Broadway Bucket List: Abby Mueller Sings Her Three Musical Dream Roles

Abby Mueller is back as music superstar Carole King in the hit Broadway bio-musical Beautiful: The Carole King Musical.
Abby recently dropped by the BroadwayBox studio with accompanist Ian Weinberger to absolutely slay us with her wide vocal range as she performed "My White Knight" from The Music Man, "I Don't Know How to Love Him" from Jesus Christ Superstar, and "I Miss the Mountains" from Next to Normal. Don't miss the chance to hear this stunning voice live in Beautiful!

[@georgiamargaux7516]

how many mueller’s are there like wow what a talented family

[@abigailnoelmortensen482]

Georgia Margaux i think there’s four of them? Jessie, Abby, and two boys. I know one of the brothers is Ron Weasley in cursed child.

[@ReallyCoolSami]

four! there's abby, jessie, andrew, and matt.

[@anapaulamartins9371]

well I just figured out right now that there is more than one mueller

[@sophiamuharram]

Idk who their voice teacher was but Jessie and Abby have the most beautiful voice and amazing technique. Like I can’t. Obviously they have natural talent, but their technique!!! And their voices are so versatile!! They can play anything.

[@ericcanfield3183]

jessie and abby as violet and daisy in sideshow pls

[@Analblockage]

This idea is genius.

[@ZoraTheberge]

Actual sisters in the role! LOVE IT

[@jennhiemstra]

HOLY ACTUAL CRAP, THIS IS SOMETHING I NEVER KNEW I NEEDED...do a second Broadway revival with these two and I can't see how it could go wrong this time!

[@FandubWorld]

Yes, yes and DOUBLE YES!

[@mollypavilonis5718]

CAN YOU IMAGINE

[@jamesosullivan6055]

I saw her yesterday in SIX in Chicago. Absolutely breathtaking voice and performance. What a star.

[@margaridacunha1992]

everyone in that family has an insane range... wow I'm shook

[@gabblanke6678]

I love how jessie originated Carole king on b-way and now her sister is playing Carole now it just feels full circle somehow

[@madiowens2298]

jessie and abby look like twins and im living for it

[@auspicious93]

literally just discovered that Jessie had a sister...... I'm very late to the party lol

[@tessaokeefe9866]

Love that Abby literally has a twin brother but everyone thinks Jessie is her twin

[@berf13]

@@tessaokeefe9866 funnily enough, I find that Jessie and Andrew (their youngest brother, not Jessie's partner ha) could pass more as twins than Abby and Matt... Although Matt and Abby are both very soft spoken, so listening to them talk they sound more like twins. Either way the genes are incredibly strong with that family.

[@tessaokeefe9866]

@@berf13 I totally see that

[@clairegillingham1768]

I need her Heart of Stone right now omg. I bet she's fabulous in Six.

[@abigailnoelmortensen482]

C. Gillingham there’s a bootleg audio on youtube

[@PlaidBoyPDX]

She is. Overwhelmingly good.

[@islaballantine]

If you go find the channel Alexness there’s an upload called “your heart of stone” it has the few minutes of acting leading up to it as well as the full song. Enjoy!

[@gyokkers3774]

She sings it the best from who I've heard which is quite a lot of Jane Seymours

[@karsteng3737]

That... was the best I Miss the Mountains I have ever heard in my life and I need her to be cast as Diana right this minute

[@FandubWorld]

Safe to say talent runs well in the Mueller family :D

[@samk1188]

how is nobody talking about that rendition of my white knight like this might be my favorite ever. she modernized it so perfectly

[@maddietillem6778]

The emotion she put into I miss the mountains though... she's amazing

[@ashareeoo]

WHOA! A Mueller sister! Insane!! I love the bright quality of her voice. "Miss the Mountains" was EXCEPTIONAL too. Wowza.

[@seansantaclarita1]

I low key judged her before ever listening to her because I thought she only attached herself to the success of her sister and that’s why she’s working but after hearing her, I get why she’s Carole King on Broadway right now! She has a very similar color and tone to as Jessie but she has her distinct choices and the most interesting acting choices. Amazing.

[@bambibloggerfantage]

seansantaclarita1 she also has a strong soprano voice

[@ifinditamazing]

She came to NY before Jessie did! She was in the Kinky Boots ensemble forever before Beautiful opened!

[@GregtheBat]

I could listen to her Mary for hours on end. I literally just did. I repeated that section of the video for a while.

[@asterismos5451]

I Miss the Mountains is such an under-appreciated song so it's really nice to see it being loved!

[@Ambwosia]

ABBY AS DIANA WOULD ROCK SO HARD!

