BOYFRIEND VS. BROTHER MAKEUP CHALLENGE

[@seanrice1222]

Stoney won this one! He nailed that line ✌️

[@denisem1093]

I think they both won. Nile for a nightlife dance look and Ash for a romantic date night look. They both did great.

[@marief4826]

Can we just talk about Ash fixing the little baby hair around Joanna’s ear in the beginning🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️ So sweet!

[@RobertHeslop]

I'd had to go to Ash, just by a margin. It looks a lot more natural and matches skin tone better

[@luuorallemn9921]

Ash did a great daytime look, while Nile went more for a nighttime feel. Both look good on you because you're already beautiful to begin with. No matter who did the best make-up, we all agree that Stoney wins for the best line 👏😊↕️🖌

[@Devila103]

The win goes to Ash! I can't stop wondering how difficult it was to remove the Sharpie lipstick! 🤣

[@chrissummers5115]

I'd love to see the guys trying on different wigs! Or there might be an app you can use that shows them in different ones. That would be such a good laugh but then these videos always make us chuckle and I'm always smiling when I watch them. That's why everyone should subscribe. They'd never regret it.

[@jn5859]

Unrelated new episode idea: The whole squad goes completely sober for a week (or 2 or whatever), documents the process- the good, the bad, and the surprising You can call it a public service to bring awareness to people going through addiction and sobriety Plus I think it would force the squad to be EXTRA-creative with ways to entertain themselves, and I would watch the heck out of that 😄

[@nicolagibbons6624]

I love that idea

[@ZellieMoogle]

"We're all fit aren't we" 🤣 Dang straight you are, such a beautiful AND talented bunch! 😍🤩😎

[@silverkeys]

Both. Like Ash's for the day look and Niles for a dramatic evening look. But you look super good natural. You don't need makeup at all.

[@susanlawson4547]

I love Nile’s side! He went big and bold with the eyes and I’m here for it.

[@susancurry1346]

Love it, Nile for a nightclub do, Ash for a dinner date, Luke for a lovely line !

[@TheVelvetLoungeLife]

Joanna and Ashley are too cute. Nile and Joanna are sibling goals. Stoney, Ashley and Nile awesome guys, great lifetime friends super goals. I see 🙈 more love in your futures. Be well and stay safe ✨😊✨

[@mohammadal-drees3106]

As soon as Nile applied that clown-like eyeshadow, he lost! 🤣😂 Ash did a decent job.

[@mollylandless1294]

Ash deffo did the best but Nile’s matched his top so I am here for it 😂

[@jenniferbento9141]

What mascara brand did you use?

[@karashears1032]

Definitely Ash!!!! They should do your hair and nails ( including toes) OR you could make it even more fun and make them paint their own nails since that is even harder then doing someone elses.

[@sharrandawson6268]

I love how Ash kept his side natural

[@susanlawson4547]

Also, you should do one where Sally does Nile’s/the boys makeup

[@bethraven6349]

A video I never knew I needed ❤️

[@smontalvo210]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣love all of you!!

[@endersmith162]

I lost it at the Sharpie lips 🤣🤣🤣

[@socialbutterfly69]

Makeup was daytime & nighttime , good job

[@kathrynchadwick]

This is actually super impressive from both I’m shocked, but also they are both perfectionists by nature I guess! 😂 Niles lashes!!!!

[@karensexauer6138]

Ash won when he figured out the color of eyeshadow should be the one that was most used. He's a logical guy, not just a romantic one!

[@mariearmstrong7718]

Boyfriend, for sure! OMG, Nile! Ash, Joanna looks like herself! Sharpie lips are permanent guys!😂

[@emilyzeller9778]

I was hoping I wasn't the only one yelling at them for using sharpies

[@TheOriginal1GypsyWoman]

Boyfriend for day, brother for dance performance. They both did pretty well. 😊

[@Smooxox1]

Outfit challenge is a great idea 👏

[@AniWatX]

Ash won. I love the more natural looking eyebrow that he did too. Nile’s was pretty good too.

[@savannah4439]

Nial was not kidding about the Wilson eyelashes! I am so jealous of both of y’all 😂

[@robsutherland5744]

How could I possibly choose? Nice job guys.

[@TH-fc2ou]

Ash of course!!!

[@deegingerkid]

I don't hate Nile's treatment of your eye. It's striking and you can carry the color! But Ash overall did you more justice. And Nile's experiment witht he mascara is how I feel when I wear it! I'm a ginger, so my eyelashes are blonde. I don't even really realize they're there until I wear mascara...which I never do. XD Y'all are too funny together

[@sleepyj3798]

can we talk about nile using the eyebrow gel on himself 😂

[@Unpopable_Bubble]

I actually really like Nile’s side! You have the perfect eyes for a good smoky eye!! Nile you should toooootally let Joanna do a full face of makeup on you!

[@edwardthomas4005]

Ash....Natural beauty everytime.

[@stacym88]

Boyfriend!!! I like the natural look.

[@charlottetate94]

I lost it when Nile started putting foundation on with his hands😂

[@vivianamarce666]

Joanna your eyelashes are gorgeous!!

[@jguitar23]

Ash succeeded the elegant 18th century look, lovely!

[@joyfulinternecion]

I feel like Niles face is more of a night out and Ash is more of your everyday filming colors. I like the color on Niles sharpie on you!

[@blacksheep9772]

Nice lashes Nile 👌

[@lilyh4563]

Nile's side is my favorite it was awesome .

