giant no matter what the age. It should always be remembered, though, that his greatness was combined with him being a deep humanitarian - that is why he was (and still is) respected and loved by so many and why I am a crusader in upholding his legacy.

[@amh9494]

Lloyd George was the PM who brought in the pension will before Churchill's time and i think that's clearly the beginning of welfare.

[@theonlymeaning]

@nickgent9949 Very, very beautifully written. Thank you.

[@Amidat]

He copied the "welfare state" from the Nazis

[@philpryor7524]

You are deluded, incorrect and should start again, seeking truth.

[@nickgent9949]

You are an ignoramus. Can I suggest you read Martin Gilbert, Roy Jenkins, Andrew Roberts and others. You are going against the grain of history. What is your reading list? I suspect that you are a woke leftie, who has no respect for history as you don’t want to be deluded by the truth.

[@danabennett4098]

From 21:07 to - 22:32 - LISTEN TO THIS STATEMENT - of the reason to just ignore the Palestinians' longtime (millenia) residence in THEIR land.

[@nev707]

I thought the Luftwaffe bombed London first, albeit as a result of German planes getting lost and deciding to drop their bombs. This was even portrayed in the movie, “Battle of Britain”.

[@JH-ck1nr]

They did and ask the Poles about Warsaw!!! Complete Anti Churchill and Anti British Lies. Germany bombed everyone's cities and invented terror bombing of civilians.

[@jimseltzer2002]

They did.

[@Aamiin733]

Brother paul my Allah bless you and your family

[@Jaggermonster-k1j]

Jeffrey Sachs, Scott Ritter, Victor Van Davis, Thomas Sowell and the gentleman blogging in this video are heroic ❤

[@susanwestern6434]

Scott Ritter the convicted paedophile.

[@jacobjorgenson9285]

Norman Finklestein Avi Shlaim Ilan Pappé Miko Peled

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@marymachowska686]

Jeffery Sachs is the one who destroyed Polish economy with the communist after 1989. I hope he realized that that Poland lost their capacity of being great independent country without interference of other countries who stole everything from Poland. I’m one of million Polish who had to leave Poland because of that. Yes, Mr. Sachs is one of those who is responsible for exodus 10 million Polish people last 30 years.

[@monkeydragon3347]

My Lord! Bless me with righteous offspring.”So We gave him good news of a forbearing son.Then when the boy reached the age to work with him, Abraham said, “O my dear son! I have seen in a dream that I ˹must˺ sacrifice you. So tell me what you think.” He replied, “O my dear father! Do as you are commanded. Allah willing, you will find me steadfast.”Then when they submitted ˹to Allah’s Will˺, and Abraham laid him on the side of his forehead ˹for sacrifice˺,We called out to him, “O Abraham!You have already fulfilled the vision.” Indeed, this is how We reward the good-doers.That was truly a revealing test. And We ransomed his son with a great sacrifice (Ishmael).and blessed Abraham ˹with honourable mention˺ among later generations:“Peace be upon Abraham. This is how We reward the good-doers. He was truly one of Our faithful servants.We ˹later˺ gave him good news of Isaac-a prophet, and one of the righteous.We blessed him (Abraham or Ishmael) and Isaac as well. Some of their descendants did good, while others clearly wronged themselves. And We certainly showed favour to Moses and Aaron,and delivered them and their people from the great distress.We helped them so it was they who prevailed. We gave them the clear Scripture,and guided them to the Straight Path.And We blessed them ˹with honourable mention˺ among later generations:“Peace be upon Moses and Aaron.”. (Ash-Shafat 100-122)

[@moky1269]

Brilliant video thank you ❤

[@patmccarthy]

Tariq Ali ? Well that will be a balanced and unbiased view for sure.

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

Could you possibly do a video using this book or illan Papoe the Ethnic Cleansing of 🇵🇸 and compare it with experiences of the native Americans Bury my heart at wounded Knee By Dee Brown. I read both books and they leave gulp of tears in your heart.😔😔😔 They are excellent books that amplify to people how devastating the situation is in 🇰🇼

[@galeparker1067]

​@@jayal1992totally agree!! Dig deeper, much is still unknown. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 BTW..... Check out some American Hollywood movies of the 1930's-1950's...... 😂😢. Totally "shameful"? Did ANY OTHER COUNTRY do anything like this???? I am REALLY curious. 👃✌️🇨🇦

[@verenatuna9010]

​​@@galeparker1067 American, huh? Hollywood (movie- industry) is - and always was - a Jewish domain...