[@kaitlynpollack8119]

i need her as diana asap as possible please

[@HugeMusicalFreak]

I come back to this video all the time. It's insane how perfectly she nails each song and makes them all her own. She puts so much of herself into them that I feel like I know her. I hope she gets more big roles because wowza

[@richardurbano7133]

She or Jessie would be a PERFECT Diana

[@silentsmurf]

Richard Urbano Jessie’s too young imo

[@linnycrocus6023]

No but seriously she would absolutely kill it in Next To Normal. Revival please!

[@MrAkardashian]

So was she busy for Jesus Christ Superstar Live because yesssssss henny

[@Sashacalderon]

You can really emotional I miss the mountains is...I sang a couple of months ago for a recital and completely broke down and I can see how powerful her emotions are here wow 😭

[@lmm05005]

Excellent job in Six! Such a talented family!

[@SammyShipp1]

abby needs to release an album pls

[@thomasszymanski1107]

Beautiful portrayal of Diana. I hope you do get to perform her someday. You would do the role and Alice proud for sure!

[@n.fosbinder6312]

I saw her as Carole not knowing anything but she was Jessie's sister...I CRIED V HARD. SHE V GOOD. SHE DO ALL THE THINGS.

[@ChantalMonette]

legit chills

[@sheikhnafismuhtade5250]

SHE DESERVES MORE ATTENTION!!!!💕

[@annemargarettesanoy7463]

She's gonna get it through Six

[@MadisonHalla]

she has an absolutely *incredible* voice!! I could listen to her a *million* times and not get tired of her voice!

[@ReadToMeAtMidnight]

And here I am for the fifth time today, coming back to this video to listen to I Miss the Mountains

[@abigailford9032]

she has such a beautiful, well rounded, well trained voice what the heck 😍😍😍

[@keelynoxleymitchell]

She's incredible!!! I appreciate how different she is compared to her sister. :)

[@perrymcwilliams8349]

She and Jessie should play the sisters in Frozen!!!

[@wickeddisney55]

OOOO that'd be fun who'd be who tho?

[@snorlaxkcs]

@@wickeddisney55 I feel like jessie is more extroverted than abby so jessie as Anna and abby as elsa. that would be so interesting😭😭

[@singinggemini]

I'm so happy I found this comment because I was just literally thinking about this yesterday!

[@liagoldenberg9377]

who allowed her to be this talented like excuse me leave some talent for everyone else

[@stephanievizzi9147]

Ahhhthe music man 😭🙌🏻 I’m so happy to hear someone sing this but especially Abby!

[@maddietillem6778]

Wow! How can she go from operatic legit soprano songs to belty mid range stuff in literally a second? Girls got an amazing range. AND THE EMOTION

[@medmcmuldren]

We saw Abby Mueller in Beautiful in San Francisco. She was wonderful.

[@lindaflores8224]

Ugghh she's so talented

[@pianosign]

ABBY MUELLER AS DIANA ASAP PLEASE

[@Mangafreak681]

Damn, she KILLED I miss the mountains

[@kaylynrhall]

if abby doesnt play diana sometime , i might actually die...

[@OhAnnise]

Abby for Jenna :)

[@nataliepatterson1128]

👏 next 👏 to 👏 normal 👏 revival 👏 with 👏 derek 👏 klena 👏 as 👏 gabe 👏

[@mattiemccarthy9102]

Natalie Patterson he’s a bit too old

[@willcohen1031]

Mattie McCarthy he still plays teen roles (Nick in Jagged is 18) so

[@Broadway_Ben]

Will Cohen just because he does doesn’t mean he should...

[@samstein3244]

I feel like Derek Klena's voice is very operatic-disney-character-like, where Gabe is much more punk rock (as a character not just Aaron Tveit) so I dunno but I feel like Derek would be a good Henry

[@asnalelo.165]

@@samstein3244 aaron is classically trained and played Gabe so

[@aliciawilliamson3010]

THAT TEAR

[@jaanakiradhakrishnan4442]

Not to compare her to Jessie, bu they have such similar mannerisms. Like the face she makes when she sings "Love him", Jessie makes that same face!

[@maggiepeterson7915]

abby in JSC is something we NEED

[@erinschwarz7001]

I NEED ABBY AS DIANA IN NEXT TO NORMAL RIGHT NOW PLS!! Where can i sign the petition?

[@kailundennie1622]

Her mary is beyond perfection !

[@imaginat7856]

Wow, she is incredible... so, SO talented!!

[@torim1224]

Perfection!!!!! Like this isn’t fair 😘

[@jilliank6379]

I adore how Abby’s dream role is Marion. Jessie played Marion about a year ago

[@Cristinnazario]

It’s crazy how her and Jessie sound so similar, such amazing talents!

[@Sianothis]

Wow she and Jessie have such similar voices and so talented!!!