[@ItsAMbutyoutubechangedmyname]

Niles is the best on as a night out when nobody really sees the details ,😂 both did a great job for not knowing what the heck did

[@daabee236]

I’m shocked but Nile! Didn’t expect that though

[@amandabennett1776]

Brilliant!!

[@vanessasigurdson2061]

Nile is stunning with those eyelashes!!

[@alicefryman3372]

Ash’s by far - sorry Nile 😂

[@lanibasich4781]

Ash did the best makeup!

[@alicekubinkova2681]

Ash for sure 😁

[@annahunt3818]

Hands down, Ash wins.. Sorry Nile! She’s too beautiful for that much make-up! Great job guys! I laughed so hard when Nile did foundation with his hands!

[@NicholaB29]

Boyfriend for naturally and brother for raving 😁💖

[@larissadueck2643]

Ashley, like usual, won this challenge

[@chloexo3503]

Ash actually smashed that

[@jacquiion5677]

Both lads did really well. But gotta go with Ash. Well done lads

[@chloexo3503]

Nile wasn’t lying, J’s lashes are insane

[@edwinroman8684]

right

[@alissacoburn220]

I've been wanting to try that foundation! Do you love it?

[@alissacoburn220]

And, of course, it was Ash. Heavy on the blush, but still.

[@Chibihugs]

They both did really well but Ash won. His eyeshadow application was neater but I loked both color choices

[@Elen8878]

Definitely more brother be bf. It’s a brilliant mix

[@claudiaeriksson3139]

Super girly question but what is that mascara it’s gorgeous with nice coverage

[@Klingon2468]

Ash did a better job applying the make up, but Nile had a bolder choice and if both sides were done Nile's way you would look super hot and sexy. Ash's way makes you look hot but girlfriendy I think Ash did it like that on purpose. (marking his territory) LOL Stay safe. 👍👍👍

[@Faith-Ireland]

Ashley!!!!

[@daiseycasey2718]

I think niles is good for night and ash is good for day! Nile had gorgeous lashes

[@ajajackson1679]

Nile all you have to do to get mascara off is to uses some vaseline and rub it on your lashes. It will wipe right off 😊

[@brittnibooker5047]

Ash is day and Nile is the night look -actually if we’re gonna go for artistic make up then I prefer Nile’s bold choice but I am so sorry I am horribly distracted by the fact that we just let them apply sharpie to her lips?!?? My girl Jay whyyyyyy?!💜😜Shooketh

[@MissIvyMayhemBurlesque]

Ash won 😂😂

[@robinaddis-vaughn7271]

Ash's side because it's closer to J's normal look. But, Nile is right, J can definitely pull off that color eyeshadow if it was applied correctly.

[@anniesalomonsson8651]

Ash 💕

[@tracycostello2183]

The mascara on Nile just makes his eyes pop!!!

[@phillipspark7255]

That's uncanny how good you both are 👀

[@AnnaAnna-uc2ff]

Thanks.

[@abigailmaddison8797]

Boyfriend ❤

[@annebridges2631]

Boyfriend makeup is best

[@pamkowaski1608]

One is more lighter and natural the other is darker and bolder. Both work depending

[@julieloveshockey10486]

I’m thinking the makeup counters have no competition 🤣

[@alexandrahamilton776]

Ash all the way

[@nillaskat1]

They both did really well but the lips with a sharpie is what got me

[@debbiefryer7389]

They both did a good job,but ash won it,if nile had gone for a lighter eyeshadow then who knows ❤

[@MissMalikaA]

I'm voting Ash for the makeup, both were pretty good tbh

[@patriciajones7144]

Please can you and ash do “Do you love” me dance by Sophie and Thomas. Would love to see you do it.

[@loopyloujuggler]

Ash won definitely!!!

[@Abigail_Wyatt]

Wow never noticed Nile’s lashes till now. Lol😝

[@izuminigatake2014]

First!! Ash is the clear winner, I'm sorry Nile 🤷🏻‍♀️😂😂 It would be nice if Nile and Ash were made up by Joanna

[@kristinarobinson5277]

It would depend on the event I think, they are both good

[@inaf1079]

Ash won.....again 😁

[@celestegross6622]

I'd go out in Ash's makeup but Nile did a great job on your eyebrows.

[@shellystitt6703]

I liked both sides, Ashley brought out your natural beauty, while Nile went with more outgoing. Who won, idk I liked them both.

[@pamkowaski1608]

They both went overboard with the blush

[@nbarnes6225]

I like the color Nile chose (application needs work), but Ash did a better job.

[@courtneysmith9039]

Ash definitely won 🥇

[@elizabethsmith6960]

It’s a close one, I’d say Ashley won that. I think if Nile had gone a little easier on the eyeshadow, it could have been his day! Lol. X

[@nickreyner]

Ash!!!!

[@sarahdemeter6639]

Ash!

[@Amateur.Nail.Art.1]

Ash’s side is more of a natural look. Nile’s side is more of a glam look. Luke did an excellent job doing the line down the center.

[@speechy_keen4878]

Nile is right, Jay has amazing lashes.

[@Laurydeleeuw]

Nile did them brows good

[@ZoZoIb]

Tbf the first time i ever used eyeshadow, it did not look much different than niles side XD its harder than it looks

[@stinkkistonkki]

Niles eye, but Ashlys face!

[@kellymurphy7537]

Sorry Nile, Ash smashed it.