[@davidatkinson5858]

Imagine fighting a war and then whining about the consequences of losing....hypocritical

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@brendageorge9621]

I have read both books and agree they would make for brilliant discussion How many people know that Churchill was a fervent eugenic supporter? That is to say, that any people physically or mentally unpaired should bit be allowed to reproduce. He supported the US eugenic effort when hundreds is thousands of people were forcefully sterilized by sterilization or castration . Nazi Germany took the lead from the US in this regard. Absolutely shocking.

[@abderrahman9043]

thank you paul for your work !!

[@DidiDa-v9l]

Thank you for reading to us and explaining it. I need to read this.

[@a3media404]

Interesting video. I shared on my timeline.

[@rachidelmhaoud7199]

"They will carry their burdens on the Day of Resurrection"

[@fidelcatsro6948]

🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@charananekibalijaun8837]

That's an odd title for a video if you bear in mind that Palestinian people are a pretty recent phenomenon. Invented by the Egyptian Arafat roughly 10 years after Churchill's death

[@austinrules9385]

Ilian Pape - 10 myths about Israel.

[@charananekibalijaun8837]

@austinrules9385 it's Ilan Pappe, notorious self-hating Jew

[@lindadee2053]

Unless I misheard, England and America didn't bomb Dresden until very late 1944 / early 1945. This was several years after Hitler ferociously bombed England in the so-called Battle of Britain. In other words, Hitler and Germany started everything, including WWII.

[@avrahammakeler6979]

Churchill was the right man in the right place at the right time.

[@stephenbrookes7268]

We can look back throughout history, especially that of the great Empires (great meaning huge as opposed to wonderful) and track multiple atrocities and acts that we would consider war crimes. The Romans performed genocides in Europe, Carthage and to the Celts. The Ottoman Empire were ruthless in their enforcement of Islam. The most famous of their genocides being in Armenia. All of the European empires colonised parts of Africa and were ruthless in imposing taxes. Belgian rulers were especially brutal. The Spanish were brutal in Mexico and parts of what is now USA and throughout their South American colonies. I could write a book about imperial racism, slavery and genocide. Whilst Winston was a typical aristocrat, putting his class above all others and doing whatever he saw fit to the "lesser beings"! At the time there was an existential threat from another empire. If we judge anyone from the past by standards we now set for ourselves, we will see brutality, atrocity, unfairness and injustice. If people are not seeing this in current conflicts then they need some psychiatric help. Looking back at the crimes of Hitler and Churchill is only serving to deflect attention away from current warmongers. In Ukraine and Palestine! So Mr ALI, what skin colour of supremacy was the Ottoman Empire enacting? I think anyone that has any sort of genetic, linguistic or racial affinity with the Ottoman Empire, should basically go sit in a corner and shut the F up!

[@kitemanmusic]

Great comments, Stephen. Not well known: Muhammad had white skin and kept black slaves, whom he called 'raisin-heads'

[@stephenbrookes7268]

@@kitemanmusic The Prophet (pbuh) displayed many behaviours that would now be viewed as problematic. One thing he famously said was, that Islam and the behaviours of people should change to fit in with the times and the laws and traditions of lands they chose to live in. I wonder how well that hadith is followed today!

[@ghester07]

Churchill was very smart! He knew what he was talking about!

[@menacetohighsociety]

He was smart enough to cosy up to Stalin.

[@kirstyduncan408]

​​@@menacetohighsocietyA guy who killed more Christians than AH killed in total in the camps. Top bloke.

[@chrisheath2637]

@@menacetohighsociety Possibly to fight Hitler ?

[@koosleroux9862]

This esteemed author should see how the African people messed up South Africa: Self-enrichment of the leaders, inefficiency, corruption and crime.

[@solyomalbazz4925]

The point is not to find the truth, but to have the heart power to embrass it.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

I'm not Muslim but I really like your comment. Peace

[@johne.mckenzie9344]

Thanks so much!

[@Osoba333]

Tariq Ali -British writer?😂😂😂

[@stevejames9531]

It is a historic fact Churchill own mother was American Jew so asking him what he thinks of jewish people if like asking a block of wood what it thinks of wood

[@sheenapearse766]

Interesting detailed research on the recent history of Palestine and Zionism , and Imperial attitudes to other races / peoples . I don’t think it helps to judge past actions or attitudes by our contemporary values - other than to understand the origins of the current injustice , and emotionally to make us feel righteous . A rhinoceros is a rhinoceros , and Churchill was Churchill - a beast from a different age . Hero or villain - maybe a bit of both ?