[@soopersalad2509]

love her

[@kennydreadfuls861]

Get you a person who can do both! Pop and legit! Love it!

[@torim1224]

Abby is so insanely talented and she just makes me happy 😊

[@mayaroth5654]

I miss the mountains never made me cry until tonight. Her voice is so gorgeous. We need a rivalry with her as Diana. What a gorgeous and versatile voice

[@kylenebrender8611]

I have to say I always skip I Miss the Mountains on the recording because I just hate it. But she has made me love it. Wow.

[@HeySarah20174]

That is the best I’ve ever heard “I don’t know how to love him” sang. Just wow

[@yopyopo]

Yay!! Incredible beautiful performance from a equally Beautiful soul inside & out.

[@carrieloria]

Next to normal revival and she’s Diana... PLEASE?

[@richardurbano7133]

We need a Nex to Normal revival with Abby as Diana

[@mayaroth5654]

this actually gave me chills. Such a beautiful voice!!!!!

[@stephetheridge7757]

That emotion though 👌🏻😭 brilliant.

[@iwokeuplikethispod]

ABBY AS DIANA NEEDS TO HAPPEN, IMMEDIATELY.

[@laurynshealy6698]

I’m watching her sing I Miss The Mountains and IMMA NEED SOME TISSUES

[@CanadianFreaks123]

queen

[@melissadejesusfanrebeccafe8248]

Mine so Mine idola , i love you Abby Mueller ❤️

[@ryanfaure3120]

Omg she's gonna be amazing as Jane Seymour 😍😍😍👌🏻

[@HannahKitchen99]

Yasssss this Diana

[@jonna8016]

i would love to see her as diana in a N2N revival!

[@lisagerber1427]

Amazing

[@maysaaalikhan962]

YAAAAAAS

[@RaySingh87]

OMG!!! She totally rocked IDKHTLH!!

[@janicesim3521]

Abby and Melissa Benoist are such great singers in Carole King musical 😍🤩

[@roryshirley2177]

This so crazy because Jessie is literally in the music right now

[@roryshirley2177]

The music man

[@melissadejesusfanrebeccafe8248]

So Mine and her Family and true Friends ❤️

[@MelissaDeJesusFadeJessieMeAbby]

Perfection

[@lonelylittledot]

Oh my gosh she looks so much like Jessie!

[@mollypavilonis5718]

Her as Mary I am living, and her acting as Diana wow

[@mollymacaskill5029]

and now her sister is in The Music Man

[@jacobmccain8794]

Jesse and her look soooo much alike

[@rociopaz447]

Omg her and jessie look and sound so similar😱💖

[@kennydonovan848]

Wow wow wow

[@Chrystle823]

If they adopt me, maybe I’ll become just as talented 🤞🏾ya know

[@happyexpat3744]

Abby, at least from what I saw above, shares many of the expressions with her sister, Jessie. Similar voices, too, technique wise as well as tone. How interesting to be in competition, hopefully a sibling competition, with one of the most appreciated Broadway stars, today. Great genetics.

[@darthbanana2110]

I thought by Carole King she meant Carole Baskin and now I really want a Tiger King musical.

[@ryanfaure3120]

It's actually happening. With Kristin Chenoweth 👀

[@natalieg5690]

her head voice sounds very similar to Laura Osnes! not to compare them or anything (cause both are amazing in their own way), it's just something i noticed.

[@hospitalgal101]

Gah. I NEED her to sing Could We Start Again, Please?

[@ms.cellaneous4380]

And everything's alright!

[@lolkayleen2757]

she m u s t be diana at some point p l e a s e

[@MelissaDeJesusFadeJessieMeAbby]

Cute Abby

[@hannaevelyn3545]

She looks so much like her sister.

[@juliamarie6385]

she would make a BEAUTIFUL clara

[@natalieg5690]

oh YES

[@asnalelo.165]

in Piazza?

[@vroszii4200]

Just LET HER PLAY DIANA

[@lili_tarn]

the spitting image of jessie

[@metikabegleiter1770]

Lili Tarn I know, but I feel a little bad comparing them because I know that being compared to your sibling can suck😂

[@tessaokeefe9866]

Technically Jessie is a spitting image of Abby cause Abby is older

[@sylenef.3430]

God damn genetics

[@Ifedayo1official]

Why didn’t she play Jenna ???? Also her and Jessie sound a lot alike kinda scary .

[@vianna9428]

She is Jessie Mueller’s sister right? Cause the same last name the same face and the same freaking voice. Either that or they are the same person

[@tessaokeefe9866]

Yep! Abby is like 1 or 2 years older than Jessie

[@hospitalgal101]

To the nine people who disliked this, who hurt you?

[@claudettechin492]

😄