[@niranjanhaldipur208]

Churchill is supposed to have said or written : "Individual Muslims may show splendid qualities, but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world. Far from being moribund, Mohammedanism is a militant and proselytizing faith." Any comments?

[@kingsman8475]

Sounds like the Baptist!

[@fenlander7114]

Much appreciate your positive affirmation of Winston Churchill, deeds not words.

[@JustDucky-d9k]

I wish Churchill was still around, we need him and people like him.

[@rayratchford8338]

are you for real the biggest bastard what as ever lived churchill

[@susanarupolo2212]

Even though I am not Arab or Arab descendent , but I believe in History and Justice. Thank you very much

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤

[@ntdisciple]

​@RussianFans-vn6cj Galatians 5 10 I trust as to you in our Master that you will NOT consider OTHER BELIEFS, but that the one troubling you shall bear the judgment, whoever he may be. xref-2 Galatians 4 9 But now, knowing Elohim, but rather being known by Elohim, how do you turn again to the weak and poor principles to which you desire again to come under their bondage (note) xref-1 These were people who were before patterning pagan cultic practices and now came to faith in YHWH and are now known by YHWH and were turning back to the former pagan practices. Galatians 1 6 I am surprised at how soon you have turned to another good news, away from Messiah who has called you to grace.

[@BrendaSheard-vt9fu]

It supports all of the BLACK BIBLE ISRAELITES REAL ESTATE OF ISRAEL...SOME ONE LYING AGAIN.AGAINST THE LAND. TAKE PEOPLE BELONGINGS. ...FROM 😮🌏🌾🖤🌹

[@dharma__3]

If you actually do believe what you wrote, Susan, you would fully support ISRAEL.

[@ntdisciple]

@@dharma__3 ‭‭Revelation‬ ‭2:9‬ ‭NKJV‬‬ [9] “I know your works, tribulation, and poverty (but you are rich); and I know the blasphemy of those who say they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan.

[@DevilbyMoonlight]

when you judge someone by what they do and what they say you have to take in the norms of the timeof history and the situation at that time.

[@alanaadams7440]

Amen. You cannot judge these people by current culture and politics

[@mjh5437]

Try telling that to all the BLM race grifters.

[@geofflepper3207]

I have no sympathy for anyone at any time in history who said or acted as if they felt that some humans have rights and their lives matter and other humans have no rights and their lives don't matter. And let's be clear that despite the rhetoric about spreading Christianity or about civilizing other races or about moral superiority of Christians and Jewish people the political leaders saying such things knew very well that that was all nonsense rationalization spoken and written to justify horrific actions that served certain economic, political and military interests. They knew what they were doing was wrong - they just didn't care. Somewhat similar to how Trump and Putin pretend to be spiritual religious people to justify horrific actions that serve certain political and economic interests. White European Christians and white European Jewish Zionists didn't invade and occupy the lands of other people for religious reasons - they did it for economic, political and military reasons. If it was just about being good Christians and Jewish people then they could have stayed in Europe and done that and left the rest of the world alone.

[@babachandrasekhar2452]

Tariq Ali forgets to mention that the Jews who came from Europe purchased the lands from the absentee landlords in Syria while the local Arabs were only tenants on the land.

[@jeangordon]

He didn't forget to mention it; he purposely omitted to mention it because it interferes with what he wants people to believe.

[@rick4electric]

14:44 - Such prescience! He actually figured out before anyone else that if you take someone's farm away from them, they will get mad! If we had only known then what we know now!

[@tm75_88]

As a christian italian, I appreciated a lot this content

[@lone_star3961]

Paul again proving how much he has progressed in Jihadi curriculum😂

[@farhanmalik8100]

Urine drinker is not allowed here 😂😂😂 Bastard

[@geofflepper3207]

What a bizarre way you have of describing someone having basic morality and humanity and being free of racism and thus believing that it is wrong for white European Christians and white European Jewish Zionists to conspire to steal the land of Palestinians and drive them into prison camps and into exile so that white European Jewish Zionists can occupy that Palestinian land thus letting white European Christians and white European Jewish people no longer have to deal with each other. When you think that believing that non-white people deserve basic rights and to be safe from colonialist invasion apartheid and oppression is somehow "religious extremism" then you display your racism and religious extremism.